Re: Life on Saturn's Moon?
Singh Soorma · 10 Mar 2006
Daas Soora,
I agree with what you are saying, but how is discussing the possibility of life on another planet/solar system/galaxy any less relevent than what goes on in the world. If life exists on other planets, then that is a part of Vaheguru's Kudarat and his hukam and nothing is above Vaheguru's hukam. Vaheguru is Sarb Viapak, he is ever present in everything and everyone in the universe. So stop hating the universe. Non of us have seen Maya for what is really is i.e. illusion.
Gurbani and the Janamsakhis do not dispute the fact that life can exist on other places than Earth. Unless you can provide a Gurbani tukh which proves that life does not exist outside of earth.
Re: Life on Saturn's Moon?
Singh Soorma · 10 Mar 2006
Daas Soora Jee,
I don’t know how that Tukh proves that there is no life outside of earth. On the contrary, we have numerous Tukhs saying that there are life forms all over the universe. In Japji Sahib while narrating about Karam Khand, Guru Nanak Dev Jee clearly says the following:
THITHE BHAGAT, VASAI KAY LOH||
KREH ANAND, SACHA MAN SOE||
The Bhagats of many worlds (kay loh) dwell in Karam Khand
Where they are in Anand as Vaheguru is ever present in their Mann(mind)
Guru Nanak Dev Jee clearly tells us that life not only thrives in other worlds, but innumerable Bhagats in Karam Khand come from many different worlds (kay loh).
Guru Nanak Sahib further writes:
THITHE KHAND, MANDAL, VARBHAND
JAY KO KATHAY, TA ANTH NA ANTH
THITHE LOH, LOH AKAR
There are planets, solar systems and galaxies.
If one speaks of them, there is no limit, no end.
There are worlds upon worlds of His Creation.
You see Daas soora jee, Guru Nanak Sahib further expands on how Vahegurus creation is so large that there is no end to how much a person can talk of it. Furthermore, if you read the Sakhis of Guru Nanak Sahib, please read the Sakhi of when Guru Jee went to Baghdad. According to Bhai Gurdas Jee, Guru Nanak not only took Pir Dastgir’s son to numerous worlds but also brought back parshad from another world. Bhai Gurdas Jee writes that Guru Nanak Sahib did this Kalaa within an eye blink (akh phurkh). Kavi Santokh Singh also confirms this sakhi and even goes into more detail than Bhai Gurdas Jee.
Re: Life on Saturn's Moon?
Singh Soorma · 11 Mar 2006
Daas Soora jee, I think that you are talking about the theory of Multiverse. According to this theory, there are many parallel universes like our own, and many earths in those universes like our own. I don’t dispute this either as even Gurbani mentions that their are many universes i.e. multiverse.
But within our own universe, Gurbani mentions that there are Bhagats from other worlds. What do you think Khand, Mandal, Varbhand means? It translates to earths, solar systems, and galaxies. Even the Upanishads mention this.
So in a way what you are saying is also correct as Gurbani does not dispute the multiverse theory (Kaee Sarishtieaa), but at the same time Gurbani also mentions that in Karam Khand there are Bhagats from many Khands, Mandals, and Varbhands. Also please read Bhai Gurdas Dhia Vara and Kavi Santokh Singh’s sooraj Parkash where the Sakhi of Guru Nanak Dev Jee and Pir Dastgir’s son. In Sooraj Parkash, Kavi Santokh Singh leaves no doubt that there are Bhagats on other worlds.
[%sig%]
Re: Life on Saturn's Moon?
Singh Soorma · 12 Mar 2006
Singh Soora the tukh you provided i.e. brehamai vaedh veechaar aakh sunaaeiaa|| man a(n)dhar aha(n)kaar jagath oupaaeiaa||(But created the universe out of his ego. Brahma thoughtfully recited the four Vedas;)
This tukhs doesn’t really disprove that life exists on other worlds. I dont know how you interpret Tukhs to come to such a conclusion. All it says is that the universe was created out of Brahmas ego. Bhai Vir Singh Jee translates this tukh differently. This Enlgish translation wrongly translates ‘Jagath’ as universe. Jagath is a Punjabi word which means world, not universe. So the correct translation of that tukh would be “Brahma created the world(Jagath) out of his ego”.
I think that you are making the same mistake that a lot of people in the west make. The English translations of Guru Granth Sahib and Bhai Gurdas Dhia Vara are not 100% accurate. The most accurate translations are in Punjabi, especially the ones which are done in accordance to the grammar rules. Please read Bhai Vir Singh Jee’s translation of Bhai Gurdas Dhia Vara. In the Punjabi translations you will never see concepts such as planetary systems, solar systems, universe being described as higher world or lower worlds. You only see English translations doing this abomination of a translation. The problem is that the English translations are not direct translations of Gurbani, but inaccurate attempts to translate the Punjabi translations of Gurbani. That is why they are so inaccurate. They are innacurate translations of translations, not direct translations of Gurbani like the Punjabi ones are. Just take a look at the following inaccurate translation:
lakh akaash pathaal lakh akh furak vich sabh dhikhalaaee||
And in a wink of eye visualized him the upper and lower worlds.
The English translation of this tukh wrongly translates Akaash Pathaal as ‘upper and lower worlds’. The Punjabi translations translate Akaash as sky and Pathaal as earth. You see, these are materialistic in nature and not spiritual realms as you think. If you read Suraj Parkash, Kavi Santokh Singh writes Guru Nanak Dev Jee showed the boy many worlds within our universe taking many years, and all this happened within an eye blink (akh phurk) as if Guru Jee even has control over Time itself.
Furthermore, if there is no life on other worlds, then please kindly exlpain to me what does the following tukh translate to in Japjee Sahib:
THITHE BHAGAT, VASAI KAY LOH||
KREH ANAND, SACHA MAN SOE||
The Bhagats of many worlds (kay loh) dwell in Karam Khand
Where they are in Anand as Vaheguru is ever present in their Mann(mind)
I would be very interested to know how you would translate these straightforward tukhs which clearly say that in Karam Khand, there are Bhagats from many worlds. Either Guru Nanak Dev Jee is wrong in stating that there are Bhagats in Karam Khand from many different worlds, or you are wrong in stating that there are no such worlds and that life only thrives on earth (which Gurbani clearly does not support).
What is even more interesting is that today I went to the Gurdwara. At the Gurdwara the Singh that was doing Katha on the meaning of "Lakh Pataala Pataal, Lakh Agaasha Agaash"(Japji Sahib). This Giani said that like earth there are other worlds with life on it in out universe. He even gave Guru Nanak Dev Jee's sakhi in Baghdad as a reference to prove that Bhagat are on other planetary systems.. This incident left me totally blown away. I take this as a divine sign from Vaheguru that my views on this subject are the correct ones as the Singh was saying exactly what I was saying. This was no coincidence for me.
[%sig%]
Re: Life on Saturn's Moon?
Singh Soorma · 12 Mar 2006
LK jee, you have misunderstood what I wrote. I did not say that Karam Khand, Sachkhand are planets. Of course they are spiritual realms, as Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee also confirms this in his book ‘Sachkhand Darshan’.
What I wrote was that in Japjee Sahiab it says:
'THITHE BHAGAT, VASAI KAY LOH||
KREH ANAND, SACHA MAN SOE||
The Bhagats of many worlds (kay loh) dwell in Karam Khand
Where they are in Anand as Vaheguru is ever present in their Mann(mind)'
Here Guru Jee says that in Karam Khand, there are Bhagat from many different worlds like our own. Of course Karam Khand is not a planet (physical). It is a spiritual Thah, Jagaa like Sachkhand which is beyond our physical comprehension of the 5 senses. But the roohs(spiritual beings) that reside there were originally from materialistic worlds like earth.
Karam Khand like Sach Khand is a spiritual Thah that a parkashvaan rooh will go to after the physical death. A Parkashvaan Rooh can access KaramKhand, Sachkhand while alive as Dasam Duar is the direct access to those high spiritual realms (depending on the spiritual level of the rooh one will get access to Karamkhand or Sachkhand).
[%sig%]
Re: Life on Saturn's Moon?
Singh Soorma · 13 Mar 2006
LK Jee,
Whether or not the Khands are a spiritual state is a matter of another discussion. This idea that it is a 'spiritual state' was first thought of by Sahib Singh. But Sahib Singh also admits that he has never had any mystical experience. Bhai Randhir Singh Jee who also was an expert in Viakaran writes that the Khands are actual spiritual realms, and he has also had mystical experiences. The term Khand itself means thah, Jagga. I don’t know how Sahib Singh translated these as 'spiritual states'.