Re: Cinema At Guru Nanak Dev Jee's Asthaan
Kulbir Singh · 17 Dec 2003
Dear "G", I don't want to comment on whether cinema are "Devil" or not. One thing is for sure. Given the spiritual atmosphere of Gurdwara Sahib, it not appropriate to have a cinema next to a historical Gurdwara. How would sangat feel to see huge half-naked posters of girls hanging right across from the Gurdwara Sahib? I personally won't feel great. I am sure there are numerous gursikhs out there whose religious sentiments would be hurt if there was a cinema across from a historical gurdwara sahib.
Re: Cinema At Guru Nanak Dev Jee's Asthaan
warrior*princess · 17 Dec 2003
G jee, why do u argue against everything?
Re: Cinema At Guru Nanak Dev Jee's Asthaan
my thoughts... · 17 Dec 2003
Veer G, it is very good that you like to express your opinions. But you have to be very receptive towards other peoples opinions also. And, if you do disagree with the other person, then there is a always a respectable way to express your feelings. Veeray, no offence to you, but in most of your posts you come off being very rude. I'm not sure if that is your intention, you only know that, but please tone it down a bit. Whatever you say harshly can also be said with pyaar. Take it easy will you. Everyone is here to learn. Even if our opinions differ, we should still be able to sit down together and discuss our differences with pyaar.
Re: Cinema At Guru Nanak Dev Jee's Asthaan
Kulbir Singh · 17 Dec 2003
-----------
well thats your own problem personally I wouldnt care one bit wouldnt effect my sikhi at all... maybe there's a half naked picture up there or not... its your choice to acknolagde it or look at it...
----------
"G", I did not say that everyone's sentiments would be hurt with having a cinema across from a historical gurdwara. There are some highly spiritual gursikhs like you, who stay oblivious of such evils. But please "G" jee, realize that there are many like us, who are weak-minded and would get hurt, offended and perhaps faltered seeing a cinema, a liquor store or a tobacco store across from or adjoining a Gurdwara.
"G" jee, realize that the Sikhs are so conscious about not having such distracting and anti-Gurmat things around our Gurdwaras, that in the early 1980s the Sikhs launched a morcha to have Siri Amritsar Sahib, Siri Anandpur Sahib and Siri Govindwal Sahib declared holy cities. A part of this demand was to move out liquor stores and tobacco stores from the cities.
Now think of this "G" jee. Say this theatre does get built in front of this historical gurdwara sahib. What kind of crowd would be gathering outside the cinema? Imagine youth playing loud music, some youths teasing girls (as it happens commonly in India around theatres), drunks roaming around, smokers smoking right outside the Gurdwara Sahib etc. How would you feel? I am sorry! I just remembered that you are oblivious to such evils. But please be empathetic and think of others like us, whose feelings may get hurt.
Lastly, having a cinema in front of the Gurdwara Sahib is a recipe for future conflicts and fights. Gursikhs will get offended by anti-gurmat activities across from the Gurdwara Sahib and there will be trouble. To avoid all that, this cinema should not go ahead.
In Delhi, a cinema very close to Gurdwara Sis Ganj Sahib, was bought at a astronomical price of 20 crore (200 million ruppees, 7 million dollars). The cinema was not worth 1/10th of the price that was paid but gursikhs paid the price to get the cinema away from the Gurdwara Sahib.
Hopefully, you will understand "G" jee.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Cinema At Guru Nanak Dev Jee's Asthaan
my thoughts... · 18 Dec 2003
Veer 'G', I totally understand what you are trying to say, and I respect your opinions.
It would be very wrong for a Gursikh to intentionally hurt the fellings of a fellow Gursikh's, but if it does happen unintentionally, then the person hurt has every right to question the other Gursikh's stand. If we keep such misunderstandings inside us and let them fester, then we will obviously develop negative feelings towards fellow Gursikhs, which is the worst. Also, we are all brothers and sisters, so if a fellow brother or sister comes up to you and tries to point out a possible weakness or fault in us then we shouldn't be offended by this, but rather be happy that someone else cares about us, and we should be willing to discuss the situation with them.
Also, you mentioned that we should be able to control our thoughts. Veer Kulbir Singh ji has answered this very nicely in his post, but I just wanted to add my two cents. In Japji Sahib, Guru Sahib says , if we can win over our mind, then we can win over this world. Only a few have been able to do that. The only way we can stop nonesense from coming into our head is through doing naam and baani, and sangat of Gursikhs, and also by avoiding things that might lead to bad thoughts such as bad sangat, looking at the opposite gender, going to cinemas, etc. And also, it is our responsibility as Gursikhs to preserve the respect of Guru Sahib, with the kirpa of Guru Sahib. By having a cinema next to a Gurdwara, it would be very disrespectful to Guru Sahib, and we already know what comes part-in-parcel with the presence of a cinema.
You are right that these things cannot be avoided, but in certain cases, such as this, Gursikhs have to take a stand and try to stop it.