Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

kakkars and kirtan

kakkars and kirtan

Question · 29 Mar 2003

Fathe Can someone who wears a Kirpan (sometimes), but doesn't think it is a kakkar do kirtan at akj samagam? Fathe

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Singhnee · 30 Mar 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! You will get different answers from different personalities because it all depends on maryaada the organizers of kirtan follow. As per my knowledge the Tapoban Sangat follows the sidaant of gurmat that a keertania should be an amritdhari person. They let children do kirtan who are not Amritdhaari but wear kakaars(getting ready to get Amrit) and follow the dress code(Gurmukhi baana). At some other smaagams organizers don't care about gurmat in order to achieve quantity. They don't care about Gurmat dress code or kakaars.

Re: kakkars and kirtan

RoopKaur Khalsa · 30 Mar 2003

vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh >>>>>Can someone who wears a Kirpan (sometimes), but doesn't think it is a kakkar do kirtan at akj samagam? Fathe<<<<<<< If someone does not think that the kirpan is a kakaar, then that shows how much respect they have for Guru ji's hukam. THen what is the point of that person doing keertan, if he or she does not beleive in the gurus hukam, then why would he or she want to do keertan? vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh ~RoopKaur Khalsa~

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Question 2 · 31 Mar 2003

Fathe Can someone who wears a Keski (sometimes), but doesn't think it is a kakkar do kirtan at akj samagam? Fathe

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Kulbir Singh · 31 Mar 2003

To the best of my knowledge, one who wears 5 kakaars and gurmukhi baana, is allowed to do kirtan at akj samagams. > Can someone who wears a Keski (sometimes), but doesn't think > it is a kakkar do kirtan at akj samagam? Yes. I have seen many non-akj gursikhs doing kirtan at akj samagams. I think, as long as one is wearing 5 kakaars, including a dastaara, one is allowed to do kirtan. Great raagis like Bhai Jawala Singh (father of famous Avtar Singh, Gursharan Singh) used to perform kirtan at time of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh. Bhai Jawala Singh was not in akj but was a good gursikh who used to wear doohra-dastaara (keski and dastaar). Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Question 2 · 31 Mar 2003

Fathe I think you missed the point Kulbir Singh. We all know keski is kakkar, but if we allow those on stage that do not believe keski to be kakkar, we are allowing those to do kirtan who only wear 4 kakkars out of five in their everday jivan/rehni-behni. Is this acceptable? It would be like someone who wears Kirpan while doing kirtan on stage, but then we find out at home they just put the Kirpan in a drawer. Wouldn't we confront this person and say this is wrong, you need to go get pesh, then you will be allowed back on stage when you have all 5 kakkars. Well, what is the difference between keski and kirpan? I don't see any. They are both kakkars. And they both carry the same importance. Fathe

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Kulbir Singh · 31 Mar 2003

I personally am not sure of this one yet. Your logic seems correct to me. It makes sense that ones who are not in rehit, should not be allowed to do kirtan (children exempted). I just wrote what I have seen normally in AKJ and not talking about the official policy of akj on this.

Re: kakkars and kirtan

SarblohKaurKhalsa · 31 Mar 2003

WaheguruJeeKaKhalsa,WaheguruJeeKiFateh! As far as I know, Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib maintains strict adherence to gurmat, but a lot of the time, as "Singhnee" mentioned, the "rules" for dress-code get thrown out the window at other keertans whenever the organizers feel like it. For example, usually, a bibi wearing make-up, with her eyebrows plucked, wearing a gaudy red suit would not be able to do keertan I would think/hope. But under certain circumstances, although I don't think it's RIGHT, it has been allowed. Also, before I ever started wearing a keski, I was at a keertan where they were short keertanis, so to fill time, they let me do keertan (without keski). But again, I don't think it was right to bend the rules like this. I don't think there should be any difference between kirpaan and keski or any other kakaar, but how are we going to ensure that those doing keertan really DO believe that keski or kirpaan are kakaars? I suppose we could employ the Thought Police, but in general, I think we just have to hope that if one is wearing the kakaars, then it's not just for show, but out of pyaar and humble acceptance of Guru Sahib's hukams and rehit. From personal experience again, before receiving Amrit, I started wearing a keski and dastaar, but did not wear a Kirpaan regularly. I did however wear it to keertans where, again, I was given time to do keertan. But this was totally wrong of me and reeks of ego-filled pakhund. I may be missing the point here too, but I believe we should do keertan for Guru Sahib, not for people, so why put on a show and come to Guru Sahib's darbaar as something we really are not? Guru Sahib is all-knowing and we can't trick Him. "Paakhund, Parbrahm kadey naa paaey"

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Singhnee · 01 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! Sarablohkaur bhainji is right. We all should think about that. There should be no compromise on gurmat.

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Question 3 · 01 Apr 2003

Fathe Kulbir Singh wrote: "I personally am not sure of this one yet. Your logic seems correct to me. It makes sense that ones who are not in rehit, should not be allowed to do kirtan (children exempted). I just wrote what I have seen normally in AKJ and not talking about the official policy of akj on this." If something makes sense according to Gurmat logic, and we do not follow it as official policy of our jatha, is it not wrong? Either we are wrong, because we are going after quantity or we do not have the courage to stand up for truth. Or the jatha is wrong because wrong people are in control of it. So, the question is what do we do? If we know something is right logically according to Gurmat shouldn't we take steps to follow it? Shouldn't we make sure our jatha is following it? Please answer. It seems hypocritical to me that our jatha would promote keski as a kakkar on websites and literature and other medium, but the one main thing about a kirtani jatha, the kirtani stage, we show dhil there and do not enforce it. Remember, we are not saying keski is just a part of Gursikhi bana. We are saying it is a kakkar. There can be no exceptions for a kakkar. There can be no dhil. No jatha can show any slack in questions of kakkar.

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Amritpal Singh · 02 Apr 2003

I totally agree with "question" person. The problem is people dont like rules people like to do what they want. I've seen with my own eyes when rules are applied to keertanis, the reactions are such, "why all the rules??", "just let people do keertan", "too strict". But what is the point of keeping up old rehits if we are gonna have dhills in them. The problem in my opinion is theres alot of people in "jatha" who dont really follow or care for the stands that jatha is there for. They are interested in doing keertan only and nothing else. Keertan is a Huge huge part of gurmat, but there are so many other issues that go ignored. As for the keskhi issue, i've personally seen bibian with "keskis" do keertan, but these keski's are not really keskis they look muslim women with hijab. A keski should be at least 2-3 metres with a jooda on top. I dont mean to hate on any bibian, but we must realize that we should be proud to display keski not hide it. In conclusion we should be Pro rules in keertan and enforce them with no dhills. Once u give one exception that opens the door up.

Re: kakkars and kirtan

SS · 03 Apr 2003

I agree with Amritpal Singh on this one. One dhil(even if it is a small dhil) will lead to more dhils in the maryadha. Best thing is not to have a dhil to begin with, which will lead to more dhils in the Maryadha. Over the years Jatha has definitely had one dhil after another. We should follow rules and no dhil in the Panths Maryadha should be allowed.

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Seva Singh · 04 Apr 2003

Only a amritdhari singh or singhnee should be doing keertan on stage in the presence of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, A kirpan is manditory as well as Kuddaa, Kunga, Kachearaa, and Kesh. Without these 5 kakars and amrit one should not be allowed to do keertan on stage. they should practice there full rehit before preaching any Bani to fellow gursikhs. an exception can be made for very young gursikhs who are not amritdhari yet but wear there kakars. One who cannot practice there rehit should definitly not be preaching bani from our Guru's to sangat, when they themseleves are not following the guru's hukum. As for bibian a keski should be worn and is recommended but a amritdhari bibi with a chunni or a ramal should be allowed to do keertan and not be discriminated agianst in any way.

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Singh · 04 Apr 2003

To those veer's/bhen's who are saying this is such a dhil - are you really saying Bhai Sahib was was letting in dhil in allowing Keertan by those Singh's who were not part of Jatha and/or did not believe for example that keski is kakaar etc although would themselves wear phag on stage ofcourse (as per Kulbir Singh's post)?

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Khalsa · 04 Apr 2003

VaahiguroojeekaakhalsaaVaahiguroojeekeefateh To Seva Singh: I think you got the kakkars a little wrong. Its Kirpan, Kachera, Kanga, Kara and Keski. Not Kes. You probably made the mistake while typing. Its ok. It happens sometimes. If you read the literature and gurmat and other sections of this site, you will know that keski is a kakkar. To Singh: Guru Gobind Singh Ji is our Guru. Not Bhai Randhir Singh. Not Bhai Jeevan Singh. Not Bhai Tejinderpal Singh. Guru is Guru. Guru leads us. Not others. VaahiguroojeekaakhalsaaVaahiguroojeekeefateh

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Seva Singh · 04 Apr 2003

To Khalsa I think your mistaken and i was right, not a little wrong but right. Its Kirpan, Kachera, Kanga, Kara and Kesh, Not Keski. I did not make any mistakes while typing as you said. Anyway the main point was these 5 kakars are mandatory along with Amrit if an indivdual wants to do keertan or Gurbani veechars or taddee kutha infront of Guru Sahib and sangat. Wjkk Wjkf

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Mr. Singh · 04 Apr 2003

To Seva Singh Veerji I would suggest you read the literature section of the website and dosome research on keski as a kakkar and if you do not agree with certain points mention them on the forum. I would like to know the basis for ur belief. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji kee fateh

Re: kakkars and kirtan

Veer · 08 Apr 2003

Seva Singh, did not you ever wonder as to why no one who is not wearing a keski is allowed on the stage by akhand kirtani jatha? only hear in vancouver we have made sure even those that wear keski but don't believe it as kakkar but just wear it as show will not perform on our stage. singhs from toronto should be following as well.