Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

Tribune News Service · 18 Mar 2006

Sikhs part of Hindus: Josh Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, March 18 Even as Mr Harcharan Singh Josh, newly appointed member of the National Commission for Minorities (NCM), today kicked off a controversy by describing Sikhs as part and parcel of Hindus, the Jathedar of Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, the SGPC President, Mr Avtar Singh, and Mr Tarlochan Singh, former Chairman of the NCM, have deplored his statement. They said Akal Takht and the SGPC had already acknowledged that the Sikhs enjoyed a ''distinct and separate'' identity and Mr Josh had no right to question the same. Though Mr Josh had breakfast with Jathedar Vedanti at his residence here today and held a marathon meeting with the SGPC chief, both have announced that they will not hold any more meeting with him (Mr Josh) till he withdrew his controversial statement. Mr Josh had stated that it was only a turban that distinguished a Sikh from a Hindu. He claimed that the Sikhs came from the same 'Hindu culture' and they should admit this fact gracefully. ''Guru Gobind Singh sacrificed for whom?'' he asked. He said the Sikhs should not deny the facts that they were baptised to protect the Hindus - their brethren -from the Mughal tyranny. He, however, advocated for a separate Anand Karaj Act for the Sikhs. He also assured that the NCM would endeavour to bring back the 'blacklisted' Sikh youths who wanted to join the mainstream of the country. Earlier, the Chief Khalsa Diwan (CKD) honoured Mr Josh on his appointment as member of the NCM. Mr Charnjit Singh Chadha, president of the CKD, and other members of the organisation were present on this occasion. The SGPC chief said Mr Josh was nominated being member of the Sikh community and hence his "irresponsible statement" amounted to his disqualification. He said Mr Josh's statement showed that he wanted to watch the interests of the majority community instead of the minority. Peeved at the controversy, Mr Tarlochan Singh, former Chairman of the NCM, said Mr Josh must understand that the Sikhs had a separate religion and identity. He said during his stint as Chairman of the NMC, he had arranged written statements from Mr K. Sudarhsan, RSS chief, and Mr Ashok Singhal, VHP leader, that Sikhs enjoyed a separate identity. He said he had now moved the Lok Sabha to amend Article 25 of the Indian Constitution that equated Sikhs with Hindus. Mr Josh has had stint as general secretary of the Indian Youth Congress and was considered a confidant of Sanjay, younger son of Ms Indira Gandhi. To a pointed question, Mr Josh admitted his Congress background and said that at one time he cropped differences with Sanjay Gandhi and joined the Congress group led by Mr Swarn Singh, the then Foreign Minister.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

LK · 18 Mar 2006

Poor guy. Good to see Vedanti & Co doing something useful (which they don't most of the time) Hopefully be seen as a separate intity soon, and mr Josh will get ridf of his ignorance =)

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

Gurpreet Sumra · 18 Mar 2006

Harcharan Singh Josh, New Chairman of Minority Commission of India who replaced Tarlochan Singh has created furore by saying that Sikhs are Hindus. He further added that everyone knows that Sikhs were created by Guru Gobind Singh ji to protect Hindus, brethren of Sikhs to protect them from Mughal Tyranny. Further, that it’s only a Turban that separates Sikhs from Hindus and Sikhs came from the same Hindu culture. These irresponsible statements by a person holding such a high post, for sure indicates that he is acting at someone’s behest or he is completely ignorant of who Sikhs are?. Sikhs are not Hindus, it has clearly been stated by Guru Saab “na hum hindu naa musalmaan”, further Sikhs have nothing in common with Hindus from their birth till death. Hindus have mundan sanskar- Sikhs don’t, Hindus worship stones-sikhs don’t,Hindus have different marriage ceremonies from Sikhs, even at death they have entirely different practices and different scriptures which have different teachings altogether. To top it all Sikhs place of worship Gurdwara is entirely different from Hindu temples. There is not even a single thing that Sikhs have in common with Hindus except for the relation of humanity which Sikhs have in common with every human being on this earth. This humanity was the reason that Guru Tegh Bahadur Saab sacrificed his life to protect helpless people from tyrant rulers of that time and not because those rulers were Muslims. Guru Gobind Singh did not create Sikh to protect Hindus, rather Guru Gobind Singh would have done the same thing to protect innocent Muslims from Narendra Modi in Gujarat,Bal Tacheray in Mumbai and from other Hindu terrorist organizations(VHP,Shiv sena,Bajrang Dal)in Ayodhya. Guru Saab would have done the same thing for innocent Christians in Orissa , tribals in North East and Dalits in Southern part of India. These statements ,for sure are made to instigate Sikhs though Sikhs don’t want any kind of trouble “hamra jhagra raha na kou, pundit mulla chhade dou”(SGGS,1159). Regarding Josh, he was the secretary of minority department of AICC(All India Congress Committee), what a department in a party who is responsible for the genocide of minorities. May be the department to work on finding out how to eliminate minorities. That’s why he got this position. Tarlochan Singh, former chairman’s Sikhi is now boiling on this statement because he is no more the Chairman, but now he has forgotten that he was the one who made statements that ram comes so many times in Guru Granth Sahib so Sikhs should wear Mukat like Mishra(Badal) and do paath of Ramayan and Havans with chunni around their necks. Jathedar Vedanti would not speak a word or take any action against this, because Josh babu is doing the same thing what Vedanti wants. He can issue Hukamnama against Joginder Singh of Spokesman because he talks about distinctness of Sikhs and Sikhi but not against Josh. Vedanti should immediately issue a hukamnama to Josh , to ask for forgiveness as he has spoken against Sikh Panth. Vedanti, wake up and stop issuing hukamnamas to Gurbaksh Singh kala afghana,Joginder Singh who talks about Sikhi and stop helping Sant Baba syndicate by the name of Sant Samaj. This Sant Baba syndicate, in Virsa sambhal Sammelan passed a self styled resolution that Sikhs should not raise any questions about the authenticity of dasam granth, so that they can impart practical knowledge about it. Jathedar Vedanti is also known to be very fond of these writings, that’s why he always maintains silence on this issue. Vedantiji, If you still have some shame left after Sarna brothers episode then issue a hukamnama against Josh and Sant Samaj. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

LK · 19 Mar 2006

Regarding Josh, he was the secretary of minority department of AICC(All India Congress Committee), what a department in a party who is responsible for the genocide of minorities. May be the department to work on finding out how to eliminate minorities. ----------------------------------- That is worrying. Very worrying indeed.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

jS · 19 Mar 2006

With 90% of youth having cut their Kesh in Punjab, I suppose you could call them Hindus. There is a fairly rapid absorbtion into Hinduism going on at the moment of Sikhs. In 20 years time will people even challenge that they are not Hindus? A sense of pride in Sikhism needs to be instilled in Sikhs by Sikhs themselves. At the moment the Indian TV and media show Sikhs as a joke, this is not going to encourage the youth. This new NCM person needs to be sacked.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

?? · 19 Mar 2006

Statement by Josh shows bankruptcy of his knowledge of Sikhism. Any group of people becomes a nation when they have their distinctive religion, language, script, dress and sovereign state. Sikhs have or had all these. Hybrid tea plants are grafted on unreal root stock to produce high quality flowers or fruits. They are classed as superior product. You can not class them same as the useless rootstock. Guru Nanak Dev ji was born in a Hindu family but rejected its principles. Sikhs have every attributes of a nation apart from sovereign state which was annexed by the British because of the "GADDAR HINDUS" dressed as Sikhs. I think that Josh is the next generation of these "gaddar Hindus" reaping all the benefits from GOI as the job is given to a Sikh (only in appearance) but beneath these clothes he is a member of RSS.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

Singh · 19 Mar 2006

With all the Brahmanvad rituals Sikhs are beginning to observe thanks to socalled Maahpursh, it is any wonder people are confusing Sikhism as being a part of Hinduism. Buddhism was also finished because they stoped practicing the original path of Buddha and started Hindu practices like worshiping moortis.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

KK · 19 Mar 2006

Akalis and Congress and the the ordinary Sikhs by doing nothing are heading towards Hinduism at a fast rate. I used to ridicule Khuswant Singh when he said Sikhs may dissapear in his history of the Sikhs book in the 1960's but now I think he may have a point.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

KK · 19 Mar 2006

Sikh bodies seek removal of Josh from NCM Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, March 19 Even as various Sikh organisations have sought the immediate removal of Mr Harcharan Singh Josh as a member of the National Commission for Minorities (NCM) for challenging the distinct identity of the Sikhs, he (Mr Josh) dared them saying “Let Akal Takht summon him”. Talking to The Tribune from New Delhi on telephone today, Mr Josh said he would decide whether to appear or not before Akal Takht only after receiving summons to be issued by the Sikh clergy. He reiterated that the Sikhs were part of the Hindus as they still enjoyed common culture. While spokesman for the Dal Khalsa Bhai Mohkam Singh urged Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti to summon Mr Josh at Akal Takht for his alleged ‘irresponsible utterances’ and ‘excommunicate’ him from the Panth, Mr Parmjit Singh Sarna, president, Delhi Akali Dal, Mr Manjit Singh Calcutta and Mr Harinderpal Singh, both SGPC members, demanded his immediate removal as a member of the NCM. They said Mr Josh should either step down or the Central Government should remove him from the NCM. Mr Sarna said if Mr Josh wanted the ‘assimilation’ of the Sikhs into the majority community then he had no moral right to continue as a member of the NCM. Mr Calcutta, who is also the patron of the Chief Khalsa Diwan (CKD), deplored the nomination of Mr Josh to the NCM saying he did not know the basic tenets of the Sikhism. He also expressed concern over the honour bestowed by the CKD and other Sikh organisations on Mr Josh without knowing his credentials. However, reiterating his utterances that “Sikhs are part of Hindus”, Mr Josh said there were many families where one brother was Hindu and another a Sikh. The Hindus and the Sikhs were inseparable, he said. He said marriages between the Hindus and the Sikhs were common, which was a symbol of common cultural ties between the two communities. However, to a pointed question, Mr Josh denied that he was ever deputed by the Congress to justify the Operation Bluestar in 1984 in the foreign countries. However, the spokesman for the Dal Khalsa said the Sikhs hold the Hindus in high esteem like other faiths and communities but it was wrong to dub them as part of the Hindus. He threatened to mobilise Sikh masses to enforce the removal of Mr Josh if he failed to apologise.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

LK · 20 Mar 2006

I recommend Mr Josh to read 'Are Sikhs a Nation' By Mehar Singh Chaddah. Brtiliant. I shall quote: "If on the plea of intermarriage and interdining the Sikhs are to be clubbed with Hindus, then the same formula will apply to Jews, Christians and Buddhists (Both Japanese and Chinese), who intermarry and interdine. But these communities do not forego their religions thereby. A marriage does not affect the religious beliefs of the partners" PP 43-44 Which is really common sense. Just because one child is Hindu and one is Sikh doesn't mean they are one. Just means that Hindus prefer to have one Sikh child for teir protetion. They used it for protection. But this does not mean that they were CREATED for protection, just like a metal zipper can be used to conduct electricity, even though it is isn't MADE TO conduct, it isn't it's function (it is simply one of it's characteristics) Bhull chukk maaf

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

Mehtab Singh · 20 Mar 2006

And then they ask us why we need a separate country of our own.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

KS · 20 Mar 2006

SIKH FEDERATION (UK) PRESS RELEASE Sunday 19 March 2006 SIKH FEDERATION (UK) SLAM FOOLISH COMMENTS BY JOSH At the weekend it was reported that Harcharan Singh Josh the newly appointed member of the National Commission for Minorities (NCM) had described Sikhs as part and parcel of Hindus. Immediately upon learning of his comments the Sikh Federation (UK) slammed his comments as totally irresponsible. In a radio broadcast and through a press release the Federation urged Sikhs in Panjab in positions of responsibility to take united action to ensure Josh apologised, withdrew his comments and to consider if he should be forced to step down from his position as he appears to lack all knowledge to represent Sikhs. Josh a former general secretary of the Indian Youth Congress and a close confidant of Sanjay Gandhi stated that it was only a turban that distinguished a Sikh from a Hindu. He claimed that the Sikhs came from the same 'Hindu culture' and they should admit this fact gracefully. ''Guru Gobind Singh sacrificed for whom?'' he asked. He said the Sikhs should not deny the facts that they were baptised to protect the Hindus - their brethren - from the Mughal tyranny. A Federation spokesman said: "It is widely acknowledged that the Sikhs have a distinct and separate identity and any Sikh that refuses to accept this demonstrates he lacks the knowledge and ability to represent the Sikhs on the likes of the National Commission for Minorities." A Federation spokesman said: "We are aware the Jathedar of Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, the SGPC President, Avtar Singh Makkar and Tarlochan Singh the former Chairman of the NCM, have all condemned Josh's statements. We are also aware that Josh met with Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti and the SGPC chief yesterday and now both have announced that they will not hold any more meetings with Josh until he withdraws his controversial statements. The SGPC chief said Josh was nominated as a member of the Sikh community and his "irresponsible statement" amounted to his disqualification. He said Josh's statement showed that he wanted to watch the interests of the majority community instead of the minority. Tarlochan Singh, former Chairman of the NCM, said Josh must understand that the Sikhs have a separate religion and identity. He said he had now moved the Lok Sabha to amend Article 25 of the Indian Constitution that equated Sikhs with Hindus. A Federation spokesman said: "If Josh fails to apologise and withdraw his statement he will be making a mockery of the Jathedar of Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti and the SGPC President. In these circumstances Josh should be forced to resign from his position on the NCM and be replaced by a Sikh who knows what he is talking about." Gurjeet Singh National Press Secretary Sikh Federation (UK)

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

P.S · 20 Mar 2006

Dear Lionking, Can you pls let me know from where I can get this book, 'Are Sikhs a Nation' By Mehar Singh Chaddah P.S.S

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

Roopkaur · 20 Mar 2006

>"If on the plea of intermarriage and interdining the Sikhs are to be clubbed with Hindus, then the same formula will apply to Jews, Christians and Buddhists (Both Japanese and Chinese), who intermarry and interdine. But these communities do not forego their religions thereby. A marriage does not affect the religious beliefs of the partners" PP 43-44< This quote has nothing to do with Sikhs, since Sikhs do not intermarry with others. Sikhaa dee rotee betee dee sanjh hor Sikhaa naal hee hundee hai. As for others calling Sikhs Hindus, well, like stated before, a lot of the fault lies in the Sikhs, many of whom, to appease others give up on Sikhi asools. For example, recently in one of my classes we had a discussion on the Kirpaan issue in Canada, and a lot of the people were against the judgement. But what most surprised me was a Punjabi girl beside me was taking the other side. I asked her after class whether she really thinks Kirpaans should not be allowed, and she said that she know where the majority are coming from, and that her own parents are amritshuck, but she always argues with her mother and tells her not to wear the kirpan. When socalled Sikh youth start telling their parents to take off the kirpan just so trouble wont be caused, well, what more can I say...

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

LK · 20 Mar 2006

Author: P.S Date: 03-20-06 07:35 Dear Lionking, Can you pls let me know from where I can get this book, 'Are Sikhs a Nation' By Mehar Singh Chaddah P.S.S -------------------------------------- The book can be ordered from Singhbrothers.com ---------------------- Author: Roopkaur Date: 03-20-06 08:02 >"If on the plea of intermarriage and interdining the Sikhs are to be clubbed with Hindus, then the same formula will apply to Jews, Christians and Buddhists (Both Japanese and Chinese), who intermarry and interdine. But these communities do not forego their religions thereby. A marriage does not affect the religious beliefs of the partners" PP 43-44< This quote has nothing to do with Sikhs, since Sikhs do not intermarry with others. Sikhaa dee rotee betee dee sanjh hor Sikhaa naal hee hundee hai. -------------------- All I'll say is, go and look in Punjab, and let us know whether Sikhs intermarry in Punjab or not (whether we like it or not). He's talkign abot what Sikhs DO, not what Sikhs SHOULD or COULD DO. As for rotee betee dee sanjh, we are not talibans, but Sikhs of the Gurus, and unforunatly (perhaps for you,) Guru ka Langar is one of the elements shattering worldy labels, including being a SIkh or a "hardcore-bibeki Sikh" for that matter. Guru Ka Langar, as far as I'm aware does not discriminate between caste,creed, skin colors, as far as I'm ware.. But I could be wrong, since according to you, you cannot have 'rotee betee de sanjh' with non-Sikhs, which bluntly means that no non-Sikhs is welcome to the Gurdwara, sicne anyone in the Gurdwar should participate in Langar. I promise, it is not 'Seene Basenee' vali gal, but quite a prominent part of Sikh history. Regards

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

uk singh · 21 Mar 2006

From an other post on this forum Nihang Singh celebrated Holly by throwing colours at Sri Anandpur Sahib then surely Sikhs are Hindus. It is our own fault. "Paissa khotta aapna Baneeye noo ki dosh".

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

Roop Kaur · 21 Mar 2006

>'rotee betee de sanjh' with non-Sikhs, which bluntly means that no non-Sikhs is welcome to the Gurdwara, sicne anyone in the Gurdwar should participate in Langar.< This discussion on bibek has taken place many times before, why go over the same points over again. The rotee betee dee sanjh hukam is given at EVERY single amrit sanchaar. not just the jatha's or those who promote bibek. It does not mean non Sikhs cannot come to Gurdvara, but that SIkhs should eat food prepared by rehitvaan Gursikhs. Why twist my words when you already know what bibek is? The langer cooked by rehitvaley gursikhs, i.e. guru ka langar, can be eaten by anyone and all alike, regardless of caste, creed etc. but in order for it to be langer, it should be cooked by Guru ke Sikh.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

Roopkaur · 21 Mar 2006

>'rotee betee de sanjh' with non-Sikhs, which bluntly means that no non-Sikhs is welcome to the Gurdwara, sicne anyone in the Gurdwar should participate in Langar.< This discussion on bibek has taken place many times before, why go over the same points over again. The rotee betee dee sanjh hukam is given at EVERY single amrit sanchaar. not just the jatha's or those who promote bibek. It does not mean non Sikhs cannot come to Gurdvara, but that SIkhs should eat food prepared by rehitvaan Gursikhs. Why twist my words when you already know what bibek is? The langer cooked by rehitvaley gursikhs, i.e. guru ka langar, can be eaten by anyone and all alike, regardless of caste, creed etc. but in order for it to be langer, it should be cooked by Guru ke Sikh.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

LK · 21 Mar 2006

Author: Roop Kaur Date: 03-21-06 12:31 >'rotee betee de sanjh' with non-Sikhs, which bluntly means that no non-Sikhs is welcome to the Gurdwara, sicne anyone in the Gurdwar should participate in Langar.< This discussion on bibek has taken place many times before, why go over the same points over again. The rotee betee dee sanjh hukam is given at EVERY single amrit sanchaar. not just the jatha's or those who promote bibek. It does not mean non Sikhs cannot come to Gurdvara, but that SIkhs should eat food prepared by rehitvaan Gursikhs. Why twist my words when you already know what bibek is? The langer cooked by rehitvaley gursikhs, i.e. guru ka langar, can be eaten by anyone and all alike, regardless of caste, creed etc. but in order for it to be langer, it should be cooked by Guru ke Sikh. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Yes but, you went to the extent of saying (if I udnerstood you correctly) about SIkhs only eating with Sikhs. Although I see your point in bibek (but strongly disagree with you), it was not bibek you spoke about, since i was speaking about INTERDINING, of which you came and started saying that Sikh do not eat WITH NON-SIKHS. This is not about bibek or who has prepared the food. Not at all. I have never heard about the 'rotee betee de sanjh' (ie. interdining) only amongst SIkhs, and if it is given it goes against the historical tradition of langar and pangat. You have been twisting my words, when I was speaking about interdining, you started talking about bibek, which is completly irrelevant to my post.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

KS · 22 Mar 2006

Excommunicate Josh, say Sikh leaders ML Kak Jammu, March 21 While taking a strong exception to the recent statement of Mr Harcharan Singh Josh, a member of the National Commission for Minorities, in which he had stated that Sikhs were part of Hindus, several Sikh leaders of Jammu and Kashmir have appealed to Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Jathedar of Akal Takht, to summon him and expel him from the community. At a meeting held here today, which was presided over by Mr SS Wazir, a former president of the state gurdwara prabandhak board, the Sikh leaders urged Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, to sack Mr Josh from the Commission as he had not only underplayed the sacrifices committed by the community and the Sikh Gurus but showed that he (Josh) was a "stooge of the Congress." The Sikh leaders said Mr Josh had been appointed a member of the Commission as he was a Sikh and the Sikhs were a minority community. The meeting was attended among others by Mr Narbir Singh, president, Shiromani Youth Akali Dal, Mr Mohinder Singh, chief organiser Bhai Kanahiya Nishkam Sewa Society, Mr Paramjot Singh, president, AISSF, and Mr Amar Singh, president, Sikh Welfare Society. The Sikh leaders wanted Mr Josh to resign from the Commission as he had a “dubious past” and had been "deputed by the Congress for justifying Operation Bluestar in 1984 in foreign countries." They appealed to the Prime Minister to appoint a Sikh leader of integrity and honesty in his place as member of the Commission

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

deadmanwalking · 10 Apr 2006

First of all, Guru Nanak may have said he is not a muslim or hindu, do you guys even know the meaning of that phrase? Some people interrupt things differently. Bhai Bala was a hindu and Mardana was a Muslim. Guru Nanak Dev Ji was for everyone not for one sect hence that is why he had to use the phrase above. The world Singh did not exist before Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born in a Hindu family. We are part of the Hindu sect. I suggest you read the Dasham Granth where Guru Gobind Singh Ji mentions Bharma, Vishnu and Mahesh. If you want I can get the quotation for that as well and write in on the site. Does it mean that a Namdhari's are not true sikhs just because they do not believe in the Granth Sahib as their living Guru instead believe in 12th Guru Ram Singh Ji? Does it mean that a person who believes in the Guru Granth Sahib as their are not Sikh's? Absoultely not. Again you may interrupt Namdhari's of not being Sikh's and they may interrupt you as being Guruless and not Sikh's. I suggest you read the Dasham Granth and Guru Nanak Dev Ji's Janak Sakhi. Sincerely, Dead man walking

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

... · 11 Apr 2006

Kuka, Welcome back! You think Bhai Bala was a Hindu? You think after spending all that time with Guru Nanak he went home and worshipped statues and wore the Jaeneu? You think he still believed in Caste? After hearing Guru Nanak about naam you think he didnt' want naam himself? You think Bhai Mardana was a Muslim and believed in Mohammed as the last prophet? This doesn't even mesh with Sikh history and janamsakhis which say Bhai Mardana asked to be a Sikh and was cremated. You can "interrupt" us however you want, but I "interpret" you as being a Niguraa who thinks he's a Hindu. Guru Gobind Singh told us "jab eh gahey bipran kee reet, mai(n) na karo(n) in kee parteet". You guys have done just that. Bhai Gurdas says “Hindus and Muslims have started two separate ways...they all are not equal to even one hair of a Guru’s Sikh, who has effaced his sense of ego” Also, “the Guru has created the mighty Gurmukh panth. This panth keeps itself away from the boundaries of the Vedas and the Semitic scriptures...” Dabistan-e Mazahib, one of the oldest histories of religion in India says “To be brief, Nanak’s followers scorn images. Their belief is that all Gurus are Nanak...They do not recite the mantras of the Hindus and do not pay respect to their idol-temples. They do not count the avtaras for anything. They do not have any attachment to Sanskrit, which the Hindus call the language of angels” Qazi Nur Muhammad in 1764 wrote: “the Sikhs are the disciples of a Guru and that fortunate Guide had lived at Chak. The ways and practices of these [people] are derived from Nanak who showed to the Sikhs a separate path. His [last] successor was Gobind Singh, from whom they received the title ‘Singh’. They are not from amongst the Hindus. These miscreants have a distinct religion of their own” You may be a Hindu, but I and the Khalsa Panth certainly are not.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

deadmanwalking · 12 Apr 2006

Okay Veer Ji, 1. If you think you are a true Khalsa then who were the God's before Guru Nanak Dev Ji? Answer: Sri Ramchander in Treta Yug and Krishan in the Dwaper Yug. Kulyug which is the present age was Guru Nanak but people who believe in a Guru after Guru Gobind Singh Ji would be the 12th Guru Ram Singh Ji. I am not critisizing anyone here but according to Namdhari beliefs its Satguru Ram Singh Ji's yug who is to bring Satyug. Please note that I am not interfering with your beliefs with Sri Granth Sahib as your Guru so therefore continue to follow your tradition. 2. Who did Guru Teghbadur sacrfice his head for? Answer: Hindu sect. Again there was no such thing of the word Singh during those times. 4. Guru Gobind Singh Ji's name was Guru Gobind Rai Ji before the prefix of Singh was added. Guru Gobind Rai Ji is a hindu name not a sikh name. Why Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji create the word Singh? Answer: During the chotic time of the muslim empire the Hindu Sect were afraid of fighting. Guru Gobind Singh Ji had to show them courage so therefore he made them into warriors and the word Singh was used. 3. Why would Guru Gobind Singh Ji mention the names of Lord Bharama, Lord Vishnu and Mahesh (Lord Shiva ji) in his dasham granth? If you consider yourself true Khalsa then Guru Gobind Singh Ji would have not mentioned the names of the Hindu gods at all. I suggest you understand the Satyug, Treta Yug, Dwaper Yug and the current age which is the Kulyug. These ages do exist and each incarnation of God came to these yugs. Also there are many Sikh out there that do not believe in Guru Nanak Dev Ji as an avtar of God. Majority of the Sikh's consider him to be a messenger of God. Again people do not even understand their own Sikh religion. It is better to understand the roots of Sikhism and each of the Yugs how they are correlated to Sikhism. Wahi Guru Jey Key Fath

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

LK · 12 Apr 2006

Veer '...' I am very interested in 'Dabistan-e Mazahib' and other old historical references of the Sikhs I was wondering where I could get hold of the work of Qazi Nur Muhammad and Muhsin Fanni (Mohsin..or however you spell his names) Are these historical accounts entirely on Sikhs are do they only mention Sikhs, and, again, where can i find thses, since I have heard a lot about themf rom many parcharacs and respected Sinkhs :) Had a quick look on sibghbrothers (who I doubted would have them), and couldn't find it there. ANy other book shop in India you know of where I can find old historical references such as the above mentioend? Thank you in advance :) Bhull Chukk maaf.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

deadmanwalking · 12 Apr 2006

Hey Author, Do you want to chat on MSN messenger or yahoo messenger about this in greater details? It seems like the administration does not like freedom of speech. I will give you my msn messenger address: [address removed] Sincerely, Dead Man Walking.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

... · 13 Apr 2006

1) Ok, you can continue to wait for Baba Ram Singh and call yourself Hindu. If Ram and Krishan are your gods, good for you. I for myself believe as Guru Gobind Singh says, "Kishan Bishan kabhoo(n) na dhiaoo(n)" and "raam raheem puraan koran, anek kahai mat ek na manio(n)". 2) Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib sacrificed is head for freedom of religion. He didnt' believe in the customs of tilak or janjoo. He was against them, but he believed everyone should be able to practice their faith without persecution. Your point, once again fails. 4) "Gobind Rai" : how is Das or Rai exclusively Hindu? Next you will say Gobind is Hindu too so Guru Sahib must have been Hindu. These are names. Has nothing to do with religion. 3) (why are 3 and 4 transposed??) Guru Gobind Singh translated these kathas which were only available in Sanskrit. If you actually read them, you'd know Guru Sahib writes that he does not believe in or revere any of them. If you think the presence of "raam" and "gobind" etc. make Guru Granth Sahib "Hindu" then there is also "allah" "raheem" "kareem"; does this make Guru Granth Sahib Muslim as well?

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

deadmanwalking · 13 Apr 2006

Dear Author Ji, Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji write about Bharma, Vishnu and Mahesh in his Dasham Granth Sahib? Guru Sahib would have not written the name of the 3 Gods unless he did not believe that they existed. Please answer this question and I would love to hear this response? Sincerely, Dead Man Walking

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

... · 13 Apr 2006

dead man, Of course they exist. Guru Sahib didn't "write about them" he translated the existing literature. Why? So it wasn't a secret anymore. I've given quotes of Guru Sahib saying he doesn't believe in any of them. These gods exist but aren't even equal to a Gursikh, forget Guru Sahib. I have even read some Gursikhs' books where they say the Bhatts were incarnations of these gods who became Sikhs to get liberation. But what does Japji Sahib say about them? These gods are only in Gian Khand "kaytay Kaan Mahesh. Kaytay Brahmay gharat ghareeai roop rang kay vays" (Kaan is Krishan, Mahesh is Shiva). These gods are in Giaan Khand. A Sikh aspires to Sachkhand. So what relevance do these gods have to us?

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

... · 13 Apr 2006

ਗੋਂਡ ॥ ਭੈਰਉ ਭੂਤ ਸੀਤਲਾ ਧਾਵੈ ॥ ਖਰ ਬਾਹਨੁ ਉਹੁ ਛਾਰੁ ਉਡਾਵੈ ॥੧॥ ਹਉ ਤਉ ਏਕੁ ਰਮਈਆ ਲੈਹਉ ॥ ਆਨ ਦੇਵ ਬਦਲਾਵਨਿ ਦੈਹਉ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਸਿਵ ਸਿਵ ਕਰਤੇ ਜੋ ਨਰੁ ਧਿਆਵੈ ॥ ਬਰਦ ਚਢੇ ਡਉਰੂ ਢਮਕਾਵੈ ॥੨॥ ਮਹਾ ਮਾਈ ਕੀ ਪੂਜਾ ਕਰੈ ॥ ਨਰ ਸੈ ਨਾਰਿ ਹੋਇ ਅਉਤਰੈ ॥੩॥ ਤੂ ਕਹੀਅਤ ਹੀ ਆਦਿ ਭਵਾਨੀ ॥ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਕੀ ਬਰੀਆ ਕਹਾ ਛਪਾਨੀ ॥੪॥ ਗੁਰਮਤਿ ਰਾਮ ਨਾਮ ਗਹੁ ਮੀਤਾ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਣਵੈ ਨਾਮਾ ਇਉ ਕਹੈ ਗੀਤਾ ॥੫॥੨॥੬॥

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

california apna · 13 Apr 2006

Bharma, Vishnu and Mahesh are these god's part of sikhism did the guru's acknowlede their exsistance that they did or do exsist.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

LK · 14 Apr 2006

"..." jee, what is your proof of them being in gyan khand?

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

... · 14 Apr 2006

LK, It's in Japji Sahib as I have quoted already. Here it is again: ਧਰਮ ਖੰਡ ਕਾ ਏਹੋ ਧਰਮੁ ॥ ਗਿਆਨ ਖੰਡ ਕਾ ਆਖਹੁ ਕਰਮੁ ॥ ਕੇਤੇ ਪਵਣ ਪਾਣੀ ਵੈਸੰਤਰ ਕੇਤੇ ਕਾਨ ਮਹੇਸ ॥ ਕੇਤੇ ਬਰਮੇ ਘਾੜਤਿ ਘੜੀਅਹਿ ਰੂਪ ਰੰਗ ਕੇ ਵੇਸ ॥ ਕੇਤੀਆ ਕਰਮ ਭੂਮੀ ਮੇਰ ਕੇਤੇ ਕੇਤੇ ਧੂ ਉਪਦੇਸ ॥ ਕੇਤੇ ਇੰਦ ਚੰਦ ਸੂਰ ਕੇਤੇ ਕੇਤੇ ਮੰਡਲ ਦੇਸ ॥ ਕੇਤੇ ਸਿਧ ਬੁਧ ਨਾਥ ਕੇਤੇ ਕੇਤੇ ਦੇਵੀ ਵੇਸ ॥ ਕੇਤੇ ਦੇਵ ਦਾਨਵ ਮੁਨਿ ਕੇਤੇ ਕੇਤੇ ਰਤਨ ਸਮੁੰਦ ॥ ਕੇਤੀਆ ਖਾਣੀ ਕੇਤੀਆ ਬਾਣੀ ਕੇਤੇ ਪਾਤ ਨਰਿੰਦ ॥ ਕੇਤੀਆ ਸੁਰਤੀ ਸੇਵਕ ਕੇਤੇ ਨਾਨਕ ਅੰਤੁ ਨ ਅੰਤੁ ॥੩੫॥

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

fresnosikh · 14 Apr 2006

WJKK WJKF Just like Christans and Muslims are not Jews because they believe in Moses and the Old Testament. Sikhs cannot be defines as Hindus. For all the spineless people who continue to make this argument about Sikhs being Hindu should have the courage to say Muslims and Christans are Jews and we shall see how quickly they retract their statements after being threatned. Bottom line is that as Guru Gobind singh Ji said "All human race is one". Everything came from one GOD (whaeguru) makes the entire creation as one. Very unique concept of Sikhism.

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

LK · 17 Apr 2006

'...' jeeyo, you speak of these khands as if these are some kiind of physical adobies. Prof Sahib Singh and many other say that they are "atmic avastha". I'm not sure I understand the Pauri correctly. I will have to relook at it before I write further. Also, could you please tell your brither about the source of azi Nur Mohammad, and where I can find that.. since it sounds like a very interesting Source. Bhulll Chukk maaf

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

... · 17 Apr 2006

LK, Many Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh and others have said that the khands are realms. Not aatmic stages. Bhai Sahib has written about it quite clearly. I'm not sure how you could say Brahma, Mahesh and others dwell in someone's aatmic stage? But at any rate, even with your own interpretation, it still shows that they aren't in the highest realm. As for the source of the Kazi Nur Muhammmed quote: JS Grewal has edited a compilation called "Sikh History from Persian Sources".

Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member

LK · 19 Apr 2006

From how I udnerstand it, it is a spiritual stage, not someones. In that sense, rahma Mahesh and other reached that spiritual state, or spiritual avastha, if you like, and not realms. I am not the only one to say this, and I thus disagree with Bhai Randhir Singh in this issue. Thanks for your response about the source of Qazi Nur Muhammed. It is much appreciated. Does this book also include the stuff from Dabistan (Mohsin Fani)? Thanks a lot once again penji/Paji =D