Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Lareedaar Bir

Lareedaar Bir

Singh · 31 Jan 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! i just wanted to ask, if people say that non-lareedaar is only simplyfied for us so we can read it and understand it and its not the true guru. this means that any bir apart from the one which got gurhiaai from guru gobind singh ji is not a true gur or only "simlpyfied" for us. is this true??? plz help me with this problem wheguru ji ka khalsa waherguru ji ki fateh! [%sig%]

Re: Lareedaar Bir

moorakh · 01 Feb 2006

gurbani is guru so when tapoban say that only lareedar gurbani is guru why do they not pronounce it lareedar? Why do they break it when they read it as it doesnot stay gurbani then?

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Singh · 01 Feb 2006

Even in birs that Singhs have written by hand have mistakes in them. Writing Guru Granth Sahib by hand is a massive seva, obivously there will be mistakes on the way. Therefore any bir with Guru's writing in there is Gurbani no matter if its laReedaar or pad-ched. LaReedaar is just a style of writing, if you look at old rehitnamas hey are written in the same way. I have seen and heard LaReedaar pathis doing paath completely wrong. [%sig%]

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Roopkaur · 01 Feb 2006

>so when tapoban say that only lareedar gurbani is guru why do they not pronounce it lareedar? Why do they break it when they read it as it doesnot stay gurbani then?< What a dumb argument to justify the breaking up of gurbani. The "doing" of paath comes from the fact that you are reading gurbani and seeing where one word ends and another begins. When the paath is turned pad ched, you are no longer "doing" anything, you are simply reading someone else's manipulation of gurbani. >Even in birs that Singhs have written by hand have mistakes in them. Writing Guru Granth Sahib by hand is a massive seva, obivously there will be mistakes on the way. Therefore any bir with Guru's writing in there is Gurbani no matter if its laReedaar or pad-ched. LaReedaar is just a style of writing, if you look at old rehitnamas hey are written in the same way. I have seen and heard LaReedaar pathis doing paath completely wrong.< The hand written mistakes in birs are not done on purpose, however, the pronters who make pad chhed saroops and knowingly breaking up bani, when they know full well that they could be making, and are making a mistake. To larideer is the writing of gurbani, it is not simply another witing style, but THE writing style of gurbani. pad chhed is just trying to copy the punjabi way of writing. Atleast when paathis are doing the wrong paath from laridaar saroop, it is the paathis fault, and not a mistake in bani, but in a pad chhed saroop, are you now going to call guru ji wrong when the paath is split up wrong? It is pathetic to see so many Sikhs selling out on the original saroop of guru ji. Instead of working to create awareness in the quom of what a terrible mistake Sikhs are doing, they themselves put the Laridaar saroop down. Why is it that other dharms, such as Muslims with their Koran, and Jewish people with their Torah, can keep the original form, yet some Sikhs like to be ghulaams and what to say of others putting Sikhs in an inferior position, themselves like to drag themselvevs down.

Re: Lareedaar Bir

D Kaur · 01 Feb 2006

Singh, If you look at all puratan Singhs (from all jathas), they all said that pad ched is manmat. Why is that? If Pad ched was okay, why wouldn't they do parchar of pad ched. It is todays Singhs that are making up excuses and making paath easier for themselves by promoting pad ched and taking a stand against laridaar saroops (our true guru).

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Singh · 02 Feb 2006

wahgeuru ji! Bhenji,.. Guruji never ever stopped us from reading gurbani from pad-ched! He was antarjaami so he could have told us about this as well as he told us about other things?? Singh wrote:

Re: Lareedaar Bir

ji · 02 Feb 2006

isnt the meaning the same in both? i mean there some people that dont even no gurmukhi would they be considerd as manmuks to?? its not about the way it is written but they way u interprate it and put it inot practise

Re: Lareedaar Bir

man · 02 Feb 2006

"laridaar saroops (our true guru)". thought it was Guru granth sahib ji ?? have we got a new guru ??

Re: Lareedaar Bir

D Kaur · 02 Feb 2006

Singh, Guru ji never invented Pad ched saroops. In fact there were no pad ched saroops back in the day, so how would guru ji stop someone from reading pad ched? JI, Those people that don't know how to read gurmukhi should learn. How sad is that, that a person can't even take out time to learn how to read gurmukhi. We are all to busy with watching tv or hanging out with our friends that we can not take 30 mins of our time everyday to learn how to read gurmukhi. I know children that are 7 years old who are able to read from laridaar saroops. Those that don't even know how to read should feel ashamed of themselves. There are many examples of words that are split differently in one pad ched bir than another. Does it not matter if gurbani is written wrong? Man, The word saroop is referred to Sri Guru Granth Sahib. As for my knowledge, gurgandhi was given to a Laridaar saroop (guru granth sahib) and that is my only guru. I know of no other guru!

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Ji · 02 Feb 2006

i dont fink u can say that that because u dont no gurmukhi you should be ashamed of urself... the people that dont no how to read gurmukhi are not from a strong sikhi background n are not taught sikhi in the family but have taken time out to learn about sikhi starting to keep kesh trying to keep rehat etc..n there are some amritdharis that dont no how to read gurmukhi it doesnt mean that their aint real sikh. sikhi is not a religion based on a language but is based on philosophy.. yes they should try n learn gurmukhi to read bani in its original form that i agree with but learning a new language is not something that u can learn over night it takes months n months to learn a new language

Re: Lareedaar Bir

D Kaur · 02 Feb 2006

That may be the case for some individuals, but I know of many individuals who are raised in an amritdhari family and do not know how to read punjabi/gurmukhi. I never said that if a person doesn't know how to read ain't a Sikh. You are putting words into my mouth. But I would be embarassedd if I never knew how to read and a 7 year old kid does. Gurbani is written in gurmukhi and should only be read in gurmukhi. Why are we using the english language to read gurmukhi? This is another reason as to why people do not bother to learn how to read gurmukhi. They think that they can read bani in english, so there is no need to learn gurmukhi.

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Roopkaur · 02 Feb 2006

>Bhenji,.. Guruji never ever stopped us from reading gurbani from pad-ched! He was antarjaami so he could have told us about this as well as he told us about other things??< Pad ched just got started in this century so how would guru ji tell us not to do it. And he gave the gur gaddi to the laridaar saroop, how else can he say to do paath from laridaar saroop. >laridaar saroops (our true guru)". thought it was Guru granth sahib ji ?? have we got a new guru ??< Guru ji gave gurdaddi to lareedar saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I would argue the introduction of Pad ched birs is the 'new' concept we are dealing with, not lareedar, lareedar is in fact the original.

Re: Lareedaar Bir

ummm · 03 Feb 2006

"Laridaar saroop (guru granth sahib) and that is my only guru. I know of no other guru!" confused, you say guru ji only gave guruship to laridaar saroop, but the one problem i have is why except printed birs ???? there were no printed birs in guru jis times, wonder if these would be acceptable to guru ji ??? also who really has the authority print, write, Gurbani in the form of Guru granth sahib ??? most of these printers nowadays have no respect (or very little) and treat the Birs as books, seriously need Akal Takhat to pass a few resolutions and have only one legitmate printer, personally think it would be better if they got a team of handwriters to write the birs by hand....

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Feb 2006

Whats so difficult about Lareedaar ?? IF the Muslims can take the trouble to read and memorise an alien language ( Arabic is NOT the language of 90% muslims)..why cant we sikhs just take a little trouble to read lareedaar instead of being spoonfed on padd chhed ?? Its whats called PRIORITIES !! do we make GURBANI a priority or not ?? Why do we let some one do the padd chhed for us ?? We are too lazy. Jarnail Singh

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Heera Singh · 03 Feb 2006

I have a question.... would u all do mattha tek to a pad chedd bir? Don't get me wrong, personally I believe we should all be encouraged to have Lareedar saroops... but thats jus not a reality rite now... and yes Lareedar saroop is the way Original saroops were compiled... so I think, rather then putting down the concept of pad chedd bir's we should encourage people around us to go with Lareedar saroops... and we do that with love ... we should explain why we feel this way, and the importance of it.. a lot of people that check out forums are new to sikhi or are just getting inovolved... so they want to know what we do and why we do it... we shouldn't make people feel inferior, 'cause whether u mean to do it or not, thats what you guyz are doing... IMHO... Sree Guru Granth Sahib Jee is my guru... whether its in the form of padd chedd or lareedar.. I will bow my head and read from any saroop... in my perception, Gurbani is Gurbani... some might have difference of opinion.. but thats okay... we're all different and all have our different path... and as sum1 stated above, we're not all brought up with Sikhi.. most people i know that have come on the path have done so on 'their own accord'... meanin they found sangat... and they fell in love with gurbaani... most of their families are not into sikhi at all, so they've had to basically learn everything on their own.. we're all different stages of our lives.. so rather then sayin people should be ashamed of themselves, i think we should encourage them to learn and maybe even offer assitance... its all about love... one thing I see on forums in general is a lot of put down where people are made to feel inferior to others... we're not all Gurmukhs.. people are made to feel as if they are not good enuff to be Sikh... i don't think that was the message of our Gurus... I don't see much love on the forums... i think we all need to take a moment and think about how we go about answer questions and making comments... one thing to one person might be 'common sense', but that concept might actually be totally new to sumbody else... Guru Nanak Dev Jee started to spread the message of love... it seems as we are forgetting that message these dayz... bhul chuk maaf Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!

Re: Lareedaar Bir

singhould only · 03 Feb 2006

so you should only matha tek the bir sahib which got Gurgadhi!! [%sig%]

Re: Lareedaar Bir

D Kaur · 03 Feb 2006

Ummm, There is a difference between punjabi and gurmukhi. Punjabi writing is written with the words separate, whereas gurmukhi is written with the words together (laridaar). I do not accept the birs that are written in the Punjabi language but accept the birs that are written in gurmukhi. Rather it is written by hand our printed doesn’t matter. Heera Singh, Yes everyone is at a different level and there are some individuals that try to follow and come into Sikhi and there are the others that justify Sikhi to benefit their own needs. Should a person that is born in an amritdhari family and is amrithdhari themselves not know how to read paath? My intention was not to put anyone down but to make everyone realize the state that we Sikhs are at today.

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Feb 2006

Heera Singh Ji, Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. The One and ONLy thing fundamentally WRONG with a Padd chhedd sroop is that the PERSON who did the padd chhedd did it accordign to HIS OWN PERCEPTION.....its NOT the ORIGINAL. Example from your post: Don'tgetmewrongpersonallyIbelieveweshouldallbeencouragedtohave Lareedar saroopsbutthatsjusnotarealityritenowandyesLareedarsaroopis thewayOriginalsaroopswerecompiled... (Original) Do n'tget mew rongper son all yI belie ve we shou ld all been couraged .. MY Paddchhedd version of Your message First Line Only..... just an example but SERIOUS DAMAGE to MEANINGS has been doen and can be doen in various padd chheds according to authors. Soem panktees arerendered menaingless..yet the pathi will read as if nothing is wrong as it si WRITTEN there before him.( the GURU IS WRONG.not the pathi)....whereas in LS he will be Forced to THINK before he separates the words..and any MISTAKES he makes are HIS OWN..the GURU is CORRECT all the time. Thats the only contention.. Jarnail singh

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Heera Singh · 03 Feb 2006

The question still hasn't been answered though: Would you do mattha tek to a bir thats compiled as padd chedd?

Re: Lareedaar Bir

???? · 05 Feb 2006

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji It is unfortunate that our guru ji has been distant to us due to the cause of certain people back in 1950. I was reading the topic 'The true Guru is lost' in the gurmat section and when i came across the paragraph where it states "Those on the gurmat path should not attend any smagam with pad-chedd saroop on the throne. It would be like bowing before the manmat of pad-chedd supporter". Reading this, i do feel upset because as much i would like to be in the sangat of our True Guru, i am as much restricted. Living in UK i don't know of one gurdwara sahib which does seva or has parkash of Lareedar Maharaj. The question comes to mind is that, my only good chance of having guru ki sangat is at smagams and other kirtan programmes. So to keep the honour of guru i could not attend any of these but then how would i fulfill the anand that one gets from being in sangat of gumukhs? That does seem in unirresistible. I know that the sangat from tapoban don't go to other places due to this fact or i think i know. So pls i have a benti to the admin sangat if they could give me some guidance towards this as well. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji.

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Feb 2006

Author: Heera Singh Date: 02-03-06 23:21 The question still hasn't been answered though: Would you do mattha tek to a bir thats compiled as padd chedd? ............. Thats a "trick" question . WHY ? Because I matha Tek to the Sroop of Mahraj Ji that is PARKASH in the Gurdwara on the Palki Sahib. It would be very "unbecoming" of me to go check first..and then only matha tek..as if I am better than all the sangat sitting there that has already matha tekked. Only when I begin to DO PAATH on the sroop will I know whether sroop is paddchhedd or lareedaar. Mostly the sroop is always padd chhedd - 99% of the time. The Paaths I DO for my own benefit, and for my Family are done on Lareedaar at my home. Paaths done on Padd chhedd are NOT, in my opinion shudh at all. Jarnail Singh

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Learner · 05 Feb 2006

what about Gutka Sahibs, should they too be laridaar or is pad-ched acceptable in Gutka Sahibs?

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Feb 2006

Gutka Sahibs are for "Learners"....to learn and practise....they can be paddchhedd....as long as Lareedaar is used from then on....sort of "L" driver status for learner drivers.....

Re: Lareedaar Bir

...... · 06 Feb 2006

Gyani Ji is that not a bit of a contradiction. if padd-ched for a Gutka Sahib is done then (like you said) it is done in accordance to the matt of the individual and may contain mistakes but Guru Ji is perfect shouldn't Gutka Sahibs too be Lareedar. why should we change Gurbani to suit us. Why should Guru Ji be changed for the convenience of "L" drivers, why dont people go in accordance to Guru Ji, learn it the hard way, the right way why the exception in the case of Gutka Sahibs????

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Balbir Singh · 06 Feb 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! It seems there are some hard core expert examiners. They can find out who has read the Lareedaar Saroop or the Pad Ched Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji just by hearing the Paathee. I was failed in their examination because I was using neither of those. Balbir Singh

Re: Lareedaar Bir

fool · 06 Feb 2006

why the exception?? how about we just dont help the learners we jsut stick to lareedar and not help people learn gurbani in lareedaar or not. lets just save ourselfs and becuz of our ego not help others

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 06 Feb 2006

Author: ...... Date: 02-06-06 05:52 Gyani Ji is that not a bit of a contradiction. if padd-ched for a Gutka Sahib is done then (like you said) it is done in accordance to the matt of the individual and may contain mistakes but Guru Ji is perfect shouldn't Gutka Sahibs too be Lareedar. why should we change Gurbani to suit us. Why should Guru Ji be changed for the convenience of "L" drivers, why dont people go in accordance to Guru Ji, learn it the hard way, the right way why the exception in the case of Gutka Sahibs???? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> well if you hold that view...then HOW is the learner going to LEARN ?? The "Teacher" will also be a human...with "his own" padd chhedd ?? Or are you suggesting just get a Lareedaar Sroop/gutkas.... and begin to "learn" all by yourseff is the best solution..Na puchhoh ate na dasso !! THAT puts an end to the "Taksaals" ??? Jarnail singh

Re: Lareedaar Bir

sewak · 09 Feb 2006

Reading from the above posts, we see that padd ched birs have mistakes done by those printers. Then, why can't we correct all those mistakes there are in the gurbani as it should be pronounced and then print it in padd ched. In this way, the padhi who is reading it will not make any further mistakes, and then Gurbani is read as it should be.

Re: Lareedaar Bir

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Feb 2006

Author: sewak Date: 02-09-06 17:04 Reading from the above posts, we see that padd ched birs have mistakes done by those printers. Then, why can't we correct all those mistakes there are in the gurbani as it should be pronounced and then print it in padd ched. In this way, the padhi who is reading it will not make any further mistakes, and then Gurbani is read as it should be. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Because the "mistakes" are INTERPRETATIONS.... Example: we all read in Japji... Vaaraian NA javan ek vaar... soem says this should be Vara aan Na Javan ek Var... and he has a good point..because in Gurbani there are many other shbads where the AAN is mentioned.. IF you have a Paddchhedd by the Author No. 1....it will be varrian NA..and by the second Author it will be Vaar AAN Whereas GURU JI in lareedaar is.. Varriannajavaanekvaar.....when YOU read that....GURU JI will have Kirpa on YOU and YOU will read the correct version...and NOT blindly follow the One already made for you. Reading Paddchhedd is FINE..for learners..then go on to lareedaar for YOUR OWN PERSONAL EXPERIENCE..One to One with Guru Ji I am 57 and in the past one year I have had momentous changes..I have tasted..what i used to beleive was sheer exaggeration, I have seen what i thought was sheer imagination.. i used to emphasise Gurbani PAATH at the expense of NAAM JAPP..in the past one year my personal experience changed this perception..suddenly..proving to me GURBANI is ETERNAL TRUTH and no exaggeration, no imagination and no oversimplification or empty metaphors.. i have read padd chhedd for 45 years and Lareedaar for 5....the 5 seem more "heavy" than the 45....more productive, more pleasant..more tasty and sweet...I dont know this may be just me..?? or maybe not ??BUT one thing for sure..I will Always reccommend LAREEDAAR to anyone who cares to listen. PERIOD. as they say you can take a horse to water but you cannot make it drink...so guys make up your minds..you want to just see the water or drink it..eat Makhhan or chew on COTTON ( Both are snow white ) Jarnail Singh