Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh Unlike what is previewed in bias news and bias books, Khalsa jee was not obssesd with hatred for monne/hindus, as a matter of fact, he iss often quoted saying, May a hindu become a true hindu, a muslim a true muslim and a Sikh a true Sikh. Evidence for this can be seen below - He obviously didn't have anything against talking and discussing and laughing around with hindus/mones. Now here's my question - who is this in the picture? =D

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006

I thought about the option that it might be a press reporter, but press-reporters usually don't have children around when interviewing militants... Might be his friends for all i know...?

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

Harmanjit singh · 29 Jan 2006

guru Fateh With yellow headcovering is subramaniam swami(politition), I don't know about others except sant jarnail singhji. Harmanjit singh [%sig%]

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

ssingh · 30 Jan 2006

the guy with child has a kara on, the other mona has a rumal, and the one with eye glasses can't be determined. bad evidence

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

singh · 30 Jan 2006

Lion King Ji Why do you use the word "militant"? Is that was he was...is that what all those Singhs were/are? There is a problem when Sikhs themselves begin to use the lingo of the Indian government and of oppressor. I am ashamed.

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

w/ever · 30 Jan 2006

well if you look the man on Baba ji's right is wearing a kara

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

a singh · 31 Jan 2006

SINGH JI, what else do you call a SAPAHI, is it not a warrior for truth? which is the same as a militant for truth. AKAL PURKH KI FAUJ- the military of GOD, contains of Gods militants.

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

Singh · 31 Jan 2006

These are south Indians. Many South Indians sympathised with Sant Jernail Singh Jee because they also felt that the majority Hindi speaking community was trying to replace their languages with Hindi. The guy with the Kara seems to be a Punjabi Hindu. It is very common to see Punjabi Hindus wear Karas.

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

LionKing (LK) · 31 Jan 2006

Yep I agree with "Singh", just ebcause he's got a KaRa doesn't mean anything unfortunatly, as mone nowdays only wear kaRa, and Punjabi hindus have started wearing KaRas too (muslims tooo have started now - is the Guru Great or what??) ********* Author: singh Date: 01-30-06 00:41 Lion King Ji Why do you use the word "militant"? Is that was he was...is that what all those Singhs were/are? There is a problem when Sikhs themselves begin to use the lingo of the Indian government and of oppressor. I am ashamed. ************ Mere pyaarey veer jeyo, I apologize if the word militant offended you. In my English vocabulary I found that being the most suiting as it is neutral in the sense that it deosn't indicate whether the weapons are raised for a god or bad purpose- for then I would have used the word "terrorist" Actually I'm writing a report on 1984, what word do you think I should use that makes me at the same time be as objective as possible, yet not offend anyone. Definition of "militant" according to encarta dictionary. ********** mil·i·tant [ míllit'nt ] adjective Definitions: 1. aggressive: extremely active in the defense or support of a cause, often to the point of extremism 2. involved in fighting: engaged in fighting or warfare noun (plural mil·i·tants) Definitions: somebody aggressively supporting cause: an aggressive defender or supporter of a cause [15th century. Directly or via French < Latin militant-, present participle of militare "be a soldier" < milit- (see military)] ************ As a matter of fact even if I called them a terrorist, seriously donesn't matter because his actions spoke for themselv. The only reason I posted the pic was to show those who think he had a anti-hindu and anti-money mentality, they are wrong and that the Singhs did their best in the movement. Again please suggest me a word that would work for a western report with wester standards that would not disrespect the Singhs, yet stay objective. Terrorist is tremendously negatively charged, so is extremist and fundamentalist. words such as - The "saint soldiers" were fighting fot the cause of the Sikhs....or whatever will be tremendously bias in the other direction, therefore to take an objective stand, I see militant as the best word as it doesn't disrespect, yet doesn't seem bias. Please give me suggestions of words I can use Bhull chukk maaf for offending you

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

Baldeep Singh · 31 Jan 2006

To read about Dr. Subramaniam Swami's opinion about Operation Bluestar and Baba Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bhindranwale Please feel free to visit the following link http://allaboutsikhs.com/bluestar/ob01.htm

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

singh · 31 Jan 2006

LK, the word militant has a negative connotation no matter what context it is used in. this is the reason i do not like the word when it is to be used for singhs and kaurs who have fought for/are fighting for the panth. if you are writing a report and are at a lack for words, i would suggest that you devote some words of explanation to the fact that the word militant cannot fully define Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale. expecially because there is more to what he did than just militancy. it began peacefully and there is a reason we use 'sant-sipahi" to refer to such individuals. this is part of the story as well...so you could tell it. also, another thing to consider is that though your report is in english and in the "western" world, you are a part of the amalgamation of cultures that makes up "the west' and you have a right to introduce new terms to it...think of the british and the world "durbar" "raj" and most recently in western lingo "pandit"...such introductions are especially acceptable in academia. you can even use sant sipahi if you would like. perhaps use the term "yoda" simply meaning fighter note that by using only the word militant you are being one-sided. you want to be objective...and i agree it is important to be objective in an academic paper...but make sure that in your quest for objectivity you dont begin to sound like the indian government...too often we (all of us) when trying not to be biased, end up being biased against the very side we think we will favor. by using the world militant as your standard you are using the vocabulary of the indian government-one of the parties in the conflict...it is already biased if that is the only term you use. you can balance your paper out by using terms that both sides would use. ...you can use terms like freedom-fighter or revolutionary, in certain parts of your paper to describe the Sikh perspective, while using the word militant to describe the indian government's assessment of Baba Ji. either way, in my view it would be injustice to only use the word militant. good luck on your report and i wish you chardi kala! fateh jio! ps...i agree about the word terrorist and hope that it does not appear in any form in your report (as i am sure it will not).

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

Truth · 31 Jan 2006

LionKing: unfortunately, even the word militant isn't the best descriptive word for what the Singhs stood for. But looking at the other options (since you want to also remain "objective" to your academic audience), militant seems like the least disrespectful word out of he usual list (terrorist, separatist). Here's my hint: many scholars also find themselves in a similar delima where they have to use a word arouses certain emotions and images that the author doesn't wish to bring forth. So what do you do?: redefine the word militant to what YOU want it to mean in the context of your report. This way you maintain respect for shaheed Singhs and you also become more concise.

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

LionKing (LK) · 01 Feb 2006

Thank you for your nice ideas Singh veer jeyo and Truth jeyo. Veer jeyo, words the government uses are the above mentioned, terrorists, fundamentalists, extremists, seperatists. Daas has read a few books by objective writers such as Cynthia Mahmood Keeply, who try their extreme best to stay away from labels, but when using having to use a label they always use the word "militant", same with some books that are written from a pro-sikh perspective, this has given me the impression that it's a word that seesm to be the most neutral I can find in the context. ------ So what do you do?: redefine the word militant to what YOU want it to mean in the context of your report. This way you maintain respect for shaheed Singhs and you also become more concise. ------- I think this is an excellent idea, and will now think twice about how to defne it=) ****** ps...i agree about the word terrorist and hope that it does not appear in any form in your report (as i am sure it will not). ****** Oh yes it will - under the section about the state terrorizing the local people in punjab with terrorists such as Gobind Ram, Beanta and KPS Gill responsible for liquidating innocent villagers - that's the whole purpose of the report =) So back to the picture - the orange guy is Swami [thanks for the link Baldeep Singh jeyo - it's extremely useful!!!], who's the guy with the kid and the guy with glasses? Bhull Chukk maaf

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

M S Nijjar · 01 Feb 2006

Could the topic opener next time name Sant Jee with a little more respect in the topic title instead of just "Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa", this would ideally be SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHALSA BHINDRANWALE, or if you are one of those people who believe "there is no such thing as a Sant", then at least BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHALSA. It is more respectful to such a great incomparable jewel of the Sikh Panth! [i]No offence to you though, thanks alot![/i] Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!!

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

guruji's_Student · 01 Feb 2006

Omg ... people are going to start thinking bad of sant ji .. because he is talking with other people WAHEGURU ever heard of equailty? .. and if you do not know the ful sotory behind it .. dont belive it all waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

..... · 01 Feb 2006

Completely off the subject....Ive seen this picture many times, but this only has come to my eye now, is baba jarnail singh wearing some kind of brown trousers. Bhul chuk maaf, Ive just never noticed that before, maybe someone can give more info... maybe its a pajama. Patanee.

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

Truth · 01 Feb 2006

LOL...those aren't "brown trousers"...that's their loyee (shawl).

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

..... · 02 Feb 2006

acha sorry, I didnt mean to offened no one, just looks like brown pajama or pant.

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

LionKing (LK) · 02 Feb 2006

ehmm *cough* So anybody know who the people in the photo are? *cough*

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

Damdami Taksal (UK) · 02 Feb 2006

The monay that have been pictured with Sant Jee came to see them unexpectedly. For this reason Sant Jee and the Singhs had taken off their cholay and were in more casual clothes. For this reason to cover their legs and Kachhera out of respect, Sant Jee asked of a Lohee.

Re: Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa

Gagan · 03 Feb 2006

Oh so thats a Lohi All this time I thought that Sant jee was wearing a brown dress pant. My Bad...Thanks for clearing that up for me.