Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gender discrimination???

Gender discrimination???

sanjo · 15 Apr 2006

Sikhi is totally against discrimination via gender. that is the sikhi that the gurus have given us. but is todays "sikhi" living up to the hukam of guru ji? do we truely look at both genders as equal or are we influenced by society to think of women as inferior. das himself stupidly makes this mistake sometimes. but i was thinking how some time ago people had a debate on how bibia should be able to do kirtan at harmindar sahib. and i havent seen bibia do kirtan there yet, so i was wandering what the conclusion to that debate was, or if indeed whether the debate is still going on. i think bibia should be able to do kirtan and be sevadars at harmindar sahib and obviously all gurdwareh, but i think that debate as died down abit, for me its one of the pressing issues we should deal with. alot of people with an outside view of sikhi would think that the men control everything, do we not potray this anti sexist idealogy which preaches equality enough? its an amazing thing what guru ji done. he commanded that women get equal rights to men, its totally amazing considering the time at which guru ji pronounced this, a male dominated culture, daughters looked upon as a burden, women chucked on the funeral pire of husbands etc etc. guru ji didnt just say it was wrong he put his words in to action and stopped this stuff. this is one of the most important things guru ji done, but do we give this that much importance or are alot of us too quick to forget such great teachings. if sikhi is truely against sexism, which it should be, then women should most definately be allowed to do kirtan etc at places like harimandir sahib. das also thinks every singhni should have the personality of a lioness, and not back down from any situation. women sometimes consider themselves weaker than men, but asoon as u believe u are weaker then u are indeed weaker. if guru ji has said that u are equal then u are! every singhni must believe this and be tyar bar tyar. it is not only the singhs that may have to do seva on the battlefield etc. i was saying this to my muslim friend, and that if he was perhaps in trouble and his life was at risk etc, if there was a gursikh near by, it would be that gursikhs responsibility to help him, otherwise what is the point of wearing the kirpan. when i said a singhni would also have to help him, he was totally shocked. he couldnt believe how a woman could defend a man. but i remember thinking that anything can happen with naam and amrit and that how amazing sikhi and guru ji is that he can give that gursikh singhni soo much strength enough to overcome soo many prejudices and become a lioness. who knws one day one of our bhenjia myt come to our rescue if we are not tyar bar tyar ourselves. its just great how guru ji has made sikhi and how it totally differs from other faiths. so yh anyway bibia should be able to do kirtan and other seva at harimandir sahib, in my humble opinion. bhull chuk maaf waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Gender discrimination???

E · 16 Apr 2006

sikhisms view of equality is absolute truth, that of the western society has been twisted. in sikhi men and women are equal, as in both are equally important, both have different roles which are equally important. singhs and singhnia share many roles also, for example doing seva, kirtan etc. other roles are not shared, for example mother caring for baby feeding , which a man cant do. this isnt inequality, god made men an women different, different doesnt mean unequal. god made men physically stronger, this doesnt make then superior, it just means they are suited for certain roles. western society thikns women should take mens roles, and men take womens they think this is equality..........now wander divorce rates in the west is something like 50% for first marriages 75% second marriages 90% for third marriages. when a women tries to take their partners role it results in violence, studies my colleagues have done at university showed the most commmon cause of domestic violence is partners fighting to become 'boss'. the west has a warped view of equality that doesnt work eg - god made men stronger therefore he's practised inequality. in anand karaj men walk in front of the women, this practices inequality this is rubbish, do not mix the 'wests' view of equality with sikhi. but you are right, there should be singhnee's doing kirtan and seva at harmandir sahib, there is no reason why they cant as long as they are amritdharee keski-dharee. at the moment i think the commitee there only allows hajoori raagis to do kirtan, and i dont think there are many singhnees who are hajoori raagis, this maybe why there arent many singhnees doing kirtan