Re: who's weaker?
good question · 28 Mar 2004
I agree with "wondering". Why is it okay for men to take off their shirts in public and its wrong for a woman to do so. Like I have see my dad without a shirt on walking around the house, but never my mom.
Shouldnt it work both ways, like if a man gets kaam looking at a woman, wouldnt a woman get it if looking at a man with out a shirt on? Where is the equality in this?
sangat pleases give your views.
[%sig%]
Re: who's weaker?
singhsation · 29 Mar 2004
Dear 'good question' -
The reason your dad can get away with walking around with his shirt off and your mom cannot, has to do with the fact that your dad is a man and a man's body is not nearly as sexualized as a women's body. Societal norms, western or punjabi do not tolerate such nudity in women.
I'll give you a more striking example. A khalsa is a khalsa is a khalsa - hopefully there is no question as to this statement. Whether a khalsa is a woman or a man, they are equal.......
.......but not when it comes to the body. Men and women can both wear cholay, but it would be considerd unacceptable for women to wear cholay the way most men do ie. kachera with no pants, lower legs completely bare.
Equality exists in the sphere of our spirituality, the respect we are accorded, our atma and gursikhi. Guru ji's kirpa is not diffrentiated on the basis of our sex.
However, there is a very real physical inequality between men and women (strength and size being the obvious ones) and society has built certain rules based on these physical inequalities and Punjabi society is no different. While many times there is a clash between our culture and our religion, in this case, I don't see any conflict.
daas
Re: who's weaker?
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 29 Mar 2004
honestly speaking,
i think NONE of these rules apply in gurmat
i know this is very politically INCORRECT to say this
but i think if a KHALSA woman wants to wear whatever KHALSA men wear, in the "land of gurmat" there is no objection
Guru and God look at your BHAAVNAA and your REHIT, they do not look at 'what people will think' or 'what society thinks' or 'what is normal'
In Bhai Randhir Singh jee's autobiography there is a story of Mata Gulab Kaur who was a sant and she wore only a shawl and her 5 k's .... I will never dare to call her wrong
At Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib's nishaan sahib installation ceremony there were 2 bibiaan in the Punj Pyare who wore cholaas without pajamees.... I will never dare to call them wrong
Let me make one thing clear
the Khalsa and Gursikhi are
NOT WESTERN
NOT EASTERN
NOT PUNJABI
NOT ENGLISH
NOT POLITICALLY CORRECT
and definately don't give a care in the world about cultural superstitions
The Khalsa lives in the love of the Almighty
in the hukam of the Almighty
by the will of the Almighty
under the charan sharan of the Almighty
and looks up to nobody else but the Almighty
These rules dont' apply for teh Khalsa
seperating men and women ANYWHERE is manmat, and the problems are in the MIND not in the maryada ... you will not make men less sexual by seperating them... or women less sexual by seperating them...
I am a serious rogee - I don't have control over my kaam, krodh, lobh, moh and ahankaar.
The only thing that has helped me is listening to and understanding and accepting and following Gurbani Shabad Keertan in the Saadh Sangat and most of all reciting Naam.
Kaam is healed by Naam,
not by Western or Eastern Society's laws.
bhul chuk maaf karnaa
daas
[%sig%]
Re: who's weaker?
singhsation · 29 Mar 2004
Dear "kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa"
No one is saying that kaam is healed by western or eastern society's laws; however, no religion or practitioner of religion exists in a vacuum.
Every religion is going to draw its examples/lessons/parables from the culture surrounding it. Sahib Satguru Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji Maharaj writes of Chandi - the reference to Chandi is lost without culture as a context.
Culture isn't paramount nor am I saying it is paramount but it IS there, whether you choose to turn a blind eye to it or not.
Your post, while idealistic, is not realistic. I have zero hesitation in taking off my shirt if I have to, for sports or swimming or what have you. If you are a woman, do you have the same lack of inhibition? If you are a male, do you encourage sisters and mothers to take off their tops so they can be "equal".
Seperating men and women is not always manmat; that is a gross overgeneralization.
Do you think it is manmat that men and women have different public bathrooms? Do you think it is manmat that men and women compete in gender-specific categories in sports? Or do you think female olympic wrestlers should be wrestling in the men's division? Is that fair?
How about job requirements where there are different physical requirements for men and women? (Police force, firefighters). Keep in mind that women's rights groups have fought hard to establish these different requirements - requirements that recognize that the differences nature has imposed upon them do not take away from their ability to do the job.
The fact of the matter is men and women are not physically equal and never have been.
Some of these differences are overtly taken as sexual, ie breasts, legs.
How is recognizing the differences Akal Purakh has created between men and women manmat or against Gursikhi?
You mention bibian in the Panj Piare. They were not bibian - they were the Panj Piare. Do you get my point? (note, I am sure you are aware of the arguments that don't support bibian being part of the Panj Piare - arguments I do not wish to engage in because I don't feel strongly one way or the other).
I seriously doubt if these bibian would be willing to take off their tops or walk around with bare legs in scenarios where men would have no hesitation. ie. wrestling, ishnaan at Harimandar Sahib sarovar etc.
I agree with you, that God doesn't care about what other people think of you. So now I ask you, why don't you walk around naked? What do you care what people think?
Tell you what, do this tomorrow: Get up in the morning, do your ishnaan, simran and bania. Make sure you have all of your kakkars on and then go to school or work like that - with no other clothes. Also, make sure you convince the women in your household to do the same thing.
Will you do it? Can you do it? If not, then that is acknowledging that much of what we do is in the bounds of culture and society.
Guru ji understands this. We're not hermits. Guru ji told us to know and understand this world, and, in fact, commands us to learn politics so we can truly understand the way the world moves.
In this case, dear brother or sister, I must respectfully disagree with your argument although I appreciate the sentiment behind it.
daas
Re: who's weaker?
kar kirpaa sab rayN theevaa(n · 29 Mar 2004
Dear singhstation veerjee,
I sincerely hope that in my post I did not insinuate that I am calling for, or supporting, an altogether rejection of clothing. What I meant to say was that the Khalsa does not fall into the confines of cultural context. Wherever you see cultural context being applied, please do not see that as such - it is in fact Gurmat being applied in adaptation to the surrounding environment. When a chemeleon changes its colours, IT changes its colours, nobody forces it to. In the same way, Khalsa holds a sovereignty over its personal presentation that will not be imposed upon. But the similarities between the chemeleon and Khalsa end there. At a certain point, the Khalsa will boldly refuse assimilation and must remain "niaaraa." If Gurmat says a certain thing is good or bad, a true Khalsa will do it. If society says a certain thing is good or bad, a true Khalsa will look to Gurmat only and then make the decision. This would apply for all things.
I leave my gender out of this because it's irrelevant. If I am male I would do what Gurmat says, and If I am female I would what Gurmat says, and Gurmat is very clearly egalitarian, while recognizing differences.
I certainly did not intend to give the notion that I reject the differences between males and females. Rather my only concern is the forced seperation of Khalsa men and women. If there are manmukhs, bemukhs and saakat people there - forced seperation might be required. However for Khalsas, their sexual, sensual and emotional attitude acts in accordance with Guru jee's teachings, regardless of the circumstance.
Case-in-point Bhai Rama Singh jee being asked to share a room and sleep beside a woman. She trusted him for being a Sikh, and that very night he had Darshan of Guru Gobind Singh instructing him to become a Khalsa.
The people who live 100% by gurmat are very rare, and I humbly apologize if my post was a gross generalization. It seems like a very "controversial" move that Bhai Bota Singh started charging taxes to people on the streets (as if the Khalsa ruled the place) when nearly everybody in Punjab thought that the Khalsa was extinct. It seems like a very "gutsy" move that the Khalsa DECLARED Khalistan in 1987, rather than REQUESTING Khalistan. It seems very "idealistic" that in Chamkaur 40 Singhs slaughtered thousands upon thousands of opponents. The Khalsa has characteristically always been very "idealistic," "gutsy" and "controversial" . . . this is just their sweet nature.
There are only a few virlay Gurmukh sajjan in this world who prefer to wear only their kakaars and perhaps a chola. Only a few who prefer to have no job, and get no formal education, and instead teach themselves - or become entrepreneurs, or just do whatever is within their power to serve the Khalsa.
I am not one of these, but I sure-as-hell support them and argue that I could never call their way-of-life as wrong.
I agree with you that those Bibiaan are Punj Pyare so they will dress as the Punj Pyare do. But who do the Punj Pyare dress as? If I had been talking about the punj pyare and the composition of gender, I would have used the phrases, "2 bibiaan and 3 bhai." As you are concerned about not being in a vaccuum, please understand that assuming the Punj Pyare live in a vaccuum is also incorrect. The Punj Pyare, whatever the gender composition, are actually the representation of what every normal Khalsa should be. They are a representation of what we all should be - all of us, not the best of us, all of us... not the extremists and fanatics out of us... all of us... but that's the thing... all of us can't be there - those people are rare, that's why we call them "cream of the crop" --- however that doesn't mean the crop shouldn't try to emulate them.
If Gurmat says it's okay to wear pajamees, then it's okay. If Gurmat says it's okay to wear socks and runners, then it's okay. If Gurmat says that women at Harimandir Sahib should do their ishnaan behind a wall while men do ishnaan in the open, then it's okay.
But I think a true Khalsa will wear something or not wear something, and will do something or not do something if Gurmat says, not if their culture says.
Guru Gobind Singh is the Khalsa's sachee sarkaar.
I have a lot of work to do before I can call myself a sachee daasee or sachaa sevak. However those people who are there - I can never say that their way is impractical, idealistic (and therefore inappropriate) or anything like that. Gursikhaa(n) nou saabaas hai. That's all I can say.
bhul chuk maaf karnaa,
daas
[%sig%]
Re: who's weaker?
singhsation · 30 Mar 2004
Dear "kar kirpaa sab rayN theevaa(n",
Perhaps we are misunderstanding each other but I have no disagreement with anything you have written.
The khalsa does as the khalsa does and our actions are measured against a standard laid out by gurmat, not society.
However, gurmat does not mention whether we should wear leather pants or burlap skirts; running shoes or sandals; togas or business suits. These are choices made within the context of culture/society. The same holds true for wearing or not wearing clothes.
Again, no disagreement with me on the Khalsa being sovereign and that gurmat prevails regardless of society's restrictions or demands. However, there is nothing inherently wrong with following the societal norms where the customs parallel gurmat or are not in conflict with gurmat.
daas
Re: who's weaker?
singhsation · 30 Mar 2004
Dear Mkhalsa,
I have to respectfully disagree with some of what you've stated.
While there is going to be some variance in the population, in general, men are stronger. There are some women, think olympic lifters, who in addition to their training are genetically gifted and can probably lift more than 90% of the men on this forum. These women are not the norm.
While culture plays a part in determining who is expected to be strong (men) and who is not (women), culture is definitely not the sole determining factor.
The fact of the matter is that nature has built men to be stronger than women. More muscle mass, greater amounts of testosterone, lower body fat - these are some of the things making men stronger than women. In fact, no matter how much or how hard women work out, they simply will not be able to bulk up and get thick like men do unless they're on steroids (which will create a whole host of problems in women).
Mai Bhago, if she had muscles the size of Baba Deep Singh ji, was not representative of the average woman. If she was, then we would see a lot more genetically 'buff' Punjabi girls. Mai Bhago was an exceptional Singhnee.
Moreover, swordplay is not subject entirely to strength and women can compete successfully against men. The main factors here are skill, technique, experience and then strength (in my opinion). This holds true for other martial arts as well. My sister (amritdhari) has been a black belt for years, can probably double the number of pushups of 90% of the men on this forum and has explosive speed most people can only dream about. She has competed and won at both national and international levels - something to make every Gursikh proud.
However, while she has the ability to knock out or seriously hurt guys who are lesser skilled than her or slower than her, at a certain point, strength starts to become a factor. I don't have a black belt but when we spar, although my technique isn't quite as sharp as my sister's, my greater bodyweight and strength give me a decided advantage.
Respectfully, I must disagree with the analysis on wrestling - if both the combatants are equally skilled or similarly skilled, the stronger person is going to win.
Shastar vidya is a different beast - skill and speed play a much greater role than strength and I think women can already compete with men in this field. If you ever get an opportunity, try your skill against a woman who has been doing kendo for a few years or arnis and you'll know what I'm talking about. Its just a matter of time before women doing gatka today have put in enough training time to make up in skill and speed what they lack in raw strength.
daas
ps. I am the biggest advocate of martial arts. If you are a Sikh, you are obliged to know how to fight. This includes shastar vidya as well as empty-hand fighting. Sikhs used to be considered the ultimate warriors like "carved stone on horseback" and our physical prowess was intimidating. Now, most Gursikhs I see are in garbage shape and couldn't knock out a fly if they tried. Join a gym, buy a punching bag and start training!
Re: who's weaker?
singhsation · 30 Mar 2004
Dear Mkhalsa,
I'm sorry, I cannot agree with this, regardless of what a beginner anthropology class has to say about it.
Please forgive the graphic example, but a change in perception isn't going to change the fact that men have testicles and produce testosterone.
Biology, not cultural perception determines bone density, height, hormone levels etc. Will a change in cultural perception make me taller? Will it somehow increase women's ability to put on more muscle? Definitely not.
Cultural perception comes into play when roles are examined. If we go by a an exaggerated patriarchal society where only men are expected to be warriors and women stay in the kitchen and raise kids, strength will be a positive attribute for men and men will seek to acquire it, increase it. Since, in this case, the society defines the women's role as that of caretaker, there is no encouragement or requirement for women to get stronger.
In this sense, cultural perception plays a part - if the society expects men to be strong and women to be weak, men will seek to be stronger and women will not have the same compulsion to get stronger.
If we switch to an 'amazon' like culture where the men stay home and the women hunt, the women will seek to get stronger and the men won't.
However, the ability to get stronger is limited by biology. Imagine a scenario where both men and women are warriors and both seek to get stronger - on average, men will remain stronger than women.
If differences in strength were a figment of cultural perception - why are there such significant differences ibetween the sexes, in the amount of weight lifted by competitive olympic athletes?
In the above example, both female and male are trying to lift as much as they can - perception, if it does play a part, demands that both lift as much as they can and win! Why do men lift more than women?
For that matter? Why are male olympic sprinters faster than female sprinters? Why do male high jumpers have better verticals than females?
Cultural perception, if it plays a role at all, demands the absolute best from these highly trained and motivated individuals, so why these differences in performance?
The answer is Biology. In general, men are stronger or have the potential to be stronger; cultural perception does not change this.
daas
[%sig%]
Re: who's weaker?
singhsation · 01 Apr 2004
Dear 'Nonsense' -
I have to agree with pretty much everything you said. G's comments had a definite sexist slant to them. However, to give G the benefit of the doubt, perhaps he did not really intend to say what he did.
Strength, REAL strength goes beyond the physical - a Singh fighting against the Moghuls is one type of strength - a Singhnee watching her children get cut to pieces and thrown into her lap, but refusing to give up her faith, is the definition of Gursikh strength.
Roles change....the role of women, including Gursikh women, is different now than it was two hundred years ago, even 100 years ago. Many Gursikh women are educated professionals, excelling in their chosen field of work - this was not always the case. This change came about because society in the whole changed, making it acceptable and even desireable for women to get educated and join the work force.
Singhnian, from the time they are young, should be encouraged to be as courageous and unflinching as their brothers - the role they play in the world is not as limited by their sex as it once was, and it is a gross disservice to place artificial limitations on what they can accomplish.
But this whole line of discussion has changed from what was originally being discussed, namely, physical strength. While there is definitely an inequality in physical strength, this does not mean that women are somehow inferior creatures who should be confined to the home.
I think the participation of women, Gursikh women, in academics, in sports, and in the work force indicates their ability to be successful in pretty much anything in the modern world.
daas
[%sig%]
Re: who's weaker?
singhsation · 01 Apr 2004
'Nonsense',
I think you're mixing what I wrote with what someone else has written - I haven't made any mention of 'bras' or many of the other things you are responding to, in any of my posts.
regarding Singhnian fighting against the Moghuls - I am sure there were Singhnian fighting alongside the Singhs but I doubt if this was the norm.
I'm not sure what you're disagreeing with in my post - I've already stated that swordplay is not a function of strength alone and there are any number of women who could defeat men.
If you are disagreeing with something I have said, please point to it specifically so I can respond to it specifically. As I see it right now, I have very little disagreement with what you've written.
daas
Re: who's weaker?
boomshakala · 25 Mar 2005
Were equal but not in the physical sense. It is normal to see men bathing with shirts off and it im pretty sure peopledont even think twice about it when they see it or feel any kaam. But its just simpy different if a woman is doing it. And i dont get the point how are you going to convince all the babeh n stuff who do ishnaan to start going behind a wall, or all the bibyan to start doing ishnaan out in the open. You are obviously never going to convince these people there going t othink your an idiot for even bringing it up. There isnt a need to critisize everything, just let some things be because they are fine the way the are.
Re: who's weaker?
Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 25 Mar 2005
Sikh women should adorn themselves with Dastaar - most distinct. Whether it be a high Damaala or small Damaala, the size does not come into account, Chola can also be worn with or without Pyjamee. Gurmat believes in equallity, however the dress worn by members of either sex should not be too showy and should be simple.
As for PaRdaa at Shri Harimandir Sahib Sarovar, this is a must as Men, generally speaking are of weaker minded than Women Kaam wise. Kaam (Desire) is a very bad disease, only by the Grace of Satguru through his Naam can it we be cured of it.
Sarab Rogh Ka Aukadh Naam||