Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

sanjo · 07 Apr 2006

i have been told shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi, baba jarnail singh bhindranwale's "right hand man" was a nihang and sent by a nihang to do seva for the movement. i have seen pictures of baba jarnail singh ji with a nihang sitting opposite each other talking and i was told that the singh opposite baba ji in a dumala (white dumala i think) is the nihang who sent surinder singh sodhi. i was just wandering who this nihang is? it has been suggested to me that he is baba nihaal singh of harian vela. but i dont know so i just want to clear that up if anyone can help thank you. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

babasingh · 08 Apr 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh That Nihang jathedar is Baba Nihal singh harianvelan wale. Surinder singh sodhi was originaly from Akhand keertani jatha family. After his father's death he used to live with his uncles and then nihang singhs.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

LK · 08 Apr 2006

I'm not sure if he's a nihung, but from what I've read he used to be their assassin, and would punish those they considered guilty (i.e. no innocents) He used to have a walkman whenever he used to go on his scooter since he's rather die listning to Gurbani than anything else =) Was killed by the assassine appointed by Longowal, who was meant to kill BHindranwale, but due to lack of guts they didn't kill him, they killed his right hand man instead.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

Prabhjoyt Singh · 08 Apr 2006

Bhai Surinder Singh Sodhi was not a nihung and the person your are talking about in Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa's picture is nihal singh harianvela wala, he used to be safe with Sant Ji but after the attack on Sri Harmandir Sahib in June 84 he said in an interview "if that Jarnail Singh had left Harmandir Sahib none of this would happened". nihal singh aint all that hes cracked up to be, ive heard peoplee call him a "zinda shaheed" like what the hell??

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

JEEVAN SINGH · 08 Apr 2006

I WOULD LOVE TO KNOW MORE INFO ON SHAHEED BHAI SODHI, IF ANY ONE HAS PICTURES PLEASE POST THEM [%sig%]

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

Singh · 08 Apr 2006

"he used to be safe with Sant Ji but after the attack on Sri Harmandir Sahib in June 84 he said in an interview "if that Jarnail Singh had left Harmandir Sahib none of this would happened". nihal singh aint all that hes cracked up to be, ive heard peoplee call him a "zinda shaheed" like what the hell??" To be fair what he said is true and I think most people know in their hearts that it is true; the army needed a reason to attack Harmandir Sahib and Sant Jarnail Singh was the perfect excuse. Akal Takht would not have been shelled if it was empty. It was shelled because the Singhs were proving difficult to flush out. Furthermore Baba Nihal Singh has done huge Seva for the Kaum. He is a highly Gurmukh Singh. Many people know what he has had to go through and he has no doubt done alot of Kurbani for the Panth.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

ekta · 08 Apr 2006

yup santji was the excuse, cause sant ji was in 36 other gurdwaraye also.. o and during those times the lines between akj ddt or nihungs were'nt as thick ast hey are now... no 1 cared...sant ji worked along with babbars, babbars with nihungs nihungs with sant ji...it was regardless. now we have youth drawing thick boundries.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

JEEVAN SINGH · 08 Apr 2006

whats his kurbani ? [%sig%]

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

sanjo · 09 Apr 2006

"ekta" is correct, back then all they cared about was if u was a khalsa, nowadays people wona know what jatha u belong to, wearing the kakkars isnt enough. even tho we may favour some jatheh for their maryada, i think we shud keep our views to ourselves n accept everyone, jus like baba jarnail singh ji khalsa used to.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

moorakh · 09 Apr 2006

You all need to wash your mouths and eyes before thinking of doing ninda of Jathedar Baba Nihaal Singh jee. Don't do/say such a think you will have to repent for.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

ekta · 09 Apr 2006

honestly babbar khalsa WUZ NOT AN AKJ party it wuz started by AKJ sangatis but alll of the KHALsa were part of it..ddt akj nihung nanaksaari.....rare.......its actually a fact look deep into it and u'll see even the deras that teach bhagti only had membes in it even hindus....

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

Singh · 10 Apr 2006

"yup santji was the excuse, cause sant ji was in 36 other gurdwaraye also.." Some of these Gurdware may have had followers of Sant Ji in them, I am not sure. Regardless, even if they didn't, there is no way the army could have justified shelling Akal Takht if it was empty, as I previously said. Read my post again. How could the army justify taking tanks into Harmandir Sahib today tomorrow if there was no one occupying it?

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

okay · 10 Apr 2006

I don't know about Sodhi coming from an AKJ family or not but I know that he was with Baba Nihaal Singh as a younger Singh and Sant Ji came and chose Sodhi to join the morcha as Sant Ji saw something special in Surinder Singh Sodhi. I think this was when Surinder Singh was still young... So Surinder Singh's roots are from a nihang jathebandi, if people are going to break it up like that He was a very talented kharkhoo singh who was extremely dedicated to bhagti. His shaheedi happened at a very young age

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

LK · 10 Apr 2006

Author: Singh Date: 04-08-06 14:14 "he used to be safe with Sant Ji but after the attack on Sri Harmandir Sahib in June 84 he said in an interview "if that Jarnail Singh had left Harmandir Sahib none of this would happened". nihal singh aint all that hes cracked up to be, ive heard peoplee call him a "zinda shaheed" like what the hell??" To be fair what he said is true and I think most people know in their hearts that it is true; the army needed a reason to attack Harmandir Sahib and Sant Jarnail Singh was the perfect excuse. Akal Takht would not have been shelled if it was empty. It was shelled because the Singhs were proving difficult to flush out. ************************ Singh, I will be quoting from a post I made earlier on another forum- //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// Actually that is not true. Sangat Singh (alternative member of joint intelligence agency) writes that around the Asian games (around Oct-Nov 1982), his talks with Lt Gen S.K Sinha said that he had been told by Indira Gandhi to prepare a report on the history of the Darbar Sahib. And so he did. He prepared a 22-page report on the history of the Golden Temple and discouraged an attack to be launched. S.k Sinha was the vice army chief, and was 'degraded' for refusing to participate in the attack. In an article Sinha went to the extent of saying 'Sant Bindranwale did nothing wrong in preparing'. Let's quote - ------------- S.K. Sinha, a General in the Indian Army, who was contacted to conduct theattack but declined, is quoted as say the following on July 16 1984: “The Army action was not the ‘last resort’ as Prime Minister Indira Gandhi would have us believe, decided upon toward May-end (1984). It had been in her mind for more than 18 months.” Said the General that when he was GOC-in-C ofwestern Command, he got a call around 10 p.m. from ‘someone in Delhi’ that adecision had been taken at the highest level that the Army should undertake thearrest of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. Nothing was heard after the General told the caller that in matters like this he would like to hear from either the Chief of Army Staff or the Defense Minister. This was towards 1981 end when Darbar Singh was Chief Minister i.e. nearly 30 months before the Army actually struck at Amritsar.--- This was long before the Akalis launched their morcha in August 1982. Shortly after the morcha, the Army began rehearsals of a commando raid near Chakrata Cantonment in the Doon Valley, where a complete replica of theGolden Temple complex had been built. “Another training involving AviationResearch Centre Commandos, was given in the Sarsawa area and Yamuna bed in helicopters converted into gunships. This plan, earmarked for implementation first in August last year (1983) and then in April this (1984) year, was given up as it had leaked out to the Sikh militants.” “In view of these military preparations, ifSant Bhindrawale and his men decided to defend the Golden Temple with all their might and means, no one can, and should, blame them.” “you are duty-bound to do your all when you know someone is going to raid your house. In this case, the house was the holiest Sikh Shrine in the world.” “All you have to do isto match the adversary’s weapons with your own weapons of equal, if not more, fire power. This is an acknowledged rule of combat.” “Mrs. Gandhi contends that arms were being collected by Sant Bhindranwale for the last one year. But this was much after she herself had drawn up plans for Army action against theGolden Temple and other gurdwaras. In December, last year (1983) two trenches were dug by Sant’s men in front of Teja Singh Samundari Hall within the holy complex but he was persuaded to fill them up. This proves that till then noresponsible Akali leader was prepared for an armed showdown with the Government."2 S.K. Sinha, ”Sant Bhindrawale did not nothing wrong by defending the Golden Temple.” Spokesman June June 2001:28-29 ------------------- http://64.233.179.104/search?q=cache:ZaFgA...se&ct=clnk&cd=2 2- Now the crucial question arises, would the Government have prepared such a massive army operation if there were no Singh occupying it ? The Fact that Sangat Singh, an alternative intelligence agent spoke to the army General S.K Sinha, who reported that the operation was being prepared 18 months before totally refutes your point. Let's choose to not believe what Sinha says. Let's ask Tully. Tully gives evidence for the attack beign prepared 9 months before the trauma. Mary Anne Weaver of the Sunday Time concurs (I can give u dates and pages if you want). 9 Months before means, around september-october. Another Army general (I believe Dyal, or Sunderjee, I can confirm if you request)) reports that they were told to prepare the attack Jan 25th (it was definetly January) 1984. The fortification of the complex started in Febuary (Lt. Gen Aurora of the Bangladesh war). That completly shatters the theory that it was due to militants inside the temple, who although were in the complex since around November 83 (I believe), fortification didn't begin before febuary. It is clear that the Army operation was being planned, if not prepared, a long time before the attack. Bhull Chukk Maaf //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// It was only an excuse, fact is that they had started planning (if not preparing) long before they moved in. ************ Furthermore Baba Nihal Singh has done huge Seva for the Kaum. He is a highly Gurmukh Singh. Many people know what he has had to go through and he has no doubt done alot of Kurbani for the Panth. ************* Having had met Baba Nihak Singh personally about two years ago, I wasn't too impressed by his behaviour (not as in manners, but in terms of how much of a Sikh he acted like) I don't have much to add about him, however I personally lost all my respect for him that day. Regards

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

Go Babbars!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! · 10 Apr 2006

never heard of any rare or nanaksaryiyeh Babbars. As far as i know none of these deray wale took part in the movement, instead they were on the government side and against the Singhs fighting for the liberation of the Khalsa Panth And yes Shaheed Bhai Surinder Singh Sodhi is from AKJ family as i have meet them and they also tell of this

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

a nobody · 10 Apr 2006

If I'm not mistaken, BK was started in Canada by Shaheed Jathedar Talwinder Singh Babbar and a group of Singhs from BC in 1978. Vadawa Singh, Tarsem Singh, Resham Singh etc. were not involved in Babbar Khalsa until Talwinder Singh's visit to India in 1980. Sukhdev Singh was not involved in Babbar Khalsa until almost 1 year later. The original founders of Babbar Khalsa were not AKJ or from any other Jathebandi, just Singhs with a mission in mind.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

Niranjan Singh · 10 Apr 2006

Picture of Sodhi's family Above is a picture of Sodhi's sister and her children, the photo above Sodhi is his brother-in-law who passed away several year ago. He was also from AKJ. Sodhi's mother and father were both from the Jatha, along with his sister and her entire family. In fact, Jathedar Bhai Surat Singh "Puran Ji" knew Sodhi when he was very small. Sodhi also lived at Harian Velan Tarna Dal.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

dsfgdfgsd · 10 Apr 2006

he had nihang roots that's it

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

seva · 11 Apr 2006

Dear "ekta" BKI was always an AKJ thing. That is why they were such a strong unit and are the only operationally active group today. Definatwly no rara dera lot in there. None of these dera lot ever did anything during the 80`s.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

JEEVAN SINGH · 11 Apr 2006

any more pictures and info on bhai sodhi ji ? [%sig%]

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

jhamka · 11 Apr 2006

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh just a side note i know off 2 singhs from rara sahib that the police killed in fake encounters, plus Baba Charan Singh Kar Sevawale and six sevadars were killed by the police, baba ji was torn in two by two jeeps.Vaheguru. lets not pick on jathas nearly every jatha took a hit in the 80s-90's par naam shaheedia noo

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

JEEVAN SINGH · 12 Apr 2006

sant bhindrawale said when sodhi became a shaheed ' i wish my right arm be cut off, but sodhi not killed ' . [%sig%]

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

Joka · 12 Apr 2006

BK is not an AKJ thing just like BTF and KCF are not Taksal units, they involved singhs from all the different jathe! Try speaking to some of the older singhs who were around then and not just live in some weird dream jatha lands!! N does it matter where a Singh came from! lol cant believe people are soooo obbssessed with "this singh was from here or there!! oooooo well done extra points for jatha xyz cus this shaheed singh came from there!! its 28-29 now!!!" hardly anybody mentions on jeevani, just he was akj, he was from nihangs, he was from taksal, id say he was from the fauj of guru ji!

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

.... · 12 Apr 2006

sant bhindrawale said when sodhi became a shaheed ' i wish my right arm be cut off, but sodhi not killed ' . this is same as 10th master who sacrifice entire family for kaum.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

singhji · 14 Apr 2006

I remember hearing Sant ji speech in which he talks about sodhis shaheedi, and how akali dal had him killed. I could be wrong but that is what i remember. I remember him saying "Sada Sodhi Kyo marya" in an almost sad voice. And than asks what pop did he do to deserve death. Any information on this shaheedi would be greatly appreciated.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

LK · 14 Apr 2006

'singhji' you are right. They employed these killers to kill Bhindranwale, but do to lack of guts.. they didn't shoot him, but the Singh sitting beside him.. which happened to be his right hand man ..

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

... · 14 Apr 2006

Gurcharan Sinh of the SGPC (not Tohra, another one) had Sodhi killed. Sodhi was killed while sitting in a tea stall waiting for someone. Sant Jarnail Singh was not anywhere near him or "beside him".

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

JEEVAN SINGH · 14 Apr 2006

the g.o.i considered sodhi as a major major threat ! he was sant jis main advisor [%sig%]

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

JEEVAN SINGH · 14 Apr 2006

i heard the murderers were captured and chopped into pieces and scattered on to the g.t road ! [%sig%]

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

... · 14 Apr 2006

The woman who lured Sodhi there was caught, killed and chopped into pieces. A sack with her remains was found. I'm not sure that was a very good thing to do, but that's the history.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

LK · 15 Apr 2006

Author: ... Date: 04-14-06 14:38 Gurcharan Sinh of the SGPC (not Tohra, another one) had Sodhi killed. Sodhi was killed while sitting in a tea stall waiting for someone. Sant Jarnail Singh was not anywhere near him or "beside him". ---------- That's what A.R Darshi wrote.. I agree, hacking her into pieces wasn't the most Sikh thing one can do. Definetly doesn't reflect the nature of a Sikh. Beant Singh Satwans Singh could have used an axe til chop Indira with..lol... they chose to shoot her... That is one of the things that make me get a bit suspicious on the 'Singhs'. No matter how much bad she did, there is absolutly no justificcation of chopping someone. At first I thought it was a thing the government spread to malign the Siks, but later when I asked Darshi, he too confirmed that she was chopped into peaces. Disgusts me. Awefully. Where did you read about the chopping '...' veer/bhen jeeyo?

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

..... · 15 Apr 2006

death is death it dont matter whether it is chopping sum1 to pieces or shooting them ...

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

LK · 16 Apr 2006

'.....', So you seriously think it's better to chop someone and torture them to death than to shoot their head off? Go to India and ask someone who's been tortured and as thme whether they wanted to live thorugh the torture or woudl rather die quickly? If they did it, what they did was wrong.

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

singh · 25 Apr 2006

Surinder singh sodhi wasnt shot or it wasnt an attempt to kill bhindranwale, a singhni that sodhi really trustd and was a good family friend called him and said goi or cops were harrasing her and she needed help(she needed help with something, i think tahts wat it was) and he agreed to meet her in private to talk about it, because he couldnt go out in public because he was wanted, so the bibi met him and she gave him chai with sumthin in it and he passed out and she handed him over the goi and got mnoey for it....too many traders in our panth

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

... · 25 Apr 2006

singh, that is not the story at all. If you really want to get into the nitty gritty, the girl lured Sodhi to a tea stall and said she wanted to talk about her boyfriend who was beating her and mistreating her. At the tea stall, her boyfriend came and shot Sodhi. There was no poison involved and the Government of India had no direct role (if any at all).

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

singh · 25 Apr 2006

yaim pretty sure she poisned him and handed him over for money, ive heard this version from people who actually knew sant ji and were a part of the morcha and knew sodhi

Re: shaheed bhai surinder singh sodhi

sanjo · 26 Apr 2006

i thought bhai sahib was killed in a hotel room?