Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Response to SS Dhanoa in Tribune

Response to SS Dhanoa in Tribune

Gurpreet Sumra · 06 Mar 2006

Respected Dhanoa ji, Jai markandya rishi ki Subject: Is Guru Saab Ram’s Avtaar? As said by you that Guru Saab’s are avatars of Ram and Krishan, let us see what our Guru Sahib Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji says about these Ram and Krishan. First of all there are two Ram’s used in SGGS : one is used for Akal Purakh, Waheguru “hau to ek ramaiya le ho, aan dev badlawan de ho”(875) I need only one God, ram who is omnipresent(jo har jagah ramya hoya hai) and for that take away all the 33 crore devi devta from me. Other Ram is used for Raja Ram of Ayodhya,son of Dasrath ,husband of Sita and brother of Laxman who is known as one of the avatars of Vishnu. About this Ram , many non Sikhs through Sikhs like you, Tarlochan Singh of Minority Commission(He said that Ram is used so many times in SGGS so Sikhs should do Ramayan ke path???????), Giani Puran Singh(former jathedar Akal Takht) who left no stone unturned to prove that Sikhs are offsprings of luv-kush(whether there were any luv-kush that’s a different topic), Sant Baba who gives their self made stories seasoned with Ram krishan masala, Rashtriya Sikh Sangat. They are suucceding because we have Lal chand in Sikhism today like you. Let us see what SGGS ji says about Ram and Krishan: “kete pawan pani baisantar kete kan Mahesh Kete brahme gadt ghadiye roop rang ke ves” (7) So many winds, waters and fires; so many Krishnas and Shivas. So many Brahmas, fashioning forms of great beauty, adorned and dressed in many colors “aakhe brahme aakhe ind, aakhe gopi te govind Aakhe isar aakhe siddh aakhe kete kite buddh” That God’s akalpurakh’s name is being recited by brahma, Indra, gopiyaa, krishan,shiv,siddhs and buddhas which are created by him. “Nanak Nirbhau Nirankar hor kete Ram rawal Ketiyaan kan kahaniyaan kete Ved vichaar”(464) Nanak recognizes only one fearless, formless lord, other then that many Ram came and ended as dust and there are numerous stories of Krishan and many thoughts of Vedas. “pandey tumra Ram chand so bhi aawat dekhya tha Raavan seti sarbar hoyi ghar ki jyot gawai thi”(875) Hey pundit(during Guru Saabs time we have bodi and dhoti wale pundit,now we have dastardhari and kacheradhari pundit) your Ram, I have seen too, Rawan took away Sita and Ram lost his wife.(Can god lose his wife?) “rowe ram nikala bhaya sita lachman bichad gaya Rowe dehsaro lank gawai jin sita aad daur wai”(953) Ram is crying because he has been thrown out of his palace and has also lost sita and brother laxman, dehsaro=Raavan is crying because he has lost his lanka. Now Guru saab here has described both Ram and Rawan together to show the similarities between them. Such a pitiable condition where Ram is dahaan mar ke ro reha hai can’t be that of God. On the other hand there is Guru Gobind Singh ji saying “in putran ke sees par vaar diye sut char,char muye to kya hua jeewat kai hajaar” “Ram jhure dal melwe antar bal adhikar,bantar ke sena sewiye man tan jhuj apaar Sita le gaya dehsaro lachman muyo sraap, Nanak karta karanhaar kar vekhe thap uthap Man main jhure Ramchand sita lachman jog,Hanwantar araadhya aaya kar sanjog Bhula dait naa samjhai tin prabh kiye kaam, Nanak beparwah so kirat na mitai ram”(1412) Here Guru Saab is telling the story of Ramayan: God creates and destroys and sees.ram is just an ordinary person. To fight Rawan he is running from pillar to post to collect army of monkeys and is taking service of Hanuman. Then he is crying when Rawan took Sita and Lachman died bcos of curse.But Ram could not understand that God is doing all this . “Ram gayo rawan gayo,jaa ko boh parwaar Kaho nanak thir kuch nahi supne jeyo sansar”(1428) Again Ram and Rawan together, both went away, so how can Ram be something special. So , if we go through above shabads from SGGS then I am unable to find if Guru Saab is praising Ram somewhere, or talking highly about him.On contrary he is been described as person who can’t even understand God, akal purakh and has been shown crying like mortal beings, taking help of monkeys. How can such person be God who can’t even take care of his brother and wife. Then Ram is always shown with Ravan as both couldn’t understand God’s will. Now how can a Sikh then say that Guru Saab is Avtaar of such a person who is crying and running from pillar to post. A sikh has to follow the hukam of SGGS and Guru saab has cleared everything about Ram. It is for information of every Dastaardhari hindu , that if you don’t want to read and understand Gurbani then atleast don’t spread lies as your masters wish. Sikhs can’t follow these stories of Ram,krishan because for Sikhs the message of Guru Saab is clear “hamra jhagra raha na kou, pundit mulla chhade dou”(1159) We have nothing to do with mulla and pundit’s stories. So its clear but still people wants to fight by saying Sikhs are Hindus because they have Dastardhari pundit with them. “pundit mulla jo likh diya,chhad chale hum kachu na liya”(1159) For spreading lies Guru saab says : “jhooth na bol pandey sach kahiye haume jaye sabad ghar laiye”(904) jai shri Ram!!!!!!!! http://www.tribuneindia.com/2006/20060304/edit.htm#7 [%sig%]

Re: Response to SS Dhanoa in Tribune

Truth · 07 Mar 2006

SS Dhanoa is a tool !!!

Re: Response to SS Dhanoa in Tribune

Vikram Singh · 07 Mar 2006

Please listen to following track "Ram in Guru Granth Sahib" from the following link: http://www.ggsacademy.com/sikhdipehchan.php to know about Ram in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Fateh.

Re: Response to SS Dhanoa in Tribune

A_Singh_UK · 07 Mar 2006

Akal Ustat Kite Krisan se koot kotai upaae He hath Created millions of Krishnas like worms. Usaare ga?he pher mete banaae He Created them, annihilated them, again destroyed them, still again Created them.

Re: Response to SS Dhanoa in Tribune

LK · 09 Mar 2006

Ram Rehim Puran Kuran Anek Kahe mat ek na maneyo. Let us know if you recieve any response =)

Re: Response to SS Dhanoa in Tribune

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Mar 2006

SS Dhanoa....Mandeep Singh Bajwa...alias ..Ranjit Kaur Randhawa...are India lovers ( AT ALL COSTS) and Sikh haters ( under any circumstances).. Its their game to play this game turn by turn....when one gets tired out or boring..the next one takes over....same topics again and agaian..and agian..to tire us all out.. IGNORE them...