Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

Panthic singh · 19 Apr 2006

Why are Panthic Sites supporting Manmat? if you portray to be panthic dont support manmat.

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

Singh · 20 Apr 2006

ekta one supporting nangs comes to mind!

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

errr... · 20 Apr 2006

can you please clarify?

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

. · 20 Apr 2006

which site and which manmat are you talking about? please be more specific so sangat can take appropriate action if need be.

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

.====. · 20 Apr 2006

which manmat camp are u referring to

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

singhni · 20 Apr 2006

I assume you are reffering to EktaOne website supporting Sikh Student Camp. Ekta One has a responsibility to promote Gurmat. "EKTA" does not mean gathering every nilly willy mentoo rinkoo and bunty regardless whether they actually believe & follow Gurmat or not. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ http://www.panthic.org/news/115/ARTICLE/1841/2005-10-02.html Disappointing Sikh Student Camp and more... Sunday 2nd of October 2005 Panthic Weekly News Bureau Letters to the Editor Your article on Nihangs The Editor, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear Panthic Weekly Editors, I am really pleased on the article in the Panthic Weekly on Nihangs, who are true Nihangs according to Gurbani. There is no doubt that you know of the Nangs that were recently present in the Sikh Student camp. My nephew went to this camp and has kind of been led to believe that the Nangs are correct in their Snatan ways. I disagree with him and sent the Panthic Weekly articles, which have made him think a bit hard on Sikhism over all. These Nangs are the modern mahants in Western Sikh world and are trying to distort our Guru Ji's ways. They will fail and I pray the day come when they too may understand what is right and wrong. The surprising thing is that the most educated youngsters who are doing A' levels get pulled by these Nangs. Just goes to show how innocent and immature the opinion or belief is of Sikhism in our teenagers of today. The Sikh student camp has been going on for a couple of years, I never thought there were anti Gurmat practices at these camps until recently. I always thought the people who organised such camps were knowledgeable on Sikh Panth Maryada from the Akal Takht. However, it has become a known fact from the recent camp that the Nangs definitely get invited every year and they carry on their Hindu practices from which the most disgusting, which I heard was that they cut their arms for blood to anoint the Khanda and then scream out Jakarry. According to my nephew when I asked him why they did this, he replied that the Nangs seems to think it's the original way it has been done and the way the general Sikh kaum puts up the khanda has been britishisized! He also mentioned it's because of their love for Guru Ji that they scar their arms for blood to anoint the Khanda, and also it's similar in Japanese Samurai who have doing it for centuries. Nangs are similar warriors to the Japanese samurai!! I tried to explain that in daily ardaas we reiterate and ask for "daana sir daan naam daan" the biggest daan is naam daan that we ask for, it is which we have to give back by doing kamai of naam in our lives. Where is the mention for blood, name me any of our famous puratan Sikhs and from Our Guru Sahiban who performed such rituals. Panthic Weekly, I'm utterly disappointed that these kind of mix/bodge up version of practices happen in these camps, I wouldn't at all be surprised if they would introduced innocent Sikh youth to bhang in the langar in the coming years. Unless of course a group of people counter this by talking to the Sevadaars of these camps that they should have only Akal takht marayda adhering Sikhs to do parchaar at these camps. I recently wrote to the sevadaars of the BOSS camp and Khalsa camp if it's possible for a mega camp by all , to see if these Nangs would turn up for their parchaar. I got a mixed response, it may or may not happen, I hope it does even if it was once every 2-5 years. By doing so it would hit two birds with one stone. It would encourage ekta in the youth and further understanding of marayda and secondly make these Nangs feel left out , because I know for a fact if such a camp would happen these idiots would not be invited for parchaar, even if they were they wouldn't have the guts to come. But it's a dream lets' see if it ever happens. Once again Many Thanks for your articles may Guru Ji bless you more for such seva. H Singh ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

1978 · 20 Apr 2006

EktaOne has a problem with REAL nihangs

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

Sulakhan Singh Flora · 20 Apr 2006

Nangs and Namdharis. They seem to be linking up doing kirtan diwaans in our area. Usually get a group of namdharis doing kirtan followed by one of the nangs doing some katha. It's the latest trend.....

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

hmmm · 20 Apr 2006

So if you wanna get into camps n the best ones, then lets look at every angle. Im not any camp supporter so dont get me wrong. Im not AKJ or nothing but i believe the best camp out there is Khalsa Camp. Thats my opinion...

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

. · 20 Apr 2006

Author: Sulakhan Singh Flora Date: 04-20-06 05:47 Nangs and Namdharis. They seem to be linking up doing kirtan diwaans in our area. Usually get a group of namdharis doing kirtan followed by one of the nangs doing some katha. It's the latest trend..... ---------------------------------------------- The Nangs who you are implying to, are they doing nand parchar, or is it just your closemindedness that is grouping a Singh who does katha with the nangs? I know exactly who you are talking about, and would urge you to please state some fo the nang-gand he is spreading. I have personally listened to many of his Kathas, and find nothing objectable that is hindu-ized, like the main nangs are. He condemns many things the 'real deal' nangs do. Also how do you clasify a nang - anyone in the UK claiming to be a Nihung? Unless any manmat oarchar is done, it is not nice of you to go and brand people nangs left and right, due to theri sangat.

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

Neutrallllll Singh · 20 Apr 2006

i have never been Sikh Student camp but let me tell u this, i chat to people who go to all camps throughout the year and out of them all, Sikh Student Camp brings people into Sikhi... maybe its not the best camp, but in terms of bringing people from the streets into Sikhi, it does it the best. Khalsa Camp does excel in many other areas. My proof is 6 people i have spoken to - 3 have taken "choolah" over Vaisakhi and will be taking Amrit hopefully near Gurpurab of Guru Nanak Dev Jee this year. They keep their rehat and do nitnem and 2 of these have started wearing a keski regularily. One of these people went to BOSS Sikhi camp, and then Sikh Student camp - and when she came out of Sikh Student camp, she was buzzing and has started learning keertan being influenced by some of the attendees there such as Sukha Singh. End of the day, this is what is needed in London because around those areas, Sikhi is weaker than the midlands or the north - but i think thanks to Sikh Student Camp its strengthning there tremendously and will soon take over as the strongest because at the moment, the North Sikh Societies are leading the way. Theres different levels in my view and i think many would agree with this... Beginners camp = Sikh Student Intermediate camp = Sikhi Camp (boss) Advanced camp = Khalsa Camp bhul chuk maaf

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

LK · 20 Apr 2006

Right on Neutral Singh! Agree with you completely. The camps are differently structured and target different groups. To call them anti-panthic just because of that..lol.. Don't have much to say..

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

just me · 21 Apr 2006

totally disagree. this is an old argument. If it is a beginners camp, then it still has a responsibility to protray sikhi properly. Going around with plastic goats, and pretending to cut its head off is not mature. Swearing at other sikhs, brainwashing people that everyone else is britishfied, girlfreind/boyfriend situations, bob being a idiot, kamalroop spreading poison, threatening girls who resist advances, etc. That is not Gurmat regardless of whether it is a beginners camp?

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

singh · 21 Apr 2006

agree with "just me"

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

......... · 21 Apr 2006

just me - the actions you disagree with are only the actions of a few known "idiots" who prance around everywhere - it is not representative of the camp. the camp in itself still does a lot of great stuff - respect to it

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

GS · 21 Apr 2006

Ive heard swearing from Amrtdhari Singhs who attend the other camps as well. And girlfriend/boyfriend situations.. once again many naujawaans from the other camps are also into this kinda thing... ive known of a few people whom went to Sikhi camp and made friends there with the opposite gender, and then started dating them. In Sikhstudent camp, there is no brainwashing, lol, maybe u should attend it, before making such comments?

Re: Panthic Sites Supporting Manmat Camps

Admin · 21 Apr 2006

thread closed.