Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

geting marriage twice

geting marriage twice

po singh · 01 Feb 2006

can gursikh get marriaged twice??????????????

Re: geting marriage twice

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Feb 2006

can and should are two different things mate !! SHOULD a GURSIKH get married twice ? Getting married twice is POLYGAMY and punishable by Civil law in almost all countries worldwide. Getting a Divorce and then getting married again...again is NOT as per GURMAT. Anand Karaj in Guru Ji's Presence is only ONCE - if this chance is blown...??? Get married again..ONLY if your spouse DIED.....and you still "NEED" one. The rest is up to you....CAN ?? or NOT ?? BUT GURBANI doesnt support it. Jarnail Singh

Re: geting marriage twice

D Kaur · 01 Feb 2006

A gursikh is allowed to remarry under certain circumstances. If they just want to remarry for the sake of it, then that is against Sikhi.

Re: geting marriage twice

bebeiki · 01 Feb 2006

bhand mooya bhand bhalueyaa when one's singhani dies, he can marry if he want otherwise better would be if spent rest of the life in the service of Khalsa Panth because he has already finished his married life. Now if at all he find it difficult to carry on alone, he can marry but he should marry to a needy widow so as to be needful and resonable. If some a gursikh is in seperation or divorce, he should not marry. But if he has kids in addition, he must not marry in any case because he has responsiblity on his shoulder which no other person should share with him rest of his life to fulfill his gristh obligation as per gurmat bebeik.

Re: geting marriage twice

singh · 01 Feb 2006

yes, guru gobind singh ji did.

Re: geting marriage twice

priceless · 01 Feb 2006

singh wrote: > yes, guru gobind singh ji did. good. shabash. thori kasar baki hai. sab kuch keh deo ji guru gobind singh ji deeyaan do gharvaliaan, oh mass khade si, phim te bhang da sevan bee karde si .... kuch sharam hai baki

Re: geting marriage twice

Rehat Maryada · 01 Feb 2006

Anand Karaj is a precious ceremony blessed in the presence of Guru Sahib. How is it possible to nullify the Anand Karaj and remarry without consulting Him, i.e. without the permission of the Panj Pyare. DKaur what do you consider 'certain circumstances'? I believe that remarrying if one's Singh/Singhni has passed away, or left his/her Sikhi may be permissible. However, divorcing/remarrying due to bad feelings/misunderstanding could be very costly at the spiritual level (here & beyond). In the latter case, unless the Panj Pyare feel it fit to permit a divorce (and let's face it how many would carry that burden on their shoulders), it's quite likely that it would be seen as polygamy in the eyes of God. I agree with you Bebeki that especially if one has children, the primary responsibility is to nurture the soul(s) you have been blessed with. I cetainly have not come across the concept of divorce/remarrying in any of Bhai Randhir Singhs books. It is not in keeping with Bibek rehat if the partner has not deceased/or left Sikhi.

Re: geting marriage twice

LK · 02 Feb 2006

Getting a Divorce and then getting married again...again is NOT as per GURMAT. Anand Karaj in Guru Ji's Presence is only ONCE - if this chance is blown...??? Get married again..ONLY if your spouse DIED.....and you still "NEED" one. The rest is up to you....CAN ?? or NOT ?? BUT GURBANI doesnt support it. ************************ If some a gursikh is in seperation or divorce, he should not marry. But if he has kids in addition, he must not marry in any case because he has responsiblity on his shoulder which no other person should share with him rest of his life to fulfill his gristh obligation as per gurmat bebeik. **************** I disagree with you and agree with - ************** Author: D Kaur Date: 02-01-06 15:37 A gursikh is allowed to remarry under certain circumstances. If they just want to remarry for the sake of it, then that is against Sikhi. ************** Although these certain circumstances are rare they do exist Do you suggest that wifes that are raped by their husbands (i.e agianst their will) just tolerate it and live their life under oppression? DO you suggest wifes that are abused by (punjabi) men stay oppressed and live under "dabao"? Sikhs have been taught to stand up against oppression. If someone oppresses you begin by tolerating and adjusting. If theres not change in the person, a diveroce is acceptable - Guru Ji is not a rigid block of stone, with rigidi rules - he wouldn't prefer you stay and get abused rather than getting diveroced and fine someone else...

Re: geting marriage twice

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 02 Feb 2006

Guru Gobind Singh Ji also sacrificed his father, mother, four beautiful Sons..? How many have you mr. singh ?? And for your info that is a DIRTY low down LIE. Guru Ji married only ONCE as per GURBANI. He wouldnt be double mouthed and do soemthing but say soemthing else. Jarnail singh.

Re: geting marriage twice

moorakh · 02 Feb 2006

what if you have been married (anand karaj) and then your partner leaves you for no reason whatsoever (there is a reason but maya related). partner wants a divorce and won't come back. does this allow the other partner to re-marry? we are both still young in our late 20's. i have tried everything possible to resolve the situation but to no avail. one interesting fact my partner has said that they are aware of what they are doing and will accept any (spiritual) punishment received. does this make it doubly worse for them because they know what they are doing? as you can see they have totally lost the plot sikhi wise. we have no children. i agree with everything which has been said by sangat. marriage is a one time thing. not something which can be jumped into and out of when it does and doesn't suit us.

Re: geting marriage twice

confused · 02 Feb 2006

i am on my second marriage, the firt marriage failed because the girl just wanted to remain friends and failed to grasp the concept of man and wife. I have since divorced and re-married and my wife is the best thing thats ever happened to me. I have stopped eating meat and started to grow my beard. I am more into Sikhi. How does this apply to the comments in the above post? Because of my divorce I am more into gurmat and sikhi. WGJKWGJKF

Re: geting marriage twice

D Kaur · 02 Feb 2006

Rehat Maryada, certain circumstances such as if a spouse passes away or if a spouse leaves and falls out of gurmat. But LK has made a good point. What if a lady gets abused by her husband over and over again. She later divorces him and is now Single and a single parent of a infant and is living alone without parents or anyone else. Is she to survival and support herself and the child all alone? How would she work and take care of her infant who needs 24 hour care?

Re: geting marriage twice

LionKing (LK) · 02 Feb 2006

i agree with above comments, there is no reason why a divorce shoudl be condemned in above mentioned circumstances (all all measures of trying to staying together have been used)

Re: geting marriage twice

Sukhdev Singh · 02 Feb 2006

VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheGuruJeeKeeFateh D Kaur wrote : "But LK has made a good point. What if a lady gets abused by her husband over and over again. She later divorces him and is now Single and a single parent of a infant and is living alone without parents or anyone else. Is she to survival and support herself and the child all alone? How would she work and take care of her infant who needs 24 hour care?" This is not a very good arguement or reason for remarriage. A GurSikh should practice Gurmat even if it means hardship for themselves. My mother in law never got married again after her husband took Shaheedee in April 1978. My wife was only 6 months old & her sister was only a year older. She incurred alot of hardship bringing up the kids but didn't even consider remarriage. I and alot of others respect & praise her actions. She was not the only one there were alot of wifes of Shaheed Singhs that did not re-marry. There were some that did but I don't think their decision are much praised but they are not put down either because they were unable to take the hardship. The bottom line is re-marriage is a weakness and if someone is strong enough they should resist. Bhul Chuck Maaf Karnee VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheGuruJeeKeeFateh

Re: geting marriage twice

LionKing (LK) · 02 Feb 2006

Sukhdev Singh ji, although it was a personal decision of your mother in law not to get re-married it is ABSOLUTELY NOT banned by Guru Ji do the female to get remarried. Guru Amardas JI encouraged it. There is not reason it should be considered as a weakness. It would be the same as stating that marriage IS ALL about weakness, if rearriage is abut weakness. i do have a lot of respect for your mother in law for her decision, however it needs to be realised it was her personal decision, and not something the Guru had forced her to do. It's not abour resisting of kaam or anthing like that, but if marriage is about getting sangat - someoen to do Simran with. Someone to do Paath with. SOmeone to inspire children with- then that is EXACTLY what remarriage is about - and IMHO it would thus be erronous to say that remarraige is a weakness bhull chukk maaf

Re: geting marriage twice

confused · 02 Feb 2006

i am on my second marriage, the firt marriage failed because the girl just wanted to remain friends and failed to grasp the concept of man and wife. I have since divorced and re-married and my wife is the best thing thats ever happened to me. I have stopped eating meat and started to grow my beard. I am more into Sikhi. How does this apply to the comments in the above post? Because of my divorce I am more into gurmat and sikhi. WGJKWGJKF Please can somebody explain the above circumstance. Am i in the wrong? [%sig%]

Re: geting marriage twice

Gurpreet Sumra · 02 Feb 2006

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh, Whatever is written or has been delibrately written or forced into our history about the marriage of Guru Sahibs is not per Gurmat. I am not ready to believe that Guru Sahib preached something and practiced something else.The fault lies in us we just listen to famous Kirtaniyas and kathavachaks and never try to read ourself where this sort of history is written, who wrote it?, what was his religion? under whose regime was it written? if he was a sikh was he influenced by some other school of thoughts? All these points has to be kept in mind before reading any history, Beacuse Sikhs were busy fighting against injustice and living in jungles and there Gurdwaras and history at the same time was being played with. Second point, we have Guru Granth Sahib ji , if anything seems in contradiction to its teachings we should try to figure out.I want to ask how many of you have ever questioned any kirtaniya or kathawachak telling fairytales?Why dont we confront them in a polite manner, they will themselves stop it then. About a month or two ago a very famous kirtaniya was in Dixie Gurdwara in Mississauga, he was telling story of Guru Nanak sahib and phulka by bebe nanki, my friend went to him after kirtan and asked him he said guru nanak dev ji used to do bhavishyavanis(forecast) and when he asked about phulka thing bhai sahib ji said" eh gallan baith ke karan waliya ne". Anyways about marriage : In old days Raja maharaja used to have many wives , even so called Gods have thousands wives and having many wives was considered as a status symbol. Guru sahibs has more then 2 wives has been written basically because of two reasons: 1) To praise Guruji as I already stated it was considered as status symbol, so whoever poet or writer was may be he has this thing in mind. 2)To degrade Guruji as it is clear in Bala janamsakhi. In Bala janamsakhi Guru Nanak Sahib has two wives.In other Granths Guru Gobind Singh ji and Guru Hargobind Sahib ji has been shown with 2-3 wives. Gurbilas Patshahi 6win which was presented as a gift by Joginder Singh Vedanti to Sikhs ,thanks to Sikhs of Guru Granth and Guru Panth SGPC banned it says that Kaulaan was the keep(rakhail)of Guru Hargobind Sahib. The third reason is that Guru Hargobind sahib and Guru Gobind Singh ji's wives names were different in their parents house and were given different names in Gurughar. Guru harGobind sahib's wife's name was Mata Damodari but she was renamed as Mata Nanaki.In the same way Guru Gobind Singh ji's wife's name was Mata Jeeto ji but was known as Mata Sundri in Guru Ghar may be because of her beauty. Some people dont agree, for them I have a humble request that our opponents are very cunning and clever they are not at all naive or novice. Keeping Gurbani in front of us we can only say that our Guru sahibs married only once. Kaulaan and Mata Sahib Kaur are Singhnis of Guru Sahib who embraced Sikhism against the wishes of their family. Gurfateh Note: Some points borrowed from Gurmat Niranya Kosh(Dr. Gursharanjeet Singh) [%sig%]

Re: geting marriage twice

Simple Singhani · 02 Feb 2006

WJKK WJKF no ur not, your on the right path ''confused'' . As long as you tried as hard as you could to keep the other marriage together. why couldn't you have become more into sikhi in your first marriage? did u ask your wife weather she wanted to take the sikh way of life? why is it different to this marriage? hmm.. bhull chukk maaf WJKK WJKF

Re: geting marriage twice

singh · 02 Feb 2006

The remarriage of a widow or widower is encouraged in Sikhism. The Anand Marriage Act, 1909, gave a wife status equal to that of her husband. The marriage establishes a permanent relationship between the partners and there is no provision for a divorce under this Act. The only reasonable excuse to violate this contract should be case of extreme abuse and in that case also after long period of unsuccessful efforts to fix the problem by staying together. The worst case to get remarried would be if there were child of marriage. The child will suffer and it would be a great injustice. So best thing would be both parents (if can not live together in any case) must agree to make an arrangement to the best possible and stable upbringing of the child. The better option would be if father give the sole custody to the mother and give all the financial support and positive cooperation so that child is not suffered due to failure of parents. [%sig%]

Re: geting marriage twice

D Kaur · 02 Feb 2006

Sukhdev Singh ji, I gave one scenario, but there are many other ones. That is great that your mother in law was so strong, but everyone is not as strong. The topic is if it is against Sikhi to remarry, and I dont think so. Please tell me what your stand is on this.

Re: geting marriage twice

singh · 02 Feb 2006

Sorry to see so many people on this site with such , in my opinion wrong and extreme views (ie your only allowed to do this, you cant do this you cant do that). Thank God that the truth always wins. In the mean time I feel many of the sikhs posting on this site and their children will be challenged by muslims concerning some of these issue, marriage, meat etc and dissolutioned and then converted, it brings alot of pain to the families concerned . But the pain is gift that then makes people change their false beliefs to the truth (which btw i dont claim to know).

Re: geting marriage twice

confused · 03 Feb 2006

WGJKWGJKF Bibi Simple Singhani, thank you. my first wife was full of Maya, wanting to go to nightclubs and in general was not interested in Sikhi, but was more so into Punjabiness. More so she was not ready for marriage and left on her own accord. I was mis-led by her parents. With my wife now she has come from a strong Sikhi background all her family (immediate) are Gursikhs. We talk alot about Sikhi and current affairs and it made me wonder about life and waheguru. Needless to say meeting my wife was the best thing that happened to me and I always thank waheguruji for I am blessed. I hope I have not offended anyone by this post. WGJKWGJKF [%sig%]

Re: geting marriage twice

LionKing (LK) · 03 Feb 2006

******** The better option would be if father give the sole custody to the mother and give all the financial support and positive cooperation so that child is not suffered due to failure of parents. ******** I don't agree, that the mother should get sole custody, as it is an EXTREMELY hard task to raise children on their onw. Please don't give me examples of people who have raised theri children alone - as tha is their choice. A Bibi or Bhai for tha matter should have all right to re-marry without any fuss what so ever.

Re: geting marriage twice

no1 · 03 Feb 2006

i havent got a dad, and my mum raised us by herself. she hasnt remarried and we're all fine. nobodys stopping her, she can if she wants. in this situation i think its ok.

Re: geting marriage twice

Singh · 06 Feb 2006

Conclusion- There is nothing wrong with remarrying!

Re: geting marriage twice

From allaboutsikhs.com · 06 Feb 2006

From allaboutsikhs.com http://allaboutsikhs.com/mansukh/123.htm What is the Sikh attitude to divorce? Sikhism favor family life and monogamy. The ideal family is one where there is mutual love and respect between the husband and the wife and their children and grand children if any. The Anand Marriage Act, 1909, gave a wife status equal to that of her husband. The marriage establishes a permanent relationship between the partners and there is no provision for a divorce under this Act, for the Sikh marriage (Anand Karaj) is a sacrament and not a civil contract. However, in olden times if the marriage broke down, the woman would leave her husband and go and stay with her parents. Nowadays, the partners may live separately, or apply for a divorce after some time, under the Hindu code or the civil marriage Act. At that time, it is for the court to decide to grant a divorce or not, and in case the divorce is decided by the Court, it may make a provision for the support of the woman and the custody of the children and their maintenance. The Sikhs have no Personal Law, but they are covered under the Hindu Code in India. However, in certain cases, the custom of chaddar, which implies the present of a bedsheet by a man to a woman indicating his decision to take her as his wife is legal in Punjab. Generally, grounds like cruelty, adultery, change of religion, suffering from an incurable disease and in some cases incompatibility of temperaments are accepted by Courts for purposes of divorce. A second marriage after divorce is permissible. The remarriage of a widow or widower is encouraged in Sikhism. Under which maryada would a Sikh take divorce becuase there is no Gurmat Maryada for Divorce. There can be a option for a tila sikh but not for bebeiki singh [%sig%]

Re: geting marriage twice

Amazing · 07 Feb 2006

Singh wrote: yes, guru gobind singh ji did. Classic! How do you know Guru Sahib was married twice, three four ... times? were you there at both Guru Sahibs weddings? I bet your great great great........ grandad/grandma/chacha/mama/massur/phuphurs sons, cousins friend brother his sisters nece friends blah de blah blah was present yea! Joker! Think before you type.

Re: geting marriage twice

LionKing (LK) · 07 Feb 2006

*********** Author: From allaboutsikhs.com Date: 02-06-06 20:01 Under which maryada would a Sikh take divorce becuase there is no Gurmat Maryada for Divorce. There can be a option for a tila sikh but not for bebeiki singh ************ So basically, what you're saying is, if the women accepts to be raped and be abused - shes a Bibeki Singhnee? We need to understand that Guru Sahib wasn't stupid. He knew these issues exist yet he decided not to comment on them. He decided not to write - IT IS WRONG TO DIVORCE - instead he allowed it to stay grey, instead of making it black and what - there MUST BE a reason for it. Guru sahib gave us 1430 angs of GURBANI - wisdom words, encouragements, inspiration, telling us to love God, love humanity, to oppose tyranny - yet he didn't say anything abuor divorce? Was he retarded? My Guru was not retarded. My Saajanra did everything for a reason. My Sajjanra decided not to write anything about divorce, he did encourage remarriage after death - he went against every social cutom at the time, byt giving a demorolized people ground to stand on. Are you saying bibis who are abused an raped (which are extreme cases) should not object - and accept it for mutual relationship? In that case Guru Arjan Dev Sahib Ji should not have opposed mughal tyranny, opposing oppression - For mutual relationship of the Guru and government - this would save bloodshed. Guru Sahib did not make everything black and white, therefor there's no reason we as Sikhs should do that either. Extreme cases exists. Guru Sahib did not comment on certain subjects for that exact reason IMHO. Bhull chukk maaf