Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Are we hindus or muslims

Are we hindus or muslims

return to original sikhi · 11 Dec 2003

Someone once told me that sikhs either practice sikhi as muslims or hindus. That is, they follow strict nonsensical laws like muslims without any though or understanding of it, ie. looking at a girl once then looking away (i know singhs that do this, and this is actually straight out of islamic Shari'a). or treating pictures and the SGGS as an idol, bathing their rooms in milk and bowing to pictures. Looking at gurus as avatars, association with materialism when concerned with SGGS. I think that we as sikhs have forgotting our wonderful roots. The Gurus cast away ALL rituals, except for one, the only ritual that has any importance....that is Japping on NAAM. I was just wondering what people though about this.

Re: Are we hindus or muslims

Want to know more, · 11 Dec 2003

foolish acts will get us no where, agree yeh? we need ta fite da evil 'round us.

Re: Are we hindus or muslims

a point · 11 Dec 2003

You mentioned that some singhs don't look twice at another woman. Are you suggesting it's ok to gawk at another woman and oogle her? If someone happens to look twice, no big deal, but looking at a woman with lust is wrong. "Partriyaa roop na paykhai naytr" "Akhee(n) sootak, vekhnaa partriyaa par dhan roop" As for rituals: naam is biggest, but Guru sahib has oultined assistant karmas to make our lives more prepared for naam. This is not ritualism at all, it's called REHIT.

Re: Are we hindus or muslims

ranjit singh · 11 Dec 2003

Depends on what you classify as a ritual. For example, would you consider matha teking to Guru Granth Saahib Jee a ritual? Clarify what you mean by ritual. I personally think that term is used too loosely, without putting much thought into it. Also, the example of not looking at a woman twice and comparing that to Shari'a law is ignorant. You're going to condemn Singhs for not staring at women? Also, as far as I know, muslims who are strict about Shari'a would get a strict punishment for breaking any rule. Singh's that don't stare at women, do they also get officially punished if they happen to slip up and stare or take another look at someone's roop that they find attractive?

Re: Are we hindus or muslims

G · 12 Dec 2003

I hate muslims :D and I hate hindus

Re: Are we hindus or muslims

kaur · 12 Dec 2003

The admin. should not allow comments such as "G's" on this forum... it is promoting pure hatred... Completely against Sikhi...

Re: Are we hindus or muslims

Admin · 12 Dec 2003

We totally agree with you Kaur Bhain jee that it is against Sikhi to make comments like "hating Hindus or Muslims". The reason we allowed this post to go through was so that our vigilant and Gurmukh readers correct this person "G" and explain to him or her that it is wrong in Sikhi to pass such comments. Many others would learn in this process. If we had let stopped this post, we would have lost an opportunity to inform all Sikhs that such thinking or comments are not in accordance with Gurmat. Admin.

Re: Are we hindus or muslims

Bikramjitsingh · 14 Dec 2003

return to original sikhi wrote: > Someone once told me that sikhs either practice sikhi as > muslims or hindus. > > That is, they follow strict nonsensical laws like muslims > without any though or understanding of it, ie. looking at a > girl once then looking away (i know singhs that do this, and > this is actually straight out of islamic Shari'a). > If a Sikh looks at a girl and then averts his gaze then that's a good thing. If it's in the sharia then I don't see many Muslims practicising it. Are you saying that the sharia is something unique so if something is in the sharia then it means that it was the Muslims who thought it up first ?. Anyway when we used to live in India we were always taught to look away from girls. In this country when someone from India visits someones house and the female members are around, it almost looks rude to people born here when that person doesn't look in the direction of the female and it looks like they are ignoring her. [%sig%]

Re: Are we hindus or muslims

SinghinUS · 14 Dec 2003

You shouldnt hate Hindus or Muslims. THere are good hindus and muslims, and there are also bad hindus and muslims. in the same token, there are good sikhs and bad sikhs. However, we are neither. Sikhi is an independent religion which is neither Hindu nor Muslim, but Sikhism is tolerant of other faiths.

Re: Are we hindus or muslims

G · 15 Dec 2003

Im sorry I just didnt like the posted topic "Are we hindus or muslims" because we are neither... and I dont really hate them... I hate being referd to as one of them