Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Guru ka Singh · 05 Apr 2004

What are your views? I have been married 5 years have a couple of kids. When we got married I was not into Sikhi. Over the last year I have discovered myself and my goal in life. I have fallen in love with Sikhi and have found so much contentment. I want to give my head to the Guru and take Amrit. The problem is my wife is not intereseted in taking Amrit, to be honest with you she's not really into Sikhi. Initially we began having a lot of marital problems as she felt she was loosing me to SIkhi and I was not the person she married 5 years ago. She married me as a mona and I have now taken the roop of a Sikh. Over the year she has begun to understand why I want to commit to Sikhi. She knows that I have found peace and even says she is jealous that I seem to be content. However, she feels she can't let herself go. She's still to attached her ego. Our lifestyles have changed dramatically and she has been with me all the way. We gave up meat & alcohol & don't really associate ourselves much with the 'Khaan-Peen' world out there. She's learnt alot more about Sikhi through seeing the changes in me. She was brought up with stereotypical ideas of GurSikhs as being fanatical and strict. Obviously these perceptions have now changed. I want us to move on with our lives and take Amrit, but she has told me she's not interested and can't see herself ever taking it. I can't force her or emotionally blackmail her into having the same love I have. We are obviously different when it comes to this although we love each other deerly. Please give me some advice.

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Mohan Singh · 05 Apr 2004

Your children, parents, wife, freinds are all temporary and will come and go in this world but what counts in this life is your spiritual level and your closeness to Waheguru. It sounds harsh but if you think you are ready to Amritshak and your wife has no intentions, then take Amrit but you will have to treat her as a sister. Also if you wish to keep bibek (which you must) you should only eat from other Amritdharis. I am not Amritdhari yet and the problem of keeping bibek with a family of non-Amritdharis is one I will still need to face in the near future. If you are commited to the Sikhi path your influence will rub off on her and do ardas for her, it is possible Guru Ji may also bless her with Amrit also. Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

jagroop singh · 06 Apr 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Guru Ka Singh Ji, i'm in EXACTLY the same position as you so know how you feel...your story and my story are identical. Bhai Mohan Singh, is it okay for a Sikh to take Amrit without their spouse so long as they can strictly keep Rehat e.g. chastity, bibek etc. i hope this does not become my final (and only option) but if it does, it would be worth me keeping it in mind...would the Punj, if satisfied with the person's level of committment, give the gift of Amrit? Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Singh · 07 Apr 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! I cannot say what the rehit is now...but the old marayada of akj used to be that if you wanted to get pesh you would have to bring your wife as well...akj did not pesh just one person if there is jorree....this can be confirmed from older singhs....i was told this by older singhs as well...it is aobut akj in 70s and early 80s...maybe now they changed it because some famous akj kirtanis own wives are not keski valiea and they want to spread fame through these famous singers...but ask any old akj singh and if singhs wanted to do any seva in jatha....like langar...or deg.....or panj piaray....or even kirtan....their singhnee had to be keski valiea and had to take amrit from the jatha....that means be nam drir....they all changed it now....oh yeah one more thing...in toronto puran singhs were going to make akj registered....and in the consitution they put that only someone whos wife is keski valiea and amrit shak from akj can be a member of akj....they never got it registered....but they approved this consitution from gurus sangat so i saw it with my own eyes....so to answer your question....you are one jorree.....you both have to amrit shak....plus no akj panj piaray should allow you to shak allone...it is against rehit....maybe you will find some akj jathas that do it...since this is a difficult time and not many within are following this rehit.....mainly it is just a big show or rock concert for the super star singers...but i am talking about real namabyas singhs...

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Mkhalsa · 07 Apr 2004

I have to disagree. If one takes amrit without their spouse, it is allowed, why should one spouse suffer when the other wants to remain engrossed in manmat? As long as the spouse that takes amrit does not take jhoot or have marital relations. I beleive I read this in one of bhai sahibs books as well, rangle sajjan?

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Mkhalsa · 08 Apr 2004

hmm.. I want to correct myself on what bhai sahib says, in chapter 21 of rangle sajjan he says the sikh tenets require a husband and wife to be baptised as a couple.

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

kookar · 08 Apr 2004

VaheguroojikaKhalsaVaheguroojikiFathe!! Veer Mkhalsa Jee I understand your point of view but its been a maryada that if we are married we have to get pesh with our spouse. Incase spouse is not ready to get pesh then i would suggest get pesh before 5 and let them decide whether you shall get the amulak daat of Amrit or not. VaheguroojikaKhalsaVaheguroojikiFathe!!

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Mohan Singh · 09 Apr 2004

Could the couple divorce in this situation if it came to it? What would happen if the wife never took amrit, then she would have stopped her husband (who was ready) getting mukti?

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

simran_sewa_sacrifice · 09 Apr 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! actually marriage for one person is allowed (without their husband/wife) provided certain things are agreed on ect... just read the story of giani daleep singh in the literature section of this site. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

khalistani · 10 Apr 2004

Vaheguur je ka khalsa vaheguru je ke fateh! if she wont take amrit at all, take it by ureself, but u have to treat her as a real sister bhula chuka maf Vaheguur je ka khalsa vaheguru je ke fateh!

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

jagroop singh · 05 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf is it not possible for both husband and wife work toether towards Sikhi and still live as a married couple? is it not unfair to deny the wife if she is willing to join the path? vjkk vjkf

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

answer · 05 Jan 2005

as stated earlier this is partially the story of Giani Daleep Singhs ordeal in a similar situation as the poster of this thread: ____________________________________________________________ Before the start of samagam, Giani Harbhajan Singh Chaminda and myself expressed our desire for partaking Amrit. Bhai Sahib said, "Well, take full bath and be present before the Akhand Path starts and listen to whole of the recitation." We did as instructed. After Bhog of Akhand Path, keertan of Asa di Vaar was over by about 10.00 a.m. Panj Piyaras assembled in a room in the presence of Sri Guru Granth Sahib for initiating new Khalsas. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee, Bhai Attar Singh Jee, Bhai Surjan Singh Jee Gujarwal, Bhai Parbhakar Singh Jee Lalton and a Singh Jee from Phallewal served as Panj Piyaras, and Jathedar Ram Singh Jee was in attendance to Sri Guru Granth Sahib. First Giani Harbhajan Singh appeared before Panj Piyaras. He was asked whether he was married or not to which he replied that he was married. He was asked if his wife is also with him and ready to partake Amrit. To which he replied that he has come alone. At this he was told that both, he and his wife, should be present together. He alone cannot be administered Amrit. Bhai Harbhajan Singh came out very dejected and weeping, he went straight to a manger (Khurli) in the courtyard, threw himself in it and started wailing uncontrollably. I tried to console him and find out the reason for his grief but he could not utter a word. Then the Panj Piyaras called me; I went inside, bowed before the Guru and stood up with folded hands. Thus proceeded questions and answers about my marital status: "Are you married or not?" "I am married." "Then you can not be administered Amrit in the absence of your wife." "It means that if my wife does not agree to partake Amrit I will have to die without coming under the umbrage of Guru. I do not need a wife I need Amrit. Please find a way to administer Amrit to me." "You will have to pledge in the presence of Panj Piyaras and Guru that unless your wife partakes Amrit and she is married to you as per Gurmat traditions by performing Anand Karaj, you will not consider her as your wife." As I had married as per Hindu rites. I agreed to this condition. Bhai Sahib again said, "The pledge you are going to take before the Guru is difficult to keep. Give a second thought to it." I thought for a moment and replied, "I consider Panj Piyaras as living image of omnipresent Guru. When in the presence of Guru, Sri Guru Granth Sahib, the living image of the Guru, Panj Piyaras bless me then I will be able to face any difficult situation and all problems would be solved." "All right bow before the Guru, you will be administered Amrit." I was very much attached with Giani Harbhajan Singh. I requested on his behalf, "Harbhajan Singh is very upset. He is weeping and wailing and can not be consoled. Please consider him also under similar condition." My plea was accepted and he was called in again. ____________________________________________________________

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Dil · 06 Jan 2005

VJKK,VJKF; It is funny to consider your wife as sister? You are married to a lady as per gurumaryada and I donot think that gurumaryada ever says to consider you wife as sister if, she is not interested to take amrit. Even I am against divorcing her for amrit or even I against forcing her to accept amrit. Just try to keep your self perfect and give her some more time and do ardaas till she accepts amrit. VJKK,VJKF;

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

khalistani · 06 Jan 2005

vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh alright, i dont wanna post anymore, but i noticed a mistake on my behalf i was wrong u can both be married, and one ba mridhari as long as u dont have ANY type of relations thas the rule bhula chuka maf vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

question · 06 Jan 2005

Why must she be treated as a sister? Bani and theology based answers are requested, not opinions. If he is married to her, has kids with her, it seems absurd that she must now be treated as a sister. I don't see how taking amrit automatically means a person has to treat their wife as a sister. Is it because having taken amrit, one is born again and thus all previous relations are ended. If this is the case, would re-marriage solve the problem (accepting that an amritdhari can marry a non-amritdhari)? What about the kids? Should the guy treat them as someone else's kids or should he acknowledge them as his own? If he acknowledges them as his own, does this not point to his having once had sexual relations with his new "sister"? no disrespect intended.

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

gypsy123 · 06 Jan 2005

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! could Kulbir Singh please reply to this post? Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 06 Jan 2005

khalistani veer, Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. you wrote: if she wont take amrit at all, take it by ureself, but u have to treat her as a "real sister" what is a REAL SISTER ? and an UNREAL SISTER. ?? Can we Really MAKE a WIFE into a "REAL" sister as this is biologically IMPOSSIBLE... and following your logic.."unreal sisters" can be later converted to wives ?? as they are unreal sisters and not real..anyway Reminds me of one of my students who as a teenager just wouldnt adress any girl..as BHEN JI....his excuse.."IF I call a girl BHEN JI..then how can I marry her later ?? And since I dont know who/which girl is going to be my future wife...I cannot take the RISK of calling every girl BHEN JI ?? Confused Jarnail Singh.

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

Jagjinder · 06 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Das di ainy koovat ta nahi hai par pher vee since I felt concerned, I want to suggest you guys something. As long as you can carry out bibek and you are ready to accept all conditions, you should be going for Amrit di daat. Remember Gurbani da farmaan - "Hans akela Jayee". Veerjiyo you have to go alone, no Giani, no member in the group, no advisors none from your family would be going with you. you need not take literal meanin try to understand the essence of the Shabad. Your deeds are only thing which will contribute to your destiny. If your wife is not participating or for that matter you are not participating in your wife's deeds, you are not responsible for destiny of your partner. Moreover, beside a religious baptism, In Sikhi, Amrit is way to live your life, to give you a disciplened and better way of living Bhul chuk maaf

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

question · 06 Jan 2005

Are there any answers to the below post or Jarnail Singh's post? Some were adamant in stating that the wife must be treated as a sister and that sexual relations were not allowed. I would still like to hear gurbani based, theology based reasoning behind these opinions. question wrote: > Why must she be treated as a sister? Bani and theology based > answers are requested, not opinions. > > If he is married to her, has kids with her, it seems absurd > that she must now be treated as a sister. > > I don't see how taking amrit automatically means a person has > to treat their wife as a sister. > > Is it because having taken amrit, one is born again and thus > all previous relations are ended. If this is the case, would > re-marriage solve the problem (accepting that an amritdhari can > marry a non-amritdhari)? > > What about the kids? Should the guy treat them as someone > else's kids or should he acknowledge them as his own? If he > acknowledges them as his own, does this not point to his having > once had sexual relations with his new "sister"? > > no disrespect intended. >

Re: Taking Amrit without your Spouse?

GuruSa Singh · 07 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh ! Let the Punj decide. Ultimately only they can decide your fate, not individuals on this forum. I suggest you do pesh at the next Amrit Sanchar and see what Guruji decides for you. I myself took amrit without my wife as I was in an indentical situation to the original poster. Before I went in to do Pesh I did an Ardas and was basically ready for whatever decision Guruji would make for me via the Punj Pyaray. With Guruji's kirpa I was allowed to take Amrit.