Skip to content
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Forum
If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
<..> · 06 Apr 2004
I was thinking about this. We often hear Sikhs use to following lines: "if you're a Hindu, be a good Hindu. If you're a Muslim, be a good Muslim. If you're a Sikh be a good Sikh..."
Reflecting on this, I can firmly conclude that it makes NO sense. Can we further say "If you're a Jain be a good Jain" or maybe "If you are a Satan worshipper, be a good Satan worshipper..."
Guru Sahib says :
eik jainee oujhurr paae dhhuruhu khuaaeiaa ||
Some are Jains, wasting their time in the wilderness; by their pre-ordained destiny, they are ruined. panna 1285
******
hi(n)dhoo a(n)nhaa thurukoo kaanaa ||
The Hindu is blind; the Muslim has only one eye. panna 875
*******
So when we say be a "good Hindu" arent' we saying "If you're blind...then be really really blind" and for Muslims, "If you're KaaNaa, be really really KaaNaa"
And for Jains, "If you're wasting your time and ruining yourself, then do it good! Waste more and ruin yourself more!"
I don't know. The thought just entered my mind. What a really nonsensical phrase that we have made common.
Re: If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
utkl · 06 Apr 2004
maybe it means by being a good hindu or muslim in this life they might get a chance to be a sikh in their following lives if they do their seva good deeds or whatever they do properly.
Re: If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
Singh · 06 Apr 2004
You only become Sikh by the grace of Guru Ji. Those who have good Karma will get this opportunity. When Guru Sahib tells Muslims to be good Muslims, he also tells them to remember God and be truthful and honest in their lives. By doing this, they may get the chance to be a Sikh of Guru Ji. Guru Ji's path is the final path before we meet God.
Re: If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
<..> · 06 Apr 2004
Guru Sahib never tells Hindus to be "good Hindus" he tells them that they are "blind".
There are shabads in Guru Granth Sahib that give qualities of a "Muslim" like he is "mom dil" ie. heart of wax etc... but if a Muslim attempts to take on these qualities, he no longer remains a Muslim, he becomes a Sikh.
Re: If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
s!nghn! · 06 Apr 2004
I've heard this line "if you're a Hindu/Muslim/whatever, then be a good Hindu/Muslim/whatever" used mostly only by those who put political correctness ahead of all else. If you say Sikhi is the best religion, they say Guru Sahib respected all faiths and wanted Hindus to be the best Hindus, and Muslims to be the best Muslims, etc etc etc.
I think it all comes down to a post from before which touched on our insecurity and how we for some reason end up being the ones to put ourselves down and can't grasp that we do indeed have the best faith. Rather than "offend" people with the truth that they are indeed wasting away their lives, we'd rather basically tell them that yes, ruin yourself even more!
Re: If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
??? · 06 Apr 2004
This is a fascist thread...there has been much evil done in the world on account of being the 'chosen' people and the opinions above are indicative that many of the "Gursikhs" regard themselves to be part of the "chosen" people on account of being Khalsa Sikhs...
...very concerning to see such horrors taking hold of our people...
Re: If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
<..> · 06 Apr 2004
"horrors taking hold on our people"!!!??
Singhs in puraatan times used to refer to all other religions as "kachay pillay" and "churaasee daa maal" or unbaked/weak and fodder for the cycle of birth/death.
The difference between a Sikh and any other faith is that Sikhs don't believe that non-Sikhs go to hell or are punished. They believe that followers of those religions will get what they work for (heaven, etc.).
It's a hugeee problem these days that Sikhs themselves have such confidence problems that they no longer see themselves as special and as chosen by Akaal Purakh for the revelation of the ENTIRE truth. We start to feel a little ashamed when we say "Raj Karaygaa Khalsa" and explain it away, "oh no...the PURE will rule...not US! God forbid!"
And we're not chosen! Of course not! "Khalsa akaal purakh kee fauj, pragtio khalsa parmatam kee mouj" is just a saying! We aren't really the best.
I've always wondered if people who act like this have actually bothered to understand what Tva Parsaad Svaiyay mean.
Re: If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
hanji · 06 Apr 2004
baba jarnail singh said summit like" if ur a hindu be a good hindu if your a muslim be a gud muslim if your a sikh be a gud sikh" thats good enuff for me cos he wasnt just anyone.
Re: If You're a Hindu Be a Good Hindu???
.. · 06 Apr 2004
Here's some GREAT advice I read to an guy from a Sikh background wanting to convert to Islam:
As a religion, "Sikhism" will always be on par with other faiths, so you choosing Islam is fine. But as a universal dharma, I cannot agree that Islam or any other religion (including "Sikhism") can compare to Sikhi. And if you do decide to adopt Islam, then remember that you can still be a Sikh of the Gurus at the same time.
WHO brainwashed our people SO WELL??? We DEMAND to be one amongst many when we clearly are not!! My God! This inferiority complex is going to kill us!
Guru Nanak revealed a true and perfect faith that is unique. Why do WE demand to make it just like the others?