how did khalistan fail
how · 12 Apr 2006
how did we lose the war for our independence. [%sig%]
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
how · 12 Apr 2006
how did we lose the war for our independence. [%sig%]jhamka · 12 Apr 2006
vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh the WAR is still on, we not wiped out yet, even if one gursikh is still alive we will carry on fighting akaaalAB · 12 Apr 2006
my two cents............... 1. terrible, terrible government and police repression 2. backstabbers like badal 3. turncoats such as zafarwal, chouhan etc. 4. rupee/dollar/pound, whiskey more important 5. some people started acting like criminals giving the movement a bad name 6. few killed hindus to give the movement a communal color 7. meek surrender during operation black thunder. would never have happened in the days of praatan sikhs 8. reduced support in america-we have our own issues to deal with post 9/11 9. reduced support in districts outside amritsar and gurdaspur 10. punjab's population is barely 2/3rd sikh. the other religious communities not with khalistan as the concept has not been explained properly 11. lack of support from western countries (even dan burton has become india's friend) 12. lots of generals, desparate lack of soldiersSingh · 12 Apr 2006
We may have lost the battle, but the war is still on. In the end Good will triumph over evil just as Shri Raam defeated Ravan. Satyame Vijayte. As long as we remain Nyara as Guru Gobind Singh Jee said, we will receive help from Guru Jee. Currently we Sikhs are loosing our distinctiveness and assimilating into popular cultures across the world. We need to come back to our puritanical ways and stop all the innovations and deviations that have crept into the Panth.moorakh · 12 Apr 2006
khalistan zindabaadJEEVAN SINGH · 13 Apr 2006
they can never beat us ! khalistan will come [%sig%]Seenq · 13 Apr 2006
They consider a crime in India if you ask for Sikh Independence and Khalistan. You are known as a terrorist just because you asked for Sikh rights!!!!!!ssingh · 13 Apr 2006
The fading of Sikh militancy By Soutik Biswas BBC News, Delhi Times change. The verdict in Canada following the destruction of an Air India jumbo jet over the Atlantic in 1985 is a reminder of the extent of Sikh militancy in India at the time. Several thousand people died in nearly 10 years of militancy - and India's Sikhs effectively became alienated from mainstream society. In a series of events that that shocked the nation, the Congress government led by Prime Minister Indira Gandhi sent troops into the Sikhs' sacred shrine - the Golden Temple complex in Amritsar - to flush out the militants holed up there. A few months later, in October 1984, Mrs Gandhi was gunned down by her Sikh bodyguards. Her death triggered riots in which, according to official figures, more than 3,000 Sikhs were killed by rioting mobs. But now, over two decades after it all began, the divide between Sikhs, who make up 3% of India's population, and Hindus has been bridged and the antagonism with the Congress party largely disappeared. 'Different realities' The elevation last year of Manmohan Singh as India's first Sikh prime minister was the culmination in the changing relations. Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale The face of Sikh militancy in the 1980s Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale "The alienation between the Sikhs and Congress is a distant memory now. The ground realities are very different today," analyst Mahesh Rangarajan told the BBC News website as Mr Singh took office. There are many Sikhs who still feel bitter about the way they were targeted after Mrs Gandhi's assassination and the inaction, or complicity of Congress politicians as the riots developed. But the deep distrust that once existed between the community and the party no longer exists. One reason is the sheer length of time which has elapsed since the horrific riots of 1984, when Sikhs were singled out to be lynched and torched to death in public. "Time is a great healer, and it has done the same to the relationship between Congress and the Sikhs," Punjab-based political scientist Professor PS Verma told the BBC. Losing steam The wounds have been actually healing over the last decade. India has had a Sikh president and a home minister, both with roots in the Congress party since Mrs Gandhi's assassination. The antagonism between the Sikhs the Gandhi family lost some of its steam. This is perhaps in part because no member of India's first family participated in active politics between 1991, after the killing of Rajiv Gandhi and 1998, when Sonia Gandhi became the Congress party chief. Sonia Gandhi Sonia Gandhi helped reconcile the Sikhs and Congress Interestingly, the Congress' fortunes began picking up in the early 1990s in the Punjab, - the northern Sikh majority state which had been the epicentre of the separatist militancy. This was despite the overwhelming dominance of Punjab's regional Akali Dal party, which has been consistently critical of what they describe as the Congress' "insensitivity and mistreatment" of the Sikhs. In 1993, barely a decade after the anti-Sikh riots, the Congress swept the village council polls in Punjab - the turnout of voters was as high as 82%. Six years later, in the 1999 general elections, the Congress party led in Punjab over its formidable Akali Dal rivals. Congress party chief Sonia Gandhi also played her role in the reconciliation process. After taking charge of the party in 1998, she went around Sikh places of worship - gurdwaras - in Delhi apologising for the riots. "I feel this kind of incident should not have happened," Mrs Gandhi told the Sikhs. "And my husband Rajiv Gandhi felt the same." Community and Congress Two years ago, the Congress convincingly won the state elections in Punjab, dislodging the Akali Dal from power. The state continues to have a Congress-led government. Sikh devotees in Amritsar Sikh devotees in Amritsar "The Congress was not an untouchable any more for the vast majority of Sikhs, as it was for many years after the raid on the holiest shrine," said analyst Yogendra Yadav. "The election also signalled a return to normal politics in Punjab, where questions of development and interest fulfilment were taking centre stage - thus displacing questions of identity, alienation and terrorism that dominated its politics for well over a decade." Surveys reveal that Sikhs in the capital Delhi, which saw most of the rioting in 1984 and has a substantially large community population, began voting for the Congress heavily from the 1998 general elections onwards. So much so that in the recent general elections, Congress mopped up six of the seven parliamentary seats in Delhi. This was despite the fact that the party had fielded two candidates, including a former minister, who were indicted for their involvement in the riots, and later acquitted by the courts. In fact, Punjab's Akali Dal party had appealed to all Sikhs in the Congress to quit the party as it was "brutally insensitive" and insulted the Sikhs by deciding to field the two candidates who were "the butchers of innocent Sikhs". The Akali Dal's campaign is not entirely political rhetoric - it reflects the sentiments of a smaller section of Sikhs who still remain bitter with the Congress and feel that it did not do enough to punish the rioters. Manmohan Singh's appointment as prime minister will continue to further bridge the gap between the community and the Congress, analysts believe.how · 13 Apr 2006
what the hell the congress still has people in it's party who helped kill inocent sikh's and they have yet to be punished whats wrong with our people in the punjab i guess all that non sence has gotton to their heads.yea · 14 Apr 2006
was Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale a puppet for indira gandi if now is thier proof because i hear it was indira gandi who gave power to Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale.Prabhjoyt Singh · 14 Apr 2006
"I feel this kind of incident should not have happened," Mrs Gandhi told the Sikhs. "And my husband Rajiv Gandhi felt the same." Yeh makes sense even though rejiv organised the massacaressingh · 14 Apr 2006
there is not going to be the Khalistan in punjab that people dream about. People in punjab dont care about khalistan. People in the west do demonstations and sign petions to put pressure on their western government to get India to act. But India is becoming a very powerful country and wont give a cr@p what England or Canada thinks. The only way sikhi can become a world power is if it can be shown to be a sucessful global religion, not just something for punjabis. So my advice is be the best in what you do , business, sports, music, studies, exams, jobs etc. - that is the only successful parchar. People should look up to you... · 14 Apr 2006
singh, that's a naastick (atheist) approach to Khalsa Raj. We aren't the Polish or some ethnic group that will do well in culture and business and then gain respect. We will only get our respect when we become Gursikhs that please Guru Sahib and he will give us Khalsa Raj. No other power matters. As for what Indians think: who cares? The Indians were happy under the British as well. It was "crazy" Sikhs in North America and Europe who supported the Gadar movement and the independence struggles. Nothing has changed. Indian Sikhs have slave mentality. When Sikhs come to the West they realise what it means to be free and the value of freedom and begin to see the need for Khalsa Raj. We will be a "succesful global religion" not when we have money and good jobs, but when we have a Panth of high avastha Gursikhs.JEEVAN SINGH · 15 Apr 2006
INDIA WILL FALL WHEN IT BECOMES THE MOST POWERFULL ' SUPERPOWER ' COUNTRY IN THE WORLD !!! KHALISTAN WON'T JUST BE PANJAB BUT ALOT BIGGER ! PAKISTAN IS ALSO ON ITS WAY TO FALL [%sig%]yea · 15 Apr 2006
was Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale a puppet for indira gandi if so is thier proof because i hear it was indira gandi who gave power to Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale.... · 15 Apr 2006
I don't understand how Sant Jarnail Singh was given power by Indira. Can you explain how this would be possible? Did she pay thousands and thousands of Sikhs to go to his divaans and support him? The only point people have for saying that Sant Jarnail Singh was a "puppet" is that she didn't clamp down on him and crush the movement he was starting at the very start as she normally would have done. She did this because she though Sant Jarnail Singh would take away power from the Akalis but didn't realise how powerful he could really get. Even if we accept this argument, it still doesn't in any way make him a "puppet" or gave him power. If you have heard something else, please do share it.simple · 15 Apr 2006
we never lost a single war or battle a singh gets shaheed he wins when have we lost khalsa has never lost india is guru ji's the world is guru ji's everything is guru ji's think sachkhand think of the armies of shaheed singhs that look down on us what have we lost wake up in the mornings do your simran and always be ready to fight for times will always come when we need to fight but we will never lose we never have we didnt lose in 1984 think about how many of us got shaheed think about how many people took amrit after what have we lost nothing stop fighting amongts each other wake up in the mornings do your nitnem do simran stop fighting on how to do simran when you dont do it just do it guru ji watches you dont you think he'll lead you the right way dont you have faith in him why do you talk about decisions guru ji will make we just got to be preparedsingh · 15 Apr 2006
we did not lose the battle. singh's have never lost. 1984 was a cheap move by the government. the most awaited comeback will happen, we have to make sure we remain ready for it!LS · 16 Apr 2006
Desire for Khalistan Alive and Well in Punjab Khalistan Zindabad Slogans Raised at Holla Mohallah Festival WASHINGTON, D.C., March 21, 2006 – Slogans of “Khalistan Zindabad” filled the air at the Holla Mohallah festival in Anandpur Sahib, Punjab, led by Dal Khalsa and the Shiromani Khalsa Dal. The two organizations pledged to unite to liberate the Sikh homeland, Khalistan, which declared itself independent from India on October 7, 1987. Dal Khalsa, led by Satnam Singh, president of Dal Khalsa, and Daljit Singh Bittu, pledged to “provide a fresh platform for the Sikhs who were depressed withe the incompetent and incapable leadership of various factions of the Akali Dal,” according to The Telegraph, an Indian newspaper. Satnam Singh said the organizations would reach out to people to involve them in “the struggle to uphold our honor and dignity,” the newspaper reported. The Punjab government led by Chief Minister Amarinder Singh has directed the police that both groups be put under watch. Dal Khalsa has sponsored numerous marches in Punjab in support of a free Khalistan, the Sikh homeland that declared its independence from India on October 7, 1987. It was the organizer of the two events at which Sikhs were arrested for making speeches and raising the Khalistani flag. History shows that multinational states such as India are doomed to failure. Countries like Austria-Hungary, India’s longtime friend the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia, and others prove this point. India is not one country; it is a polyglot like those countries. It is doomed to break up as they did. “The uniting of these two organizations is very good for the Sikh nation and its aspirations,” said Dr. Gurmit Singh Aulakh, President of the Council of Khalistan. “The Indian government continues to persecute and kill our Sikh brethren,” he said. “Unity is essential for the liberation of Khalistan,” he said. “As Professor Darshan Singh, a former Jathedar, said, ‘If a Sikh is not for Khalistan, he is not a Sikh’,” Dr. Aulakh noted.“This shows that the drive for freedom is still alive in Punjab,” he said. “What kind of democracy watches people for demanding freedom? Why don’t they watch the Black Cats who have killed thousands of Sikhs with the protection of the Indian government?” he asked. The Indian government has murdered over 250,000 Sikhs since 1984, more than 300,000 Christians since 1948 as well as tens of thousands of Christians throughout the country, over 90,000 Muslims in Kashmir since 1988, 2,000 to 5,000 Muslims in Gujarat, tens of thousands of Muslims elsewhere in India, and tens of thousands of Assamese, Bodos, Dalits, Manipuris, Tamils, and others. An Indian newspaper reported that the police in Gujarat were ordered to stand aside in that massacre and not to get involved, a frightening parallel to the Delhi massacre of Sikhs in 1984. The Indian Supreme Court called the Indian government's murders of Sikhs "worse than a genocide." Indian police arrested human-rights activist Jaswant Singh Khalra after he exposed their policy of mass cremation of Sikhs, in which over 50,000 Sikhs have been arrested, tortured, and murdered, then their bodies were declared unidentified and secretly cremated. He was murdered in police custody. His body was not given to his family. The police never released the body of former Jathedar of the Akal Takht Gurdev Singh Kaunke after SSP Swaran Singh Ghotna murdered him. No one has been brought to justice for the Khalra kidnapping and murder or for the murder of Jathedar Kaunke. Yet according to a report by the Movement Against State Repression (MASR), 52,268 Sikhs are being held as political prisoners in India without charge or trial, some since 1984! Missionary Graham Staines was murdered along with his two sons, ages 8 and 10, by a mob of militant, fundamentalist Hindu nationalists who set fire to the jeep, surrounded it, and chanted “Victory to Hannuman,” a Hindu god. None of the people involved has been tried. The persons who have murdered priests, raped nuns, and burned Christian churches have not been charged or tried. The murderers of 2,000 to 5,000 Muslims in Gujarat have never been brought to trial. “Only in a free Khalistan will the Sikh Nation prosper and get justice,” said Dr. Aulakh. “India should act like a democracy and allow a plebiscite on independence for Khalistan and all the nations of South Asia,” Dr. Aulakh said. “We must free Khalistan now.” www.khalistan.comsingh · 16 Apr 2006
we didnt lose '84 ??? ur deluded mate - living in a fantasy world. SO in that case why do people go on demonstrations and get upset about 84 why dont they celebrate it every year- all the innocent people that got killed , women raped, sikh literature burned forever! GREAT! get real mate most youngsters in Punjab have chopped of their hair since 84 84 is just what the government wanted. It was planned over time. The Government and Indra Gandhi befriended Jarnail Singh, they were very tight at first and then turn against them as has been done by the USA with Sadam and Bin Laden. Thats why people call them puppets.Prabhjoyt Singh · 16 Apr 2006
"Singh" dont talk rubbish Indira and the congress had nothing to do with Sant Jee and whats your source or are you one of these jokers who make baseless poits and cant back themIts me again · 16 Apr 2006
Agree with AB. I think Sikh's were not clear on their goal and agenda of the struggle. Most top Sikh thinkers who were also militants were killed in start of the struggle, and the following militant leadership was more of show of muscle instead of using the brains. One very important thing, the war is being fought with Orthodox thought in mind which won't get the support of moderate Sikh's....If we want Khalistan then it should be not a fanatic country....I will give you some examples here.... Militants started to force their idiology on public, such as forcing women to take yellow dupata's, forcing men to keep beard and turban, forcing people to change their social life to meet their likings.....These things make us no different then Taliban and which is against Sikh rules anyways.... Sikhisim excepts all and based on concept of live and let live...until we as Sikh's don't adopt this thinking we can't win, we can never win.california apna · 16 Apr 2006
whats the difference between moderates and fundamentilist and why do they fight so much.Its me again · 17 Apr 2006
Dear california apna Moderates could be anybody who practice their religion as they wish but do not impose their way of doing things on others and fundamentilists are those who impose their way of doing things on others and go to the extent of hurting sombody if they don't agree with them.... eg: Hindu fundamentilists destryoed babri masjid eg: Many Amritdhari Sikh's harass and make joes of people who are born in a Sikh family but cut their hairs. (this is a way of fanaticism) basically saying I am a better person then you because I have a long beard and you don't...I don't beleive that is Sikhisim. hope this helps...singh · 17 Apr 2006
For prabhjot singh: 1) He was supported by the Congress (I) (Indira Gandhi) in the SGPC elections of 1979, though only 4 of his 40 candidates were able to secure seats. ' 2) For all his protestations that he was not a politician, Bhindranwale campaigned actively for the Congress in three constituencies' during the 1980 general elections. 3) During the 1981 elections to the Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (D.S.G.P.C.), 'in an attempt to divide Akali votes, the Congress (I) had asked the A.I.S.S.F. [All India Sikh Students Federation] to put up candidates for the Delhi gurdwaras whose campaign was led by Sant Bhindranwale. No A.I.S.S.F. candidate won.' Are you one of those deluded people who beleived he survived the attack and was waiting in Pakistan for all these years to take over Baba Takhur Singh?california apna · 17 Apr 2006
what is the moderates idealogy and a fundamentilist's idealogy.Prabhjoyt singh · 18 Apr 2006
"Singh" I have always beleived Sant Ji to be Shaheed and thats a fact, and could provide some references that he was supported by congress? Sant ji did ask Bhai Amrik Singh Ji and others to take part in SGPC elections but there is no proof of Congress supporting them. One thing is tat the congress did not oppose Sant Ji at the start as they thought he would be against the Akalis and even offered him Rs. 50 crore to continue parchaaar but never say Sikhs are Gulaam and Sant Ji refused and despite this you reckon he was with congress, your the deluded one.kaur. · 18 Apr 2006
WE WILL GET KHALISTAN AND KHALSA RAJ WHEN WE ALL START ACTING LIKE PROPER GURSIKHS THAT FOLLOW REHAT FULLY, WAKE UP AT AMRITVELA AND DO SIMRAN AND READ BANI WIV LOVE AND COMPASSION!! THE ONLY WAY KHALSA WILL RULE IS IF WE BECOME KHALSAS FIRST, READ BHAI RAMA SINGHS BOOK AND OTHER GURSIKHS BOOKS, THEY WILL ALL TELL YOU THAT WE NEED TO BECOME KHALSAS FIRST,WE NEED TO BECOME PURE BEFORE KHALSA RULES! AND IT WILL HAPPEN 1 DAY, WE ALL JUS NEED TO GET OUT ACTS TOGETHER AND MAKE IT HAPPEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! READ BANI, DO SIMRAN,DO SEVA AND BE COMPASSIONATE, KIND AND CARING AND FULL REHAT FULLY... GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ONCE SAID THAT REHAT IS MORE IMPORTANT TO ME THAN THE SIKHS, MEANING WE NEED TO FOLLOW REHAT FULLY AND NOT CUT BACK, NOT LET THIS MAYA GET IN OUR WAY, BECOME PURE THEN -------->KHALSA RAJ KAREGA!!Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 18 Apr 2006
VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh What Bibi Sahib 'KAUR' Jeeo said is absolutely right, but what khalsa raj really means is becoming a Khalsa and having this raj over your body. This is all we should want, and not khalistan. If you have this khalsa raj you wouldn't care for khalistan, as to you everywhere you go would be heaven. There's only Khalsa Raj, not Khalistan. If one desperately asks for khalistan that means that person lacks rehit, bani and especially NAAM! We have to take complete control over our body even from the things we think are minor such as movies/tv, console games and so on. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFatehJEEVAN SINGH · 18 Apr 2006
i think the views of daas are wrong [%sig%]t dot jatt · 18 Apr 2006
why khalistan could khalistan survive as it's own country or would; the farmers of punjab and everyone be in even more trouble financially.JEEVAN SINGH · 18 Apr 2006
the farmers of panjab will be more better because in khalistan they could sell their crops at their prices and not the prices that india ( center delhi ) throws at them !!!!!!! they will be more independent and can sell to the rest of the world, which they can't do now !! the water of panjab will go to panjabi farmers to produce better crops rather than having it taken away from us by force in the current situation [%sig%]Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 18 Apr 2006
VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeekEefateh Bhai Sahib 'JEEVAN SINGH' Jeeo, in the future Khalistan will come but not purposely by singhs/singhnis causing a war or anything to attain it, but by singhs/singhnis having Khalsa raj over thier own world, which is the body. Once this is occomplished the people in punjab will need protecting and these khalsas will be there to protect them and destroy the wicked. Then the whole of the punjab will be free for the taking, since there won't be anyone there to have power over it. However, there's yet more to this taking and power over punjab. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeekEefatehkaur · 22 Apr 2006
could you guy's give evidence that it was the indian government killing inocent hindu's in punjab to make the sikh's look badt dot jatt · 22 Apr 2006
why have a khalistan when we can take over new deli like how hard is it to destroy india, like seriously look at the size of their soilders and i doubt worshipping statue's would help.mittu · 22 Apr 2006
is there no way punjabi farmers at present cannot broker deals with large supermarket chains in the west? can intermediete people help just for example sake farming ace dhillon in cali? people with a bit of money and power to approach western companies? therefore less going to indian middlemen........ · 22 Apr 2006
i dnt know much about bhai sant jarnail singh jee as ive onli started to tke steps into sikhi..but ive heard to different stories about him and dont know which 1 is right..i mean obviously i wouldnt want to say that people who are followers of him are wrong...howeever imnot sure what the truth is..... cuz recently i was asked by this person that why do sikhs beleive in him when he was a terrerists etc..........i turn around and say no he wasnt......i get a reply back saying welll if he wasnt then why do some sikhs deny the fact that he did have weapons in harminder sahib? if they know that they were used for whatever purposes then why do sikhs deny this fact......so i didnt have an answer.....? hpe i havent offended anyone......and hpe that the replies will clear my confusion :)t dot jatt · 23 Apr 2006
for sikh's and himself to protect themselves from being massacored from the hindu government if that makes you a terrorist then so be it.singh · 23 Apr 2006
we havent stuffed Harimandir Sahib with weapons now, and as far as I know we`re not getting massacared now. . . . and the guy(t dot jatt) who thinks we should take over Delhi/India and thinks it would be easy is livin in a fantasy worldHyper After Amrit · 23 Apr 2006
DONT FORGET the words of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj: KOI KISI KO RAAJ NAH DEHAIN... JOH LEHAIN NIJ BAL SE LEHAIN! No-one will give anyone raaj..only those who take by force take it.JEEVAN SINGH · 23 Apr 2006
WEAPONS ARE A PART OF LIFE FOR SIKHS !! WE BOW ARE HEADS TO WEAPONS ! [%sig%]singh · 23 Apr 2006
so why didn`t Guru Gobind Singh take over India, or get raj over the world by force???JEEVAN SINGH · 24 Apr 2006
GURU GOBIND SINGH JI SENT BABA BANDA SINGH BAHADUR TO ESTABLISH KHALSA RAJJ IN PANJAB ! SO CALLED ' SINGH ' WHY ARE YOU AGAINST SIKHS HAVING SOVERIGEN INDEPENDENT RULE WHEN GURU GOBIND SINGH JI SAID SELF RULE IS A MUST FOR SIKHS. RAJJ BINA NAHIN DHRAM JALE HAI DHRAM BINA SABE DALE MALE HAI NATIONS CAN NOT SURVIVE WITHOUT SELF RULE, AND RULE HAS ALWAYS BEEN TAKEN BY FORCE. [%sig%]....------.... · 24 Apr 2006
a question just occured to me.... guru ji left us with sikhi right and if khalistan is a MUST for sikhs to survive then why wasnt we left with khalistan...meaning everything wouldve been sooooo much easier and alot of innocent people wouldnt have died if all of this was sorted out at the time of guru ji... ...not trying to cause any debate but seriously looking for an answer???Dogra · 24 Apr 2006
Guru Gobind Singhji sent Baba Banda Singh Bahadhurji to defeat the invaders and give India back to its people. Baba Banda Singh was from Dogra Rajput background. Guruji carried out tremendous self scarifice in his fight agaginst Aurangzeb for all the people like his beloved father before him.Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 24 Apr 2006
VahegurujeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeekeeFateh Bhai Sahib '....------.... ' Jeeo, Khalistan was never left for us; we don't need khalistan to survive, thats being weak saying that. Guru Jee didn't leave us with Khalistan because he wants to test us by making us live around manmukhs, to see if we weaken but if not then the treasure of khalsa raj will be shown to a few in the near future to be established. Khalsa aren't meant to rely on a land, but on Vaheguru Jee through self raj, which is khalsa raj. Sat Sri Akaal VahegurujeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeekeeFAtehJEEVAN SINGH · 24 Apr 2006
'dogra ' india is a word given by the british when they ruled it all together !! india is the name of alot of countries but together by the british, it never used to be like that. [%sig%]PTE SINGH · 25 Apr 2006
The word India comes from Indus, the name of the river that runs through the Indus Valley now in Pakistan. This river was also known as the Sindu. All the people from that civilisation (namely) Punjabi's and Sindi's were known as Sindu's and or Hindu's. The rest of India and the people init were named after that prominent region and those people. In fact the Punjabi and Sindi (Rajasthan in India) people (Aryans) are the actual Hindus, not the darker skinned Dravidens of central and southern India. India was also unified under one kingdom under Ashoka and the Mughal Empire though the British concreted this. Regardless of religion, as a people or race we already have a claim to the nation of India, in fact we created and dominated it. The nation of India is my birthright. So unlike the other Sikh brothers I am not happy to only have a small corner of it and give the rest away just because my religion is different to the majority. If I changed my religion tomorrow would I cease being my fathers son and therefore give up claim to his land and property? would I settle for less than my share? NoBhupinder Singh "daas" · 25 Apr 2006
VaheguruJEeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Banda Singh Bahadar wasn't ever sent to establish khalsa raj but to punish those who killed his sahibzadas. In fact he only symbolised the power Guru Gobind Singh Jee will give to the panj in the future to establish khalsa raj, as similarly punjab will need to be punished whilst protecting innocents. Sat Sri AKaal VaheguruJEeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFatehDhian Dhar · 25 Apr 2006
The true Raj of Khalsa is when we become one with God. Only then we are truly Khalsa and only then we can truly be victorious. All else is just pomp and show. True Khalsa does not desire Raj, but it is bestowed upon him by Guru Ji anyway. Khalsa Raj is very easily gained. The hard part is to become Khalsa.JEEVAN SINGH · 25 Apr 2006
IT WILL BE GREAT TO RULE ALL OVER INDIA SO THAT TRUE BEGUMPURA AND HELMI RAJJ CAN BE ESTABLISHED BUT SIKHS HAVE NEVER RULED ALL OF IT WHICH DOSEN'T MEAN RULE NONE OF IT !! KHALSA RAJJ WAS RULED UP UNTIL DELHI AND SOME TIME OVER DELHI, WE NEED SOME SECURE PLACE WHERE WE CAN LIVE WITH INDEPENDENCE, SELF - DETERMINATION AND SOVERIEGNITY, PANJAB HAS ALWAYS BEEN THAT PLACE. SELF-DETERMINATION AND INDEPENDENCE IS THE BIRTHRIGHT OF ALL NATIONS, SIKHS ARE A NATION. ' DHIAN DHAR ' YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT AN INDIVIDUAL, AN INDIVIDUAL DOES NOT SEEK RAJJ HE/SHE SEEKS GOD !! BUT KHALSA AS A WHOLE NATION SEEKS HELMI BEGUMPURA KHALSA RAJJ. [%sig%]jagtar singh · 25 Apr 2006
well said jeevan singh [%sig%]AB · 25 Apr 2006
well, technically speaking (absolutely objectively), a sikh is the pm of india and another sikh is the chief of army staff so you could say that sikhs rule india ;-)jagtar singh · 26 Apr 2006
well gyani zail singh was the president of india in 1984, he sat back and allowed the attack on darbar sahib, ethnic cleansing of sikhs in panjab and massacre of sikhs in delhi, boota singh was the home minister !! the army chief j j singh states he is an indian first then sikh ! what can you expect of him ! pm manmohan singh had state terrorist jagdesh tytler as his cabinet minister. i think it is very wrong to say sikhs rule india just cus the pm is sikh and thats make everything alwright ! making a sikh pm was never a sikh demand ! how about fullfilling the anandpur sahib resolution [%sig%]singh · 26 Apr 2006
why didnt guru Nanak make a khalistan? why didnt any of the other gurus? to the person who rekons: "GURU GOBIND SINGH JI SENT BABA BANDA SINGH BAHADUR TO ESTABLISH KHALSA RAJJ IN PANJAB !" why did waheguru then sent the British to destroy Khalsa rule in Punjab? do you think Waheguru didnt agree with Guru Gobind Singh ji`s idea?? (a few questions to think about)PTE SINGH · 27 Apr 2006
I'm a Sikh, but i would not want to live in the kind of Khalistan that is being banded about here. Any country built on religion is destined to fail. Secular societies rule the world today and best serve humanity. Humanity comes before religion and only nations built on humanity are true nations. UK 28 [%sig%]A Singh · 27 Apr 2006
Putting aside the various arguments for now - clearly this tread is enough to show why didn't get Khalistan. We have Bibi "Kaur" talking about high ideals of seva and simran, yet shouting it at us through her capitals and then others join her as "Singh" challenges them with his views - shouting about peace! That is quite something - usually something one sees at the Islamic society talks in most university!!! Why are we shouting - because we feel hurt (yet at the same time talk about being 'chardi kala' and 'accepting' hukam?), then we use quotes which are NOT part of Bani to try and support our rationale for Khalistan. I think the answer to the initial question is very easily obtained from reading the above thread and seeing for yourself the reality of those who propose it and why and does who perhaps choose an alternative.Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 27 Apr 2006
VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai SAhib 'PTE SINGH' Jeeo, how do think the future of Khalsa Raj will be built, by Guru Jee's true Khalsa, completely similar to the people from Tapoban Gurdwara in Canada. Through people like that a ground held by Vaheguru Jee will be built where Punjab shall be another smaller version of Saachkhand. You will have to be completely strict in Sikhi to enter Punjab. Not anyone will be allowed. 'Any country built on religion is destined to fail.' How dare you say this!! Religion is what this world was made for, not for sinners, but to practise religion. What do think holds up Saachkhand, Naam does. Naam is the foundation of Sikhi and this is what will built true Khalsa in the future from now. Don't be a Sikh then!! If you don't wish to stand by yourown. Don't worry I know for a fact that you will end up living in the khalsa raj of punjab. Also, do you know what Khalsa Raj means? Having raj over yourself and then it spreads to other Sikhs who then become Khalsa until it becomes a nation of Khalsa, and this is Khalsa Raj. Khalsa Raj will be sustained and leadered by Guru Gobind Singh Jee, the panj piarey. Not through one person but through the panj piarey. The ground will be stabalised due to the essence of Saachkhand being alive there, which again comes back to the fact that true Khalsa will be living there. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeeKeefatehjagtar singh · 27 Apr 2006
pte singh indian political leaders (all of them congress, bjp, rss, vhp, communist, etc ) since the british left have been advocating and implementing one agenda that is HINDU - HINDI - HINDUSTAN do you perfer living in that ? khalsa nation is the most secular of all i think, when ever sikhs have ruled there has never been communal violence or ethnic cleasing of any other religion ! huge mosques that you see in panjab today were built under khalsa rajj for the muslims, and mandirs for hindus. sikhs every day call for SARBAT da bhala not just sikhs ! waheguru is the giver and taker of all, khalsa is wahgurus and waheguru will give khalsa victory !! khalsa rajj will come its all about time ! and in khalsa sikh rajj it has never been said that only sikhs can live in it ! its about bringing independence and freedom for all. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATHE [%sig%]Dogra · 27 Apr 2006
PTE Singh, What u say about the Aryans is untrue. Recent archaelogical evidence in the Indus valley clearly proves an advanced civilisation b4 any Aryans supoosedly came across the very difficult terrain of the Hindu Kush mountains 3500 years ago. Did they come by magic carpet or flying horses??? The indigenous Dravidians Indian people were there in North India, the trickle of Aryans who got through supposedly were minute in numbers in comparison. India is the land from the Khyber pass to the south to Himalayas to Burma. It is every Indians ancestral right to wander this land. The partition was an abomionation against the ancestral: there never was dur ul islam Humanistic: how can u force people from their ancestral homes just because of faith Democratic: there never was one person one vote for partition. Hence the partition is illegal. Never forget the majority of people, regardless of faith lived together peacefully. Maharaja Ranjit Singh was a secular leader who respected all faiths and no faith peoples.if · 27 Apr 2006
khalistan failed because people were fighting out of anger not for sikhism.PTE SINGH · 28 Apr 2006
Bhupinder Singh Daas What will you do to the majority of people who live in Punjab at this time who are not Sikhs in the 'true Tapoban' tradition? At least 40% of the population is Hindu or otherwise and of the remaining 50% how many do you think fit into the Tapoban way of thinking? Are you gonna ban alcohol, meat and all things non Khalsa? Surely a pure Tapoban state cannot exist unless all non-Tapoban people are moved out with force? Jagtar Singh I would have no problem with a Khalsa Raj like the one you describe and existed under Ranjit Singh, however that is not the type of country that people are advocating. The majority of Sikhs, let alone the other Punjabis don’t want it. If we don’t want to live in a Hindustan then why would the Hindu Punjabis, who’s claim to Punjab is equal to ours, want to live in a Khalistan? Dogra The point you make is similar to mine in that a further partition of India is not required. However I did not deny the Dravidans who populated North India were not of an advanced civilisation, did I ? The descendents of the Aryans are still minute compared to the Dravidan population in India, and history throughout the world has shown how trickles of people have gone on to dominate a region. I’m guessing that those Aryans used the same flying carpets as Alexander the Great did a few thousand years latter. However I am happy for you to direct me to the evidence that shows that the Aryans have made little impact on India and that Punjabi’s are indigenous to the plains of India. We live to learn. UK, 28 [%sig%]sarjitsinghkhalsa · 28 Apr 2006
khalistan never fail khalistan coming in 2008 we have lot dhan singhs dogras now dastarihundus so when khalistan comes we will have khalsa fbi to lock them in the prison and make them do the dirty work so keep a note of themsinghnee · 28 Apr 2006
as bhai sahib bhai jeevan singh ji said khalistan mangan walleyoo pela khalsa banoBhupinder Singh "daas" · 29 Apr 2006
VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib 'PTE SINGH' Jeeo, You will see what will happen to those in punjab, but I'm not going to tell you, as its unspeackably horrible and something that you won't be able to understand. Bhai SAhib sarjitsinghkhalsa Jeeo, How do you know about this? Also, if you've had visions of this that means your apart of this establishment of Khalsa Raj in punjab. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeeKeeFatehPAUL · 29 Apr 2006
pte singh why are the hindus of panjab never loyal to panjab ? and who say's only sikhs can live in khalistan ? [%sig%]asdf · 01 May 2006
ok can you prove that hindus of the punjab our never loyal to the sikh's while you have many sikh's who have let down other sikh's and their wwere hindus of punjab who helped protect sikh's from the police of punjab by hiding their sikh neibours and distracting the police now the hindu's of india our the once who hurt the sikh's the hindu's of new dheli hurt the sikh's their the once that massacored the sikh's so whats our beef with hindus of the punjab when it was the hindus of rest of india destroying us, as the punjab suffers and the sikhs in the punjab suffer so do the hindus of the punjab with the sikhs.Dogra · 01 May 2006
PTE SINGH, Alexander came a few 1500 years later, exactly, when technology was more advanced. Punjabis are indigenous, as you know the invaders were minute in comparison, Indus valley civilisation ring any bells? if not then: http://www.archaeologyonline.net/artifacts/aryan-harappan-myth.html http://www.mountainman.com.au/news95_f.htmdevi lal chopra · 01 May 2006
what is an aryan? i am sure i came across that in history search with the nazis. how many indians look like germans? blond hair, blue eyes, tall broad? i have not seen any. so who are these aryans in india? lol, its joke when you see indians calling themselves aryans, like why bumlick ingrezsi? do these beautiful blond looking bjp indian aryans not have an identity of their own to be proud of? british ingrezi ruled over our indian cow plains for 2 centuries stealing your wealth, devaluating india into poverty, and planting its puppets to engineer more poverty. and some of our indian bhai think they blond noble blue blooded aryan? serious inferiority complex issues. anyways khalsa raj will come, all colours will blend one day, free kitchens will be established the world over. khalistan was a reaction, khalsa raj is part of the sikh faith, the first journey is to begin the path of a sikh, take amrit, and walk towards God. Those who do not believe in khalsa raj may hold their breathes during ardas time no problem.123 kid · 09 May 2006
i was wondering why were the hindu's in the punjab being murdered for what the people of new delhi did to the sikh's not the hindu's from the punj123 kid · 13 May 2006
i wouldn't mind fighting for justice in india but wouldn't want to live in a khalistan that is runned like afganistan was by the talibon, i believe killing hindus of the punjab was cowardly considering it was the hindus in new delhi and the polictions who killed inocent sikh's why did we never go after them rather then try pushing everyone out of punjab.