Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)
no jatha singh · 23 Mar 2006
"srbloh bbek is wonderful as it make you feel niara and better than other fellow sikhs"
i would have thought there are few things worse than something which makes you feel better than fellow sikhs
I think sikhs are supposed to recognise Waheguru`s kirpa instead of developing haumai.
Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)
akj wannabe · 24 Mar 2006
Author: ksg
Date: 03-23-06 16:35
"srbloh bbek is wonderful as it make you feel niara and better than other fellow sikhs. other than that what else do you need out of this"
True what "..." says, as it is the petty minded sikhs who are against sarabloh bibek. This is because they beleive those who follow the hukam of sarabloh bibek think that they are better than others just because they eat out of sarabloh.
But this does not make sense, this means we shouldn't do any paath because we will think that we are better than others. we shouldn't get up at amrit vela because it will give us haumai ! Amrit vela is also a hukam given by guru ji like sarbloh bibek. What makes them different.
[%sig%]
Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)
questionable · 25 Mar 2006
how can your spirit be fed by what is in your stomach? it seems like a far-fetched concept.
Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)
the paap man · 25 Mar 2006
I would like to practice sarblohi rehit because it is simple and healthy and it keeps a person humble and helps them to focus on sikhi but saying "it's hukam to do so" is not 100% certain for me, because nobody has been able to show me any hukamnama, thankhahnama, rehitnama, or even tell me any sakhi about why sarbloh rehit is most important. there is only one shabad, "sarbloh ki rachha hamnai," which could mean that your shastars should be sarbloh - but many jatha singhs wear steel kirpans. this makes me confused.
Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)
questionable · 25 Mar 2006
it's an interesting thought, that food is filled with "vibrations". appeals to the "mystics" amongst us.
food made by baptised sikhs=magical and pure
while food made by the rest of the world=unholy and not fit for the faithful
all respect to rehitnaamay aside, i believe guru nanak dev ji would shun such an attempt at creating a closed society.
Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)
questionable · 25 Mar 2006
...,
Guru Nanak Dev Ji's life is in contradiction to your statement that "Guru Nanak wanted his Sikhs to have the society of other Gursikhs." Guru Nanak Dev Ji spent such a huge portion of his life travelling and being a guest in other societies. He not only ate with these people, he ate the food that they had prepared. How can his life and example be in line with the practice of limiting our interactions with the world through food only prepared by Gursikhs?
And, to take it further, wouldn't the logical extrapolation be for Gursikhs to also grow all of their food personally? Because the majority of the world's food is planted and harvested by poor peasants, many of whom do not lead lives dictated by their faiths because of the extenuating circumstances of living a life of abject poverty. Do their hands make "bibeki" food less pure? Or is it only the hands of the people whom you can see touching/cutting/cooking your food?
I respect your decision to partake in the company of the faithful only. However, I do not believe "bibeki" as you describe it, is in line with the Guru's ideals of society.
Lastly, I was of the impression that we do not believe in magic or mysticism. The discussion is on food, and not on amrit, which I agree, recieves its power through bani. How is food prepared by Gurmukhs magical and why would anyone need magical food to lead an enlightened spiritual life?
Thank you for engaging these questions.
Respectfully
questioning kaur
Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)
Jaap naam!! · 26 Mar 2006
Just jaap naam...if no one keeps bebik because of 'dhila mind' then carry on..just like a death person, when you give a death person a sweet..'Ghur' then he will not be able to describe what he has tasted!! The people that argue are the ones that have not got anything inside...!! The people that have had the sweet they can not describe it and wont argue...the ones that have got nothing argue!! Gurrroo
Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)
Jaap naam!! · 26 Mar 2006
Sorry deaf not death!! OPssiii!!
>>sorry paaji/penji did you mean that those who dont keep bibek dont becuase they have a tilla mind?<<
It is a dhil...!! one is just trying to ignore the rehit because they cant be bothered!
Re: Sarbloh bebek???:)
Harsimran Kaur · 26 Mar 2006
I spent some time to read all the above and I like to suggest that meat is banned, rehanamas are correct as long as they are according to Gurbani (had been mixed up by our enemies), kirtan can be done in or out raags with devotion if we can read Gurbani then we can also sing it without raags.
If you have doubts about anything then ask Guru ji directly (find a way to talk and understand Guru ji).
Raagmala is not Gurbani (ask Guru ji if you can read it or not if you have doubts). It was a good discussion but instead of doubting Guru ji 's rehat and teachings do naam simran and read Gurbani.
Sarabloh is a good thing but should be prepared and eaten freshly and extra food should not be kept in the sarabloh bhande.
As for dry atta etc. I would suggest that in India I have met singhs who were used to wash wheat or corn then dry it and make atta, using home made ghee as well. They were used to milk themselves. Every thing is possible. You don't need to rely on others.
Like we are not living in India so try your best to keep rehat as it is important. The best thing is reading Gurbani and following it.
May Waheguru bless us.
Your best wisher