Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

body building

body building

bob the builder · 07 Feb 2006

wjkkwjkf sangat ji, i would just like to ask if training your body and building muscle is against sikhi. replies would be appreciated. wjkkwjkf [%sig%]

Re: body building

unreal · 07 Feb 2006

Of course it's not against Sikhi - both Sikh men and women should ensure they are in top physical shape, which, in many cases includes building muscle. There may be some who say bodybuilding crosses the line into egoism; however, I think the benefits of such a healthy discipline far outweigh the risk of egoism which must be guarded against whether you work out or not. I would much rather see Singhs pursue a discipline leading to good physical health, larger muscles, strength etc than see Singhs pursue a lifestyle leaving them fat and/or scrawny. Tyar par tyar, I believe, also means being physically tyar par tyar.

Re: body building

.. · 07 Feb 2006

thers nothing wrong abt it .

Re: body building

BirRaas Singh · 07 Feb 2006

I would suggest rather then doing the gora style bodybuilding, Sikhs should commit themselves to Indian style mehanta. This include the classic behtak, dand, bal-leh, and overall waryam. Ask any old babeh about these if you dont know what they are. Western bodybuilding leads to excess of mass and muscles which restrict movement and comprimise flexibility. Whereas Indian style relies on working against your own bodyweight to provide natural resistance, leading to a slimmer, flexible, and proportional body frame.

Re: body building

G-Singh · 07 Feb 2006

[gurbani] dohrw ] blu CutikE bMDn pry kCU n hoq aupwie ] khu nwnk Ab Et hir gj ijau hohu shwie ]53] [/gurbani] when you do bhagti your body will get weaker and a bhagat would put his faith in guru sahib to take care of them

Re: body building

G · 07 Feb 2006

G-Singh, I believe that's a gross misinterpretation of bani...please read the context. WJKK WJKF

Re: body building

ekta · 07 Feb 2006

a singh needs muscle 2 wheel around an ak47....

Re: body building

Bir Rasi · 08 Feb 2006

how about taking protein? like i have checked the ingrediants for meat products and buy a brand that is perfectly veg. it is ISO Whey it is a concentrated form of protein that goes right to the muscles. i was just curious though, can sangat see any comprimise of rehit in taking these? i mean fine you can get protein from nuts and daal, but from reading books from trainers they tell you that taking this protien righttttt after a work out is best. just wondering...

Re: body building

LS · 08 Feb 2006

What is the view on public displays of Body building for men and women. A Punjabi newspaper has an advert for this happening in the Punjab, with women in swimsuits.

Re: body building

LionKing (LK) · 08 Feb 2006

I agree, does thta mean we shoulnd't care about our body? We shouldn't practise gatka and stay in form? (although I don't, i realise we should =P)

Re: body building

Prabhjoyt Singh · 08 Feb 2006

As long as you dont take any stereriods its ok

Re: body building

Ravinder Singh · 08 Feb 2006

Well said veer BirRaas Singh ji. Most people bodybuild for their bodies to look good (leading to excess ego), but a gursikh should excercise for functional strength (to stay tyar par tyar) in case Guru sahib gives him any physical seva to do.

Re: body building

unreal · 08 Feb 2006

Body weight excercises are great as a component of working out but I strongly believe a weight lifting program, in one form or another, is essential to maximizing both functional and aesthetic results. Such a program would include not only bodybuilding type excercises for body composition but powerlifting and olympic lifts for raw strength, power and speed. No matter which way you look at it, the greatest athletes in the world, be they sprinters, wrestlers, decatheletes, mixed martial artists, all include weight lifting in their training regimes. Fact of the matter is, after a while, your own body simply isn't enough resistance anymore - there is no strength gain in being able to do 400 pushups as opposed to 200 pushups. On the other hand, being able to clean and press 400lbs as opposed to 200lbs relates to a huge gain! BirRaas Singh wrote: > I would suggest rather then doing the gora style bodybuilding, > Sikhs should commit themselves to Indian style mehanta. This > include the classic behtak, dand, bal-leh, and overall waryam. > Ask any old babeh about these if you dont know what they are. > > Western bodybuilding leads to excess of mass and muscles which > restrict movement and comprimise flexibility. Whereas Indian > style relies on working against your own bodyweight to provide > natural resistance, leading to a slimmer, flexible, and > proportional body frame.

Re: body building

unreal · 08 Feb 2006

Ego is a mental 'thing' - that is why you see it in both the strong and the frail, regardless of whether they work out. Many people enjoy the discipline and ability to change their bodies by working out and I do not think there is anything wrong with this - in my opinion, it's far better than resigning oneself to a gut and toothpick arms. Please don't paint everyone with the same brush. Unless you're trying to make the point that having a lean, muscular physique is inherently "wrong". Ravinder Singh wrote: > Well said veer BirRaas Singh ji. > Most people bodybuild for their bodies to look good (leading to > excess ego), but a gursikh should excercise for functional > strength (to stay tyar par tyar) in case Guru sahib gives him > any physical seva to do.

Re: body building

!!!!!! · 08 Feb 2006

WJKK WJKF singhs and kaurs the puratin singhs did workout so that there body would be able to take the weight of carying shastars and they did this with body weight exercises like all the singhs, for example baba deep singh ji, were built and they only did bodywieght exercises. ofcourse if u want to get quick results it is ok to use dumbels and all that equipment but for the poor people like das its better to use bodyweight instead. just make sure u dont use any sterariods or protein stuff k? WJKK WJKF

Re: body building

unreal · 08 Feb 2006

Use whatever is available to you but I would not describe bodyweight excercises as "better" but as something to be used in conjunction with weights. If you don't have access to weights, then definitely, continue doing bodyweight excercises. There is this misconception that all things older must be better - this is not true. Puratan Singhs were limited by their circumstances as to how they could and could not train and they were also limited by the knowledge available at the time. Today, coaches and strength atheletes are much more knowledgeable about fitness than at any period in the past. Use all the tools available to you - don't ignore them simply because they weren't available to puratan Singhs. !!!!!! wrote: > WJKK WJKF > > singhs and kaurs > the puratin singhs did workout so that there body would be > able to take the weight of carying shastars and they did this > with body weight exercises like all the singhs, for example > baba deep singh ji, were built and they only did bodywieght > exercises. ofcourse if u want to get quick results it is ok to > use dumbels and all that equipment but for the poor people like > das its better to use bodyweight instead. > > just make sure u dont use any sterariods or protein stuff k? > > WJKK WJKF

Re: body building

Ravinder Singh · 08 Feb 2006

Unreal wrote: >Ego is a mental 'thing' - that is why you see it in both the strong and the frail, regardless of whether they work out. Many people enjoy the discipline and ability to change their bodies by working out and I do not think there is anything wrong with this - in my opinion, it's far better than resigning oneself to a gut and toothpick arms. Please don't paint everyone with the same brush. Unless you're trying to make the point that having a lean, muscular physique is inherently "wrong".< Thankfully i'm not that dumb to imply that ego is found only in the strong. I clearly realize that ego affects us ALL. In my opinion bodybuilding results in positive and negative gains on ones mental state. Gaining confidence is a positive but increased vanity and ego is the negative. I have noticed this in others and experienced it myself. The physical gains are increased strength and size but being too bulky leads to less flexibility, speed and movement. Natural bodyweight excercises (dand/baithak etc) lead to a lean, muscular physique as well as functional strength required for fighting/wrestling.

Re: body building

.... · 08 Feb 2006

"Bir Rasi" ji in response to your question about whey.. ... whey is a milk based protein but in the making rennet is added to it. rennet is derived from cow intestines etc and hence is non vegetarian... i would suggest you go for soy protein... ISO soy is as good in terms of the amount of protein per serving. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: body building

unreal · 08 Feb 2006

Please take no offense but this is a very, very broad generalization you have made - so broad, that it is, in my opinion, without merit. Moreover, the fact remains, elite athletes who train for speed, strength and agility lift weights. These athletes include world class sprinters, olympic wrestlers, pro football running backs, all-around sportsmen like decatheletes, judo practitioners, hockey players, full-contact mixed martial artists and the list goes on.............. All of the above need strength along with speed, agility, explosive power. That these elite amatuer and professional athletes all lift weights in their training regimes is a big HINT. Take a look at sprinters who squat 500, 600lbs to increase starting speed or wrestlers who do cleans and snatches to increase their speed and explosive power for throws. That is the use of weights to increase functional strength. Believe it or not, free-body pushups and squats are limited in this regard. After a certain point, all you are doing is increasing muscular endurance and there are very little gains to be made regarding strength and explosive power. (With the exception of plyometrics; however, even with plyometrics, most coaches don't recommend athletes start the more difficult excercises until they can squat 1.5 to 2 times their own body weight). Are bodyweight excercises good? Yes, many athletes include them in training. Are they all that is needed? Depends. If all you want is an 'ok' physique with 'ok' athletic gains, then they are fine. If you want to add muscular size to your frame, if you want to be as strong as you possibly can be, if you want to reach the highest levels of athleticism your body is capable of, then bodyweight excercises are not enough - you must include some form of weight training.

Re: body building

ekta · 08 Feb 2006

whats wrong iwth protien? u eat protien in food ne ways? this is so ghetto saying these things. one thing, i am a bodybuilder.... DO NOT EXPECT HUGE RESULTS FAST. results are slow and steady, like 10-20lbs a year gain in muscle, that to with a perfect diet.... if u want to build muscle for men, u should look at taking in atleast 1.5grams of protien per body lb. Now not allt hat protien should come from shakes....meat (if ur aeater dont' change topic) dalla etc. are good sources what ever floats ur boat. creatine can also be used, nothing wrong with it, just increases ur energy level and water level, water increases the rate at which protien synthsises. thnx

Re: body building

amarjeet singh · 09 Feb 2006

unreal there are plenty more imprtant things then weights please. i wouldnt say doin weights is rong but u dont need to do weights at all. ur tym can b betta spent. doin weights isnt really gonna help ur kamai now is it.

Re: body building

. · 09 Feb 2006

take a look at the mentality of some of these athletes ie the new lightweight pakistani boxer in england, down to earth humble simple and always wanting to learn. I do not understand why some singhs feel training gives more ego. there is a world of difference for some reason between people and why they train. The gyms i have frequented i have found guys blac k white indian pakistani to be really brill compared to apney boys training in gurdwara gyms who like to have the ego over each other probably due to excessive punjabi culture and upbringing.

Re: body building

singh · 09 Feb 2006

Also supplements help as well, but can be expensive and you MUST makesure they contail completely vegetarian ingredients and obviously no form of illegal steroids as they are not natural supplements! But protein is a MUST as it helps with growth and recovery and your body doesnt hurt as much, creatine is also a good add with protein but again makesure it is a fully vegetarian one nd not the animal based.

Re: body building

singh... · 09 Feb 2006

i am yet to see a truly naam abhiyaasi bodybuilder.

Re: body building

unreal · 09 Feb 2006

amarjeet singh, This topic has nothing to do with what is going to help your kamai; the topic is weight-lifting and physical fitness. Spending time on an internet forum, and going off topic at that, isn't going to help your kamai now, is it? :) (I say this in good humour - don't take any offense.)

Re: body building

amarjeet singh · 09 Feb 2006

true unreal, true indeed. but i spend a lot less tym on internet then u wud have 2 spend on weights to get built up. theres no need. this website is a sikhi forum so kamai always has a place

Re: body building

unreal · 09 Feb 2006

You seem to be implying lifting weights and kamai can't go together. I would argue, it's much easier to do simran while working out than it is while debating/discussing on the internet....Just like its easier to do simran while doing physical work/activities than it is by doing more academically/intellectually challenging activities. Moreover, when a gursikh has a couple hundred pounds resting on his back and his legs start shaking, and knees start to buckle, believe me, his silent naam japna becomes a loud naam japna as he pushes the weight up - WAHEGURU!!!!! :) Strong spirit, strong mind, strong body - ideal for a Sikh.

Re: body building

BirRaas Singh · 09 Feb 2006

It really depends on WHY you train, for what reason and what your intended goal is. Not every goal or physique is ideal for every individual. I have personally done both, weightlifting for 4 yrs, and Waryam for 1 year, and i definitly feel much more healthy by doing just Waryam. Physical mass dies with age, a healthy body doesnt.

Re: body building

unreal · 09 Feb 2006

While I agree with your statement that it "depends" on why you train, your last statement makes no sense. "Physical mass dies with age, a healthy body doesn't" Of course it does! Unless you're telling me healthy bodies live forever.... As one ages, the whole body starts to break down, strength, size, stamina everything begins to "die" or weaken. Health in general becomes more fragile with age - everything from circulation, to bone density - ever wonder why older people end up breaking their hips more often than younger people? And in direct contrast to what you are implying, resistance training is one of the very best things to do as one gets older! There is a huge amount of scientific research out there on the benefits of weight lifting as one gets older. I strongly urge everyone to try and get their moms, dads, and grandparents to start a weight lifting program. (And start lifting yourselves as well if you aren't already.) Take a look at the following article, "Growing Stronger - Strength Training for Older Adults: Why Strength Training?" on the Center for Disease Control and Prevention: http://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dnpa/physical/growing_stronger/why.htm And if you get the time, check out the following articles: American College of Sports Medicine. Current Comment: Exercise and the Older Adult. Indianapolis, IN, July 2000. www.acsm.org/pdf/COA.pdf. Evans, W. "Functional and Metabolic Consequences of Sarcopenia." J. Nutr. 127:998S-1003, 1997. Evans, WJ. "Reversing sarcopenia: How weight training can build strength and vitality." Geriatrics 1996:51 (May):46-53. Evans, WJ. Cyr-Campbell, D. "Nutrition, exercise and healthy aging." J Am Diet Assoc. 1997:97:632-638. Hagerman, FC. Seamus, JW. Staron, RS. Hikida, RS. Gilders, Rm. Murray, TF. Toma, K. Ragg, KE. "Effects High-Intensity Resistance Training on Untrained Older Men." I. Strength, Cardiovascular and Metabolic Responses. Journal of Gerontology: BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES 2000, Vol. 55A. No. 7. B336-B346. July 2000. Perrig-Chiello, P, Perrig. Ehrsa, R. Staehelin, HB. Krngs, F. "The effects of resistance training on well being and memory in elderly volunteers." Age and Aging. 27:469-476, July 1998. Tufts University Diet & Nutrition Letter, Sep 94, Vol. 12 Issue 7, p6, 2p. W.H. regards, unreal BirRaas Singh wrote: > It really depends on WHY you train, for what reason and what > your intended goal is. Not every goal or physique is ideal for > every individual. I have personally done both, weightlifting > for 4 yrs, and Waryam for 1 year, and i definitly feel much > more healthy by doing just Waryam. Physical mass dies with > age, a healthy body doesnt. [%sig%]

Re: body building

Bir Rasi · 10 Feb 2006

i do use ISO Whey Protein, im a veggie right soo its all good right singho?

Re: body building

amarjeet singh · 10 Feb 2006

unreal, wat im tryin to say. is tht weights dnt matta. from goin on tapoban, i can improve my sikhi, through great posts on gurbani and such. weights dnt improve knowledge of sikhi or sikhi, or ny thing, jus big muscles. hu cares. u seem 2 obsessed with weights. im not sayin training is manmat, im jus saying there more important things. a bit of liftin here and there to keep on shape is fine, but y over do it. wa u tryin 2 b, sum kind of superman?

Re: body building

unreal · 10 Feb 2006

amarjeet singh....for lack of a better word, wow - nothing says class like personal attacks. But you might be right in what you say....... ....after all, anyone who works out or has knowledge about proper training must obviously be trying to be "sum kind of superman" (good God). Do not automatically equate knowledge with obsession and don't be threatened by knowledge either. Whenever someone has more knowledge than me on a subject, I take that as an opportunity to learn and try my best to learn as much as I can from that person. On this particular subject, I happen to have a good deal of theoretical and practical knowledge - instead of being defensive and trying to paint weight-training as 'useless', try to learn - I would be happy to share what I know with you or anyone else....... .....because the fact of the matter is, weight training is excellent for the body and the concept of 'tyar par tyar' makes it a requirement for us to maintain physical fitness. amarjeet singh wrote: > unreal... u seem 2 obsessed with weights. > ....wa u tryin 2 b, sum kind of superman? [%sig%]

Re: body building

in moderation... · 10 Feb 2006

light weight training is good to keep the body strong and in shape. HOWEVER excessive training for increased muscle mass and excessive, frankly un-natural and un-healthy protein intake, or using protein supplements, is not what guru sahib wanted. if you are going to do this you may as well use steroids etc i see no difference. your natural healthy diet of daal, subzi, plenty of fresh fruit and water should be an adequate supply of protein and nutrients for your training and if it is not then you have to rethink why you are training in the first place. bruce lee was extremely strong and an excellent fighter (he did incorporate weights in his routine i believe?) yet his muscles in terms of size were not large at all. so guru sahib knows at the end of the day if you are doing these weights to stay tyaar-bar-tyaar and healthy or if you had some side intentions of looking more attractive - when you flexed your bicep/chest muscle infront of the mirror and thought no one saw you - guru sahib certainly did! in that case, it is complete manmat.

Re: body building

amarjeet singh · 10 Feb 2006

im sure u have waaaaaaaaaaaay more knowledge then me about weights. maybe it is excellent for body but is it excellent for the mind? ny ways i dnt wanna argue anymore bhai sahib unreal so you continue with your weights, and lets just hope we never get into a fight, bcos im very scinny and im sure u with you 8 pac and all that, would knok me out no problems

Re: body building

??????????? · 10 Feb 2006

hahaha yeh true amarjeet singh... watch out there! also... i agree wiv amarjeet singh, not sayin trainin is manmat nd it is gud 2 be strong khalsas... so we can stick up 4 oursleves nd sikhi... eg.. doin gatka nd training but dont let it take over ur lives... dont let it get in the way of ur sikhi... its not as important.. but yehh dont be weak ppl that get thrown around nd cnt do anythin when sum1 mocks sikhi... we need warriors in the panth 2! saint-soldiers!! but become saints first....

Re: body building

unreal · 10 Feb 2006

Dear 'in moderation': I don't see how you can know what guru sahib wanted or did not want re weight-lifting. What is excessive for one person is not excessive for another and, frankly, I see your comparison of steroids as a gross exaggeration. What is the difference in old-time wreslters drinking litres of milk, pounds of yogurt to get protein as opposed to drinking protein shakes (as long as they are vegetarian)? Then you say protein shakes are unhealthy - on what basis? How is it unhealthy? Is there research backing this statement? Unless you are solely subsisting on protein shakes, they can be a great addition to a healthy diet. Re Bruce Lee - according to his own workout journal, overall, he was not extremely strong. He had a relatively weak squat and a weak press. However, he was in the top 1 or 2% when it came to curling strength.... There is this false impression amongst forumites here that weight-lifting ends up producing bloated physiques - this is incorrect. If you look at olympic lifters who compete in lower weight classes, you'll note that they are extremely strong, have great physiques, without looking like pro bodybuiliders. The same holds true for sprinters, boxers, and wrestlers (in restricted weight classes). in moderation... wrote: > light weight training is good to keep the body strong and in > shape. HOWEVER excessive training for increased muscle mass and > excessive, frankly un-natural and un-healthy protein intake, or > using protein supplements, is not what guru sahib wanted. if > you are going to do this you may as well use steroids etc i see > no difference. > bruce lee was extremely strong and an excellent fighter (he did > incorporate weights in his routine i believe?) yet his muscles > in terms of size were not large at all. so guru sahib knows at > the end of the day if you are doing these weights to stay > tyaar-bar-tyaar and healthy or if you had some side intentions > of looking more attractive - when you flexed your bicep/chest > muscle infront of the mirror and thought no one saw you - guru > sahib certainly did! in that case, it is complete manmat.

Re: body building

G-Singh · 10 Feb 2006

If you truly want to be tyar bar tyar do as kamaiee as possible, Leave your hopes on guru sahib and dont let any dhils creep into your rehit. You'll get all the shaktis this way and MUCH, MUCH more. If you think purataan singhs were able to fight the way they did cuz of muscle mass or working out, you are horribly mistaken. Even if they were fairly strong (a jatt in punjab back in the would have been strong), having muscle mass isnt what wins you wars that your outnumbered 20 to 1. Faith and pyaar for guru sahib is what helps you. Jis kaa sahib dad hoe tis no maar na sakai koe Guru sahib will always take care oh his bhagats, so if you have dont your bhagti, you'll get the rest of the shakteean without a problem. Sant gyanee jarnail singh jee, bhai amrik singh ji, and other soormay of the 80's, how much did they work out, but still they able to wage quite a battle just thru their kamaee.

Re: body building

unreal · 10 Feb 2006

Dear amarjeet singh, I'm also pretty sure I have waaaaaaaaaaaaay more knowledge than you :) This is not a matter of haumai, it seems to be an obvious fact. I am sure you have waaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more knowledge than me on many other topics (and this is when I would try to learn from you instead of hiding defensively behind shallow humour and ad hominem attacks). And yes, it can be excellent for the mind. In case you missed it, I suggest you scroll up and read the article on older people working out and the positive benefits on memory. Moreover, while I can't recall the exact study, I recall there being research showing the positive benefits of excercise on depressed individuals. Furthermore, the positive benefits of weight training on overall energy are backed up in many studies. This is in addition to increased self-esteem and the sense of accomplishment from reaching certain targets and improving personal bests... Regaring your being very skinny - thats ok - if you're really and truly happy being skinny and are healthy otherwise, then that is fine. However, if you want to become stronger, faster, and develop more explosive power, I suggest weights. Regarding my beating you up, what a sad, sad statement. Whether I can beat you up or not, is neither here nor there - it is a non-issue. You have now sunk to personal attacks (hidden behind the thin veneer of false humility) instead of attacking the argument itself. Bravo! MOREOVER, you indicate you would be beaten up because you are very skinny ------- there is nothing wrong with being skinny but if you believe this is the reason I, or anyone else, could beat you up, then it is your duty as Sikh to remedy that problem. Guru ji's Singh's should be tyar par tyar - and that means physically as well. If you feel that you are so skinny that you cannot fight properly, then you need to start eating more and hitting the gym to remedy this problem. regards, unreal amarjeet singh wrote: > im sure u have waaaaaaaaaaaay more knowledge then me about > weights. maybe it is excellent for body but is it excellent for > the mind? > ny ways i dnt wanna argue anymore bhai sahib unreal so you > continue with your weights, and lets just hope we never get > into a fight, bcos im very scinny and im sure u with you 8 pac > and all that, would knok me out no problems

Re: body building

unreal · 10 Feb 2006

G-Singh, I don't disagree with you that kamaiee is the core foundation but that does not mean we don't actively to try to improve our situation. If what you say is true, why did puratan Singhs practice gatka? Why pick up the sword at all - why not just put all hopes in Guru ji? The answer is, all hopes were always in Guru ji and that is what enabled the Singhs to fight; however, Singhs were expected to help themselves physically as well. If this wasn't true, puratan Singhs would not have trained in wrestling, in swordsmanship, in archery and in horsemanship. If the above held true then, the same holds true today - tyar par tyar includes a physical element. The argument that puratan Singhs didn't work out is flawed on several levels: 1. There are many things we do today that puratan Singhs were not able to do - this is a function of changing times and advancing technology. If we're going to hold true to only what puratan Singhs did, none of us should speak in English, drive cars, fly in airplanes or use the internet. 2. There is no indication puratan Singhs would not have used weights if they had access to them and the time to utilize them to increase their physical abilities. 3. Today, we have much more knowledge than puratan Singhs did in many different fields. This includes physics, chemistry, medicine, dentistry, nutrition, engineering, and yes, fitness as well. Muscle mass is one benefit of lifting weights, not the only one. Also consider strength and explosive power. Again, by comparing Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji and other shaheeds, you are comparing apples with oranges: 1. Sant ji and the shaheeds did not have the time or the freedom to work out - they were being hunted and were fighting for their lives. 2. There is no indication Sant ji and the shaheeds wouldn't have worked out if they had the time and freedom and knew of its benefits. 3. Sant ji and the shaheeds most likely did not know as much about physical fitness as many of the researchers and coaches in the field today. 4. When you are called to defend yourself or someone else who is being picked on or bullied, do you intend to cut off their head with a sword, or blast them away with an AK-47? Neither of course! You will have to use the physical abilities which you have at your disposal and weight lifting (along with training in the fighting arts) is what will help you, the same way training in gatka helped the puratan Singhs. It just blows my mind that there are so many people on this forum who are getting defensive about weight-lifting? No one has made the argument you must work out 8 hours a day, 7 days a week; no one is saying you must focus all your time on working out and fitness. So why this defensiveness? Is it because of a laziness to actually work out? Is it because we are comfortable being weak and don't want to put in the effort to get stronger? No matter which way you look at, working out is a great benefit to the body and that is the bottom line. I don't see why something which is so beneficial is being looked down upon.

Re: body building

khalistani · 10 Feb 2006

i agree 100 percent with unreal bhula chuka maf

Re: body building

Ravinder Singh · 11 Feb 2006

What has bodybuilding got to do with being tyar par tyar? If you're talking about being tyar par tyar for a physical encounter then the only attribute a bodybuilder has is strength. Strength alone will not win a fight. Skill, speed, agility, guts and most importantly.. strength of spirit are needed for a fight. Your spirit is strengthened through being mentally tough. How do we become mentally tough? By fighting with our mind 24/7. Battling with and keeping control over the 5 enemies within. Keeping our rehat solid no matter what hardships we face. Japping Naam with pyaar, athay-pehar, with every swaas. These are the qualities that will make us a tyar par tyar soora. Bodybuilding will mentally weaken us because our dhiaan is not within us, it is outside.. on our bodily apearance. It will make us always conscious of ourselves not god conscious.. making us vainly look in the mirror all the time, want to wear the best (usually tight) clothes etc. This is not the way of the Gurmukh.

Re: body building

Ravinder Singh · 11 Feb 2006

There isn't anything wrong with lifting weights for a while to gain a bit of extra strength, but bodybuilding is a different ball game.

Re: body building

.. · 11 Feb 2006

i agree totally with unreal . i think we should learn from him . veer ji , i m 19 yrs old very skinny person , i have been working out in the gym since last 4 weeks , my strength has increased little but becus i can lift more weights now. but my weight is still the same 125 ponds . i can see c my bicep grown a half inch more . do u have any advice for me ? how to increase my mass. i m pretty sure that Guru Gobind Singh ji will be happy when he look at his singhs and see them being strong not mere weaklings . obviously humilty , naam kamai , nimrata is also required with this . and i have noticed one more thing . being free from kaam or lust is very important in building strength . i u mess up one day the next day u won;t be able to lift tht much weight . am i right ?

Re: body building

unreal · 11 Feb 2006

Now I'm just repeating myself.....please read the above thread properly. Also, if you take the time to read the thread properly, you'll note the emphasis has been on lifting weights, not some form of bodybuilding. Although, anyone who works out consistently with weights will end up looking muscular. Your comment about bodybuilding weakening the mind is quite baseless - first, the topic is weight lifting, not bodybuilding. Second, if you have anything outside of your opinion re weightlifting weakening the mind, please post it. And, ultimately, I think you are wrong. Physical fitness is an important component of being tyar par tyar and weightlifting is excellent for increasing physical fitness. I'm not going to repeat myself - read the above posts on gatka, ak47's etc for a more thorough analysis of this point.

Re: body building

unreal · 11 Feb 2006

No offense meant, but your comment illustrates your lack of knowledge regarding physical fitness. You cannot just lift for a while to gain a bit of extra strength -- as soon as you stop, your strength will start to fade. Moreover, why would you want to go half-way? If you're going to do something, do it properly. Why settle for a bit of strength and not try to be as strong as possible? Again, it blows my mind that so many people are so dead-set against working out despite all of the positive benefits. And all that is being offered in argument is foundation-less opinion. If you don't work out, don't like to, are too lazy to work out, whatever your reason, fine, don't work out. BUT please don't try to ridiculously justify your own personal choice with some "its against Sikhi because I say it is" argument. This is a disservice to all the readers because research shows weighlifting provides for great positive benefits. Whats next folks? I guess running should also be on the hitlist: Don't do any running Sikhs! Because while it improves your heart, it also gives you, OH THE HORROR!, shapely and strong legs, firms your butt and lowers your bodyfat and we should avoid those benefits at all costs! And did Sant Jarnail Singh ji and the Shaheeds go for jogs? Huh - did they? Of course they didn't so we shouldn't either. We should do our best to remain physically weak and even more importantly, we should LOOK weak to everyone else. So when someone says or does something to us or others, we can raise our weak arms and say "hey you, stop it! otherwise I'll hit you with my tidh" Ravinder Singh wrote: > There isn't anything wrong with lifting weights for a while to > gain a bit of extra strength, but bodybuilding is a different > ball game.

Re: body building

Admin · 11 Feb 2006

This topic is now closed.