Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

ADAM N EVE

ADAM N EVE

Singh · 28 Feb 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Wheguru ji ki fateh i would like to know the sikhi response to adam and eve? i know that sikhs dont believe in them, but why ?????? please let me know your views Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Wheguru ji ki fateh

Re: ADAM N EVE

peace · 28 Feb 2006

well look at kaley chinney gorey.could they have had different adam and eves via alien intervention? i am not racist but skin pigment under two centuries of sun or environment is not enough. there had to be different adam and eves for different peoples, this then contradicts the biblical versions like a lot of other things ie earth was square, or moon has celestial significance when gorey landed up ther and planted american flag while the muslims consider moon sacred. that contradicted their belief as did the earth ending in year 2000. among that other ideas like 7 heavens or planets when science is still uncovering countless more when Guru nanak said theres countless planets when western science was undeveloped.

Re: ADAM N EVE

.... · 28 Feb 2006

according to literature adam n eve only had two boys and so how did the human form begin? maybe thats where the apes come into the story: evolution, etc

Re: ADAM N EVE

Jasmin · 28 Feb 2006

Its just a story. Can't take it literally. You really can't take any Purana type story literally, it's not history, it's morality play. The moon is a just a spherical planetoid. Doesn't really matter who visited it- that's what it is. However, it does an important job by controlling tides.

Re: ADAM N EVE

. · 28 Feb 2006

in guru granth saheb, adam and eve are not mentioned when guru saheb talks about creation.

Re: ADAM N EVE

..... · 28 Feb 2006

i know they are not mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib Ji, but does that mean then we dont believe in them ????

Re: ADAM N EVE

ks · 28 Feb 2006

ask yourself why would you believe in that story? Do you believe other bible tales?

Re: ADAM N EVE

Truth · 28 Feb 2006

actually, there probably was a person called Adam. But all the stuff about him being the father of mankind...that's not true acording to Gurbani. But Gurbani does make mention of Adam. He is stated as someone who did good deeds and then was given many years in heaven as a reward (not sachkhand, mind you). (now i know many will jump to srigranth to search for adam...but i must warn you, they have erroneously translated the shabad by bhagat kabir ji. Their translation calls Adam the father of mankind, but if you can read gurmukhi you will know that the actuall shabad doesn't mention that anywhere. The translator may have been influenced by christian theology and accidently added more to the translation than neccessary).

Re: ADAM N EVE

Jagjit Singh · 01 Mar 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, the theory of adam and eve has been scientifically proved as not possible. The genetics of the following generations would clash. I remember studying in biology at grammer school about genetics. An example was given about an Egyptian royal sect. They believed they were of pure blood. So to perserve this pure blood line, each generation only slept with their mother, sister or daughter. It sounds sick, but this was their fundamental belief on how pure they were. Anyway, after 3 generations, the children that were born were all born handicapped or with genetic defects. Eventually the sect died out. As far as gurmat, Sahib Siri Guru Nanak Dev ji states one form cells another was created and so this creation came into form. This is also what we study about amobia, and how one cell tunrns into two and mass is created. But also Guru Ji says, why do we need to spend our time figuring out how creation began, when we should be looking at what we are doing in this creation, and if we can leave the cycle of births and death. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh

Re: ADAM N EVE

gardari lal · 01 Mar 2006

i do not believe in bible stories but heres a silly question if humans evolved from apes then why are there still apes on this planet? why did they not evolve into humans? or even nearlike?

Re: ADAM N EVE

veggi powa · 01 Mar 2006

a child is born from a woman as we know it. somehow eve was born from adams rib? i aint very smart and still waiting for a wife but i know this much she aint coming out of my rib. scientifically impossible, factfully incorrect. adam and eve ate an apple or fruit then begins the sin. but fruit is good for your health. why would god punish you for munching something good for you? and if all these billions of souls werecreated from adam and eve then where were they before? where do they go after? where did they come from and go to in timeline? how can billions of souls be born put into physical frames as a result from sin? then again no wonder musalmans appear depressed. i always imagined life to be a gift, something to be celebrated more so with the name of God .even when we see the animal kingdom pets move walk interact then where did they come from? whos their adam and eve?

Re: ADAM N EVE

k s · 01 Mar 2006

biblical versions of adam and eve follow on to some descendants one married his sister. now what bloke on earth would marry his own sister? the cultures languiages of the world are distinctly different for people to have ever been one. Take the hopi or south american indians, what connection would they have with a caucasian? none.adam and eve is a story that holds no logical weight. diversity is best to accept and love people for what they are. adam and eve punchline is " my religion is the most original from where the world starts". christianity islam and jews were not the first. religions have come and gone, people have livd and been destroyed countless times. Its nothing new, the world carries on. But one thing is sure we are all from waheguru jis creation. he made us the way he wanted.

Re: ADAM N EVE

TUF · 01 Mar 2006

ADAM AND EVE ARE A STORY IN THE BIBLE FROM THE BOOK OF GENESIS. MOST OF THE STORIES IN THE BOOK OF GENESIS SHOULD BE CONSIDERED TO BE METAPHORICAL... NOT REAL, BUT JUST TELLING A PARTICULAR MORAL. THE THEORY OR LAW OF EVOLUTION IS MORE REALISTIC. AND EVOLUTION WORKS WITH THE SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB'S TEACHINGS. ALSO, SOMEONE ASKED WHY APES ARE STILL AROUND IF MAN EVOLVED FROM APES. FIRST OF ALL, MAN DID NOT EVOLVE DIRECTLY FROM THE APES THAT EXIST TODAY. RATHER, HUMANS AND THE OTHER GREAT APES SHARE A COMMON ANCESTRY FROM A COMMON ANCESTOR THAT IS NOW EXTINCT. ALSO, JUST BECAUSE ONE CREATURE EVOLVES FROM ANOTHER DOES NOT MEAN THAT THE ORIGINAL MUST GO EXTINCT. LOOK AT THE PEPPERED MOTHS IN THE UK. THEY WERE ORIGINALLY WHITE AND NOW A BLACK SPECIES HAS EVOLVED FROM THEM. HOWEVER THE WHITE ONES ARE STILL PRESENT. BOTTOM LINE IS THAT EVOLUTION AND MOST LAWS OF SCIENCE ARE COMPATABLE WITH THE GURU GRANTH SAHIB WHICH IS TESTIMONY TO ITS GREATNESS TO TRANSCEND TIME, UNLIKE THE BIBLE, KORAN, TALMUD, ETC. AND COMING BACK TO ADAM AND EVE... THATS JUST A STORY THATS USED BY THE WESTERN RELIGIONS (CHRISTIANITY, ISLAM AND JUDAISM) TO SUPPRESS WOMAN AND BLAME THEM FOR ALL SIN WHICH IS SIMPLY RIDICULOUS.

Re: ADAM N EVE

indra daman singh · 02 Mar 2006

perhaps you should be careful before you state what is or is not in gurbani. adam is mentioned in guru granth sahib jee. read the following lines from guru arjun sahib jee's shabad in raag bhairo, ang 1161 baabaa aadham ko kishh nadhar dhikhaaee || oun bhee bhisath ghanaeree paaee ||2|| (from sikhi to the max, http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=4140 ) i find it interesting that many sikhs today believe in hindu mythological characters because they are mentioned in the guru granth sahib jee but do not realize that by believing in these figures they are creating inherent contradictions in gurbani. gubani also uses Abrahmanic (Jewish, Christian, Islamic) mythological characters, perhaps not to the same extent as Hindu characters, but they ARE mentioned. we should be careful to not state what we do not know for sure about gurbani. secondly, we should think twice about what role mythological stories really have in gurbani... could it be that they are just there as examples and are not meant to be taken literaly???....