Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Langar

Langar

i seriously don t hink · 01 Jan 2004

1. In amritsar and india gurdwaras, only amritdharis make langar 2. In canada, non amrithdaris are allowed to make langar. Being bibeki and not eating from nonamritdharis means = not eating langar from non amirthdaris. but where will the line be drawn? langar is langar? is it not? langar is encouraged to be eaten by all.

Re: Langar

Singh · 01 Jan 2004

If langar isn't prepared with proper maryada what makes you so sure Guru Sahib will accept it? No offense bhainji/veerji, but your argument doesn't make much sense. If guru sahib has a certain maryada for something (i.e. langar), why would anything less be acceptable?

Re: Langar

Akali_Fauj · 01 Jan 2004

If langar in Amritsar is being prepared by Amritdhari's, then should it not be prepared by amritdhari's in every other gurdwara? It would make sense if a manmukh ate from an amritdhari's hands but not the other way around. A manmukh can benifit from eating from an amritdhari persons hand. What will an amritdhari person benifit from eating from a non-amrithdari person? if anything there kamaaee will end up going down. [%sig%]

Re: Langar

Mkhalsa · 01 Jan 2004

If your father asks you to make cha a certain way for him every day. Say with just one teaspoon of sugar and just the right amount of milk etc, and this is how he wants it, and then one day you make it and give it to him with no sugar, or with three teaspoons of sugar, will he like it? you made him the cha, you could even say to someone else who wants it "no this is my dads cha, not for you" but would your dad accept it? in a similar manner, we can make all the food we want, we could order it from a restaurant, we could bring in pot heads and alcoholics to make it, we could get a big steak and run a kirpan through it, does it magically become guru ka langar if its not accepted by guru sahib? how can we do something which is against that rehat that guru sahib set out for us and actually think he will accept it? what madness is this?

Re: Langar

i seriously don t hink · 01 Jan 2004

i was thinking in a different sense if langar is prepared, and they call it guru ka langar, it surely is accepted?? i dont know, what is the sangats perspective on this ? well now im thinking, guru ji ate from his servant , not sure of the name bad memory, and the roti had milk, and the rich person forgot his name, his roti had blood but that emphasizes kamaee, and truthful living... don't know, please shed light on this topicc

Re: Langar

- · 02 Jan 2004

your talking about malik bhago and bhai Lalo. THis sakhi jsut shows us how important bibek wa to guru ji. he ate from Bhai Lalo who was his sikh and his kamaaee showed up in the khaanaa that he had prepared, while on the other hand malik bhago was a manmukh and his kamaaee, or lack of , also showed up in his food, Imagine how many Malik Bhagos there could be in non bibeki langars making langar and all the sikhs eating it while Guru ji refused to eat it during his time,