Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

bani bani bani · 29 Nov 2003

why wont admin post my discussion on sathigur....do u fear question so much.....is that not the point of sikhi.......

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Admin · 29 Nov 2003

Your posting did not meet the required standards of this message board. We believe that Guru Nanak Dev jee is Satguru. Your post unsuccessfully tried to prove that Guru Nanak Dev jee was an ordinary human and not Satguru. We don't believe this topic is open for discussion for any Sikh. Sikhi starts from believing that Satguru Nanak Dev jee is Satguru (true and eternal Guru). Anyone who doubts that Satguru Nanak is the jagat-Guru, Satguru, is not a Sikh and their parchaar will not be allowed on this message board. Please don't post messages that are insulting to Guru Sahib. We will never approve such messages. Admin

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

concerned · 30 Nov 2003

well done to admin for observing this as it sounds like sdo chela/some new anti-sikhi again please keep up the good work thelast thing the youth need is doubts in the basic foundations of sikhi, instead of getting youth closer to guru ji some anti panthic segemnts seem determined to destroy the true path there should never be any questions on the 10 gurus, dhan sri guru granth sahib jee, five kakkaars, nitnem etc. - otherwise u should not consider yourself to be a sikh of the guru sdo although supposedly forgiven, still has his site up promoting the same sort of questioning as above and totally degrading bhai sahib bhai gurdaas jee well done on trying to promote the true path of gurmat may guru jee bless you in this sewa waheguru jee ka khalsa waheguru jee ke fateh

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

premi · 30 Nov 2003

WJKK WJKF I AGREE WITH YOU DHAN SHRI GURU NANAK DEV JI. WAAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA ! WAAHEGUROO JE KEE FATEH !

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Mandeep Singh Khalsa · 01 Dec 2003

waheguru ji ka khalsa|| waheguru ji ki fateh|| ok what i am going to say may be wrong, but i am a 'learner' so do forgive. i for one believe Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji is as said before Satguru and not human however me being a liberal and open to discussion and for the learning of all (which is the point of these forums), why not discuss this point? the reason why i say this is not because i am doubting sikhi or Guru patshah but because this is an international website and people who are not sikhs want to see the justification for our beliefs and so it is necessary that we do have this discussion. Also, where i work on the weekends there are a lot of muslims and all of them say one thing again and again which annoys me even when i do answer them = your guru is human, where did he get his knowledge from? etc.... etc.... and so i feel it is necessary that a SENSIBLE debate is needed. Do forgive if i have been sacreligious. Bhul chuk maaf karni. Daas Mandeep Singh Khalsa, UK

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Amardeep Singh · 01 Dec 2003

What mandeep singh is saying makes sense to me. I often have discussion with my non-sikh friends about what guru nanak was. Was he the equivelent to jesus.....being a god among men. Or was he closer to Buddha, simply a man who had acheived greater consciousness. Now as long as the posting is not offensive, it should be allowed on the site. And legitimate questions are not offensive .Educate, do not censor. On that note i was personally wonder what the shabad sathigur maeraa sadhaa sadhaa naa aavai n jaae || My True Guru, forever and ever, does not come and go. has to do in relation to this discussion? Please forgive any mistakes i have done Fateh

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

my thoughts... · 01 Dec 2003

Personally, I believe this message board is for discussing Gurmat related issues, and topics that will help inspire new comers and help increase our knowledge of Gurmat. However, I do not understand how questioning whether guru sahib was an ordinary human being or Satguru will help us understand gurmat any better, rather it will just cast doubts in our mind. I don't think we as, humans, have reached a state where we have to the right prove or disprove, or question, whether Guru Sahib was a simple human being or not. If you want to know, read Gurbani, try to understand Gurbani, have faith in guru sahib, that will answer your question. Sometimes, it is hilarious reading posts like these, we use the name 'Singh' yet we question Guru Sahib and we can't even determine whether our satguru is actually satguru, if we had faith then these questions wouldn't be raised. You will gain nothing, this dicussion will be/is a complete waste of time, if have questions like these, go and consult, Guru Sahib himself, Guru Nanak Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj.

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

kinetikman · 02 Dec 2003

God came to the earth in the body of a human and is called Guru Nanak.

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Jagjit singh · 02 Dec 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I agree with the admin on this. I understand what my veers, are saying, but i think we should stick to Gurmat. If you go on most egroups, there is so much rubbish written in the name of sikhi. On many there is currently a movement wanting pork and beef in gurdwara langars, or on sikhsangat.com, we always hear of the amount of silly rubbish being put on sikhawareness.com. The same ususal guys with nihang rubbish, latest being women should take Amrit from kirpans, creating their separate Amrit, and women and times of the month, so they cannot do seva, or the one about how men should shave their genetials. This is the sick rubbish that is coming out of sikhawareness.com. I am not sure what kind of sikhi is being followed and what exactly they are promoting. Now a person can spend all day going on these forums countering the rubbish which is being written, and endlessly argueing with these shraatee people. They will never stop, and I do not think they even believe it, which is why they always hide behind silly names. But all you do is move away from sikhi. Here on this forum there is a very good atmosphere, and it one of the few forums where people come and actually learn something positive about Gurbani and Gurmat. I think we should keep it that way. If Gursikhs wish to discuss quieries put to them by muslims, or others, just put them on as direct questions. But lets keep away from complete sillyness. The problem with internet is it does act as an amplifier for people who are usually just one man bands, who come on the internet, and act like Dons. Just my view. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

selfish moorakh · 02 Dec 2003

agree with the last. and if muslims keep asking about guru sahib den jus reply to them pir mohammed had his message relayed by an angel. guru nanak had his message relayed with a one to one with God end of. if they cant understand that their problem. if they dont wanna research bani and instead pose questions without research after pointers indeed dats der issue.

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Kulbir Singh · 03 Dec 2003

O Misled ones, SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK, JIN KAL RAAKHI MERI|| Nanak and Satguru end with an aunkad. Satguru and Nanak are thus inseparable. “Satguru” is visheshan of naav “Nanak”. In this pankiti Siri Guru Arjun Sahib jee clearly calls Guru Nanak “Satgur”. Should we still have any doubt whether he was a Satguru or not? In Bhatt Baani, the Bhatts make is clear: SATGUR NANAK, BHAGAT KARI IKK MANN, TAN MAN DHAN GOBIND DEEYO|| (Satguru Nanak did meditation on Naam with utmost concentration) Bhatts call Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee “Satgur”. Need anyone say anything more to prove that Guru Nanak Sahib was “Satguru”? JINAA NANAK SATGUR BHETIYA, TINA MILIYA HAR SOYEE|| (Only those whom Guru Nanak meets, get to meet Vaheguru) Nanak and Satguru end with an aunkad. Satguru and Nanak are thus inseparable. “Satguru” is visheshan of naav “Nanak”. In any case, who are destined to wander in this terrible ocean of world, will never accept Guru Nanak Sahib as their Satguru. Only the fortunate ones can accept Guru Nanak Sahib as their Satguru. What can we say about the ones who have fallen from this pious status of Sikhi? Vaheguru ne aap bhulaaye ne uh. I appeal my lost veers and bhains who have been misled by a misled person to believe that Guru Nanak is not Satguru, to shed their false beliefs and accept this reality. That person whom you are following was thrown out of panth. First he stayed defiant but later he retracted and presented himself before Guru Panth and accepted his mistakes. When he has given up his beliefs, what reason do you guys, his chelay, have in sticking to these false notions like Satguru is some mysterious thing and not Guru Nanak Sahib. O ignorant ones (his chelay), don’t you know that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee much more than his human body that he gave up about 500 years ago. He was always light form and will stay that. Don’t waste your precious human form. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Mandeep Singh Khalsa · 03 Dec 2003

waheguru ji ka khalsa|| waheguru ji ki fateh|| looking at the answers that came after mine, i now have a greater understanding and hope that i will get to know enough gurbani to answer the questions posed to me. I do appreciate why the admin blocked the message but also understand that if there is a question i should post it here. bhul chuk maaf karni daas Mandeep Singh Khalsa, UK

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Gurdaspuria · 04 Dec 2003

Waheeguru Jee ka Khalsa WaheGuru Jee Kee Fateh Guru Nanak Dev is/was not ordinary human. Akal Purkh send him to save us from kaljug. Akal Purkh Place pooran jote (Sateguru) into Guru Nanak Dev jee. The Guru jee taught us do pooja, seva of Sateguru by doing Naam jap in order to meet Sateguru. I will not say anybody misguided. I will not say that Guru Nanak Dev jee Is not Sateguru. Simply I will say what Gurbani says. I believe the meaning of the tuks which veer Kulbir Singh mentioned is as follows: 1) sabh thae vaddaa sathigur(u), naanak(u), jin kal raakhee maeree ||--750 naanak(u)-karta karak Guru Arjan Dev jee Nanak(Guru Arjan Dev jee) describes greatest of all is SateGuru, who saved my Honor. Here is same message Guru Nanak Dev jee is Giving: vfw vyprvwhu siqguru imlY q pwir pvw ] vaddaa vaeparavaahu sathigur(u) milai th paar(i) pavaa ||……1091 If I meet with the great, self-sufficient Sateguru, then I am carried across. 2) sathigur(i) naanak(i) bhagath(i) karee eik man(i) than(u) man(u) dhhan(u) gobi(n)dh dheeao ||….1405 sathigur(i) – used in prepositional form, meaning through Sateguru naanak(i) - karta karak Bhatt Bal jee says: Through Sateguru Nanak did Bhagti, single-mindedly; He surrenders His body, mind and wealth to the Lord of the Universe. This is a fundamental Gurmat principle that bhagati is to be done through Sateguru. And the Bhagti is of the Sateguru. It is not Gurmat principle that sateguru does bhagti. Please look at the following tuks: sachee bhagath sathigur thae hovai sachee hiradhai baanee ||---------602 True Bhagti is obtained only through the Sateguru, when the True Word of Bani is in the heart. manamukh bhagath karehi bin sathigur vin sathigur bhagath n hoee raam ||…..768 The self-willed manmukhs practice devotional rituals without the True Guru, but without the True Guru, there is no bhagti. 3) jinhaa naanak(u) sathigur(u) bhaettiaa thinhaa miliaa har soee ||2||---451 naanak(u)- karta karak – Guru Amar Daas jee Nanak(Guru Amar Daas jee) describes: Those who meet the Sateguru, the Lord Self meets them. ||2|| man thoo(n) math maan karehi j ho kishh jaanadhaa guramukh nimaanaa hohu || 441 O mind, don't be so proud of yourself, as if you know it all; Become humble by following the Gurmukh system (Gurmukh way as described in “SateGuru Ki bani”: Believe in one & only one God, search God within, through Sateguru, repeat God’s Name with great devotion, live sin free family life, do good deeds) Bhul chuk Maaf karna jee Waheguru Jee ka Khalsa WaheGuru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Kulbir Singh · 05 Dec 2003

Gurdaspuria jee, I think you are trying to prove that Satguru is some power other than Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. This is the philosophy of that person who was excommunicated out of panth but later retracted and got peshed at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib. It is one of the fundamental Sikhi principle that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is our Satguru and before coming to this world in human form, he existed in jyot form and has been merged in Vaheguru. In essence, Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is the Guru form of Vaheguru himself. Vaheguru himself takes the form of worshipper, what is being worshipped and Naam that is used to worship him. JYOT ROOP HAR AAP, GURU NANAK KAHAAIYO|| (The jyot-roop Vaheguru himself took form of Guru Nanak). Here “Jyot roop Har” is Karta kaarak noun of Kiriya vaachi shabad – kaahaiyo. “Guru Nanak” in this pankiti appears as Karam Kaarak. Some may argue that it is Sampradaan Kaarak but I think it is Karam Kaarak. Either way, the meanings don't change much as there is a very fine line between "Karam Kaarak" and "Sampradaan Kaarak". >>>>>> 1) sabh thae vaddaa sathigur(u), naanak(u), jin kal raakhee maeree ||--750 naanak(u)-karta karak Guru Arjan Dev jee Nanak(Guru Arjan Dev jee) describes greatest of all is SateGuru, who saved my Honor. >>>>>>>>>> I am not sure how you arrived at these meanings. In this pankiti you cannot separate “Nanak” and “Satguru” as they both appear in “Karta Kaarak” form of noun. Jin is the pronoun used for “Satgur Nanak” and appears in karta kaarak form as well. “kal” is an istree-ling naav used in the form of “karam kaarak. “meri” is a pronoun used in form of “Sampradaan Kaarak”. “Satgur Nanak” is the karta kaarak of kiriya-vaachi shabad – “raakhi”. You say that “Nanak (Guru Arjun Dev jee) describes”. Where did you get this verb “describe” from? It is not mentioned in the shabad. The meanings are very straight-forward that “Satgur Nanak is the greatest of all who has kept my honour”. Why you want to insert in here “Guru Arjun Sahib describes” and unnecessarily complicate things? The master of Gurbani viyaakaran, Professor Sahib Singh too has interpreted this as I have written above i.e. Satgur Nanak is the greatest of all. >>>>>>>>>> 2) sathigur(i) naanak(i) bhagath(i) karee eik man(i) than(u) man(u) dhhan(u) gobi(n)dh dheeao ||….1405 sathigur(i) – used in prepositional form, meaning through Sateguru naanak(i) - karta karak Bhatt Bal jee says: Through Sateguru Nanak did Bhagti, single-mindedly; He surrenders His body, mind and wealth to the Lord of the Universe. This is a fundamental Gurmat principle that bhagati is to be done through Sateguru. And the Bhagti is of the Sateguru. It is not Gurmat principle that sateguru does bhagti. Please look at the following tuks: >>>>>>>>>>> Veer Gurdaspuria, your meanings above are totally against Gurmat Viyaakaran. In order to get the meanings of “Through Satguru Nanak” you will have to have this shabad in “karan kaarak” case. The reality is that in this pankiti too “Satguru Nanak” appears in karta kaarak case. The sihaari in the end of these words cannot mean “through” but means “Ne”. The correct meanings are as follows: “Satguru Nanak jee did bhagtee with one mind i.e. full concentration. He gave his body, mind and everything to Gobind”. Please refer to any translator and you will find the meanings that I have done (By Guru kripa). The next pankitis make my translation even more solid: ANGAD ANANT MOORAT NIJ DHAARI, AGAM GIYAAN RASS RASSIYO HEEYO|| (Guru Angad Dev jee has enshrined unreachable Vaheguru inside himself. His mann is full of nectarous rass of Naam) Please note that here too “Angad” has a sihaari in the end but the meanings here too are in “karta kaarak” and not in “karan kaarak”. GUR AMARDAAS KARTAAR KIYO VASS, VAHO VAHO KAR DHIYAAIYO|| (Guru Amardaas jee has brought Vaheguru in his control by constant meditation of Vaheguru Vaheguru) Again Gur and Amardaas end with sihaaris and do not mean “through” or karan kaarak as you think sihaari always does. Here too the meanings should be done in karta kaarak. SIRI GURU RAAMDAAS JAIYO JAI JAG MEH, TAIN HAR PARAM PAD PAAIYO|| (O Siri Guru Ramdaas jeeo, you glory resounds in the universe. You have attained the top position of Vaheguru). Here “Siri Guru Raamdass” appear in “Sambodhan Kaarak. “Jag” appears as “Adhikaran Kaarak. “Har” appears as “sanbandh Kaaarak”. “Param Pad” appears as “Karam Kaarak”. Hopefully these translations will satisfy you that “Satguru” and “Nanak” in these pankitis are inseparable. >>>>>>>>> 3) jinhaa naanak(u) sathigur(u) bhaettiaa thinhaa miliaa har soee ||2||---451 naanak(u)- karta karak – Guru Amar Daas jee Nanak(Guru Amar Daas jee) describes: Those who meet the Sateguru, the Lord Self meets them. ||2|| >>>>>>>>>>>> In my humble opinion, both “Nanak Satgur” here appear in “Karta Kaarak” case and not only “nanak” in karta kaarak as you suggest. Then could you please let us know, what kaarak is “Satguru” then? They both have an aunkad in the end and are inseparable. “Jin” appears as “Sampradaan Kaarak”. Har soyee appear in “Karam Kaarak” case. I humbly suggest that you read more about Kaaraks. Following are the eight kaaraks used in Gurbani: 1) Karta Kaarak 2) Karam Kaarak 3) Karan Kaarak 4) Sampradaan Karak 5) Apaadaan Kaarak 6) Adhikaran Kaarak 7) Sambodhan Kaarak 8) Sambandh Kaarak. Every noun and pronoun that appears in Gurbani appear in one of these eight kaaraks. Depending on what kind of lag-maatars the word has, we can determine which kaarak it is in. Please refer to Professor Sahib Singh jee’s Gurbani Viyaakaran for more details. You can also refer to Giani Harbans Singh jee’s Naveen Gurbani Viyaakaran. Please don’t give any more pankitiyaan to prove your point. First refute what I have written and then start something new. There is no point in debating something if we are not going to complete what we start. Refute what I have written above and then move on to the next pankitiyaan. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Gurdaspuria · 08 Dec 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Kulbir Singh jee, I was out of town for the weekend, please excuse me for not responding promptly. I reviewed you message and believe that before we take a deep dive into Gurbani Varakaran to understand the meaning of the tuks you mentioned. It is important to make sure that we are on the same page on the fundamentals of Gurmat principles and processes as mentioned in Shri Guru Granth Sahib jee to approach Akal PurKh as our Gurus and Bhagats specified. If you disagree with any of the following please let me know. - There is one and only one sateguru for the whole mankind - Sateguru is sabad saroop and joot saroop of God - Sateguru is present from the very begining: does not take birth and dies - Gurbani urges, humans to do pooja /seva of sateguru by Naam (Gurmanter/ God’s name) jap ke in order to meet/see Sateguru. - pooja /seva of sateguru and Akal Purkh is one and the same. - When a person follows Gurmukh path, meets/sees Sateguru, with Akal purkh’s Grace. Then, that person sees the jot in every body, sees no stranger or enemy, Can hear anhaad sabad, punj doots comes under control………., then,gets to the Veraag avatha to meet/see God while following the Gurmukh path, Ultimately meets/sees God with Sateguru’s Kirpa. Gurmat path is: Believe in one & only one God, search God within, through Sateguru, recite God’s Name with great devotion, live sin free family life, do good deeds. Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Kulbir Singh · 09 Dec 2003

Gurdaspuria jee, I agree with what you have written. I also believe that "Satguru" is Guru Nanak who is jyot of Vaheguru and is Vaheguru daa roop. Now could you please refute what I wrote in my previous email or agree with it? At the same time, I request the admins to not allow postings that try to prove that Satguru Nanak Dev jee was not a Satguru but only a "Great Human". Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: what is wrong with my posting on sathigur

Admin · 10 Dec 2003

We have received some posts that are insulting to Guru Nanak Dev jee. Such posts have not been approved and will never be approved on this site. This site is to promote Guru Nanak Dev jee's mission and not insult Guru Sahib. This thread is now closed. No more posts under this thread will be entertained.