Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

Totally confused · 10 Feb 2006

Forgive me for my weak knowledge, but could anyone explain if we have the concept of guilt in Sikhi and if so is Nitnem the way to absolution as well as the path to God? Should a Sikh feel guilty if they have betrayed another or should they just say it is up to God to judge and make no attempt at amending their behaviour. Can one make amends in this life? If so should it be to the person concerned or only to Waheguru? What if some has committed a perceived wrong on another and has no guilt about it - is this because there is no concept of guilt or because the person has no heart. If it is the latter is that God's Will? Always more questions than answers! Totally confused :-(

Re: Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

LK · 10 Feb 2006

Author: Totally confused Date: 02-10-06 04:40 Forgive me for my weak knowledge, but could anyone explain if we have the concept of guilt in Sikhi and if so is Nitnem the way to absolution as well as the path to God? Should a Sikh feel guilty if they have betrayed another or should they just say it is up to God to judge and make no attempt at amending their behaviour. ********************* Gur Sahib has left soo much pyaare, Gurbani, morals, Values. Guru Sahib gives us morals - why would a SIkh betray a person to begin with? *********** Can one make amends in this life? If so should it be to the person concerned or only to Waheguru? *********** Karmi apo Apni - you reap what you sow... ************** What if some has committed a perceived wrong on another and has no guilt about it - is this because there is no concept of guilt or because the person has no heart. If it is the latter is that God's Will? ************** lol, guilt doesn't come from the haert, guilt is due to dodgy stuff going on in the brain. No it does not mean the person has no heart, it cuold mean 1 - that the person seriously doesn't think what he's done si wrong 2- has some abnormality in the brain fi the person NEVER feels guilt, as it is fromt he brain that guilt comes from again, Gurbani gives us the morals - Don't betray people - so why do that to begin with?

Re: Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

ks · 10 Feb 2006

guilt in the context of religion is a semetic construct. It is not mentioned in Gurbani, but there are always consequences for actions good and bad.

Re: Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

guru guru · 11 Feb 2006

what is funny is when we are happy and want something, then it's guru guru guru, vaah nobody can say anything higher than the praise we reap on guru sahib..... but then when some dukh enters our life or when our thoughts change then its, i believe differently to what guru ji is saying, i do follow what they are saying, but on this issue i think differently and will do differently. then we use our own minds, and guru ji is cast away by the wayside. stop being so selfish people. hukam is not a 2-sided coin! we reap what we sow - a most perfect justice.

Re: Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

no jatha singh · 11 Feb 2006

i think the chali mukte sakhi may answer some of your questions. I think it is good to make amends, with pyar as the motivator, rarther than guilt. It is good to give forgiveness and recieve it. - like the lords prayer- forgve us our trespasses as we for give those who trespass againts us. Guilt is based in the past, and our minds should not be focused /doing simran of the past like this. In sikhi , guru Nanak would not have stresssed kirt karo ( honest hard work) if it was ok to leave things to God eg say to yourself if its in his will he`ll feed me. Sikhi says Karta - Purkh- God Is above everything but he`s in the creation in infinite forms as the creator and doer. So we are part of God's infinite form, sikhi tells us to remember that and try not to think that we are the doer, but that God's will is being played through us. So basically, I think you would try to make amends (udham), if the other person complies and forgives,understand that it was God that did ALL of that- the betrayal and the forgiving . If not , its still God`s will, try snd think of it as mitha bhanna and dont screw yourself up with guilt again

Re: Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

Totally confused · 14 Feb 2006

Thank you everyone for your replies. Just wanted to quickly say that I'm that one who feels that he has been betrayed; and it was the lack of guilt, the sheer ungratitude and selfishness of some one who I thought was my friend that I was trying to understand. They feel no guilt over their own actions and have completely justified them to themselves. LK -yeah I know it's the brain :-) I was using the heart as a metaphor; but I think you know that. Also you said " Should a Sikh feel guilty if they have betrayed another or should they just say it is up to God to judge and make no attempt at amending their behaviour." Thats exactly what I was trying to understand. But my hurt was from the fact that the other party feels no guilt. "why should a Sikh betray another" ... I don't know. But it happened and was at some levels due to greed, selfishness and thinking that usuing people and tossing them away was a perfectly acceptable thing to do. I see so much of this attitude all around me and notice it so much more after my own experiences. ks - "guilt in the context of religion is a semetic construct."; I'm really sorry but I don't fully understand that. If you have the time could you explain a bit more. guru guru - "we reap what we sow - a most perfect justice." Thats what I thought. But I wasn't sure if that would happen in this lifetime or another. I'm still not sure. njs - I have tried to make amends with pyar, even to the extent of trying to accept blame where it was not mine to accept. But it was refused in a nasty way; hence I find it hard to forgive. But great reply and it really spoke to me. I didn't want this to be about my hurt, I'm was just trying to understand how we deal with pain, guilt (lack of as well as presence of), how to forgive. To see what Guru Ji has to say so that I may learn from this. Thank you all.

Re: Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

ks · 14 Feb 2006

guilt is a complex unique to christianity/judiasm/islam. Eastern religions generally don't have a concept of guilt.

Re: Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

sikh · 16 Feb 2006

Totally confused ji do simran and slowly but surely the love will begin to grow in your heart not manmat love but the real love! and then you will be able to move on and forgive which is the biggest gift of all.

Re: Concept of Guilt in Sikhi

TD · 16 Feb 2006

totally confused, i think what you went through must have been tough, bcos i too endured some pain. that person never once showed remorse or any form of apologies to me!!!! i understand what you must be going through. takes time!