Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What am I to make of Sikh history books?

What am I to make of Sikh history books?

Geezer · 28 Mar 2006

Can someone give me some advice. I enjoy reading and am interested in my Sikh roots although I am far from perfect. I have been reading of late to help me gain a better understanding of Sikhism, Sikh history and Panjabi culture in general. I believe in a general level of free speech (not open disrepect though), but I'm finding some of the books contradicting what I was taught about Sikhism and History from my family. I purchased a book by MCleod about the rehat and was really shocked by what it contained especially about the 5 Ks. The issue of vegetarianism is another confusing issue. And I was shocked to hear that some Nihung Singhs have taken opium and marijuana (even my parents confirmed this!) What am I supposed to make of these things? I also listen to dhadhi and katha which helps restore balance. What do you all think of modern scholarship? On the one hand it seems good and on another......not good.....I don't really want to hide myself from anything that is true, even if it is uncomfortable but .......

Re: What am I to make of Sikh history books?

fresno sikh · 28 Mar 2006

wjkk wjkf Just like any other sikh growing up with lot of confusion like Radhaswami relative all around me hindus with their own imposing ideas. It was tough to filter out information about life and sikhism in general. After some time of listening to regular kirtan, sakhis from preacher and going to gurudwara every sunday didn't seem enough. One day I bought a book call Bandgi Naama. I dont like reading books in general. I read the book in 3 days. Every time I put the book down it seem like I wanted to read more. After that things made more sense. After that Some other books I read were of sants Like sant Attar Singh Mastuane wale, Sant Harnam Singh Buchoe kala, Sant Nand Singh Nanaksar Wale, Sant Gurbachan Singh Taksal Wale , sant Harnam Singh Rampur Khera wale and few more. Listened to the kirtan and katha of sant Isher singh Rare wale. Life made perfect sense. Felt estatic to be born in a sikh family loved life as an oppurtuinty to do sewa, read bani and naam jaap. Thanks [%sig%]

Re: What am I to make of Sikh history books?

kookar · 28 Mar 2006

daas would like to do a humble benti and say that you should take a look at katha by giani thakur singh...for this moorkah he places history and gurbani to a very accurate degree..the rehit that he explains in his katha is that of practical in a sense that he has practiced it his self and then telling others do to so..this all leads to one making it to the dasam dwaar and obtains vahegurus darshan. daas believes books are written from more of a western approach where things are chopped and changed to suit the writer. Maybe when we are blessed with antharjamtha we can see for our selves what it was really like.

Re: What am I to make of Sikh history books?

Singh · 28 Mar 2006

"I purchased a book by MCleod about the rehat" Probably the worst book you could have chosen. Note that most the sources he quotes where questionable material comes up is in the late 18th century and 19th century when there was a most definate Hindu influence in Sikhism. Just compare the "oldest" Rehatnameh in the book like Tanakhahnama and Sakhi Rehat Ki (where you will find nearly no questionable material) to later Rehatnameh where there has been plenty of Brahmin influence, and there is plenty of questionable things. And I wouldn't say McLeod's refutation of Bhatt Vehis was particularly strong either. McLeod's book is not really a good history book but an extremely scholarly and alternative view of historical sources. Perhaps you should study books such as History of the Sikhs by Sangat Singh if you want a good, well referenced and well studied view of Sikh History. Books such as McLeod's are purposefully written to cause controversy (personally for me it was a highly interesting read but it most certainly didn't change my views on Rehat substantially at all)

Re: What am I to make of Sikh history books?

singh · 28 Mar 2006

I don't think Mcleod is the man you should read, he had deliberately crooked some facts out of revenge against singhs when he was refused to read a saroop of guru granth sahib jee when singhs saw him he lighted smoking...he was sponsored by Indian govt and did write to give a bad impression of sikhism. Mcauliffe is much better writer than Mcleod. recently there was thread on this forum 'Library books on Sikhism' something like that...and sangat have given a quite a long list on books on sikhism [%sig%]

Re: What am I to make of Sikh history books?

aman · 28 Mar 2006

I think , purathan Singhs were very good Singhs.Although Macleod wrote a lot of stuff about sikhism and Guru Granth Sahib. Story goes as Golden Temple Granthis at that time gave permission to Macleod for the translation of Guru Granth Sahib In english.But what he did was he lit his cigarrete and started smoking infront of Guru Granth SAhib while translation.THE singhs after confirming this , threw him out of the Golden TEmple.Afterwards he was finally able to receive a copy of Guru Granth Sahib by the help of Arya Samaji Lala Lajpat Rai.It was seen that he changed some of the things about the sikh history according to his own mind. Don't think that Macleod was superior to 10 Gurus OR Guru Nanak DEvji who created the sikh religion. The answer to your second question is regarding the consumption of Bhang and opium sort of things.THe obvious reason for this is at that time sikhs had to fight lot of enemies.Even 5 sikhs against the enemy of lakhs.I think then to get rid of pain and heavy wounds and serious injuries these things were given.i think the custom started then and we don't know the ayurvedic Vaids (doctors ) of that time might be using these things as Herbs to treat people.It gives a sense of cure or healing.No matter to this day , doctors while performing major surgeries give codiene, heroin or opium to the people so that they should not stress themselves and get rid of pain.I think those were the pain killers known at that time and widely used. Regarding vegetarian issue, none of the Gurus or the Sants or Brahamgyanis ate meat.That solves this problem. There was a time period where Khalsa Sikhs used to live in Jungles and when they were surrounded with enemies for months and a year , no food to eat . They ate tree leaves to survive themselves.I think might be after so many struggles when they never found vegetarian food , then they went for non-veg.THat too Jatka.Killing the animal at an instant , so that he should not get the feeling of being hurt.

Re: What am I to make of Sikh history books?

LK · 29 Mar 2006

I agree. The first wrong step you took was buying a book by Mcleod (one of the most critisized books on Sikhi, by Sikhs) Second mistake was that you bought a book with Rehtinamas, which includes alot of dodgy stuff. I knwo of several other Singhs who went 'unbalanced' after reading his books, and had to do a lot of Seva/Simran to get back on track. I personally try to stay away from his books and his opinions, and only stay to the translations he has on the Rehitnamas, and that too with 10 eyes open. ------- Author: singh Date: 03-28-06 13:05 I don't think Mcleod is the man you should read, he had deliberately crooked some facts out of revenge against singhs when he was refused to read a saroop of guru granth sahib jee when singhs saw him he lighted smoking...he was sponsored by Indian govt and did write to give a bad impression of sikhism. Mcauliffe is much better writer than Mcleod. recently there was thread on this forum 'Library books on Sikhism' something like that...and sangat have given a quite a long list on books on sikhism -------- I think , purathan Singhs were very good Singhs.Although Macleod wrote a lot of stuff about sikhism and Guru Granth Sahib. Story goes as Golden Temple Granthis at that time gave permission to Macleod for the translation of Guru Granth Sahib In english.But what he did was he lit his cigarrete and started smoking infront of Guru Granth SAhib while translation.THE singhs after confirming this , threw him out of the Golden TEmple.Afterwards he was finally able to receive a copy of Guru Granth Sahib by the help of Arya Samaji Lala Lajpat Rai.It was seen that he changed some of the things about the sikh history according to his own mind. Don't think that Macleod was superior to 10 Gurus OR Guru Nanak DEvji who created the sikh religion. --------- Actually if I'm not mistaken, Mcleod is still alive. The story of smoking infront of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, and being appointed to translate Guru Granth Sahib Ji, being thrown out,m and taking help from Pandits was actually Ernst Trumpp [A Christian Missionary, knowing some Sanskrit, with a big fat ego]. He was refused help from Singhs due to his own hankar and thinking that Singhs don't know anything, and was thrown out due to smoking. He was not appointed by Government of India, but the British, to translate Guru Sahib, since they wanted to learn about this 'warrior people'. His translation is not complete (only about a third) and his preface has very bad things written about Guru Ji and Sikhs (if requested I can upload some pics I took from his translation). Also, one of the reasons Ernest didn't work seriously (though he is 'mubarak' for doing the First English translation (rejected by Sikhs at the time), is because he saw Sikhs as a passing phase in history, that would soon be extinct, and hence there wasn't any point in doing a very thorough work. This was Earnt Trumpp, nor Mc leod. They are however both, in the same catagory, as (very bias) western scholars, with no clue what they're talking about. For more on Mcleod and Ernest Trump, please read this by Bhai Trlochan Singh - http://www.globalsikhstudies.net/issues/HISTORY.htm http://www.sikhspectrum.com/022004/ish_mcleod.htm http://www.globalsikhstudies.net/pdf/Re_Research_in_Sikhism.pdf Again, I recommend you put the book on your shelf and let is dust there for the rest of your life (or better yet, recycle the paper) and buy a proper book on Sikhism, Such as 'The Sikhs in History' -Sangat Singh 'The Sikhs' Patwant Singh, 'Sikhs and Sikhism' I.J Singh, The book on Sikhism by W. Owen Cole (not 100% on the order of the name, lol) Bhull chukk maaf [%sig%]

Re: What am I to make of Sikh history books?

Singh · 29 Mar 2006

read the books of Bhai Randhir Singh, Bhai Vir Singh, Prof Puran Singh and Bhai Trilochan Singh. These were all written by very chardi kala Gursikhs. They will teach you alot more about Gursikhi.

Re: What am I to make of Sikh history books?

sanjo · 29 Mar 2006

i thfound bandgi nama very usefull, though if you are just introducing yourself with sikhism it may be better to read books on the gurus lives etc first. get a basic picture of what sikhism is all about, then proceed on to the "heavy" stuff. it is a hard book to grasp, i certainly wouldn't have understood some concepts in bandgi nama if i hadnt read other books. i didnt even relaise the importance of simran till about 3 months ago!!! great book though,