Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Harnek Singh excommunicated

Harnek Singh excommunicated

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jan 2004

According to this news in Tribune India, Harnek Singh has been excommunicated by Sant Samaj. Excommunicated from what/where? If he has been excommunicated from Khalsa Panth, then what right does Sant Samaj have to excommunicate someone from KHALSA PANTH? Only Siri Akal Takhat can do this. I think the newspaper probably got it wrong and he was expelled (not excommunicated from Panth) from Sant Samaj - the union of Sants in India. By the way, it is about time Akal Takhat Sahib took some action against Harnek Singh and investigate the allegations against him and take action if they are proven. Daas, Kulbir Singh Baba Harnek Singh excommunicated Jupinderjit Singh Tribune News Service Ludhiana, January 4 The controversy over the control of Nanaksar Dera at Siahar village took a new turn today when the Sant Samaj headed by Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi excommunicated Baba Harnek Singh, the reigning Sant at the dera, for his alleged objectionable activities in Canada. Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi, convener of the Gurmat Sidhant Parcharak Sant Samaj told Ludhiana Tribune that the five-member panel of the Sant Samaj consisting eminent religious personalities, had excommunicated Baba Harnek Singh for allegedly drinking liquor and participating in objectionable activities in Canada. While Baba Harnek Singh was not here to comment, a spokesman for his group rejected the Sant Samaj orders saying Baba Harnek Singh was a saint and not a member of any sant samaj from which he could be ex-communicated. The spokesman said the Sant Samaj and other organisations had approached Baba Harnek Singh several times with a membership offer, which he had refused saying the saints should not become part of such unions or associations and should only concentrate on religious activities. The Sant Samaj had formed the panel to probe the allegations of misconduct against Baba Harnek Singh. It was found that he was challaned in Canada for driving under the influence of liquor. The panel had given 15-day time to him to clear his position, but he chose not to respond. Meanwhile, tension continued in Siahar village for the fourth consecutive day today as rival factions sticked to their stands and no dialogue could take place despite efforts by the Khanna police. The report of a visit to the village by Baba Harnek Singh in next few days for participating in a function on January 13 had added to the tension as the rival group was gearing up to stage a show down at his arrival. The Khanna SSP, Mr Parmod Ban, had already announced that no one would be allowed to breach peace of the village. Heavy police force had been deployed in the village to avoid any untoward incident. Both groups have convened separate press conferences tomorrow to put forward their point of view. The first incident of violence took place on October 11 between the two warring groups fighting for the control of the dera. Nine persons, including three cops were injured, one of whom died on December 25. The villagers had been demanding the control of the dera to be handed over to Baba Mann Singh. The other group headed by Baba Harnek Singh refused as Late Sant Meehan Singh had given his gaddi to him and not to his sons about a decade ago. Much is at stake in the controversy. The control of the dera would provide the beneficiary hold over nearby 7,000 acres in Canada, besides several thousands of acres in Punjab and other parts in India. The stakes were quite high as three lakh million dollars were said to be the earnings from one crop in Canada. At present, Swami Kanwaljit (In charge Asian group), Mann Singh, Govinder Singh and Surjit Singh Jodhan are members of the dera headed by Baba Harnek Singh. The followers of the sect include foreigners and VVIPs. The working at the dera was normal till September 11, when its present management allegedly got the rooms there vacated, which were till now occupied by Mann Singh, Sewa Singh and Harchand Singh sons of late Baba Meehan Singh.

Re: Baba Harnek Singh excommunicated

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 05 Jan 2004

sad...he wuz also cought gambelling in las vegas

Re: Baba Harnek Singh excommunicated

Jagroop Singh · 05 Jan 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Does anyone know who runs the Coventry 'Thath'? Is it still under his control or under the control of people who oppose him because of these incidents? Just wondering. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Baba Harnek Singh excommunicated

Trying to be Gursikh · 05 Jan 2004

I think it's run by sewadars who support him. I was over in Coventry during the xmas break and visted the Nanaksar Gurdwara. There is a notice on the board signed by 8 to 10 senior sewadars showing their support. I

Re: Baba Harnek Singh excommunicated

singh · 05 Jan 2004

hey i got a q can the panj who collectively are the guru status ex communicate someone if they do anything wrong?

Re: Baba Harnek Singh excommunicated

Kulbir Singh · 05 Jan 2004

Rival group to approach Akal Takht on Harnek Singh issue Tribune News Service Ludhiana, January 5 Joyous at the expulsion of Baba Harnek Singh from Sant Samaj, the rival group headed by Baba Mann Singh has decided to approach Akal Takht with a plea of excommunicating the former from the Sikh Panth. The Baba Harnek Singh group has already rejected the expulsion orders issued by a five member panel of the Gurmat Sidhant Parcharak Sant Samaj headed by Baba Sarbjot Bedi, arguing that Baba Harnek Singh was never a member of the so-called Sant Samaj and hence could not be expelled. Addressing a press conference here today, Mr Gurdev Singh Grewal, spokesman of the Baba Mann Singh group, said that Baba Harnek Singh was fined by the Canadian Government for $600 for driving in an inebriated condition in 2000. Providing a copy of the documents relating to the judgement, Mr Grewal said that his reports had shown 80 ml alcohol in his blood. The Baba was directed not to drive for one year in Canada. The press conference was attended by Baba Mann Singh, Baba Sewa Singh and Baba Harchand Singh, the three sons of the late Baba Meehan Singh, and the village panchayat. They alleged that Baba Harnek Singh had allegedly planted a granthi in Siahar Thath who was a bad character and was accused in the murder case of a villager. Mr Grewal stated that they wanted peace in the village and would do every possible effort to maintain it. He also said that the birth anniversary of the founder baba would be organised peacefully.

Re: Baba Harnek Singh excommunicated

yo · 05 Jan 2004

Isn't a hukam from the punj the same as a hukam from the Guru?

Re: Baba Harnek Singh excommunicated

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 06 Jan 2004

oh the drama

Re: Harnek Singh excommunicated

Admin · 06 Jan 2004

As mentioned before, we don't want to start a debate on the maryada of Nanaksar at this time. Please don't post messages about Nanaksar samprada at this time. We had to disapprove some messages on Nanaksar, even though they made sense as we feel that this is not the right time for this controversey. Admin.