Deredaars Vs Gurudums
Kulbir Singh · 19 Dec 2003
Who are more dangerous to Khalsa Panth - Deredaars (Sants who get themselves revered but believe in Guru Granth Sahib jee) or Guru-dums like Beas Radhasoami, Naamdharis etc. The deredaars want pratishta and fame but they believe and acknowledge the authority of Guru Granth Sahib jee. True they introduce slight variations in Rehat Maryadas but there are small differences. How much can the Khalsa Panth get hurt if a jyot is lighted in Sri Akhand Path Sahib or if they place a coconut in Siri Akhand Paath Sahib? The followers of these deras do not get fully disconnected from the Khalsa Panth. They at least stay within the reasonable distance. I know many followers of sants who are fine Sikhs and their children are just Sikhs. However once a person gets converted to RS or Kuka, then their is no coming back. They are lost forever. In case of Deredars, there is a hope but in case of RS and Kukas there is no hope. This does not mean that I condone the Sants or suggest that we should develop some tolerance for them. We should continue to work towards educating people that Guru Granth Sahib is our living Guru and we can get everything we want from this Guru. Guru has shown us the way of Vaheguru. Vaheguru is the doer of all things and a Sikh who is the Khalsa (God's own) of Vaheguru need not go to anyone else. The biggest branch of Radhasoamis is Beas and it is this that is hurting us. There are many small branches in Punjab i.e. in Hoshiarpur (Baba Faqir Chand), In Tarn Taran, In Sri Anandpur Sahib, In Ferozepur etc etc. These small branches cannot hurt us too much. RS can hurt us more than any other Guru Dum because they have spread very fast. My friend's jeeja (brother in law) became a Radhasoami. This fellow converted dozens of people into RS i.e. his parents, brothers and their families, and many friends. This way these guys spread. RS promises salvation with least regard to outer image of a person. RS has no faith in Kes and Dastar yet their Gurus in Punjab wear kes and dastar simply to attract Sikh population. Gurinder Singh the present Guru of RS Beas used to trim his beard and I think he even had his hair cut before he was selected for Guruship by Charan Singh, their previous Guru. Now this man Gurinder has a long white beard and looks like a Gurmukh. Why?? Just to attract the Sikh population. There has been one good thing since Gurinder Singh took over. Many of his western followers have left him or are disgruntled at him for many things. Our simple-minded Sikhs go to their dera and get impressed by many things. Following are answers to some of the comments they make after visiting their dera: 1. Dere (Beas) vich safaayee bahut hai (There is a lot of cleanliness in the dera). So what? Canada vich bahut safayee hai. Go to "First Canadian Place" in downtown Toronto and you will find abundant safayee there. What does safayee of a building have to do with sprituality? Just because the dera is clean does not mean that they sell great spritual product. Have you not heard a saying, "uchi dukaan pheeka pakwan" (Great restaurant but tasteless food). 2. Uthe intazam bahut achha hai (There is great system there): So what? There is great intazaam (system) in USA, England Canada or in private companies of India like Tata Industries, Hindustan Motors etc. What is the big deal if they have great system or if the management is great. This just proves that they are very organized but this does not prove that their spiritual product is of equally high quality. 3. Baba jee (Charan Singh or Gurinder Singh) katha bahut achhi karde hun: So what if he is a great speaker. Clinton is a great speaker. Why not make him your Satguru. Just because someone is a great speaker does not mean that they are also great spiritual teachers. These are just few examples of the type of comments the impressed people who come from there express. These people then turn and start criticizing SGPC for not doing anything. True, there is room for a lot of improvement but SGPC is running many dozen schools, colleges and hospitals. The problem is that they just need to do a little more effort and also learn to take credit for something they do. There is no doubt we should also have safaayee, we should be organized and we should have good speakers. Dera Beas maybe a great dera but they cannot give free langar like Guru Ramdas jee's house in Sri Amritsar can do. Food is given according to the status of the person. Lodging also depends on one's status. If you are a NRI (Indian living outside of India) you get good accomodation but if you are from India you get poor facilities. Until 1953 there used to be two langars in Beas i.e. one for low-castes and others for high castes. Then after pressure from the Govt. they had to reverse. How can a true Guru (so called true guru) like Sawan Singh permit such discrimination. In short we need to expose RS and other Gurudums and also need to work to eliminate the need of fake sants from Panth Khalsa. Daas, Kulbir Singh