Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Harcharan Singh · 14 Mar 2006

Kirtan in the Original Style Amritsar, Punjab, India - The Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee SGPC revived the pre-Independence tradition of using traditional instruments in performing Kirtan (hymn singing) at Darbar Sahib. A six-member Ragi Jatha, led by Professor Kartar Singh, Director of Sangeet Academy, Anandpur Sahib, took the opportunity Tuesday of reviving a tradition in tune with that exercised during the period of the ten Sikh Gurus. In addition to the present-day Harmonium and Tabla, the Ragi Jatha used instruments such as the Tanpura, Taus, Surmandal and Dilruba in performing Kirtan. Thousands of devotees who had come to pay obeisance at the sanctum sanctorum of Darbar Sahib tried to extend their stay to attending the Kirtan. However, owing to paucity of space, majority of the devotees had to leave. Amritsar residents also remained glued to their television sets to watch the Kirtan in traditional style on the local ETC Punjabi channel that directly telecasts the morning and evening Kirtan from Darbar Sahib. As the Jatha came out after performing the evening Kirtan, several devotees gathered around them to learn more about the traditional musical instruments. Amongst the Sangat was SGPC President Avtar Singh. At the conclusion of the Kirtan, Singh expressed his commitment to revive the traditional style of Kirtan as he made it clear that no Ragi Jatha would be allowed to perform “filmi song tunes” for Kirtan. He added that best Ragi Jathas would be invited from within the country and abroad to continue the process of Kirtan with traditional musical instruments. Kartar Singh said that his happiness was beyond measure given the fact that he had now fulfilled his long cherished dream of performing Kirtan at Darbar Sahib with traditional instruments. He said that as many as thirty students in the Anandpur Sahib academy were training themselves to perform Kirtan on traditional lines, and they would fill the vacuum of Ragi Jathas lacking traditional skills in using traditional musical accompaniment. "We used the Harmonium partially, and it would cease to be the part of Kirtan in due course of time," he added. Wahe Guru

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

LK · 14 Mar 2006

This was about a month ago wasn't it?

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

sanjo · 14 Mar 2006

i saw the kirtan actually it was brilliant, loved it. but i wouldnt like to see the harmonium disappear.

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

baba singh · 14 Mar 2006

guru 's kiertsn returns ? from where ? only because of tanti saaj? The saaj makes kirtan ?

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Harcharan Singh · 15 Mar 2006

Kirtan performed as instructed in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj, in compliance with Guru Ji's Nirdaareth raag and and the correct use of Rahao performed by Guru pyare makes Guru Ji's kirtan, Guru Ji's saaj obviously bring us closer to how Kirtan was done in Maharajs day - the corrrect instruments for Guru's kirtan. Please don't turn this into "what about all the people who don't comply with the above.." The subject heading issimply implying "how kirtan was done in Guru Ji's day - hence Guru Ji's kirtan.

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

A Story of My life · 15 Mar 2006

Vahiguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa! Vahiguroo Jee Kee Fateh! I am a Hindu Bhaiyaa who wants to convert to Sikhism. Sorry I don't like to refer to myself as a hindu because I have been living the lifestyle of a Sikh for quite some time now. I was born in patiala but then we moved to Harmandir Sahib when I was a kid and I was so touched by the beauty of the Gurbani that was recited in the Darbar Sahib. When 1984 came around the police came to my house looking for Sikhs. I told them I was a Sikh and I would die for the Sikh gurus. But my parents told them I was crazy and I was really a Hindu and presented my birth certificate to them prooving I was a Hindu. 1984 really touched me deeply I still cry to this day about it. I now live in Toronto and have been living here for 3 years now. I am 35 years of age. When I was in Harmandir Sahib I used to sit there for hours. One day the granthi sahib asked me if I ever went to the mandir and he was surprised he said if you are a true hindu be a hindu and go to the mandir. He said that is was Sant Jarnail Singh said. I was so touched by hearing that the personality of such a saintly man was being destroyed by people who had hijacked Hinduism and made it a fanatical religion. Praise be to waheguru for saving me. I keep all my hair and wear a dastaar and kara but I was wondering if I could take amrit. I have my nitnem memorized and have had the opportunity to put my musical talents ahead abd pursue gurmat sangeet. I learnt Hindustani Classical Vocal Music from my father who learnt from the great Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan and was good friends with Ustad Amir Khan Sahib. However, I have realized that singing those Hindu bhajans and ghazals and what not were useless. One day, since I am fluent in English, Punjabi, Hindi and French, I picked up an amrit kirtan that was given to me as a gift from one of my good friends before I left Amritsar College. He told me to recite at least one shabad a day after doing my nitnem and I would be very happy. I started doing this and saw that realized the beautifal raags the Gurus chose to write them in I was amazed! I started doing the kirtan and I got so much anand it was amazing. I just wish I could take amrit soon. Please let me know of upcoming amrit sanchaars. I just thought I would share my story with you. Thanks. [%sig%]

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Singh · 15 Mar 2006

It is not that the actual music or naad or even the Saaj that makes kirtan. The thing is that a tradition started by OUR Guru Jis YES I MEAN OUR SIKH GURU JIS is now being revived. In the gurmat sangeet tradition that the guru jis started there is so much emphasis on bani is beautiful. I do not see why every time a Sikh begins learning an artistical form of rendering bani people are like WHAT ARE YOU DOIN?G?!? People have told me that there is not point learning raag just learn the bani. But if I feel I can do what's the harm? And its not even about me If I feel so proud of my Gurus ( this is not ego but a form of saying feeling so connected with my Guru) teaching and love the Gurus why should I not try being like them. Its like this everyone looks at Michael Jordan and they are like we want to be like him. They may not even get close but that is a dream. I think if we can learn gatka we can learn gurmat sangeet. Why don't we go out and learn another martial art why do we have to learn gatka? Not only do we see the spirituality but we also want to do it because the Gurus did it and Gursikhs used it. THEY ALSO USED RAAG! Guru Gobind Singh Ji was the creator of the taoos and have you seen his rabab? it is beautiful? Now you are telling me Guru Ji wouldn't be proud that we are trying to revive the Gurus Kirtan OR Gods Kirtan? Now tell me are you wrong or are the people who feel they want to be like the guru in every which way wrong? Well guess what non of us our wrong I just wanted to make a point that by creating this stigma against tanti saaj and kirtan we are not doing any good. Sorry I did not meant any offense or Iw as not trying to bash anyone. Bhul Chak Maaf. I am just a lowly beggar I make many mistakes. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Jee Kee Fa teh!

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Harcharan Singh · 15 Mar 2006

Story of my life Ji... You are blessed. I am sure Tapoban Sahib or any Gurdwara near where you live will be glad to help you achieve your wish of becoming Guru Gobind Singh child. I find it amazing that our divine gift which has been hijacked by Ghazal, Quawali, Hindu Classical singers... (I say hijacked, becuase non of them has ever given our Guru's mention - the source of their success) is now coming full circle and returing to the panth. Please stay strict in doing kirtan in Guru Ji's raag, don't compromise, learn more, you need to ensure that you don't bring Indian Classical influences to kirtan i.e. singin raags at certain tmes, long alaaps, rendering sur during a shabd etc... Follow the Rahao as chorus and create beautiful compositions... I would love to meet you and/or hear your kirtan in raag, if you have time, please contact me, may be we can share some thoughts/tips. Address is [address removed]. ps, Baba Jarnail Singh did make those comments, but what he meant was simply, whatever path you choose to follow, make sure you follow it properly, as God intended (he did not damn the rest of the non-sikh planet as some people do today). You have chosen to follow in Guru Maharaj's path, so you know what you want, and you are trying to do it correctly, there could be nothing which is more beautiful than this.. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru j iki Fateh

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Raag · 15 Mar 2006

I don't see the big hoha about using the right string instruments. Whats the tanpura going to do for you when you need to stand up for Sikhi. All this focus on using ancient string instruments, it's all a farce. Stop the meat and sharab in the Gurdwara run community halls. These classical singhs sit in the same halls in thoses Gurdwaras where meat and sharab are allowed to be served. i.e Ramgharia Slough, Southgate For what, "A performance". Might as well become naamdharis and do nothing but sell your performances.

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Harcharan Singh · 15 Mar 2006

Raag or who ever you are, You should be brave enough to use your real name if your going to make statements like that, which bring zero contribution to this topic. In that case we can apply your unintelligent arguement to Bhai Mardana and his rabab, what was the point Guru Nanak Dev Ji having Bhai Mardana with him 24/7 - over a journey of 12,000 miles, and what was the point our Guru's inventing and gifting us with these divine instruments which you are now brave enough to call a farce. Very brave, people like you, hiding behind forums and making pathetic comments. If you have an issue with community centres and it is true what you are saying then do something about it, open a new thread, what has this got to do with it? If some kirtan has been done in halls for reasons i.e. there may have been an Akand Paath or capacity, or to demonstrate instrumental solo's in promoting the instruments (which is not respectful to do in front of Maharaj, because it doesn't constitute kirtan), how are the Gursikh perfoming to know what goes on in the halls? You should have come forward and informed them. Please, think, and be constructive and not destructive.

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

babasingh · 15 Mar 2006

if raagi is siting in darbar sahib with his tanpura and singing shabad with two tablas, two sitars, three sarangis and his mind is busy to follow whole group and trying to remember tunes alaps he learned from his ustads And other singh is siting in prison with no instruments, his eyes r closed but he is playing his karay as khartalan and singing shabad from his heart in pooran rang withouit knowing around which one is gurus kirtan?

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Harcharan Singh · 15 Mar 2006

I wasn't aware those were the only 2 options in the world.

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

babasingh · 15 Mar 2006

thats just example harcharan singh

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Raviraj Singh · 16 Mar 2006

In my opinion it is not that we are placing emphasis on the instrument we are simply preserving a tradition of the guru jis. It does on make you any less a sikh or any less religious if you don't choose sting instruments. But, we should at least respect them, not in the sense that they are Guru Ji becasue they are not even, but because Guru ji blessed us with them. This is what I call true pyaar. A long with the panj kakkars and amrit guru ji blessed us with gurmat sangeet. It is said that guru gobind singh ji sang with a tanpura, he also played the rabab and created the taoos. Is not this great!?! Please do not put down this tradition. In my view if you can put this tradition down then whats the point of upholding any other Sikh tradition? I do feel however, without the bani and naam abhyaas this stuff is not important and has no value. Listen to kirtan with tanti saaz and you will feel the difference though just the way they work with your psyche. However, also making it excessive with having like 20 instruments and singing a shabad now that is wrong. This is usually how it is you will have 3-4 kirtanee singing. It is known that many people used to sing together and sing bani in raag. There is usually maybe 2-3 people playing a string instrument, maybe one tanpura or swarmandal. Back in the days you might have had 20 people singing but maybe 3-4 with instruments. I mean we don''t need to make it excessive yet we can hold on to a tradition. And traditionally sitar is not used in gurmat sangeet. Also when you look at alaap. in my opinion it is wrong to use them in between a shabad just as it is wrong using naam simran in the middle of the shabad. It just breaks the attention that you should be paying to the shabad and you may loose the shabads meaning. Traditionally in gurmat sangeet there are really no alaaps. The style that was used was Dhrupad. This is known as a chant form in music and is very slow and breaks up the shabd so you can get the full meaning of the bani. However, nowadays some people just do not want to listen to the bani so tunes have been sped up. But anyways, this was a very devotional form that was used even by our gurus. Please do not bash this style of kirtan as it is purely gurmat. I learn gurmat sangeet and still have a lot to learn i have jsut touched the tip of the iceberg. Let me tell you it is very meditative and you make a deep connection with Akaal Purakh Waheguru Ji. I am not trying to be egotistical or anything please don't misunderstand me. It is just very difficult to write my attachment with wahegurus love. There is nothign wrong with any other kirtan other than it is destroying such a beautiful tradition. We already have assimilation into bollywood tunes. This is part of our history just as gatka and I don't any of us would want to see it die!!?? People we need a revival movement and I think gurmat sangeet is an integral aspect of a sikhs life. Let me tell you that you can sing without any instruments too. If I was to go to jail I would probably sing my bani any time its because it is something I love. From Guru Ji I feel people just see faults in everyone else instead of looking at their own faults. Ham Nahee Changay Bura Nahee Koay. Also Sikhi also has a personal aspect to it so if you feel gurmat sangeet helps your sikhi path please pursue it. Sorry for the super long post and Bhul Chuk Maaf. Sorry if I offended anyone that was not my intent. Waheguru have mercy on us all.

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Harcharan Singh · 16 Mar 2006

Wahe-Guru ji ka Khalsa Wahe-Guru Ji ki Fateh, Baba Singh Ji, Guru Maharaj's Kirtan, is kirtan done makeing the "most" of any resources around you to do the kirtan justice. The answer would be both are Guru Ji's kirtan. I don't think Prof Kartar thing would have any of the troubles you mentioned. Raagis who have devoted their life to singing kirtan as close as possible to how our Guru's did, have no need to recall anything from anyone. They know gurmat sangeet like a childhood language and are able to render endless variations of one raag intuitively. Baba Singh Ji, when you eat roti every day, does you mind first of all recall how your parents taught you to eat? Vere Ji, please don't discredit those like Kartar Singh, who in the face of Bollywood kirtan popularity, have struggled to keep Guru Ji's kirtan maryada alive. There is no need to always compare everyone to a member of AKJ as I see happeing on this forum so often. We should all learn to see and take the good from people. It would be nice to see a senior member of the Jathaa tell the youth/new initiates this once in a while i.e. there have been and still are thousands of Gursikh who exist outside of the Jathaa who do much seva for the panth. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Harcharan Singh · 16 Mar 2006

Pre-British/SGPC days kirtan was performed by many raagis. Reasons are obvious, there were no microphones, amplifiers and ludspeakers then, so to reach a sangat of thousands, raagis had to train their voices very hard and there needed to be a number of saaj to reach all the sangat, it was a true labour of love. Then the mysterious (not to mysterious) disappearance of both raag and Guru de saaj happened. Here is a picture (Dhanvaadh LK ji), of Darbaar Sahib and some of it's raagis at the turn of the century. To get an idea, for those of you who do kirtan in Gurdwara sangat, try an experiment and don't use the electrics, this will really help you to appreciate how tuff and talented the puratan raagis were back in the day... I recently heard a perfomance done without mics and many saaj/kirtani, it sounded awesome, the volume of the joraa, saaj and voices was in complete balance and complimented each other perfectly. Today, we find either the tabla, the baja or the voice of one kirtani is overpowering in most cases, due to modern intervention. Waheguru

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Raviraj Singh · 16 Mar 2006

This picture can also be found in Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha's Mahan Kosh! :)

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

babasingh · 16 Mar 2006

The answer would be both are Guru Ji's kirtan.(harcharan singh ji ) that means it was always there not returning with tanti saajs

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Raviraj Singh · 16 Mar 2006

Baba Singh agreed, but the return of using the instruments and raags blessed to us by guru ji to recite guru jis shabad is what is returning. I am not bashing AKJ or anyone I believe we are all Sikhs here and don't belong to any one jatha. I am just trying to make you realize this event is significant in that there is an attempt at reviving the gurmat sangeet tradition' but not the shabad gurbani because gurbani has always been present. There is nothing wrong with doing akj style kirtan or any other style but it is also beautiful that people want to stick to traditions :) just as people are trying to revive and preserve gatka amongst the Sikhs. This is just an attempt to ensure that this tradition remains ever lasting. I mean we don't have to wear bana all the time but we choose to ensure the beautiful saroop of guru ji does not go away and we adhere to the path of Sikhi. I know that is a bad analogy my apologies but just feel happy that there is an attempt to preserve our traditions. We should try preserve our Sikh Culture (note not the punjabi culture) in every which way. Look at the Hindu fold for example.. there is an arya samaj temple near my house in markham (14th and Kennedy) and although I am aware of their history in relation to Sikhi, they have classes for kids to preserve their heritage. They always proclaim that hindu culture is the culture of india however that is not true. Look at how they are capitalizing on Sikhs who gave up so much for India and to the South Asian culture. Without Sikhism Punjab would really have no culture other than bhangra, bhang, sharab and heer ranjah! What kind of culture would that be? Let's get together and make Sikh Culture so rooted amongst our Sikhs and our youth that we will never be made fools of. Sorry for any hurtful comments I may have written I am only a mere slave to the waheguru and the world and I will have made mistakes. Bhul Chuk Maaf.. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Harcharan Singh · 17 Mar 2006

Unfortunatlely Guru Ji's gifts weren't there. If there was an option, then I am sure they would have been. Today there is an option. Hence, Guru Ji's gifts are returning. If I started doing kick boxing and claimed it was Guru Hargobind Ji's shaster vidya, would I be right? No, but that does not mean that if I am ever in a circumstance where I do not have access to Guru Ji's martial art, or access to kirpana, khande, chakkar etc, that I wouldn't still fight anyway I know how? This is not a competition, it's your choice if you want to adopt your Guru's culture or more modern trends, but please don't use gursikh who went through hard times as an excuse for us all not to make an effort. Everyone is trying to preserve all other aspects of Guru Ji's heritage, this is no less important. Just because it is not dominant in our lives, does not mean it is not important to the Sikh panth - anything that was important to our Guru Sahiban, should be important to the panth.. Waheguru

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

LK · 17 Mar 2006

Picture psoted by Bhai Harcharan Singh: also, babasingh, Guru's Kirtan is that which is done with Guru's isntructions isn't it =)?

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

singh · 17 Mar 2006

bhai harcharan singh, u say singhs of the past didnt have the resources available to maybe perform on tanti saaj. yet the pic is of raagis at the turn of the century. this is roughly the same time period as Sant Attar Singh, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, and other great gursikhs. my point is that this surely shows resources were available for learning saaj bt for some reason the did not. Yet these singhs reached immense spiritual heights performing non title raag kirtan on vaja. agreed title raag kirtan is excellent, yet if one does not perform on tanti saaj, and not in title raag, these gursikhs are examples of wat still can be achieved!

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

babasingh · 17 Mar 2006

Guru ji never said in Gurbani to use certain instruments to do keertan. First guru sahib used rabab but in the time of next guru jis sikhs started using different saajs. There was change. They were never instructed by guru sahib to use them and leave rabab does that means it was not guru nanaks keertan? If in guru granth sahibs time we r using vaja . Why its not guru jis keertan ? if the whole sangat is singing shabad all together without any instrument thats also a keertan no one holds sitars tanpure rababs in nagar keertan sangat just play chimtay with gurbani we still say its nagar keertan there is no saaj who has power to make it keertan LK can u plzzz tell whats gurujis instructions are ? guru ji never says to leave the saajs or stuck with them. No big importance kb ko BwlY GuMGrU qwlw kb ko bjwvY rbwbu ] kab ko bhaalai ghu(n)gharoo thaalaa kab ko bajaavai rabaab || How long must one search for angle bells and cymbals, and how long must one play the guitar? Awvq jwq bwr iKnu lwgY hau qb lgu smwrau nwmu ]1] aavath jaath baar khin laagai ho thab lag samaaro naam ||1|| In the brief instant between coming and going, I meditate on the Naam, the Name of the Lord. ||1|| myrY min AYsI Bgiq bin AweI ] maerai man aisee bhagath ban aaee || Such is the devotional love which has been produced in my mind. hau hir ibnu iKnu plu rih n skau jYsy jl ibnu mInu mir jweI ]1] rhwau ] ho har bin khin pal rehi n sako jaisae jal bin meen mar jaaee ||1|| rehaao || Without the Lord, I cannot live even for an instant, like the fish which dies without water. ||1||Pause|| kb koaU mylY pMc sq gwiex kb ko rwg Duin auTwvY ] kab kooo maelai pa(n)ch sath gaaein kab ko raag dhhun out(h)aavai || How long must one tune the five strings, and assemble the seven singers, and how long will they raise their voices in song? mylq cunq iKnu plu csw lwgY qb lgu myrw mnu rwm gun gwvY ]2] maelath chunath khin pal chasaa laagai thab lag maeraa man raam gun gaavai ||2|| In the time it takes to select and assemble these musicians, a moment elapses, and my mind sings the Glorious Praises of the Lord. ||2|| kb ko nwcY pwv pswrY kb ko hwQ pswrY ] kab ko naachai paav pasaarai kab ko haathh pasaarai || How long must one dance and stretch out one's feet, and how long must one reach out with one's hands? hwQ pwv pswrq iblmu iqlu lwgY qb lgu myrw mnu rwm sm@wrY ]3] haathh paav pasaarath bilam thil laagai thab lag maeraa man raam samhaarai ||3|| Stretching out one's hands and feet, there is a moment's delay; and then, my mind meditates on the Lord. ||3|| kb koaU logn kau pqIAwvY loik pqIxY nw piq hoie ] kab kooo logan ko patheeaavai lok patheenai naa path hoe || How long must one satisfy the people, in order to obtain honor? jn nwnk hir ihrdY sd iDAwvhu qw jY jY kry sBu koie ]4]10]62] jan naanak har hiradhai sadh dhhiaavahu thaa jai jai karae sabh koe ||4||10||62|| O servant Nanak, meditate forever in your heart on the Lord, and then everyone will congratulate you. ||4||10||62||

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

LK · 17 Mar 2006

----------- Author: babasingh Date: 03-17-06 09:09 Guru ji never said in Gurbani to use certain instruments to do keertan. First guru sahib used rabab but in the time of next guru jis sikhs started using different saajs. There was change. They were never instructed by guru sahib to use them and leave rabab does that means it was not guru nanaks keertan? If in guru granth sahibs time we r using vaja . Why its not guru jis keertan ? ------------- 1- No-one has ever said that the kirtan HAS TO be done with Tanpura, Taos, Saranda etc, you choose your instrument yourself, just that it's really sad we're replacing the instruments that our GURUS designed and INVENTED for a BRITISH Invention (or German I think) We are clearly replacing the instrument designed and played by our Gurus to one that was brough to INdia by the British. If you want to do Kirtan with a vaja - go for it, just make sure tha the gift of the Guru isn't lost :) --------- if the whole sangat is singing shabad all together without any instrument thats also a keertan no one holds sitars tanpure rababs in nagar keertan sangat just play chimtay with gurbani we still say its nagar keertan there is no saaj who has power to make it keertan LK can u plzzz tell whats gurujis instructions are ? ----------- The ones clearly written in black and white right above every signel shabad. Guru Sahibs instructions are written RIGHT before the shabad, yet you missed it last time you were reading Gurbani? Good on u for quoting Gurbani out of context.

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Singh · 17 Mar 2006

"A Story of My life" ji Do you teach hindustani vocal? If you would be willing to, could you give me your number?

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

babasingh · 17 Mar 2006

LK The ones clearly written in black and white right above every signel shabad. Guru Sahibs instructions are written RIGHT before the shabad, yet you missed it last time you were reading Gurbani" who told u that i missed it r u anteryami ? it just says raags name there but we r talking about saajs its not writen that which saaj we have to use for that raag only thing i am saying is that guru's keertan wasnt gone anywhere without tanti saajs Goray singhs use guitar it was never used by any guru sahib does it means its not a keertan ?

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

Harcharan Singh · 18 Mar 2006

BabaSingh Ji, This is a silly arguement. Please anser this question: If you "have a choice",are you going to use divinely designed instruments given to us by our Guru's, to which no instrument on Earth can compare visually, technically or spiritually (as they were specifically designed to do jirtan in raag), OR; Are you going to use a Austrian invented instrument that was originally designed for and used by street performers in the gettos of Europe? Secondly, it was forcibly introduced in a very short time perdiod in 1905 (no one questions this) when also at the same time, our tanthi saaj disappeared. Ultimately, you cannot do raag on a Vaaja. Vaaja does not allow the use of meend and gamak and does not produce microtones, which are core to differentiating between Guru Ji's raags. YES, if we do not have access to Guru Ji's saaj, then anything will do as a subsitute, even a dijaridu (Aboriginal piece) as Daya Singh uses to perfom Kirtan. Lastly, no one is forcing anyone to use anything to perform kirtan, the important subject is Nirdaareth Raag, that is Guru Ji's hukum, if we could use the irreplaceable instruments that Guru Ji blessed us with, that would be even better. We are simply trying to promote our Guru's gifts, what is peoples problem with that? If you want to keep on using the gorayan da vaaja, good luck to you, but please stop questioning those who want to see their Guru's saaj bacj in Guru's ghar. If we didn't have dastaar material one day and had to wear a baseball cap, would that make it ok to wear a cap for the rest of our lives? Also, please stop using mahapurkh as an aid to this arguement. We are using our Guru's as role models, there should be no need for further comparisons. Mahapurkh are not here to ask questions to today, but our Guru's hukum and gifts are returning, we should seek to give them their rightful status back. Waheguru

Re: Guru's Kirtan returns to Darbaar Sahib...

babasingh · 18 Mar 2006

wah bai wah harcharan singh u r compairing vaaja with baseball hat. We have rehatname for hat but never heared of any rehatnama for vaaja do u know guru ji used to make gumbads in gurduwara but we r using speakers.Isnt it a keertan if its coming from speakers? its not guru's hukam and gift what question u wanna ask to mahanpurakhs. In last centuray bhai randhir singh ji, sant sujan singh ji, singhs from taksal and many other gurmukhs n ragis did keertan with vaaja how they got many blessings from akal purakh if they never did gurus keertan ? yes we can use any instrument and it will be still gurus keertan