Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

Jagjit singh · 21 Feb 2006

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! Pyare jio, recently there have been many discussons on freedom of speech. Especially in light of the Behzti affair, jerry Springer stage show, danish cartoons and many others. Sikhs argued during the Behzti affair that it is not a case of freedom of speech, but whether one has the right of freedom to offend. The Arts Council and many english or europeans argued that one should have the right to offend. They took the moral high road and took the freedom of speech to an extreme level. Personally I disagree, because I think with freedom of speech comes a moral duty of truth, and responsibility for the resultant effect of the freedom of speech. But many who are fundamentalist in this freedom of speech will disagree with this. But the events of yesterday of the jailing of British historian David Irving for 3 years, does show that hypocrisy in the european attitide. I am completely against right wing attitudes, and fascism, and clearly David Irving conclusion that the holocaust was fabricated is wrong. Today we still have the physical reminders of Auschwitz and Sobibor death camps. But despite the facts that David Irving was wrong, does that give a state the right to jail him. Further revelations that many europeans states ban freedom of speech on many subjects, for example, in France you are banned from writing about its human rights record in Algiers. Now I am, no way agreeing with the behaviour of david irving, or danish cartoons, or the muslim behavior. But for all those who mentioned Freedom of Speech in terms of behzti, where does this now leave the stand? Clearly now there is a recognition that europeans have one rule for themselves and another for the rest. As society we should have freedom of speech, but that does not mean we have the Freedom to offend? Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!

Re: Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

gabroo · 22 Feb 2006

double standards galore!

Re: Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

Manjit · 22 Feb 2006

Wgjkk Bhaji What guidance does bani give us on this issue ? Is there anything similar from sikh history ? Wgjkf

Re: Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

gabroo · 22 Feb 2006

examples from history & baani? LoADS jio... TRUTH IS THE HIGHEST VIRTUE... BUT HIGHER STILL IS TRUTHFUL LIVING. So having one standard for somebody and another standard for someone else wouldn't happen if Khalsa ruled and lived according to the 'matt' given by Guru sahib. so if Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib ji defended hindus to their right of expression... i think we too should support an oppressed nation in this situation. Although, in THIS situation, the muslims have reacted so negatively that it doesn't warrant our support. If they had gone about reacting in a more constructive way, then it would be our duty to help. Khalsa should make an informed decision as to whether it is prudent to help someone in a cause or not. It might be argued that currently, Khalsa don't even make informed decisions on things concerning our own Nation. In which I case it could only be said that the state or level of Khalsa lifesyle or dedication would be the blame for that. Guru jee hore kirpa karan Khalsae te

Re: Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

Jay Singh · 22 Feb 2006

Many things that Sikhs say can be offensive to others - Sikh's criticism of other religions, especially the Hindu caste system, for example. So if Sikhs want to have the freedom to offend others, Sikhs should be mature enough to counter or refute offensive things without trying to ban them.

Re: Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

chandar · 22 Feb 2006

the bhatti ting involved a rape scene at da gurdwara. How many times has that happened in reality? i been gurdwara all my life i have not been raped or heard of any bibia or blokes that have been except for one case in my life and that too was not fact but heresay. therefore it does not depict real facts. it was a blatent attempt by an adult to ridicule her dharm. The suicide bombings are wrong but why are these not condemned by the silent majority? what the world is going through is radical threat of islam superstate by means of terror, forceful conversion, mass majority phycological warfare on non muslims. perhaps there will never be a justification for insulting prophet mohammed but until muslims denounce suicide bombings the press and their supporters will carry on with "free speech" and this does depict the reality. Ie iraq, afghanistan 07 07 sep 11. These are all backed by qoutes maybe mistyranslated from hadiths and qurans. So muslims must denounce suicide bombings all over thw world, be part of mainstream society, encourage peaceful coexistance and then these cartoons will be looked upon as a smear campaign on islam by people. The examples of bezti and cartoons appear the same side of the coin at face value under freedom of speech. The facts behind them and the real issues are totally different. Rape scenes are not common place in gurdwaras while suicide bombings with a promise for a place in paradise under islam are. In an ideal world nobody should face religious harrasment or attacks. But muslims need to do a lot of groundwork to present their rligion proprly. Why do we keep seeing scenes of angry men rioting, killing, fatwas, murders, kidnapping minoritis and ntimidating? because that is the relity of attempts to create a super pan islamic state backed by hadiths. Muslims need to sort out which hadiths are relevent to the world they live in and be part of it to progress forward.

Re: Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

LionKing (LK) · 22 Feb 2006

Chandar, whether we like it or not, we've got several Chicago valey, Dhanwant Sui, pehove valey and what not.. Are these all made up? They happen. It's happened in the UK, and unless these people are whipped they ain't gonna get sorted... Right Panga Man?

Re: Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

LionKing (LK) · 23 Feb 2006

Also, jagjit SIngh jeeyo, who decides what is offensive or not? For a Sikh, it's not offensive to throw a picture of Guru Nanak Dev Ji in the bin, since it just trys to depics something undepictble, so in theor there shuldn't be anything offensive about it, but a lot of people would see it offensive, since most Sikhs have gone back in tiem and started worshipping Sobha Singh's hand-made drawing:S

Re: Freedom of speech or Freedom to Offend?

Jagjit Singh · 24 Feb 2006

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, we have the boundaries of good sense, and civil responsibility, and ultimately the realms of truth. I think with freedom of speech comes a moral duty of truth, and responsibility for the resultant effect of that freedom of speech. I often find those who constantly complain about freedom of speech are the ones who have views that are completely objectionable, and not accepted by sensible minded people, or people who intentionally use sensationalism for publicity. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh