Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

..... · 22 Mar 2006

i was having a talk with one of my friends, it was basically about how India media is not "free", it is cencored, so you should be careful & not blindly believ everything you read. He said, that your probably right, but why is it that the BBC, an independent org, who is not controlled by UK or Indian Government, which is considered "free", why did they term the Shaheeds of 1984 as terrorists? why were Sikhs, who faught for Sikhi labelled terrorists even though the BBC knew that the Darabar Sahib was attacked, 10,000 dead, that 1984 riots, fake encounters... but still Sikh were the bad ones... India was always shown as the victim... even when the BBC refers to Indira Ghandhi.. it is always mentioed "Sikh problem" & how she had to deal with it After so much that Indian Gov did bad, the BBc still called the Sikh bad... you just have to look at the comment Mark Tully has always made about the "Sikh problem"

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

Daas Soora · 22 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh bhai sahib Jeeo, why wouldn't we be considered innocent from the incident that occured at the time. Tell me this, which from Sikhs and the hindus look more like goraa, the hindus of course. Goraa have always judged from the way they've look from the outside, not from the inside but the outside. The Sikhs have/had more religion than hindus, and when did goraa start loving lifestyle of religion. The goraa know the agony the sikhs went through and the harshness of what the hindus did, but still by looking at our dastaar, chola, kirpana etc, they would still judge them from that no matter how innocent they were. So, don't feel upset over this, as this is the way Vaheguru Jee created Kalyug to be like; a place where Manmukhs find wrong/bad to have religion. Don't worry this won't last for long. Daas Soora VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

...... · 22 Mar 2006

Soora ji i appreciate your comments but my friend, while understands why Sikhs stood up for themselves but has a problem with why the Western media took the side of India and im afraid that by saying, the West looks at the Sikh appearance with distrust won't stand for much. Thinking about it, i too dont understand. Can any one share anylight but i agree Soora Ji, who care what the BBC thinks but i still want to be able to argue why the BBC took India's side

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

khalistan · 22 Mar 2006

to destroy the minority group in england. [%sig%]

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

nobody · 23 Mar 2006

gurfateh.....khalistani jeeo.....perhaps u r right.....like wat france is doin....not allowing sikhs to wear turbans.....maybe tats they wanna do in england as well.....juz a thought....gurfateh

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

sumanpreet kaur · 23 Mar 2006

in 84 the reason y the british government ignored this issue and thought the same thing was cos their trade relationship with india was far more important then fundamentel human rights abuses india censors its media the number of books and films dat r banned cos they portray the indian government in a bad way the bbc didn't see the human rights abuses happen in front of their eyes they only know what the mainstream indian media tells them nothing eva changes

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

hm · 23 Mar 2006

why does the bbc strangely have a pro muslim bias at the time harbouring anti sikh sentiment? this is very constant in bbc mids. we need media trained journalist sikhs to get into th bbc

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

jugroop singh · 23 Mar 2006

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, i think the issue is a bit more subtle than that... if you look at journalists such as Mark Tully, who was born in India and has spent much of his life there, you sense an attitude of 'attachment' to all things TRADITIONALLY India...'a diverse continent of amazing smells, sights, religious diversity and yet order amongst chaos'. its a romantic image held by a lot of westerners and the sad thing about romance is that it creates blind spots... so for journalists such as this, and now especially given the post 9/11 climate, dealing with the issue of 'militants' is never going to be sensitively handled... sadly, the manner in which authors such as Mehmood who almost 'immersed' themselves within the world of Kharkoos, and only then began to understand what motivated them, is not the common approach that all journalists will take - and being seen to have a 'soft spot' for any armed civilians is now almost perceived as tantamount to supporting terrorists! with the BBC in particular it's even more complex because they are funded by government money - only recently it was reported that the government will have more say about what kind of issues should be prioritised by the BBC in terms of their broadcast content. but then conversely, maybe the increase in armed uprisings and militancy across the world may lead to media organisations broadcasting more material and investing more time and money into research regarding such current issues... VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

Nav Singh · 23 Mar 2006

Don't blame the Western media. They don't know enough about Sikhs to form an image. The problem is that the so-called Sikh leadership hasn't informed the media or anyone in general about Sikhs and 1984. Some examples: 1.Following Bluestar the Govt. of India spent crores of rupees sending video tapes and other items to foreign govts. and media outlets around the world. These tapes justified Bluestar and painted ALL Sikhs as terrorists. The SGPC and fat Akalis with ALL thier money DID nothing to tell the world. 2. How many SGPC wale/Akalis made documentaries about November 1984? The whole world knows that Sikhs assasinated Indira Gandhi. But not a dime was spent by the SGPC/Akalis on telling the world about the aftermath or contacting the Western media. 3. How many Sikh leaders in the West or in India educated the world about the genocide in India from 84 to 92? Millions of dollars were spent on gurudwaras (one for the ramgarhias, one for the ravidasias, one for the jats one for a doabees etc.) but did any one think of using that money to educate the Western public about the Sikh genocide? All that money could have been used to a.) make documentaries b.) make movies c.) write books d.) advertise in major newspapers about the Sikh genocide e.) launch an awareness campaign about the genocide. 4. Even after the murder of Balbir Singh Sodhi in 2001, Sikhs all over the US refused to fund Mistaken Identity a documentary that would have told the US public about Sikhs. 5. How many SGPC members/Akalis/gurudwara pardhaans can give a savvy interview using proper English to Western journalists? Don't blame the Western media. We Sikhs have been too narrow minded to tell the world about us.

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

sanjo · 23 Mar 2006

true say so why dont we do something now? i think a good place to start should be to write a letter lo. so i am gona try and create a letter if i have the time and i think alot of people who feel strongly about this should also do this. with a massive influx of letter the bbc would have to atleast consider the possibiility pursuing a true documentary on sikhs. "sikhs in the city" was good but never really addressed the issue of "militancy". then u got people like mark tully who obviously all the goreh are gona believe cos he seems a "nice educated guy". pathetic man. come on lets all get our pens out im sure we can find an address from somewhere. here we go> BBC Complaints, PO Box 1922, Glasgow G2 3WT

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

JS · 23 Mar 2006

I agree with Nav Singh millions are spent on Gurdwars where several exist already . On most days the Gurdwaras are not even 10% full and committees havre to appeal for people to do sewa. Ask them for a few thousand pounds to finance a publication in English to promote Sikhi and they will not give a single pound. Even today with France and the Turban, mistaken identity in the USA and dialogue with Governments in the west about Sikhi , things are not happening as they should.

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

uk singh · 23 Mar 2006

it ssimple, the character of sant bhindranwale has never been seen in the west. it is unheard of for individuals to encourage their community to arm them seleves and sacrifice them selves, this concept in sikhi is portrayed very poorly. so no matter what the circumstances, the sikh idology does not fit with western thought, simply because it has never been explained in the appropriate way. just a thought....when guru ji went to hindus they said ram, when they met muslmims they said allah, when they met shiv ji followers they spoke on their terms. a problem sikhs have today is tha we do not see through the eyes of others, perfect example, the kirpan case. it is crazy that an individual can use religion to carry a knife without question. now this is a typical example of western view. but us sikhs simply give th ebulshit explenation of " self defence" and expect the world to see us other than terrorists. we are a joke, the intelligent sikh of guru gobind singh is an endangered species

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

Mohandas · 23 Mar 2006

The thing is the BBC most likely got the news from Indian News Agencies who are likely to be saps

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

umeka · 23 Mar 2006

Nav Singh jeeO S.G.P.C. stands for Shromani GOLAK Prabandhak Committe. So what can we expect from our fat stupid leaders. Pleae do not use the word Akali for these rats. They are just Kaalees with Khaalee heads on their shoulders. Akali is really a great word.

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

Daas Soora · 24 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeekaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFAteh Bhai Sahib 'uk singh' Jeeo, the reason for why we wear a kirpan is due to self defence, but we aren't going to look through other's eyes to tell a lie so that they understand. The kirpan plays a major role in our religion, and the world should just be able to understand this and accept it. Also, the reason you gave, ie self defence, is in fact a reason to let others understand, but apparently there is a deeper reason for why we do wear the Kirpan. Firstly, the kirpan is spiritual but in a materialistic form, as it acts upon the strength of a Sikh. For instance, when an immense amount of Naam is japped, and a really high level is reached, the power of Naam is absorbed into the Kirpan. The Sikh then gains an immense amount of strength, which gives out a sort of rass, as he/she then becomes apart of the kirpan. I now don't wish to proceed with this reason, but basically all you need to know is that every kakaar given to us benefits and helps the Sikh in a special way even though Vaheguru Jee has placed it in a materialistic form. The kirpan is meant to be spiritual but are we going to tell goraa this, as they wouldn't understand the concept of a kirpan being this. Hence they see it as a weapon of some sort. So, we have to give the reason of self defence. Daas Soora VaheguruJeekaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFAteh

Re: Why does the bbc think the Shahheds of 1984 were terrorists

PTE SINGH · 24 Mar 2006

At the risk of sounding unpopular, the fact is that in the same way that the media apparently banded all Sikhs as militants, we also band everyone as innocent or Shaheeds too readily. The people that were killed in the Delhi riots were inncocent and it was a travesty. Those who fought and were killed in the years after Bluestar were shaheeds. Those that found themselves in the Darbar Shaib that night and died fighting the armed attack on the Darbar Shaib were shaheeds and heros. However those that were already based there hiding in a sacred shrine armed to the teeth and inviting the attack of the armed forces, were militants. [%sig%]