Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Only one amrit...!!

Only one amrit...!!

P walla! · 06 Mar 2006

Wjkk wjkf Piyari saddh sangat jio...firstly daas would like to ask forgiveness because daas cannot find the shabad that this post is relevant to…but daas is talking about the shabad that every person quotes…yes amrit is one! Then talking about jatha bandis and saying that amrit is one don’t matter if you take it from a jathabandi that is less strict in maryada and rehit..!! Daas does not agree with this as rehit is very important…keeping bibek (sarbloh), waking up amritwela, preparing amrit in sarbloh etc. Daas is not trying to attack jathabandis because there are some chardikala singhs out there….Akhand Kirtani Jatha, Taksaal etc. Daas was doing veechara with my father and brother, we had asked our father if he wants to take amrit…from the jatha, but father wanted to take it from Soho road…(not that its bad) but we did ardaas for him to keep strict rehit or the minimum! He then quoted the shabad that daas was referring to the top…daas started to think about what he was saying….Daas might not have a point…but that is what daas is looking for from the sangat ji!! Daas asked which guru introduced this piyari bani…father had said Guru Amar Daas ji (could be wrong) Then daas started think more about the time….there was no jathabandis then…and you could only get amrit from the Guru…so why has Guru Mahraj introduced this shabad there must be another meaning to it…!! It can’t be towards jathabandis…! Just need some knowledge on this…please this is benti, that we don’t start to attack other jathbandis!! Also can some one kindly put the piyari shabad on this topic!! Daas might not make any sense and things might not be clear so please pick them out and don’t attack daas! J Gurrrrrrrroooaa Wjkk Wjkf

Re: Only one amrit...!!

P wala!! · 06 Mar 2006

Daas has found the shabad. [gurbani]slok mhlw 2 ][/gurbani] salok mehalaa 2 || [gurbani]ijn vifAweI qyry nwm kI qy rqy mn mwih ][/gurbani] jin vaddiaaee thaerae naam kee thae rathae man maahi || [gurbani]nwnk AMimRqu eyku hY dUjw AMimRqu nwih ][/gurbani] naanak a(n)mrith eaek hai dhoojaa a(n)mrith naahi || [gurbani]nwnk AMimRqu mnY mwih pweIAY gur prswid ][/gurbani] naanak a(n)mrith manai maahi paaeeai gur parasaadh || [gurbani]iqn@I pIqw rMg isau ijn@ kau iliKAw Awid ]1][/gurbani] thinhee peethaa ra(n)g sio jinh ko likhiaa aadh ||1|| Daas hears this gurbani a lot when it comes to saying that amrit is one....is the bani even talking about the amrit that we recive from the beloved panj piyare!! gurro

Re: Only one amrit...!!

. · 06 Mar 2006

everyone has their own experiences of amrit.evryones is diferent.u cannot say one amrit is better than another. your father is a very clever chap

Re: Only one amrit...!!

simple singhani · 06 Mar 2006

vaheguru jee ka khalsa vaheguru jee kee fateh! I agree with your dad!...amrit is amrit where ever u take it. just because the amrit rehat aint strict doesnt mean your father can't keep strict rehat himself.. does it? by thw way.. when you say you don't know if it talks about the punj pyara amrit.. it makes more sense if it was.. than the other amrit naam.. because how can you have more than one. hmm.. im not sure i even make sense.. this is hard. Is their a particular reason why your father wants to take it from soho road gurudwara? ( just wondering) My dad loves soho rd gurudwara aswel.. he says its a very peaceful place etc.. even though people tell him not to go ther, he still goes. vaheguru jee ka khalsa vaheguru jee kee fateh!

Re: Only one amrit...!!

Vikram Singh · 06 Mar 2006

Please listen to track "What is Amrit?" by Prof. Darshan Singh from the following link: http://www.ggsacademy.com/sikhdipehchan.php You will get very good understanding of amrit. Fateh

Re: Only one amrit...!!

... · 06 Mar 2006

There is only one amrit for sure. The shabad you pasted is about that amrit within us, but which is released and discovered by the Guru after amrit sincharr. All amrit sinchaars aren't equal. an old post by Kulbir Singh on the issue: ____________ If there is an amrit sinchaar organized by AKJ or Jatha Bhindran and they don't keep the most basic amrit maryada, then I don't think such amrit can be classified amrit. First of all there must be the true Saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Secondly, there must be Punj Pyaray who are tyaar bar Tyaar Gursikhs and the ones who strive to keep full rehit. Thirdly they should follow at least the basic maryada of amrit. Here are some points to ponder upon: 1) If the saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is not there, can amrit sinchaar be done? I don't think so. 2) If there are only 4 Gursikhs and not 5 Gursikhs to do sewa in Punj Pyaray can such amrit sinchaar be valid? I don't think so. 3) If Sarblohi Baata and Sarblohi Khanda is not there can such amrit sinchaar be valid? I don't think so? 4) Punj Pyaray ask for heads at the time of amrit sinchaar. Before the abhilaakhis can go inside to give head, they must wear full baana including all kakaars and dastaar. If they don't wear kakaars, can their head be accepted or will they even reach that point where their head will be asked? I don't think so. They must wear baana to enter amrit sinchaar mandal. If they don't wear dastaar, can their heads be accepted? No way. this daas is of the firm determination that Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj would never accept a head without the dastaar or without kakaars. It may be acceptable if the Gursikh wears the dastaar but does not consider it a kakaar but accepts it to part of mandatory baana like many Nihungs and Taksalis do but to offer your nanga head without a dastaar and just covered with a thin chunni, is not acceptable. 5) If Punj Pyaray just give you Naam but don't implant it inside you or don't teach you how to japp Naam, how would you japp it? Without method, how do you japp Naam? Where do you focus your dhyaan? So it's best if Punj Pyaray teach how to japp Naam. 6) Punj Pyaray should give amrit and not "Ikk Pyara". In all organizations I have heard of, Punj Pyaray prepare amrit but in most cases, one one pyara imparts amrit to seekers. This is not correct maryada. The whole purpose of receive amrit 5 times in your mouth, 5 times in your eyes and 5 times in your hair is to enable each one of the Punj Pyaray do so. I know in AKJ this maryada is still going on. Some other jathas may have it too and they are dhan if they are maintaining this maryada. But most of them have lost it. If there are small differences in maryada we should ignore them but if a person chhaks amrit with totally non-maryada (e.g. Nanaksari, pakhandi saadh amrit like Kashmira Singh etc) then I think its fair for a rehitvaan Singh to not do roti beti dee saanjh with such person, not out of hatred but out of respect and love for Gurmat Maryada. Such statements like "Amrit prepared by all organizations is same" are nonsense statements. How can amrit prepared by a pakhand like pehowa be amrit? How can amrit prepared by adulturous saadhs be amrit? How can amrit given to women wearing makeup and earrings be amrit? Statements like "the whole Panth does this and majority does that" are naive statements. Are we to keep maryada according to what the majority position is? Majority of the so called Sikh diaspora is patit i.e. they cut their hair. Are we to say that cutting hair is okay? As the matter of fact, it has already been accepted by most people now.

Re: Only one amrit...!!

P wala!! · 06 Mar 2006

Such statements like "Amrit prepared by all organizations is same" are nonsense statements Daas totaly agrees with this and the post from bhaji Kulbir Singh...!! "amrit is amrit where ever u take it." daas does not really agree with this but yeh if you read the post by Bhai Kulbir singh then it makes it way more clear! Also this is the quotation that daas is talking about...when people say amrit is amrit! Sorry sangat jio because daas had not made it clear that is why you got confused...my father only wants to take it from Soho road because its less strict and wont tell him off as much, because he is going pesh!! "But father wanted to take it from Soho road…(not that its bad)" As you can see daas did not attack any jathabandi!! "u cannot say one amrit is better than another." Piyara jio Daas didnt even think that...cant see where you got that from!! Maybe its my fault..!!

Re: Only one amrit...!!

. · 07 Mar 2006

i think that everyone should look for the jathebandi with the most puratan rehat (whatever that may be), after doing as much research as they can on puratan rehat and comparing it to the rehat today. its not so much as you should take amrit from a particular jathebandi but just find the rehat which is most authentic. also, im sorry p walla but if you agree with kulbir singhs statement, then you have to agree that if the "true" saroop of guru granth sahib ji (lareedar) isnt present than the amrit sanchar isnt "valid". alot of jatha amritsanchars dont have lareedar saroop so what do you say to that, does that mean the amritsanchar isnt valid? if your father wants to take pesh with soho road just because they wont be as severe, then maybe your father has to re-evaluate why he's actualy going pesh in the first place. the "punishment" from akj would be more "severe"...but it would onli entail doing more seva...which should be something that a gursikh would want to do as much as he can of anyway.

Re: Only one amrit...!!

Harjeet Singh · 07 Mar 2006

Can you do simran with someone who has not taken Amrit from AKJ? There's this guy who wants to sit with us when we so kirtan but he has taken Amrit from the a sant jatha. He keeps rehat and seems very chardi kala, but does not keep the sangat of true Singhs. Some of the Singh think he should not do kirtan with us unless he does pesh from AKJ Punj. Is this right?

Re: Only one amrit...!!

Singh · 07 Mar 2006

If you are talking Amrit, then you are giving your head. There is no compromise. You give everything. But if you take Amrit somewhere because you think they are less strict, then you have started compromising at stage one, what will happen later?

Re: Only one amrit...!!

P walla! · 07 Mar 2006

My brothers and sisters you have made good statements...yeh its true if father does try to avoid it then what will happen there...more 'shither' from the jams!! Amrit is very important...and so is rehit...daas does not want to go in to the lareedar topic because when ever we do we start to fight and no way will daas let that happen with his brothers and sisters!! What ever we can do then we should do it!! What ever the sangat belives in daas belives in...you lot control me!! 'Some of the Singh think he should not do kirtan with us unless he does pesh from AKJ Punj. Is this right?' daas does not agree with this...do keertan together whats wrong in that...if you lot do saas graas in the keertan that is not right...just consentrate on the shabad, daas is not saying that one should not do simran in keertan...just control the saas graas!! We are not better then anyone everyone is better then us...! Lets do keertan and do 'vadiai' of Mahraj together!! Jaap Naam gurrrrooooaa

Re: Only one amrit...!!

T · 07 Mar 2006

fateh , why do people tell your dad not to go soho road gurudwara ?( wondering )

Re: Only one amrit...!!

e · 07 Mar 2006

simple singhanee amrit is only amrit if the amrit sanchar is conducted in the way instructed by dasm patsah ie 5 gurmukh singhs, who are themselves baptised, follow khalsa rehit, wear 5 ks not 4 (keski), nitnem etc singhs cant be peshi gurbani says do not call youreself my sikh if you dont wake up at amritvela, hence singhs selected for panj seva must be amritvela singhs if amrit sanchar is not as follows amrit is not made hence amrit is amrit, its either amrit or its not at certain gurdwara i have become aware of sants, who make sanghat matta tek to him before guru granth sahib one should not go to such gurdware, where this beadbi of guruji takes place i advise you read amrit ki hai by bhai sahib.

Re: Only one amrit...!!

- · 07 Mar 2006

some jathe have amrit sanchars where 5 'singhs' who have very loose rehit, dont wake up amritvela, eat out go cinema etc make up panj. some jathe have panj made of sikhs who eat meat and drink intoxicants, you tellin me these 5 ppl are panj pyare? and amrit is amrit? some ppl claim they can make amrit by themselves, yes 1 person is this amrit?

Re: Only one amrit...!!

- · 07 Mar 2006

sum ppl got amrit to take home in plastic bottles from soho road its really good, you can put it in the fridge and have it the next day ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Such 'amrit' is not amrit

Re: Only one amrit...!!

P walla!! · 07 Mar 2006

Please lets not attack nishkam jatha...Soho Road...Its not bad there they have done a lot of seva...if they were bad then why have chardikala singhs done seva as panj piyare there...example...Sagoo bhai sahib and Giani Amolak Singh who has spent time with Bhai Sahib Randir Singh!! 'why do people tell your dad not to go soho road gurudwara ?( wondering )' Sorry Piyara but no one has told my dad not to go there...daas wanted him to take amrit from jatha because it has strict rehit which needs to be followed ie keski...naam drir!! If one reads Bhai sahib Rama singhs book then they will realise the power and importance of keski and swas swas simran..!! Other wise daas has no problem with soho road or any other jathabandi and no one else should aswel...because they have done much more seva then daas has!! Dont know about you guys because you lot are chardikala!! Gurrrrrooo :))))

Re: Only one amrit...!!

amarjeet singh · 07 Mar 2006

taking pesh at soho rd just to a more realxed rehit is manmat. if ur father is aware of what the true rehit is. ie keski 5th kakaar, naam drir, and he avoids it jus to get an easier life this is not very great at all

Re: Only one amrit...!!

singh · 07 Mar 2006

p wala, it is not manmat to take amrit from a jatha you agree with - even if they are "less strict" than others. being "strict" does not bring you closer to Waheguru...sikhi is ALSO about prem and about kirt - unfortunately many people forget this fact. (i acknowledge that rehit is important, but there are different ideas of what is accpeted rehit - i.e. if you believe in the tapoban rehit you dont eat from non-bibekis - does this mean that this is the perfect rehit - no, it is stricter rehit) i am not posting to offend anyone, just to point out the basic fact that if you do have the requisites of an amrit sanchar - 5 chardi kala pyaray, sarabloh batta, guru sahib, etc - it is amrit. be happy that your father wants to take amrit - and if you are worried about "strictness" - DON'T. you are his sangat and as many have said and gurusahib has iterated - you are who you hang out with...hopefully he will take on your qualities (i am assuming you are chardi kala from your posts) fateh jio!

Re: Only one amrit...!!

Bazzer · 08 Mar 2006

Well said singh, a sane voice amongst the masses. If the prerequisites are present - 5 chardi kala pyaray, sarabloh batta, Guru Sahib Ji, etc - it is amrit, no question. BTW Kesh is the kakkar.

Re: Only one amrit...!!

singh · 08 Mar 2006

Author: Bazzer Date: 03-08-06 04:47 "BTW Kesh is the kakkar." oooh - bhai sahib why didnt you tell me earlier? ive been sitting here thinking it was keski before and you have definately changed my mind now!

Re: Only one amrit...!!

:o · 08 Mar 2006

so wat if ur getting amrit and u realise that the punj pyareh arent giving you amrit "correctly"?

Re: Only one amrit...!!

P walla!! · 08 Mar 2006

'being "strict" does not bring you closer to Waheguru...sikhi is ALSO about prem and about kirt - unfortunately many people forget this fact.' Bhai sahib not that sure what you mean by strict does not bring you closer to waheguroo...ive always been told that mahrajs loves rehit not the Sikh or you must of misunderstood what daas has said...so please forgive me if so!! What you said about prem is so true!! Its about faith...one prani can be doing routines all his life...but one prani might just take amrit and then start to jaap naam with faith..!! The one with faith and prem will gain a lot!! The one that does routines thinks it as routines but you should always think it as seva!! Some times most of us don’t get raas and the amritwela doesn’t be as chardikala as the day before...for example your mind might be all over the place..but if you sit there and carry on, thinking that this is seva then it gets a lot better!! 'be happy that your father wants to take amrit - and if you are worried about "strictness" - DON'T.' Oh yes daas is very happy..but he is doing it for the wrong reasons...daas wasn’t trying to talk about my personal life...daas was only using this as an example!! Daas is trying to say that it is important that in the process of taking amrit it needs to be with full maryada and how sad it is to say that only a few have these qualties!! For example daas has seen a Vasakhi video from India...and in this video 5 Singh’s had prepared the amrit with mahrajs blessings but only two of them were giving it out!! Would that be classified as amrit??? "BTW Kesh is the kakkar." Please bhai sahib this is a benti to your beloved feet lets not start an argument about keski or kesh…daas would advice you to read Bhai Rama Singh jis book!! Why would a very very very chardikala singh like himself want to lie! It does not make any sense…what gain would he of had to lie..!! We are young we have no knowledge we have seen nothing yet…but these gursikhs have…we should follow there examples..!! Sangat might say listen to mahraj…but like daas has refered before..doesn’t mahraj say I love rehit not a sikh! Also in the book it has said that mahraj gave his full darshan…wow!! May be a few Singhs can clarify this that have had darshan of bhai sahib Rama Singh does he really believe this or has some one just put it in??? Gurrrrrrrrroooo Sorry for keep on buging the sangat!!

Re: Only one amrit...!!

Daas Soora · 08 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh singh Jeeo, Being very strict is a good thing. You said that by being so it doesn't mean you'll get closer to Vaheguru Jee, but your wrong, because by being strict your trying to lead a discipline life by selling your entire soul to Vaheguru Jee. Less manmat and more gurmat. Doing Sarbloh bebek is excellent, not watching tv/movies is excellent, doing extra naam Japp in the day is excellent, and so on, as by doing all these one can surely reach Saachkhand and become one with vaheguru Jee in this life. Prem comes from being strict, people have to realise this. Forgive me if I've said anything wrong. Daas Soora VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Only one amrit...!!

adf · 08 Mar 2006

daas is stoopid

Re: Only one amrit...!!

singh · 08 Mar 2006

daas soora ji, you are strict because of prem. rehit is important (and yes guru sahib has stated that more important than the "individual" is the rehit - ie the deeds a sikh does), but your deeds must be sincere. this post started with p wala speaking about his father and he reasoned that his father had the wrong motive for taking amrit. i do not know them personally, so i will now speak in general terms. if a person is ready to take amrit from the guru in exchange for his/her head and is willing to live a life according to gurugranthsahib and the sikh rehit, it cannot be for bad motives. the debate here is not about motive or intention - it is about what we as a quam (panth) consider to be a gursikh way of life. too often we judge others by our own standards and not by gurmukh standards. agian i contend, that if an individual is sincerely a believer in guru sahib and is willing to adopt the gursikh lifestyle then it is not the wrong motive. i hope this makes sense, fateh jio! p.s.

Re: Only one amrit...!!

Daas Soora · 09 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib adf, If your referring to me when you said stupid, thanks. I deserved that, and if you want, i hope you do, slander me more. It makes me humble everytime. singh Jeeo thanks for that summary, and I didn't intend to start an argument with you or anything. Daas Soora VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Only one amrit...!!

singh · 09 Mar 2006

daas soora ji, no offense taken and i hope you understand that i feel that same - we are here to discuss not argue. fateh jio!