Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

could you please help me?

could you please help me?

kaur!!!! · 24 Mar 2004

waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh i am wondering when takin a isnaan where do we place our five kakaa's?? could you please help me thanks. waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: could you please help me?

Kulbir Singh · 24 Mar 2004

According to what I have learned in the sangat of Gursikhs and from books by Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, here is the procedure we should follow at amritvela: 1) We should get up at amritvela. 2) We should try to clean our stomach (through excretion) before doing ishnaan. 3) We should brush our teeth (or use daatun). 4) Tie our keski to our waist, wrap Siri Sahib (kirpaan) around keski and also keep your kanga there. Open our kesh. 5) Use full cold water (no hot water at all) and wash your hair and face. In Canada, water is ice-cold in summer and winter. The feeling after taking shower in cold water is amazing. Consciousness reaches it's maximum. Abhyaas goes automatically. 6) After washing your hair, soak out water and comb your hair and beard. Wash your kanga and place in in your jooRa (hair knot). Tie your keski ( a new one, a fresh one) on your head. 7) Wash your Siri Sahib and Gaatra or use your second set of washed gaatra and Siri Sahib and tie it around your head. 8) Now do ishnaan of your body, again with pure cold water. Such is the affect of cold water (ice cold water) that automatically swaas swaas simran abhyaas starts in full force. The feeling after ishnaan with cold water is undescribible (beyond description). 9) Keep separate towels for your body and hair. Use your body wala towel and dry your body. 10) Remove your kachherra and ensure that the right leg is removed first. Keep the wet kachhera in your left leg for now. 11) Take your new (fresh) kachhera (must be white kachherra, long till knees) and place your right foot or leg in the new kachherra. Now remove your left leg from the wet kachherra and wear your left leg in the new kachherra. 12) All the time while we do ishnaan we must do either Siri Jap jee Sahib or Vaheguru Gurmantra or Mool Mantra. Otherwise Guru Sahib does not accept ishnaan dee sewa. Bhul chukk dee maafi. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: could you please help me?

me · 24 Mar 2004

des the japji saahib count for nitnem?

Re: could you please help me?

Singh · 24 Mar 2004

wicked post kulbir singh!! Ok, now a couple of questions so you could clarify, 1) can we combine those 2 showers into one? i.e. wash our hair as we wash our body or no? i don't fully understand what you mean with the 2 seperate showers, like the first time for the keshi, do we just put your heads into the shower area? 2) does it matter which feet we take out first? left or right? you specified right first.. anyways, just asking! please clarify. otherwise, wicked post! real educational.

Re: could you please help me?

Kulbir Singh · 24 Mar 2004

------- des the japji saahib count for nitnem? --------- I am not sure if it counts or not but I personally don't count it for myself. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: could you please help me?

anonamous · 24 Mar 2004

GurFAteh, wicked post veer :) a few Q's tho - 10) Remove your kachherra and ensure that the right leg is removed first. Keep the wet kachhera in your left leg for now. -------------------- Why so? I knwo muslism say Left is 'unholy' but why left for us :O? ---------- 11) Take your new (fresh) kachhera (must be white kachherra, long till knees) and place your right foot or leg in the new kachherra. Now remove your left leg from the wet kachherra and wear your left leg in the new kachherra. --------------- I use kachera, is not other color aloud? ------------- Ques in 'Singhs' post also struck me, please clarify veer :) bhulla chukk di khima

Re: could you please help me?

.. · 24 Mar 2004

>>After washing your hair, soak out water and comb your hair and beard. Wash your kanga and place in in your jooRa (hair knot). Tie your keski ( a new one, a fresh one) on your head.<< so you do that to wet hair?

Re: could you please help me?

..kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa · 24 Mar 2004

just to clarify i do not follow this rehit but i think it's a very good guideline for leading a balanced lifestyle and it's very inspiring the gursikhs who do this rehit this is in response to ".." bhainjee/veerjee when i do ishnan of my kes i wash my kes and then i soak out the water like bhai sahib has said when i soak out the water, then i use my the towel for my kes to dry my kes and then i do my kanga, while doing the kanga any extra water also comes out - and by the time i am doing my jooRaa, my kes are no longer soaking wet, or even dripping wet, they are just slightly moist so don't worry about you having a soaking wet head when you tie your keski - that is easily preventable by doing the above and hairdryers fry your hair anyway so that's not healthy when you use conditioner and/or leave-in conditioner it makes it much easier to do your kanga with less tangles and also less water ~~~~~ and i would just like to mention here that this is the amazing thing about sikhi we all know that it is your spiritual love and dedication to the naam that matters the most, but what other religion teaches you that to live in this world you must be a balanced person what religion gives you practical real life advice such as just because women have periods doesn't mean they're impure just because you're low caste doesn't mean you are lower human being what religion gives you day to day guidelines such as brush your teeth every day and you won't feel pain those who don't wash their hands after going to the washroom are going against gurmat do your kanga twise a day and take a shower in cold water and by the same token this religion teaches you to love everybody and see God in all to respect all as equal and to practice self reflection to abandon maya and still be able to live in the world to remain awake and not be ignorant, and still be worry-free i have taken efforts to learn about other religions and i have yet to find such a balanced and rich lifestyle teaching as gurmat dhan dhan gursikh dhan dhan guru dhan dhan sat sangat bhul chuk maaf karnaa waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!

Re: could you please help me?

jeevan · 26 Mar 2004

kulbir singh do your self do issnan with cold water?

Re: could you please help me?

Kulbir Singh · 26 Mar 2004

------ kulbir singh do your self do issnan with cold water? --------- I am not sure what you are going to gain by asking me if I do ishnaan with cold water but to answer your question - by the kirpa of Siri Guru jee, I do ishnaan with pure cold water every morning. I am not the only one who does so. Numerous Singhs and Singhnees I know do ishnaa with pure cold water. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: could you please help me?

uk singh · 26 Mar 2004

Kulbir Singh, do you read the holy Japji Sahib with your hair uncovered - during a hair wash?

Re: could you please help me?

Kulbir Singh · 26 Mar 2004

---------- Kulbir Singh, do you read the holy Japji Sahib with your hair uncovered - during a hair wash? --------- I am getting all grilled by sangat today. How come? How come my peshi is being taken today and others are spared? Yes I do Siri Jap jee Sahib while taking shower and sometimes I do Gurmantr and at other times I do Mool Mantr. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written in Gurmat Bibek that a Sikh can do paath like this or if drying hair, so long as he or she is not holding a pothi or gutka, and is doing paath from memory. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: could you please help me?

uk singh · 26 Mar 2004

Sorry Singh Ji....did not mean to offend you. However, I have been advised not to recite paat when combing my hair...

Re: could you please help me?

Question · 28 Mar 2004

1. is it bad to wash your body first then do your hair 2. although the answer should be "wake up earlier", is there anyway other than using a hairdryer i can use to make my kesh dry faster, since at the moment unless i use a hairdryer my hair isnt dry in time. how long does it take, for your hair to dry, from coming out the bath to bone dry, ready to be tied into jurra for the day?

Re: could you please help me?

canada singh · 28 Mar 2004

Kulbir Singh, do you use a hair dryer to dry your hair? I heard its not good because it can dry out your hairs.

Re: could you please help me?

G SINGH · 24 Nov 2005

Vahiguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vahiguroo Jee Kee Fateh bhai sahib kulbir singh ji, i would just like to let you know that even though are views are very differeing, i have nothing but full respect for you. Vahiguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vahiguroo Jee Kee Fateh

Re: could you please help me?

1699 · 24 Nov 2005

Kulbir Singh you are truley an INSPIRATIONAL guy....hence the "grillings" you are getting.............and Im not even amritdhari and I think so highly of you.

Re: could you please help me?

... · 24 Nov 2005

1699 - the only person we should think highly of is Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Only Guru Jee is perfect and does not make any mistakes... We humans make mistakes without realising.

Re: could you please help me?

singh · 24 Nov 2005

its like an interrogation, question after question. All you need now is that white light in ur face and a punjab police officer threatening to torcher you.

Re: could you please help me?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 24 Nov 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Jee, I really respect you as well, there's a certain glow inside of you that lights up every post you send on this message board and even your images of the Khalsa camp have a certain humbleness and goodness inside of them. You have a Khalsas spirit. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: could you please help me?

. · 24 Nov 2005

----------- Author: Question Date: 03-28-04 05:17 1. is it bad to wash your body first then do your hair ---------- somebody asked the same question i was wondering. can't we do ishnaan of body first and then wash kesh and leave them open to dry while doing nitnem (while still keeping keski around waist)? or is it essential to be fully tyar-bar-tyar when entering guru sahib's darbar (even if it's only in your own home)?

Re: could you please help me?

amarjeet singh · 25 Nov 2005

firstly i dont tihnk it matters which leg u take out of your kachera first as long as u always have one long in kachera secondly i think you should first have body ishnaan then kes ishnaan i agree with all the other points bhai kulbir singh has made

Re: could you please help me?

singhni wannabe · 25 Nov 2005

vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikefateh i have herd that wen you dry your hair you shouldnt keep rubbing your hair with a towel as it pulls your hair out!! and we shouldnt use a hair dryer but drying your hair naturally does take a very long time. vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikefateh

Re: could you please help me?

SS · 25 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh A couple of question for Kulbir Jee I agree with most points apart from the following:::.... Why wash the sri sahib and gatra? Why wash in cold water , doesn't Guru Sahib know that living in a cold country it can be extremely difficult for some people, is Guru Sahib not understanding on this issue? Why white kacheera? Why right leg first and then leg after? Why keep separate towels your only drying hair for crying out loud, does the body come polluted after washing so towel used on the body cannot be used on the hair,...why? The above points seem to be of bramanical influence in the Khalsa...so much bharm I don't understand the neccisity of the above point, thank God they are not in the rehat maryada from the Akal Takt. Kulbir Ji in this day and age we need the answers to why not just I don't know why and I follow it, then it's just blind faith isn't it?? And you're not sure if it count while doing Japji as doing ishnaan,why not , of course your not sure as your not the one who created this bharm type marayda.. How do you know Guru Sahib doens't accept isshnaan di seva,.. does Guru Sahib meniton this anywhere if so please help understand???

Re: could you please help me?

singhni wannabe · 25 Nov 2005

bhai kulbhir singh does it matter if you do body ishnann or kes ishnaan first?? i thougt it didnt matter as long as you did both!

Re: could you please help me?

HGHFH · 25 Nov 2005

JSUT A FEW QUESTIONS WHY DO U HAVE TO WASH HAIR EVERYDAY ? WHY DO U HAVE TO WEAR A WHITE KESHERA?? WHY RIGHT LEG 1ST ? WHY COLD WATER?

Re: could you please help me?

Kulbir Singh · 25 Nov 2005

In my earlier days, I too used to do body ishnaan before keshi inshnaan. Then some Singhs mentioned that since our head is the supreme part of our body, it should be washed first. They also mentioned that as per our tradition, Singhs do ishnaan of the head first. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: could you please help me?

singh · 25 Nov 2005

yeh but technically we dont as u mention we are supposed to brush our teeth and go to the toilet before we have ishnaan so we are washing our teeth and lower area anyways before we wash our hair

Re: could you please help me?

Kulwinder Singh · 25 Nov 2005

My Dear Vir Kulbir Singh Ji, Is this not reducing the Glory of Sikh Philosophy by over emphasising on some personal basic instructive life style of yourself or some other Gurusikhs ? Guru Nanak gone around the world to introduce Sikh Philosophy and defying most useless instructiveness of prevailing practices of time , Guru Arjan Dev Ji made it constitutional to accept philosophy rather then instructions, Guru Teg Bahadur Ji made it principle to stand by philosophy, Deshmesh Pita Guru Gobind Singh Ji confirmed the Khalsa to be light years away from Brahminwad and Instructiveness of other religions, Guru Granth Sahib make commitment that at least his follower should not become robotic instructions followers just like other religions and enforce life in the best philosophy for humanity e.g. Sikhism. Dear Kulbir Singh Ji your comment seems like declaration: " Sikhism is for people who can have bath in just cold water even in cold environment like Canada, an Amritdhari should not go either to north poll, south poll or extreme weather conditions, as having bath in cold water mean a serious pain/ problem ( some time fatal) for human being in those environment, north poll and south poll and some other extreme cold environments are restricted areas for Sikhs ? So for a human being living in those areas Sikhism is not practical ? " Lot of Sikhs, non Sikhs and Anti-Sikhs read this form and I find your comments in this post bit strange. It reduces Sikhism to any other instructive religion. I would seriously like some reply on this from you and other Gurusikhs . Your Guru Bhai Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: could you please help me?

ok singh · 26 Nov 2005

I have a Q. I do keshi ishnaan but then i tie keski and do body ishnaaan. then i go in hazoori of guroo jee and do nitnem. now thing is all that time kesh stay wet... what should i do?

Re: could you please help me?

vichar · 26 Nov 2005

all singhs i know who knew bhai sahib wash body first then wash kesh otherwise kesh would have to be tied up while still wet, kesh is supposed to be allowed to dry naturally before it is tied up, without rubbing with a towel - as kesh is sacred it should be treated with upmost respect

Re: could you please help me?

Kulbir Singh · 26 Nov 2005

Vichar, ------------ all singhs i know who knew bhai sahib wash body first then wash kesh otherwise kesh would have to be tied up while still wet, ------------ Well, Singhs I know wash their head first. If you personally think that it is Gurmat to wash the body first, then you can do as you please. I just wrote here my views and what I have learned in the sangat of Singhs. You don't have to agree to it. And as for your question how we would tie our wet kesh, please refer to Bhai Sahib's own book Gurmat Bibek that clearly writes that if required Kesh can be tied wet. Read that part of Bhai Sahib's book for details. ----------- kesh is supposed to be allowed to dry naturally before it is tied up, without rubbing with a towel - as kesh is sacred it should be treated with upmost respect ------------- There is nothing wrong in using the towel to soak out water from kesh. If you rub the towel heavily, then it may damage hair but if you do it softly, there is nothing wrong in using the towel. As the matter of fact, it is a must that towel is used to drain excess water from hair. Yes kesh are sacred but who do kesh lose respect when using the towel. Kulwinder Singh jee, You can't dismiss rehit of Khalsa by calling it Brahmanvaad. Many rehits may not make sense to you but that does not negate the importance of those rehits. ----------- Lot of Sikhs, non Sikhs and Anti-Sikhs read this form and I find your comments in this post bit strange. It reduces Sikhism to any other instructive religion. ----------- Who says that Gurmat is not an instructive religion? Everything is done in a specially prescribed way. Naam Sanskaar, Amrit Sinchaar, Anand Sanskaar, and Mirtak Sanskaar all is done with a certain maryada. All Sikhs are supposed to rise at amritvela, do ishnaan, japp Gurmat Nam, read certain Baanis, etc etc. In the evening all Sikhs do Rehraas Sahib and Sohila Sahib. Are Sikhs not following instructions of Guru Sahib by doing all this? So what's wrong with being an instructive religion? There are some well known rehits that must be followed exactly as ordered: Kirpan must be of Sarbloh and in Gaatra KaRA must be Sarbloh and in the right hand Kachhera must be white and up to knees. Keski must be of four colours only and be at least 2.5 yards long Dastaar must be one of the four colours and at least 5 yards long. It must be worn in a certain way and removed in a certain way. Kangha must be of wood. Kangha must be done in Kesh twice a day. In the morning it should be done before the ardaas for nitnem and in the evening it should be done before Rehraas Sahib (unless there is a genuine problem in doing so). A Sikh must strive to wear baana at all times. A Sikh must not consume tobacco and other intoxicants. A Sikh must refrain from Fornication and adultery. A Sikh must not remove hair from body. A Sikh must not consume meat. A Sikh must memorize baani regularly. A Sikh must try to do shudh paath and try to arrange to get santhiya to accomplish this. The saakhi of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj reprimanding a Sikh doing wrong paath proves that we must strive to do shudh paath. There are many such rehits that Sikhs follow as per instructions from Guru Sahib. Some of these rehits are written, some are not and the ones not written are carried forward Seena-baseena. Having faith in Singhs telling these rehits is important. If they tell you something that is not anti-Gurmat, then it is our duty to follow it. Kulbir Singh

Re: could you please help me?

. · 26 Nov 2005

2) We should try to clean our stomach (through excretion) before doing ishnaan. *********** Sometimes I try my best, but it doesn't work - What do I do? Not do Ishnana until it finally comes out an hour later? ****** 3) We should brush our teeth (or use daatun). ******* Most dentists recommend that you brush teeth before going to sleep (rati), and after eating Breakfast, as this allows the teeth to "rest" and not be pested by bacteria.... ****** 8) Now do ishnaan of your body, again with pure cold water. Such is the affect of cold water (ice cold water) that automatically swaas swaas simran abhyaas starts in full force. The feeling after ishnaan with cold water is undescribible (beyond description). ******* Not commenting on myself, or how I do ishnan I've got a question - If this is sometihng that Will benifit our spirituality then surely it must be mentioned in Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, just liek waking up AMritvele and keeping kes is Emphised in Bani as something that will help us in the spiritual jeevan, where in GURBANI does it say that this will help us... (as Gurbani is all about spirituality and benifiting Spiritually....) **** 10) Remove your kachherra and ensure that the right leg is removed first. Keep the wet kachhera in your left leg for now. **** Why right leg first :S I take my left leg first so that I can keep myself balanced with my strong foot (right one), and then I put the left one into the new Kachera keeping the right one in the kechara at the moment... ******************* Author: Question Date: 03-28-04 05:17 2. although the answer should be "wake up earlier", is there anyway other than using a hairdryer i can use to make my kesh dry faster, since at the moment unless i use a hairdryer my hair isnt dry in time. how long does it take, for your hair to dry, from coming out the bath to bone dry, ready to be tied into jurra for the day? ****************** I used to not use Hairdryer, However quick enough I noticed that, that's more disrespect of kes than drying the, as tying wet kes will make them smell, and will make you get a head ache, and having wet kes thought the day is generally not a good thing....... To be hoenst Hair dryers do make your kes go a bit dry and dodgy, but Id' rather use Hair Dryer than notusing anytihng, cause Kes can sit their uncoveered for hours and hours in the contry I live, and still be as moisty as a few hours before.... Just a few things tha came up while reading.....

Re: could you please help me?

Kulwinder Singh · 26 Nov 2005

Dear Kulbir Singh Ji you have written: “Who says that Gurmat is not an instructive religion? Everything is done in a specially prescribed way. Naam Sanskaar, Amrit Sinchaar, Anand Sanskaar, and Mirtak Sanskaar all is done with a certain maryada. All Sikhs are supposed to rise at amritvela, do ishnaan, japp Gurmat Nam, read certain Baanis, etc etc. In the evening all Sikhs do Rehraas Sahib and Sohila Sahib.” Dear Vir Ji, if above mentioned things are used to describe Instructiveness of some religion, organisation or country then there is no place on earth which is not instructive. I give your examples and answers in response. Naam Sanskar: Birth Registration is Must in all countries( most countries) Amrit Sinchaar: in material way you can take it in some ways being qualified in some subject, Getting degree, most universities have traditions to give degree’s in a Specific way. Anand Sanskaar: Registration of the marriage is Must also in Many courtiers, especially western. Mirtak Sanskar: Death Registration is also must in most countries Above four are done in a very certain ways in most countries, there are Rules and regulations to implement the above mentioned things, if these thing are not done in certain time and with facts and obligations that can lead straight fight with the law of the land Does that For instant living in Canada / USA / UK and Australia make it instructive ? Getting up early, having bath in the morning is common for many number of people. of human beings in the world. Many other religions also recite the religious text in the morning and evening it is fair to say mostly people who do this in a regular way are deeply religious people rather then average human on plant. “Are Sikhs not following instructions of Guru Sahib by doing all this? So what's wrong with being an instructive religion?” ANS: I have proved above that these are not things which can be used to describe the character of a religion as instructive. What is wrong with being an instructive religion ? : Everything, instructive mean that human beings are treated like dumb stupid and low wit animals, which for sure Sikhism does not do that and any attempt to say it does actually diminish the Glory of Guru Sahib. You have also written many other things my answers are written with Ans on front: ” There are some well known rehits that must be followed exactly as ordered: Kirpan must be of Sarbloh and in Gaatra “ Ans: Do you think if Guru Ji’s time they had better way of making better Kirpans then Guru Ji would have said do not improve the quality of Kirpans. Shashater improvement was dear to Guru Ji too. Think my dear vir ji. Or Guru Ji would have said, oh let’s our enemy have good weapons even if we can afford them we will not improve our shashatrs. Gaatra Yes what else is the best place to put a Kirpan ? ” KaRA must be Sarbloh and in the right hand “ Ans: Just read the above ans, although I do not mind Sarbloh Kara, Right hand is chosen as when you do some deed with your right hand it remind you of Guru Ji. ” Kachhera must be white and up to knees “ Ans: I can understand the up to knees bit as wearing long Chola and very short Kachera is not desirable, But white is compulsory ? I know most people till this day in India have white but , I do not understand what would Purple colours’s harm is going to be ? “ Keski must be of four colours only and be at least 2.5 yards long “ ANS: 2.5 yard or 250 yards, I am not going into the length, to me it should be worn with pride in your Guru and must have influence over your acts in life to make a difference in your life to make you more kinder and better human being. ” Dastaar must be one of the four colours and at least 5 yards long. It must be worn in a certain way and removed in a certain way. “ ANS: Same as Keski answer above. Although the style can be individuals and looking after of Dastarr should be with Love and care. ” Kangha must be of wood.” ANS: Most people used the Kanga made of wood in Guru Gobind Singh ji’s days, I think Guru ji would not have made phone call to some top Designer to design anything in specific with some expensive material ” Kangha must be done in Kesh twice a day. In the morning it should be done before the ardaas for nitnem and in the evening it should be done before Rehraas Sahib (unless there is a genuine problem in doing so).” ANS: If you are swimming instructor and your hair get wet four times a day, A Sikh must be able to do kanga four time a day rather then just twice. If at night time for some reason your hair get lose then you should tie it up again if required with doing Kanga too. So no limit on 2 do more times if it is required. But must make sure your hair maintenance is done with love and respect. “ A Sikh must strive to wear baana at all times. “ ANS: Why ? what if Sikh has job where Baana is not practical ? “ A Sikh must not consume tobacco and other intoxicants.” ANS: I agree with that. ” A Sikh must refrain from Fornication and adultery.” ANS: I agree with that. I think most of the world agree with that. ” A Sikh must not remove hair from body.” ANS: If a operations need to be done which involve the removal of hairs then the Sikh must baksah this and chaeck Amrit again. ” A Sikh must not consume meat. “ ANS: Do not agree on this , Akal Takhat does not agree with you on this either, I although do not eat meat but I do not agree with you on this. “ A Sikh must memorize baani regularly.” ANS:Strongly Disagree with you, A Sikh must do Vicar of Gurbani ( analysis) regularly. Guru Ji have told us that do not become parrot try to become better in life and aim higher. ” A Sikh must try to do shudh paath and try to arrange to get santhiya to accomplish this. The saakhi of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj reprimanding a Sikh doing wrong paath proves that we must strive to do shudh paath.” ANS: there are many lessons in every event, everybody can select what ever comes in their grasp. ” There are many such rehits that Sikhs follow as per instructions from Guru Sahib. Some of these rehits are written, some are not and the ones not written are carried forward Seena-baseena. Having faith in Singhs telling these rehits is important. If they tell you something that is not anti-Gurmat, then it is our duty to follow it.” ANS: If they tell you something that is not anti-Gurmat, then it is our duty to follow it. Like : degh touched from out side by “substandard sikh” is spoiled ? and should be prepared again ? Also Kulbir Singh ji ignoring Guru Granth Sahib ji’s Philosophy and implementing some Gurusikhs’s practices is no favour to either an individual to make their life better or serve any good to the Sikhs in general or humanity in specific. Kulwinder Singh

Re: could you please help me?

NS · 27 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Excellent responce by Kulwinder Singh Jeeo I agree 99% with all your points part form one: “ A Sikh must memorize baani regularly.” ANS:Strongly Disagree with you, A Sikh must do Vicar of Gurbani ( analysis) regularly. Guru Ji have told us that do not become parrot try to become better in life and aim higher. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ I think Kulbir Jee is also correct here, we must memorize and do vichaar regularly as you mention. When it comes from memory and you already know the vichar, then it's out of this world, one cannot do without the other

Re: could you please help me?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 27 Nov 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh I wasn't ever told that a cold bath has to be had at amritvelaa, but after reading Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Jee's post, I had the cold bath today, and it felt great, I felt much more active and my Naam was Japping automatically as you said it would. Your definantly right that the metabolism rate increases enormously. Thanks incredibly for that information Kulbir Singh Jee. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: could you please help me?

Kulbir Singh · 28 Nov 2005

Kulwinder Singh jeeo, Your response has really surprised me. It seems like you have some kind of complex (perhaps Ahsaas-e-Kamtaree) and are an apologetic to other religions for no reason. Reading your post has given me the impression that any instruction that is unique in Sikhi is not good but if instructions found in Sikhi are also found in other religions or amongst common people, then those instructions don’t make Sikhi an instructive religion. Strange theory this is. ------------- Naam Sanskar: Birth Registration is Must in all countries( most countries) ----------- But name in other religions is not kept like its kept in Sikhi. An ardaas is performed before Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and the name is chosen by the first alphabet of the hukamnama received from Guru Sahib. How is this same as other religions? ----------- Amrit Sinchaar: in material way you can take it in some ways being qualified in some subject, Getting degree, most universities have traditions to give degree’s in a Specific way. ------------- And taking amrit is not same as getting a degree from some college or university. Taking amrit would be more comparable to taking admission in a university for the purpose of graduating. ----------- What is wrong with being an instructive religion ? : Everything, instructive mean that human beings are treated like dumb stupid and low wit animals, which for sure Sikhism does not do that and any attempt to say it does actually diminish the Glory of Guru Sahib. ----------- According to Gurbani, people are dumb and low wit animals, unless they come to the sharan of the true Guru (Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee) and obtain Naam from the true Guru. Gurbani makes it abundantly clear as in the following pankiti that ones who are without Naam (Amrit chhakna) are dogs, pigs, crows, donkeys, serpents and are basically like animals. Their life is full of filth. Ponder upon the following pankiti: [gurbani] gur mMqR hIxs´ jo pRwxI iDRgMq jnm BRstxh ][ [/gurbani]gur ma(n)thr heenasy jo praanee dhhriga(n)th janam bhrasattaneh || That mortal who lacks the Guru's Mantra - cursed and contaminated is his life. [gurbani] kUkrh sUkrh grDBh kwkh srpnh quil Klh ]33] [/gurbani] kookareh sookareh garadhhabheh kaakeh sarapaneh thul khaleh ||33|| That blockhead is just a dog, a pig, a jackass, a crow, a snake. ||33|| ----------- Ans: Do you think if Guru Ji’s time they had better way of making better Kirpans then Guru Ji would have said do not improve the quality of Kirpans. Shashater improvement was dear to Guru Ji too. Think my dear vir ji. Or Guru Ji would have said, oh let’s our enemy have good weapons even if we can afford them we will not improve our shashatrs. ------- I have full belief that even today Guru Sahib would have chosen Sarblohi Kirpan as a Kakaar. And still to this date, no metal is better than Sarbloh. --------- Gaatra Yes what else is the best place to put a Kirpan ? --------- There are many other ways of keeping the Kirpan. Numerous other people keep daggers. You can refer to their ways of keeping dagger. We Sikhs must keep kirpan in Gatra. ----------- ” Kachhera must be white and up to knees “ Ans: I can understand the up to knees bit as wearing long Chola and very short Kachera is not desirable, But white is compulsory ? I know most people till this day in India have white but , I do not understand what would Purple colours’s harm is going to be ? --------- If you don’t understand, then just follow our tradition and wear a white one. Don’t start questioning everything. If you see no harm in wearing a purple kachhera, that does not mean that White Kachhera stands negated. Kachherra must be white and we have no right to break any rehit. If Singhs have been wearing white kachherra from centuries, we must continue this tradition. -------------- “ Keski must be of four colours only and be at least 2.5 yards long “ ANS: 2.5 yard or 250 yards, I am not going into the length, to me it should be worn with pride in your Guru and must have influence over your acts in life to make a difference in your life to make you more kinder and better human being. --------------- Your answer bewilders me. It is as if you had to say something. Where did I write that we should not wear it with pride. My point was only that it should be at least 2.5 yards, long enough to be a Keski as opposed to a Patka that some wear. A patka cannot be called a Keski. ---------- ” Kangha must be of wood.” ANS: Most people used the Kanga made of wood in Guru Gobind Singh ji’s days, I think Guru ji would not have made phone call to some top Designer to design anything in specific with some expensive material ------------- Again a totally nonsense response from you. What is the purpose of your comments? From hundreds of years, Sikhs have been wearing a wooden comb and just because your sceptical mind does not agree with this does not mean that Sikhs should change this rehit and start wearing plastic or other kangha. ----------- ANS: If you are swimming instructor and your hair get wet four times a day, A Sikh must be able to do kanga four time a day rather then just twice. If at night time for some reason your hair get lose then you should tie it up again if required with doing Kanga too. So no limit on 2 do more times if it is required. But must make sure your hair maintenance is done with love and respect. ----------- I never said that you can’t do it more than once. My point was only that we must comb our hair at least twice a day. Why does this bother you. -------- ” A Sikh must refrain from Fornication and adultery.” ANS: I agree with that. I think most of the world agree with that. -------- I don’t think the whole world agrees to this. I don’t know why you keep mentioning the whole world. Who cares whether the world agrees or not? What matters is that our Guru Sahib has ordered us to refrain from it and we must obey our Guru Sahib. ------------ “ A Sikh must memorize baani regularly.” ANS:Strongly Disagree with you, A Sikh must do Vicar of Gurbani ( analysis) regularly. Guru Ji have told us that do not become parrot try to become better in life and aim higher. ---------- So the cat is out of the bag. You call doing paath of Gurbani talking like a parrot. This is what Kala Afghana says. In other words you are saying that if a Sikh does not understand baani, then there is no use of reading Baani. Refer to the 4 pauris of Suniyae in Siri Jap jee Sahib and then see what the greatness is of just listening to Gurbani. Yes, we should do vichaar of Gurbani but reading baani without vichaar, with concentration is good too. Just by saying Baani, one gets purified and if one also listens to it, one becomes very pure (Sunntay puneet, kehtay pavit). ---------- Like : degh touched from out side by “substandard sikh” is spoiled ? and should be prepared again ? --------- Yes. -------- Also Kulbir Singh ji ignoring Guru Granth Sahib ji’s Philosophy and implementing some Gurusikhs’s practices is no favour to either an individual to make their life better or serve any good to the Sikhs in general or humanity in specific. --------- Also, Kulwinder Singh jee, by ignoring the centuries old traditions and introducing your own and by raising doubts about Rehit in the minds innocent Sikhs is not service to Panth. Kulbir Singh

Re: could you please help me?

vichar · 29 Nov 2005

interesting have you got page referances for where 1) it says you can tie kesh up wet and 2) where it says wash kesh before body

Re: could you please help me?

Hargurmit Singh · 29 Nov 2005

Guru Pyare Kulvinder Singh Jee, If you follow even 50% of what Bhai Kulbir Singh has outlined as our Rehat Maryada in a very eloquent way, you will FEEL the difference in your LIFE. If you can make more than 50% as PART of your daily routine, you will feel very good. I can only say this through personal experience. FOLLOW the rehat rather than DEBATE it. That is when you will get the FRUITS of it. [%sig%]

Re: could you please help me?

Kulwinder Singh · 30 Nov 2005

My Dear Vir Kulbir Singh Ji, Thanks for getting back with fantastic criticism. You are right in saying that I have some kind of complex, But I am not “apologetic to other religions”, although if found that there is need to be I would not hesitate in admitting that. But with the grace of my Dear Guru Gobind Singh Ji I do not have to so far. >> Reading your post has given me the impression that any instruction that is unique in Sikhi is not good but if instructions found in Sikhi are also found in other religions or amongst common people, then those instructions don’t make Sikhi an instructive religion. Strange theory this<< The point is these instructions are found in the lost liberal democracies and if you going to call these customs of countries as inductions then, Living in USA, CANADA, UK……… will be not living in free society it would be instructive society. The instructions I am pointing out is, Changing chachera in certain way, Doing dastar in certain way, having bath in certain way. The once in life time even can not be compared to be an instructive religious styles. Guru Sahib Says: ਕਾਟੀ ਬੇਰੀ ਪਗਹ ਤੇ ਗੁਰਿ ਕੀਨੀ ਬੰਦਿ ਖਲਾਸੁ ॥1॥ And if guru has done band khalasi, then these instructions are bandans. I am not saying by any mean that, the Amrit Sanchar should held in a some kind of drive though, Amrit Sanchar is a tradition to make the entry into the Khalsa way, it has many lessons in the whole ceremony which are specifically designed to deliver an amazing experience and knowledge. So do not think I am some how against the traditions of Khalsa, We do parkash of Guru Sahib in set ways, We do sukhashan in a set ways, these are traditions which are dear to me too. These are Traditions and can not be seen as instructive character of the religion. In UK we have very traditional way of opening parliament, We have queen’s speech, but even carrying on these traditions do not make living in England an instructive life. I agree with you that Amrit Chackna can be taken as admission to a school, that is fine with me. You have really made a very seriously bad suggestion that my Guru’s bani say: “According to Gurbani, people are dumb and low wit animals, unless they come to the sharan of the true Guru (Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee) and obtain Naam from the true Guru.” Vir Ji I will explain the shabad you have quoted and I do not disagree with Gurubani. But think and take a look at this. Does it look like that Guru Sahib is saying “people are dumb and low wit animals” =========================================================== ਗੁਰ ਸੇਵਾ ਤੇ ਭਗਤਿ ਕਮਾਈ ॥ ਤਬ ਇਹ ਮਾਨਸ ਦੇਹੀ ਪਾਈ ॥ ਇਸ ਦੇਹੀ ਕਉ ਸਿਮਰਹਿ ਦੇਵ ॥ ਸੋ ਦੇਹੀ ਭਜੁ ਹਰਿ ਕੀ ਸੇਵ ॥1॥ ਅਨਿਕ ਜਨਮ ਭ੍ਰਮਤੌ ਹੀ ਆਇਓ ਮਾਨਸ ਜਨਮੁ ਦੁਲਭਾਹੀ ॥ =============================== ਕਬੀਰ ਮਾਨਸ ਜਨਮੁ ਦੁਲੰਭੁ ਹੈ ਹੋਇ ਨ ਬਾਰੈ ਬਾਰ ॥ The shabad you are quoting is ਗੁਰ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਹੀਣਸ੍ਹ ਜੋ ਪ੍ਰਾਣੀ ਧ੍ਰਿਗੰਤ ਜਨਮ ਭ੍ਰਸਟਣਹ ॥। gur ma(n)thr heenasy jo praanee dhhriga(n)th janam bhrasattaneh || That mortal who lacks the Guru's Mantra - cursed and contaminated is his life. ਕੂਕਰਹ ਸੂਕਰਹ ਗਰਧਭਹ ਕਾਕਹ ਸਰਪਨਹ ਤੁਲਿ ਖਲਹ ॥33॥ ॥ kookareh sookareh garadhhabheh kaakeh sarapaneh thul khaleh ||33|| That blockhead is just a dog, a pig, a jackass, a crow, a snake. ||33|| You are misusing the shabad, What it mean is The person who is not aware of Guru’s Mantar (In order to see the light, enlightenment), the only reason to be close to Guru is to be enlighten. so that Human can make their life in this world and after life success. Surely anybody who is not enlighten ( The enllighter Veheguru and Guru as somebody who take you from Dark to light) remain in the dark and what difference it is with that person and an animal. In a nutshell if you are human and remain in dark are you not taking the full advantage of your incredible valuable life as human on this earth, Gurbani is saying that The difference between an animal and Human should be that humans can tell the difference between right and wrong and animal normally cant. And you have selected this quote to say Our Guru Ji is saying that “people are dumb and low wit animals, unless they come to the sharan of the true Guru (Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee) and obtain Naam from the true Guru” Where as Guru Ji is saying people who remain in dark without Guru( Guru’s textual meaning is also the one who take from dark to light) , have wasted this fantastic opportunity as human to make their life better. Vir Ji you really need to understand that when you say that only people who come to the sharn of Sikh Guru’s have worthy life it does not make sense to have a Guru who say. ਕੋਈ ਬੋਲੈ ਰਾਮ ਰਾਮ ਕੋਈ ਖੁਦਾਇ ॥ ਕੋਈ ਸੇਵੈ ਗੁਸਈਆ ਕੋਈ ਅਲਾਹਿ ॥1॥ ਏਕੁ ਪਿਤਾ ਏਕਸ ਕੇ ਹਮ ਬਾਰਿਕ ਤੂ ਮੇਰਾ ਗੁਰ ਹਾਈ ॥ ਬੁਰਾ ਭਲਾ ਕਹੁ ਕਿਸ ਨੋ ਕਹੀਐ ਸਗਲੇ ਜੀਅ ਤੁਮ੍ਾਰੇ ॥1॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਹਮ ਨਹੀ ਚੰਗੇ ਬੁਰਾ ਨਹੀ ਕੋਇ ॥ Our Guru loved everybody, Even you accept that many Muslim brother fought on the side of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, they never converted to Sikhism and Guru Gobind Singh ji never intended to push them in conversion, So take these Brothers who gave their life but did not change their religion were animals ? How you going to explain this: ਅਵਲਿ ਅਲਹ ਨੂਰੁ ਉਪਾਇਆ ਕੁਦਰਤਿ ਕੇ ਸਭ ਬੰਦੇ ॥ ਏਕ ਨੂਰ ਤੇ ਸਭੁ ਜਗੁ ਉਪਜਿਆ ਕਉਨ ਭਲੇ ਕੋ ਮੰਦੇ ॥1॥ I am looking forward to your answer dear Vir ji. You are saying : “ I have full belief that even today Guru Sahib would have chosen Sarblohi Kirpan as a Kakaar. And still to this date, no metal is better than Sarbloh.” (Just a note: I accept you have admirable emotional attachment to Sarbloh.) So refined metal of modern time, which are more flexible controlled weight, strong and sharpen like nothing before does perform better then al know metals are still not better then sarbloh, I wonder then All the modern defense manufactures are completely mad to spend millions of pound to spend on research in creating better metals ? Vir Ji do not get emotional in making judgment, Guru Ji have given you eyes and brain to see for yourself. Even in Guru Jis time Shardaloos use to bring better weapons as gift for Guru Sahib ji and Khalsa. You are saying “If Singhs have been wearing white kachherra from centuries, we must continue this tradition.” Don’t get me wrong I do not have any issue with white, it is a nice colour, Just compulsion is bit odd. Sikhs also kept horse and Guru Gobind Singh ji use to like when Sikhs use to bring horses as seva, now rightly Sikhs have cars, motor cycles and bikes, that is nothing to do with braking the tradition it is just a common sense, which Guru Nanak Dev ji started to point out from the birth of Sikhim. Having Parbhat pheris and chonkies are our tradition, but we do not do that in Western countries because it is quite inconvenient, and Sikhs do server their duties to the penth without these. Cooking on the Dung cakes and Wood is how it is use to be, now we use Gas and electricity which is 100% right, as the main aim is to have energy for utilities not the resource or delivery. In olden days Gur was used for Karah Parshad, now we use Sugar. I agree with you “A patka cannot be called a Keski” Vir Ji you are saying “From hundreds of years, Sikhs have been wearing a wooden comb and just because your skeptical mind does not agree with this does not mean that Sikhs should change this rehit and start wearing plastic or other kangha.” I have no issues if somebody want to use wooden Kanga, my point is this thing that because for 100 years we have used something and now we should not change it is bit clinging to something where we there is no specific need, The main idea is kesh Sambhal ( hair maintenance) and that should be done properly. Sikhis is a dynamic religion, it has changed when ever their was need, it has adapted new things and challenges where ever we been. Our Guru have the most kind hearted in the world, You have written: “So the cat is out of the bag. You call doing paath of Gurbani talking like a parrot. This is what Kala Afghana says. In other words you are saying that if a Sikh does not understand baani, then there is no use of reading Baani. Refer to the 4 pauris of Suniyae in Siri Jap jee Sahib and then see what the greatness is of just listening to Gurbani. Yes, we should do vichaar of Gurbani but reading baani without vichaar, with concentration is good too. Just by saying Baani, one gets purified and if one also listens to it, one becomes very pure (Sunntay puneet, kehtay pavit).” In order to reply to I wrote as given below: Strongly Disagree with you, A Sikh must do Vicar of Gurbani ( analysis) regularly. Guru Ji have told us that do not become parrot try to become better in life and aim higher. Now where have I said doing path of Gurbani is talking like parrot: I am saying Guru Sahib have said aim higher, when you are doing path it is something you want to do to get contentment, fulfill your duty and get enlightenment, To the complete opposite if you are just memorizing which you said is no way near the path, Path is something done the side effect of this may be that you may memories the Gurbani, But to say that memories Gurbani without the heart for doing path ( you did not say doing path) is miles away from what you are saying now. Your use of “Kala Afghana” ‘s name in talking to me is very deeply heart full. You can call me anything and get disappointed with me, I am well short of your stature, but do not cal me something people think as Penth Dokhi, My intentions are never ever to take shine off my Guru, All I want is to introduce my amazing, fantastic, magnetic , unparallel good Guru to the whole world as I see only Guru Granth Sahib ji have solution to the world problems. Vir Ji, You have said to me I have a complex, Yes I do, but you seems to put all efforts to monopolies the GOD for Sikhs which actually reduces the Glory of Guru Sahib by suggesting that even GOD is narrow minded, The whole world accept Guru Granth Sahib as the Guru of the world but you keep on promoting it as a Guru for only Sikhs. Yes Sikhs have far more responsibility to take knowledge form Guru Sahib, But even if a Christan , Hindu or Muslim want to learn from Guru Granth Sahib ji’s treasure they are welcome, in the process if they chose to become Sikhs well and good if they don’t then Guru Ji do not restrict them from getting enlighten. My dear vir ji , I do not have an issue with any body following any strict rehit or traditions, but when those who follow that kind of rehit turn up to be unkind to other and label others as substandard then it is worth pointing them out to Guru Sahib’s teaching and our Glories History. Get one thing straight, If the God is monopoly of only Sikhs then you are not taking about the same God as Guru Nanak, Guru Gobind Singh and Guru Granth Sahib ji talking about. GOD is kind and he love all his creation, regardless of their origin, caste, colour, Language, way they worship, Geographical location etc. It is an insult to THE GOD if you say he is monopoly of Sijhs. You have read Jafarnama, Even after getting the worst possible treatment form Arungzeb, Guru Gobind Singh ji never said that non Sikhs do not stand a chance to be with GOD. You have also written: “ by ignoring the centuries old traditions and introducing your own and by raising doubts about Rehit in the minds innocent Sikhs is not service to Panth “ Vir Ji I last thing I want in life is to make doubts in anybodies mind about the Greatness of Sikhism, Please also note by ignoring the wishes and philosophy of Guru Granth Sahib one have no chance of being doing any favor to Sikhism, Guru, Sikhs, Humanity or themselves. I strongly believe even if some evil person want to do that they will not be successful as Guru Granth Sahib ji have capacity to tackle any such evil attempts, The flow of Love from Guru Granth Sahib is so powerful that I have seen, experienced with my own eyes that people who were not very keen or anti Sikhs have to admit that there is no better Guru in the world then Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Vir ji if you show the Vishal Hirda of Guru Sahib to the world, They will embrace Guru Sahib , If you close the path, make it difficult for other to even listen, it will certainly do no favor to The Sikhs and actually harm us and reduce the glory of our Great Guru Granth Sahib ji. I am not saying we are in number game by any mean like some other religion, quite the opposite of it, Guru Granth Sahib give lot of love, and any body who know about Guru Granth Sahib can not help but fall in Love with them. My not in personal conflict with you or anybody but to show the world how Great is our Guru is and how we can solve the world’s problem. I genuinely believe you are good person with good heart and very well read too, But I find you seem to more focus on exclusion of the religion rather then the Guru Sahib’s Inclusive philosophy which Guru Granth Sahib ji is a living Proof. You seems to concentrate making sure that who ever want to be get in love with Guru ji have to face Hardship of outside, where as I see it start from the Kindness as Dya tarm ka mool hai, and progressing along the Kindness, love and Seva. I don’t doubt your commitment to the penth I just find you concentration very odd and harsh. Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: could you please help me?

Singh · 30 Nov 2005

Kulwinder Singh, Your method of debate is powerful. Write so much volume on the topic (which should be answered in maximum 3-4 sentences) and savour the fact that the reader or person you are debating with cannot take the time to read, let alone reply to your post. You classified Rehit as Bandan, and that Guru Sahib did our band-khalas. Did Guru Sahib do our band khalas from Manmat/Maya or did he do it for Gurmat asools as well? According to your twisted logic, nitnem and amrit vela are also bandans that should be removed. Your quotes from bani about "koi bolay ram ram..." and "kudrat kay sabh banday" say that all people are children of God. It doesn't say anywhere that these religions are good or equal to Gurmat. I can find you examples where Hindu and Muslim religions have been shown to be unequal to Gurmat. I can show you quotes that say Jainism is a disgusting path. You do seem to have some kind of complex that refuses you to accept that Gurmat is supreme and yes, there are indeed some rules that need to be followed.

Re: could you please help me?

Kulwinder Singh · 30 Nov 2005

Dear Vir Hargurmit Singh ji, Fantastic Name, Congratulations just for having that cool name. and many thanks for very valuable advise. Kulbir Singh is a Good man, and I respect him for his commitment to penth. we have difference of opinion some time very strong difference. But my love and respect for him as individual is not less then any other of his close friends and associates. He is very well read, and he do invest his time (very valuable ) for making difference in the Society. One of the most strongest bond I feel we have is that we both have common real father Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Most likely he is obeying son and I am most annoying son, but I say what I feel. May be I am 100% wrong but , Gurbani Says that we must do Vichar so this is a Vichar. I do feel sad some time making strong argument, But feel passionate enough to do say what I feel is right. Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: could you please help me?

Kulwinder Singh · 30 Nov 2005

Dear Singh Ji, Where I have said Rehit, Gurmat asool, Nitname and amritvala is Bandan? Dear Vir Ji I have never Said Gurumat is not THE BEST, I say this for the record that Sikhism is the best philosophy in the World. Sikh Gurus Shir Guru Granth Sahib ji is THE BEST GURU IN THE WORLD. There is no parallel in Kindness, Love, intelligence, bravery, Sacrifice and Simplicity to SIKH GURUS. And there is only one Guru Who have solution to the worlds problems that is only GURU SHRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI. Who Said Rules are not acceptable ? Dear Singh Ji you should make a case based on the facts of what I have said rather then Just Jumping on some strange imaginations. Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: could you please help me?

Kulwinder Singh · 04 Dec 2005

Dear Singh Ji, Forgot to comment on your writing below. “Your method of debate is powerful. Write so much volume on the topic (which should be answered in maximum 3-4 sentences) and savour the fact that the reader or person you are debating with cannot take the time to read, let alone reply to your post.” First thanks for the complement anyway but it is Guru Sahib who give me guidance to make the case rather then my method or my wit which is absolute non existent without my Guru Sahib. Second you have said which feel like I write more then required, Vir Ji if the matter have to be discussed in detail then I am sorry it will take that much writing. The Person I am debating this topic is Kulbir Singh ji have great stamina to read and write, you just have to look into the past debates where Vir ji have given well detail arguments with strong points. Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: could you please help me?

Kaljug Jeev · 04 Dec 2005

waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh...kulwinder veerji..are you from malaysia..cause i thought only malaysian question and answer back in rehat..tupid people...well kulwinder veerji...im not on any site but...why not just follow what was written was told??cause what iv seen is only people who are over educated try to be cleverer than guru ji...sorry to say..iv seen it..but im not telling anything about u..and im not even judging you...and why do u debate on stuff like this when it is already so strong that alot of gursikh follow that rehat?? bhul chuk maaf..kulbir veerji...mad respect for a gursikh like you..plz do post more of ur opinion...very inspiring.. waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh!

Re: could you please help me?

Kulwinder Singh · 05 Dec 2005

Dear Kaljug Jeev Ji, Many thanks for the comments, and sharing you feelings about me and counting me in..tupid people..., It is nice, still nice of you to share some thoughts if you think of me like that then I am sorry but I am what you see what you get. And if you see stupid person in then yes I am stupid, any way I think myself as stupid person too so we both agree on something. I don’t know why you have said “what iv seen is only people who are over educated try to be cleverer than guru ji...” My Dear Kaljug Jeev Ji , I am stupid so that text line does not cover me. My whole attempts are to understand some parts of the Guru Bani. I by no means even a worth an electron touched my Guru Sahibs slipper. So please save your valuable comments for somebody who is really educated and is clever then stupid person like me. What this form is about is Vichar, May be some time uncomfortable but still Vichar, I not very bright but what ever Guru Sahib allow me to do vichar I am happy to do it. Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: could you please help me?

mahender kaur · 08 Dec 2005

if u can get read the book Gurmat rehni and panj kakar