Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

ks · 07 Mar 2006

what makes a kakkar, kirpan for example, a kakkar. Can any bladed object that you keep on your person be considered a kirpan (disregard whether it is sarbloh or not for the moment)? Does it have to have a particular shape, or a manufacturing technique? how about the kachera? Disregard the nalla issue, is there a certain construction technique or fabric? how about the kanga? Does it have to be a small little wooden comb? Can any wooden comb be considered a kanga as long as you keep it on your person? What if you don't even use it to comb your hair?

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

ks · 09 Mar 2006

awesome response!

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

singh1234 · 09 Mar 2006

amrit makes a kakaar a kakaar guru nishaani

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

moorakh · 09 Mar 2006

puratan rehitnamas from bhai daya singh ji, bhai chaupa singh ji, and guru gobind singh ji have instructed us to wear sarbloh kara and wooden kara. i am not sure about the others but perhaps there were similar rehitnamas about those. hukamnama from sri akal takhat sahib has said kirpan should not be ritualistic or pendant, it should be real kirpan.

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Mar 2006

awesome question ?? nah...simple really. A kakaar is what GURU JI told us is a kakaar. Guru Ji told us a KIRPAN is a kakaar....not a talwaar, khanjar, khanda, keris, scimitar, dagger,swiss army knife, chinese chopper, etc etc etc. He could have easily said.."anything sharp will do....and then we could carry a broken bottle, a blade, a switch blade, a swiss army knife, a khanda, a scimitar, a keris, a dagger chopper, whatever....BUT GURU JI SAID A KIRPAN. PERIOD. So a KIRPAN it is. Manufacturing technique..sarbloh...particular shape.. imho..a kirpan is a kirpan ONLY if it has its own distinctive shape...so is a "sword"..a "Scimitar"..a "Chopper"..a "Khanda"..etc..NONE is exchangeable for any other and still be called by its own Name. I cant carry a "Keris" and call it Swiss Army Knife ?? can I. Nala and Rubber strings..in Kachhera ?..this is more complicated. some want to retain the Perfect "original" ( although they cant possibly get the original cloth....there were no machines to weave cloth in those times..and RUBBER BANDS never existed...old chinese clothings have a number of strings to tie instead of BUTTONS...because they didnt have buttons in those days.. and COLOURS were also limited...so others may want to have some modern influence... GURU JI ONLY said NO LONGER THAN THE KNEES...nothing about Nalas, cloth, colours, etc etc. The LENGTH is mentioned because a kachhera LONGER than Knee Length looks like a DHOTEE...just look at how a DHOTEE looks when it is LIFTED UP and Jangha tied ( one side lifted up through the legs and tied up in front - a HANUMAN kacherra !!) this is when a dhotee wearer wants to fight.....and AFTER that he will DROP the dhotee down as normal wear !! GURU wanted us to be always Tiar bar Tiar....hence kacherra above the Knees....how you keep it there is up to you..( I dont subscribe to those theories about "....nalla is more "difficult" to open ( when trying to commit adultery !!) and that rubber bands make this easier..blah blah. The NALLA should be on YOUR BRAIN..THAT is what will make it HARD to commit adultery....IF YOUR BRAIN OKAYS adultery...no nalla in the world can stop it. strictly my personal views...no offense to anyone and no compulsion to follow... Jarnail singh

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

uksingh · 10 Mar 2006

Moorakh Ji u said about hukamnama from Akal Takhat saying that kirpan must be a real kirpan and not pendant, ritualistic, have u got a link to this or where it says this,. This is vevry important as in uk we are fighting for rights of wearing a kirpan, and some gorai agencies keep referring that some sikhs wear the symbolic one (the small ones around neck or etched onto kanga' so any hukam from Akal Takhat is much appreciated. Gurfateh ji

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

Rashpal Singh · 10 Mar 2006

VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh A Kirpan should be made out of Sarbloh. No other weapon counts as a Kirpan as Bhai Jarnail Singh rightfuly said. But you can carry other Shastar as extras. Kangha is wooden and should be tucked behind the joora. It should used at least twise a day to comb kesh Kara is made from Sarbloh Kacherra is white and up to kneelenght. A Kacherra must have a Naala, according to tradition, otherwise how can it be a Kacherra? Without naala it makes it more like a Knickerbocker. Bhai Randhir Singh had a long discussion about this in jail when he wasnt given a fresh Kacherra. You can find this conversation recorded in Bhai Sahibs Autobiography. The kacherra is also sewn in a certain way. VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh [%sig%]

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

ks · 10 Mar 2006

thanks all. I did not realize that a kirpan was a weapon in its own right before the Guru blessed us with this kakkar. Obviously, only a kirpan can be a kirpan. rashpal singh: what is the pattern of kachera? as for the kanga: does it have to be the traditional kanga design? That shape doesn't comb my hair well, I prefer a wider toothed comb. As long as it is wooden, can it be considered a kakkar? Can I keep it somewhere other than behind my joorda? Like in a pocket on the back of my kirpan/gatra?

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

:o · 10 Mar 2006

why do we wear kashera?

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

Sher Khalsa · 10 Mar 2006

kashera must have a naala. if its elastice someone can just come and pull it down, u cant pull it down when its naala.

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

g · 10 Mar 2006

lol @ carrying a broken bottle

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

LK · 11 Mar 2006

------- A kakaar is what GURU JI told us is a kakaar. Guru Ji told us a KIRPAN is a kakaar....not a talwaar, khanjar, khanda, keris, scimitar, dagger,swiss army knife, chinese chopper, etc etc etc. He could have easily said.."anything sharp will do....and then we could carry a broken bottle, a blade, a switch blade, a swiss army knife, a khanda, a scimitar, a keris, a dagger chopper, whatever....BUT GURU JI SAID A KIRPAN. PERIOD. So a KIRPAN it is. --------- What exactly is a Kirpan? Is there any default design of it? Does the handle have to look like the taksali model or cna it be the other standerd oe made to fit the hand? or is this a kirpan: ------ Manufacturing technique..sarbloh...particular shape.. imho..a kirpan is a kirpan ONLY if it has its own distinctive shape...so is a "sword"..a "Scimitar"..a "Chopper"..a "Khanda"..etc..NONE is exchangeable for any other and still be called by its own Name. I cant carry a "Keris" and call it Swiss Army Knife ?? can I. ------ You still havn't been able to give a description of what exactly a kirpan should look like in terms of SHAPE --------- Nala and Rubber strings..in Kachhera ?..this is more complicated. some want to retain the Perfect "original" ( although they cant possibly get the original cloth....there were no machines to weave cloth in those times..and RUBBER BANDS never existed...old chinese clothings have a number of strings to tie instead of BUTTONS...because they didnt have buttons in those days.. and COLOURS were also limited...so others may want to have some modern influence... GURU JI ONLY said NO LONGER THAN THE KNEES...nothing about Nalas, cloth, colours, etc etc. The LENGTH is mentioned because a kachhera LONGER than Knee Length looks like a DHOTEE...just look at how a DHOTEE looks when it is LIFTED UP and Jangha tied ( one side lifted up through the legs and tied up in front - a HANUMAN kacherra !!) this is when a dhotee wearer wants to fight.....and AFTER that he will DROP the dhotee down as normal wear !! GURU wanted us to be always Tiar bar Tiar....hence kacherra above the Knees....how you keep it there is up to you..( I dont subscribe to those theories about "....nalla is more "difficult" to open ( when trying to commit adultery !!) and that rubber bands make this easier..blah blah. The NALLA should be on YOUR BRAIN..THAT is what will make it HARD to commit adultery....IF YOUR BRAIN OKAYS adultery...no nalla in the world can stop it. --------- Whats the point of the kashera then, since it can easily be exchanged with boxers, shorter than the knee? Would that be okay in your opinion? I know other Malaysians (including Capt Sukhdev Singh) who think it is. ----- Kirpan should be made out of Sarbloh. No other weapon counts as a Kirpan as Bhai Jarnail Singh rightfuly said. But you can carry other Shastar as extras. ------ So If I make a shaster with a blade (i.e not one with nails or something) with a handle out of sarbloh it is a kirpan? Is a kattar a Kirpan ? (considering the rehitname i've read don't mention the word Kirpan, but actualy shasters, like kattar etc) ----- Kacherra is white and up to kneelenght. A Kacherra must have a Naala, according to tradition, otherwise how can it be a Kacherra? Without naala it makes it more like a Knickerbocker. Bhai Randhir Singh had a long discussion about this in jail when he wasnt given a fresh Kacherra. You can find this conversation recorded in Bhai Sahibs Autobiography. The kacherra is also sewn in a certain way. ----- Agree 100%

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

... · 11 Mar 2006

A kacherra is white and it has a nala. White kacherra is mentioned specifically in Bhatt Vehis. I don't understand what colour limitations existed at that time. There were colours of all kinds, so why would the kacherra colour be limited? A nala is also necesaary because as mentioned, kacherra isn't boxer shorts. It is a garment that opens up and the length of the kacherra, as a general guideline, should be at least about twice your waist circumference.

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

LK · 11 Mar 2006

Author: ... Date: 03-11-06 06:04 A kacherra is white and it has a nala. White kacherra is mentioned specifically in Bhatt Vehis. I don't understand what colour limitations existed at that time. There were colours of all kinds, so why would the kacherra colour be limited? A nala is also necesaary because as mentioned, kacherra isn't boxer shorts. It is a garment that opens up and the length of the kacherra, as a general guideline, should be at least about twice your waist circumference. ------------ What specifications are made to the kachera? does t mention being white and a naala?

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

... · 11 Mar 2006

There is no need to make specificatins for the kacherra. It'a kacherra! Asking if it needs a nala is like asking whether a kirpan needs a blade. It's just part and parcel of the term "kacherra". The Bhatt Vehi at any rate only says white.

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Mar 2006

My KIRPAN is the one i bought from the local Gurdwara stall owner who brought it from punjab......i dont have any idea whether it is is taksalli/akj/bhinderwallee/whatever. On my recent trip to punjab i bought a few other types and shapes as well. all look "kirpans" to me...maybe i need some more "kirpanning knowledge"... My kachherra is WHITE and with Nala. And YES the Kacherra WAIST must be twice or three times the length of the actual Waist in order to MAKE the "Valls"...FOLDS. So THAT requirement NULLIFIES BOXER SHORTS/etc etc. So I WITHDRAW the comment on RUBBER BAND as that possibly CANNOT fit this description - i made that comment without thinking !! Sorry lols. BUT i do stand by my assertion that the real "NAALA" should be on the BRAIN...because most of us tie a RISKIVEE GANDDH..and that can be opened in a split second ( if you know the technique).....danger if you get the ganddh messed up..and the call of nature is high noon !!! enough of that. WHITE may be a requirement because as we know WHITE is very difficult to keep in original state....so the SINGH JI must be extra careful...extra diligent in washing it regularly..etc etc and any "DAAGS" would be easily visible... Malaysians like Capt Sukhdev Singh and myself are "Miles apart" on Gurmatt...maybe even light years apart !! lols Jarnail singh

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

ks · 11 Mar 2006

jarnail singh, why are "valls" necessary? with your recent comment, I have to ask for clarification: is a kirpan a type of weapon outside of Sikhi? In other words, does there exist a standard for kirpans before the Guru's time? If not, then the Gurus must have had some standard for the kirpan. This is what I'm trying to find out.

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

LK · 12 Mar 2006

My kachherra is WHITE and with Nala. And YES the Kacherra WAIST must be twice or three times the length of the actual Waist in order to MAKE the "Valls"...FOLDS. So THAT requirement NULLIFIES BOXER SHORTS/etc etc. So I WITHDRAW the comment on RUBBER BAND as that possibly CANNOT fit this description - i made that comment without thinking !! Sorry lols. ------------------- No comment is stupid. Just out of curiosity, where did you get that there is a requirement that the width of the Kachera must be 2 or 3x the width of the waist? Is this written somewhere or are you basing this on the traditional kacheras? ---- BUT i do stand by my assertion that the real "NAALA" should be on the BRAIN...because most of us tie a RISKIVEE GANDDH..and that can be opened in a split second ( if you know the technique).....danger if you get the ganddh messed up..and the call of nature is high noon !!! enough of that. ----- So true. LoL As for Capt Sukhdev Singh, well you comment just reminded me of him. Hope I havn't offended you in any way =)

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

... · 12 Mar 2006

LK, Please realise that rehit is an ORAL tradition. Your fixation on written things is based on a western approach which codifies everything. Eastern approach doesn't work that way. Again a kacherra is a garment that has folds in it and is at least 2 times the circumfrence of the waist. An old rehitnama (Bhai Daya Singh I believe) says that a kacherra should be 1.5 yards in length.

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

LK · 12 Mar 2006

Author: ... Date: 03-12-06 07:38 LK, Please realise that rehit is an ORAL tradition. Your fixation on written things is based on a western approach which codifies everything. Eastern approach doesn't work that way. Again a kacherra is a garment that has folds in it and is at least 2 times the circumfrence of the waist. An old rehitnama (Bhai Daya Singh I believe) says that a kacherra should be 1.5 yards in length. ---------------------------- Bhen jeeyo/veer jeeyo, I consider that it is vital that what I rely upon has a historical basis, and thus I consider it important that there is written evidence. I disagree with you that the Rehit is oral, or that anything in Sikhi is infact oral. Very few things in Sikhi are Oral, e.g. the Fateh and the Jaikara. Apart from that pretty much everything and anything cna be found in the Rehitnamey, Bhat Vehiya, Janam Sakhis, the Bhangu, Gian Singh, Santokh Singh, Bhai Vir Singh, are all scholars who have investigated out written history (also some of the few oral things). There were 52 poets in the Guru's darbar, apart from theearlier poets who write mahan things like Bhai Gurdas Ji, whose composition has a lot of the Rehit such as waking up Amritvele etc. Thus I disagree that the Khalsa way is oral, however I do acknowledge that there are a few things that have remained oral in our rich history/heritage. Thus I consider that Sikhi has been different from Eastern approuch in this aspect. Please forgive me If I have stated anything wrong, or have offended anybody.

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

... · 12 Mar 2006

No, I think rehit is in fact oral. Desa Singh writes in the seventh stanza of his rehitnama, “that rehit which the five utter, keep that steadfast in your mind” and later in the ninth stanza writes “that is the first rehit, the one which the five Singhs said in the Paahul ceremony. The other different rehits which are spoken of, that is which I will go on to explain ”. Clearly the written rehit is secondary to the one which was orally elucidated by the Punj Pyaaray. Things like the vidhi to prepare amrit, punj kakaars, daily nitnem, are generally not found in any of that literature. Some make references but there is no detailed account of it. There is no systematic codification of rehit.

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

LK · 12 Mar 2006

Although you bring up a very valid point of Amritsancher, the first Rehit by Bhai Desa Singh is as follows: [gurbani]pRQm rihq Xih jwn KMfy kI pwhul Cky ] soeI isMG pRDwn Avr n pwhul jo ley ][/gurbani] prathham rehith yehi jaan kha(n)ddae kee paahul shhakae ||asoee si(n)gh pradhhaan avar n paahul jo leae || To drink the Ambrosial Nectar of the Khanda (Amrit) is the primary instruction for the Sikh. He who abandons all other initiations is truly a great Sikh. Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh http://www.sikhitothemax.com/rehat.asp?id=92 Reading the first few verses Bhai Desa SIngh talks about fixing the rehit told by Panj into the hear (man vich DriRh kar ke laona), about reciting Japji Sahib and Jaap in the morning, doing Vaheguru Simran, saying Vaheguru Ki Fathe to any Singh you might meed, stay away from slandering, show resect for sacred hymns etc etc, nowhere does he mention that the first rehit is that which the Punj tell, but he specifically says that the first rehit it to be blessed with AMRIT. THat is the first Rehit. The second rehit he narrates is that he should bow to reciew initiaton and accept the Rahit accepted by the Punj. So it first begins by talking about a Rehit prior to the Amrit Sanchar, which is actually taking the Amrit. It is actually going there and beging there for Amrit, is the First Rehit. The second Rehit is to listen and accept the Punj's Hukam (which all comes from Rehitname) The Rehit which is told in the Amritsanchar is also written in the Rehitnamas. Daily nitnem is mentioned again and again by several different poets. There are very few specific mentions of the Punj k's together, and Amrit sanchar, however they are all described in there in one way or another. Whereas one might talk of the Khanda (initiation by the double edge sword) some other might talk about XYZ. Rehitname contain pretty much everything that has to do with Sikh Rehit. Even such things that are against Gurmat (unforunatly, they have obviously been edited...). It's all in there. Thus I disagree that the religion which takes the pride of being the only such, that has had it's OWN founders write the scripture can EVER be called an oral tradition. Christianity is an oral tradition with the bible being written later. Islam is an oral tradition. Hinduism is an oral tradition. Buddhism is an oral tradition. Sikhi is UNIQUE, and IS NOT, since 99.9% of everything is written! (Thank God) As I said, I do acknowledge that some things such as the complete Fateh (only Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh bolavey is mentioned, but the whole thing is not), the Jaikara, and a few other things have not been mentioned. Forunatly we don't need to look much in the old rehitname now, since we've got the Rehit Maryada which pretty much sums all the Gurmat oriented principles up in a small booklet less than 30 pages! bhull chukk maaf

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

Dalbir · 12 Mar 2006

Sat Siri Akal, Someone told me that the 5 K's are a recent convention in Sikhism. In older rehit-namas they only stipulate Kesh, Kachera and 5 weapons (panj hathiar). Alot of them mention karad (translated as knife). But 5 K's are not mentioned until well into the 19th century in literature. Even Cunningham (1849) doesnt mention them explicitly in his book History of Sikhs. So did Guru Gobind ordain the 5 Ks or were they a later formulation? What about bhang and opium? How are Nihungs allowed these things and others not? Some of the older rehits even ban Sikhs from learning Persian, although Guru Gobind himself knew it, based on the Zafar-Namah. What are we to make of this

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

... · 12 Mar 2006

Bhatt Vehis clearly mention and list the five kakaars. They are one of the oldest sources.

Re: what makes a kakkar a kakkar?

LK · 13 Mar 2006

What about bhang and opium? How are Nihungs allowed these things and others not? ------------------------ They are not. It can be understood that they MIGHT have used it as medicine during war times, however it is nothing that is allowed when ther eis no probems around. --- Some of the older rehits even ban Sikhs from learning Persian, although Guru Gobind himself knew it, based on the Zafar-Namah. --- Yes some Rehitname have been edited by some dodgy people with agendas of their own. And, as you point out it woudl be compleltly illogical to prohibit learning of persion, as that would inhibit the Guru's SIkhs from understanding what the Guru is saying (i.e. in the Zafarnama)!