Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

? · 30 Jan 2006

I just watched a video of some post-Amrit Sanchar Kirtan. Something seemed very odd. The Panj Pyare brought the Batta with remaining Amrit into the Divan hall where the Kirtan was going on. Then the Panj proceeded to distribute Amrit (as if it was Karah Parshad) to all the Sangat. However some of the Sangat was Mona, etc. It was difficult to tell if Amrit was distributed to Monas but certainly it was given to young boys wearing western clothes, Patkas so it was unlikely they were Amritdhari. Also young girls wearing jewelery etc (again it was not able to tell if they were Amritdhari but it certainly did not appear that way). At the end the Amrit was given to the Kirtani. Again all of these was done openly in the Sangat. My question is, is this normal for the Sangat to be given Amrit at the end of an Amrit Sanchar? And should this be done openly with non-Amritdharis, etc.

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

G · 30 Jan 2006

that shoulddnt be done everr

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

Gurukaiashq · 30 Jan 2006

Gurfateh This is absolutley NOT as per AKAL TAKHAT REHAT MARYADA and is wroing in my opinion.

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

khalistani · 30 Jan 2006

thas wrong theres a maryada to doin a amrtisanchaar u can check some of itout at damdamitaksal.com bhula chuka maf

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

.. · 30 Jan 2006

is this video online? are you sure it wasnt just parshaad?

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

singh · 31 Jan 2006

Where is this done and who is doing it?

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

hop · 31 Jan 2006

lol bebe nanaki at it again i dont belive this is sikh practise.

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

singh · 31 Jan 2006

At some amrit sanchars they give choola at the end to sangat! Duno if that right or wrong? It def shouldn;t be considered as real amrit. Would be interesting to know why the do give choola tho? [%sig%]

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 31 Jan 2006

the "Khande Batte dee PAHUL....is strictly for the ABHILAKHEES..not as a parshaad for any tom dick and harry. The Abhilakhees are supposed to FINISH it all off by drinking from the Batta INSIDE the room before they come out. maybe some people are having.."diabetic cold feet".....about drinking too much sugar water ??..so just like they say to Karah parshaad..swaiyah jii.bilkul kinka hee dena ji....now it is the turn of the Khande dee Pahul..bass ji bilkul thorra ..rehan do..jee bass hogee !!!..and just like the Karrah parshaad batta is beign Taken for a WALK all over the Gurdawra..in the car park, outside langgar halls..along the walkways..Parshaad lay lo parshad lay lo jee..so it seesm the PAHUL Batta will be taken thsi way..amrit lay lo bayee amrit lay lo jee... STOP this MANMATT..nip it in the BUD..before it spreads like wild fire.

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

singhni · 31 Jan 2006

dear "hop" your post sounds plain stupid - "bebe nanaki at it again i dont belive this is sikh practise". thats very offensive - do u know who Bibi Nanaki Ji is???? you were obviously referring to a gurdwara - but please post properly or dont post at all

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

singh · 31 Jan 2006

people who do this stuff in midlands should be exposed. That is the only way it will be stopped.

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

International Akaali · 31 Jan 2006

gupt why are you giving damdamitaksal reyat maryada???? is that akal takht????? i never knew damdami taksal labels it self higher then akal takht WOW interesting!!!!!

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

Guru Ji's Student · 31 Jan 2006

I think this post is about CHOOLA

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

Dhiyalang Saroopae · 31 Jan 2006

Jarnail Singh Jee, **and just like the Karrah parshaad batta is beign Taken for a WALK all over the Gurdawra..in the car park, outside langgar halls..along the walkways** Forgive me, but is there some sort of rule that says Parshaad cannot be taken outside of the Gurughar? I was always under the impression that everyone in Sangat should be allowed to partake in Karah Parshad no matter where they might be. I have seen Gurudwaras giving Karah Parshaad to many people who might be doing seva outside of the Gurughar?

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

Dhan teri sikhi · 31 Jan 2006

Is it true that after a amrit sanchar at bebe nanaki gurdwhara, they taken the bata out the amrit sacnhar and give it to randon people, even though they did'nt have a full ishnaan and wernt in western clothes. If this statement is true, it is totaly manmat. Amrit should only be distributed in a amrit sanchar with covered windows. It stays in there and gets finished in their.

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

. · 31 Jan 2006

they have been giving coola to anybody who wishes to have some, amrit or no amrit in the atlanta samagam. I thought this was ok. they spashed it their eyes and everything. at that point i thought it wa ok . but now that i think abuot it .nvm! lol o i have seen girls who have taken amrit wear earing. just because they wear jewlery and makepup doesnt neccesacly mean that they are mona?or am i wrong . i might be , this is just my opinion so no offence to anyone

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 31 Jan 2006

dear Dyalang saroopeh jio, Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguur ji ki fateh. What i am "objecting" to is the way the Karrah parshaad is being "hawked" like a rehrree wallah style. Karrah parshaad is a GIFT..a Blessing..for those who ATTEND GURU JI's DARBAAR...and one must at least make an attempt to do that. This taking it around is a modern practise. If a group of youths yacking away in a Gurdwara Car Park insisit on being served "take away" Karrah parshaad..and they are obliged..whose fault is it ?? They already have the "privilege" of loud speakers..that "bring the Guru/Hukm/Vaak/Ardass to them" and so they dont have to go to the trouble of attending Guru Drabaar....next it is bring them parshaad and then serve them take away langgar as well . These are DIGNIFIED THINGS..Gurbani/Hukm/Vaak/Ardass/Karah parshaad/Langgar....Lets act to PRESERVE their DIGNITY. As I said bhul chuk maaf..no offense to anyone..living or dead..real or fictitious. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

Dhiyalang Saroopae · 01 Feb 2006

Jarnail Singh, I see. But, just to make sure ,you wouldn't object to sevadaars giving Karaah Parshaad to sevadaars who cannot make it to the darbaar if they are engrossed in doing seva for Guru's Langar? Would that be okay? cheeers.

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Feb 2006

Author: Dhiyalang Saroopae Date: 02-01-06 10:16 Jarnail Singh, I see. But, just to make sure ,you wouldn't object to sevadaars giving Karaah Parshaad to sevadaars who cannot make it to the darbaar if they are engrossed in doing seva for Guru's Langar? Would that be okay? cheeers. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>. Thats OK mate.. They would probably already matha tek and paid their dues to Guru Ji earlier in the day....and besides somebody's got to do the sewa as well...as all cant be sitting in the Darbar sahib ...cheers Jarnail Singh

Re: Giving Amrit to Kirtanis/Mona's at Amrit Sanchar?

movie · 01 Feb 2006

vjkk, vjkf if it's online...can you please post the link to the video. vjkk, vjkf