Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

jas kaur · 03 Mar 2006

from: www.ikonkaar.blogspot.com An Interview with Maj. Gen. Shahbeg Singh Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Major General Shahbeg Singh, whose body was found in the basement of the Akal Takht on June 6, 1984 along with that of Bhai Amrik Singh was interviewed by The Telegraph four weeks before he died. He was a sad, sick man eaten up with bitterness against the Indian government and obsessed with the idea that he had been thrown out of the army because he was a Sikh. A brilliant General who organised the Mukti Bahini in the 1971 Bangladesh war, he was "suspected of having taken away loot" and eased out the army. He seemed surprised, however, that his name was being linked with the Dashmesh Regiment and said that he did not believe in violence. He made no attempt to hide links with Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, however. The General was a slight, frail-looking man with a flowing grey beard. His bitterness about what had happened to him had obviously overwhelmed every other consideration. The ruling passion of his last years was anger and hate. Q: Why were you removed from the army? A: You should ask the army. I'm the only person whom they did not even put on trial. If they could put other Generals on trial, if they could take them to court martial and frame charges against them, why couldn't they do the same for me? Q: Why didn't they give you a trial? A: Because they had nothing against me and they just wanted to throw me out. Leave alone a fair trial, they didn't give me any kind of trial. They threw me out under a special clause which has never been invoked in the British army and has been invoked in the Indian army only in my case. This is a special power given to the Army chief under which my services were "administratively terminated" one day before they ended. Then they started two other cases against me : one was that I got a truck in somebody else's name and the other was that I built a house costing Rs. 9 lakhs. I told them that I had built the house for Rs.1.75 lakhs. Vigilance valued it at Rs.1.8 lakhs or something. In the court it came down to exactly what I had said. Q: So you won the cases? A: I won the cases. But I wasn't dismissed on those grounds. What happened then was they handed over the case to the CBI for investigation. After my dismissal they filed this case in the court, so for five years I was humiliated and harassed in court. I realised they were delaying justice deliberately, I went and talked to the Home Minister, Giani Zail Singh, and he promised justice. I had gone with the then Advocate General who is a friend of mine, and he told Gianiji that this man has done so much for the country. He said, this is probably your only General who has brought so much fame to the country and look, what you are doing to him. Gianiji asked for the case to be reviewed, but he never did anything about it. In any case, nothing was done. And instead of withdrawing these false cases against me they went on deliberately delaying the legal proceedings. The judge wrote a letter to the CBI saying that the time and efforts of the court should not be wasted and witnesses should be produced in court. Inspite of this the case continued to be delayed and the CBI told me that they could delay it for 20 years if they so wished. Q: But how did you suddenly fall out of favour after being a hero in the Bangladesh war? A: Because I made a statement, not a statement really, I just said, during the Emergency, that nobody was indispensable in the service of this country. This to me was a patriotic statement. But this statement was carried through the backdoor to the Army Chief and the PM, and God knows what they thought that I was a rebel, or whatever. The aim was to deny me my promotion because I was a Sikh. This is how Sikhs are being persecuted in the army. Q: Do you feel that other Sikhs in the army are also discriminated against like this? A: Of course. It is not just a question of being discriminated against. We are suspect. It has been stated by no less a person than Air Chief Marshal Arjan Singh on TV that Sikhs as a class should not be suspected. Q: Can you tell us a little bit about the Mukti Bahini, how you went in and set it up. A: These are all top secret things about which I am not supposed to talk. I'm not even allowed to write a book. (If I talked) I would be called unpatriotic and I don't want that. Q: But can't you tell us about the first time you went in and what it was like? A: You can ask General Jagjit Singh Aurora. He was my boss. I'm not in the habit of talking about these things. Q: But since you've been victimised.... a: Of course, I've been victimised. I even appealed to Mrs. Indira Gandhi. I said, let me be court martialled now, or put me up before a civil court, or a tribunal headed by an eminent legal man. As a last resort I even suggested that my case be looked into by someone like Mr Arun Nehru. I also stated in my appeal that I was unwell and that my wife was suffering because I had continuous active service for 12 years with only a six months' break in between. I was serving in Jammu and Kashmir when I went for the Chinese War. There, again, in General Kaul's book I am mentioned because, at a time when people were retreating and bringing dishonour to the country, I was going forward and bringing honour. Read Untold Story, page 419, I think. Q: What was your rank at the time? A: I was Lt. Colonel, yet the work I was doing was not that of commander's. I was staff officer. First, I was staff officer to General Harbaksh Singh, then I became staff officer to General Kaul and after that came General Manekshaw. I was General Staff Officer in IV Corps for all these three Generals. Another person who was told to move "forthwith" from Jammu and Kashmir to go and face the Chinese , took 20 days to get there. I took one day. Now that is my patriotism. But I am a Sikh and he is a Hindu. He became an Area Commander, Lt. General, but I was singled out so that I could not come forward for further promotion. And all kinds of charges were brought against me. I was even told that I was a friend of Mr Bahuguna after he had been removed from chief ministership in UP. Now, what I said then was: I've got nothing to do with politics but if he had been invited earlier, when he was the chief minister, to participate in a mushaira, how can I tell him not to come; even though the commissioner and the DIG told me that regular reports were being sent on him to Delhi. This was also considered an anti-national act, - the fact that he came to a mushaira in Lucknow arranged by me. Q: But do you really think it was because were a Sikh? General Harbaksh made it to a higher rank and so did General Aurora. A: Well, they probably denied promotion to me because there would have been too many Sikh Generals. Q: But were you a supporter of the Sikh cause in those days? A: I have always been spiritually inclined. My mother taught me Japji when I was only five years old. And then I was in the habit of always organising an akhand path wherever I went. When Gyaniji has a picture taken carrying the Granth Sahib on his head he is considered a devout Sikh. But when I did it as a General they spoke of me as a religion-oriented man. Q: How long have you been living here (Golden Temple)? A: For about three weeks. You see, after winning these two cases we had `sukhoed' (vowed) a certain amount of prayers. So every Sunday, for three Sundays, we have had to go to Gurdwara Baba Deep Singh for six hours of meditation and recitation of the Sukhmani Sahib. Then we have done an akhand path here at the Darbar Sahib and we still have an akhand path and langar to do at Baba Bakala. And a certain amount of prayers I still have to do here. I wake up everyday at 3 am, have a bath and then at 4.30 I am there for the palki Sahib Sewa. When the Guru Granth is carried from the Akal Takht to the gurdwara. I stay on there for my normal path. My Sukhmani Sahib I do either there or come back here. Then I go back for the Rehras (sunset prayers). Q: So you've been here for some months? A: No, only three weeks. As my village is here next door, I go and live there. It's just about 10 miles from here, a village known as Khayala, where I was born. You people suspect that I must be here for this and that reason. But it's only because of these path (prayers) and my wife's illness, which is a gift from Mrs. Indira Gandhi. I have been living in non-family stations on active service continuously for 12 years. She was diagnosed as having a tumour in the bladder, an infection which has never properly healed. In my appeal to Mrs Indira Gandhi I said, look, we are getting old and, if not for me, then for the sake of my wife who has done so much for this country, you should look into my case and give me justice. Q: Are you a supporter of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale? A: As far as my relations with Sant Jarnail Singh are concerned, there is nothing to suspect. I've told you that I am a patriot. Probably in a finer mould then the Prime Minister herself. I have met Bhindranwale. There is no doubt of it and I also feel that there is a strong touch of spiritualism in this person. He is a man who stands by the truth. The Government is deliberately terming him a traitor because his brand of politics probably doesn't suit them. But the fact is that there is hardly a Sikh in this world who does not accept him as a leader. I also accept him as a leader. I firmly believe that he is the only Sikh born after Guru Gobind Singh who can get justice for the Sikhs as a community in this country where we have been persecuted ever since independence. We are suspected individually and as a community. Q: But do you support violent methods: A: No, we don't believe in violence. We have proved it by courting arrest last year and staying in jail for three months. I think that is probably why they decided to put me out and not give me my pension. The orders were received when I was in jail. Having served this country with gallantry and distinction, this Government thinks it necessary to deny me even my pension. I became a Bengali for the sake my country. I cut my hair and then I took amrit again. I trained General Zia-ur-Rahman. He and his wife Khaleda saw me when they came here. He was with me as one of the sub section commanders responsible for victory in Chittagong. I am the only General to have been treated in such a shabby manner. I cannot even afford medical expenses when I had a massive heart attack last year. [Courtesy : The Telegraph] http://ikonkaar.blogspot.com/2006/03/interview-with-maj-gen-shahbeg-singh.html Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

KS · 03 Mar 2006

General Shabeg Singh- the great general of modern times belonged to village Khiala, about nine miles from Am Chogwan Road. The eldest son of Sardar Bhagwan Singh and Pritam Kaur. He had three brothers and a sister. The General traced its lineage to great Sikh warrior, Bhai Mehtab Singh who along with Bhai Sukha Singh slew the notorious Massa Rangar in 1740 and thus avenged the desecration of the Golden Temple. The family was was well-to-do and prosperous and had good size of land holding of over 100 acres. The village Khiala was earlier known as Khiala Nand Singhwala. Nand Singh was the great grandfather of Shabeg Singh. Later on the name got shortened. Mother of Shaheg Singh was devout lady but she was very practical and a great disciplinarian. She never forgot to remind her children and grand children that they were the descendents of Baba Mehtab Singh and must live up to the family name. Sardar Bhagwan Singh was the village Lambardar and remained quite occupied with the problems of the village folk who always looked to him for guidance and depended greatly upon his advice . In 1952, the younger brothers Sardar Shamsher Singh, Sardar Jaswant Singh along with their brother-in-law shifted to Haidwani in the Terrai area of UP after having bought farmlands there. In 1957, Jaswant Singh died. From his early childhood Shabeg Singh displayed qualifies of leadership and intelligence much above that of the average village child. He was quick witted and often pontaneously composed extemporaneous verses to caricature interesting village personalities He displayed a keen interest in history and literature and his village teachers were impressed with his intellectual ability. They advised Sardar Bhagwan Singh and Pritam Kaur to send him to a school. He was sent to Khalsa College Amritsar for secondary education and from there to a Govt. College Lahore for higher education. He was an outstanding foot ball and hockey player and excelled in athletics. At the age of 18 years he had equaled the India records in 100 meters sprint and was the District Broad jump champion. However, even though he had a natural ability for sports he did not wish to pursue that as a career, his mind was on the army, which was considered a noble profession. He excelled in studies and generally topped his class. In 1940, an officers selection team visiting Lahore colleges were looking for fresh recruits to the Indian Army officers cadre. Out of a large number of students, who applied, Shabeg Singh was the only one to he selected from Government College and sent for training in the officer training school. After training he was commissioned in the second Punjab Regiment as a Second Lieutenant. Within a few days the Regiment moved to Burma and joined the war against the Japanese, which was then in progress. In 1944 when the war ended he was in Malaya with his unit. After partition, when reorganization of the regiments took place, he joined the Parachute brigade as a Paratrooper. He was posted in the 1st para battalion in which he remained till 1959. By nature Gen Shabeg was a voracious reader, he had read about every military campaign and knew the biography of every military general of consequence. He had a natural flair for history and loved reading. He could fluently speak Punjabi, Persian, Urda, Gorkhali besides English and Hindi. He was an instructor in the Military Academy at Dehra Dun and held a number of important staff appointments in various ranks In the army he had a reputation of being fearless officer and one who did not tolerate any nonsense. People either loved him or dreaded him because of his frank and forthright approach. During the course of his service in the Indian army, Shaheg Singh fought in every war that India participated in. In 1947, he was at Naushera in Jammu and Kashmir fighting against the Pakistan Army. While at Staff College, in addition to the academic work, he set a record in winning three, point to point and five flat races on horse back a record never equaled. Because of his knowledge of military science and excellent grasp of military operations he was appointed a Brigade Major after the staff course. As Brigade Major of 166 Infantry Brigade- a crack formation, he feit most at home when the formation was out on military exercises. In 1962 during the India-China war, he was in NorthEast Frontier Agency as a Lt Col in HQ four Corps where he was GSO-J (Intelligence). In the 196S operations against Pakistan, he was in the Haji Pir Sector in Jammu and Kashmir, commanding a battalion of Gorkha troops. He commanded 3/11 Gorkha Rifles with distinction and was mentioned in dispatches for the capture of important enemy positions on the Haji Pir front. A few days before the battalion was to he launched into attack, the Commanding Officer (that time Lieutenant Colonel) Shabeg Singh received a telegram from his mother informing him that his father had expired. Being the eldest he quietly put the telegram in his pocket and no one in his battalion even knew that the commanding officer had lost his father on the eve of battle, Only when the operations were over, did he apply for leave and perform his duty of consoling his mother and family. His mother, Pritam Kaur, never asked why he had not been reached for performing the last rites. Everything was understood the call of duty to defend the nation's frontiers was of primary importance. Soon after the 1965 operations, Shabeg became Col G.S. of an infantry division, after which he was given command of the crack 19 Infantry brigade in Jammu Sector. In 1%9 when the Eastern sector of India was becoming deeply involved in Naga anti-insurgency operations he was posted as Deputy GOC of the largest Indian Division - eight Mountain Division which had nearly 50 thousand troops under command. With his leadership qualities and employment of dare~devil tactics he was greatly successful in handling the counter-insurgency operations in that region. Mukhti Bahini In 1971, when the political turmoil in East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) started and the Bengalis declared their intentions to separate, the Yahya Khan Govt cracked down on the Bengalis, forcing them to flee to neighboring Indian States. India decided to intervene and in 1971 started the clandestine insurgency operations in East Pakistan. The Indian Army Chief Field Marshal Manekshaw specially selected Shabeg Singh, then a brigadier, and made him in-charge of Delta Sector with lead Quarters at Aggartala. He was given the responsibility of planning, organizing and directing insurgency operations in the whole of Central and East Bangladesh. Under his command were placed all the Bangladesh officers that had deserted from the Pakistan Army. These included Col Osmani, as adviser, Maj Zia-Ur-Rehman and Mohammad Mustaq. Zia Ur Rehman later became the President of Bangladesh while Mustaq Mohammed became Bangladesh army chief. Starting from about January to October 1971, the insurgency operations gradually grew to such an intensity that by the time war started, the Pakistan army in East Bengal had completely lost their will to resist. The Indian Govt did not want the world to know that the Indian Army was training and directing the Bengali insurgents so all activities were very secret. Shabeg was so thoroughly involved in these clandestine operations that for five months from December 70 to April 71, his family had no news about his whereabouts. They believed he was till in Nagaland and wondered why he did not write because he had always been regular in writing home to his wife. In April 1970, the first letter was received from the Civilian address of a Merchant shop in Aggartala and his name was written as S.Baigh, such was the nature of secrecy maintained of the Army's involvement in the insurgency movement. The wife was quite confused and the family wondered what was going on because the letter was very brief and just said, "don't worry I am ok.". Meanwhile as the Mukti Bahini got bolder, the Pak Army in the East began to grow demoralized due to the onslaught. It got so widely dispersed in trying to contain the 'Mukti Bahini' that when the Indian Army launched its operations in Nov.1971 they were able to walk through to Dacca, virtually unopposed. Over one hundred thousand enemy troops with the complete general staff surrendered,leading to the emergence of Bangladesh. The credit of this great achievement was mainly due to the efforts of Shabeg Singh, who spent day and night organizing, motivating and training young Bengali youth to fight for their land. Such was the motivation of a Bengali youth force known as Mukti Bahini and so perfect the direction of their operation that no senior administrative officer felt safe in Bengal. Guerilia strikes were launched on five star hotels and on ships in Chittagong harbor to show the extent of power which the Mukti Bahini wielded. Strategic bridges were destroyed, factories closed and movement within Bangladesh restricted resulting in a paralysis of the economy. No doubt it was a cakewalk for the Indian Army when the actual operations were launched. The Indian government promoted Shaheg Singh to the post of Major General and awarded him the Param Vashist Sewa Medal in recognition of his services. He had earlier been awarded the Ati Vashist Sewa Medal also. He was made General Officer Command of MP Bihar and Orissa. The Jaya Pyakash Narayan movement had started during 1972-73 and became a serious threat to the Indira Govt. Police were sympathetic with JP and his followers, so the Government decided to use the Army. Gen Shabeg was asked to arrest JP and take some harsh measure against his followers but he refused saying this was not his job. The result was that the Congress Govt later instituted a CBI inquiry to harass him on cooked-up charges and he was out posted of the area. After the Indo-Pak wall, all the Pakistani POWs were under his jurisdiction and senior General Staff were kept at Jabalpur which was also the HQs of MP.Bihar and Orissa area. Due to jealousy of certain senior army officers , he was not given the command of a Division which was a move of the Army for denying him promotion. Here was a field commander with so much war experience-denied command of a combat formation. Why so? Only to do deny him promotion when his name came up. While he was posted as GOC of the UP Area HQs in whose jurisdiction the Kumaon Regimental Center is placed, it was found that the commander of the Kumaon Military Farm had given a large sum money to the Chief, Gen Raina, who was himself from the same regiment. A court of inquiry discovered that General Raina (a Kashmiri Brahmin), Army received over two hundred thousand rupees from the Kumaon farm to meet expenses for his daughter's marriage. When this information was brought to the notice of the General Office Commanding, Shabeg Singh; he told Gen Raina about the findings of the Court of Inquiry and requested the chief to return the amount as the Military farm of the Kumaon Regt was already running a loss. The result was that Gen Shabeg was promptly posted out of the this indiscretion and the inquiry hushed up. The forthwith posting was an unprecedented action because peacetime postings are never conducted on such emergency basis. Soon after that the Army instituted a court of inquiry against Gen Shabeg Singh which dragged on for one year till the date of his retirement on May, 1 1976. The main charge against the General had accepted a plaque costing Rs 2500 as a gift on his positing out of Jabalpur area HQs. -Even though a similar present had been predecessor and it is common for senior officers to accept such gifts. However, in the case of Gen Shabeg it became an offense. Some other flimsy charges were also made like allowing his official house land to be used for cultivation purposes and permitting sale of goods purchased from customs in the area HQs Canteen. These practices had been in vogue even before Gen had taken command of the area in 1972. The vindictiveness of Indian Government and the Army Chief was made obvious, when one day prior of Gen Shabeg's retirement, on April 30, 1976 the hero of Mukti Bahini, a highly decorated general with PVSM & AVSM, who had been actively involved in every operation that Indian Army fought since his joining service and who spent the major portion of his life in field areas separated from the cost of his wife's health and the education of his children was dismissed from the Army. Such was the treatment meted out to a brave soldier and an outstanding General, a leader of men, whom the Indian government and some senior Army officers in 1984 after Operation Blue Star dubbed as 'disgruntled' and frustrated because he was loyal to his community and fought for its honor and to protect the Golden Temple against the Army attack. Gen Shabeg Singh was convinced, even while he was still serving in the Army, that the Government of India was curbing the freedom of Sikhs all over India. He was aware of the discrimination against Sikhs in denying them promotions and the general hostility of the Govt. who were set to weed out the Sikhs from the Army. The general reduction in the strength of Sikhs in the Army and the policy of the Govt. towards Sikhs in Punjab by denying them capital industry, restricting the Sikh peasant to farming of wheat and crops whose prices were also controlled to deny them full reward. The denial of full and fare shares of river waters were apart of an overall conspiracy to deny Sikhs their legitimate due. At the same time the propaganda of the Indian Government against the Sikhs, painting them as communal. Their demand for autonomy was treated as treachery and anti-patriotic by the Govt, and the "free" press vociferously branded the Sikh demands as secessionist. The beleaguered Sikhs had no way to voice their grievances, they were not properly organized, they had no press which commanded international attention. The Akali party as painted as party of uneducated, unlettered, obscurantists Sikhs so that belonging to intelligentsia, shied away from it.The Akalis in turn were suspicious of these former Government servants and doubted their loyalties. This resulted in growing gap between the Sikh Intelligentsia and Sikh politicians. Retired Sikh Army officers as well as Civil Administration preferred to join the Congress rather than a Sikh political party. In 1977, Gen Shabeg Singh decided to throw-in his lot with the Akali Party as it was the only party in Punjab which was Sikhism oriented instead of Congress which was more of a secular party. He met Sardar Gurcharan Singh Tohra and offered to work as a soldier of Panth. The shrewd SGPC president was initially hesitant and distant but gradually was won over by the sincerity of the general and started seeking his advice important matters like associating Sikh Intelligentsia and ex servicemen with the Aakli Morcha. It was the way of Shaheg Singh thatt once he took a decision, he stuck to it and refused to be shaken from his resolve. His brother, who was progressive and well -to- do farmer and an active political worker in the Terrai (state of UP in North India)at Bazpur became the first victim of the Government's oppression on the family. The local Congress leader along with the police connived to finish him and he was killed by the Congress leader in 1978. The same congressman has ever since been terrifying the Sikhs in that area. The loss of his younger brother, was a big blow to Shabeg Singh but his resolve not weaken. The general and his family members were harassed, the CBI tried to implicate the general in a case of alleged misappropriation of wealth and dragged on the case till 1983 Dec., to embarrass and harass him. Eventually the case fell through due to its flimsiness and the acquitted general said to his son, "These CBI official knowing too well the weakness of their case and feeling ashamed of their vain attempts to slander me could not bear to look me in the face." For five years he had to bear with this govt. sponsored harassment only because he had opted to politics and not taken repressive means against Jaya Prakash Narain's movement a few years earlier. Gen Shabeg Singh was very active during the Akali's peaceful agitation against Government policies of "seeing Sikhs as terrorists" and "river waters and transfer of Chandigarh to Punjab" of 1980 to 84. He courted arrest a number of times and won the hearts of the agitationist who saw that here was one leader who did not accept any preferential treatment in prison. He slept on the floor on a single rug and gave his cot to any old or infirm co-prisoner. He cared for their wants and protested to jail authorities for better conditions for the old and weak agitationists. He won the respect of his colleagues and other leaders like Prakash Singh Badal, Balwant Singh, H.S. Dhindsa and Vice Chancellor B.S.Samundri. Most Akali leaders liked and appreciated his work and sense of dedication. All those who associated with him were enthused by his Spirit He became popular with the people in Punjab and was soon fully engrossed in his service to the "'Panth". During the periods when he was out of jail he spent a major portion of his time in the village at Khiala where his mother lived He did not care for the old age comforts that he had planned for by constructing a comfortable house at Dehra Dun. His wife too came to stay in the village where he spent most of the time. This was inspite of her ill health due to a defective kidney and hypertension and the neglect of their house at Dehra Dun. Punjab had become a leaderless state in 1982- or perhaps there were two many leaders. The people of Punjab were confused. There was Gurcharan Singh Tohra, Parkash Singh Badal, Sant Longowal, Jagdev Singh Talwandi and a host of other big and small leaders. But everyone was suspect in the eyes of the people thanks to the Govt. propaganda and machination of Congress led by Gandhi. Now stepped another leader, a charismatic personality. A saint and leader of the renowned 'Damdami Taksal' Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. A selfless, dedicated leader who was frank, forthright and outspoken. He had but one interest only - the interest of the Sikh community - the Khalsa. He did not mince words when he attacked the deceitful politics of the Congress. He spoke out plainly on how the Sikhs had been exploited, and how the Akalis', inspite of their assertions, had fallen prey to the politics of deceit and disruption. They were accused of neglecting Sikh interest when in power to appease the Central Congress Government. People flocked to him. He soon emerged as the undisputed leader of the Sikhs. His following grew at an alarming rate to the discomfort of the Indira's congress Government. When Gen Shabeg Singh met Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, he felt naturally attracted to this out spoken, plain and bold man who was a natural leader and whose word, all Sikhs, specially in rural Punjab, The two became closer and closer with passing time. In 1983 Gen Shabeg Singh and other leaders suggested to Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale and Sardar Gurcharan Singh Tohra to get together the Sikh intellectuals and discuss the dangerous situation that was being created by the Government,which was bent upon exploiting the Sikhs to win popular Hindu support and how it could lead to a breaking point. Gen Shabeg Singh worked ceaselessly in drafting letters and inviting eminent Sikhs and ex-Army officers to attend the meeting. which was eventually held and all shades of Sikh leadership felt convinced of the need of unity at this critical juncture. A very large number of retired army personnel attended this meeting and this frightened the Govt. A resolution was made that if need be, Sikhs would sacrifice their lives for the cause. A line was drawn and all who agreed were asked to step across it. Gen Shabeg Singh led the way. With passing time, the only way the Sikhs could escape from the conflagrant situation that was developing was to remain united, but the Govt was steadily working toward eroding any such moves because it had already made up its mind to teach the Sikhs a lesson. Indira Gandhi, developed a new strategy in dealing with the unwelcome emergence of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. She cleverly planned to use the phenomenon to finish Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrranwale and also win the support of Hindu majority at the cost of the Sikhs. A massive smear campaign was launched to denigrate the new leader who she knew would never compromise on principles. The story of what followed is well known. With each passing day the Governments shameless tirade against the Sikhs grew and grew. There was no way for the Sikhs to respond bul only by getting stuck deeper in the quagmire. Eventually Sant Bhindranwale and his loyalist were forced to seek shelter in the apparent safety of Akal Takhat. The only hope of Sikhs was unity of leadership but that was not to be. They were not strong enough to repel an all out Govt attack, though they had the power to hold the police and allied security forces at bay, perhaps for many months. Now Sant Jarnail Singh needed Gen Shabeg Singh's help. The General was away at Dehra Dun trying to recuperate from a serious heart attack that he had suffered a few months before, while on one of his "Sikh Prachar" meetings. A special messenger reached the house at Dehra Dun in the middle of March 1984, with a message from Sant Jarnail Singh Bhandranwale that he was needed at Amritsar. After convalescence at Dehra Dun, Shabeg Singh and his wife had planned on a visit to Hajur Sahib where his wife had pledged to offer prayers once his CBI case was decided In Dec 1983 he had been acquitted of all charges. But this visit was not to be. Without second thought and still not fully recovered he left for Amritsar and that was last he saw his Dehra Dun home which he had planned to spend a peaceful retirement in pursuit prayer and meditation. At Amritsar, he got fully involved in setting up the defenses against Government attack on the Golden Temple complex. He had to plan his defenses such that they were inconspicuous because the pilgrims' movement to the Golden Temple and around it had to remain unhindered. At the Same time, the defenses had to be very effective. He was in his element now. In the service of his community he did not mind giving up his life. He had always had a love for warfare and thought of death in battle a privilege. Perhaps he had a hidden desire to die fighting and in the holy presence of our Gurus. What better place then, than the Akal Takhat and the close proximity of Harmandir Sahib and in the service of his community. Tirelessly he worked against time with the prayer of Guru Gobind Singh on lips "Deh Shiva Var Mohe……." In the past, whenever in war, he always offered this prayer. Being an Army General he must have been very well aware of the odd against him. Re had less than 200 young Khalsa youth to help him. Though these were no ordinary youth. They were highly motivated, dedicated to the cause and each one resolved to fight to the last when the time came Yet he knew that with this small band, and hardly any resources with which to resist the might of the Indian Army, he might surely be overwhelmed. In the interest of the Sikh cause, he did suggest to Sant Jamail Singh Bhindranwale to leave the Akal Takhat and seek refuge outside the country to carry on the struggle. But how could the head of Damdami Taksal accept such a suggestion however practical it may have appeared. Perhaps Indira to knew and had calculated on this. When the time came, he would prefer sacrifice and martyrdom in the footsteps of Baba Deep Singh. Here was combination of two great traditions. One, the head of the great Daindami Takhsal and another a descendent of Bhai Mehtab Singh who had at this very place slashed off the head of vile Massa Rangar and carried it on his spear charging through the bewildered soldiers of the Nawab 250 years earlier. In the meanwhile, the political situation grew worse Indira Gandhi was playing her cards as per the game plan. Hindu feelings against Sikh throughout the country had been sufficiently aroused to condone any action against Sikhs including an assault on the Golden Temple. Commandos had been rehearsed for months at Chakkratta. Come June 1984 and it was time to call in the army and administer the 'coupe de grace'. The army leader had been carefully selected, Lt Gen R.S. Dayal though the Chief of Staff to Gen Sunderji the Army Commander in charge of the operation was yet given greater coverage by the Govt. dominated media to show that the Army Sikh officers even at the highest level approved on the Golden Temple. Major Gen K.S.Brar, a Sikh only in name, clean shaven, married to an anglo-Indian who smoked and drank and cared not for Sikhism, these two were orchestrated as the leaders of the attack. Giani Zail Singh who signed the papers for army action was the President of the country. He later denied that he knew about army action. On June 1 and June 2 Gen Brar himself went to asses the defenses of the temple dressed as a pilgrim and convinced his superiors the operation would take only six hours. On June 3 at 9:30 a.m. Punjab, Amritsar was sealed off and no movement of people allowed into the Golden Temple or out of it. At 8:30 a.m. that day Gen Shabeg Singh had literally forced his mother, wife, sister-in-law and nephew to leave the complex and go to the village. They had come there to offer prayers on the Shaheedi Gurupurub of Guru Arjun Dev which fell on June 4 and make arrangements for the annual 'Chownki' which pro ceeds from Harmandir Sahib to Gurusar the Gurdwara of guru Hargobind Sahib. The Chownki (party carrying the Guru Granth Sahib) halts at village Khiala which is on the way. Soft drinks, tea and snacks are served to everyone and this duty had been performed by Pritam Kaur, General Shabeg Singh's mother since many, many years. Even if she was alone, she made sure arrangements for the Chowmki's were made by the village folks At Harmandir Sahib, thousands of pilgrims who had come for the annual occasion could not leave before 9:30 a.m. and were trapped, many thousands would lose their lives in the massacre that was about to be unleashed by the power-hungry Indira and her stooges. Sikhs would be presented with another group of martyrs. The last chapter in the lives of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, Bhai Amrik Singh and Gen Shaheg Singh along with those valiant youth who fought for the honor of Golden Temple and the Sikhs was about to close. So too would be lost the lives of thousands of innocent pilgrims while those spared would rot in camps and prisons of the Indian Govt. for many years. Yet a new chapter in the history of the Sikhs was about to begin. Ever since Blue Star, tens of thousands of Sikh youth have lost their lives in the struggle to achieve an autonomous state, a land which the Sikhs can call their own. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- BIBLIOGRAPHY Copyright © J.S. Grewal

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

singh1234 · 04 Mar 2006

HOLD UP!! it says in there that general shabegh singh cut his hair for india and then retook amrit. he put india before sikhi. my respect has gone down so much now

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

.... · 06 Mar 2006

singh1234 bhaji all of us make mistakes but Guru Ji is forgiving, he peshed and was blessed with Amrit again, Guru Ji forgave him , who are we to judge i completely see where your coming from, and to put anything before Sikhi is not right, but he admitted his mistake before the Punj and after did seva not many could have and is a Shaheed

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

Gurughar da Kookar · 06 Mar 2006

Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee kee Fateh. A lot lot and tons of thanks to Bibi Jas kaur and Ks for putting this information. Really, he was a great man. Hats of to such a Great Shaheed. Keep putting like this information. Keep it up.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

P walla! · 06 Mar 2006

Bhai sahib jio...how can your respect for a shaheed singh go down...this is a very low response that have you said!! Maybe he did not have that much knowledge of sikhi or piyaar...but what he did later in 1984 can not be described...! Before writting anything think about it...are you so chardikala that you have never done anything wrong...!! Sorry if this post sounds harsh...but daas gets really upset when individuals like yourself start to put down the kurbani of these amazing gursikhs!! Gurrrrooo :(

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

Jagjit Singh · 06 Mar 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I have the utmost respect for any Shaheed. If we consider the stories of individuals like General Subheg Singh or even Bhai Satwant singh. They may not have been the most dedicated Amrit vela wale Gursikhs, but this does not mean they did not have high characters. In fact ,their charachters leave many of us standing. They were dediacted to the path of truth, and gave supreme sacrifices. In fact, even for Indians, they were and should be far greater patriots than the ones whos staues are made today. What sacrifice did many of congress leaders ever give? Even Indira Gandhi considered herself so superior that her campaign against the Sikhs and people like General Subheg singh, started because they clearly stated a nation is far bigger than any leader. She could not tolerate that mentality and she thought she was India, and above any indian. Even Ragiv Gandhi said " when a large tree falls many janwars (insects) get killed." He said this showing no remorse for the genocide in Delhi riots. One day Indians will read their history. We need to write it properly. They will judge. Like today Bhagat singh is respected in India more than Nehru, so if we document history properly people in the future can judge exactly what the Gandhi dynasty actually contributed to India, and how it manipulated it. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

singh1234 · 06 Mar 2006

Yes i would be fine with this, if he did not brag about do0ing this action. Shaheed Shebeg Singh said "I became a Bengali for the sake my country. I cut my hair and then I took amrit again." He is proud of this. Great Shaheeds of the panth like Bhai Satwant Singh, Kehar Singh, All the Babbar Shaheeds. They gave their all, expecting nothing in return and for no other motive apart from sikhi. As much as i respect Gen. Shabegh Singh, and his impressive military knowledge, his shaheedi was not nishkam. he had a motive, which was to get back at india. Now please dont go back at me syaing hes a shaheed hes beyond questioning. He was angry at india. I can quite confidently say that had General Singh not been cruelly treated by India he would not have joined the movement, so his shaheedi was borne of a personal vendetta, not necessarily his love of sikhi. Is that not a fair comment. Now please dont everyone start going that what i said is paap this or that. I respect his shaheedi and his sacrifice for the panth. but i do feel that Bhai Sahibs shaheedi was also about personal reasons and so was not nishkam shaheedi.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

Daas Soora · 06 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeKaKhalsa VaheguruJeKeFateh Sangat Jeeo there's nothing wrong with 'singh1234' comments - he's aloud to have his own opinion. Daas also agree, in a way, with what he's saying. However, Bhai Sahib Jeeo you have to remember that to become a shaheed is very intense, extreme, god-like and special, and for many this is a hard deed, a hard sacrifice to give for the panth. Basically, what i'm trying to say is that he must have had good karma in order for him to take amrit again at the end before his death. On the other hand he still didn't get to saachkhand at the end but obviously had to be reborn, or perhaps ended up in another khand below saachkhand. Forgive me if Daas has said anything wrong, but this is just my opinion. VaheguruJeKaKhalsa VaheguruJeKeFateh

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

... · 06 Mar 2006

Rather than trying to act like Dharmraj and figuring out which Khand Bhai Shahbegh Singh went to, just appreciate his sacrifice. He may have cut his hair "for India" but he learnt from his mistake and gave his life for Sikhi. Bhai Mahan Singh of 40 Muktas made up for his mistake by spilling his blood and giving his life. I don't see Gen. Shahbegh Singh as having done differently.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

KS · 06 Mar 2006

I cannot even begin to understand some people on this forum who try to pass judgement on Mahan Shaheed Shabeg Singh. He was one of the architects of the Sikh movement and it was because of him that the Indian army broke up and fled after their initial attacks. Tanks were brought in because they could not fight Shabeg Singh and the Sikh fighters directly. How can somebody even pass judgement on a great person who made one of the greatest stands in Sikh history. 1234 were you a perfect Sikh from birth? Nearly everybody was in favour of India in the 60's and 70's it was only after 1978 that Sikhs began to wake up.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

singh1234 · 06 Mar 2006

No veerji i am not perfect. But noone claims me to be a mahaan gursikh. difference is that he is made to be mahaan shaheed. Now i have full full respect for general shabegh singh in regards to military activities, and that without him, the singsh were not organised well enough. i appreciate that, and i appreciate that he was crucial to the movement. HOWEVER, and this is an issue unless you are blinded by the glory. Bhai Shabegh Singh was proud to cut his hair for india. If he said, i made a big mistake of cutting my hair, i messed up etc then yes we can see he asked for forgiveness and so should not be criticised. However when one says, "oh look how great i sacrificed for india, i even gave up my sikhi for india!" how is that to be respected. You guys are treating it as if he made the mistake and was very repentant, where this interview clearly shows he was not. He shows pride in doing that action for his country. Many people give shaheedi, however not all are selfless for the panth. Baba Jarnail Singhs shaheedi was selfless. Jathedar Sukhdev Singhs shaheedi was selfless. Shaheed Anokh Singh Jis shaheedi was selfless. Even Bhai Satwant Singh Ji's shaheedi was selfless. However, General Shabegh Singh had his shaheedi for his revenge against india. It wasnt about the movement. IT was about getting back at india. How can you deny that? He says it in his own words. Dont let the word shaheed blond you.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

govinder · 06 Mar 2006

Singh ji Reality speaks more than words.. dont just screw the one line he said in the interview ...You always know how media edits everything, so see the deeds and not the words..and also he was in the army and I know army personals, they are not good at conveying emotions. Great writer Professor puran singh in his early life became a monk but then changed after coming in contact with bhai veer singh. sikh from ujjain was a vaishnav and even stayed at anandpur sahib for a long time but could not believe in Guru and went back. bUt after he realised his mistake he took amrit and he was amongst the 40 scholars who were trained by Guru sahib at Damdama sahib for the katha and santhya of Guru granth sahib ji. so you or me are not sure whether his shaheedi was accepted by akal purakh or not, but dont malign anyone..this is the principle of sikhi. ok if he is in sachkhand arent u just mudslinging at akal purakhs piyara. and one more thing I have heard who so ever dies for any good cause are called shaheeds...even if for protecting ones country, ones self respect...anything...

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

KS · 06 Mar 2006

1234 you have have a lot of learning to go through, read again the account of Shabeg Singh. It was after the Bangaladesh war in 1971 that he realised what india was about and the undercover discrimination happening against Sikhs. Baba Manochahl was in the indian army, many of the Shaheeds had jobs , do you think they earned an income by being Sadhs? No they worked for an income for there familes. Stop insulting Mahan Shaheed Shabeg Singh who fought the Indian army for 6 days, just think are you even able to come close to this? Many mona have become Sikhs should they always be reminded that they were mona and are not true Sikhs. 1234 tell me what you qualification and achievements you havefor Sikhi to pass judgements

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

cyber singh · 06 Mar 2006

singh 1234 makes a strong case. to tell you the truth when i read that i was a little dissapointed that he cut his hair. that being said, can we trust this article? aren't almost all media censored by the indian govt? so i am inclined to think this could be propoganda to make the General look vengeful or what not. it is a very slight, underhanded tactic typical of Indian propoganda. that is just a hypothesis.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

KS · 06 Mar 2006

From the post abot Gen Shabeg Singh 'a leader of men, whom the Indian government and some senior Army officers in 1984 after Operation Blue Star dubbed as 'disgruntled' and frustrated because he was loyal to his community and fought for its honor and to protect the Golden Temple against the Army attack. Gen Shabeg Singh was convinced, even while he was still serving in the Army, that the Government of India was curbing the freedom of Sikhs all over India. He was aware of the discrimination against Sikhs in denying them promotions and the general hostility of the Govt. who were set to weed out the Sikhs from the Army.' 1234 your post sounds like what the Indian Government and some senior army officers said.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

LS · 07 Mar 2006

The way the Indian Telegraph article was written was to put down Shaheed Shabeg Singh, as has been stated by many, do not trust the Indian media. Actions speak louder than words , Shaheed Shabegs Singhs defence of the Akal Takht and Harimander Sahib cannot be matched.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

P walla! · 07 Mar 2006

By going pesh isn’t that person asking for forgiveness...only because on the post it might come to the impression that he was proud...you weren’t there, bhai sahib you don’t know how he was feeling by just reading a post!! Why question jio??? Just jaam naam!! Gurrrooo thats all we try to do look for a mistake and then attack it!! But dont look at none of the good points...this shows our weakness!

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

jagat · 07 Mar 2006

singh1234 you are ranting and wasting time on this message board how about some action so many people are roaming around free on the streets of india who have done something againsts the sikhs what u gonna do about it? huh!!!

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

sanjo · 07 Mar 2006

1231 made a fair point n its his opinion but i dont agree. that interview was given months before blue star so we dont know what shabeg singhs state of mind was after giving that interview. if he received amrit again he obviously realised his mistakes and wanted to be gursikh. shabeg singh ji said he wanted to spend retirement at his home with his family and pursueing meditation etc. you can tell shabeg singh had pyar for sikhi and wanted to be gursikh. do you think he would give this all up just to get revenge? i find it hard to believe he could pursue silly motives especially if it meant not seeing his family again. where as giving kurbani for sikhi out of pyar for sikhi is a different story and i fully believe shabeg singh ji done that with pyar for guru sahib. i also think sant jarnail singh ji khalsa bhindranwale would be able to recognise a persons jeevan, and they became close friends so i have faith in sant ji's judgement. all ino is shabeg singh is a shaheed from who we can learn alot.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 08 Mar 2006

singh1234, it is very inappropriate for you to judge Shaheed Bhai Shahbeg Singh jee's "tone of voice" from a written document and then make accusations on him. The comment that he made that he "cut his hair and retook amrit" was not in pride, it was in anger and frustration. He was saying it in the tone of "For this thankless government, this thankless terrorist army, I gave up so much and look what they did to me." If you carefully read his words and you understand his frustration you will realize that he was not proud of cutting his hair. He regretted taking such an action for the government. Bibi Amarjit Kaur (Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh ji's wife) said that during 1984, some of the most amazing military techniques were used by Shaheed Bhai Shahbeg Singh ji in order to oppose the Indian army forces attacking Harimandir Sahib. One of these techniques was sending electric currents through the whole sarovar so all of the Indian commandos that flew in from helicopters would be electicuted to death when they tried to enter by way of the sarovar. He used other intelligent methods to defend Harimandir Sahib and the Singhs and protect the honour of the Sikh community. You are saying that he put the government before Sikhi but actually he gave up his career, his family, and his life for Sikhi June, 1984.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

Jagjit Singh · 08 Mar 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, considering what General Subheg Singh did in bangladesh, it makes one wonder if he had survived Operation Bluestar, what he could have achieved in Punjab. In reference to cutting his kesh, I understand the point the Gursikh was making, but we also have to understand one assol of Gurmat. After one has been peshed and judged by the Panj Pyares, we have no right to bring up past deeds. That day is a new start for everyone. He took Amrit, so his jeevan began from that day. As far as his love for India. All of the things that happened to him were because he put his conscious before his duty. Even if that had not happened to him, I still think he would have been with Sant Jarnial Singh. We must remember many thousands of sikhs deserted the Indian army and travelled to darbar sahib to defend it at Operation BlueStar. They were called "Dharmi Faujis". They left their barracks, but were air bombed on the roads while they made thier way to Amritsar. Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

jeet · 21 Mar 2006

How can we be so narrow minded like singh1234. Do not present Khalsa as fanatics. What bigger sacrifice one can do than giving his life. Many of us wont even speak the word "khalistan" openly in India. And we pass on comments on these guys' kurbani. Even if taking revenge was Gen. Singh's motive that was for all others. If Indian govt was all too good for Sikhs and Sikhi, even Sant Bhindranwaley wud not have started the morcha. Obviously all this was started because Sikhs were angry over Indian govt. So was Gen. Singh. What do u mean by Nishkam Shaheedi. Giving your life is not worth any gain. So every Shaheedi is Nishkaam. Sikhs were not born to fight against India. It was because we had grudges against its govt that Sikhs fought.

Re: interview with maj. gen. shahbeg singh

.. · 22 Mar 2006

Please do not undermine his shaheedee.