Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

A Shadow over Southall

A Shadow over Southall

jagroop singh · 11 Apr 2004

"Gurmat goes straight out of the window as Southall Nagar Kirtan organisers seek to appease everyone…apart from Guru Sahib that is!" <<< So what takes your fancy Jagroop Singh? I’ve got some Bhangra music if you like…nice and cheap, give it a go – what, you’ve heard that already? How about some ‘Singhs’ who want the Sangat to start taking Cannabis… OK so you’ve checked them out already, but check this out - how about some Namdhari exhibitionism; bet you ain’t tried that yet… this stuff will get you proper whacked! >>> <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><> Come join the Nagar Kirtan, Those 'Sikhs' Know how to chill Next year it’ll be better, Come and get your thrills… Whatever you’re into, Come along and promote And don’t worry if it’s Sat Guru that you demote!!! The Southall Nagar Kirtan organisers, who I imagine consist of Gurdvara Sahib Committees and ‘Sikh Community Leaders’, may as well have been drug-dealers on Sunday 5th April. The stuff they were forcefully pushing, as the Sangat wound its way around a drizzly grey Southall, certainly made me think of them as such. As the day unfolded it became obvious they were desperate to get rid of their wares, preying on anyone and everyone. What this writer witnessed on Sunday was actually not just sad, spiritually defunct and enormously irrelevant…it was absolutely offensive. Let’s take a look why by starting of mildly and then getting progressively hotter. There was minimal Parchaar for both Sikhs and even more so non-Sikhs. Surely the whole idea is to spread Guru Sahib’s universal message of Love for humanity and Love for Vahiguru. Even the abstract ambience of Gurbani, to the untrained Western ear that is, was lost amongst the flood of Manmat-inspired Bhangra which came belching out wherever my ears could turn. If people must listen to what I am increasingly beginning to feel is the Panjaabi equivalent of Gangsta Rap (i.e. derogatory, animalistic, sexist, offensive), then just stay as far away from the back of the procession as you possibly can…don’t compete with The Word of Sat Guru Sahib; at least show that amount of basic respect. Then there was the limited smattering of ‘UK Nihungs’ walking here and there which was tolerable – even though I personally feel that most of their Mat is anti-Gurmat, at least we didn’t have contend with them spewing it down our throats. However, let’s remember, did we really want our Naujawan being exposed to these impressive looking Bana-clad guys who were handing-out massive wallplanners from a car-boot…that is knowing full well that they promote the use of Cannabis amongst other past-times? Somehow even this wasn’t the bottom of the barrel, that is as far as my expectations represent a barrel…at least the UK Nihungs accept, in principle, the concept of Guru Gobind Singh Sahib as the last human Guru. Give me a hand; you must have realised I’m really trying to get a grip here… And now we come to the icing on the cake. No-one’s got a problem with Namdharis, like the rest of the world, enjoying the Nagar Kirtan if they choose to - despite the obviously inherent ironies when they do decide to ‘celebrate’. But when they’re given their own float as part of the main procession, we have to ask: What on earth is going on? According to them, Guru Gobind Singh Sahib left the majority of the Sangat behind, changed his name to Baba Ajapal Singh and remained far away in Nabha where he lived up until 1812. Oh, they also believe in their own words that, “havan and yagya [Hindu rituals] make the country prosperous and bring down rains when needed…To protect and to breed cows is the highest duty of a Namdhari…Before the creation of the Khalsa Panth, Dasam Patshah Guru Gobind Singh Jee performed a havan as part of devi pujan in 1697 at Naina Devi mountain”. Erm anyway, let’s not get sidetracked. Where does this leave us in terms of Guruship because I for one thought that was passed-over to Eternal Guru Granth Sahib Jee? The answer is they have a ‘LIVING GURU’ called ‘SAT GURU JAGJIT SINGH’. While they marched along behind their float, a painting of their 12th ‘guru’ (none other than the great Gursikh freedom fighter Baba Ram Singh) was displayed for all to see. Sadly they didn’t use their float to quote this amazing man, who was of course nothing more than a great Gurmukh. Prior to his death in 1885, Baba Ram Singh communicated with the Sangat through letters he sent them whilst imprisoned as an exile in Burma. He tried as much as he could to prevent them from making the unforgivable mistake of regarding him as the Sat Guru. The noted historian Dr Ganda Singh, in his work entitled “Kukiyan Di Vithiya” (History of Kukkas), shares these letters. The following excerpts paint a very clear picture: “The world is needlessly making claims about me {letter no. 11}. I need only Gursikhi…they are barking needlessly. They have become mad {letter no. 33}.I have not even the slightest Guruship in me {letter no. 10}. Brothers after the Ten Patshahis [Soveriegn Gurus], Guru Granth Sahib is the Guru and is Eternal. There is no other Guru {letter no. 44}. Accept Guru Granth Sahib as the Guru manifest {letter no. 36}. Make offerings to Shabad Guru…Don’t refer to me as Siree Maharaj {letter no. 40}. I am not the Guru {letter no. 38}”. The Namdharis are so misguided they don’t even acknowledge and respect the words of the very man they claim to be so devoted to; instead they positively go against his wishes. Well perhaps they haven’t heard about these letters. Perhaps next year we should invite the Radha Soamis and the Nirankaris as well and have one big ‘heretical personality-cult party’. After all, if you give one anti-Panthic group special treatment, why not extend invitations to all the others? They’ve certainly got lots in common. The Namdharis who obviously think that the Khalsa Panth is without a Sat Guru, used to like ripping the Angs (limbs) of Sat Guru Sahib as though they were news-clippings. The Radha-Soami ‘guru’ prefers sitting higher than Sat Guru Jee which is for him ‘a lifeless book’, and one of the Nirankari ‘gurus’ literally went one step further by actually placing his foot upon Sat Guru Jee! The burning question is why has the concept of Nagar Kirtan degenerated into a pathetic show, where the whole idea is to unnaturally assimilate anything and anyone so long as the money keeps coming and the crowds keep flowing? Nagar Kirtans, an opportunity to take Guru Sahib into the foreign world of the wider community, have become nothing but mish-mash Asian melas, syptomatic of the most depraved cultural aspects of the non-Sikh Panjaabi masses – bhangra, shouting, food and the promotion of drugs and anti-Panthic elements. In fact, it is safe to say that this year’s Southall Nagar Kirtan was nothing less than a consistent and perfectly executed example of how best to commit complete beadbee (disrespect and insult) towards Sat Guru Granth Sahib Jee. We should be handing-out quality educational materials to non-Sikhs showing them the beauty our Sat Guru Jee embodies. Kirtan sheets could be distributed which translate/transliterate the words and sounds they find themselves being drenched in; set Shabads would allow them to keep track of what’s being sung. With a simple sound and feedback system, we could ensure that several Kirtan floats throughout the procession are always singing the same Shabad together. We shouldn’t have to keep crowds interested by forcing tonnes of food towards them at every opportunity – what’s wrong with functional provisions in the form of Langar? Instead let us use this day to carry out the Sacha Sauda (true transaction) of feeding the homeless wherever they may be by utilising the many Gurdvara Sahib kitchens across the country. After lovingly preparing the Langar, let’s go out onto the streets and serve it to those who really need it. And for crying out loud, I’m sure even the inhabitants of Timbucktoo have heard the dhol being played by ten people at once…must we rely upon this tired cliché at every Nagar Kirtan?! Much better to let the sound-waves of Gurbani work their magic; the whole point of every Nagar Kirtan. The learning point for us can be summed-up by the following questions: What kind of activities do we think will encourage a greater understanding of Sat Guru Sahib and Gurmat during Nagar Kirtans? Most of all, how can we best keep the focus squarely upon Sat Guru Sahib? However, the central thrust of this article is pointless unless we attribute responsibility, and let’s not mince words here – putting aside all other issues temporarily, which anti-Panthic organisers allowed such blatant opponents of Sat Guru Sahib to command a float during the Southall Nagar Kirtan? Who needs the RSS when you’ve got people such as this ‘organising’ Nagar Kirtans! These people who are at best spineless puppets, and at worst open enemies of the Panth, must hold their heads in shame and really do some serious Soul-searching. It is now up to the Southall Sangat to ensure that these people are questioned, that they explain themselves and are then dealt with adequately. To add more salt to the injury, I am obliged to share with you what a very reliable source told me - the Namdharis had apparently been guaranteed up to 6 months ago that they would be allowed a float, so this wasn’t some kind of last minute cock-up due to miscommunication or some other minor slip-ups. Can members of the Sangat across the country, and in fact all over the world, ensure that the other Nagar Kirtans which will soon take place do not suffer the same fate as this one. Shame on people such as me who didn't shout any protests or attempt to stop the float from moving onwards when the sick episode in question unfolded before our eyes... Please contact the organisers and demand to be given details about who has been given a float etc. All that’s left to say is can those who were responsible for organising and implementing this year’s Southall Nagar Kirtan respond to this article by contacting the Editor of this publication, and make clear exactly what they are playing at. If they choose to remain silent, well that would indeed represent a very affirmative answer…an answer that will be unpalatable, but quite telling nonetheless. [%sig%]

Re: A Shadow over Southall

sikh_living_in_southall · 12 Apr 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ke fateh Dear Jagroop Singh Excellent article and i share the same pain and frustrations you have felt at the antics of Gurdwara committees in Southall but in specific the management of Havelock Rd Gurdwara. I was their at the nagar kirtan and a bunch of Namdhari's came to the carriage of Guru-Ji made a offering of some sort, don't think they bowed to Guru-Ji and then they distributed their own parshad that they'd brought woith them? An absolute disgrace to us..........whos to blame? They don't give a damn about the welfare of the sangat. The president Himmat Singh only had the new Gurdwara erected so that it would be his living legacy......they have totally bled the sangat dry of money........how much can the sangat keep giving out? At every opportunity they blatantly are asking for donations - and even have their favoured baba doing the same as well - one so called baba that they promote and i think holds great sway over the committee on sunday asked the whole sangat to empty everything in their pockets...........? They just see us as cattle....... We have a millionaires corner, where anybody who has given a sizeable donation to the gurdwara gets their name on a plaque on the wall? No pictures of saheeds or leading sikh figures anywhere in the gurdwara......I'm sorry but the fire that burns inside me towards these guys is so hot if i dont stop now i will say some very bad things.......... The sangat is dead in southall these guys control everything - we need people to stand up and take control once more - put Gurbani and its parchar at the forefront of the gurdwaras agenda........they hold guru-ji and promote guru-ji as a fundraiser............ Its time Guru minded Sikhs took back control of Gurdwara......

Re: A Shadow over Southall

sikh · 12 Apr 2004

who organised the nagar kirtan? which singh sabha?

Re: A Shadow over Southall

Sehajvir Singh · 12 Apr 2004

I'm speechless. I can't believe it has come to this. Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru.

Re: A Shadow over Southall

sikh_living_in_southall · 13 Apr 2004

the nagar kirtan was i believe organised by the gurdwara management of singh sabha gurdwara havelock rd........ the 17 million pound + gurdwara - the gurdwara which according to Himmat Singh is the 2nd most important gurdwara in the sikh diaspora/kom - and yes he said this on tv - at the opening of the new gurdwara he said this was the 2nd most important gurdwara after the golden temple - his words not mine..........temple do we idol worship? Harmandair Sahib!

Re: A Shadow over Southall

warrior*princess · 14 Apr 2004

Thats really bad... Couldnt the naamdharis have been chucked out of the nagar keertan by some group of singhs? Or were they more scattered? That means parchaar also needs to be done against drug-taking. There are already enough problems....just gets worse everytime i hear about southall. Maybe there should be some sort of Sikhi Event that is just as big in the sense that there will be stalls/sessions based on all the topics that oppose all the wrong doings that occurred at the nagar keertan. But this event should be out in the open rather than inside a Gurudwara Sahib...(at least nearby to a Gurudwara Sahib but remembering to have a good location to avoid circumstances of baistee etc)..which would make it more possible to attract those Sikhs who hardly attend the Gurudwara Sahib....but it would have to take place during peak times like VaiSakhi... ......just a thought!

Re: A Shadow over Southall

uk singh · 14 Apr 2004

To add more salt to the injury, I am obliged to share with you what a very reliable source told me - the Namdharis had apparently been guaranteed up to 6 months ago that they would be allowed a float, so this wasn’t some kind of last minute cock-up due to miscommunication or some other minor slip-ups. the Namdharis have been present at the last 3-4 Nagar Kirtan programmes. So booking 6 months advance really has no basis. As far as I can see anyone can join in as long as they are performing kirtan or making a racket. The Sangat in Southall tolerate the Namdharis simply because they are well known and well respected musicians that teach Gurmat Sangeet. In all the years that I have attended no one has confronted them once - eventhough they turn up in relatively small numbers. You are correct in saying that someone needs to resolve the issue by liasing with the likes of Himmat. Unfortunately the youth in Southall are completely shunned by the committee, are not taken seriously and have to practically beg just to get a room for a youth Kirtan programme. Kiddies camps are a complete 'NO NO'! Havelock Road Gurdwara has been a waste of money as it has no room for 'any' youth events/camps, and it has catered more for architectural design rather than a practical Guru Ghar.

Re: A Shadow over Southall

uk singh · 14 Apr 2004

**To add more salt to the injury, I am obliged to share with you what a very reliable source told me - the Namdharis had apparently been guaranteed up to 6 months ago that they would be allowed a float, so this wasn’t some kind of last minute cock-up due to miscommunication or some other minor slip-ups. *** the Namdharis have been present at the last 3-4 Nagar Kirtan programmes. So booking 6 months advance really has no basis. As far as I can see anyone can join in as long as they are performing kirtan or making a racket. The Sangat in Southall tolerate the Namdharis simply because they are well known and well respected musicians that teach Gurmat Sangeet. In all the years that I have attended no one has confronted them once - eventhough they turn up in relatively small numbers. You are correct in saying that someone needs to resolve the issue by liasing with the likes of Himmat. Unfortunately the youth in Southall are completely shunned by the committee, are not taken seriously and have to practically beg just to get a room for a youth Kirtan programme. Kiddies camps are a complete 'NO NO'! Havelock Road Gurdwara has been a waste of money as it has no room for 'any' youth events/camps, and it has catered more for architectural design rather than a practical Guru Ghar.

Re: A Shadow over Southall

Guru ka Singh · 16 Apr 2004

Naamdharis have been actively hovering around the Sikh sangat in UK for over 30 years. Our parent's generation didn't seem to do anything about it. We really need to stand our ground when in comes to Namdhari's distorting OUR history at OUR events. Be vigilant at the coming Nagar Kirtans in the UK and watch out for the Namdhari/Naang etc propganda.

Re: A Shadow over Southall

the dirt under ur shoes · 16 Apr 2004

If u think southall is bad who witnessed the 300 yrs celebrations at Anandpur Sahib they had kouke, RSS and other anti-panthic organisations.