Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sarbloh bebek???:)

Sarbloh bebek???:)

confused! · 23 Mar 2006

VJKK VJKF when one does sarbloh bebek are they only meant to make food in sarbloh for that one day or can it be saved for another day in a container? Can all doing sarbloh bebek answer this question please, as daas is very happy but confused but still trying to remain happy. he he, ha ha see i'm still happy. VJKK VJKF

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

ksg · 23 Mar 2006

srbloh bbek is wonderful as it make you feel niara and better than other fellow sikhs. other than that what else do you need out of this [%sig%]

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 23 Mar 2006

No ksg, it's petty minded Sikhs who feel inferior when they see a sarbloh bibeki. As for storage: Singhs generally use clay to store. Making enough for one day is the best way though.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

no jatha singh · 23 Mar 2006

"srbloh bbek is wonderful as it make you feel niara and better than other fellow sikhs" i would have thought there are few things worse than something which makes you feel better than fellow sikhs I think sikhs are supposed to recognise Waheguru`s kirpa instead of developing haumai.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 23 Mar 2006

no jatha singh, ksg was taking a shot at sarbloh bibek. He wasn't being genuine. Sarbloh Bibekis don't feel better than anyone. They're just following Guru Sahib's hukam.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

ksg · 23 Mar 2006

if They're just following Guru Sahib's hukam then they should not treat other sikhs as teelay to the limit of not sharing food with them. none is perfact, every sikh love his guru, that is why he believe in Guru. But when you exceed the limits of your tolerance if someone does not agree with you, then it is not GURSIKHI. e.g. Just imgine every nonsrblhi will have the same kind of feeling as the srbloh bbeki veers would be having when they find intolerance of pro-GURMATSANGEET Sikhs towards srbloh bbeki veers for their failure regarding nirdhart-rag kirtan hukum of Guruji. i respect both srblohi and nirdhartraag kirtanis as long as they remain humble and does not put down other sikhs failing to meet their expectations. Just to clear, I believe nirdharat rag kirtan is guru's hukum and srbloh was guru's tradition(not hukum) but both are not the minimum mendatory rehats without which one cease to be Sikh. Sory ji, for all my bhuls. [%sig%]

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

sanjo · 24 Mar 2006

can sarbloh bibekis eat processed food? i.e stuff tht comes in plastic packaging. i have always admired sarbloh bibekis, but wondered where u get ur bread n stuff from. do u mak ur own bread? lol wierd question?

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

singh · 24 Mar 2006

yes, sarblohis makes their own bread

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

!!!!! · 24 Mar 2006

WJKK WJKF i do not think that one needs to make their own bread as roti tastes better. WJKK WJKF

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

akj wannabe · 24 Mar 2006

Author: ksg Date: 03-23-06 16:35 "srbloh bbek is wonderful as it make you feel niara and better than other fellow sikhs. other than that what else do you need out of this" True what "..." says, as it is the petty minded sikhs who are against sarabloh bibek. This is because they beleive those who follow the hukam of sarabloh bibek think that they are better than others just because they eat out of sarabloh. But this does not make sense, this means we shouldn't do any paath because we will think that we are better than others. we shouldn't get up at amrit vela because it will give us haumai ! Amrit vela is also a hukam given by guru ji like sarbloh bibek. What makes them different. [%sig%]

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 24 Mar 2006

KSG, I feel that sarbloh bibek is a hukam as is found in rehitnama of Bhai Daya Singh and tradition followed in many jathebandis and in amrit sinchar. At any rate, all Sikhs should be bibeki, and if a Sikh isn't, I think it is legitimate to not eat their food. As for raag kirtan: I am a supporter of raag and believe it should be done as much as possible, but are you suggesting someone who doesn't know raag but sings a shabad is committing a kurehit? Violation of rehit? Because not eating bibeki food is a kurehit, if you are suggesting that raag is a rehit like that, then certainly the poor Sikh who is singing to himself in some simple tune is committing a kurehit. Also tell my why all historic accounts tell us it was Guru Arjan Dev Sahib who started singing Shabads in Jotian in sangat? This is not in raag so it is also a kurehit?

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

akjuk-ute · 24 Mar 2006

"all Sikhs should be bibeki, and if a Sikh isn't, I think it is legitimate to not eat their food" im sure bhai sahib accepted food from amritdharees who werent sarbloh eg singhs who do nitnem, amritvela, eat only from other amritdharees. ie singhs with basic rehit/ jeevan

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

singh · 24 Mar 2006

bebek's make their own food because a non-amritary has touched the food that is already processed, so they make their food from scartch right? But isnt that scratch,. like the atta and sugar and whatever"scratch" they use also one time or another touched by a non-amritary because they do have to pack that and make that scratch in factories too? Please correct me if I am wrong, I am not taking a stab at bibek's, i am just wondering

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 24 Mar 2006

Although this has been described many times before, dry raw materials can be used by bibekis. Bibekis make their own food because it's hukam to do so. Food prepared by amritdharis is beneficial for spirituality when it's cooked with naam/bani.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

singh · 24 Mar 2006

but that dry material was still touched by maybe a smoker or someone who was singing dirty songs, so wouldnt be the same as a ppizza that is being cooked by the hands of sumone who smokes or is singing dirty songs?

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

ksg · 24 Mar 2006

... ji >>I feel that sarbloh bibek is a hukam as is found in rehitnama of Bhai Daya Singh and tradition followed in many jathebandis and in amrit sinchar. At any rate, all Sikhs should be bibeki, and if a Sikh isn't, I think it is legitimate to not eat their food.<< Just like you feel srbloh bibek is a hukam based on some rehatnamey none of which is wholly acceptable to anyone including yourself, some gursikhs feel that nirdharth raag (as written before almost every shabad in Guru Granth Sahib Ji) is ordained by Guru Sahibs themselves not by any Gursikhs and there is no doubt about it to anyone. Everyone including srblohi also read the name of the rag also when doing path But there are only few who give this title rag a practical shape by singing accordingly. Does not it make sense to you. if not just find the posts of bhai Harchan Singh to have better understanding. My point is not to put down any rehat but all i wanted to say is we the Sikhs(students) must not become judge(Guru Sahib). We become so when we start feeling ourselves different (in superior sense) than any other gursikh who we find does not follow a particular rehat that we follow and we decide to treat him like a teela and go to the extent of not sharing food and even associate with. That is crossing the limit of being a Sikh. Just think, how would a sarblohi react to another Sikh who think it is ghor manmat and stricly disobeying Guru sahib by listening or performing to kirtan in a tune other than nirdhart rag as ordered in B&W in Guru Granth Sahib JI. Just think about it. Do not misunderstand me. I am not your enemy. I am your sikh brother. pl trust me. I also wish and pray to have the blessing of following our Guruji but I believe that the more one practice Sikhi, the more humble he should be. A true Sikh will always believe all other sikhs better than him and will remain lowest of the lowest. This should be reflected from the behaivior of a Sikh towards other at all times or otherwise his growth has started to stop with the arrival of sooksham haume(ego) which he may not be even aware of. believe me. Sory ji once again, for all mistakes. I do not want to argue like start hitting head with a wall. I hope I have expressed my feelings, if find good, accept it otherwise trash them as i do not claim my self to be a bebeki (or pooran) sikh and I myself has lot lot to learn in a long way to go on path of sikhi. [%sig%]

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

questionable · 25 Mar 2006

how can your spirit be fed by what is in your stomach? it seems like a far-fetched concept.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

the paap man · 25 Mar 2006

I would like to practice sarblohi rehit because it is simple and healthy and it keeps a person humble and helps them to focus on sikhi but saying "it's hukam to do so" is not 100% certain for me, because nobody has been able to show me any hukamnama, thankhahnama, rehitnama, or even tell me any sakhi about why sarbloh rehit is most important. there is only one shabad, "sarbloh ki rachha hamnai," which could mean that your shastars should be sarbloh - but many jatha singhs wear steel kirpans. this makes me confused.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 25 Mar 2006

From the article on Bibek. See bold for reference to sarbloh ***[NOTE: proof for the tradition of Bibekee Singhs can be found in the historical records of M.A. Macauliffe who writes "..so amid the general corruption of the religion of Gobind there are to be found about one hundred Sikhs at Naderh in the Dakhan, who are said to have up to the present time preserved intact the faith and ceremonies of Guru Gobind. They have kept aloof from the contact of Brahmins. Brahmin ministrations are not permitted either at their births, their marriages, or their obsequies. Whether they be Brahmin or Sudras who receive the sacramental pahul, all are by this fact admitted within a pale of social and religious equality. Brahmin weds Sudra and Sudra weds Brahmin. No need, therefore, to put their infant daughters to death through fear of not obtaining for them husbands of their own social status, as is the custom among such a large section of the Sikhs of Punjab. And widow marriages, reprobated by Hindus and now consequently by the Sikhs of the Punjab are habitually solemnised with the clearest conscience among the Sikhs of Naderh...At Patna, as at Naderh, the Sikhs pay the strictest attention to the Injunctions of Guru Gobind. Sleeping or waking, they are never without the habiliments known as the "five Ks." So strong is the aversion of the more orthodox among them to Hindus, that they will not even partake of food cooked by their hands. This is carrying orthodoxy a long way, but still further is it carried when they will not partake of food cooked even by a Sikh who has not on his person all the ‘five Ks’" (Macauliffe in "The Sikh Religion under Banda and its Present Condition") Various Puraatan rehitnamas also make clear the importance of Bibek for a Sikh. Bhai Daya Singh rehitnaama contains the following bachans: "Bhojanaad Moundit naal chhakey, Tankhaiyaa" or One who eats food with a Mona/non-Sikh, is guilty of a breach of conduct (Piara Singh Padam’s Rehitnamay pg. 72); also "Patr sarb loh kay, bhougtay asan souaad....loh patr mai chhakai," meaning: using utensils of sarbloh, one eats tasty food...one should eat in sarb loh utensils" (Padam, 75) The Rehitnama Hazooree by Chaupa Singh says "Guru kaa Sikh...apaNy langar rasoee vich Sikh rakhey. Hukaie, Topeeaa, BhaadNee, chor, yaar, jooaybaaz, kurehiteeyaa na rakhai" meaining "A Guru ka Sikh...should keep only a Sikh in his langar and kitchen. Smokers, hat-wearers, shaven people, theieves, gamblers, kurehitees should not be kept" (Padam, 85). In Sau Sakhee, sakhee #8’s rehitnama it says clearly "So Sikh gur ka janeeay, Monay ann na khai" meaning: such is a Sikh of The Guru who does not eat the food of Monay/Non-Sikhs. [End-Note]***

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 25 Mar 2006

As for food feeding your spirit: everything you eat has an effect on you. That study on how words have an effect on water has become very popular and I think everyone should take a look. Even amrit is created through "words" and doesn't it have an effect on your spirit? The vibration that food carries with it, passes on to us. If it's negative vibrations, it hurts spirituality. If it's naam vibrations, it raises us up.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

ksg · 25 Mar 2006

...ji i feel that arguing with you is just like hitting head on the wall. you are also like those who do not see their own weeknesses but are so much blindly intolerant to find weeknesses in others. [%sig%]

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 25 Mar 2006

ksg, what have I not tolerated of yours? I have a belief in sarbloh bibek. I told you I believe in raag as well, but that clearly it is not a rehit like sarbloh bibek, because Guru Sahib himself created "jotian" shabads, and a Sikh singing a shabad in a simple tune because he doesn't know a raag isn't committing a kurehit. I find it funny when people talk about nimartaa and humility and "i am bhulanhaar, please forgive me" but it all falls away pretty quickly when you don't agree with them. The only intolerance I see here is yours.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

LK · 25 Mar 2006

Various Puraatan rehitnamas also make clear the importance of Bibek for a Sikh. Bhai Daya Singh rehitnaama contains the following bachans: "Bhojanaad Moundit naal chhakey, Tankhaiyaa" or One who eats food with a Mona/non-Sikh, is guilty of a breach of conduct (Piara Singh Padam’s Rehitnamay pg. 72); also "Patr sarb loh kay, bhougtay asan souaad....loh patr mai chhakai," meaning: using utensils of sarbloh, one eats tasty food...one should eat in sarb loh utensils" (Padam, 75) The Rehitnama Hazooree by Chaupa Singh says "Guru kaa Sikh...apaNy langar rasoee vich Sikh rakhey. Hukaie, Topeeaa, BhaadNee, chor, yaar, jooaybaaz, kurehiteeyaa na rakhai" meaining "A Guru ka Sikh...should keep only a Sikh in his langar and kitchen. Smokers, hat-wearers, shaven people, theieves, gamblers, kurehitees should not be kept" (Padam, 85). ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1- Chaupa Singh is probably the least reliable of them all! 2- By quoting the Rehitnama (of Chaupa Singh) I assume you support it. Does that mean that if you were in charge of making sure Gurmat was followed in a Gurdwara, you would only allow Sikhs to participate in the Langat? oh vaheguru! Is this where our Sikhi is going? I not arguing about bibek. I'm questioing your usage of the passage from Chaupa Singh's writings. Jesus Christ! I can't believe you quoted it. It tells me you support it, which means that if you were in charge of making sure Gurmat was followed in a Gurdwara you would enforce this Rehitnama, which means non Sikhs (who, cut their hair, wear hats, shae themselves, smoke, gamle, steal) would not be allowed into Langat. Please clearfy your usage of that quote. 3- Sau Sakhi contains much dubious content. I wouldn't see it as a reliable sources at all 4- Since you seem to think Rehitnamas by Bhai Daya Singh Ji (or supposedly by Bhai Daya Singh Ji, hoeever most people realise they're copies of copies of copies of copies, and thus not originals), would you also acknowledge the following? - Those who have received either khayule hi pahul or charan hi pahul cannot eat Muslim meat (kuttha), domestic pig, or donkey. [15, 42, 63, 79, 80] (i.e. Khalsa being restricted from KUTTHA, NOT MAAS). Clearly mentioning pig or donkey, means it's okay to eat the rest as long as it's not kutha Would you acknowledge that? Let's see sometihng more - -------- To adopt the forms of caste is not to our taste. Any member of the four castes can take amrit initiation. 26 The following are useless: a Khatri without a weapon, a Brahman without knowl­edge, a Shudra with learning, and a recluse with a woman. The religious duty (dhuram) of a Khatri is to bear weapons and consume food. [22, 73, 77] ------- First enying Caste, and then acknowledging it by talking about the religious duty of a Khatri, rather than a SIKH. Does that seem like a Very 'Sikh' instruction (refering Sikhs to as Khatris) If You acknowledge the above rehitnamas, please let me know. My most important issues, is that of Chaupa Singh Rehitnama, thus I would request you to clearfy you stand on that please.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

ksg · 25 Mar 2006

...ji Is it Sikhi to claim and state yourself bebeki by yourself. That is what I mean. Are we obeying all the hukums of Guruji. I do not think so about myself. Do you think so about yourself. if not, then neither you nor am I a bebeiki sikh if I just believe what I only follow just to mention sarbloh(to which personally i do not think medatory kukum although i agree it was a Guru's tradition just like using rabab, taus, siranda) or nirdharat rag kirtan(which is one of the clear hukum although I believe it is one of those hukums for which we have to strive life long but this is not the mendotory to start with) for example. I also love sarbloh because my Guru used it and liked it. but he did not made it mendetory just like he did not made mendatory rabab, siranda, horse, and so many other things that our Gururs used. But as his Sikh, I am all for keeping alive all those things which our Guru liked, chose and used. And I higly appreciate and respect those who work on even one of these things. On the other hand we are obligated to work on all what is wrritten in Guru Sahib. Is not it. Is It a long or difficult way. Yes it is but that is the way. eg regarding Kirtan, A Sikh can start from simple tune but his goal should be what is clearly written and I do not see how can a Sikh refuse that. Just Like a sikh can start learning from padshed but his goal is to laridar or A sikh can achieve the hukum of eating less, sleeping less in steps . BUT if you follow one or two of these, still it is not the end of Sikhi, still a long way to go and keeping yourself lowest (practically not by just saying) is the way to go. [%sig%]

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

singh · 25 Mar 2006

Well...after all these hukamnamas,there shouldnt be any doubt regarding the importance of bibek and if one can keep sarbloh thats better. But the problem is that I stay in a hostel in delhi where u have shavers,smokers(their day starts with bidi),topees,adulterers(all day listen to dirty bollywood songs and see girls with corrupt eyes) etc cooking food in the mess. I will be taking amrit only when i leave this HELL. Can any veer tell me from where i can get sarbloh batas.I tried buying them from Bhai randhir singh ji centre in BRS Nagar,ludhiana but to my surprise they dint have batas there.It will be nice if some one can tell me from where i can get GOOD AND AUTHENTIC sarbloh.Its tough to trust the shopkeepers outside gurdwaras in delhi and i guess even in punjab now.I need some authentic source. This world is going to HELL. Khalsa Raj is coming shortly. BOLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO NIHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAL SAT SRI AKAL

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 25 Mar 2006

LK they say "a little knowledge is a dangerous thing" I've already told you that the approach to rehitnamas is if a) there are internal contradictions, clearly the anti-Gurmat stuff can be dismissed. b) if something is not against Gurmat and covered in multiple rehitnamas, it should be accepted. You are the one who said that the rehitnamas are important codifications. Either you can say they are important sources or you can dismiss them entirely, not pick and choose your approach based on when it supports your argument. 2) Langar: it's your ignorance that you don't know the difference between a langar and a pangat. A langar is where the langar is cooked and pangat is where it is distributed. Only Sikhs are allowed in the langar whereas everyone is welcome in the Pangat. At any rate, Chaupa Singh rehitnama is one of the oldest rehitnamas out there, according to all scholars. The fact that it has been adultered is also clear and acknowledged, but that doesn't mean you throw it all out. Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnama: you cite [15, 42, 63, 79, 80] ; I don't know if you're trying to appearly overly-scholarly or what, but of those passages, only one is applicable to the point you made. 15 says to eat, sleep and speak in moderation. 42 says not to eat with out a kacherra, or believe in yogis, jains, clean-shaven and Muslims or recite other hymns. 63 is to keep your cooking are hygenic and not let your nail clippings into food. 79 is what you're talking about and 80 once again has nothing to do with your point. Kuttha means MEAT in general, and the specific mention of pig and donkey is to cover the practices of Islam. Kuthaar (axe) is the source of kuttha and kuttha has no reference to Halal anywhere. The specific reference to Pig and Donkey is because in Islam both these are forbidden and no one should think it's ok to eat just to spite the Muslims. LK, do you have a job besides arguing? Or are you full time ? And next time, please post only relevant citations, as opposed to random passages.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

Singh · 25 Mar 2006

LK please do drop the pseudo-scholarly attitude. Daya Singh Rehatnama is written in verse not prose and therefore has no couplet numberings. Those you refer to, most likely you have just copied out of the McLeod book where he puts them in himself so he can more easily reference things.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

LK · 25 Mar 2006

Author: ... Date: 03-25-06 10:31 LK they say "a little knowledge is a dangerous thing" I've already told you that the approach to rehitnamas is if a) there are internal contradictions, clearly the anti-Gurmat stuff can be dismissed. b) if something is not against Gurmat and covered in multiple rehitnamas, it should be accepted. ------------------------------------------------ There are many many things that are repeated again and agan, thus the quantity of times something is mentioned has no relevance at all, unless you acknowledge that the forth Kurehit is to have Sex with a muslim women (which many do say) ------------- You are the one who said that the rehitnamas are important codifications. Either you can say they are important sources or you can dismiss them entirely, not pick and choose your approach based on when it supports your argument. -------------- I do see rehitnamas as important sources. They are there for the Sikh to be able to verify if something was existant at the time of the Guru, and use a litmus test call GURBANI-comparison, and then, and ONLY THEN accept them. I am not saying that they should be trusted blindly, and hence why I avoid to refering to Rehitnamas when backing up my arguement, and go STRAIGHT FOR GURBANI, which cannot be doubted! ------------- 2) Langar: it's your ignorance that you don't know the difference between a langar and a pangat. A langar is where the langar is cooked and pangat is where it is distributed. Only Sikhs are allowed in the langar whereas everyone is welcome in the Pangat. At any rate, Chaupa Singh rehitnama is one of the oldest rehitnamas out there, according to all scholars. The fact that it has been adultered is also clear and acknowledged, but that doesn't mean you throw it all out. --------------- 1 - Checked Bhai Veer Singh Ji. You are right. Langar is where food is prepared. Point noted. Chaupa SIngh is one of THE most unreliable rehitnamas ever. It is one of the ABSOLUT LEAST reliable rehitnamas, and I would have 10 eyes open when reading his rehitnamas. If read carefully, you will see how much he favours Bahmans (being from a Bahman background himself. Again I do not believe most of it to be authentic, and most likely badly edited by 'shaitan bandey'. Please read Amritpal Singh Amrit's detailed analysis on the dodgy things Chaupa Singh mentions. ----------- Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnama: you cite [15, 42, 63, 79, 80] ; I don't know if you're trying to appearly overly-scholarly or what, but of those passages, only one is applicable to the point you made. 15 says to eat, sleep and speak in moderation. 42 says not to eat with out a kacherra, or believe in yogis, jains, clean-shaven and Muslims or recite other hymns. 63 is to keep your cooking are hygenic and not let your nail clippings into food. 79 is what you're talking about and 80 once again has nothing to do with your point. -------------- As pointed out, I did not have access to rehitnamas when I wrot emy previous post. I simplied copied that from a website. Now I've got the Rehitnamas infrotn fo my, and I apologize for wrong verses. Read the second verse BHai Daya Singh Ji, Talks about Goddesses pronouncing Guru Nanaks Mantra, Varuna giving the water of immortality, Indira bestowing confectionery to make sweet and intelligence, chandi presing the kes, Hanuman presnting the soldierly kach This is the SECOND VERSE, which is the supposed answer from my Guru, when asked to tell Bhai Daya Singh ji about the Rehit of the Khalsa. Is Hanuman where Sikhs get their Kachera from? If we are to believe the second verse of Bhai Daya Singh ji, then that is the case. If we are to believe Daya Singh Rehitnama, (third verse) the gods give a Sikh four things Vishnu gives sugar, Mahadev gives pure flour, Brahma gives Ghi, of which the Kara Parshad is made. If you read verse 53, it will tell you about the forth Kurehit, which it says is having sex with a muslim, brahman women, minors, sister, relative, or someone from his own lineage. It does not say Sex outside marraiage is banned. ---------------- Kuttha means MEAT in general, and the specific mention of pig and donkey is to cover the practices of Islam. Kuthaar (axe) is the source of kuttha and kuttha has no reference to Halal anywhere. The specific reference to Pig and Donkey is because in Islam both these are forbidden and no one should think it's ok to eat just to spite the Muslims. ------------------- I'd rather believe Bhai Vir SIngh ji, than your definition of Kutha. Bhai Vir SIngh Ji, who (i believe )wasn't even involved in creating the modern Rehtmaryada, who wrote his kosh YEARS before the Rehitmaryada defines Kutha as HALLAL. I see him as an unbias person, since he didn't have anything to do with the rehitmaryada. Please see what Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha has to say about the word 'kutha'. You can find his kosh everywhere on the net. To summarize, both say that it's meat slaughtered in Muslim way. Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha refers to the Gurbani quote - [gurbani]ABwiKAw kw kuTw bkrw Kwxw ][/gurbani] Sant Singh Khalsa, who translates on STTM translates it as - ----------- abhaakhiaa kaa kut(h)aa bakaraa khaanaa || They eat the meat of the goats, killed after the Muslim prayers are read over the, http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=1738 ---------- Prof Sahib Singh defines Kutha as - [gurbani] kuTw—hlwl kIqw hoieAw [/gurbani] http://gurugranthdarpan.com/0471.html Bhai Manmohan Singh refers to Kutha as (Both Punjabi and English explaination are by BHai Manmohan Singh) - ------ abhaakhi-aa kaa kuthaa bakraa khaanaa. He eats the he-goat killed by uttering the foreign (Muslim-Kalma) words. ਪਰਦੇਸੀ ਸ਼ਬਦ ਉਚਾਰਨ ਕਰਕੇ ਮਾਰੇ ਹੋਏ ਬੱਕਰੇ ਨੂੰ ਉਹ ਖਾਂਦਾ ਹੈ। -------- ------------- Freedkot vala teeka defines it as follows- ਅਭਾਖਿਆ ਕਾ ਕੁਠਾ ਬਕਰਾ ਖਾਣਾ ॥ ਚਉਕੇ ਉਪਰਿ ਕਿਸੈ ਨ ਜਾਣਾ ॥ abhaakhi-aa kaa kuthaa bakraa khaanaa. cha-ukay upar kisai na jaanaa. (ਅਭਾਖਿਆ) ਮਲੇਛ ਭਾਖਾ ਅਰਥਾਤ ਕਲ ਮੇਂ ਰੂਪ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਕਾ ਮਾਰਾ ਹੂਆ ਬਕਰਾ ਖਾਣਾ ਕਰਤੇ ਹੋ ਫੇਰ ਕਹਤੇ ਹੋ ਹਮਾਰੇ ਚੌਕੇ ਉਪਰ ਕਿਸੇ ਨੇ ਜਾਣਾ ਨਹੀਂ ਭਾਵ ਕੋਈ ਨ ਜਾਓ ਚਉਕਾ ਅਸੁਧੁ ਹੋ ਜਾਵੇਗਾ॥ -------------- http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=472&g=1&h=1&r=1&t=0&p=0&k=2 There is absolutely no basis of saying that 'Kutha' means MEAT. Am I saying meat is allowed? Absolutely not. I am saying that the Rehitnamas say 'kuth'a is not allowed and do not restrict 'maas' - will you see these as authentic. Will you accept the above mentioned verses as, something Dasmesh Pita jee told us? --------- LK, do you have a job besides arguing? Or are you full time ? And next time, please post only relevant citations, as opposed to random passages. ---------- I will argue till my face goes blue, against anything I might see as manmat. I will not stay quiet. Ofcourse my views might not agree 100% fully with official Tapoban views, and hence why several post have been declined. I think this is a very good thread, since it is going into a bit detail with Gurmat, exactly what this phorum was made for (according tot he disclaimer which says that it's for Gurmat discussions). I do apologize for the wrong verses, since I simply copied them from a website quoting from a book. It turned out that the verses did not match with the point I was trying to make, but the above mentioned verses (which have been noted, after confirming with Padam's book) should be enough to prove that Rehitnamas are a lot of times not Gurmat at all. My conclusion from above verses: Rehitnamas are not to be trusted unless they are given an 'okay' By the ultimate Litmus test- Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj, ultimate source of Gurmat, Gurbani, and Gyan. Anything in maharaj is authentic, and anything not going in line with Maharaj is not authentic. Anything other than Gurbani cannot be trusted blindly. That is why I'm such a advocate of the Sikh Rehit Maryada, since 99% of it can easily be found in Gurbani, and the Saints/sampardava/Jathebandiya/scholars, have worked more than one and a half decade on comparing Rehitnamas to Gurbani, and finally drafted a booklet with the Gurmat-sidant, atey assult mutabak rehit maryada. I Think it is extremely important that the authority and sovereignty of the Akal Thakhat not be disrespected. Interesting discussion, and hopefully we can carry on with a peaceful and loving manner. Bhull chukk maaf.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 25 Mar 2006

The description of amrit is just flowery prose. It doesn't encourage worship of these entities in any way. If you want to apply the test of "no Hindu references" then even Gurbani or Bhai Gurdas's Vaaran don't meet it. Where at all does it say to revere Hindu gods? Reference 53 (they're not verses) does not say it's acceptable to have intercourse outside of marriage. You're reading that in yourself. Bhai Vir Singh and Bhai Kanh Singh: You said [i]"I see him as an unbias person, since he didn't have anything to do with the rehitmaryada."[/i] When debating, please do some research before making assertions. Both of them were involved in the drafting of the Rehit Maryada. Their names appear in the list that precedes it as part of the committee. It's no surprise they both define Kutha as Muslim meat. Kuthaa has it's root in "axe" or Kuthaar. When is an axe used to do halal? Then you go about giving translations of "abhaakhiya ka kuthaa". That's entirely the point LK. It says "abhaakiyaa" which is a reference to the Kalma. Why would it say "kalma-kutha" if Kuthaa itself is a reference to halal? Why be redundant and say Muslim-Kutha if kutha is halal anyways? In fact, the translation you provided "ਮਲੇਛ ਭਾਖਾ ਅਰਥਾਤ ਕਲ ਮੇਂ ਰੂਪ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਕਾ ਮਾਰਾ ਹੂਆ ਬਕਰਾ ਖਾਣਾ " goes exactly to my point. It is just "mara hooaa bakra" ie. Kuthaa (meat) which is qualified with "malechh bhaka" or "kalma". Without saying "kalma" it would have just been the meat of a butchered goat. See my point? How about this reference from Guru Granth Sahib: ਇਕੁ ਨਿਰੰਜਨੁ ਰਵਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਭਾਉ ਦੁਯਾ ਕੁਠਾ ॥ Does this mean that the love of duality was "halaaled" or does it mean it was killed? Yeah, means just killing/butchering. BTW. LK, are you a lawyer by profession?

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

questionable · 25 Mar 2006

it's an interesting thought, that food is filled with "vibrations". appeals to the "mystics" amongst us. food made by baptised sikhs=magical and pure while food made by the rest of the world=unholy and not fit for the faithful all respect to rehitnaamay aside, i believe guru nanak dev ji would shun such an attempt at creating a closed society.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 25 Mar 2006

questionable, Guru Nanak wanted his Sikhs to have the society of other Gursikhs. This is a lock on that. Social relations (roti-beti di sanjh) is restricted to Gursikhs. Food prepared by Gurmukhs is magical. Amrit is prepared by the Punj Pyaaray through bani. What could be more mystical and pure? ਵੇਦੀਨਾ ਕੀ ਦੋਸਤੀ ਵੇਦੀਨਾ ਕਾ ਖਾਣੁ ॥ ਸਿਫਤੀ ਸਾਰ ਨ ਜਾਣਨੀ ਸਦਾ ਵਸੈ ਸੈਤਾਨੁ ॥

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

questionable · 25 Mar 2006

..., Guru Nanak Dev Ji's life is in contradiction to your statement that "Guru Nanak wanted his Sikhs to have the society of other Gursikhs." Guru Nanak Dev Ji spent such a huge portion of his life travelling and being a guest in other societies. He not only ate with these people, he ate the food that they had prepared. How can his life and example be in line with the practice of limiting our interactions with the world through food only prepared by Gursikhs? And, to take it further, wouldn't the logical extrapolation be for Gursikhs to also grow all of their food personally? Because the majority of the world's food is planted and harvested by poor peasants, many of whom do not lead lives dictated by their faiths because of the extenuating circumstances of living a life of abject poverty. Do their hands make "bibeki" food less pure? Or is it only the hands of the people whom you can see touching/cutting/cooking your food? I respect your decision to partake in the company of the faithful only. However, I do not believe "bibeki" as you describe it, is in line with the Guru's ideals of society. Lastly, I was of the impression that we do not believe in magic or mysticism. The discussion is on food, and not on amrit, which I agree, recieves its power through bani. How is food prepared by Gurmukhs magical and why would anyone need magical food to lead an enlightened spiritual life? Thank you for engaging these questions. Respectfully questioning kaur

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 25 Mar 2006

Questioning Kaur, You said, "Guru Nanak Dev Ji's life is in contradiction to your statement that "Guru Nanak wanted his Sikhs to have the society of other Gursikhs." Guru Nanak Dev Ji spent such a huge portion of his life travelling and being a guest in other societies." What was Guru Nanak's mission on these journeys to go sight seeing and take in the cultures? I would suggest to you it was to make Sikhs and bring people on to the path of Gurmat. It wasn't a cultural exchange or vacation of course. As for poor people touching my food: the poorest of the poor could touch my food as long as they were Gurmukhs reciting naam. Social commentary really has no place in this debate because it's not a socio-economic question in any way. Dry raw materials as well as oils/ghee are considered fine to use. This is because they are cooked by a Gurmukh and given the stamp of Sarbloh. These aren't processed foods, and will be made into something by a Gurmukh reciting naam/bani. Bhain jee, if you think Sikhi doesn't believe in "magic" or "mysticism", I would suggest to you that naam is the biggest magic and the greatest mysticism. The power in naam isn't something that lends itself to rational explanation. It carries power with it that is beyond words. I myself had the same very logical/scientific attitude until I read Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh's autobiography and realised the power of naam. Finally you agreed it was the power of bani which makes amrit special and gives it's power. I would add the role of sarbloh as well. In the same way, food prepared in sarbloh by Gurmukhs reciting bani and naam does have spiritual power. It gives the food a certain vibration that is very conducive to spirituality. Bibek rehit is essential for a Gursikh. Guru Sahib has said that the food of the saakat (faithless) is poison. Guru Sahib has said that bhagti does not reside within someone who eats the food of the faithless.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

d · 26 Mar 2006

sarbloh bibek is obviously a compulsory rehit for every amritdhari

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

LK · 26 Mar 2006

Author: ... Date: 03-25-06 17:11 The description of amrit is just flowery prose. It doesn't encourage worship of these entities in any way. If you want to apply the test of "no Hindu references" then even Gurbani or Bhai Gurdas's Vaaran don't meet it. Where at all does it say to revere Hindu gods? Reference 53 (they're not verses) does not say it's acceptable to have intercourse outside of marriage. You're reading that in yourself. Bhai Vir Singh and Bhai Kanh Singh: You said "I see him as an unbias person, since he didn't have anything to do with the rehitmaryada." When debating, please do some research before making assertions. Both of them were involved in the drafting of the Rehit Maryada. Their names appear in the list that precedes it as part of the committee. It's no surprise they both define Kutha as Muslim meat. -------------- I was indeed mistaken on those two scholars. However, let's remember that Bhai Kahn Singh is also used by people of the Jatha to refer to scholars who believe raagmala isn't bani. I have referred to several other scholars, such as Prof Sahib Singh who clearly says Kutha - hallal. You have yet to defend your point from a scholars writings. ---------------- Kuthaa has it's root in "axe" or Kuthaar. When is an axe used to do halal? Then you go about giving translations of "abhaakhiya ka kuthaa". That's entirely the point LK. It says "abhaakiyaa" which is a reference to the Kalma. Why would it say "kalma-kutha" if Kuthaa itself is a reference to halal? Why be redundant and say Muslim-Kutha if kutha is halal anyways? In fact, the translation you provided "ਮਲੇਛ ਭਾਖਾ ਅਰਥਾਤ ਕਲ ਮੇਂ ਰੂਪ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਕਾ ਮਾਰਾ ਹੂਆ ਬਕਰਾ ਖਾਣਾ " goes exactly to my point. It is just "mara hooaa bakra" ie. Kuthaa (meat) which is qualified with "malechh bhaka" or "kalma". Without saying "kalma" it would have just been the meat of a butchered goat. See my point? ------------------------ Nahi jee, I have not fully comprehended (feeling ashamed), I have not understood you, could you please re-phrase yourself? If I understand it correctly, it (kutha) means something that has been killed WITH the kalma... Please clearfy your point, as I have not understood you completely. ------------------ How about this reference from Guru Granth Sahib: ਇਕੁ ਨਿਰੰਜਨੁ ਰਵਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਭਾਉ ਦੁਯਾ ਕੁਠਾ ॥ Does this mean that the love of duality was "halaaled" or does it mean it was killed? Yeah, means just killing/butchering. BTW. LK, are you a lawyer by profession? --------------------- In this context, it doesn't have anything to do with 'killing/butchering', in this context, both prof Sahib Singh, and Sant SIngh Khalsa translates it as 'destroyed' or [gurbani]kuTw—nws ho jWdw hY [/gurbani]. If this has anything to do with this discussion on Gurmat, no I am not a lawyer. Bhull Chukk maaf

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

Jaap naam!! · 26 Mar 2006

Just jaap naam...if no one keeps bebik because of 'dhila mind' then carry on..just like a death person, when you give a death person a sweet..'Ghur' then he will not be able to describe what he has tasted!! The people that argue are the ones that have not got anything inside...!! The people that have had the sweet they can not describe it and wont argue...the ones that have got nothing argue!! Gurrroo

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 26 Mar 2006

LK, I will try again to explain how Kutha means just meat: Abhaakhiyaa means Kalma. It is only in this ONE context in Guru Granth Sahib where the word Kuthha can be linked to "halal meat". Why? Because of the presence of the word "abhaakhiyaa" to qualify it. If Kuttha meant just "Halal meat", then the presence of "abhaakhiya" would not be required. Kalma-Halal meat would be redundant. But because Kuthaa is just "meat", it required "abhaakhiyaa" to show it's a reference to Muslim meat here. The translations you posted reveal the same thing (my comments in italics): >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> [gurbani]ABwiKAw kw kuTw bkrw Kwxw ][/gurbani] Sant Singh Khalsa, who translates on STTM translates it as - ----------- abhaakhiaa kaa kut(h)aa bakaraa khaanaa || They eat the meat of the goats, killed after the Muslim prayers are read over the, http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=1738 ---------- >>>>>>>>>>>>> [i]Abhaakhiya means the "Kalmaa". Look at the above translation. Kutha is just meat of goats. It becomes associated to Muslims because of the phrase "abhaakhiyaa". [/i] >>>>>>>>>>>> Bhai Manmohan Singh refers to Kutha as (Both Punjabi and English explaination are by BHai Manmohan Singh) - ------ abhaakhi-aa kaa kuthaa bakraa khaanaa. He eats the he-goat killed by uttering the foreign (Muslim-Kalma) words. ਪਰਦੇਸੀ ਸ਼ਬਦ ਉਚਾਰਨ ਕਰਕੇ ਮਾਰੇ ਹੋਏ ਬੱਕਰੇ ਨੂੰ ਉਹ ਖਾਂਦਾ ਹੈ। >>>>>>>>>>>> [i]Here once again, the translation qualifies just a killed goat (kuthaa) with abhaakhiyaa (kalma) to take the meaning of Halal. Otherwise kutha here is just meat.[/i] ------------- Freedkot vala teeka defines it as follows- ਅਭਾਖਿਆ ਕਾ ਕੁਠਾ ਬਕਰਾ ਖਾਣਾ ॥ ਚਉਕੇ ਉਪਰਿ ਕਿਸੈ ਨ ਜਾਣਾ ॥ abhaakhi-aa kaa kuthaa bakraa khaanaa. cha-ukay upar kisai na jaanaa. (ਅਭਾਖਿਆ) ਮਲੇਛ ਭਾਖਾ ਅਰਥਾਤ ਕਲ ਮੇਂ ਰੂਪ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਕਾ ਮਾਰਾ ਹੂਆ ਬਕਰਾ ਖਾਣਾ ਕਰਤੇ ਹੋ ਫੇਰ ਕਹਤੇ ਹੋ ਹਮਾਰੇ ਚੌਕੇ ਉਪਰ ਕਿਸੇ ਨੇ ਜਾਣਾ ਨਹੀਂ ਭਾਵ ਕੋਈ ਨ ਜਾਓ ਚਉਕਾ ਅਸੁਧੁ ਹੋ ਜਾਵੇਗਾ॥ -------------- http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=472&g=1&h=1&r=1&t=0&p=0&k=2 [i]here once again, the translation says it's just "ਮਾਰਾ ਹੂਆ ਬਕਰਾ " but because of "abhaakhiyaa" it is "(ਅਭਾਖਿਆ) ਮਲੇਛ ਭਾਖਾ ਅਰਥਾਤ ਕਲ ਮੇਂ ਰੂਪ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਕਾ" ie. Muslim Kutha. [/i] Here are other examples to show that Kutha means just killed or butchered: ਇਕੁ ਨਿਰੰਜਨੁ ਰਵਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਭਾਉ ਦੁਯਾ ਕੁਠਾ ॥ You said this has "nothing to do with killing". Use your intellect as opposed to relying blindly on direct interpretations of translations. Dr. Sahib Singh has translated Kutha hear to mean "naas ho janda" this means to destroy. To destroy is to kill. It means the same thing. Kuthaa is just a reference to killing (butchering), the meat produced is also called "Kutha". As for which "scholars" I'm relying on: I don't need to crutch a clear argument on what scholars say, but if you want a further reference, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has written on this in his book "Jhatkaa Maas Parthai Tat Gurmat Nirnai".

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

? · 26 Mar 2006

"if no one keeps bebik because of 'dhila mind' then carry on" sorry paaji/penji did you mean that those who dont keep bibek dont becuase they have a tilla mind?

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

Jaap naam!! · 26 Mar 2006

Sorry deaf not death!! OPssiii!! >>sorry paaji/penji did you mean that those who dont keep bibek dont becuase they have a tilla mind?<< It is a dhil...!! one is just trying to ignore the rehit because they cant be bothered!

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

Harsimran Kaur · 26 Mar 2006

I spent some time to read all the above and I like to suggest that meat is banned, rehanamas are correct as long as they are according to Gurbani (had been mixed up by our enemies), kirtan can be done in or out raags with devotion if we can read Gurbani then we can also sing it without raags. If you have doubts about anything then ask Guru ji directly (find a way to talk and understand Guru ji). Raagmala is not Gurbani (ask Guru ji if you can read it or not if you have doubts). It was a good discussion but instead of doubting Guru ji 's rehat and teachings do naam simran and read Gurbani. Sarabloh is a good thing but should be prepared and eaten freshly and extra food should not be kept in the sarabloh bhande. As for dry atta etc. I would suggest that in India I have met singhs who were used to wash wheat or corn then dry it and make atta, using home made ghee as well. They were used to milk themselves. Every thing is possible. You don't need to rely on others. Like we are not living in India so try your best to keep rehat as it is important. The best thing is reading Gurbani and following it. May Waheguru bless us. Your best wisher

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

? · 26 Mar 2006

"one is just trying to ignore the rehit because they cant be bothered!" how do you know thats true maybe their ignoring the "rehat" becuase they believe its more important to concentrate on other rehats first at the end of the day bibek is all about naam and helping us to do more naam just becuase someone doesn't follow bibek doesnt mean they cant be bothered.maybe this is why you didnt follow bibek, but others have their reasons, such as concentrating on doing as much naam simran ans they can reading as much paath as they can and doing as much seva. what about gursikhs such as bhai rama singh ji and bhai raghbir singh who do not follow bibek i don't think its because they can't be bothered i think its because they dont see it as a madatory rehat if it h elps you then do it but dont critisise others for not following this "rehat" /others would call it "bipran kee reet" and i'm not referring to "bibek" when i say this becuase bibek is a whole way fo life i'm reffering to the idea that bibek is "not eating from the hands of non-amritdharis and in some cases not eating from the hands of only bibekis"

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

LK · 27 Mar 2006

The description of amrit is just flowery prose. It doesn't encourage worship of these entities in any way. If you want to apply the test of "no Hindu references" then even Gurbani or Bhai Gurdas's Vaaran don't meet it. Where at all does it say to revere Hindu gods ---------------------- 1- I never said these encourage worship of those entites. I howevr do find it extremely wierd, and dubious that when Bhai Daya Singh Ji asks Guru Sahib to tell him of REHIT, Guru Sahib woudl start talking about how the kachera comes from Hanuman, etc etc. Is that something you do not find dubious? You ask Guru Sahib to tell you of Rehit, and he begisn talkign about How Sikhs get their Kachera from Hanuman. I find that extremely dubious. ------------- Author: ... Date: 03-26-06 09:01 LK, I will try again to explain how Kutha means just meat: Abhaakhiyaa means Kalma. It is only in this ONE context in Guru Granth Sahib where the word Kuthha can be linked to "halal meat". Why? Because of the presence of the word "abhaakhiyaa" to qualify it. If Kuttha meant just "Halal meat", then the presence of "abhaakhiya" would not be required. Kalma-Halal meat would be redundant. But because Kuthaa is just "meat", it required "abhaakhiyaa" to show it's a reference to Muslim meat here. --------------------- Abhakheya, does not mean Kalma. I checked up a few references on what Abhakh means.. Here's my results : Punjabi University Punjabi English dictionary- Abhakh - adj. inedible, unfit for eating, taboo; forbiden (food) Surinder SIngh Kohli - dictionary of Guru Granth Sahib similarily defines - Abakhia 1 (from sk. Abhaksha) uneatable 2. (from Sk, A+ Bhasha) Bad language, language not to be uttered) Abhakkhu (abhakh) n. (from Sk.)Abhaksha) uneatable, forbidden food Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha defines it as - "Naa Khan yog. Jis da Khana dharm anosar vedan nahi. "Lobhi Jant na Janei Bhakh abakh khai" (Sri M: 5) The bhangtee provided by Bhai Kahn Singh is vital: [gurbani]loBI jMqu n jwxeI BKu ABKu sB Kwie ][/gurbani] lobhee ja(n)th n jaanee bhakh abhakh sabh khaae || the greedy person, unaware, consumes everything, edible and non-edible alike. (ang 50) ਅਭਖੁ ਭਖਹਿ ਭਖੁ ਤਜਿ ਛੋਡਹਿ ਅੰਧੁ ਗੁਰੂ ਜਿਨ ਕੇਰਾ ॥ abhakh bhakheh bhakh taj chhodeh anDh guroo jin kayraa. They eat the uneatable; they reject and abandon what they could eat. They have a teacher who is blind. (ang 1290) Bhai Vir SIngh however gives a slightly different explaination to abhak - [Gu: Sanskrit, Abhakhs 1. na kahNE yog, 2. Athva A+ Abhakheya = Buri Bhakha] kalma (PaR ke jo Kiv khohe jande han)| yatha . 'Abhakheya ka kutha Bakra KhaNA' (472), Bhav hallal da maas khana. Bhai Vir SIngh defines Kutha as follows: " Gu:| Punjabi, KohNa to BaNda hai| kohea to Kotha ban-na Punjabi veakran da trika hai, jis tra mohna to motha te lohena to lotha banda hai. Kothna pat ko + hann (buri tra marna) sanskrit do banda japda hai. Muslamana de aya jado farsi punjabi vich ralan lagi, tado ho sakda hai ke koShtai (=mareya) da kotha roop baN geya hove, par vishesh khyal eh hai ke kohann to ko +hat, kohta kotha aio ban geya hove] 1- keha hoea. yatha - Abhakheya ka Kotha bakra Khana (472), tatha- 'tisda kotha hove shek' (856 2- Naas kiti| yatha - 'Bhao doya kotha' (329) Dekho 'Abhaekha' I understand it as follows: Kotha has several meanings, one of the meanings being 'naas kiti' i.e 'destroy', hence the shabad you provided means, as translated, litterally 'destroy', not to kill. Hindus do not eat Kutha, which they see as the 'prohibited' food. Kutha means sometihng that has been badly beaten (Bhai Vir Singh, derives the word as well) Bhai Vir SIngh however includes Kalma in his definition of 'abhkheya' because it is a property that makes the meat 'abhakheya' i.e. prohibited. If Kalma it NOT read, i.e. it is NOT Kutha, it is not prohibited, and hence not Abhkheya. The reason (as I understand it) Bhai Vir Singh includes Kalma in Abhkheya is simply because it is what MAKES it Abhakh - uneatable - prohibited food (similar to how Punjabi University and Surinder SIngh kohli defines Abakh. They do not at all mention Kalma. Referring to the Shabad 'Abhakheya ka Kutha bakra Khana' Bhai Vir Singh tells us that in this context the food becomes 'Abakh' since kalma has been read on it. Which means that Abhakheya is NOT = to Kalma, as you have stated Now lets look at the context of the Shabad: ਨੀਲ ਵਸਤ੍ਰ ਪਹਿਰਿ ਹੋਵਹਿ ਪਰਵਾਣੁ ॥ ਮਲੇਛ ਧਾਨੁ ਲੇ ਪੂਜਹਿ ਪੁਰਾਣੁ ॥ ਅਭਾਖਿਆ ਕਾ ਕੁਠਾ ਬਕਰਾ ਖਾਣਾ ॥ ਚਉਕੇ ਉਪਰਿ ਕਿਸੈ ਨ ਜਾਣਾ ॥ ਦੇ ਕੈ ਚਉਕਾ ਕਢੀ ਕਾਰ ॥ ਉਪਰਿ ਆਇ ਬੈਠੇ ਕੂੜਿਆਰ ॥ ਮਤੁ ਭਿਟੈ ਵੇ ਮਤੁ ਭਿਟੈ ॥ ਇਹੁ ਅੰਨੁ ਅਸਾਡਾ ਫਿਟੈ ॥ ਤਨਿ ਫਿਟੈ ਫੇੜ ਕਰੇਨਿ ॥ ਮਨਿ ਜੂਠੈ ਚੁਲੀ ਭਰੇਨਿ ॥ ਕਹੁ ਨਾਨਕ ਸਚੁ ਧਿਆਈਐ ॥ ਸੁਚਿ ਹੋਵੈ ਤਾ ਸਚੁ ਪਾਈਐ ॥੨॥ Wearing blue clothes, he becomes acceptable (in the eyes of Muslims). Taking bread from the Muslims he worships Puranas. He eats the he-goat killed by uttering the foreign (Muslim-Kalma) words. He allows none to enter his cooking enclosure. Plastering the ground he draws lines around it. The false come and sit upon it. They, shout "touch not, O touch not! otherwise, this food of ours will be polluted". With the polluted body, they commit evil deeds. With the impure mind, they gargle their throat. Says, Nanak, meditate thou on the True Lord. If thou art unpolluted, then alone shalt thou obtain the True One. In this Shabad, as I understand it, Guru Sahib is trying to expose the hypocracy of the Brahmins, by giving exampels how they staarted wearing 'neel vastar', taking bread from the Muslims, eating the food that is for them 'prohibited' [Kahn Singh Nabha defines Abhakh as: jis da khana dhan anosar vedhan nahi - "Lobhi jant na JaNei bhak abhakh sabh khae" (Sri M:5)], i.e. the KUTHA. Despite Kutha being against (prohibited by) their religious belief, they would STILL eat it to impress the Muslim invader, yet he doesn't allow anyone to enter his kitchen - Guru Sahib is giving a slap to the hypocrits (which ironically includes me as well, since I'm the biggest hypocrit on this planet) ************ The translations you posted reveal the same thing (my comments in italics): >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ABwiKAw kw kuTw bkrw Kwxw ] Sant Singh Khalsa, who translates on STTM translates it as - ----------- abhaakhiaa kaa kut(h)aa bakaraa khaanaa || They eat the meat of the goats, killed after the Muslim prayers are read over the, http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=1738 ---------- >>>>>>>>>>>>> Abhaakhiya means the "Kalmaa". Look at the above translation. Kutha is just meat of goats. It becomes associated to Muslims because of the phrase "abhaakhiyaa". >>>>>>>>>>>> Bhai Manmohan Singh refers to Kutha as (Both Punjabi and English explaination are by BHai Manmohan Singh) - ------ abhaakhi-aa kaa kuthaa bakraa khaanaa. He eats the he-goat killed by uttering the foreign (Muslim-Kalma) words. ਪਰਦੇਸੀ ਸ਼ਬਦ ਉਚਾਰਨ ਕਰਕੇ ਮਾਰੇ ਹੋਏ ਬੱਕਰੇ ਨੂੰ ਉਹ ਖਾਂਦਾ ਹੈ। >>>>>>>>>>>> Here once again, the translation qualifies just a killed goat (kuthaa) with abhaakhiyaa (kalma) to take the meaning of Halal. Otherwise kutha here is just meat. ------------- Freedkot vala teeka defines it as follows- ਅਭਾਖਿਆ ਕਾ ਕੁਠਾ ਬਕਰਾ ਖਾਣਾ ॥ ਚਉਕੇ ਉਪਰਿ ਕਿਸੈ ਨ ਜਾਣਾ ॥ abhaakhi-aa kaa kuthaa bakraa khaanaa. cha-ukay upar kisai na jaanaa. (ਅਭਾਖਿਆ) ਮਲੇਛ ਭਾਖਾ ਅਰਥਾਤ ਕਲ ਮੇਂ ਰੂਪ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਕਾ ਮਾਰਾ ਹੂਆ ਬਕਰਾ ਖਾਣਾ ਕਰਤੇ ਹੋ ਫੇਰ ਕਹਤੇ ਹੋ ਹਮਾਰੇ ਚੌਕੇ ਉਪਰ ਕਿਸੇ ਨੇ ਜਾਣਾ ਨਹੀਂ ਭਾਵ ਕੋਈ ਨ ਜਾਓ ਚਉਕਾ ਅਸੁਧੁ ਹੋ ਜਾਵੇਗਾ॥ -------------- http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=472&g=1&h=1&r=1&t=0&p=0&k=2 here once again, the translation says it's just "ਮਾਰਾ ਹੂਆ ਬਕਰਾ " but because of "abhaakhiyaa" it is "(ਅਭਾਖਿਆ) ਮਲੇਛ ਭਾਖਾ ਅਰਥਾਤ ਕਲ ਮੇਂ ਰੂਪ ਮੰਤ੍ਰ ਕਾ" ie. Muslim Kutha. Here are other examples to show that Kutha means just killed or butchered: ਇਕੁ ਨਿਰੰਜਨੁ ਰਵਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਭਾਉ ਦੁਯਾ ਕੁਠਾ ॥ You said this has "nothing to do with killing". Use your intellect as opposed to relying blindly on direct interpretations of translations. Dr. Sahib Singh has translated Kutha hear to mean "naas ho janda" this means to destroy. To destroy is to kill. It means the same thing. Kuthaa is just a reference to killing (butchering), the meat produced is also called "Kutha". *********************** Kalma is a property that makes it Kutha, hence why it is 'Abhakheya' i.e. prohibited food. Abhakheya is NOT kalma as you claim. Abhakheya means 'prohibited food' 'uneatable' (Punjabi Unversity dictionary, Kohli, Nabha, Prof Sahib Singh, Bhai Vir SIngh). Kalma is however something that does make something Abhakh, but Abhakheya does not MEAN kalma, as you have stated. According to both Prof Sahib Singh and BHai Vir Singh, Kutha not only means hallal, but also means to destroy something, not to kill. Kutha according to what you earlier said means MEAT, not to KILL, There's a huge difference between the two. However Prof Sahib Singh and BHai Vir SIngh both, give a second meaning to the word kutha, to destroy, to naas karna. First meaning was hallal. I agree with Harsimran Kaur that Rehitnamas are to be regarded for as long as they follow Gurbani and Gurmat. Hence why I have huge respect for the Sikh Rehit Maryada, sice it took Gurbani as a litmus test and virtually filtered out the other Rehitnamas, which have no basis in Gurbani (such as the Khalsa protecting Coews and Brahmins) It is really nice to have a friendful and respectful discussion/vichar on Gurmat, Gurbani and other Sikh litterature. I have greatly benifitted from this discussion, as it has made me actively look things up and learn new things. I hope we can carry on doing vichar/gurmat discussions in a such manner. Bhull chukk maaf

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 27 Mar 2006

LK, Perhaps you are honestly making these mistakes or losing the plot due to lack of knowledge, but your latest post is totally off base. I sincerely hope you're arguing honestly and not putting up arguments for the sake of argument. The difference between ਅਭਾਖਿਆ and ਭਖੁ or "[gurbani]BKxw[/gurbani]" is important. There is a difference of a kanna as well "[gurbani]BK[/gurbani]" which is to eat and "[gurbani]BwK[/gurbani]" which is to speak/say. You quite corecctly identified that ਭਖੁ means to eat. But that's not the word here. It is ਅ-ਭਾਖਿਆ. Bhakiyaa means to speak/langauge. In Japji Sahib everyday we read [gurbani]swcw swihbu swcu nwie BwiKAw Bwau Apwru ][/gurbani]. It means "speech" in this context. There are some instances of [gurbani]BwiKAw[/gurbani] being a past-tense verb for having eaten, but this isn't the case here. It just wouldn't fit, and besides this is [gurbani]ABwiKAw[/gurbani]which isn't a word that can possible relate to eating (being a verb, the "A" wouldn't make any sense). This is agreed upon by every single translator. Abhakhyaa then means the "un-utterable", this would be the Kalma because by uttering that, a Hindu becomes a Muslim. All the translators have translated "Abhakhyaa" as the Kalma. Then you went back to your point that Kuthaa means to destroy and not meat. Kuthaa means to kill/destroy/naas karna. It's synonomous. Kuthaa is clear related to this term. Kutha refers to the act (of killing/destroying) and also the product (meat). A word that operate simillarly is "[gurbani]muTw[/gurbani]" It means to loot or steal, but it also refers to the product, which is something stolen or obtained through bad means. So you see, saying kutha refers to the act of destroying or killing and then saying the product is just Halal meat doesn't make any logical sense and has no basis in fact. So once again, it only becomes Halal meat in the example you provided because it says ਅਭਾਖਿਆ. Otherwise it was just meat. Please once again refer to all the translations you yourself provided which confirm that it was just meat until it is qualified with ਅਭਾਖਿਆ (Kalma) where it then becomes Halal. I hope this satisfies you that Kuthaa means just meat and not Halal.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

give up? · 27 Mar 2006

please give it up you are arguing for the sake of it and you clearly need to go and research the material before you start questioning everything?

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

m singh · 28 Mar 2006

vjkk vjkf!!! Was Bhai Rama Singh sarbloh bebeki???????????????? vjkk vjkf!!

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

LK · 28 Mar 2006

Author: ... Date: 03-27-06 09:59 LK, Perhaps you are honestly making these mistakes or losing the plot due to lack of knowledge, but your latest post is totally off base. I sincerely hope you're arguing honestly and not putting up arguments for the sake of argument. The difference between ਅਭਾਖਿਆ and ਭਖੁ or "BKxw" is important. There is a difference of a kanna as well "BK" which is to eat and "BwK" which is to speak/say. You quite corecctly identified that ਭਖੁ means to eat. But that's not the word here. It is ਅ-ਭਾਖਿਆ. Bhakiyaa means to speak/langauge. In Japji Sahib everyday we read swcw swihbu swcu nwie BwiKAw Bwau Apwru ]. It means "speech" in this context. There are some instances of BwiKAw being a past-tense verb for having eaten, but this isn't the case here. It just wouldn't fit, and besides this is ABwiKAwwhich isn't a word that can possible relate to eating (being a verb, the "A" wouldn't make any sense). This is agreed upon by every single translator. Abhakhyaa then means the "un-utterable", this would be the Kalma because by uttering that, a Hindu becomes a Muslim. All the translators have translated "Abhakhyaa" as the Kalma. Then you went back to your point that Kuthaa means to destroy and not meat. Kuthaa means to kill/destroy/naas karna. It's synonomous. Kuthaa is clear related to this term. Kutha refers to the act (of killing/destroying) and also the product (meat). A word that operate simillarly is "muTw" It means to loot or steal, but it also refers to the product, which is something stolen or obtained through bad means. So you see, saying kutha refers to the act of destroying or killing and then saying the product is just Halal meat doesn't make any logical sense and has no basis in fact. So once again, it only becomes Halal meat in the example you provided because it says ਅਭਾਖਿਆ. Otherwise it was just meat. Please once again refer to all the translations you yourself provided which confirm that it was just meat until it is qualified with ਅਭਾਖਿਆ (Kalma) where it then becomes Halal. I hope this satisfies you that Kuthaa means just meat and not Halal. ----------------------------------- Bhai Sahib/Bhenji '...' jeeyo, I ahve read you post, re-looked my references (of which I had made some bluners on the way), and I had honestly made some mistakes here and there, such as looking up 'abhakh' without a 'kanna' etc. You were right Abhakheya does mean un-utterable, or something from a foreign language. I was mistaken when I looked it up. The Shabad I provided 'Abakheya ka Kutha Bakra Khana', in no way supports my argument, and I was mistaken. I Apologize for that. On the other hand, I looked up the definition of Kutha in other places, Such as the Punjabi University dictionary (Previously, I only looked up Abakh which was also the wrong spelling [doh!!], now I looked up Kutha). This time, I looked up 'Kutha', and Punjabi University dictionary also defines 'kutha' as hallal. It would be like saying that Oxford University Dictionary defines a word in English wrong (possible, but unlikely) Thus, there are now four reliable references (which are well researched, and, in certain places the word has been derived from other languages) For Example, Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha, derives it from ' ਕੁਹਣਾ', which he defines as '੨. ਕੁ- ਹਨਨ. ਬੇਰਹਮੀ ਨਾਲ ਜਾਨ ਲੈਣ ਦੀ ਕ੍ਰਿਯਾ. ਮੁਸਲਮਾਂਨੀ ਤਰੀਕੇ ਨਾਲ ਜਿਬਹਿ ਕਰਨਾ.' Bhai Vir Singh also writes something along the lines of 'buri tara mareya hoya' [just paraphrased] Prof Sahib Singh, too defines it as hallal. Punjabi University dictionary too, defines it as hallal. If we do go and research example what they base the definition on, I am sure we can find an answer. Will personally look into this, and ask some other knowledge persons (those who know languages such as Sanskrit,) etc. As it seems right now = I was mistaken about Abkheya, and I apologize for taking so much o your time for that. Kutha still means halla according to above solid references. Bhull Chukk maaf

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 28 Mar 2006

LK, We all know that at the present time and since the inception of the SRM, "kuthaa" has been defined as halal meat. All dictionaries are going to say that. Kohna/Kuthaar are the sources of this word. It is to kill. At the times of Guru Sahib and the contexts it is found in Guru Granth Sahib, it means only meant and to kill. See the "muthaa" argument above. At the present time, just because the definition has been changed to mean Kutha=badly killed/butchered=halal, doesn't mean that's the right one. This logic is based on the belief that Jhatka is acceptable because it's not Kohna and it's quick. Meat is meat. Gurbani doesn't draw any distinction between it. Kuthaa just means meat in bani. But if you will not still accept this, then all I can suggest is we agree to disagree and let the readers of this debate reach the conclusion that is most convincing to them.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

LK · 28 Mar 2006

'...' Jeeyo, I believe that meat is 'maas', and 'kutha' means 'meat' especially considering that a lot of rehitnamas bring out prohibiting kutha when slandering muslims and spurring hatred towards muslims (in several contexts) i.e Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnamas first talks about hallal, then about prostitutes, and then about associateing with Muslims again. [35] As for the SRM, I'm not sure of Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha's kosh, but I believe Bhai Vir Singh's kosh's first edition came before the SRM. ------- Kohna/Kuthaar are the sources of this word. It is to kill. At the times of Guru Sahib and the contexts it is found in Guru Granth Sahib, it means only meant and to kill. See the "muthaa" argument above. -------- I have not read the definition of 'kutha' by Bhai Vir Singh very properly, but interestingly enoughm he derives the word, and just like you compares it to 'mutha', and is still able to defines it as 'hallal'. If you are interested (which I doubt) in how he derives it, I can scan it in for you... Kohna means to kill/slaughter, as you say, but is it after 'badly beaten/butchered' according to Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha. Bhai Kahn Singh ਕੁਹਣਾ - ਦੇਖੋ, ਕੁਸ਼ਤਨ. “ਜੀਆਂ ਕੁਹਤ ਨ ਸੰਗੈ ਪਰਾਣੀ”. (ਗਉ ਮਃ ੫) ੨. ਕੁ- ਹਨਨ. ਬੇਰਹਮੀ ਨਾਲ ਜਾਨ ਲੈਣ ਦੀ ਕ੍ਰਿਯਾ. ਮੁਸਲਮਾਂਨੀ ਤਰੀਕੇ ਨਾਲ ਜਿਬਹਿ ਕਰਨਾ. ਕੁਸ਼ਤਨ - ਫ਼ਾ. __ਕ੍ਰਿ- ਮਾਰਸੁੱਟਣਾ. ਕ਼ਤਲ (ਵਧ) ਕਰਨਾ. Bhai Vir Singh also goes into detail on how it is derived. Punjabi University, which was set up to promote the Punjabi lanauage, was also effected by the SRM? Possible, not plausible. At the same time, seeing the context where it is written many times, it has been written where a lot of hatred towards muslims has been expressed Just to clearify, just because kutha means 'hallal', I am in no way saying meat is okay, or should be eaten. I do accept to agree to disagree with you Bhenji/Bhai Sahib. Thank you for teaching me the difference between the two 'abhakh'-s the one without kana and with kana. This discussion has been benificial for me personally, and I sincerely thank you for the several things you have taught me during it. Bhull chukk maaf

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 28 Mar 2006

LK, This discussion started on the Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnama and turned into a debate on kuthaa. I want to take the discussion back to Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama. You said, >>>>>>>>> If you read verse 53, it will tell you about the forth Kurehit, which it says is having sex with a muslim, brahman women, minors, sister, relative, or someone from his own lineage. It does not say Sex outside marraiage is banned. >>>>>>>>> Wrong. I've actually taken the time to go over the Rehitnama in detail. It says not to have intercourse with anyone else's "Wife, daughter, sister or mother" The Mcleod translation says another Sikhs, but the Punjabi says if a Sikhs has these relations with anothers wife, daughter sister or mother. Even if we take the Mcleod version, it cuts out Muslim women, Hindu women and Sikh women (who aren't your wife). That amounts to the bujjer kurehit we have today. Back to the maas issue. All over the rehitnama it refers to Muslim meat as "Turak kaa maas". The Mcleod book references are paragraphs 35, 57, 59. All of these say "turak kaa maas" is forbidden. Clearly Turak ka maas is Halal. All of a sudden at 79, we see the term " kuthaa". In what context? This paragraph is a reference to non-Muslim meat. Kuthaa is meat in general. The paragraph is strong proof of this. Wherever it meant Halal, it refrenced "turak ka maas", here, the rehitnama covers non-Muslim meat. It says not to eat Kuthaa (meat in general) and also mentions Pig and Donkey (both forbidden to Muslims). This paragraph (to repeat myself) is to specifically cover the non-Muslim types of meat out there. Hence the very specific references to Pig and Donkey. I'll anticipate a counter-argument here. I expect if someone wanted to be ridiculously argumentative they'd say "well, he just chose to use a synonomous term for halal here for variety". Clearly that's non-sensical because for the previous 3 arguments he used "turak ka maas" so why change here? And the references to Pig and Donkey are totally anomalous and don't fit unless you see that the entire paragraph is a reference to meat forbidden to Muslims (kutha being just regular meat, not special Halal meat which Muslims require). So perhaps the strongest evidence that Kuttha is just meat in general (and clearly NON-Muslim meat) is in Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama itself.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

-b- · 28 Mar 2006

ouch. game over LK....case closed.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

LK · 29 Mar 2006

----------------- Author: ... Date: 03-28-06 21:09 LK, This discussion started on the Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnama and turned into a debate on kuthaa. I want to take the discussion back to Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama. You said, >>>>>>>>> If you read verse 53, it will tell you about the forth Kurehit, which it says is having sex with a muslim, brahman women, minors, sister, relative, or someone from his own lineage. It does not say Sex outside marraiage is banned. >>>>>>>>> Wrong. I've actually taken the time to go over the Rehitnama in detail. It says not to have intercourse with anyone else's "Wife, daughter, sister or mother" The Mcleod translation says another Sikhs, but the Punjabi says if a Sikhs has these relations with anothers wife, daughter sister or mother. Even if we take the Mcleod version, it cuts out Muslim women, Hindu women and Sikh women (who aren't your wife). That amounts to the bujjer kurehit we have today. --------------------------------------- Veer jeeyo, I am indeed using Mcleod's translation (only for translation purposes, I have not and don't plan on reading his earlier section, so don't worry, i' not a mcleod-ist). When reading Mcleods traslation another's wife is not found at that place. Now that you've decide to come back to Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnama, I would like to have a straight answer, a yes or no. You previously (in the athing thread) about how else does anyone expect to get rehit (reliable) other than if the Guru himself dictates it, so when Bhai Daya Singh Ji asks Guru Ji to narrate him the Rehit, Guru ji supposedly starts talking about how Sikhs have gotten their kachera from hanuman. Do you believe that, that is something Dashmesh pita ji would say? I am expecting a simple yes or no. My point of bringing up kutha, was simply to show that several things appear in Rehitnama several times, which doesn't necessarily say that they are according to Gurmat. Another case that could be brought up, is how Bhai Desa Singh claims it a duty of the Sikh to protect cows and bahmans ਗੋ ਬ੍ਹਹਮਣ ਕੀ ਰਖਿਅਾ ਕਰੈ | ਤੁਰਕਨ ਸੋ ਅਤਿ ਹਠ ਕਰਿ ਮਰੈ ਤੁਰਕ ਦੇਕ ਨਹਿ ਸੀਸ ਨੀਵਾਵੈ | ਰਹਤਵਤ ਸੋ ਸਿਘ ਕਹਾਵੈ |16| [I wasn't able to put the tippi/bindis/addaks...] I believe Bhai Chaupa Singh also brings this up, along with how Brahman should be asked to preform the Anand Karj. These are all obvious modifications. That was my only point. That was what I was trying to say - no matter how many rehitnamas say something they have to be measured on the scale of Gurbani, the ultimate and eternal truth. ************* Back to the maas issue. All over the rehitnama it refers to Muslim meat as "Turak kaa maas". The Mcleod book references are paragraphs 35, 57, 59. All of these say "turak kaa maas" is forbidden. Clearly Turak ka maas is Halal. All of a sudden at 79, we see the term " kuthaa". In what context? This paragraph is a reference to non-Muslim meat. Kuthaa is meat in general. The paragraph is strong proof of this. Wherever it meant Halal, it refrenced "turak ka maas", here, the rehitnama covers non-Muslim meat. It says not to eat Kuthaa (meat in general) and also mentions Pig and Donkey (both forbidden to Muslims). This paragraph (to repeat myself) is to specifically cover the non-Muslim types of meat out there. Hence the very specific references to Pig and Donkey. I'll anticipate a counter-argument here. I expect if someone wanted to be ridiculously argumentative they'd say "well, he just chose to use a synonomous term for halal here for variety". Clearly that's non-sensical because for the previous 3 arguments he used "turak ka maas" so why change here? And the references to Pig and Donkey are totally anomalous and don't fit unless you see that the entire paragraph is a reference to meat forbidden to Muslims (kutha being just regular meat, not special Halal meat which Muslims require). ********************* 1. I thought we agreed to disagree? I guess not. It's okay. It's human nature. 2. If it has not been used as synonomous term, please tell me why 'musalli', and 'turkani' as intervariably been used? Can we sat that one of these do not refer to muslims? The same argument can clearly be applied to GUrbani. If the word 'maas' (which i assume we agree) means meat, why would Guru Ji suddenly start using the word 'kutha' at some instances? ******* It says not to eat Kuthaa (meat in general) and also mentions Pig and Donkey (both forbidden to Muslims). This paragraph (to repeat myself) is to specifically cover the non-Muslim types of meat out there. Hence the very specific references to Pig and Donkey. So perhaps the strongest evidence that Kuttha is just meat in general (and clearly NON-Muslim meat) is in Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama itself. ******* Why would the author, first talk about meat in general, and then suddenly mention meat forbidden to Muslims? To me, this makes no sense. Also as far as I'm aware, only pig is forbiden to muslims (first time I hear, donkay is too.) Please elaborate bhen/veer jeeyo On a side note, you veer jeeyo/bhen jeeyo said that the very product of the verb (i.e the product of kutha, would be meat in your opinion, hallal in my opinion), isn't gurbani saying that the product of doing kutha is 'halla' here - And 956 - ਮ: ੧ ॥ ਸਚ ਕੀ ਕਾਤੀ ਸਚੁ ਸਭੁ ਸਾਰੁ ॥ ਘਾੜਤ ਤਿਸ ਕੀ ਅਪਰ ਅਪਾਰ ॥ ਸਬਦੇ ਸਾਣ ਰਖਾਈ ਲਾਇ ॥ ਗੁਣ ਕੀ ਥੇਕੈ ਵਿਚਿ ਸਮਾਇ ॥ ਤਿਸ ਦਾ ਕੁਠਾ ਹੋਵੈ ਸੇਖੁ ॥ ਲੋਹੂ ਲਬੁ ਨਿਕਥਾ ਵੇਖੁ ॥ ਹੋਇ ਹਲਾਲੁ ਲਗੈ ਹਕਿ ਜਾਇ ॥ ਨਾਨਕ ਦਰਿ ਦੀਦਾਰਿ ਸਮਾਇ ॥੨॥ http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=956&punjabi=t&id=41036#l41036 [A pretty photographic Shabad :)] First Mehl: The knife is Truth, and its steel is totally True. Its workmanship is incomparably beautiful. It is sharpened on the grindstone of the Shabad. It is placed in the scabbard of virtue. If the Shaykh is killed with that, then the blood of greed will spill out. One who is slaughtered in this ritualistic way, will be attached to the Lord. O Nanak, at the Lord's door, he is absorbed into His Blessed Vision. ||2|| ਅਰਥ: ਜੇ ਪ੍ਰਭੂ ਦੇ ਨਾਮ ਦੀ ਛੁਰੀ ਹੋਵੇ, ਪ੍ਰਭੂ ਦਾ ਨਾਮ ਹੀ (ਉਸ ਛੁਰੀ ਦਾ) ਸਾਰਾ ਲੋਹਾ ਹੋਵੇ, ਉਸ ਛੁਰੀ ਦੀ ਘਾੜਤ ਬਹੁਤ ਸੁੰਦਰ ਹੁੰਦੀ ਹੈ; ਇਹ ਛੁਰੀ ਸਤਿਗੁਰੂ ਦੇ ਸ਼ਬਦ ਦੀ ਸਾਣ ਤੇ ਰੱਖ ਕੇ ਤੇਜ਼ ਕੀਤੀ ਜਾਂਦੀ ਹੈ, ਤੇ ਇਹ ਪ੍ਰਭੂ ਦੇ ਗੁਣਾਂ ਦੀ ਮਿਆਨ ਵਿਚ ਟਿਕੀ ਰਹਿੰਦੀ ਹੈ। ਜੇ ਸ਼ੇਖ਼ ਇਸ ਛੁਰੀ ਦਾ ਕੁੱਠਾ ਹੋਇਆ ਹੋਵੇ (ਭਾਵ, ਜੇ 'ਸ਼ੇਖ਼' ਦਾ ਜੀਵਨ ਪ੍ਰਭੂ ਦੇ ਨਾਮ, ਸਤਿਗੁਰੂ ਦੇ ਸ਼ਬਦ ਤੇ ਪ੍ਰਭੂ ਦੀ ਸਿਫ਼ਤਿ ਸਾਲਾਹ ਵਿਚ ਘੜਿਆ ਹੋਇਆ ਹੋਵੇ) ਤਾਂ ਉਸ ਦੇ ਅੰਦਰੋਂ ਲੱਬ ਰੂਪ ਲਹੂ ਜ਼ਰੂਰ ਨਿਕਲ ਜਾਂਦਾ ਹੈ, ਇਸ ਤਰ੍ਹਾਂ ਹਲਾਲ ਹੋ ਕੇ (ਕੁੱਠਾ ਜਾ ਕੇ) ਉਹ ਪ੍ਰਭੂ ਵਿਚ ਜੁੜਦਾ ਹੈ, ਤੇ, ਹੇ ਨਾਨਕ! ਪ੍ਰਭੂ ਦੇ ਦਰ ਤੇ (ਅੱਪੜ ਕੇ) ਉਸ ਦੇ ਦਰਸ਼ਨ ਵਿਚ ਲੀਨ ਹੋ ਜਾਂਦਾ ਹੈ ॥੨॥ (Prof Sahib Singh Ji) Although this Shabad has nothing to do with meat, the metaphors used in it are valueble when doing vichar. I understand ths should as Maharaj, is telling this sheykh/person, that the true 'kutha' (hallal - something seen by Muslims as clean - unpolluted) is in geting rid of the blood of 'greed', with the knife of 'truth'. When that kind of 'kutha' is done (i.e. removing the 'blood of greed', using the 'knife of truth'), The product is the true hallal (true cleanliness, being attached to the lord) The Shabad, has once again nothing to do with meat, but as I understand it, Guru Ji's metaphor of using 'kotha' (butchered/badly beaten) and showing that the product back then, as well as today is the same: hallal. I might have misunderstood the shabad, but let's do vichar on it, and please share your understanding of this shabad (I may have misunderstood it completly) Bhull chukk maaf Karni

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

... · 29 Mar 2006

LK, It's impossible to debate with you. It's absolutely clear you have no interest but to argue for the sake of arguing. Any third party would be able to see now that kutha means meat. You said, >>>>>>>> If it has not been used as synonomous term, please tell me why 'musalli', and 'turkani' as intervariably been used? Can we sat that one of these do not refer to muslims? The same argument can clearly be applied to GUrbani. If the word 'maas' (which i assume we agree) means meat, why would Guru Ji suddenly start using the word 'kutha' at some instances? >>>>>>>> What are you talking about?? It says "turak ka maas" 3 times and where "kutha" was used, there is no mention of "turkani" or "musalli". Your sentence doesn't make much sense. Your second point of why Guru Sahib would choose to use "kutha" at other instances: Guru Sahib never makes the switch in one shabad. Just like many other words, he uses one term in one place and another somwhere else. Why does Guru Sahib called hand "kar" one place, "hast" elsewhere and "haath" at another? Then you said, >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Why would the author, first talk about meat in general, and then suddenly mention meat forbidden to Muslims? To me, this makes no sense. Also as far as I'm aware, only pig is forbiden to muslims (first time I hear, donkay is too.) Please elaborate bhen/veer jeeyo >>>>>>>>>>>>> Donkey is forbidden to Muslims. Look it up. You've got it wrong: the rehitnama talks about Muslim meant then switches to non-Muslim meat and forbids that. Why? I have no idea. Why does the rehitnama writer first forbid intercourse with anyone's sister, wife, mother, etc. and then go on to specifically forbid intercourse with a Muslim or Brahmin woman? Finally the shabad you pasted: it uses "kutha" to mean the act of butchering. That's what it means and thats how it's used...I dont' see the issue? I'm growing tired of debating you. You haven't explained why "abhaakhiya ka kuthaa" was used.

Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)

Admin · 29 Mar 2006

This discussion is totally off topic. Topic closed.