Protest Against Chatter Singh & Jeevan Singh Publishers
Panthic News Service · 05 Apr 2006
Protest Against CSJS Publishers, Disrespect of Gurbani
Sunday 2nd of April 2006
Panthic Weekly News Bureau
Amritsar Sahib, Punjab (KP) - A protest was held by Sikh youths from various Sikh organizations in Amritsar, Punjab. The protest was held against Chattar Singh Jeevan Singh Publishers due to the publisher violating an order from Sri Akal Takhat Sahib, which strictly prohibits them from printing or selling Saroops of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
The protest was held under the leadership of Advocate Jaswinder Singh Khalsa (member of Shiromani Committee), Jathedar Dilbag Singh (head of Mission Council International), Surjeet Singh, Parnam Singh (Akhand Kirtani Jatha), Surinder Singh Ramta (head of Suchayth Khalsa) and Rajinder Singh Purewal (General Secretary of Singh Sabha Gurdwara Derby U.K).
Though the police force had virtually created a wall around the store of the publisher, the Sikh youth carried on with their peaceful protest shouting slogans in full force. The protesters exclaimed that if the publisher Chattar Singh Jeevan Singh, who is still carrying on with these acts even after a ban imposed by Sri Akal Takhat Sahib, did not cease to sell and publish saroops of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, they would have to face strict action.
During the protest, a memorandum was sent by the protesting party to the secretariat of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib and the Deputy Commissioner. In the memorandum, the protesters demanded that legal action should be taking against the publisher Chattar Singh Jeevan Singh who hs been disrespecting the saroops of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. A portion of the memorandum was also directed toward the Jathedar of Siri Akal Takhat Sahib Joginder Singh Vedanti, in which it stated, “The Khalsa Mission Council along with all Panthic organizations will launch a struggle against this new massand [publisher]. This struggle will continue until these massands desist from their wrong deeds. We have come to give you [ addressing Akal Takhat Jathedar] this memorandum so that you may take strict action against them. We appeal to you that keeping in mind the feelings of the Panth, this newly emerged masand, the owner of Chatter Singh Jeevan Singh and Sons should be expelled from the Panth as he has defied the order of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib three times while continually challenging Sri Akal Takhat Sahib Ji and the Guru Panth.”
It should be noted that even after the ban on selling and printing saroops of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was put into effect, this publisher has been defying that ban. Interestingly, it has been reported that the publisher has been carrying on with their defiance of the ban with the support of none other than Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti and his personal supporters. This accusation has not only been stated by the general public put also by Jagdev Singh Talwandi, the former president of Shiromani Committee, who also made this accusation during his tenure as president.
The publisher's store subject to this controversy is very close to Sri Darbar Sahib. The signboard on this store can clearly be read from the parkarma of Sri Darbar Sahib. The sign reads, “The saroops of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji can be purchased here.”
Re: Protest Against Chatter Singh & Jeevan Singh Publishers
Quantam physics · 05 Apr 2006
I have in the past ordered books from chatttar singh jeevan singh , and have been offered Guru Granth sahib saroops to purchase that they had published, when I enquired as to how they would get the saroop to Uk for me Sumeet singh one of the managers said they would post it with the other books I ordered and it would arrive after 3 months by ship, I was amazed I couldn't believe that he was saying he would send Guru ji's saroop by ship as a parcel for 3 months. Since then I have boycotted there business , they also own CJ International Hotel which overlooks Darbar sahib
Re: Protest Against Chatter Singh & Jeevan Singh Publishers
kulpreetsingh · 06 Apr 2006
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!!
the owner of the chattar singh jeevan singh store beside singh brothers in front of the sri akaal takhat sahib enterance is a very superficial character. he tries to butter up people to make them purchase more things from his store. his son has a trimmed beard and an arrogant attitude. he was eating chips and without washing his hands he went to show me books about sikhism. i feel very ashamed to admit i didn't correct him at the time. i know i will suffer bad karma for my negligence. i really felt anger towards him and i tried to get out of their quickly and not purchase anything from their store. strangely they have a sink for all customers to wash their hands as they enter, and you are required to remove your shoes. this is good, but the owners may not follow it. the owners, clearly from the story above, have only concern in making money from guru granth sahib ji, not showing respect to guru granth sahib ji.
the other chattar singh jeevan singh store near gurdwara sahib sees ganj in delhi is a small closet type of room in a small alley. the amrit keertan pothi was on the floor. i placed it on a shelf but my heart was sinking looking at the state of the store and the disrespect to gurbani. they had pothis in a top shelf that may have been sitting there for how many months, i don't know. i couldn't bare to see it all with my eyes.
the stalls outside of gurdwara bangla sahib have no rumalas to cover gutka sahibs. all gutka sahibs are placed out in the open for anybody to touch. they are not covered or respected. all of these stalls have patkas that look like caps. they have patkas with various designs, i.e. american flag, colourful, etc. all of these stalls also have "miniature (wannabe) kakaars on a string" and other pendants.
at the store adjacent to gurdwara sahib sees ganj, there are two women working there - one is the mother and the other is her daughter. they wear earrings and jewellery but they are amritdhari. they took out a box of gutkas to show to one woman, and emptied the box ONTO THE FLOOR. my stomach got into a knot, my blood pressure went up and my face turned red. i told the woman, "aunty ji those are gutka sahibs please put them on the shelf right now. why did you leave them on the floor." she responded, "i was just showing this lady the gutkas, sorry."
outside of harimandir sahib in front of the baba sri chand mandir there are people lined up along a brick wall every few metres. they have all their products laid out and they are selling them. most of them have different types of food packages. commonly you get those type of food (dry rice, sweets) as parshaad in the gurdwara. these stall owners try to sell it as PARSHAAD as well even though they might smoke, they might drink, and the parshaad has not had bhog of guru sahib done. they tell you to come and buy PARSHAAD from them but it is just snack food, not guru ji's degh.
my grandmother's purse got stolen INSIDE OF HARIMANDIR SAHIB. we made a report about this to head granth of darbar sahib, gyani gurbachan singh ji. he was shocked. he requested us to write full explanations and letters to joginder singh vedanti and sgpc members, and he said he would do whatever he could to start an inquiry about how such a thing could happen. the purse was most likely stolen by an indian person who didn't know what canadian passports are. they left the canadian currency and canadian passports and identification in the purse. they took all of the rupees.
a sevadaar at guru arjan dev nivas tried to get me to pay him back for his kindness in letting me make soup for my sister who had just got out of the hospital. i was making soup for her and he offered to help us out in any way. later his real intentions became known when he said, if i had known your number in canada i could have asked you to bring me a watch from there. i don't have a watch, see? he showed his wrist. my grandmother gave him a watch later that day.
the sevadaars at guru arjan dev nivas do not let any foreigners stay there. they try to scare them off by showing them substandard rooms with indian washrooms. when we drove from jalandhar to punjab we had a driver who spent a lot of years in amritsar. he told us the guru arjan dev nivas and other nivas sevadaars are paid by hotels to discourage westerners from staying in the nivas and encourage them to stay in hotels.
when we went to gurdwara sahib "shaheedaa" - the place where jathedar nihang baba deep singh jee amar khalsa shaheed's antam sanskaar was done and from where he threw his sees towards harimandir sahib. at that gurdwara, as i posted before on this forum, people put their hands towards a oil lamp and put their hands to their forehead seeking blessings from the "jyot."
the stores that are located as you walk outside of harimandir sahib, they are part of the white buildings that surround harimandir sahib. they are inside the gates of harimandir sahib so they are part of the external complex. there is a store that sells DVDs of bollywood movies. thinking of how many disgusting scenes and bad words that those movies have, these tapes, CD's, and DVDs are being sold in a store that is PART OF THE HARIMANDIR SAHIB COMPLEX.
i can go on but it is so exhausting to even think of these horrible situations.
i could not tolerate going to sikh stores in india. it was a painful experience. there is very very less satkar of gurbani at sikh stores in india. sometimes i wanted to cry.
there were only a few good sikh stores that showed respect for gurbani, like the damdami taksal store near harimandir sahib, and a few other stores. they were very careful and very respectful.
otherwise, most of the stores are causing extreme disrespect to guru granth sahib, and guru khalsa panth. they are neglecting gurbani, gutkas, etc. and they are doing parchar of manmat like patkas, fashions, kakaar necklaces. they are commercializing the gurdwara, and corrupting the guest houses. indians are committing so much beadbi of guru maharaaj and we aren't doing anything about it.
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaaheguroojeekeefathehhhh !!!!!!!!
Re: Protest Against Chatter Singh & Jeevan Singh Publishers
Jagdev Singh Rai · 06 Apr 2006
Is this the first time anyone has ever protested? Oh well better late than never!!! Are they the only printers who are doing this?
Re: Protest Against Chatter Singh & Jeevan Singh Publishers
kulpreetsingh · 06 Apr 2006
vaaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!!
I would also like to add that I have seen with my own eyes people packing books outside of the Chattar Singh Jeevan Singh store.
They were packing boxes on the dirty street outside the store, with no satkaar, and there could be any gurbani in those boxes - there could be amrit keertans, gutkas, etc.
The people packaging them were generally hired labour (non-sikh and non-interested).
This is not a generalization because I have observed their attitude towards gutkas and pothis - they don't CARE about gurbani.
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!!!
Re: Protest Against Chatter Singh & Jeevan Singh Publishers
Rashminder Singh oz · 07 Apr 2006
Sting operation puts SGPC in piquant situation
Violation of hukamnama by private publisher
Varinder Walia
Tribune News Service
Amritsar, April 6
The sting operation, exposing violation of the ‘hukamnama’ (edict), pronounced by the Sikh clergy in 1998 by the private publishers has put Akal Takht and the SGPC in a piquant situation because both the institutions have failed to implement the edict in the past eight years.
A video recording has shown blatant violation of the edict by a publisher near Harmander Sahib complex.
The ‘Hukamnama’, pronounced by the then Jathedar Akal Takht, Bhai Ranjit Singh, on April 9, 1998 while banning publication of the Holy Guru Granth Sahib, had directed that only the SGPC would be responsible for its publication. However, the sting operation showed that in gross violation of the edict, a private publisher was ‘selling’ Guru Granth Sahib to a Muslim for placing it in a ‘mazar’ (tomb).
However, the Akhand Kirtani Jatha and representatives of various Sikh organisations have given a list of 60 private publishers, most of them in Amritsar who were openly publishing and selling Guru Granth Sahib in violation of the Hukamnama.
Representatives of Sikh organisations have threatened to gherao the private publisher on April 6. They have also threatened to take direct action against the SGPC and Akal Takht secretariat for having failed to implement the Hukamnama.
However, Mr Harbhajan Singh of ‘Bhai Chattar Singh - Jeewan Singh’ publication house, claimed that they had not indulged in violation of the edict. He, however, said that he was ready to appear before Akal Takht to submit his clarification in this regard. He said his firm had been printing Guru Granth Sahib much before the inception of the SGPC. Some resolutions of the SGPC had approved the publication of Guru Granth Sahib by this firm, he claimed.
Mr Harbhajan Singh alleged that some rival publishers who themselves were printing the Birs of Guru Granth Sahib singled out his firm due to ‘professional jealousy’.
Meanwhile, the SGPC has reportedly sought 15 days to implement the edict . However, sources said that the SGPC is unable to meet the demand for the Holy Guru Granth Sahib all over the world due to its limited sources.
The Sikh representatives alleged that the edict was being violated in connivance with the SGPC and Akal Takht.
On the other hand, the private publisher has lodged a written complaint with the DIG and district police chief against representatives of various Sikh organisations. The publisher alleged that he had been receiving threats to his life.
The SGPC, on the other hand, has threatened to organise a march from Bathinda to Damdama Sahib in protest against registration of criminal case against Giani Balwant Singh Nandgarh, Jathedar Takht Damdama Sahib and other Sikh leaders who took away Guru Granth Sahib from a ‘mazar’ at Balluna village in the wake of the edict, issued from Akal Takht.
Sikh circles are questioning the role of the SGPC and Akal Takht in resorting to direct action at Balluana while they had failed to implement the edict in Amritsar.
[%sig%]
Re: Protest Against Chatter Singh & Jeevan Singh Publishers
Jagdev Singh Rai · 07 Apr 2006
Looks like Punjab is begining to wake up! About time.....