Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

singh · 13 Feb 2006

debate happening on this link. Knowledgable sikhs, please respond http://groups.msn.com/OXFORDISLAM/general.msnw?action=get_message&mview=0&ID_Message=254&LastModified=4675546668685938379

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

... · 13 Feb 2006

take the answers to their questions from www.whyichosesikhism.com They are standard questions these guys have in their database. Nothing new here.

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

Ironfist_4fairdeal · 13 Feb 2006

What to debate with these mulleys who put up a seal on their brain on the day they learn first lesson of islam and refuse to think beyond that seal. What a stretegist foundation of the islam is that the founder of islam claimed himself to be the final prophet of god, so according to him there is seal of prophethood after him. He claimed that there is no god but only Allah and Mohammad is his final prophet. This claim restricts the followers of islam to think some thing beyond their nose and realise that there may be some better religion or philosophy of life. Then what is the point to debate with them Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

Gursikh(learner..........) · 14 Feb 2006

Sorry for cut,copy and paste But will solve the problem to the end http://abhiyaas.blogspot.com/2006/02/how-is-sikhee-different.html How is Sikhi different? By :Gupt wannabe naam abhiyasee Sunday, February 12, 2006 How is Sikhee different? ( better to read from the original link above with the gurmukhi fonts ) The only way in which Daas can prove how Sikhee is different is to compare it with other faiths through divine Baanee (teachings from Guru Granth Sahib). Daas does not mean to offend or slander any religion, but will also not hesitate in speaking the truth. krim imlY scu pweIAY Duir bKs n mytY koie ]6] kuram milai such paaeeai dhur bukhus n maettai koe Receiving His Grace, we obtain Truth. No one can erase His Primal Blessing. (ang 62) Islam (Ang 140) imhr msIiq isdku muslw hku hlwlu kurwxu ] mihur museeth sidhuk musulaa huk hulaal kuraan Let mercy be your mosque, faith your prayer-mat, and honest living your Koran. srm suMniq sIlu rojw hohu muslmwxu ] surum sunnath seel rojaa hohu musulumaan Make modesty your circumcision, and good conduct your fast. In this way, you shall be a true Muslim. krxI kwbw scu pIru klmw krm invwj ] kurunee kaabaa such peer kulumaa kurum nivaaj Let good conduct be your Kaabaa, Truth your spiritual guide, and the karma of good deeds your prayer and chant. qsbI sw iqsu BwvsI nwnk rKY lwj ]1] thusubee saa this bhaavusee naanuk rukhai laaj Let your rosary be that which is pleasing to His Will. O Nanak, God shall preserve your honor. Guru Nanak Dev Jee has made it crystal clear in this Shabad to become a pure Muslim or a pure minded being; virtuous living is of highly importance. (Ang 141) pMij invwjw vKq pMij pMjw pMjy nwau ] punj nivaajaa vukhuth punj punjaa punjae naao There are five prayers and five times of day for prayer; the five have five names. pihlw scu hlwl duie qIjw KYr Kudwie ] pehilaa such hulaal dhue theejaa khair khudhaae Let the first be truthfulness, the second honest living, and the third charity in the Name of God. cauQI nIAiq rwis mnu pMjvI isPiq snwie ] chouthee neeath raas mun punjuvee sifath sunaae Let the fourth be good will to all, and the fifth the praise of the Lord. krxI klmw AwiK kY qw muslmwxu sdwie ] kurunee kulumaa aakh kai thaa musulumaan sudhaae Repeat the prayer of good deeds, and then, you may call yourself a Muslim. nwnk jyqy kUiVAwr kUVY kUVI pwie ]3] naanuk jaethae koorriaar koorrai koorree paae O Nanak, the false obtain falsehood, and only falsehood. Guru Sahib has made it apparent in this Shabad that just by praying 5 times a day one does not become a good Muslim, one has to praise the Lord with every breath. muslmwxu khwvxu musklu jw hoie qw muslmwxu khwvY ] musulumaan kehaavun musukul jaa hoe thaa musulumaan kehaavai It is difficult to be called a Muslim; if one is truly a Muslim, then he may be called one. (Ang 141) Guru Sahib says in this Shabad one has to put away the delusions of life and death, submit to Gods will, rid selfishness and be mercyful to all beings; Guru Jee says it is difficult to become a true Muslim - a disciple of Prophet Mohammeds faith. skiq snyhu kir suMniq krIAY mY n bdaugw BweI ] sukath sunaehu kar sunnath kureeai mai n budhougaa bhaaee Because of the love of woman, circumcision is done; I don't believe in it, O Siblings of Destiny. jau ry Kudwie moih qurku krYgw Awpn hI kit jweI ]2] jo rae khudhaae mohi thuruk kuraigaa aapun hee katt jaaee If God wished me to be a Muslim, it would be cut off by itself. suMniq kIey qurku jy hoiegw Aaurq kw ikAw krIAY ] sunnath keeeae thuruk jae hoeigaa aouruth kaa kiaa kureeai If circumcision makes one a Muslim, then what about a woman? (Ang 477) This shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Jee, a Muslim who meditated on the Mantra Raam. He says I teach both Hindus and Muslims, I meditate with every breath. muslmwxu soeI mlu KovY ] musulumaan soee mul khovai One who cleanses himself of impurity is a Muslim. (Ang 662) Guru Sahib has made it quite clear the only way to become a true Muslim is to purify ones mind through the praises of the Lord 24 hours a day. Guru Sahib has written extensively about the Hindus and Muslims failing in their practice, it is difficult to express. Muslims say all non-Muslims are classed as Kaafirs (non-believers) and we have no right to live unless we convert to Islam. FUMfy ihMdU qurk sB pIr pYkMbr kauim kqyly] toonddae hindhoo thuruk subh peer paikunbur koum kuthaelae All the sects, pirs, paigambars of the Hindus and Muslims were seen (by Baba Nanak). (ang 1) Bhai Gurdaas Jee says all the holy men of Hindus and Muslims threw away their teachings of God through their ego. There is no equality; Muslim women keep themselves covered where as men don’t, men are allowed 4 wives, women just 1 husband, Muslims do good for 1 month during fast, for the rest of the year they are slaves to their minds desires. Women are not allowed in mosque for prayer (Muslim holy place of worship). There are many more negatives, but there is no need to continue so Daas will stop here. Hinduism Hindus believe in many rituals, for example, Rakhree, wearing threads around their bodys to class themselves higher than others (Janeoo), they believe in high and low castes, idol worship - God cannot be seen through a stone he is only found from within through devotional worship of Simran (meditation). They believe in more than one God, Gods and goddesses. There are so many flaws in these religions, Daas feels bad in going through so many negative points of each religion. nwnk scy nwm ibnu ikAw itkw ikAw qgu ]1] naanuk suchae naam bin kiaa ttikaa kiaa thug O Nanak, without the True Name, of what use is the frontal mark of the Hindus, or their sacred thread? (ang 467) ihMdU AMn@w qurkU kwxw ] hindhoo annuaa thurukoo kaanaa The Hindu is sightless; the Muslim has only one eye. (ang 874) Most of the Shabads in Guru Granth Sahib Jee Guru Jee talks about Muslims and Hindus together, on how they should improve their practices. In this Shabad Bhagat Naamdayv, a Hindu Bhagat is saying a Hindu has no spiritual wisdom and a Muslim has realized a little bit, then he says Naamdayv knows more as he meditates on the Lord. (Ang 951) ihMdU kY Gir ihMdU AwvY ] hindhoo kai ghar hindhoo aavai The Hindu comes to the house of a Hindu. sUqu jnyaU piV gil pwvY ] sooth junaeoo parr gal paavai He puts the sacred thread around his neck and reads the scriptures. sUqu pwie kry buirAweI ] sooth paae kurae buriaaee He puts on the thread, but does evil deeds. nwqw Doqw Qwie n pweI ] naathaa dhothaa thaae n paaee His cleansings and washings will not be approved. muslmwnu kry vifAweI ] musulumaan kurae vaddiaaee The Muslim glorifies his own faith. ivxu gur pIrY ko Qwie n pweI ] vin gur peerai ko thaae n paaee Without the Guru or a spiritual teacher, no one is accepted. rwhu dswie EQY ko jwie ] raahu dhusaae outhai ko jaae They may be shown the way, but only a few go there. krxI bwJhu iBsiq n pwie ] kurunee baajhuhu bhisath n paae Without the karma of good actions, heaven is not attained. sco scu vKwxY koie ] sucho such vukhaanai koe One who speaks the True Name of the True Lord, nwnk AgY puC n hoie ]2] naanuk agai push n hoe O Nanak, is not called to account hereafter. Daas has cut this Shabad short as it is quite a long Shabad. (Ang 1158) Bhagat Kabeer Jee hmrw Jgrw rhw n koaU ] humuraa jhuguraa rehaa n kooo I have no quarrel with anyone. pMifq mulW Cwfy doaU ]1] rhwau ] punddith mulaa shaaddae dhooo I have abandoned both the Pandits, the Hindu religious scholars, and the Mullahs, the Muslim priests. Pause buin buin Awp Awpu pihrwvau ] bun bun aap aap pehiraavo I weave and weave, and wear what I weave. jh nhI Awpu qhw hoie gwvau ]2] jeh nehee aap thehaa hoe gaavo Where egotism does not exist, there I sing God's Praises. pMifq mulW jo iliK dIAw ] punddith mulaa jo likh dheeaa Whatever the Pandits and Mullahs have written, Cwif cly hm kCU n lIAw ]3] shaadd chulae hum kushoo n leeaa I reject; I do not accept any of it. irdY ieKlwsu inriK ly mIrw ] ridhai eikhulaas nirakh lae meeraa My heart is pure, and so I have seen the Lord within. Awpu Koij Koij imly kbIrw ]4]7] aap khoj khoj milae kubeeraa Searching, searching within the self, Kabeer has met the Lord. The Bhramins would not let the shadow of a so called low caste come in to contact with their body. They would take a bath saying they are filthy. dieAw kpwh sMqoKu sUqu jqu gMFI squ vtu ] dhaeiaa kupaah sunthokh sooth juth guntee suth vutt Make compassion the cotton, contentment the thread, modesty the knot and truth the twist. eyhu jnyaU jIA kw heI q pwfy Gqu ] eaehu junaeoo jeea kaa hee th paaddae ghuth This is the sacred thread of the soul; if you have it, then go ahead and put it on me. nw eyhu qutY nw mlu lgY nw eyhu jlY n jwie ] naa eaehu thuttai naa mul lugai naa eaehu julai n jaae It does not break, it cannot be soiled by filth, it cannot be burnt, or lost. DMnu su mwxs nwnkw jo gil cly pwie ] dhunn s maanus naanukaa jo gal chulae paae Blessed are those mortal beings, O Nanak, who wear such a thread around their necks. caukiV muil AxwieAw bih caukY pwieAw ] choukarr mul anaaeiaa behi choukai paaeiaa You buy the thread for a few shells, and seated in your enclosure, you put it on. isKw kMin cVweIAw guru bRwhmxu iQAw ] sikhaa kunn churraaeeaa gur braahumun thiaa Whispering instructions into others' ears, the Brahmin becomes a guru. Ehu muAw Ehu JiV pieAw vyqgw gieAw ]1] ouhu muaa ouhu jharr paeiaa vaethugaa gaeiaa But he dies, and the sacred thread falls away, and the soul departs without it. The janeoo thread is put around the neck of a Hindu Bhramin stating he is high class and well versed in the Hindu scriptures. Guru Nanak Dev Jee refused to wear this thread when the Bhramins come to put it on him as a child, Nanak repeated the Shabad above. Guru Sahib made it quite clear the only way these 2 religions would purify their practice would be to praise the Lord Athe Pehar (24 hours). Both the Hindus and the Muslims tried to claim Guru Nanak was their Peer (saint). Jains Jain is a religion in which practices a lot of different forms of meditation and takes virtues like compassion to the extreme penance, they always keep their mouth covered believing bacteria is in the air which has life and if it enters the mouth they would have sinned by killing. They sweep the floor before them sweeping aside any Insects to prevent them from stepping on them. This is most definately not Gurmat (teachings of the Guru) this is a hinderance in ones practice in attaining the Lord through devotional worship, the other thing is if we are not aware of something it is not a sin, Guru Sahib made us Gristhee (householder life in society) it is difficult to take up these extreme practices in society this is why Guru Sahib took extremism away from Sikhee to teach the world by example by living in it, just like when Guru Nanak went to do parchaar (preach) he wore their robes so they would listen to him, Gods message was sent to liberate the world and not just Sikhs. (Ang 265) jYn mwrg sMjm Aiq swDn ] jain maarug sunjum ath saadhun you may adopt the self-mortifying ways of the Jains and great spiritual disciplines; inmK inmK kir srIru ktwvY ] nimukh nimukh kar sureer kuttaavai piece by piece, you may cut your body apart; qau BI haumY mYlu n jwvY ] tho bhee houmai mail n jaavai but even so, the filth of your ego shall not depart. hir ky nwm smsir kCu nwih ] har kae naam sumusar kush naahi There is nothing equal to the Name of the Lord. nwnk gurmuiK nwmu jpq giq pwih ]2] naanuk gurumukh naam juputh gath paahi O Nanak, as Gurmukh, chant the Naam, and obtain salvation. jwp qwp BRmn bsuDw kir aurD qwp lY gYn ] jaap thaap bhrumun busudhaa kar ourudh thaap lai gain Chanting, deep meditation and penance, wandering over the face of the earth, the performance of austerities with the arms stretched up to the sky ieh ibiD nh pqIAwno Twkur jog jugiq kir jYn ]2] eih bidh neh putheeaano thaakur jog jugath kar jain - the Lord is not pleased by any of these means, though one may follow the path of Yogis and Jains. (ang 674) Christianity Guru Sahib talked more about the Eastern religions in his Baanee as they were slightly more spiritual and they were the areas he did his preaching, very little is said in Gurbaanee about Christians. Daas' personal view after talking to a few Christians is that they do not meditate on the Lord so therefore, their mind cannot be purified through the name of the Lord. They believe in virtues but these are a waste of time without Naam as one is only virtuous through self ego. They say Jesus was the Son of God, Guru Sahib says we are all the Sons and Daughters of God and we can become one to one with the Lord, Christians do not believe this, they do not believe in life after death, nobody knows the true teachings of Christianity as the bible has been changed numerous number of times, the women cover their heads in church the men don’t (no equality). Daas believes any faith which does not believe in liberation whilst alive (Jeevan Mukhatee) has weaknesses in its practice. Buddhism Buddhism is a beautiful religion created by lord Buddha he was a very rich prince who gave up his wealth for compassion, contentment and spiritual wisdom, it is very similar to Sikhee in the sense that one can be liberated whilst alive, they believe in many forms of meditation and it is a very virtuous religion spiritually, but sorry to say this beautiful faith which Daas himself loves also has a lot of flaws. Guru Sahib has not directly talked much about the Buddhs in his baanee but he has mentioned them along with the Jains, Yogees, Sidhs, etc as very spiritual beings. Buddhists do not believe in God, they say the mind is another name for God once one purifies the filthy mind one will be liberated. This is totally true but as Daas has mentioned in previous posts, having faith in a supreme being (God) reduces ego quicker rather than saying 'I' have to purify 'MY' mind, this is what we are trying to kill 'THE I'. jb hm hoqy qb qum nwhI Ab qum hhu hm nwhI ] jub hum hothae thub thum naahee ab thum huhu hum naahee When I was, then You were not; now that You are, I am not. (Ang 339) Ab hm qum eyk Bey hih eykY dyKq mnu pqIAwhI ]1] ab hum thum eaek bheae hehi eaekai dhaekhuth mun putheeaahee Now, You and I have become one; seeing this, my mind is content. Buddhists shave their hair saying it keeps them simple and it hinders their practice they do not realize all spiritual energy comes from hair (rom), lord Buddha kept his Kes (hair). Women are not allowed to be ordained as Monks, they believe in celibacy; if everyone became a Buddhist what would happen to mankind? We would be extinct. Buddhists do not earn a living they beg (bhikhsha). In countries like Thailand they are so well respected people offer them money, who would we beg off if we all became Buddhists, they meditate and spend most their time in monasteries, Guru Nanak Dev Jee declined this type of practice as it does nothing to liberate mankind. They worship idols and also believe in many gods and goddesses. Out of the 5 religions Daas has mentioned, Daas has honestly got to say this is a beautiful religion and spiritually have both eyes open. kyqy isD buD nwQ kyqy kyqy dyvI vys ] kaethae sidh budh naath kaethae kaethae dhaevee vaes So many Siddhas and Buddhas, so many Yogic masters. So many goddesses of various kinds. ( (ang 7) This Shabad states so many religions including the Buddhs only reached the realm of Gyan khand (spiritual wisdom) this is the 2nd khand out of 5, Dharm khand, Gyan khand, Saram khand, Karam khand and Sach khand where God himself resides in all his glory, this is an article on its own so we wont go in to too much detail. jogI jqI qpI sMinAwsI bhu qIrQ BRmnw ] jogee juthee thupee sunniaasee buhu theeruth bhrumunaa The Yogis, celibates, penitents and Sannyaasees make pilgrimages to all the sacred places. luMijq muMijq moin jtwDr AMiq qaU mrnw ]1] lunjith munjith mon juttaadhur anth thoo murunaa The Jains with shaven heads, the silent ones, the beggars with matted hair - in the end, they all shall die. qw qy syvIAly rwmnw ] thaa thae saeveealae raamunaa Meditate, therefore, on the Lord. (Ang 476) How is Sikhee different? siqgur kI bwxI siq siq kir jwxhu gurisKhu hir krqw Awip muhhu kFwey ] sathigur kee baanee sath sath kar jaanuhu gurasikhuhu har kuruthaa aap muhuhu kutaaeae O GurSikhs, know that the Bani, the Word of the True Guru, is true, absolutely true. The Creator Lord Himself causes the Guru to chant it. gurisKw ky muh aujly kry hir ipAwrw gur kw jYkwru sMswir sBqu krwey ] gurasikhaa kae muh oujulae kurae har piaaraa gur kaa jaikaar sunsaar subhuth kuraaeae The Beloved Lord makes the faces of His GurSikhs radiant; He makes the whole world applaud and acclaim the Guru. (Ang 308) siqgur kI bwxI siq srUpu hY gurbwxI bxIAY ] sathigur kee baanee sath suroop hai gurubaanee buneeai The Word of the True Guru's Bani is the embodiment of Truth; through Gurbani, one becomes perfect (ang 304) siqgur kI bwxI siq siq kir mwnhu ieau Awqm rwmY lInw hy ]14] sathigur kee baanee sath sath kar maanuhu eio aathum raamai leenaa hae Accept as True, Perfectly True, the Word of the True Guru's Bani. In this way, you shall merge in the Lord, the Supreme Soul. (ang 1027) Dur kI bwxI AweI ] dhur kee baanee aaee The Bani of His Word emanated from the Primal Lord. iqin sglI icMq imtweI ] thin sugulee chinth mittaaee It eradicates all anxiety. (Ang 627) How can it be any clearer that Baanee came from God himself through the spirit of Guru Nanak. This amazing faith is the most recent of faiths created by God, he sent Guru Nanak in 1469 to liberate the world after he saw all the other spiritual leaders failed as it is stated in one of the Shabads above, this faith took 230 years to create, this faith was created by 10 Gurus only 6 have written in the Guru Granth Sahib, 19 Bhagats and 11 Bhatts all these souls had purified their mind and become one with God so therefore they spoke the word of God. The bhagats were from different faiths and so called lower castes this,shows the equality of this amazing faith. Guru Jee was sent to liberate mankind and spread the message others had failed to do, he took away all rituals, superstitions, extremism, caste system, gave Women equal rights and taught humans how to become one with the Lord in society. jab ehu gehe bipran ki reet, main na karun in ki parteet Guru Gobind Singh Jee says here when we bring rituals and extreme rules in our life like the bhramins I will not stand by you. An extreme Rehit without Athai Pehar 24 hour Naam Simran, virtuous living is not Gurmat this is where the Bhramins failed as they were not suitable to live in society and spread spiritual wisdom. If the mind has to do any form of Pakhand (hypocrisy) in order to keep a certain Rehit this is also not Gurmat as Guru Sahib kept us clear from Pakhand and blessed us with Sach (truthful living), we should let no practice hinder our loving devotion to God. krm Drm pwKMf jo dIsih iqn jmu jwgwqI lUtY ] kurum dhurum paakhundd jo dheesehi thin jum jaagaathee loottai The religious rites, rituals and hypocrisies which are seen, are plundered by the Messenger of Death, the ultimate tax collector. (Ang 747) byd kqyb isimRiq siB swsq ien@ piVAw mukiq n hoeI ] baedh kuthaeb simrith sabh saasuth einu parriaa mukath n hoee One may read all the books of the Vedas, the Bible, the Simritees and the Shaastras, but they will not bring liberation. KqRI bRwhmx sUd vYs aupdysu chu vrnw kau swJw ] khuthree braahumun soodh vais oupudhaes chuhu vurunaa ko saajhaa The four castes - the Kh'shaatriyas, Brahmins, Soodras and Vaishyas - are equal in respect to the teachings. gurmuiK nwmu jpY auDrY so kil mih Git Git nwnk mwJw ]4]3]50] gurumukh naam jupai oudhurai so kal mehi ghatt ghatt naanuk maajhaa One who, as Gurmukh, chants the Naam, the Name of the Lord, is saved. In this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, O Nanak, God is permeating the hearts of each and every being. (Ang 4350) Guru Sahib states in this Shabad that the Gurus teachings are to liberate mankind not just Sikhs as stated in the Shabad above, Guru Sahib says be truthful in your own faith but you will not be liberated without meditating on the Lords name Athai Pehar 24 hours. Guru sahib was strictly against conversions. AMg 1 ang 1 Page 1 Bhai Gurdaas Jee siqgur nwnk pRgitAw imtI DuMD jg cwnx hoAw] sathigur naanuk prugattiaa mittee dhundh jug chaanun hoaa With the emergence of the true Guru Nanak, the mist cleared and the light scattered all around. ijauN kr sUrj inkilAw qwry Cpy AMDyr ploAw] jio kur sooruj nikaliaa thaarae shupae andhaer puloaa As if at the sun rise the stars disappeared and the darkness dispelled. isMG buky imrgwvlI BMnI jwey n DIr DroAw] singh bukae mirugaavulee bhunnee jaaeae n dheer dhuroaa With the roar of the lion in the forest the flocks of escaping deer now cannot have endurance. ijQY bwbw pYr DrY pUjw Awsx Qwpx soAw] jithai baabaa pair dhurai poojaa aasun thaapun soaa Wherever Baba put his feet, a religious place was erected and established. isD Awsx sB jgq dy nwnk Awd mqy jy koAw] sidh aasun subh juguth dhae naanuk aadh muthae jae koaa All the siddh-places now have been renamed on the name of Nanak. Gr Gr AMdr Drmswl hovY kIrqn sdw ivsoAw] ghur ghur andhur dhurumusaal hovai keeruthun sudhaa visoaa Everyhome has become a place of dharma where singing. bwby qwry cwr ck nO KMf ipRQmI scw FoAw] baabae thaarae chaar chuk nu khundd prithumee suchaa toaa Baba liberated all four directions and nine divisions of earth. gurmuK kil ivc prgt hoAw ]ò÷] gurumukh kal vich purugutt hoaa Gurmukh (Guru Nanak) has emerged in this kaliyug, the dark age. WOW this Shabad says it all about the pure Guru Nanak, there is no equal. Nanak was the Avtar of Kal Jug (dark age). Avtar means immortal being whose mind is pure and is sitting in Sach khand (the gate of truth) waiting for duty by the Lord to come and liberate the world. All the religions above were also created in Kal Jug. srb Drm mih sRyst Drmu ] surub dhurum mehi sraesutt dhurum Of all religions, the best religion hir ko nwmu jip inrml krmu ] har ko naam jap nirumul kurum is to chant the Name of the Lord and maintain pure conduct. (ang 266) sgl Drm mih sRyst Drmu ] sugul dhurum mehi sraesutt dhurum Of all faiths, this is the most sublime and excellent faith. hir ismrin qyrw hoie auDwru ] har simuran thaeraa hoe oudhaar Meditating in remembrance on the Lord, you shall be saved. jnm jnm kw auqrY Bwru ]3] junum junum kaa outhurai bhaar You shall be rid of the burden of countless incarnations. (ang 895) This Shabad is showing equality, he did not preach faith, he preached the name of the Lord in every line of his Baanee. krm Drm nym bRq pUjw ] kurum dhurum naem bruth poojaa The karma of good actions, the Dharma of righteous living, religious rituals, fasts and worship pwrbRhm ibnu jwnu n dUjw ]2] paarubrehum bin jaan n dhoojaa - practice these, but do not know any other than the Supreme Lord God. qw kI pUrn hoeI Gwl ] jw kI pRIiq Apuny pRB nwil ]3] thaa kee poorun hoee ghaal Those who place their love in God - their works are brought to fruition. (ang 199) How amazing is Sikhee, Guru Sahib is saying practice religious rituals, fasts etc but if you keep hold of the name with every breath you will be liberated. (there is no need to practice these religious rituals). khY nwnku gur prswdI ijnw ilv lwgI iqnI ivcy mwieAw pwieAw ]29] kehai naanuk gur purusaadhee jinaa liv laagee thinee vichae maaeiaa paaeiaa Says Nanak, by Guru's Grace, those who enshrine love for the Lord find Him, in the midst of Maya. (ang 917) Guru sahib states here that those who love the lord may have wealth, live house holders life, do all the deeds that need to be done in society, have many material luxuries but they will still be detached from all of them because they will have learnt how to let go through the love of Naam. Sikhee is different from every faith, Daas can talk all day long about Sikhee through the reference of Gurbaanee, Daas realizes this article is very long and people struggle to read solid text so Daas will try and stop soon, you can judge for your self how Gurbaanee proves we are blessed to be Sikhs. We must have good karam (deeds) to be born into Sikh families but only if we realize what we are here for, so why waste time liberate yourselves through Amrit, Rehit, Naam and Baanee. A Sikh can not be liberated without these four. Pritham rehit eh jaan, khandey ki pahul shakey The first Rehit is Gurus Amrit. Rehit bina na sikh kahaavai, without Rehit (discipline) one can not be called a Sikh. Without Naam and Gurbaanee one can not be liberated. BeI prwpiq mwnuK dyhurIAw ] bhee puraapath maanukh dhaehureeaa This human body has been gifted to you. (Ang12) goibMd imlx kI ieh qyrI brIAw ] gobindh milun kee eih thaeree bureeaa This is your chance to meet the Lord of the Universe. vir kwj qyrY ikqY n kwm ] avar kaaj thaerai kithai n kaam Nothing else will work. imlu swDsMgiq Bju kyvl nwm ]1] mil saadhusungath bhuj kaevul naam Join the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy; vibrate and meditate on the Jewel of the Naam. In the Sikh faith Guru Sahib gave all Vadiyaaee (praise) to God, no human being. qy hir ky jn hir isau ril imly jYsy jn nwnk sllY sll imlwiq ]2]1]8] thae har kae jun har sio ral milae jaisae jun naanuk sululai sulul milaath Those humble servants of the Lord merge with their Lord, O Nanak, like water merging with water. (ang 1200) In no faith does the soul merge with God unlike the Sikh faith stated above. Gurbaanee is a treasure we have failed to pass on to the world, the only way the world will be liberated is through baanee. (Ang 296) iehu inDwnu jpY min koie ] eihu nidhaan jupai man koe One who chants this treasure in his mind sB jug mih qw kI giq hoie ] subh jug mehi thaa kee gath hoe in every age, he attains salvation. Gux goibMd nwm Duin bwxI ] gun gobindh naam dhun baanee In it is the Glory of God, the Naam, the chanting of Gurbani. IsimRiq swsqR byd bKwxI ] simrith saasuthr baedh bukhaanee The Simritees, the Shaastras and the Vedas speak of it. Sgl mqWq kyvl hir nwm ] sugul muthaath kaevul har naam The essence of all religion is the Lord’s Name alone. GoibMd Bgq kY min ibsRwm ] gobindh bhuguth kai man bisraam It abides in the minds of the devotees of God. Koit ApRwD swDsMig imtY ] kott apraadh saadhusung mittai Millions of sins are erased, in the Company of the Holy. SMq ik®pw qy jm qy CutY ] sunth kirupaa thae jum thae shuttai By the Grace of the Saint, one escapes the Messenger of Death. Jw kY msqik krm pRiB pwey ] jaa kai musuthak kurum prabh paaeae Those, who have such pre-ordained destiny on their foreheads, swD srix nwnk qy Awey ]7] saadh suran naanuk thae aaeae O Nanak, enter the Sanctuary of the Saints. Daas has had veechar (discussions) with many religious people from many faiths and this has bought Daas so much closer to Sikhee, there is no faith like Sikhee, Daas is not being biased - only speaking the truth, Sikhee is not a religion it is a way of life to reunite our souls with the supreme soul God (Param Atma), this is not only for Sikhs it is for the whole of mankind. If anybody knows of even just 1 flaw in Sikhee please email Daas, Daas will try to resolve your query through the light of Gurbaanee as Daas is fully aware this faith is unique. Jaago Gursikho, jaago, Panth di thae poore sansar di seva karo Naam thae bani da aasra lai ke, awake Gursikh brothers and sisters serve the Khalsa Panth and the Universe through the teachings of the true Guru (Sat Guru) by meditating 24 hrs with every breath. Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee sacrificed all his family and many Gursikhs in battle for Chardee Kalaa (higher spirits, upliftment of Panth), (Saint soldier article) lets ask ourselves what are we doing for the upliftment of the Panth, Guru Sahib is only asking for time towards Sevaa and Simran. If every Gursikh in the Panth pulled together and did they’re little bit in spreading the true word of Guru Nanak Dev Jee Paatsaah Sikhee would be in Chardee Kalaa, there would be so many more Gurmukh sSjjan (beloved friends), and less quarreling over controversial issues which in the end only bring negativity between Gursikhs and the Panth stays at a stand still. Can you please email this article to any Monae brothers and sisters you know (Sikhs with cut hair), or alternately introduce them to the blog. *monae brothers and sisters who have not come in to sikhi as yet. Next weeks article is 'Rehansbaaee keertan', why it is important to sit through a full Rehansbhaaee Keertan without going out of the Darbaar? Daas is not trying to promote any Jathebandee when one reads the article one will realize.

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

Jagjit Matharu · 14 Feb 2006

I think everyone should take a look at this website: www.faithfreedom.org It really is an eye opener.........

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

singh · 14 Feb 2006

because if you do not they just get more encouragement and spew out more crap

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

agyani · 14 Feb 2006

theres a difference between allah and god? lol how silly is that :P

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

ISDhillon · 14 Feb 2006

The quoran is an indirect revelation from god via an angel called gabrielle, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is a direct revelation from god because gurus were one with god at all times therefore this is the only direct revelation from god. You see muslims dont even believe that we can become one with god so therefore they never grasp the nature of what it means to have a direct revelation, Guru Nanak Dev Ji explains it quite satifactorily when he says "Jai se mai aavai kasam ki baani..." i reveal as the word comes to me. Hindu scriptures are inspired by reverberations that can be heard in different spiritual regions this is the source of the vedas they are not from god either that is why the presiding deity of a spiritual region is the object of their worship. With regards to koran they say "noone can write a surah like it i dare you...." this is easy tell them that you will accept their challenge if they can find even one verse in quoran that can awaken your soul like 1430 pages of bani can, if they say they can then their whole philosophy comes crashing down because in their theological position self-realisation is a farce. And this is the fundamental difference between scripture and revelation or bani, that bani is not a maryada, bani is for your soul, the divine essence within has the opportunity to rekindle its intimate bond with god through the primacy of direct revelation - sounds like boring philosophical words but it is the vital difference between the nature of bani which is guru and the purpose of quoran which is opinion, ie, our guru never left their prophet did!. We need to start to fully understand sikh doctrine before we engage in debate with other faiths many muslims I met say that for all the equality that sikhi preaches it failed to produce even one female guru from its 10 and even elected a child of the age of 8. This misunderstanding shows how they view our religion in reality the answer is that guru is bani and bani has no gender, the vehicle for bani was flesh in a male form, today the vehicle is paper which is neither male or female it has nothing to do with political times or social conditions its about how we veiw the guru - does the body really mean anything? Apologetics will always try to set premises and rules for debate like "a prophecy is proof of truth, a miracle is proof that they were prophets, god wouldnt contradict himself" This law of non-contradiction is ridiculous, you will always see these semitic faiths say things like, god is reasonable and would never contradict himself and then they rush in with the law of non-contradiction expecting everyone to bow down in defeat because they have accepted a common frame of reference instead of their own faith being a measure of its own definition. We share the same divine essence as god but are not god at the same time this defies the law of non-contradiction. You will also find that these muslims will use SGGS as a rahit maryada saying where does your guru talk about punishment etc they dont even understand that sikhism is a twin doctrine of guru granth guru panth, and it becomes increasingly tiresome to discuss and explain to them cos anythin that they havnt heard of in their religion is just met with "oh thats nonsense..." and then how can you debate, it just becomes well i dont believe in such a thing. The premise of this law in religious dialogue is quite sneeky, it follows that if god made man in the image of himself then god has a mind and is rational. God in sikhism is not as per this definition, we in sikhism believe that god made creation in the image of the souls purpose, thats why all rivers lead to the sea, thats why we have so many joons if we interpret last stanza of Japji Sahib from Pavan guru pani pitta... it is quite self explanatory how creation is made in the image of the souls purpose ie, to be one with god, the spirit is a divine essence which defies all that our minds are capable of interpreting this central theme runs throughout the whole of sri guru granth sahib ji but the semitic ones have failed to draw on such references when making their conclusions therefore this unequivically proves their motives to be suspect. Alot of this recent attacks is about hizbut tarir attempts to create a global caliphate they're excuse is that pure islam has never been practiced and when we create it then we will be able to implement shariah without corruption but we cant whilst their is kaffir in muslim countries so the systematic use of daiii and jihad to overthrow governemts is used, they start of densley populating an area and then start creating superstition in their children that all their poverty is cos of the kaffir and then the children read koran and are furthered by the hateful stuuf written therin, and then they start claims for land acquisition saying that they have rightful claims to their land. If you look at punjab today alot of gujjar have entered punjab and they dont let their children go to normal school they get taught by mullahs once a week and they cut themselves of from the rest of society and breed fanaticism which will then isolate them and they will refuse to integrate and bobs your uncle they want to seperate, its a cycle of historical abise and has to be ended at some point. Anyways off topic, ISDhillon

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

A Singh · 14 Feb 2006

Looking at the Islamic history and their hostality in present times, I believe US is doing to the Arab world is justified.

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

ISDhillon · 18 Feb 2006

Well folks I responded to the site here is the 2 links: http://groups.msn.com/OXFORDISLAM/general....&ID_Message=404 http://groups.msn.com/OXFORDISLAM/general....&ID_Message=405 But no one has bothered to respond to me. Bhul chuk maaf if I have written anything wrong in me responses. ISDhillon

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

eagle · 21 Feb 2006

but i think its time sikhs unite amongst themselves and with other religions to confront islamic radical theology that is attacking everybody. Big meetings should be held with them with the local press which would most definatly favour it as the fiery side of islam is currently sensation in the press. Get some solid sikh lecturers in, doctors, bhagti wale, proffesors whatrever it is. These meetings should then be put onto net, mp3s ipods and scripted and leaflets and books should be made to students starting from schools colleges as a preperation to know what to do in that situation and these should also be handed out at camps gurdwaras and rensbhais.

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

Ipod · 21 Feb 2006

Some of the messages are not there anymore. Did they delete some of them?

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

ISDhillon · 21 Feb 2006

Well with the deletion thing, firstly after no one responded to me I decided to cancel my membership with the organisation and then I realised that they deleted my message cos I cancelled so then I became a member again and then they added my messages on the second page of the discussion. Fundamentalism starts in the home because if the fear of hell makes them intolerant then the only way to instill a tolerant nature in these people is by giving them the same temprement of a hellish existence to fear them into tolerance. You see this is where we are headed if like the member above suggested that we dont educate society and their people through gurus message of islam, otherwise history is gonna repeat because we are not being proactive, our gurus never waited for the hell to come to their door they went out and challenged, I heard once that Guru Nanak Dev Ji went upto babar and said "babar tu jhabbar hai" meaning babar your a butcher so we have to stop seeing being proactive as a form of preaching or selling sikhi, cos at the moment alot of us have this image that those who talk about their religion are a bit sad cos their lookin for converts but thats not true i dont want converts i want more focus in society and sikhi gives clarity to all faiths through its own knowledge.

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

Sikh · 22 Feb 2006

Also, I think that we should have mature people debating with them. If someone is going to add childish comments that are insulting and teenagerish, then that will only give a bad name to Sikhs.

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

m virdee · 23 Feb 2006

please ask these muslims to read the challenge to get $50000 . Answer this challenge and prove that qiran is correct. http://www.faithfreedom.org/challenge.htm if quran is true take the challenge.

Re: Fundamentalist Muslims Challenge Sikhs

unreal · 23 Feb 2006

Yes, because the sins of the father pass on to the son? Give your head a shake Singh - two wrongs do not make a right. And if you still think that little children dying, torture and the other physical/mental abuse that has taken place is JUSTIFIED, I have little to offer in way of argument but will pray that Waheguru open your eyes and your heart. regards, unreal A Singh wrote: > Looking at the Islamic history and their hostality in present > times, I believe US is doing to the Arab world is justified.