Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

is this forum biased?

is this forum biased?

singh · 14 May 2006

what are your views? i personally believe this to be true. many a time i have posted controversial arguments which do not agree with AKJ's thinking. as this is a forum and a place for open debate i feel that although monitoring of posts is a good idea in general, the censur of legimate arguments etc. makes this forum biased. how can we learn and form ideas if we are not allowed to think outside the box? how can untruths be uncovered and wrongs righted if you do not listen to or discuss your/other people's ideas openly? i have found that any praise or support of AKJ and tapoban is allowed through quickly but legimate questions are often dismissed. i understand that this forum is run by tapoban supporters but that does not mean that their's is the only and just way. if there were other such forums made available without discrimination of free speech would you still post here????

Re: is this forum biased?

Makhan · 15 May 2006

"Yes" I agree with Singh that this phorum is biased. I sent a post about kala afgana's books because i have read all his books but phorum decided not to put it on the phorum board because I did not condemn what he has written. He is trying to weed out wrong things from sikh history. weak minded people do not like that. Phorum does not like the truth.it is biased. they have in the past stopped mine atleast eight posts. some times i think not to look at this phorum.

Re: is this forum biased?

ks · 15 May 2006

eh, this site is *the most biased* sikhi site I've ever seen. You'll be engaging in discussion and then you'll say something that the moderators (whoever they are, unseen and without reproach) don't like and your message will never make it though. So you're essentially fighting with one hand tied behind your back, never to be told what is was that caused your message to be rejected or if it was just one word that someone didn't like. who knows. I don't even know why I come here, it's the same ideological hacks who popluate the forum that hold slavish devotion to tapobanic or jatha lifestyles.

Re: is this forum biased?

J.A.T.T · 15 May 2006

Yes, you can say this forum is bias (to certain extent). "if there were other such forums made available without discrimination of free speech would you still post here????" Two words: Hell No.

Re: is this forum biased?

.s.s · 15 May 2006

mmmmmmmmmm........... just wondering ...if this forum is so biased, why are your messages being posted on this site. This sounds like free speech to me.....LOL !!

Re: is this forum biased?

some12 · 15 May 2006

HELL YES.

Re: is this forum biased?

Robert Langdon · 16 May 2006

I dont think this is a biased message board, they have put many messages up which the Singhs at Tapoban Sahib or Jatha may not agree with.

Re: is this forum biased?

A Singh · 16 May 2006

Yes it is biased...BUT...which forum isn't in its own way.

Re: is this forum biased?

S Singh · 16 May 2006

Yes, this forum is biased. The fact that they let this message go through which criticizes them shows how 'Bias' they are. (sarcasm)

Re: is this forum biased?

Jasmin · 16 May 2006

Prehaps it is biased, if biased is the term you wish to use. I'd prefer to call it focused. I've visited other forums, such as "The Living Treasure" and all I can say is "wishy-washy". On the other hand I intuitively feel this forum is more of a straight arrow. I mean you stand for something, or you will fall- for anything. Having said that the internet is vast, and if you want a different view point, then certainly go elsewhere.

Re: is this forum biased?

babajee · 16 May 2006

Waheguroo jee ka khalsa waheguroo jee kee fateh!! A Few points I want to make to the above posts that just make me laugh... I'll start by saying I have nothing to do with tapoban. 1) Kala afghana is universally banned by the entire panth and anyone who supports him is a dusht and has no concept of gurmat or gursikhi. Kala afghana did not even write his books himself. They were carefully researched by groups like the RSS and written in such a way as to brainwash innocent sikhs. They then paid this ex-police officer to use his name on them and promote them. 2) This is the OFFICIAL forum of Gurudwara Tapoban Sahib. If you dont like it, go away. Simple. Would you expect the official forum of say coca cola to allow you to advertise pepsi? would the official US government forum allow you to support al qaida? would the officla forum of the US olympic team allow you to promote australia? Then why for gurus sake would you expect tapoban to allow posts that they deem anti-gurmat, inflammatory or etc.. ie a post promoting raag mala. I do not beleive in it, tapoban does not beleive in it, in fact most of us beleive it is a kaami writing out of a kaami book. so why would they promote it? yet they still allow free discussion on it!! It is THEIR forum and up to their discretion!! So leave them be, they are doing a great seva. I agree the quality has gone down considerably in the last year, but thats mostly YOUR fault for posting such ridiculous topics as this one!! >>>>> "if there were other such forums made available without discrimination of free speech would you still post here????" Two words: Hell No.<<<<<< One word: DiscoverSikhi.com (completely unbiased from what I can see, its the least biased on on the net) and have some sharam and dont cuss on a sikhi message board. --Cali Baba Jee

Re: is this forum biased?

I Agree · 16 May 2006

admin how you've allowed this i dont know???quick stop it now

Re: is this forum biased?

amarjeet singh · 16 May 2006

if this forum is biased it wudnt have let ur post on

Re: is this forum biased?

kaur · 16 May 2006

'mmmmmmmmmm........... just wondering ...if this forum is so biased, why are your messages being posted on this site. This sounds like free speech to me.....LOL !!' ermmm so what if this post got through? there are many that don't - mainly i believe, with regards to kala afgana. i have posted a number of times on the same topic thread only to find that none of my posts have been accepted and mainly because i happen to agree with him on a number of accounts. i also posted about the bleaching of facial hair...there are many girls out there who do not cut their hair but face real difficulty in getting married because the boy's family - even though they too follow the rules of sikhi - think that she doesn't have the right looks. when i questioned this hypocracy my post was denied. perhaps admin allowed this thread through just to prove that they are open to all suggestions and thoughts...which i know they are not and i'm thinking that there are a number of people who agree with me.

Re: is this forum biased?

. · 16 May 2006

were all biased in some way or another. get over it

Re: is this forum biased?

GUrpreet Singh · 16 May 2006

if u hate this forum so much, just stay off it..........pretty common sense if u ask me if they wanna be bias they can be bias, they pay for the webspace, not you if u want another viewpoint of stuff just goto www.gursikhijeevan.com or any of the other forums

Re: is this forum biased?

amarjeet singh · 16 May 2006

kaur this forum is gr8 if u dnt like it get out plaez

Re: is this forum biased?

where is freedom? · 16 May 2006

wow its really grown-up when people, instead of putting forth comments, just tell you to leave or tell you to get out. wouldn't it be more constructive if solutions were found instead of getting all riled up? everyone has a right to be here and post how they feel. only then can we address any issues they might have. those who are unhappy...please put forth suggestions on how things can be rectified and perhaps admin can help out

Re: is this forum biased?

Sardar · 16 May 2006

>>>>>Then why for gurus sake would you expect tapoban to allow posts that they deem anti-gurmat, inflammatory or etc.. ie a post promoting raag mala. I do not beleive in it, tapoban does not beleive in it, in fact most of us beleive it is a kaami writing out of a kaami book. so why would they promote it? yet they still allow free discussion on it!!<<<<< K...I am not saying Raag Maalaa is Baani. as for it being a kaami story....LOL! man ur jokes! read the definition of it and you'll see it is not about any love story or anything no kaami story. It is actually about all the different Raags in GurBaani. Just go on this link and scroll down at the very bottom to read the definition of Raag Maalaa. Here's the link: http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=1429&g=1&h=1&r=1&t=1&p=0&k=0

Re: is this forum biased?

E · 16 May 2006

mr O i beg to differ this forum is fundamentally BIAS admin block half the posts they dont agree with thus threads have a tendancy to be onesided

Re: is this forum biased?

samething · 16 May 2006

i think it's pretty good phorum because you can put things down that are against sikhi and for sikhi ive put down some strong stuff and never had it censored.

Re: is this forum biased?

BSSandhu · 16 May 2006

This forum is the most biased sikh forum I have come across - its a bit like some islamic forums where alternate views are not tolerated. I hope the admin changes a bit.

Re: is this forum biased?

Khalsa · 16 May 2006

dont ask- is tapoban biased? ask a less obvious question like is the sky blue?

Re: is this forum biased?

makhan · 16 May 2006

now lets see if admins allows this post through

Re: is this forum biased?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 May 2006

WHAT A GREAT THREAD.... IS sggs "BIASED"....SURE !! JEHANGIR SURE THOUGHT THAT WAY...AND DECIDED TO MURDER THE COMPILER - GURU ARJUN JI..thankfully we are not "murdered"...just get our posts rejected....and oh my..that haumaii sure hurts bad... well be like me...be a member of a few Forums... www.Sikhphilosphy.net is great.....whenever my EGO is hurt by my post being rejected by Tapoban..I post it on SPN....there it is FREE SPEECH..except vulgarity....( although a few may say that is "biased" as well for it is Punjabi culture to kaddho GALAAN..and if i want to "CUSS this stupid gyani arshi"..why cant i be allowed a few choice punjabi galaan ?? I am SURE lots of "Santaan de cheleh's choice posts cussing me get rejected.....and they must hurt like hell too...so much for sants givng one peace and inner shanti..more like KRODH..MURDER..MAYHEM.. its their forum..let them manage it any which way they like....if anyone wants to enter my house..i am sure as biased as hell...as to who i allow in..so ??whats the big "S**T"...nothing really... READ all you like, REPLY all you like.....take it or leave it..FREE CHOICE !! your HEART will LOVE it..Your GURU will LOVE YOU the MORE...live and let live..

Re: is this forum biased?

Singh · 16 May 2006

Can we please stop telling people to get off of this forum, it is not the solution. Personally I dont find this forum bias. I think this forum is the best and may Guru Jee give the Tapoban admins more and more years of seva for the E Sangat.

Re: is this forum biased?

Singhstah · 17 May 2006

if biased means gurmat, then this is the most biased site ever.

Re: is this forum biased?

singh · 17 May 2006

Kaur maybe they didnt allow your kala afgana messages because kala afganas books have been banned by akal takht and maybe they didnt accept your pro bleaching messages because bleaching is manmat

Re: is this forum biased?

singh · 17 May 2006

every messageboard has a bias. It is a fact of life. Recently another messageboard had as one of its mods. Despite sangat compliants they have done nothing. Stop blaming just one messageboard. At least this one has some good Gurmat standards. Grow up and live in the real world.

Re: is this forum biased?

E · 17 May 2006

saying this forum is bias is an understatement

Re: is this forum biased?

concerned · 17 May 2006

I think this site is a biased. It seems to be very pro AKJ-UK despite what happened in the AGM this year. It would be better if tapoban singhs stuck to the truth [like they used to] & not takes sides with any organisation because not everything is as it seems!

Re: is this forum biased?

kaur · 17 May 2006

i've thought that this forum is too biased for a long time

Re: is this forum biased?

mmm · 17 May 2006

i think there should be a registration system, and ppl should be able to post openly - it'll fix alot of problems, thats for sure.

Re: is this forum biased?

singh · 17 May 2006

A Singh is correct to say that all sites are biased to some extent. The disclaimer at the top states the rules of the phorum. Everything depends on how the participants define gurmat.

Re: is this forum biased?

Common Sense · 17 May 2006

We all have our biases but some of us can see things more openly and objectively than others. When you take everything that agrees with your interpretation or viewpoint as facts and weed out anything and everything that doesn't suit your brand of Sikhi, you develop a seriously hardcore "belief system". You invest years harnessing those carved in stone beliefs and you start to become a self righteous "know it all" person. You think, "How can everyone not see that I am presenting true FACTS. How dare these lost fools argue with the TRUTH (me)?" After a while you create a solid firewall around your belief system where nothing can penetrate through it. You see your beliefs as the "absolute truth". You get an simple and easy to prove equation: Your beliefs = Gurbani = The absolute truth. Here are some of the absolute truths that no "intellectual" should dare to refute: Did Guru Nanak Dev ji maharaj and other Guru Sahib give "charan pahul" to all of their followers? You say: Yes, of course. how can anyone be a sikh without taking amrit? Did Guru Nanak Dev ji ever eat food prepared by a non-amritdhari followers? You say: Definitely NOT. How can you even think that? (Guru ji was born in a Hindu family and gave his mataji charan pahul before accepting milk). Did ALL puratan sikh women wore dastaar or kesgi? You say: Unquestionably YES. Each and everyone of them dressed like their "male singh warriors". Although they did cook, clean and took care of the house and children (as you want your kaurs to do the same!!). Did all the bhagats whose bani is in SGGSJ took amrit from Guru Sahib? You say: Most certainly. They all took amrit and dressed in the prescribed "saintly baana". No one can be a brahmgiani without complete rehit! Would you sit in sachkhand in front of Vaheguru and all Guru Sahibs in your blue baana jaaping naam forever and ever You say: If you follow "hukam", undoubtedly yes. That's how Gurbani and ALL the brahmgiani gursikhs (that you agree with) describe sachkhand. What do you ignorant intellectuals know anyway? You unfortunate souls don't have the spiritual wisdom and naam-kamai wala jeevan. Don't ever second guess the absolute truth. Before you know it, there will be a never-ending list that will make you "a niyara - special chosen guru da piyaara". You will see yourself a lot higher than rest of the "dhillay chache-pilley" sikhs. [%sig%]

Re: is this forum biased?

mr singh who · 17 May 2006

Amarjeet singh ji your post is childish. Grow up and be brave to have constructive criticism that is how you can improve yourself. Gurpreet singh"they pay for the webspace, not you" ture. No one asked for the forum. if they donot like criticism they should have their web page and then no body would be able to say any thing against them. If u want people to leave this forum then u will have a bunch of creepers those who can not see beyond the tip of their nose.

Re: is this forum biased?

J.A.T.T · 17 May 2006

>>>>One word: DiscoverSikhi.com (completely unbiased from what I can see, its the least biased on on the net) and have some sharam and dont cuss on a sikhi message board.<<<<<< That website isn't that great at all. I prefer go to http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/ Also, how exactly is "hell" a bad word? The mods of this site didn’t censor the word.

Re: is this forum biased?

Mr. Singh · 17 May 2006

common sense, stop being so bitter. i see a lot of people like you. you don't like someone's views, because you think they're too hardcore. rather than engaging in debate and accepting the outcome, you try turning it into an intellectual versus fanatic debate. this way you can try demonising the opposing view without actually refuting anything. nobody has ever said you can't try and refute the points you mentioned. go ahead. but why are you so narrow minded that you can't accept that people have different view points and won't accept your arguments? just like you won't accept theirs. do you consider that your points are more solidly grounded simply because.... you're making them? everything you say about the others, applies to you as well. you have a set of beliefs, which is contrary to the set of beliefs you mention, and you will stick to your beliefs no matter what. if somebody doens't agree with you, then they must be ignorant, blind fanatics who are trying to destroy the true sikhi given by our gurus. at least what you consider to be true. you're no better than them. they call you kachay pillay, you call them fanatics, hardliners. you're trying to veil yourself as an intellectual who only goes by gurbani and the truth, but your methods are not intellectual at all. you're simply trying to use popular views to mock and villify other views. You're no better than what you accuse others of. you consider yourself smarter, more enlightened than others. only you and those who agree with your mentality, are enlightened. everyone else is blind. so tell me, what will happen to these people that you talk about? in terms of sikhi? they can never reach god with their narrow minded views, right? only if everyone was as enlightened and unbiased as you.

Re: is this forum biased?

singh · 17 May 2006

great post common sense ji. one of best post ever.

Re: is this forum biased?

PTE SINGH · 18 May 2006

Of course it is biased it is a Tapoban forum. However i still think its run with relative fairness. I am in many ways opposed too Tapoban style Sikhi and Khalistan, yet i have never had a post that admin cut or altered. As long as your argument is sensible and non offensive i think that the forum allows it. fair play to them

Re: is this forum biased?

amarjeet singh · 18 May 2006

mr singh who i am extremely mature once u get 2 no me n i iz very brave

Re: is this forum biased?

Common Sense · 18 May 2006

Mr. Singh, I think you missed my point completely. Read my post again, and then read your attacking and poisonous response. This time try not to be so judgmental. Just to remind your that I responded to this thread called, "is this forum biased?". I posted some flavours of how some "beliefs" become "absolute unquestionable truths" for some of us because we invest so much in them. Some of your comments did make me laugh, but just attacking me won't get you anywhere. Search this forum, all of the points have been debated to death, but at the end of it, it all boils down to your own "set beliefs".

Re: is this forum biased?

A singh · 18 May 2006

Akal Takhat did not ban KA's books but Vadenti did because of personal grudge.

Re: is this forum biased?

makhan · 18 May 2006

Admin I think you have problem to understand my post. Read it again. I said if there is any thing from KA's books post is blocked. Tapoban does not agree with KA's writing. When admin block these posts I mean it is a biased phorum. Try to read and understand the post before you block it because it contains Kala Afgana's name.

Re: is this forum biased?

kaur · 19 May 2006

ooooh look how grown up admin is. a little bit of heat and they get all defensive. we just want a fair phorum. and "Author: singh Date: 05-17-06 02:39 Kaur maybe they didnt allow your kala afgana messages because kala afganas books have been banned by akal takht and maybe they didnt accept your pro bleaching messages because bleaching is manmat" my message wasn't pro bleaching. it was asking why people are hypocrits when it comes to selecting life partners.

Re: is this forum biased?

yeah..... · 19 May 2006

kaur, to bad you can't be grown up. you have a post deleted because it contained something negative or antisikh (yeah, i'm sure it was just for calling people hypocrites.... lots of other posts like that have been allowed up but not yours... sure! we believe you) and you start crying. suck it in and get on with it. and who's this 'we'? talk for yourself. you don't represent 'we'.

Re: is this forum biased?

kaur · 19 May 2006

all i was asking is why its one thing to say it is bad to bleach hair and stuff but when it comes to marriage people don't marry their sons to girls with facial hair....nothing antisikh about that. thats the hypocracy....there isn't anything bad about that. it was a serious question. and 'we' stands for those who feel the forum is biased...nothing more, nothing less.

Re: is this forum biased?

a singh · 19 May 2006

again my benti is, why doesnt this forum just become register only? That way we can see what users are posting and under what aliases they are posting. Fair debates, no biased stuff.

Re: is this forum biased?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 21 May 2006

Author: a singh Date: 05-19-06 14:28 again my benti is, why doesnt this forum just become register only? That way we can see what users are posting and under what aliases they are posting. Fair debates, no biased stuff. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>..... I agree..most of the aliases/false/scary cats would be gone..only genuine singhs and kaurs who have genuine addresses would be left... but its Admin's decision really...anything is fine with me. Although i have said it before and will say it again...this forum is more gurmatt-oriented than any other sikh forum out there. No offense to any Na ko beri nahin begana...

Re: is this forum biased?

Admin · 21 May 2006

Thread closed. Admin