Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

tabla skins made from leather

tabla skins made from leather

R · 28 Jan 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh, i was recently talking to a singh and he said that why cant we eat meat if the tabla skins that you use in the gurudwara is made from leather, which comes from a cow. he went and asked a few singhs and no1 had an anwer to his question, sangat jee please help!! bhul chuk maaf, waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh. [%sig%]

Re: tabla skins made from leather

the stoopid one · 28 Jan 2006

the tabla is just an instrument to used to sing the lords praises it doesnt matter wots its made of its a fact that a sikhs rehit involves not eating meat so why even bother questioning it!??

Re: tabla skins made from leather

Tabla master · 28 Jan 2006

simple answer there, the cow is killed so that they can eat the meat, the cows are killed so that tablea can be made, if anything I learn't that the skin used to make tablea is better from cows that have dies due to old age. Don't know if we got any tabla making experts out there who might know, but seriously the cows aren't killed for human digestion when it comes to tablea or shoes, comes to there burgers and stuff they purposely have farms for cows for that purpose.

Re: tabla skins made from leather

sikh · 28 Jan 2006

i wear leather belts, leather shoes, leather jackets and have leather chairs and sofa's it donesnt mean i eat meat.

Re: tabla skins made from leather

kds · 28 Jan 2006

the tabla is just an instrument to used to sing the lords praises it doesnt matter wots its made of its a fact that a sikhs rehit involves not eating meat so why even bother questioning it!?? so what if it is made from human skin ?

Re: tabla skins made from leather

the stoopid one · 28 Jan 2006

so what if it is made from human skin ? why would it matter your not going to eat it!!!??

Re: tabla skins made from leather

ks · 28 Jan 2006

generally, a cow isn't killed for its hide. Leather goods are by-products of the meat industry. but the real hypocrisy wrt to tabla and leather is the brahmin who will play the tabla or pakavaj, but will not repair it, as working with animal hide is beneath him, and thus hands it over to lower castes.

Re: tabla skins made from leather

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Jan 2006

Bhai Kanheyah Ji's "musk" ( water container ) was made of Leather..and all Sikhs as well as Muslims drank the water from that...i wonder if any "residue" from the elather was in the water?? and how this was resolved ?? In those times and still now, LEATHER CONTAINERS were used for Water Carriers - that is why the Water Carrier JHIUR is a LOW CASTE ( Preseumably he is Low caste becasue he uses the leather container...but a High Caste and Vegetarians can DRINK the Leather contaminated water he carried ?? Dubhidha or hypocracy..you decide. Secondly it just so happens that the meat of cows and goats is eatable... the HIDE/KEATHER INDUSTRY doesnt give two hoots to that....look at the huge amounts of croc alligators snakes and other animals slaughtered for their HIDE/FURS ONLY - their meat is useless and sent to animal feed. SO dotn hide under the ""cows not killed for tablas...cow leather is used in a million ways.." etc etc. It wont fool anyone.

Re: tabla skins made from leather

here's a thought · 28 Jan 2006

Please forgive me, Arshi Ji, but due to my ignorance, I am unclear after reading your post where you stand on this issue? I very much appreciate your thoughts, and would like to learn more. Please, I am in no way inciting any debate..I still don't understand though. Peace [%sig%]

Re: tabla skins made from leather

singh11 · 29 Jan 2006

KEEP POSTING PLEASE!!:) [%sig%]

Re: tabla skins made from leather

sinhgh · 29 Jan 2006

The tabla skin is made from dead cows, cows are not killed to make tablay

Re: tabla skins made from leather

Amrik Singh · 29 Jan 2006

I have to say, after reading up on this article that it shows hypocrisy from what has been said. I dont know much about Sikhi and cant give you quotes from the SGGSJ but just looking by this situation via logic 1) You dont kill animals but it causes them pain and suffering for the satisfaction of human taste 2) But you can kill animals and use their skin for other purposes - this dosent negate the fact that the animal still had to go through pain and suffering to get that leather Secondly, if it is against Sikhi to eat meat according the the Rehat Maryada but its ok to use leather, then surely no one would object to hunting, circus animals, animal testing, fur or treating animals in a degrading way but not actually eating them for meat....simply because you say your not eating the animal does not justify these reasons. Because leather is so widely used and it would be a very difficult item to exclude from our lives, so people chose to simply use the excuse its a by-product, but surely meat eaters can use the argument the other way round. However, it is not a by product, leather and the meat are both primary reasons animals are killed. I need to clear up that i am actually pro-veggie but at the same time im saying that we cant keep calling ourselves veggies and use leather. We need to stop hiding behind such excuses of by-products and need at accept that this is a problem that needs to be sorted out (this is also one of the reasons the veggie philosophy can so easily be criticsed and crumbles) Not having a personal attack on anyone or any Jatha these are just my own personal thoughts. If something is wrong we must accept it is wrong and work towards a better non-hypocritical solution. [%sig%]

Re: tabla skins made from leather

khalistani · 29 Jan 2006

the reasonw e dont eat halaal, or even chatka( during normal times), is because its not good for ure bhagthee and there is NO reason to eat it ure killing a animal for NO REASON thas jus stupid if it wads fo0r meat but leather is a very good material it doesnt rip easily, etc.,, especially bak in the dayz when no polyster and stuff like tha and its wa makes the tabla sound, which we use to praise vaheguru and people use it to get there minds attached to akaal so its a good thing and it does have use i this way but for eatin meat, its not good for ur ebhagthee and no point in it bhula chuka maf

Re: tabla skins made from leather

kds · 30 Jan 2006

The tabla skin is made from dead cows, cows are not killed to make tablay you are living in your imaginary world.cows are killed for leather too.when bjp government want too impose complete ban on cow slaughter in india the leather industry oppossed it.as a result the parties from that states opposed that bill.cow meat is by -product in india as majority of indians don't eat it and it is sold too middle eastern countries.

Re: tabla skins made from leather

ks · 30 Jan 2006

there seem to be some confusion over by-product. I use the term in the sense that if there is a hide that is lying around and not being used, there is no qualm in using it for a tabla head. but in the end all this moralizing about leather is moot. The Gurus supervised darbars in which the jori, tabla, and perhaps pakavaj were used---thus they are sanctified for gurmat sangeet.

Re: tabla skins made from leather

no_name · 30 Jan 2006

does any body know of any other skins that can be used for a tabla one where the shai( black circle on the poora) does not come off

Re: tabla skins made from leather

. · 30 Jan 2006

Meat is spiritual Poison. Simple as. Just as Alcohol and Tobacco is spiritual Poison. This is why meat is the Bujjar Kurehat. No more discussion needed.