Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

'Rang De Basanti'

'Rang De Basanti'

Harcharan Singh · 31 Jan 2006

Film criticised for slogans By Hindustan Times and Planet Bollywood Jan 29, 2006, 13:29 A new film 'Rang De Basanti' is one of many that uses religious references to help commercialisation. The main title and song is according to its singer Harshdeep, taken from "an extract of Japji Sahib, the Sikh's morning prayer... It is believed that early morning is the time of God and I actually felt God standing next to me and making me sing," tells Harshdeep. Religious groups believe a line was crossed when an objectionable slogan was placed on the posters of the movie. Both the SGPC and Jathedar of the Sri Damdama Sahib Nandgarh reacted strongly to it. While the posters show Aamir Khan on a horseback, the other side has the lead actors of the movie embracing each other. However, the sikh organisation have taken exception to what is written in Hindi and Punjabi (in bold letters) at the lower side of the poster - "Raj Karega Khalsa." SGPC media secretary G.S. Bedi and Jathedaar of the Sri Damdama Sahib Nandgarh (Talwandi), Balwant Singh have called it a matter of great concern and called for a ban on 'Rang De Basanti' as it amounts to an insult of the sikh community .

Re: 'Rang De Basanti'

LionKing (LK) · 31 Jan 2006

I sense it. They will twist it and say that because Khalsa means pure, we have all right to use the slogan =(

Re: 'Rang De Basanti'

Baldeep Singh · 31 Jan 2006

Are you surprised that they have come back for more to belittle Guru Ke Khalsa? The worst thing is that baffoons like Jassi Bains don Khanda necklaces around their necks, sing pathetic punjabi songs, do their idiotic bhangra moves and act like wannabe gangsters. Are you really astonished that hindus are trying to perceive sikhs to be a bunch of punjabi jesters. Punjabi attitudes and behaviour has had a profound impact on peoples perception of what sikhi is.

Re: 'Rang De Basanti'

A Singh · 01 Feb 2006

From concept point of view "Rang De Basanti" is a very good movie. Harmindar Sahib was shown very well while residing the Japji Sahib in the background. The corruption in the Indian Air Force was also covered very well. The British rule in the movie was always highlight better then the present Indian rule. This is related to the treatment of prisoners and criminals in during the British rule and present Government. The present Indian Government was shown to be far more hostile as compared to the British. This was very well highlighed in the last scene of the film. It was perhaps an indirect portrayl of "Operation Blue Star". It was shown how hostile and cruel is the Indian regiment to people who raise their voice against injustice. The movie was also Anti-BJP and Anti-RSS. The negative part of the film was the role played by Amir Khan. He has been shown as a Clean Shaven Sikh who drinks. Perhaps the reason the few shots of the film were removed, which could have been an insult to the Nihags. It was justified. Another point of observation was that if Amir Khan can grow his hair to play the role of Mangal Panday, then why can't he act as a proper Sikh.

Re: 'Rang De Basanti'

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Feb 2006

Another point of observation was that if Amir Khan can grow his hair to play the role of Mangal Panday, then why can't he act as a proper Sikh. >>>>>>>>>>>>>?? He can..BUT only if the DIRECTOR directs him to do so..he is just paid to do what the director says... KHALSA is NOT "pure" but "SLAVE" or MALKIAAT/PROPERTY... as is amply clear from our Fateh..Waheguru ji Ka kHalsa..Waheguru ji ki fateh. The Khalsa is the Property or slave of waheguru. In Persian/Farsee..any land belonging to the Government is called KHALSA. Thus when Guru Ji left Anadpur Sahib....all their properties were DECLARED "KHALSA"..that is Govt Property. Jehangir issued the same decree on Guru Arjun Ji's Property when Guru Ji was martyred. That is how Darbar Sahib and AAd Granth kartarpuri Bir came to be in Prithiya's hands. Later on Guru hargobind Ji took over and built Akal takhat..but the AAD Granth Ji bir was left with the prithiyas family..and later went to the Dhirmaliayas

Re: 'Rang De Basanti'

D Kaur · 01 Feb 2006

The movie can be as good as it wants. First of all, we should not be watching movie and should be focusing our time doing paath or something Sikhi related. Second, nothing Sikhi related should be in these disgusting movies. These movies give the Sikhs a bad name and also portray Sikhi in a negative way and as something its not. A person who drinks and is a clean shave is not a Sikh. For the directors to portray such is image is revolting. These Hindu Directors are slowly involving the Sikh community into their movies and giving them major roles. Sooner or later they are going to have Sikh’s in their movies dating and doing all the other crap these manmukhs do. As Sikhs, we should not watch such movies; instead take a stand against them.