Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

marriage and engagement

marriage and engagement

singh · 10 Apr 2006

i would like to hear the sangat's views on the following. if you are engaged to be married and your marriage/engagement is with another gursikh-that your parents chose (with the help of other gursikhs): are you allowed to speak with your betrothed (husband/wife to be)? are you allowed to begin learning about each other? to what extent? PLEASE STAY ON TOPIC

Re: marriage and engagement

seva · 11 Apr 2006

If you are negaged to be married, with your parents consent, then there is no problem in speaking and getting to know each other. After all, you will spend the rest of your life together, it makes sense to get to know each other.

Re: marriage and engagement

singh · 11 Apr 2006

I dont think theres any harm in talking to each other. but the danger is that you might start falling in love with your spouse to be before you are married.

Re: marriage and engagement

... · 11 Apr 2006

I think it might be alright if it's under supervised circumstances. But I know of situations where even amritdhari people who were engaged made big mistakes and couldn't wait and it was all because of too much communication between the two. So I would again suggest supervised interaction and that too at a minimum.

Re: marriage and engagement

singh (original poster) · 11 Apr 2006

"seva" ji, what is wrong with 'falling in love' or realizing that you really do want to be married to the person that you are engaged with? ---------- ". . ." ji, i asked the question b/c i wanted to discuss possible dissents. why must interaction be supervised? its funny, but i have good friends of other faiths who are engaged and they have not 'gone too far' before marriage. in fact they seem to be more in control of thier emotions and actions. why is there a fear in sikhi that people will go to far? are we not teaching sikh youth about the ideals of sikhi? could the problem be that we are not putting enough emphasis on HOW to live (in accordance with bani), but more emphasis one what to do and what not to do? i mean, what you are suggesting is that two grown up (adult by many standards) individuals be 'supervised' in their interaction with one another when they are engaged. what is the fear? what will happen? and will supervision solve this problem? this is something important facing sikh youth so i'd appreciate only serious responses again.

Re: marriage and engagement

???? · 11 Apr 2006

veer singh ji As gursikhs we may have quite a few common grounds, but certain things we choose to look at differently. Your stance on saying if 'adults by many standards should be supervised' or not, would generally be looking at it, as though somebody is degrading you for your abilities. But the question is, how do you look at it from a gurmukh's point of view. Wouldn't the maturity be, to be seen respectfully, also when living a rehitvaan life one does not feel the necessity to indulge themselves in such actions. It seems rather dignified and comfortable to be gathered together amongst other gurmukhs. 'why is there a fear in sikhi that people will go to far? are we not teaching sikh youth about the ideals of sikhi?' 'could the problem be that we are not putting enough emphasis on HOW to live (in accordance with bani), ' Veerji that well could be the case because i myself do know of some gursikhs who are by all other means "Adults", however, when it came to something as such, they didn't realise what a gursikhs actuall maturity should be. According to them it was all hunky dorry because as far as they were concerned they were going to be blessed by maharj through Lavaan. In that case we really need to respect and understand the importance of Lavaan and not choose our own ways.