Re: Indian born bibian
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Mar 2006
why are foreign singhs rushing to India to marry indian born bibian ??..and then deserting them to boot....bad people (nothing to do with kalyug or stayug...that si just a lousy excuse )
I find Indian Bibian much more into Sikhi and Rehat..they looked so sweet in their Banas..and even those wearing just ordinary school uniforms were decently dressed in salwar kameez..not like the ones you see in Malaysia..half dressed.
In Malaysia..the ONES who have no hope in hell of getting a decent LOCAL wife are the ones who rush to Punjab to get married - the people there are so trusting..they dont investigate as much..so even a known drug addict good for nothing can marry a doctor/MA BA educated Punajbi bibi in Punjab.... she will only find out the TRUTH when she comes to malaysia..and her husband lands in jail after a while...( after giving her a baby of course so that she wont run away to pun jab)..bad people...
Re: Indian born bibian
Dil Hindustani · 24 Mar 2006
East or West. Indian girls are best.
Re: Indian born bibian
A "Western" Individual · 25 Mar 2006
Giani Arshi Ji - I think you are mistaken...you are only looking at one side of the issue...blaming the "bad people" males for all the problems.
All,
THERE ARE PROBLEMS ON BOTH SIDES...
It is rediculous to blame bibian or bibe(guys) from any one side.
People who go from here - lie
People in punjab/india - lie
They lie about thier intentions, about thier status, and about who they are.
The issue is one of "wants" and expectations.
I have noticed in my experience that the problem is thereby two-fold...1) control and 2) what we call mazboori (necessity/reluctance)
(In the following I will use the words Punjab and India interchangebly - b/c westerners do not always just go to Punjab.)
CONTROL - most families (and individuals) want a ready-made bride or groom. They want to control how their lives will end up by ensuring that the spouse that they choose will conform to thier vision of what life should be like.
They do not realize that the person you are going to marry also has aspirations and that marriage is a fusion of souls and everything embodies in them. A marriage is the product of two individuals.
If a male goes to punjab, it is b/c he wants a girl that will "fit in" with his family. This traslates to a girl who will cook, clean, work, respect, and be subordinate to him (lets call her "traditional"). When females go they want a guy who will "fit in" with her life style. She wants someone who can come to "the West" and get a job right away, make good money, but allow her independance as a western woman (lets call him "progressive").
The problems arize when the two expectations clash. Western guys want a "traditional" girl (but the girl is looking to come to America and wants to be Western - she wants a "progressive guy"). Punjab today is not what it used to be, it is much more "westernized" in thought than when most established immigrant families left about fourty to fifty years ago. On the other hand, western girls are independant and want a "progressive" guy (guys from India are generally more traditional - b/c it is a male-centered society).
There is a problem, because people do not want to leave room for growth in marriage - they want wha they want and demand it.
MAZBOORI - Not being able to find what they want in the West, the foreigner returns to the land of her/his forefathers to find a spouse that will conform to the vision of a perfect spouse.
This puts a great demand on peole in the India. People in India are mazboor. Because of the economic conditions in the world's "largest democracy" people want to leave. They want opportunities, but often they cant do this without sometimes comprimising who they are, to fit a mold.
They lie about credentials, about family background, and about status. This leads to problems later - but what are they to do. The westerners have the upper hand. They hold "all the cards" b/c if they dont get what they want from one family that seems like it may work - they move to another, then another.
But foreigners are mazboor as well. They have to consider many things when looking for "spouses". Often big considerations are culture. They want someone who will come here and be able to raise a family and perpetuate the same beliefs and ideas that their own immigrant parents embody. They dont want thier culture to die.
There is mazboori on both sides.
--
This is not as well thought out or well written as I would like, I hope that my points come across clearly - if not I am sorry for any confusion.
Bhul Chuk Maaf,
-A "Western" Individual
Re: Indian born bibian
london singh · 25 Mar 2006
Nice post western individual. Gyaniji you told a very myopic view about what is happening. As WI said, there is deceit on both sides. Girls in Punjab complain about guys from abroad coming and marrying for dowry (usually from Canada who have only just immigrated a few years before) but do they check out these guys background? The families are more interested in the guy being from abroad so that they can send their girl abroad and the rest of the family follow her. This is why UK guys going to India even having professional jobs will be bypassed by these families in favour of a guy who works in a menial jobs but is from US or Canada. This is because it is well nigh impossible for the girls family to immigrated to the UK.
If these families really are only interested in their daughters future they would marry them to professional guys from UK and not menials from canada or US. This is why I take all the news about abandoned brides with a bit of salt. People get rishta with others of the same attitude. These greedy families eager to immigrate get greedy guys eager for dowry who then run off.
Re: Indian born bibian
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Mar 2006
i WRITE FROM personal experience with about 20 such "marriages" that I KNOW everything about....and have "heard" second hand aboutn9 others which are the same situation i describe ( but these are not that close for me know everything about them)
WI writes a much more "psychological:..type of treeatise... i wonder if he has any one close enough to him that is in that "mazboor" situation.
FIRE in another's house is as they say "FUN and Fireworks"..but when it is in ones own house it is "DESTRUCTION"...although essentially it is the same heat producing flame. Thus a unconcerned/far away perosn will justify..kooi mazbooree hogee, kee patta kee gall hai..blah blah blha.... the Actual perosn involved will say..MERA GHAR TABAH HO GIYA..meree dhee dee jindagee tabah ho gayee... THAT is the type of Fallout I deal with..in PERSON...not bookish types of "mazboorees" and blah blah blahs..
Althopugh i do beleive WI also has soem good points..to consider..maybe a few do that.
Jarnail singh
Re: Indian born bibian
A "Western" Individual · 26 Mar 2006
"Gyani" ji,
I really didnt understand the point of your post -- you implied a few things, but never made any contentions.
MAZBOOR - We all know people who are "mazboor" in our personal lives and thier mazbooria(n) are all different. It could be a family who would like to immigrate from India b/c of the economic conditions there, a family who wants a girl who will respect elders and parents in the fam in the west b/c they value, a guy who can provide for a girl when he gets to the west b/c she is in school seeking higher education, a girl who will be able to work in a reasonably good paying job when she arrives in thew west b/c the family cannot afford to live on only one income (the son's) OR a whole slew of other "mazbooria(n)."
ACCOUNTABILITY - As was posted by another, Indian/Punjabi famlies are also negligent in thier choice of spouse for thier daughters (and sons). But this is part of thier mazboori-because they want a better life, economically, for thier child. They are willing to look past gaps in the story, or difficiencies in the foreign individual, for a chance to leave India. We have all heard of or know that a 45-year old man can go to punjab and get a 22 year old bride - it isnt just something that happens in the newspaper. However, equally as astonishing is that a 45 year old woman from the west can too get a 22 year old groom.
I grant that there is a power relationship here - not balanced at all, but you have to take the blame if you are at fault, no matter how mazboor you may be.
If all you are looking at is going abraod, then you are less likely to look at other things, like family history, the persons activities, etc.
Realizing that the families in India do this, foreign rascals (and I agree that these are horrible monsters who do this) go and marry, inpregnate, and leave Indian/Punjabi girls. However, it is because the families allow this to happen, that it happens.
The difference between our analyses is not that I am looking at it only "psychologically", I am looking it it wholistically.
FIRE IN YOUR HOME - Imagine finding out that your spouse doesnt really have a BS or a MSc, or isnt really an RN. When she/he arrives in the West, you relalize that she/he cant get a job b/c her/his family lied about who she/he was. They lied about school, they lied about job experience, they lied about YOUR future.
This creates a great amount of tention in the family and the lives of everyone involed are miserable.
What is better: to be left by a foreign spouse or to be continually in the pit of fire in a disfunctional family? No real answer exists...they are both horrible existences.
I urge that we look at the issue in light of all sides who play the game of "marriage."
--
I hope my points make sense - again, time does not allow me to edit much, but I am glad we are having this conversation, it is indeed an important and relevant one.
Bhul Chuk Maaf,
-A "Western" Individual
Re: Indian born bibian
JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Mar 2006
THE SITUATION IN malaysia IS MUCH MUCH DIFFERENT FROM THE WEST..
here a foreign wife has to endure a series of two weekly Visas..then one month visas..three month visas, six month visas... for about two years..then they begin to get a YEAR Visa whereby the husband MUST accompany her to immigrationa dn endure long waits and harrassment... these visas continue year upon year 5 years..seven years..nine years..thirteen years... anytime the marriage breaks up divorce..back she goes to punjab...if she gets to stay on humnaitarain grounds ( malaysain child)..then she pays for a three moth visa at huge cost and since she cannot work legally..god knows where the money comes from... out of atotal of about 900 indian wives about 300 are single mothers (divorced) with no PR let alone cvitizenship...
so coming here is no bed of roses...say compared to canada west....its hell if you cant get along with your husband ( who may turn out to be not wanted by any malayain girl due to his drug habit)
This is reality of the single mother punjabi girls in malaysia.. PR is as distant as the rainbow in the sky....
Re: Indian born bibian
...just some kaur... · 28 Mar 2006
wow! thzt the last thing i htought i would hear. seems like i been living in my own "safe" world thinkng everything is perfect. vaheguro
hmm i used to boost about Punjabis and Sardars (Sikhs) about how great our culture is for those reasons..
lol
well that thought or ideal is the gift of todays punjabi music industry.(Thank you so much you singers and writers...lol)
anyhow about the topic... well i think people are gettin the idea now these days. people who have very close relatives in west are aware of the issues...and they know that west isn;t all that! its good cuz there are some good rules etc,but over are nothin like punjab(the assh and aram of family)