Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Banning Headscarves from schools

Banning Headscarves from schools

Kulbir Singh · 17 Dec 2003

I think this is a very wrong decision by France. I can’t believe that they are going to ban religious necessities in France. Such a thing happening in a civilized Western country is unthinkable. I am worried that this may spread to other civilized countries and it may affect the Sikhs too. We too wear dastaar (turban) and what if they refuse to look at you in a public hospital in France, for wearing a turban? What if they refuse to accept your child in school for wearing a turban, keski or even for having long unshorn hair? I think all Sikhs in Europe, together with other minorities, including Muslims, should protest and oppose this ban of headscarves. If they ban headscarves, I am sure they would ban turban too (keski). How are the Sikhs supposed to go to school, with their long hair? Next thing they will say that the Sikhs have to cut their hair to assimilate in their culture. What is next? Dye your skin and hair to look Blond? Sikhs of Europe, please do something about this, before this spreads to rest of the world. We can’t let this happen. On this issue we should unite with other religions. Daas, Kulbir Singh Chirac: Ban headscarves in schools PARIS, France (CNN) -- French President Jacques Chirac has called for a law banning religious symbols and clothing in state schools and hospitals. Chirac's remarks Wednesday came in response to a commission report favoring the banning of Muslim head scarves, Jewish skullcaps and large Christian crosses in public schools. He said he would sponsor legislation to make the ban law by next autumn. In an address to the nation, Chirac said: "I feel that wearing any kind of symbol that ostensibly shows faith, I feel that that is something that should not be allowed in schools and colleges. "If we are talking about a star of David, the hand of Fatima or a small cross, those are acceptable, but when it's very obvious, in other words, when if they are worn people can immediately see what religious faith they belong to, that should not be accepted." Later in his remarks, Chirac said the ban should also apply to hospitals. And he added: "Nothing can justify that a patient refuses, on principle, to be cared for by a doctor of the opposite sex. The law must consecrate this rule for all the ill who go to a public hospital." Chirac said the wearing of religious symbols threatened the cohesion of the French people and France's separation of church and state. "Secularity is one of the republic's great achievements," said Chirac. "It plays a crucial role in social harmony and national cohesion. We must not allow it to be weakened." He also said he did not favor enacting new state holidays honoring different religions to supplement those holidays already on the books. Chirac said France, whose Muslim and Jewish populations are the largest in Europe, must remain a multicultural society. A poll published Wednesday, showed the majority of French people side with Chirac. The poll published in the Paris daily Le Parisien showed 69 percent favor a law banning the wearing of head scarves and other religious symbols. Although directed at all three religions, the recommendation was seen as being aimed at countering Islamic fundamentalism, The Associated Press reported. Muslims, who comprise about eight percent of France's population, had urged Chirac not to propose a law to enforce any ban. Christian and Jewish religious leaders have also voiced opposition. "A law on religious symbols in the school environment could stigmatize a whole community," Dalil Boubakeur, president of the French Council of the Muslim Faith, told Reuters. The topic took on new life after dozens of girls were expelled from school in the past two years for refusing to remove headscarves. Some human rights groups said they opposed the measure. The International Helsinki Federation for Human Rights said the law would violate France's commitments to protect freedom of religion, Reuters reported. The group added that a head scarf ban would result in alienation and marginalization of Muslims living in France.

Re: Banning Headscarves from schools

singh-2 · 17 Dec 2003

if this measure is introduced, there is sure to be human rights litigation in france and then if necessary the european court of human rights. i cannot see the proposed law holding ground in front of the strasbourg court if not in front of their own courts. but litigation takes time. this proposed law is indicative two things common across mainland europe - secular fundamentalism and widespread hostility to multi-culturalism. all the problems to be created by these measures shows the extent of the underlying hostility to anything religious particularly non christian non european. it also shows the lengths european governments are prepared to go to in the name of furthering the 'european ideal' - statist, top-down, secular, culturally exclusive. [%sig%]

Re: Banning Headscarves from schools

warrior*princess · 17 Dec 2003

Kulbir Singh jee wrote: >>I think this is a very wrong decision by France. I can’t believe that they are going to ban religious necessities in France. Such a thing happening in a civilized Western country is unthinkable. I am worried that this may spread to other civilized countries and it may affect the Sikhs too. We too wear dastaar (turban) and what if they refuse to look at you in a public hospital in France, for wearing a turban? What if they refuse to accept your child in school for wearing a turban, keski or even for having long unshorn hair? << My family and i were thinking and discussing the same thing 2day!!! I have even experienced similar hatred from my headteacher leading to personal phone calls to our home regarding my dastaar when i was a kid,...headteacher said how i must wear a mini-skirt in sports(although other girls were allowed to cover their legs), and that they do not like my superiority complex with the turban image...i was a quiet girl and studied hard, yet they did not like me due to the religious appearance. And these phone calls etc started when i only had about two years left out of the four (i think) of being there at the secondary school. Of course i still covered my legs in sports and continued with my lifestyle at that school. Regardless of the meeting and personal phone calls, they couldnt really do anything about it. And all this is just in the UK. This current happening in france would give such type of teachers to use their personal hatred and begin such rules within schools. In the past I have seen documentrys on the racism in France towards Muslim Headscarfs,...i feel very sorry that they have to put up with such racism. Lets hope that France and Chirac are not successful.

Re: Banning Headscarves from schools

Singh · 17 Dec 2003

Europe is a very racist place. Pretty much every place is racist in the world. Canada is probably the least racist. Britain, America, Australia are probably right behind. Germany and France are so racist. They don't seem to care about human rights, especially for minorities at all. Its a shame they got such a good reputation through Iraq war. They're actually the biggest hypocrites out there.

Re: Banning Headscarves from schools

jagjit singh · 18 Dec 2003

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! pyare jio, just seen the news debate on CNN. The reasoning by the French goverment is that it is all about muslims, and paranioa of them. The far right Le Pen Govt were going to announce it in their manifesto for elections next year. Chirac knows its populist, and is doing it himself. Their excuse being this is a Christian country, and it is being dominated by foriegn cultures. They also use the excuse of how non-muslims are treated in muslim countries, which I admit is a very valid point. As always i fear, that this is part of a non-offical war between the West and Islam, sikhs once again will be caught by both sides, and will suffer. This is very shameful for France considering there are so many Sikhs shaheed on French soils and so many monument to commerate them. But their next generation will be disallowed to follow their religion, a religion which sacrificed to save France. Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! P.S. there will be many debates on this on various news channels, and news groups. Everyone do something practical and phone in, and email. Lets get a sikh perspective heard on this. I tried to phone CNN, but was unable to get through.

Re: Banning Headscarves from schools

kookar ram ko · 18 Dec 2003

I dont think that the law will be easily set upon france because I think that there are too many religious people in Western Europe countries and that they will revolt against this. Since there are too many, the government doesnt really have a chance. Hopefully, the law shall not be put down.

Re: Banning Headscarves from schools

rsingh · 19 Dec 2003

In the past, I know in France that they wouldn't let sikhs get citizenship and passports with dastaars on. Even a couple of years ago, they were causing sikhs a lot of hassle for getting any official photographs. Now with the muslim issue, they have a new excuse for their racist policies.

Re: Banning Headscarves from schools

Kulbir Singh · 25 Dec 2003

Call to oppose French legislation Tribune News Service Chandigarh, December 25 Dr Jasbir Singh Ahluwalia, a former Vice-Chancellor of Punjabi University, Patiala, today asked Sikhs to join others to oppose French legislation banning ‘visible’ religious symbols. In a press release issued here, Dr Ahluwalia said according to the BBC News French President Jacques Chirac and justified the proposed legislation, banning the wearing of visible religious symbols, such as Islamic headscarves and Sikh turbans etc. in public schools and at work places on the ground that such practices were “anathema to many French people....” Sikh boys wearing turbans would be most affected by this legislation. The SGPC in liaison with other like-minded organisations, should address a strong protest to the French President through the French Embassy in New Delhi, he said

Re: Banning Headscarves from schools

Kulbir Singh · 26 Dec 2003

SGPC to discuss French legislation on turban (www.tribuneindia.com) Phagwara, December 26 The SGPC general secretary, Jathedar Sukhdev Singh Bhaur, said today that the Executive Committee of the SGPC would discuss in its meeting on December 30 at Amritsar the serious issue of the proposed French legislation to ban the tying of turbans by Sikhs in public schools and work places in France. He was talking to mediapersons at the local Guru Nanak College after inaugurating a three-day zonal Gurmat training camp organised by Guru Gobind Singh study circle, Jalandhar-Kapurthala a zone, headed by Mr M.P. Singh. Mr Jagat Singh Palahi, president of the host college, was the chief guest at the camp. Jathedar Bhaur said the issue would also be discussed in the Dharam Parchar Committee of the SGPC and the Advisory Board of Akal Takht. After this, the issue would be taken up with the French Government through proper channel, he said. It may be mentioned here that French President Jacques Chirac had justified the proposed legislation banning the wearing of “visible” religious symbols such as turbans by Sikhs claiming that these were “anathema to many French people..”. Jathedar Bhaur disclosed that a high-powered delegation of the SGPC would soon visit Pakistan to take up with that government the Sikh issues of giving group visas to devotees, handing over the management of gurdwaras in Pakistan to Sikhs, running of Sikh religious places as per “maryada”, proper maintenance of historical and religious buildings and gurdwaras, increasing the revenue amount of the property in the name of gurdwaras, removing encroachments on Sikh religious places and property and setting up either a university or a hospital in the name of Guru Nanak Dev. Giving details of upcoming SGPC projects, Jathedar Bhaur said plans were afoot to have a tie-up with some other private TV channels for telecasting “gurbani kirtan” from other important gurdwaras like Takht Sri Kesgarh Sahib, Anandpur Sahib. The SGPC, at present, had kept in abeyance its plan to start its own channel as the project required atleast Rs 50 crore besides some other hassles, he informed. A multi-purpose hall would be constructed in the Golden Temple Complex for giving information of Sikh heritage and Sikhism through internet and video clips, he disclosed. A modern technology park would come up, preferably at Fatehgarh Sahib, in commemoration of the third centenary celebrations of the martyrdom of “sahibzadas” (sons) of Guru Gobind Singh, he said.

Re: Banning Headscarves from schools

Kulbir Singh · 01 Jan 2004

French Sikhs urge Vajpayee to intervene in turban ban Ranvir Nayar (IANS) Paris, January 1 Sikhs living in France have appealed to Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Punjab Chief Minister Amarinder Singh to intercede with the French government on its decision to ban display of religious symbols in public places, especially schools. French Education Minister Luc Ferry has been instructed to introduce a bill in the French parliament that will pave the way for a strict law banning display of religious symbols in schools. Under the proposed law, Muslim girls will not be able to wear headscarves or veils in school while the Jews will be prohibited from wearing their kippa. While the Muslim population of France has been the focus of the controversy, the Sikhs say that they will be hit even harder than other religious minorities by the ban. Sikh students are already facing problems in wearing patkas, or turban, in school. Sikh community leaders in France fear that with the new law, school administrations will become more hawkish and may even try to force their children to cut their hair or shave their beard. The trouble for the Sikhs does not end with schools. In fact, they are forced to take their turbans off for any photographs for getting any official French documents like the identity card or driving licence. "We are already facing a huge challenge in terms of getting the French administration to accept our photographs with the turbans. The new law can lead to a situation that will be extremely dangerous for the Sikh religion in France," says Kashmir Singh, a Sikh who has been living in France for the last 15 years. "I came to France at the height of the Punjab problem, thinking that I had come to the land of democracy, freedom and equality. But now I find that these kinds of laws are taking even the simplest of freedoms away from us. This is totally unacceptable," he adds. "We appeal to Prime Minister Vajpayee and Punjab Chief Minister Amarinder Singh to use their good offices with the French government to ensure that the Sikhs are not impacted by the new law which threatens to lead to a total extermination of Sikhism within France," says Chain Singh, leader of the Sikh community in Paris. The Sikhs are now preparing to drum up support for their cause by launching a high profile campaign for their rights in France. "We plan to join hands in a big demonstration against the new law that will be held in Paris on January 17. We will also hold our own demonstrations, later, where we will invite leading Sikh personalities from all over the world and go to the French media about how unfair and harsh the new law will mean for the Sikhs," Chain Singh told IANS. The Sikh leaders say they will not give up the fight easily and will carry the battle into the European Court of Human Rights, if the French government goes ahead with the draconian act.