Re: what is sikhi coming too...
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 13 Dec 2003
aaaaaahhhhh tha's grosse man
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
Jagroop Singh · 14 Dec 2003
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
Do the Seva of these people in a humble a good-willed manner.
Find out who she is, talk to her and in a TRULY Guru-inspired Loving manner, point out the implications of her actions...ask her how she feels and why she is acting like this...is her home life ok...was she forced to wear The Keski...maybe there's lots of issues below the surface.
If she carries on with her actions even after this, make contact with the Gursikh Sangat close to her...who should also make these attempts with Love...
And most of all, do Ardaases for her...ask Guru Sahib to guide His lost sheep...Guru Sahib always listens to His Gursikhs.
If she still doesn't refrain, and her Ahankaar and Kaam have got the better of her and are leading her evermore onwards, ask her politely to remove Guru's Sahib's Crown and then socially boycott her...it seems that Guru Sahib does not wish her to be in his Roop - Vahiguru's Bhana.
Bhul chuk maaf karna.
What do the GurSikhs think:
Is such an approach Gurmat or not?
Should less/more be done in such a situation?
What does Guru Sahib sanction in such a situation?
Can we use GurBani/Sikh History/Rehitnamae to forge out a Gurmat approach?
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
warrior*princess · 14 Dec 2003
:((((
I think that we can only help by telling those type of people, if possible, about why they should not pursue manmat actions...since it is our duty to do sikhi parchaar. But we have to approach with pyaar and not gussa....we must remember that it is by Vaheguru's will that they are mis-guided, and this can happen to anyone... so we should not come across as judgemental to 'em but instead helpful and caring.
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
warrior*princess · 14 Dec 2003
Dear anon. , good thing you knew about Naam :D vaheguroo! :)
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
jagjit singh · 15 Dec 2003
waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, when I first kept my kesh, and starting coming into the sangat, I met many wonderful Gursikhs, including some inspiring biban. One day, a lad I met in a gurdwara, came and told me one of them bibian was going out with a muslim, and had a bad character. I was quite shocked by it, and really did not believe it, so just ignored it.
Some time later, I got to know that same bibi through doing seva together at a camp. She was very dedicated to sikhi, and an excellent role model. So I mentioned to her older brother, what that lad had said, and said we should stop the ninda. A few weeks later we cornered that lad in at a gurdwara, and asked him why he was spreading lies. He finally admitted, he has secretly liked that bibi, and asked her out, but she was strong in her sikhi, and told him she does not do things like that. Anyway this rejection made him spread lies about her, to other youth, especially anti-akj circles, because she was keski wale bibi.
Anyway after a strong talking to, he admitted his mistake, and to his credit a few days later he went and apologised to that bibi for his ninda. She was not happy, but did forgive him. He since has learned from that and become a quite sincere young man.
The moral is do not always believe everything you hear. especially ninda about another Gursikh. Always give a Gursikh the benefit of the doubt, remembering many people have many agendas. However even if it is true, do something constructive to bring that person back on the path of Guru Ji. But do not put wieght on yourself of more ninda. Otherwise are not just as big a paapi as her?
waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
warrior*princess · 15 Dec 2003
excellent post veer jee!!
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
Surrey Singh · 15 Dec 2003
VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH
Hey "G"...i must say that what you are saying is nothing but manmat. You are saying its none of our business what she is doing?...look buddy, when we see our Khalsa brothers and sisters straying from the Path, we don't turn our heads the other way. It is our duty to help each other out. Maybe this girl needs someone to remind her that what she is doing is a kurat, and she is no longer Khalsa. Personally, i would approach this girl, and tell her if she has any fear of God, she would repent, and Pesh, because if she got hit by a car, and died today, she would die with her back to Guru, and God knows where she would be heading. Sometimes people's Sikhi begins to lack, and they need someone to give them a rude awakening.
VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH
[%sig%]
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 15 Dec 2003
hey "G" surrey singh is rite on
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
Surrey Singh · 16 Dec 2003
VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH
ok..."G"...i agree with you about not feeding on rumours heard about people. It's not hard to ruin someone's reputation by going around telling people lies about others. After more and more people hear about these rumours, people begin to think: "Well, everyone's saying it...it must be true"
so, i agree with you that we shouldn't believe everything we hear, but if we actually see something with our own eyes, then it's different. I think at that point, it is our farj (responsibility) to help out our brothers/sisters, by reminding them of what they are doing, and the potential consequenses. I know some people might say, "they already know what they are doing is wrong"...but sometimes people need to actually hear it from others in order to realize just how wrong it really is. The evil mind will just make up excuses for everything, and make a person believe that what they are doing is not that bad...or it will tell you, "don't worry, do it now, and then start doing Bhagti, and everything will be forgiven"...so...i don't think we should believe rumours, or spread them, but if you see it yourself, then don't just turn your head the other way, help the fallen soldier back up.
VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH
[%sig%]
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
warrior*princess · 16 Dec 2003
G jee, you wrote:
>>>thats fine but I think its silly that you think you have the right to pick your childrens husband/wife especially when that has nothing to do with sikhi thats just punjabi culture<<<
Yes parents do have that right, if they fed and helped the child to grow into an adult with Guru jee's kirpaa, then hanjee they have the right to be involved when it comes to the daughters or sons marriage so that they know the kids have found a good partner to marry to. Parents naturally care for their childs well-being. Often parents make the decision 'with' the daughter/son, and most cases the daughter/son is accepting of this!
The world is under Akaal Purakhs command, nothing evolves outside of that hukum...therefore when gursikhs parents decide to become involved in rishtaa matters, they are right to do so and it is Sikhi!
OTHERWISE, it can only end up being like some dating agency. If parents did not help in the matter, then the persons wanting to get married will start looking by themselves and then will actually approach potential partners in person - and it is highly unlikely it may not work out in the end or there are problems....going from one person to the next in person is just losing respect for yourself whether you are male/female...this is not okay without parents involvement unless there is a very good reason....but if parents cannot help in the matter then a respected gursikh can be requested to do the sevaa for them of finding a partner. Then the person involved with the parents can decide further as to whether they wish to pursue the rishtaa.
Guru Sahib jee wants us to have faith in EVERYTHING...this means, we have to surrender our MAT/ mind to Guru jee...by doing that, we accept that Guru jee understands our needs and will help us resolve our affairs, in return we keep reht. If we cannot keep such bharosaa in Guru Sahib jee then we have not truly given our heads, i.e. minds to Guru Sahib jee.
Also, we are either Sikhs or we are not. There is no half way. Therefore, punjabi culture has not place in GurSikhi jeevan, because we cannot be traditional and religious at one time....our footsteps must be towards Guru jee, any other direction just has to be the wrong way/ path.
Veer jee if you believe the practise of tradition is allowed in a GurSikhi jeevan, then please present Gurbanee, which states this.
Lastly you said: >>but when it comes down to them "likeing" each other or kissing itss soooo bad omggg "gursikhs" arent aloud to fall in love with each other thats soooo wrongg<<
If any adultry is committed, that is a bujjer kureht, therefore if you were a parent of a daughter/son who pursued such an action, you would definately be saying 'OMG!', and will try to fix the situation.
As for GurSikhs falling in love....thats their business & is ONLY okay IF the couple are married!!!
Other than that, Gurbanee explains again and again how our ultimate and true love really is for Akal Puraakh, Vaheguru jee. No other love or satisfaction can compare. This achievement is one of the goals of a gursikh married couple. We males/females are the soul brides of Vaheguru jee, our destination is to become one with Akal Purakh, in SaachKhand...until then we have to endure punishment or circle of life and deaths, or come again in the womb etc. So lets start making the most of this jeevan while we have the comforts in this lifestyle..
Vaheguru jee is the Great Giver, but we are the Ungrateful Beasts.
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
Kulbir Singh · 17 Dec 2003
Much has been written on this topic. A concerned gursikh wrote about an incident that bothered him. I don’t understand what wrong did this gursikh do by sharing his disappointment in a person wearing keski and doing anti-gurmat activities.
My advice is that you correct this girl who was wearing a keski and kissing someone at school or where ever. If you are not comfortable with her, then let her parents know about this. Her parents will be grateful to you for letting them know about their girl. If she is corrected now, it can save her spiritual life. You actually would be helping her by trying to correct her. To ignore it is totally wrong.
Would you ignore it if it was your own sister? Same way all amritdharis are brothers and sisters. We should try to help. Of course if they don’t want to hear, then you would leave them alone but we should at least try once.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
Balpreet Singh · 17 Dec 2003
I think that the point being driven across is this: humans have a weakness and that is attraction to the other gender. This is a weakness that Gurmat helps us overcome. However, if someone falters and makes a mistake, we should not shun them or condemn them. We should understand they are humans and have made a mistake. We should help them see their mistake and give them our assitance in coming back to the path.
I think others have tried to point out that this problem is more common than we may think and we shouldn't condemn anyone who is discovered or be very shocked.
I agree with all of the above. But at the same time I think that having a boyfriend or girlfriend is not appropriate and is against Gurmat. If someone we know is making this mistake, we should speak to them. If we do not, we are in fact betraying that friend and not doing him/her a favour. If we see someone drowning, we cannot walk away and say it's not our business. In the same way if somone is spiritually drowning we cannot ignore it.
Why so many posts on this topic? Because it's probably something every young Sikh will have to face or has faced.
I think we can all agree on these facts.
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
R. Dorothy Wayneright · 17 Dec 2003
> humans have a weakness and that is attraction to the other gender.
Right, one of our most basic survival instinct is a "weakness."
You go on keep believing that.
[%sig%]
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
Balpreet Singh · 17 Dec 2003
Dorothy,
I think I've mentioned that your contributions to this forum and others are generally very confrontational and rude. The same applies to the above post.
Kaam/Lust is a weakness that makes an individual go crazy for the body of another person. Under the influence of kaam people can make big mistakes that they regret later and even crimes like sexual assault, etc.
Kaam is a feeling that a Sikh tries to overcome. If you do not agree that it is something that needs to be overcome, then that is your opinion. This is a Sikh forum and I'm pretty sure the Admins aren't going to allow someone to promote the "benefits" of kaam/lust.
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
Balpreet Singh · 17 Dec 2003
Kakaaree,
Your question is a valid one. If not boyfriends and girlfriends, then what?? I have seen some Singhs try to come up with a "new" type of courtship for Sikh people that attempts to keep behaviour within certain limits and bounds. I havn't seen those Singhs succeed in finding a partner nor have they been able to avoid causing serious problems for themselves.
Frankly, I believe that a Singh or Kaur should stay in sangat. When they feel they want to get married, talk to older Gursikhs or parents. I don't support finding your own partner as this causes a lot of problems: I've seen unrequited love, misinterpreted intentions, people going too far and commiting a bujjer kurehit, deceiving families. It's too much of a problem.
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
beant singh chagghar · 18 Dec 2003
thats all fair enough but lets be practical, what if your not from jatt ancestry? how many families are gonna help you find a keski vali wife? theres quiet a few sikh amritdhari men in their prime who have approached the panth and are often knocked back in polite ways with answers like " we dont know anyone" etc. and such gursikhs are forced to break their rehet and marry outside of the jatha through their own families setting up rishte with girls who arent even amritdhari let alone keski valee bibiya. This of course leads to life pattern changes which conflict with the rehet of a sikh as well as dreams of leading a gursikhi jeevan as taught and practiced by earlier gursikhs.
im not saying dating is a way out or a right method of course it leads to lust and lust is what each sikh shud fight even when married, qoutes of bani refer to lust not unmarried lust or married life unlimited lust.
but this thing of elder gursikhs setting up rishte only works for some and not for all under the prevailing circumstances. A process which would need correction in future not to deny or push aside which leads to further complications. This of course is as big a problem as youth dating although not the prime cause or effect. If the panth wants to stand together in every aspect then surely it must demonstrate otherwise people will see through it and wonder, what do i do when faced with ideology, values rehet in my life or practicality? it will become like 2 streets merged into one? right and wrong will not be on the persons mind clear cut as those who have a lot more at their disposal to practice the pratan rehet. This is not the 17 18 19th century we live in a highly competitive environment as it is with a lot more social interaction.
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
R. Dorothy Wayneright · 19 Dec 2003
__Balpreet Singh said:__
>Kaam/Lust is a weakness that makes an individual go crazy for the body
>of another person. Under the influence of kaam people can make big mistakes
>that they regret later and even crimes like sexual assault, etc.
So should we blame guns for killing people as well? Should we blame video games too?
Does that sound silly to you? Blaming Lust as the reason for sexual assaults is just as silly.
You can not blame sexual assault on a verb!! You must blame the person!
__kakaree said:__
>Dorothy every thing has two faces like a coin. The strength of the basic survival
>Instinct can also pose one of the greatest weakness depending on whether it controls
> someone or they control it.
>
>What we want to do is develop practical guidelines and skills for self control
So we have established that is it a basic survival instinct. Who gave us this basic survival instinct? God.
But as Mkhalsa said, taking anything, even if it is a survival instinct, too far is detrimental to anyones health.
From the responses I have seen here people seem to recommend a total withdrawal from any prurient desires which I don't think is the way to go.
If god gave us the gift of lust, who are we to deny it? He gave us all of our basic instincts, and there is a reason for all of them. I always hear people saying, "Oh god gave you hair, why do you cut it and deny what he has given you," well I pose a similar question to you:
God gave you lust, why do you deny it?
Now I know someone will come in here and paste some random shabds they found on some website and run away without any of there own commentary... but I can't do anything about that, but hopefully someone will come and give me a rational reason for denying one thing from god and accepting another.
The key to life is moderation. Don't let lust run your life, but at the same time don't avoid the gift god has given you.
[%sig%]
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
R. Dorothy Wayneright · 20 Dec 2003
__Mkhalsa said:__
>the survival instinct is NOT lust. the instinct is procreation.
>lust is a pleasure whereas procreation is for survival.
But lust and procreating go hand in hand. Ever wonder why procreation feels so good?
>false pleasures take one away from god and hurt thier personal
>relationship with god.
How can it be a false pleasure when god gave you this pleasure? How can it hurt my personal relationship with god?
Let's compare two things. One procreating and the other kirtan.
We are both accepting as a fact that god created humans correct?
So on one hand we have a pleasure that god instinctively gave us and on the other hand we have a more or less man crafted pleasure (the hymns may be divine, but the musical and mechanical aspects of it are definitely man made, so at best we can say it is a 50/50 god/human construct).
Now you tell me, how can a pleasure that god gave me be bad, while a man made pleasure (kirtan) can be good?
Are you questioning gods divine wisdom? Are you saying your man made creation of kirtan is more worthy than the simple pleasure of procreation god gave you?
>I know this personally. lust is detrimental to ones mental and
>spiritual well being.
Perhaps for you. But you can't say that just because it is detrimental your your mental health it is also detrimental for everyones mental health.
One solution does not work for all. For you it may be detrimental, for me it may be beneficial.
[%sig%]
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
R. Dorothy Wayneright · 21 Dec 2003
__kakaree said:__Â
>You can look around you Dorothy and see the effects of uncommitted relationships.
>Self control is not a bad thing it's not necessarily even denying desire exists.
>But the ideal is to have desire be a tool, rather than be the tool of desire.
Which is almost exactly what I am saying.
>The children growing up here have parents whose marriages were arranged and expect
>them to think of others as sisters and brothers but at the same time as soon as they
>reach puberty even talking to each other is discouraged especially in public. These
>same youth go to public schools. They have no experience outside of what they get at
>school in dealing with the other gender. There are no guidelines set up except "don't talk
>or it’s against gurmat" How helpful is that? They are extremely vulnerable.
Which is why it is important to be open about it instead of treating it like a dirty little secret as most people on this board seem to want to.
__ĤĀ&# said:__ Â
>if you don'y beleive anything from gurbani, then what the hell arer you doing here?
Why do you assume that?
>If you question everything that pops up about bujjer kurayts and say it is ok,
>then what are you doing on this forum?
What have I said is okay?
I have posted in two threads. One which was about smoking. In it I never said it was okay according to Sikhi to smoke. I was simply say harassing others for there personal decisions is not a good idea.
The only other thread is this one.
>Personally i doon care about what you think about how people should be able to do whatever,
>but if you are going to criticize everything why are you here? What i mean is if you don't
>beleive in what sikhism preaches then why go and argue?
I am here to learn. Is that not what you are supposed to be doing as well? Is that not the definition of what a Sikh is, someone that continually learns? Why are you so afraid to hear a voice that does not sing in perfect harmony with yours?
>now asumming that you are chirstan, should i go around asking how the hell did a virgin give birth?
Actually that is valid question. How does a virgin give birth? Does it not contradict the definition of virginity?
>It would be beneficial for you to either accept skhism or if you don't, stop arguing with
>every ristriction.
Why? Why are you so afraid to ask questions? No one is forcing anyone to do anything here, we are merely discussing a topic and hopefully everyone is learning. As a Sikh should you not be encouraging more discourse to learn not only more about your faith, but others faiths and beliefs as well?
If anything, hearing from the other side should only strengthen your own beliefs unless they were weak to being with. In which case why would you want to still hold on to them (note: I am talking about this posters personal beliefs, not Sikhism)?
>It is people like you that probably have aid and going to die at the age of 55 saying whatever
>I lived my life, and the rest of you wasted it.
I was going to reply to this, but I won't because I don't think it is appropriate to be discussion sex, safe sex, and STD prevention on this forum. But if for some reason you do wish to discuss this, e-mail me.
>Well i really dont care if you beleive in being a player or whatever but aleast dont
>try to convince others its okay.
Being a "player"? Where did that come from? How am I trying to convince others to be a "player"?
Re: what is sikhi coming too...
R. Dorothy Wayneright · 22 Dec 2003
__Mkhalsa said:__
>And who questioned gods divine wisdom? its you who are questioning it. First off, god created maya,
>this illusion for us to live in, without it weare really kind of lost and drifting. Maya is where
>our bodies are. Hmm.. i think kulbir singh jee could best explain this part as I do have a hard
>time putting things into words at times.
Okay I am going to base all my responses on "maya" being the universe and our reality.
>Anyway, this maya only distracts us from god and keeps us from him. It depends on our karams, our
>free will, and gods grace of how we react to maya. If we fully indulge in it and get "pleasure"
>from it then that is our perogative, but then we made a personal choice to be stuck in it
>and continue reincarnating.
Explain to me why god would create something, then not want us to use it. Ask yourself this question, would you ever create something for the sole purpose of not using it? It doesn't make sense to me.
>You are making us all think about sikhi from different perspectives, for this, I am thankful
>and your doubts only seem to ground me more in sikhi.
Awesome.
>No drug, no boyfriend nothing can compare to the pleasure that meditation upon god gives us.
>It is your loss, I have nothing to gain from trying to show you that its 10000 times better than
>any "pleasure" you have experienced, and trust me, i know.
1) You assume I have never experienced spiritual pleasure which is false.
2) But let's say I had not. All I have to go on is spiritual pleasure being better than a worldly pleasure is your word? Sorry, your a interesting fellow, but just having your word is not enough.
>how would you explain to an alien whos never eaten the pleasures of eating a chocolate cake with
>fudge ice cream? they would just look at you quizzically thinking ur a nut.
You would explain to them the textures (i.e. rough, smooth, silky) and tastes (i.e. sweet, bitter, sour) of the cake.
>thats exactly what you are doing. You look at us thinking we havent experienced your pleasures,
>trust me, most of the people reading this board have lived enough and they find the world vile
>and dispicable in its "pleasures."
1) Why do you hate worldly pleasures? God created them just as he created spiritual pleasures. Why totally cut yourself off from them?
but more importantly:
2) Why can worldly and spiritual pleasures not go hand in hand? Why must you deny one and accept the other? Both are made by god, why do you avoid one but accept the other?
Like I said before, it's about balance. Why not experience both worlds? Spiritual and physical pleasure.