Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

dipsy · 23 Apr 2006

i was just wondering how Dasmesh Pita died was it at the battle of chamkaur ?? can anyone give details please thank you

Re: Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

waheguru · 23 Apr 2006

he never died....only we mortals die...he can not be considered a mortal......he is the supreme guru......akaal purkhs roop....and akaal purkh is AKAAL-MOORTH......so no death- birth issues there....... he didnt go to suchkund at chamkaur sahib but afterwards when he came to hazoor sahib....he never went during a battle but after doing guru granth sahib jis prakask he left for sachkund leaving us with his and all other guru jis joth! Shri Guru Granth sahib ji.....

Re: Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

PTE SINGH · 24 Apr 2006

You should try using the internet so that you don't have to rely on helpful authors like 'waheguru' in future. See extract below. Two pathan assassins, (Jamshed Khan and Wasil Beg are named in the Guru Kian Sakhian) pursued the Guru secretly and overtook him at Nanded, where, according to Sri Gur Sobha by Senapati, a contemporary writer, one of them stabbed the Guru in the left side below the heart as he lay one evening in his chamber resting after the Rahrasi prayer. Before he could deal another blow, Guru Gobind Singh struck him down with his sabre, while his fleeing companion fell under the swords of Sikhs who had rushed in on hearing the noise. As the news reached Bahadur Shah's camp, he sent expert surgeons, including an Englishman, Cole by name, to attend on the Guru. The wound was stitched and appeared to have healed quickly but, as the Guru one day applied strength to pull a stiff bow, it broke out again and bled profusely. This weakened the Guru beyond cure and he passed away on Kattak sudi 5, 1765 Bk/7 October 1708. Copyright © Harbans Singh "The encyclopedia of Sikhism. [%sig%]

Re: Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

o · 24 Apr 2006

"he didnt go to suchkund at chamkaur sahib but afterwards when he came to hazoor sahib" guru ji is always in sach khand

Re: Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

aks · 24 Apr 2006

i thought he went of on his horse after give guru guddi to guru granth sahib?? and no 1 knows what happened then? maybe thats the story were the naamdharis get their story that guru lived till 140yrs old or sumink?

Re: Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

... · 24 Apr 2006

The Kukas are propogating the story of Guru Sahib going off on a horse. This never happened. Bhatt Vehis tell us that Guru Sahib left his body in the middle of the night and his body was then bathed by Bhai Daya Singh and then the saskaar took place.

Re: Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

a singh · 24 Apr 2006

umm Author: ... Date: 04-24-06 09:46 The Kukas are propogating the story of Guru Sahib going off on a horse. This never happened. Bhatt Vehis tell us that Guru Sahib left his body in the middle of the night and his body was then bathed by Bhai Daya Singh and then the saskaar took place. ^^ guru sahib was shabad roop..im not sure if i agree with that point :/ how can shabad be burnt? :s...maybe i am wrong... but goto ikirtan.com dl dashmesh pittas jeevan katha by giani thakur singh..

Re: Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

... · 24 Apr 2006

a singh, don't delude yourself. Guru Sahib is Shabad roop but that shabad resides in a physical vase. Guru Granth Sahib is the same jot as Guru Gobind Singh but we both know that saroops of Guru Granth Sahib do burn. The shabad is not touched but the vase is physical and does. All the other Gurus were cremated like Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib's body or Guru Hargobind Sahib, so why wouldn't Guru Gobind Singh's body burn? By that argument you could say Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib's head shouldn't have been cut because he too was shabad Guru, but you and I both know that it was cut and the head and body were both cremated and Gurdwaras stand there.

Re: Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Govind Singh Jee

singh · 24 Apr 2006

the oldest account of guru gobind singh jee written by kavi sainapat (also known as saina singh) called the "sri gur shoba" states that guru jee called the sikhs into the tent where he was at nanded and asked them to bring the granth sahib jee. he then asked the sikhs to perform the gurgaddi ceremony, after which point he gave the sikhs some last instructions and told them after he was cremated not to search his ashes for bones and erect a samadhi. a samadhi is a place for ashes that hindus make, like a tomb, and though this practice is against sikhi, by the time of raja ranjit singh, it was common for sikhs to do. sikhs do not believe in worshiping samadhis, even guru jee's and so this was not a particularly spectacular request. the story of no bones having been found in the ashes and of a man later having a vision of guru jee on a horse are much MUCh later stories, written well into the 19th century by the namdharis. many sikhs have heard these stories in some way and believe them, but the oldest accounts of guru gobind singh sahib jee's akaal chalana are really no different than the other guru sahibs. the exception, of course, may be the stories of guru nanak sahib's akal chaalana and guru arjun sahib's. guru arjun sahib's body was never found after he went into the river and so no cremation took place. in addition, guru nanak's body, according the famous stories, was replaced by flowers and simply disappeared. im not going to criticise this story but i will say that similar stories abound of other holy men in india, especialy bhagat kabir sahib, and i, personaly, dont see the real "sikhiya" in that sakhi. seems just like a hagiographic account written by someone who wished to show how great guru sahib was. we all know, though, that miracles like this dont make guru jee great, but it instead the panth he created, the path he wrote, the kirtan he sang, and the sikhs he made. gurFateh