Bhangra @ Vancouver nagar kirtan
weird · 19 Apr 2006
How come there was Bhangra at the vancouver nagar kirtan? [%sig%]
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
weird · 19 Apr 2006
How come there was Bhangra at the vancouver nagar kirtan? [%sig%]Me · 19 Apr 2006
There is every year. The Gurudwara which goes against the Langar Hukamnama holds that Nagar Kirtan...but come to the Surrey one...its very Chardi Kala.msingh · 19 Apr 2006
To me they are both the same. Look around you. Nagar Kirtan means doing kirtan in the nagars(Streets). There was politics, there was Kirtan on some floats not all, there was Dhol floats, What Kind of Kirtan is this. In Surrey Bhangra groups had their stages on the street business. The idea that the Vancouver Nagar Kirtan is Kaljug is true. Surrey is no different. The thugs that are sitting at Dashmesh Darbar go to these devil nights after nagar kirtan. They are all interested in serving the devil because they have more money than the Khalsa. I will repeat this that the days of Khalsa Nagar Kirtan are vanishing. One day the Khalsa will rise and destory all these fake Khalsa in disguise at even the Gurdwaras that claim to be following Akal Takhat Marjada. $$$$ + Fundamentals = devil.Truth · 19 Apr 2006
Dashmesh Darbar is better than most places...A Singh · 20 Apr 2006
Despite the lentghy post on Manvir Singh Khalsa's blog concerning his thoughts on the origins of the Nagar Kirtan - truth be told, I cannot see any link of such practice with any Maryada. What does it really achieve in this day and age - kitch too kai, people will eventually argue that it should aim to present a positive image of Gursikhs, their beliefs etc etc. Would this not be better achieved through say, opening a free langer stall across town for the homeless, or doing some other kind of (wider) community seva [for instance, during Guru Arjan Dev Ji's shaheedi gurpurb, I recall as a child providing free water and drinks to the public frmo the Gurdwara I used attend with a leaflet describing what happened on the day - this can easily be adapted for a wider communal chairty benefit]. Instead, we hold Nagar Kirtans, now too with Maharaj in the procession followed by various floats, which now include blatantly non-Gurmat activities, make huge amounts of mess (albeit this is cleared up by the Sevadars - surely they would it be more contructive to go and clean up existing rubbish, rather than make some more and clean that up - net result, nothing!) and agian kitch too kai, gal ohi ondee eh, we have another thing to fight over between ourselves! Frankly, such processions should be stopped altogether. In india, they end up closing shops/businesses/etc for almost 6 hours whilst the procession goes on (who knows what economic impact this has on small traders, worse still the impact it may have on those requiring urgent medical assistance and have the route closed or have to undertake a longer route etc) - similar analogies are also present in the UK and Canada, be they to a smaller or larger extent. On a net net basis, these Nagar Kirtans really do very little for any Sikh purpose, regardless of how one can choose to dress the whole thing up. The same effort and resource could be easily better spent more productively elsewhere and achieve at least as much publicity and upliftment, if not more without all the residual costs.