bhai gurdas vars
seeker · 28 Feb 2006
wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh i am myself not too informed on this topic but looks like its quite a controversial one..... i've heard a little bit on both sides.. eg. some people say guru arjan dev ji described them as "the key to gurbani" but other people have said that gurbani itself doesnt need any keys .. its self explanatory... ""If you see the Kirtan section of Sikh Rehat Maryada it states 'kirtan should be only of Gurbani' but for explanation Bhai Gurdas's Vars can be used. But you would see Ragis and Kirtanyaas do kirtan of Bhai Gurdas's vars, which is a violation of the Sikh Code of Conduct. Bhai Gurdas has been a great Sikh, please don't take what I am writing here as any disrespect to him. But I personally believe that some of the Vars give contradictory meaning to Gurbani and those vars I presume were probably inserted by the enemies of the Sikh faith under his name, probably during the turbulent times of Sikh history in the 18th century. If you wish to reasearch this further, you are welcome to see me...." "My views stated here are 'unconventional' and don't go well with the Tradionalists. I would continue to believe in them unless proven wrong by documented historical references. The Touchstone for a Sikh is Gurbani of GGS (Guru maneyoo Granth....) and that's what I wish to bring to the knowledge of the future generation of Sikhs here." this is from someone else... so can u plz explain AND PLZ DONT JUST SAY THAT THIS PERSON DOESNT KNOW WHAT HES TALKING BOUT >>> lets have some fruitful vichaar here... wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh