Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Jagjit Singh · 08 Mar 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, in the last few years, many youth have gone towards reviving the classical instruments and learning Raag kirtan. I have always thought this is a good thing. It is excellent that we strive to learn the knowledge of raags. The movement towards this has been successfully led by indivduals like Prof Surinder Singh ji, who I consider a friend. I do wish to see keertan with prataan instruments. I agree this tradition should be revived. But lets not do it by criticisng everything which is non-raag. I do also think at time some pro-raag people are far too critical of non-raag keertan. Obviously everyone is against filmi tunes, but when people go as far as saying non-raag keertan is pure manmat. It make me wonder if we are not understanding the power of gurbani, and if raag has come before bani? Sangaate keertan has an important place in sikhi. It is a good thing that thousands have learned keertan and have easy access to it, learn it and teach others. The aim is always to join a human to bani, so that that human can meet Akaal. Raag keertan will never be as popular as sangaate keertan, because sangatee keertan involves the sangat en mass. Only "virlee" will ever appreciate raag. Most people find it very dry. Initially everyone likes seeing the fancy instruments, but will they travel across the country to go to raag darbars in 5 years time, like people do for rainsbhais. As far as raags. Indian music has raags as per a few notes. This is also what some youth seem to think they are. This is wrong. A raag is an emotion. The raag of the shabad is the emotion in which Guru ji was when he composed that shabad. So if raag is that emotion. The key then is to do that sahbad is the same emotion. Often I see raagis do the tunes of the raag, but they are not in that emotion, but in an emotion of ego that they can do that raag. This is pure showmanship. So is the whole "sa re ga ma" in shabad which often raagi do. When doing keertan, one should should only speak the shabad. Real emotion comes with seva, abyass, and developing a bond with Akaal via Amrit vela, and a Jeevan imbued in sangat. They are the real raagis, who sing Guru ji praises from the depths of their hearts. Prof Surinder Singh once shared a story with me, which I thought was amazing. Bhai sahib Randhir Singh once did keertan. Bhai sahib would spend hours in keertan ras, doing just one shabad for up to 48 hours. Once he did this shabad. The next day newspapers ran this story that Bhai sahib did a shabad in a raag which is highly rare. Ustads from all over india came to Bhai sahib to learn that raag. But when they came to Bhai sahib, bhai sahib just said, as I heard that shabad from Akaal (unhad shabad) so I sang it. Pyare jio, that is the true raagi, one who is imbued in the True Rang, the True emotion. Not those who know a raagi tune. The aim of this post is not to put down raag keertan, quite the contrary, but instead to make people realise that sometimes we are taking raag before bani, and further comments like non raag keertan is manmat, is very disrespectful to the power of bani. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Harcharan Singh · 08 Mar 2006

Khalsa Ji, You are correct in much of what you say. Where manmat is mentioned - there is nothing offensive intended. Gurmat or manmat - Guru's kirtan or our Kirtan? If we don't have a choice it will always be Guru's kirtan. If we have a choice, then you tell me? You are totally right in stating that many raagi are pure performers, this is the exact reason we need real raagis. The difference you have mentioned is called musicology, this is the missing element, the ashaas, the emotion, most raagis simply know and perform terminlogy only. Raag kirtan is about both terminology and musicology, we need both. When you talk of people getting bored etc, it is because of terminology. Anyone who has heard emotion in kirtan (raag) is addicted forever. So I disagree with your statement that Nirdaareth raag kirtan will always come second. Where was this sangatee kirtan you speak of for 400 years until the gorai came? No matter what you or anyone says, no composition or melody will ever compare to Guru Ji's Nirdaareth raags, they have been put in Gurbani for a reason, to be followed, as they were for hundreds of years. When it comes to making a choice and having the opportunity to make the choice, all Khalsa Panth will eventually choose their Guru over the curent evolved kirtan culture. I agree with you, the musicology, emotion, pyaar comes from Guru pyare, not from raag giaan, but do people keep mentioning this, it's common sense. The same goes for people in compete banaa, people who do naam drih, people who do NITNEM, people who do sarbloh bibeki langar seva, all is useless without pyaar for Guru. Guru Ji gave us the Nirdaarth raag for a reason, not becasue he was bored, or wanted to give us some pointless histroical info, it is at the start of every shabad, why do we keep ignoring this and justifying our current culture which has only been around for 100 years or less? Why then bother to tie dumalla, why wear blue, why keep reading gurmukhi...because this was our Guru's culture, that is more important and is timeless. Nirdaareth raag is greater than these things because it forms the framework of Bani and is the 1st hukum before the shabad starts. Think, why change the way our Guru did kirtan? Only one answer - because we don't know raag. That answer is fair enough for our Gursikh family over teh last hundred years who never had these resources. But today what is our excuse. There is none. Waheguru.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

ok · 08 Mar 2006

i totally agree with Veer Jagjit Singh's and Veer Harcharan SIngh's posts. You both have principally said the same things, but only disagreed on minute points. THis puzzled me though: >>>>>>>>>> Where manmat is mentioned - there is nothing offensive intended. Gurmat or manmat - Guru's kirtan or our Kirtan? >>>>>>>>>> How can gurbani shabad keertan EVER be 'our kirtan'? Even if it is not sung in raag doesn't mean that it is OUR keertan. I think you meant guru's style (more beneficial) or OUR style, right? However, I do agree that we should all try to rediscover our roots i.e. gurbani sangeet.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Jagjit Singh · 09 Mar 2006

waheguru ji kakhalsa waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, like I said, I think it is a good thing that there is a revival in the musicology of keertan. It is something everyone can benefit from, my post was more to do with how some people are taking it to an extreme, which we should be careful of. If we consider a rainsbhai, for example. In the hall you may have 100- 300 people sitting there. Many for at least 10 hours. If we take the music bit out for a minute. Here we have 100-300 people sitting in a gurdwara, singing or reading Gurbani for 10 hours. Now if you saw an akhand path and a sangat like that was sitting listening to it, everyone would say that is amazing and pure Gurmat. So for some just by adding a non-raag tune to the situation, something which is Pure Gurmat, will suddenly become pure manmat is such an illogical statement. In fact, it makes one think that people making these statements consider the raag higher than the bani, and do not realise the "Paras kala" of bani. I am not saying Veer Harcharan Singh is saying that, but I mention it because some youth are getting drunk on their knowledge of raags, or others who are just commentators, and are saying such things. So we should be careful before we judge keertan and bani is such a way. I agree with Veer Harcharan Singh that knoweldge of musicology is a good thing and should be encouraged. Knowledge of musicology for a keertani is just as important as knowledge of Laagan matra for any kathakar. The only thing veer harcharan singh, that you stated which makes me think is your assumption that sangattee keertan started at the time of the British. I have been in sikhi long enough to realise people blame everything on the British. I think people give them far too much credit. They did not just suddenly change sikhi A-Z as they wished. In future, people will say, laarreedar to padd-cheed happened because of the british, when in reality, laareedar to padd-ched happened because of Sikhs and their own laziness or cleverness. I have seen no eveidence to sugesst sangatee keertan did not happen at the times of the Guru jis. Even with classical instruments it does not mean sangaatee keertan cannot be done. Essentially what is sangaatee keertan. It is more than one person singing or the whole sangaat singing. It is Guru ji hukam that we all sing keertan. Guru jis wished every house to be a dhramsal. So in conclusion, feel free to promote raag keertan. But do by positively presenting musicology. We should all be clear that calling keertan, whether sangaatee or other, manmat is not right. Bani can never be manmat. waheguru ji kakhalsa waheguru ji kefateh

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Harcharan Singh · 09 Mar 2006

Veer ji, I am implying this: Do you sing or compose according to Guru Ji's hukum which is clearly stated in the Guru Granth Sahib Ji? Or do you you sing to our own composition, which it rarely ever is, most non-raag compositions are derived from other sources - you know very well what they are. Many classical compositions which were used in last 50 years, actually have their basis in folk or raag, they have just been diluted. My problem is not with them. My problem is with all the filmi and bhangra compositions that exist everywhere today, they are not isolated incidents, they are common place, and most famous kirtani use them. I know this is a difficult and sensative subject, but if we keep sugar coating the truth or ignoring it, how is change going to happen? The past 100 years are irrelevant. We should look at the previous 400 years for our answers and inspiration, namley to our Guru's. No one should ever replace them as role models, only add to them if they do not contradict our Gurus jeevan. I have met and spoken to many many giani/kirtani, some very famous ones. I have only ever had one response from them all: "Yes we know raag is the correct way, but the sangat don't like it, they will get up and walk"; in addition from 50% of them "who will feed our kids". Who do they think is feeding their kids when they are doing filmy kirtan, them, the sangat? The one who feeds them, will continue to feed them, even more so if they follow his hukum. One very talented raagi and good Gursikh who I spoke to last week, sang some beautiful but blatent filmy kirtan. He then told a beatiful saakhi of when Guru Nanak Dev Ji went to the Chorran da pind. The gist of it was that teh chor in question accepted to follow 3 rules from Maharaj, and although it seemed like he was going to loose out hugely at all three steps, he ended up being very rich. The moral - accept Guru;s hukum, live within it, don't worry about anything, Guru will take care of all - HAVE FAITH. Then he started singing beautiful filmy kirtan again. Afterward when speaking to me he told me he was a gurmat sangeet teacher and was teaching many kids like me in puratan raag!! WHY? I politely commented that if your kirtan had been in raag (as he was a raagi - with an amazing voice), it would have made my day. He says "nay puthm sangat neh ut ke chal jaana si"? Not as much faith as the chor from chorran da pind..... I am not inventing things or speculating here, i am talking from recent personal experiences, the story is always the same. The only time I feel compassion or love is when the Giani tells me he has not been blessed with raag vidya. And there are a few gianis like this, who are such pyaare sevadaar, they live for guru, and know that raag is the correct way, who we are now trying to help/educate, because their own Gurdwara, jathaa, orgs won't. The above mentioned line i.e. manmat, I have already stated - in my opinion, refers to raagis like the one mentioned above, who choose their "own" kirtan over Guru's kirtan - it refers to people who have a choice - those who know raag but don't use it. Not those who as of yet have not been blessed with Guru's raag vidya. Hope that clarifies. Sat Sri Akaal.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

ns · 09 Mar 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahegur Ji Ke Fateh Beautiful post by Harcharn Ji and Jagjit Ji, I would just like to add a small comment. May Guru Ji bless sangatan worlwide to bring about purratan kirtan in a much wider sense. However I love rehansabhai's and doubt very much I could ever get up when naam dhuni when it starts vibrating from sangat as Jagjit Ji mentions, somehow it feels as though preet takes over reet in those environments. The immense pyaar in which kirtan is done is overwhelming in AKJ rehandsabhi's it's my bread and butter. We must bear in mind that what we are talking about here most probably 80% of the sikh world is not aware of due to 100 of years of the same thing. Problem is when you preet overtakes reet for Guru's Kirtan then everything is undefinable, hope I'm making sense.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

ok · 09 Mar 2006

excellent points raised by all the veers so far! THIS is how GURMAT debate/conversation should be carried out. I am so glad that there haven't been any silly, hurtful and cheeky remarks that SOME 'Sikhs' make on this forum.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Truth · 09 Mar 2006

yes, agree with "okay"...very mature conversation. I personally have a terrible voice and not suitable for kirtan. I have no skills with musical instruments. But I love to sing Gurbani. I love Raag Kirtan, and I love sangatee kirtan. Lets just be accepting to all forms of expression of love for Maharaj. Whether it's through Bir Rassi dhadhi vaars, Sidhhi Dharna kirtan, Sangatee kirtan (both AKJ and folk), Raag kirtan, Kavi style. Lets make it a goal to never put down another Sikh for using a different method for singing maharaj ji's praises. And lets make it a goal to never put down another form of kirtan. AKJ should never put down Raag kirtan by citing examples of "most ragis don't have emotion" or "raag is too hard and boring". And Raag kirtan lovers should never call Sangatee kirtan manmat or the "easy way". If we could be accepting like this, it would be another problem solved in the panth.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

singh1234 · 09 Mar 2006

why dont we compare te rehit/jeevans of raag kirtanis vs jatha kirtanis? pr. surinder matharu v bhai jeevan singh balbir singh v. bhai joginder singh ji talwara

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Harcharan Singh · 10 Mar 2006

1234, And I suppose you are the man for the job? Looks like you are trying to start another NINDAH thread. All the above mentioned are Amritdhari and Gursikh, that is all you need to know. Stop trying to play Dharam Raj. People can make up their own minds when meeting people, nobody needs your slanderous advice. And on top of that your comment is silly, can a jathaa kirtani not be a raagi? Or vice versa? SAt Sri Akaal

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Jagjit Singh · 10 Mar 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, My purpose of starting this topic was not to put down raag kirtan. I love listening to it. But I perfer sangaatee keertan. I will go more into that in another post. Personally I see nothing wrong with puraatan instruments or raags playing more role in sangatee keertan. Lets not forget that many puraatan jatha keertans had amazing knowledge of raags. There was Bhai sahib of course, who seemed to talented at everything he touched. But there were also many Gursikhs, with obvious examples like Bhai Darshan singh Dilruba. He was given the name Dilruba because he keertan was so heart piercing. Not only was he an amazing gathka player, and the person who had so much knowledge of Gurbani that the Amrit keertan was his pothi. He compiled it. Later Gursikhs got it officially printed and it became commonly known as the Amrit keertan. But he was also the most amazing raagi. The reason I mention this for some reason some people think all AKJ keertanis do tunes, and do not do raags, when in reality this is not the case. It is just a case that so many people were influenced by Mohinder singh SDO style of keertan, that the next generation of kertaanis used that style. Currently many youth are influenced by Bhai Harpreet singh or others and will use that style in future. In bradford, I see the youth do more raags than before. The point of writing is the extremism that is put forward by many pro-raag people, that old instruments and raag are the only way and anything else in manmat. Bani is not that weak and we should not disregard it in such a way, with such comments. Like I said a raag is not a set of keys, but an emotion. Many different tunes can evoke a emotion, not just one tune. Obviously everyone is agaisnt film tunes. We are not paraniod of raag keertan. In fact we encourage it, but also raagis should not be paraniod of sangattee keertan, because the aim of Gurmat is to get as many people singing and reading bani as much as possible. The arguments that many raag extremists use, that raag is the purataan way, is fine. Yes, try harmoniums came later. But this does not mean there was no sangattee keertan at Guru sahibs times. Sangattee keertan is simple more than one person singing. When Gurbani puts so much emphasis on everyone singing and reading Gurbani, surely at Guru sahibs time, Gursikh came together and sang bani and did simran abyass together. I have felt on many occasions people go off on wierd tangents on this forums, and I get personally put off by the many disputes. I personally would like it to go back to the old days where people people had adult conversations and shared our learning and experiences to help each other on our spiritual journeys. So if we can aviod tangents, and stick the topic. There is no competition between raag and sangattee keertan, and we should not be so petty to create one. We are just exchanging personal views and opinions, which should help our greater understanding. Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Daas Soora · 10 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib 'Truth' Jeeo made a good point that AKJ valae shouldn't put other kirtan styles down, as long as it's Gurbani being sung it's OK. You made complete sense Bhai Sahib 'ns' Jeeo, and well said. The kirtan in Saachkhand is out of this world; this is a obvious statement that Singhs would agree with, as the tunes played up their are different from most of the ones played down here. Some of these tunes from Saackhand can only be heard in Ransbaes played by some Kirtanees. Daas isn't going point fingers at certain kirtanees in the ransbae that have sang a Shabad from Saachkhand but you can normally tell by the impact and love the Gurbani and the tune sang within it sounds. The effect of Gurbani and the essence from it is felt more when the one singing it does an immense amount of Naam Bhagti, as Naam is the essence of Gurbani and teachings within tells everyone to Japp Naam. So the one who follows the teachings of Gurbani with great love would most defiantly feel the effect of it, which at the same time effects the whole of the sangat in the darbar as well. Therefore, what im trying to say is that the keertan played by a Naam Abhiyaasee vala but one that does a lot of it, plays Keertan perfectly and supremely, and the tune in which is played by that person is also true. Forgive me if i've made any mistakes. Daas Soora VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Daas Soora · 10 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh BHai Sahib Harcharan Singh Jeeo, singh1234 doesn't mean it in that way. Becareful, you don't want to jump to conclusions and hurt Guru Jee's child for no apparent reason. Daas Soora VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Harcharan Singh · 10 Mar 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ke Fateh Veer Ji, You are right in most of what you say, but you seem to suggest that hukmi kirtan cannot be done by sangat? Guru's kirtan is for the sangat, raag kirtan is for the sangat, there is only one kirtan, not so many different varieties whereby different people participate. Kirtan at Guru's time would have been in raag only, the Guru Granth Sahib is the ultimate evidence, and all the sangat would have joined in. "todays" is a result of changes happening during the British Raj, simple. Great GurSikhs like Baba Shaam Singh Ji, Baba Raam Singh Ji, Baba Harnaam Singh ji were all Nirdaareth Raag Kirtani. It was post their time that changes happened to kirtan and their are many many reasons why. Here are some: Introduction of easier to learn/play instruments by the British - baja Start of All India Radio - and non-kirtan music entering the homes of many people - a big influence - this is where most of todays tunes were originally picked up/replicated. Invention of microphones, loudspeakers and amplifiers, there was no longer a need for high level kirtani who's unamplified voices could be heard by thousands. The big sell by new amatuer kirtani that sarangi and raags were being used in brothels, hence they were no longer using them - funny it didn't stop them when bajai, tablai and filmy music went to brothels. People emigrating and being influenced by the west Indian Cinema explosion - the soul source of entertainment for millions Film music expolsion across the airwaves Hindu classical music gharans claiming all our Guru;s raags to be of hindu origin, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji getting no recognition in musical history, although it is unquestionablt the biggest treasure and source of raag vidya in India's history. The changing culture of the sangat - kirtan becoming a form of entertainment - and the kirtani following suit and becoming entertainers. Gurdwara commitees emplying giani/kirtani and ordering them to sing filmy kirtan, in order to keep teh charava and sangat coming in... I can go on, but these are a few reasons for the near extinction of our Guru's kirtan. Not all are to blame, as i keep stating many great gursikh made the best of availablke resources. One of the biggest problems was that like Shaster Vidya, Raag Vidya was always passed down vocally and not written down. In addition, raag compositions cannot be narrated like modern kirtan or western music, it is to complex in this sense as the emotionally derived skills i.e. gamaks, andolas and meends do not exist in modern music. This also did not help when the powers that be decided that modern music and sangat contentment was the way. ------ Raag is not a style, and Guru deh saaj are not just "old instruments", they are way more advanced than any of todays instruments, they were made of spritual design for a specific purpose, Guur da Kirtan, unlike the baja. You are righ, this is not a competition, it is merely a request for people to revive how kirtan was done in Guru's days, and how it has been requested to be done in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. If raag vidya and saaj are not available, then baja and simple tunes are fine. But in my humble opinion, where Guru's gifts are available, we should strive to utilise them. Ther is a great misunderstanding about raag kirtan, people seem to think it is hugley complicated, takes a lifetime to master and that only the raagi can participate, this is all nonsense. I admit that some raagis do prefer solo's and like to show their skills, but the majority of the shabad follows a strict pattern which is easy for the sangat to pick up straightaway and even predict the sangeet context of the remaining pauris. Please listen to these samples, every shabad (all 59 raags) are easy to follow in a sangat: http://rajacademy.com/articles.php?category_id=49 The same way that we are supposed to be able to recite gurbani correctly, follow other rehits strictly, be able to protect ourself (shaster vidya), as Sikhs, we should also be able to do kirtan and sing the Akaal Purkhs praises. If sikhs are taught these things from a young age, being "able" at all of them is not impossible. The 3HO youth at Miri Piri academt are an excellent example - they learn Gurbani, Shaster Vidya, Kirtan - everything whilst learning their core syllabus. Unfortunately this is where the majority of problems started, from our grand-parents and parents generation, the Sikh jeevan was not retained and thus disolved in place of making money and being successful in other fields. I am pleased to say that today there are hundreds of Sikhs (growing daily) from the ages of 5 to 70 - who are all learning Guru's kirtan not to ,make money or become famous (as some people think), but to be able to perform Kirtan as their Guru's did, keep their Guru's gurmat sangeet legacy alive. These people include retired people, infants, final year law students, people in full time - busy careers, PHD students, house wives etc etc, all find time to learn kirtan, it is truely amazing what Guru's kirpa and truth can achive, their is no category of person excempt. Veer Ji, I am a kirtan fanatic, and if you like, a Nirdaareth Guru de Hukmi Raag fanatic, because that is how what my pyare Guru Arjun Dev Ji devoted his life to - composing the Ad Granth Sahib, in a complete musical format - so that we could recite it in the most beautiful way possible for all time - and Guru ji gave us the framework to be creative within that - to make our compositions, to use the best suited instruments (stringed - they even designed them for us), but most of all, to not loose the essence, the emotion of the shabad - that is the reason why each shabad is organised in bani according to it's mood - if we change the mood we change the interpretation of the shabad. Music is the highest form of art, our Guru's knew this and used it as a medium to help propogate the truth, but they didn't do this half heartedly. They did this by divine compliment - "raag ratan parvaar hua - shabad gaavan aye" - and immortalised the rendition of all gurmat kirtan for ever, no one can change that. No one is attacking anyone or being paranoid, we are simply trying to bring people back to Guru's kirtan. "khannion nikki, Vaalon thikki, et maarag jaanaa"... Waheguru

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

singh-2 · 10 Mar 2006

a few points; - there is or at least should be no difference between raag and "sangatee" keertan. if all the sangat sang with raagis doing keertan in raag then that would mean the sangat is infact doing keertan together. it is true as jagjit singh has said that too many raag fanatical keertanee of today are too much into all the extra alaap and "ooh-aa" of khyaal influenced raag than actually singing gurbani and the effect is that general sangat can neither go along with it or sing with it. but listen to keertanee like dharam singh zakhmi doing keertan in raag; everyone can sing along with keertan like that where raag is made so simple. infact many akhand keertan ragi like amolak singh australia or tejinderpal singh dhulla are more and more doing keertan in raag at akj smagams. if you listen to recordings of tejinderpal singh or indeed the old recordings of his late father joginder singh talwara you can see many of the same bhandishan used as sang by zakhmi. - to scrutise the jeevan of the keertanee is not doing nindha or playing dharam raaj. this is especially true when particular ragi make speeches criticising others for following manmat practices in their keertan style. it is then appropriate to look at these same raagi to see how gurmukh they are themselves in their own jeevan. no one can get much benefit of doing keertan with those who do not live a gurmukh jeevan. even from a strictly musical point of view keertan just sounds so much better when the raagi is one who has done santhia and has knowledge of laga-matran and of the meaning of the shabad in order to give parmaaN in the keertan. at the same time however it is too easy to say all raag keertanee are just into raag and not gurmukh whereas akhand keertanee singhs are rehitvaan. for every example of comparing a dhilha raagi against chardikhala akhand keertanis there is likely to be an examlpe going the opposite way what about comparing avtar singh raagi and mohinder singh sdo? -the main point as jagjit singh has said is that raag keertan should be encouraged. all those learning keertan should aspire to learn raag so as to beable to follow current panthic maryada which is do at least the first shabad of your keertan in raag. equally however it is wrong for raag fundamentalists to start brandishing everyone as following manmat for not doing raag. many great gursikhs and mahapurkh have over the ages done keertan without formally doing keertan in raag and so it is a brave person who dismisses all their keertan as manmat. it doesn't account for the paaras-khala of gurbani. [%sig%]

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

singh1234 · 10 Mar 2006

no but what is clear to me is this if non raag kirtan is manmat... then kirtanis such as Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji, Bhai Joginder Singh Ji Talwara Bhai Harpreet Singh Ji, Bhai Tejinder pal Singh Ji, Gyani Amolak Singh Ji, Master Niranjan Singh Ji and countless other kirtanis are all all manmukhs! All the abpve kirtanis have good knowledge of raag. how can this be! their jeevans are seen by everyone to be good. their naam kamayee is evident. These people had Guru Ji's kirpa, which they would not be getting if they went against Gurus Hukam. if someone does a manmat action, they have to be classed as manmukh! therefore you are accusing the above people, who all have knowledge of raag, to be manmukh. I await your response.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2006

I personally respect kirtan done in Nirdhaarat Raags but don’t agree with the notion that any shabad not done in Nirdhaarat Raag is manmatt. If you really think of it, every tune in the world is some raag or the other. There can be countless Raags depending on the combinations of keys. I gave this idea sometime back that the dhunis referred to on the top of some Vaars are not in the Nirdhaarat Raags. “Moosay kee Vaar kee Dhuni”is definitely not Raag Kanra. This alone proves that even though this Vaar is in Raag Kanra, it can be sung in non-Kaanra tunes as well. So long as the reet of the shabad does justice to the mood of the shabad, and so long as the kirtaniyaas are Gursikhs everything should be just fine. Who can match a cry of a Gursikh from his heart? When a Gursikh sings in Gurmat ecstasy then everything is fine. Again, don’t misinterpret this to mean that I discourage nirdhaarat Raag. Raags are fine but are not vital for Gurmat Har Kirtan. Not a single Gurbani Pankiti tells us to do kirtan in Raags. Only hukam is to sing with love. That’s all. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Harcharan Singh · 10 Mar 2006

Veer Daas Soora Ji, 1234 has said "change the record and tell your beloved surinder singh to stop eating mass". And you are telling me to be careful and give him the benefit of the doubt? Anyone who lyingly discredits a Gursikhs jeevan like this does not deserve to have his words heard. It is not good to defend a Nindak, Guru ji has told us to keep away from people like this. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

singh1234 · 10 Mar 2006

ok harcharan singh... go and ask professor if he eats maas. i am not doing his nindya it is fact i have no reason to lie on this.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

singh1234 · 10 Mar 2006

Matharu is not a gursikh. Anyone who belittles panths mahan sevaks like bhai randhir singh by claiming them do kirtan is manmat CANNOT be a gursikh. how much money has matharu made from his raj academy. he gets grants of thousands and thousands from uk government, as he is saying he is keeping a heritage alive. GO and ask matharu if he eats meat? how cana gursikh do kirtan on stage with namdharis? gursikhs do not roti beti di saanjh with those that go against Sri Guru Granth Sahib maharaj.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

LK · 10 Mar 2006

---------------------------- Author: singh1234 Date: 03-10-06 08:07 no but what is clear to me is this if non raag kirtan is manmat... then kirtanis such as Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji, Bhai Joginder Singh Ji Talwara Bhai Harpreet Singh Ji, Bhai Tejinder pal Singh Ji, Gyani Amolak Singh Ji, Master Niranjan Singh Ji and countless other kirtanis are all all manmukhs! All the abpve kirtanis have good knowledge of raag. how can this be! their jeevans are seen by everyone to be good. their naam kamayee is evident. These people had Guru Ji's kirpa, which they would not be getting if they went against Gurus Hukam. if someone does a manmat action, they have to be classed as manmukh! therefore you are accusing the above people, who all have knowledge of raag, to be manmukh. I await your response. ---------------------------- Let me change the case slightly. If padh-ched saroop of Guru ji is manmat, then surely it would be manmat to do paath from that saroop, which means all the paath done from padh-ched saroop is manmat, which means that everyone who does paath from padh-cheds are manmukhs, which includes most people calling themselves Sikhs on this planet today =) If someone reads from a saroop of Guru Granth Sahib JI can be manmat then surely the reader is a manmukh, and surely the the listeners are manmukhs. Therefore you are acussing the (practicly) whole Sikh panth alive today who read from padh-ched saroop to be manmukh. My point: If it is manmat to change the way Guru Sahib WROTE GURBANI, then surely it must be manmat to recite the bani in some other way (i.e. not shudh) then surely, it must surely be manmat to SING Gurbani in some other manner than prescribed by Guru Sahib before (practicly) EVERY SINGLE GURBANI SHABAD. Guru Sahib decided to write some Shabads in raag, some not. That tells me personally, those in Raag should be sung in raag, and those not in Raag, don't need to be sung in raag. Simple as that. Who are we to change the way Guru Sahib used to do Kirtan? p.s. If it's not clear by now; I'm not against laaridhar, nor agianst raag kirtan, as a matter of fact I acknowledge both. Bhull chukk maaf

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

LK · 10 Mar 2006

Author: singh1234 Date: 03-10-06 12:31 ok harcharan singh... go and ask professor if he eats maas. i am not doing his nindya it is fact i have no reason to lie on this. ------------------------------------------------ If someone wants to eat meat, how on earth is that relevant to this topic of " Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds" I seriuosly don't see why that was something that needed to be mentioned in this thread.

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

singh1234 · 10 Mar 2006

that is a silly argument you have presented regarding the ladiwaar saroops. LK is saying that those kirtanis who do not use raag and have knowledge of raag are doing manmat. personally i do not consider reading pad ched saroop to be manmat so your larewaar argument does not stand. and even if it did.....you have said 'which means that everyone who does paath from padh-cheds are manmukhs, which includes most people calling themselves Sikhs on this planet today =)" that is ridiculous. how can a listener determine padched or ladiwaar, so how could they be manmukh. do not assume things, as your folly is proved here. you cannot refute that on kirtan basis. if someone who has knowledge of raag and does not do raag, then according to raj academy and their matharus chumcheh, then you are a manmukh. Harcharan Singh is the one who is saying that non raag kirtan is manmat and so by default, all non rag kirtanis who have knowledge of raag are manmukhs. would you like to clarify your position on this harcharan?

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Harcharan Singh · 10 Mar 2006

Wahe Guru ji ka Khalsa Wahe Guru ji ki Fateh, Guru Pyareo, This discussion has lead to peoples jeevans. We should only be concerned with our Jeevans. I am not going to comment on which individuals are doing manmat or not, only Wahe Guru knows the true answer to this. For one, I do not personally know the mentioned Sikh, their jeevans or their reasons for doing what they do. What I was refering to was the majority of people I have seen, who derive their kirtan tunes from dubious sources. How will we ever know whether the kirtan we are listening to is being done to film music or any other borrowed music? Are we supposed to ask the kirtani, did you compose that or where did you borrow that from? In my opinion, in todays complex, multi-faceted world, Guru's way is the safe way. Maybe some Gursikh do compose their own non-raag compositions, but that does not make sense to me, if you have this skill, why would you compose your own tune, rather than one in Guru Ji's divine and purposeful framework? Where Gursikh use traditional melodies, passed down over ages , there is a big chance that their roots lie in raag any how. This is probably the case for most of all the respected Gursikh that have and do sing to non-raag. I agree wholeheartedly that jeevan is of prime importance, but now that some Gursikh have done mahaan seva over their lifetimes and collated gur-kirtan knowledge, why not try to change kirtan back to our Guru's method? What I can say is that there have been many mahapurkh/Gursikh with varying opinions i.e. Bhai Randhir Singh Ji and Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji and the raagmala issue. Would anyone like to comment on who was wrong, or who was the real Sikh and who the fake? Or could it be that whilst there are many great Gursikh in the world, only our Guru's will ever be the perfect antarjami beings? I am not forming any opinions here, neither am I trying to cause division. My view is that we should take the best we can from everyone. I take the best from my Guru Sahiban (everything about them is perfect), and no matter how great, holy or rehitvaan any Sikh is, I will never put them or their lifestyle/decisions before my Guru. Whilst my list of heroes are not specific to one jathaa - Baba Deep Singh, Baba Gurbakhs Singh, Baba Jodh Singh, Baba Shaam Singh, Baba Ram Singh Namdhari, Baba Harnaam Singh, Bhai Randhir Singh, Baba Attar Singh, Baba Nand Singh, Baba Isher Singh Rarewala, Baba Jarnail Singh Bhinderwala.....to name but a few, my first and final role model and master will always be my Guru. ਹਉ ਗੁਰ ਪੂਛਉ ਆਪਣੇ ਗੁਰ ਪੁਛਿ ਕਾਰ ਕਮਾਉ ॥ ha-o gur poochha-o aapnay gur puchh kaar kamaa-o. My view is simply this, I try to follow my Guru's instructions and jeevan. I am in no place to comment on any Gursikh, there jeevan and kamai was theirs, only Waheguru knows, it's no concern or business of mine. For me Guru da Kirtan as clearly prescribed in Maharaj is the greatest and no Sikh can ever improve on that. I agree that raag in itself is not the means to end, but a Gursikh performing Guru's kirtan, in my opinion, is uncomparable. We are not talking about professional entertainment raagis here, we are talking about hundreds of dedicated Gursikh of all ages, from all different backgrounds and careers who are finally discovering opportunities to learn kirtan in their Guru's way and their lives are changing as a result, these people are from all different Sikh backgrounds, AKJ, Singh Sabha, Ramgharia, Nanaksaria, Taksaal, Nihang...... They have found one thing in common, the ultimate gift, the Guru's method of praising God, something they have seen or come across all their life but never understood, or have misinterpreted. These Gursikh are discovering immense emotion and hightened clarifaction of their Guru's words via their Guru's kirtan, they have listened to or done mainstream kirtan or their lives, but have now been bitten with by the moods their Guru's intended them to experience and which have helped them to interpret their Guru's words more clearly, the same as when Bhai Mardana's rababi raag peirced the faithless's souls whilst Guru Maharaajs words pierced the faithless's minds, both mind and soul were conquered, these people were captured by the truth. This is the reason Guru ji gave us raag and saaj to assist in the spreading of the truth in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib, so that his Sikhs could continue to capture peoples minds and souls, capturing both are important. Until recentl years, many Gursikh didn't know of Sarbloh bibek, didn't wear nilaa banaa, didn't tie dhumallai, didn't know of or learn shaster vidya, didn't do paath from Dasmi Granth, didn't know of laridaar saroop etc etc yes some did, but many didn't. Many sikhs now strive to learn these things and make them part of their jeevan, Nirdaareth raag is no different. The only difference is that Nirdaareth raag is the basis of Gurbani's structure and our Guru's chosen method of spreading Guru's word and love. Be it because their jathaa does not practice it, because they have across entertainers or Indian classical Raagis who are raag pardhaan (using long alaaps etc), be it because they have been told that raag is meaningless, the only thing that matters is love, or whatever else, all these gur pyare who have know discovered the secrets to their Guru's raags are changing and are going to carry on changing things. It will take time, many people fear change, hold their heroes higher than their Guru's, have had bad experiences, wish to remain ignorent to the construction of bani, or are passive/compassionate to all. I agree that I may get angry at times and may over simplify the situation, that is my weakness, and I ask for forgiveness for that. Waheguru

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

uk singh · 10 Mar 2006

Having read the whole thread, I am most in agreement with the following lines presented by Daas Soora. 'Therefore, what im trying to say is that the keertan played by a Naam Abhiyaasee vala but one that does a lot of it, plays Keertan perfectly and supremely, and the tune in which is played by that person is also true.' Sangatee Kirtan is great. But we should certainly strive to perform kirtan with string and wind instruments. The AKJ and other jathey state that laridhaar birs should be read, we should wear the 4 'Sikh' colours, be sarbloh bibeki etc (all due to historical reasons). Therefore, should we not be arming ourselves with raag vidiya as this is how kirtan was performed in the past?

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

jsingh-uk · 10 Mar 2006

Raag is important....but its not the be all and end all

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

LK · 10 Mar 2006

---------------------------------- Author: singh1234 Date: 03-10-06 13:27 that is a silly argument you have presented regarding the ladiwaar saroops. LK is saying that those kirtanis who do not use raag and have knowledge of raag are doing manmat. personally i do not consider reading pad ched saroop to be manmat so your larewaar argument does not stand. ----------------------------------- Considering you seem to agree with a lot of what BHai Randhir Singh says, I re-call phorum admins saying that Bhai randhir Singh called a padh-ched saroop of Guru Granth Sahib MANMAT. If editing bani which is written, by sparating the words is manmat, is it not manmat to change the way it was meant to be recited? ------------- and even if it did.....you have said 'which means that everyone who does paath from padh-cheds are manmukhs, which includes most people calling themselves Sikhs on this planet today =)" that is ridiculous. how can a listener determine padched or ladiwaar, so how could they be manmukh. do not assume things, as your folly is proved here. --------------- Okay, the listener doesn't determine, so lets leave the listener out. The reader is a manmukh for reading from Padched? ------------ you cannot refute that on kirtan basis. if someone who has knowledge of raag and does not do raag, then according to raj academy and their matharus chumcheh, then you are a manmukh. Harcharan Singh is the one who is saying that non raag kirtan is manmat and so by default, all non rag kirtanis who have knowledge of raag are manmukhs. would you like to clarify your position on this harcharan? -------------- And according to Bhai Randhir Singh Guru Granth Sahib Ji's padched Saroop is manmat, which means that by your logic, by default all the granthis who do paath of Gurbani from the padched saroop who can do Paath from laaridhar are manmukhs!

Re: Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds

Harcharan Singh · 11 Mar 2006

1234, Shame on you for spreading such lies, and doing nindah on someone who has devoted his whole life to researching, learning and reviving Guru Hukmi Kirtan. What is the point of mentioning Professors surname, do you have a problem with it? What are you trying to show or prove? Professor Ji is a Gursikh, someone who spends their time spreading lies belittling Guru's servants is not a Gursikh. What business is it of yours what Profs income is? Is he stealing your money? For your info, Prof has set up the first Gurmat Sangeet higher education courses and Degrees in the UK. He is paid the same as any other profesionla university teacher, happy now? Any albums he makes is his own hardword and kamai, but for your info, all that money is invested in more education, the website, tours for the students etc. By bringing kirtan into mainstream education, Professor has done a massive seva for many Sikh and non-sikh youth, by allowing them to have free access to learning raag composition and perfomance, as well as learning how to play Guru's saaj, and gaining a recognised qualification form it, so that they can then go on and teacher professionally also. Is this not better than getting charged £40-60 per hour from a raagi for private lessons, and even then all you will end up learning is Indian Classical Music, rather than Gurmat Sangeet? Professor Ji does not hold knowledge bacj either, he is eager for all 600 stdents to learn everything he knows, and then add to that.. and may be teach him somehting new one day. I would love to see you call all the Gursikh Khalsa Yyouth who stem from AKJ, Singh Sabha, Ramgharia, Nanaksaria, Nishkaam Sevak Jathaa backgrounds "CHAMCHAI" to their face. Most students are youth from the age of 5 upwards, who alongside their western studies (which they are successful at) also give 2-4 hours of their day to practice kirtan and spend many weekends singing to their maharaaj at various Gurdwarai. They all do this of their own free will, and in most cases have to twist their own parents arms to support them, they are NO1 Guru de Pyare. Please, please don't rubbish them by calling them chamchai. If yo want to spread rubbish about people, at least be man enough to do it to their face. Also, how is Profesor Ji not keeping the Guru Kirtan heritage alive, actually he is doing more, he is bringing it back with a force, and it is not him alone, many students play a high profile role, in research studies, promotion, nishkaam seva etc... so credit is to the academy, not to Profesor Ji alone. He is of course responsible for back breaking work which has seen him leave no leaf unturned, and is leading the revival. But no one is anyones spoon. Professor always asks advice from his students, and is even humble enough to learn from them and change plans when students give a better suggestion. Your meat question is pathetic, Professor Ji is a Gursikh. Give it up. As for the Namdhari teachers, they no longer perform as part of the Kirtan jathaa, it is only Gursikh students. The Namdhari teach classes on learning instruments only. Professor teaches all composition, raag, history... classes, all from a pure Sikh perspective. The first batch of Gursikh teachers have now come through, so for those who have a problem with learning from the Namdhari teachers (who are the best Taus and one of the best Sarangi players in the world), this should not cause any problems for you. Now 1234 ji, I do your benti, please stop this vicous game of yours, it is a mahapaap to do nindah of someone who lives for their Guru. Waheguru