Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Last resort meat

Last resort meat

strange · 27 Jan 2006

waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh i was talking to a singh the other the day, and he was saying that in the olden days singhs used to have to eat meat as a last resort to stay alive. He also said that bhaang (the drug) the some nihangs take, he said that is a medicine and can be used. i dont really agree with his ideas/views. also a strange thing that he came up with was that sikhi was not the only way to saach khand. he said other religons like christianity and hinduism can get there as well if they practice there faith properly. again i don't really agree with this statement either. i just wanted sangat ji to clear me up on these points. please try to not drift away from the original topic. thank you waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh ! [%sig%]

Re: Last resort meat

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 27 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Bhai Sahib Jeeo i'm glad that you disagree with his views because they're false beliefs. 'i was talking to a singh the other the day, and he was saying that in the olden days singhs used to have to eat meat as a last resort to stay alive.' No, this is entirely false, as the Singhs in the past knew that as the first and last not resort but mandatory is to Japp Naam. The Singhs would know by japping Naam ones hunger and thirst is quenched; as stated in Gurbani. 'He also said that bhaang (the drug) the some nihangs take, he said that is a medicine and can be used.' If nihangs are taking this now, then there you go the distinctiveness between Guru Gobind Singh jee's Khalsa and a nihang who indulges in falsehood to satisfy his needs. 'i dont really agree with his ideas/views. also a strange thing that he came up with was that sikhi was not the only way to saach khand. he said other religons like christianity and hinduism can get there as well if they practice there faith properly. again i don't really agree with this statement either. i just wanted sangat ji to clear me up on these points.' This is blasphemy! The only religion allowed in Saachkhand is a Sikh or a Khalsa, since Bhagats like Pralaad Jee only was allowed to enter Saachkhand after he recited Gurbani provided by Guru Nanak Dev Jee. There're only Bhramgyanis as Gursikhs, the Gurus and of course Vaheguru Jee in Saachkhand. Other religions are only accepted in heaven if the Christian or Muslim is true to their religion then they're allowed only in heaven but not in Saachkhand. As the Muslim or Christian would have to be reborn as a Sikh of Guru’s to enter Saachkhand. Finally, it's obvious that your friend was trying to twist your beliefs and mould them into falseness. This is a manmukhs way of doing things from the control and influence of Maya and kalyug. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 27 Jan 2006

Gyani Jarnail Singh ji used to say - Muslaman pakka Musalman bane, Hindu Paka Hindu Bane Sikh Paka Sikh bane- A Muslimg shoudl be a proper muslim, a hindu a proper hindu anda Sikh a proper Sikh - he didn't say all ahve to surrender to the Sikh Faith. It is true that Singhs in the days used to consume meat as a last resort, when everything esle had been eaten -. when every leave of the tree was eaten (or so I have been told) they had to eat meat to stay alive.

Re: Last resort meat

singhz lets unite · 27 Jan 2006

marijuana in itself can be cure, but there are certain chemicals in the plant which distract the function of the human body and therefore gets u high. singhs did eat meat in the olden days when they lived in jungles because they had nothing else to eat. we would not have been here if they hadnt eaten meat. it was the only way they could survive. it is a rule in Sikhi, which i tink many AKJ people try to hide, that you can eat meat in life and death situation. that is when it is not wrong. now singhs ate meat at thata time because they had, not because they wanted to, and GuruJee forgaave them. now my question is that if we can not eat meat becaue animals are living things to and we're killing them for the taste of our mouth. how come we kill plants to survive just because plants are stuck on the ground and do not have legs to move around like us human beings and animals? plants have life too so why is it that we can kill plants to eat them but can not kill animals to eat them? how come i am the only one who is interested to discuss this topic but no-one else? because none else has the answer. noone wants to discuss it because they someone is going to come with a quesion i came up with and they would be speechless to answer it. i was talkin to my frend too and he eats meat. we were talkin about meat and he even said some Gurbani lines to prove it is right. how come even tho its in Gurbani that you can eat meat but still we say we cant? ANSWER MY QUESTION!! THIS PANTH IS ALREADY LOSING ITS IDENTITY DUE TO LESS PARCHAR!!!! ANSWER MY QUESTION FOR THAT ABOVE SENTENCE!!!

Re: Last resort meat

strange · 27 Jan 2006

last resort cut hair? physical death do not fear (union with god for a gursikh) death of concious is true death ( go to hell) followed by transmigration

Re: Last resort meat

strange · 27 Jan 2006

cant commit kruhet to prolong life, defies point of life

Re: Last resort meat

strange · 27 Jan 2006

admin change the 'name' of my last 2 posts, i never changed the name - just change it to 'anon' i never changed name after last person who posted the messge

Re: Last resort meat

singhz lets unite · 27 Jan 2006

see i knew it! no-one would answer my question. cuz no-one is able to!

Re: Last resort meat

Smethwickwala · 27 Jan 2006

Bhagat Kabir ji states: Oh Kabir, the dinner of beans and rice flavoured with rice is acceptable But who is prepared to have his throat cut [in the hereafter] for the hunted animal. [1374] It is a disturbing thought that many Sikhs believe that to attain spiritual enlightenment one can continue to tuck into a juicy steak, that the pain and suffering of the animal is separate to the succulent roast chicken on the table, that the cutting of the animals life force will not have a direct effect on their own 'karmic account '. Eating meat of ANY type is prohibited for a Sikh. Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji (SGGS) makes various references to meat . The reason the Gurus went hunting was not for pleasure or the need to satisfy their taste buds, they were above this , it was to settle long overdue 'accounts' to release the souls of the poor unfortunate animals who may have wronged in the past, to grant them Mukti / salvation. There is a story of Guru Gobind Singh Ji who sent out his falcon to hunt an animal, once caught Guru Ji watched as the Baaj tore into the animals flesh. Asked by one of his Sikhs what was the reasoning behind this Guru ji stated that in a previous life the animal had borrowed some money from the Baaj and swore on Akal Purakhs name that he would pay it back, he never did, now was pay back time. There are many instances like this which illustrates that the Gurus were not hunting for meat but to save these souls from the continuous cycle of birth and death. In two Hukkhamnamas of Sri Guru Har Gobind Sahib Ji there are clear cut instructions prohibiting the eating of meat, fish etc. The actual words are "Maas machhi de nerrey nahai jawnaa" Dr Gopal Singh in his History of the Sikh People. " In the Gurus kitchen (or Guru Ka Langar) meat dishes are not to be served, Giani Sher Singh in his Philosophy of Sikhism. "Kabir held the doctrine of Ahinsa or non-destruction of life, which even extended to his followers. The Sikh Gurus, on the contrary allowed and even encouraged the use of animal flesh for food.."??? Does the author go on to expand on this , does he give any evidence for this, No he does not!. Again pure conjecture and speculation from people with hidden agendas. One should step back and think for a moment what is being said here. The Gurus were pure souls, Sikhs believe them to have merged with the Akal Purkh are we then led to believe that they would tear into a chicken leg at meal time, piayrio don't even go there. Eating meat is a very primitive act and the Gurus taught us to be above this, to control our emotions and urges if we were to develop spiritually. H.S Singha in his Mini Encyclopedia of Sikhism. 'Guru Amar Das Ji ate only rice and lentils but this abstention cannot be regarded as evidence of vegetarianism, only of simple living.'??? Why cannot it be evidence of vegetarianism ? If we look at the lives of the Gurus and try to emulate as much of them as possible because we regard them as ideal living then why not this ? Now, lets get to the heart of what eating meat really means. We are talking about inflicting pain & killing another being , cutting of its flesh and muscles which that animal relied upon for its existence and consuming it, primarily for the taste. That's right, for the taste of it. We can exist quite happily without meat so why do many people feel the urge to consume it, taste plays a large part of it. Can we in our hearts believe that the Gurus advocated this? Question : Do beings get born on this earth and have living bodies just to be a convenience food ? Or do beings get born into a life with a body so that they can develop and eventually evolve away from Karma and into Dharma ? In the beginnings of SGGS , Guru Ji says : This human body has been given to you. This is your chance to meet the Lord of the Universe. Nothing else will work. Join the SaadhSangat, the company of the holy. Vibrate and meditate on the Jewel on the Naam. Make every effort to cross over this terrifying world-ocean. Your are squandering this life uselessly in the love of Maya I have not practiced meditation, self discipline, Self restraint or righteous living. I have not served the holy; I have not acknowledged the Lord, my king. Says Nanak, my actions are contemptible! O Lord, I seek Your Sanctuary, please preserve my honour. The 'body' is given to all in order to meet Akal Purkh and the Guru says that there is no other way to meet him. By killing a healthy animal for consumption interrupts its life experience and its evolution towards meeting God. Animals can sense impending doom especially if they can hear the death throws of their colleagues having a 'bolt' driven into their skulls in the shed next door. This can evoke a very powerful glandular response in the animal and hormones are pumped into its body. When you eat that flesh you take on those hormones, and of course its Karma. This has a great effect on your Atma, for the Atma feels pain. By adding the karma of that soul to yours you are also interfering with your own desire to meet the Lord of the Universe. If you have not cleared away your own Karma why would you want to create the Karma of killing and consuming the flesh of another being ? Sikhs do not eat or take into their bodies anything which is harmful or have an ill effect upon the body or mind. Meat is a stimulant of the gross passions of the mind and body. Meat is harmful on a physical, mental and spiritual level. You are killing a soul who is in the process of evolving towards God. Meat stimulates your 'lower nature' making it impossible to achieve a meditative spiritual mind set. If you want constant confusion and irritation then chew on a piece of flesh. If on the other hand you want to evolve spiritually , open up the capacity for meditative comprehension of higher truths then the karmic and polluting nature of meat cannot be ignored. It is said by many that plants also have life so why do we not abstain from eating plants ? It is very true that plants do have life but the karmic energy and consequences of eating plants do not compare to those of an animal which has nervous systems; feeling, possible thoughts, parental instincts towards is offspring. Also plants ( and I am talking about the normal ones that we eat - lentils, maize , spinach etc) are not harmful on a mental, spiritual level but are in fact good for the digestion. Much has been made of the Nihang Singh sect eating Maha Parshad, but the Nihangs also drink a concoction of Marihuana and opium called Suckha, are we all to start taking drugs because of this? Those believing they will grow big and strong by eating meat are also at a loss to explain why vegetarian Singhs and Singhnia are among the strongest and toughest people in the world and how Singhs of the past like Baba Deep Singh were able to overpower enemy armies of much greater size. For those of you thinking "we are at the top of the food chain"- you are sadly mistaken as Cannibals eat humans as well as other meat so they are at the top should we be likewise be following what they do? They (the truest of the true) burn away the bonds of the world, And eat a simple diet of grain and water. (SGGS Aang467) Kabir, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine - no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. (SGGS Aang1337) You kill living beings and worship lifeless things, at your very last moment, You will suffer terrible pain. (SGGS Aang332) Do not say that the Vedas are false, false are those who do not reflect. If in all is one god, then why does one kill the hen ? (SGGS Aang1350) Sayeth Kabir, that the best food is eating kichree (daal/lentils) where nectar sweet is the salt. You eat hunted meat, but which animal is willing to have their head cut ? (SGGS Aang1378) In this dark age of Kali Yuga, people have faces like dogs; They eat rotting dead bodies for food. (SGGS Aang1242 The Vars of Bhai Gurdas Ji are known as the 'kunji' (key) to Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. Var 31 pauree 9 : "Just because the Guru has saved the butcher,That does not mean that we can kill animals and eat them."

Re: Last resort meat

singhz lets unite · 27 Jan 2006

'i dont really agree with his ideas/views. also a strange thing that he came up with was that sikhi was not the only way to saach khand. he said other religons like christianity and hinduism can get there as well if they practice there faith properly. again i don't really agree with this statement either. i just wanted sangat ji to clear me up on these points.' what happened to the Bhagats then? there was not Sikhism back then, all of the Bhagats were either Muslim or Hindu. and still GuruJi chose to put their Baani in Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji because their Baani was true and still is. if they werent Sikhs how can their Baani would be in GGS? wouldnt they reaches hell when they died because they were either Muslim or Hindu?

Re: Last resort meat

amarjeet singh · 28 Jan 2006

no u never eat meat if ur gona die then die

Re: Last resort meat

Guru Ji's Student · 28 Jan 2006

Author: strange Date: 01-27-06 15:20 cant commit kruhet to prolong life, defies point of life Perhaps thats why eating KUTHA MEAT (described by the Guru Panth as Meat slaughtered in accordance to Muslim rites) is the Kurehat, RATHER than MEAT. Does this mean that all Gursikhs should eat meat? NO! It is more likely that a Gursikh will not eat meat and keep a simple diet. You don't need to get in arguments over meat. More simran you do, you yourself know and your diet changes. KUTHA MEAT (meaning Halal) leads to APOSTACY Eating meat as last resort. Well I am a vegetarian. If someone gave me the choice of eating meat in a LAST RESORT. I don't think I could eat it DESPITE how hungry I am, because my body is not used to it and probably feel sick! However, saying that under what extreme circumstances would a person eat a dead man's body? (it has happened like in situations of plane crashes etc)

Re: Last resort meat

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 28 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKAKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Well said, excellent Bhai Sahib 'Guru Ji's Student' Jeeo, that's what Guru Jee would love to hear a Sikh say. To think that eating meat is fine just because the singhs in Guru Jee's time did, is completely ridiculous, since were they saints if they could stoop to such a low level. There were loads of Sikhs in Guru Jee's time but does that automatically make them saints to follow. Gurbani states meat to be wrong and so does Guru Gobind Singh Jee, Bhai Gurdaas Jee and finally, so does Bhai Desa Singh Jeeo say this: kut(h)aa hukaa charas thamaakoo || gaa(n)jaa ttopee thaarree khaakoo || ein kee our n kabehoo dhaekai || rehithava(n)th so si(n)gh visaekhai || Meat, opium, drugs and tobacco. Ganja, wearing hats, another's woman and alcohol. He who never even gazes at these evils. Recognise them as my disciplined Singh. Furthermore, if choices to not to eat meat are made you know that God is there abiding within the heart. Even though Gurbani mentions alot about Muslims who forcefully kill a animal and then eat it, it still relates to all that eat meat as well. To bestow mercy upon anyone is an act of kindness, a step closer to Vaheguru Jee but a sin to eat meat. dheesath maas n khaae bilaaee || The cat sees the meat, but does not eat it, mehaa kasaab shhuree satt paaee || and the great butcher throws away his knife; karanehaar prabh hiradhai voot(h)aa || the Creator Lord God abides in the heart; In the beginning of Satyug the people didn't know anything about discipline and so they began to eat meat, but then Vaheguru Jee sent down a being to provide them with the knowledge of discipline, which was to eat vegatables and never to eat a animal not matter the situation. For those who think eating meat is a loud then I suggest you to read the topic of meat in this website, http://www.tapoban.org/gurmat.htm. There's two to be read. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee writes an effective piece on how wrong it is to eat meat. VahegurooJeKAKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Last resort meat

.. · 28 Jan 2006

singhz lets unite the bhagats were sikhs, they got nam from guru nanak dev ji directly they didnt cut hair, eat meat, smoke/drink, commit adultery they didnt follow the hindu scriptures or the quran gurbani descended on them from above, and they recited this

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006

Agree with Guru Ji's student. Nice post It woudl be naive to deny that SInghs had to eat meat in jungles. If they would not commit one kurehit and cut hair why would they commit another kurehit by eating meat - if eatiing meat was at all a kurehit..Agree with Guru Ji's student.. just because Kuttha is kurehit doesn't automatically mean we can eat meat, just means that you're not an apostate if you it it as a last resort.... that's where i stand today...

Re: Last resort meat

a singh · 28 Jan 2006

PLANTS do not have pain receptors, Plants dont have hearts like hours if youre just trying to say plants r animals without legs , youre very wrong

Re: Last resort meat

Singhstah · 28 Jan 2006

if u say that we can eat meat in a life or death situation, then what about if u were told u would be killed if u didnt cut your hair, you wouldnt would you, same thing

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006

************* Author: a singh Date: 01-28-06 08:26 PLANTS do not have pain receptors, Plants dont have hearts like hours ************** That's a pathetic argument, just because plants have a diffenr physiology to us animals, doesn't mean they don't feel pain. Animals have receptors and hormones like adrenaline and other hormones rising when we feel scared. Plants have a completly different physiology and probably have some other way of feeling pain. And even if they don't in chatka- there is no time to feel pain. Especially when it's done in some countries where they first make the animals unconscious by various methods, and THEN kill the animal - no time for adrenaline to run around in the body **** if youre just trying to say plants r animals without legs , youre very wrong ***** Plant's are jee's too, just because they don't have legs and a completly different biological and physiological structure doesn't mean they don't feel pain. I should actually do research if plants feel pain or not :S.. I will do research and will inform you in a few years =D. Point is, we cannot compaire everything in human sense. Just because we have to call Vaheguru "him" the "lord" doesn't make him a man. does God become angry? Does god become sad? or disappointed? these are all human and anthropomorphic characteristics whereas Guru Nanak’s view of God is more towards pantheistic, however Sikhs do not worship deities but the one immortal lord. We cannot always look at everything as human ebigns but need to acknowledge that other things work in other ways. Even Guru Nanak Patshah said - "The fools argue about flesh and meat, but they know nothing about meditation and spiritual wisdom. What is called meat, and what is called green vegetables? What leads to sin? It was the habit of the gods to kill the rhinoceros, and make a feast of the burnt offering. Those who renounce meat, and hold their noses when sitting near it, devour men at night. They practice hypocrisy, and make a show before other people, but they do not understand anything about meditation or spiritual wisdom. O Nanak, what can be said to the blind people? They cannot answer, or even understand what is said." ******** Am I justifing meat-eating? No I'm just showing that your argument is flawed, and that just because plants don't have pain receptors in human sense they might have other things that lead to pain and fear. bhull chukk maaf

Re: Last resort meat

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jan 2006

This incident is from the time when I began to walk towards Guru Sahib. I had stopped cutting hair. I had read in a book by Sant Gurbachan Singh jee Bhindranwalay that Khalsa should avoid meat but Khalsa is not "Vaishno" either and if need be at the time of urgency, he can eat meat. I was convinced by this argument. I still remember that day, in in the shop in the building at 1442 Lawrence Avenue West, Toronto; we were discussing Sikhi. There was this guy, who was a pure paindoo and a gangster too. We were discussing meat and I was of the same opinion as Sant Gurbachan Singh jee Bhindranwalay. When I put forward this argument, that paindoo fellow said beginning with a "big gaal": "Oye, je tere sirr tey kaam chariya hove, te hor koi chaara na hove, taan kee tu apni maa jaa bhain naal kar layenga" (Oye, if Kaam totally overtakes you and you don't see any way out, would you do it with your mother or sister). This totally embarrassed me. I could not say anything. I knew he waas right. I was very young at that time, barely 18-19 years old. This fellow was in his mid twenties. He continued and concluded that doing a Bajjar Kurehit cannot be justified. I never gave this argument of Sant jee again. Soon after, I read Bhai Sahib's book on Meat and was convinced that eating meat is a kurehit. Kulbir Singh

Re: Last resort meat

kds · 28 Jan 2006

"Oye, je tere sirr tey kaam chariya hove, te hor koi chaara na hove, taan kee tu apni maa jaa bhain naal kar layenga" (Oye, if Kaam totally overtakes you and you don't see any way out, would you do it with your mother or sister). do human needs minimum two times sex a day to survive?

Re: Last resort meat

Truth · 28 Jan 2006

Kulbir Singh, that's a pathetic example, and down right low of you to indirectly attack Gyani Gurbachan Singh ji Binderawale. It's insulting to our puratan shaheeds aswell that you would compare their usage of maas as a last resort to someone being "overpowerd by kaam". Singhs fought a Dharam Yudh. They didn't fear death, but at the same time they didn't want the dusht and enemy of the Panth to win. So either they could starve to death, or eat maas to prolong their life and possibly make the dushts taste sarbloh. And Guruji, including the puratan hukamnamas state the Kurehit as being Halal, which is Muslim method of slaughter where the animal's jugular is slit and blood allowed to drain while the animal is still alive, and kalma are recited in this whole process. That being said, Guruji and the SInghs never consumed maas as present Nihangs tend to believe. Maas was not allowed, but room was made for it as a last resort, which the Singhs had to use several times in the course of history, including when the Singhs were living in the jungles. When Singhs ate maas, it wasn't for jeeb-suaad (tongue). Again, Singhs never cut their hair as a last resort, nor did they consume tobacco as a last resort...why? because they are kurehits which the khalsa never should commit. Halal is also a kurehit, but jhatka maas as a last resort for food is not a kurehit.

Re: Last resort meat

kaal · 28 Jan 2006

hu cares wether plants feel pain or not. we dont eat meat because its hukam not to. meat is jooth.

Re: Last resort meat

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jan 2006

"Truth", Why are you upset? I gave you a true life incident. It did not even cross in my mind that I was attacking Sant jee. I have immense respect for Sant jee who happens to be my favourite Kathakaar. Kulbir Singh

Re: Last resort meat

some1 · 28 Jan 2006

according 2 many, its better to die, then to prolong ur panths fight. If on the battle field, u face death out of hunger, victory by eating your horse... which would be better for the panth? bhung was used as a painkiller, quite like morphine for the injured after battle.

Re: Last resort meat

agyani · 28 Jan 2006

ok i am sick of this - i hate it when ppl use guru nanak maharaj to justify the right to eat meat. NOW EVERYONE download this katha its ON MEAT and LISTEN TO IT http://gurmatveechar.com/katha.php?k=gts

Re: Last resort meat

singh · 28 Jan 2006

'i was talking to a singh the other the day, and he was saying that in the olden days singhs used to have to eat meat as a last resort to stay alive.' Shaktishali Sha Soora : "No, this is entirely false, as the Singhs in the past knew that as the first and last not resort but mandatory is to Japp Naam. The Singhs would know by japping Naam ones hunger and thirst is quenched; as stated in Gurbani. " Dear Shaktishali Sha Soora, do you japp naam to quench your hunger and thirst instead of eating living plants? If not, why not?

Re: Last resort meat

Truth · 28 Jan 2006

Kulbir Singh, my apologies if i miscontrued your comments.

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, I too noticed this statement and felt offended by it (although I personally do not have any conections to Taksal), I felt tha tit was offending as you, unknowingly pushed down Gyani jee.. Truth's and kds posts absolutely make sense, in the sense that you won't die if you don't feed you kaam - but you will without doubt die if your physical is not feed. ******** That being said, Guruji and the SInghs never consumed maas as present Nihangs tend to believe. Maas was not allowed, but room was made for it as a last resort, which the Singhs had to use several times in the course of history, including when the Singhs were living in the jungles. When Singhs ate maas, it wasn't for jeeb-suaad (tongue). Again, Singhs never cut their hair as a last resort, nor did they consume tobacco as a last resort...why? because they are kurehits which the khalsa never should commit. Halal is also a kurehit, but jhatka maas as a last resort for food is not a kurehit. ******** Makes total sense, and if this was a compromise the Panth could make, I am sure all Jathey would agree with it- (this way meat is not completly thrown out - it's there as a last resort, it's still not allowed to eat in everyday fashion (definetly makes sense for Taksalis, perhaps AKj could compromise on this too..?) The above could definetly be a winner! Email it to Akal Thakhat and they might just consider it (alothugh I very much doubt it) Thank you for yor amazing post Truth, as you have been able to phrase it in a way I wouldn't be - couldn't have said it better myself.

Re: Last resort meat

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 28 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh paap pu(n)n kee saar n jaanee || Those who do not understand the nature of sin and virtue dhoojai laagee bharam bhulaanee || are attached to duality; they wander around deluded. Bhai Sahib 'Truth' Jeeo, what Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Jee said completely relates to the meat situation, since if the Kaam (hunger) took control over you, are you going to attempt to commit a sin. Gurbani just uses Muslim’s way of having meat i.e. Halal as an example, due to the fact that even though Muslims go through this whole process to eat the meat it’s basically the same thing as not going through the halal process. There isn’t any difference and so this is why Gurbani uses halal as an example of the fact that you cannot purify a sin to make it acceptable. guramath dhaee bharosai thaerai ||3|| Please, bless me with the Guru's Teachings; my faith is in You alone. ||3|| To start a debate on the plant and meat business is completely ridiculous, even Goraa wouldn’t argue about this because of the common sense based within it. What Bhai Sahib ‘LionKing’ Jeeo said is true. There isn’t any point on debating on this topic but instead except Guru Jee’s Hukam, have faith within the Hukam and maybe one day Vaheguru Jee will bestow the glance of grace of knowledge upon you. As love is within faith and by having faith in Guru Jee’s Hukam is having love for the Hukam, which as a result, you’re having love for Guru Jee as he is within the Shabad. ma(n)nai surath hovai man budhh || The faithful have intuitive awareness and intelligence. The one who performs a large mass of Naam Bhagti knows the rights and wrongs, as well as their hunger and thirst is quenched so basically the body doesn't feel these human-like needs. Also, Bhai Desa Singh Jeeo has said to eat meat is a sin and this rehit was accepted by Guru Gobind Singh Jee. To make sacrifices for our Sikhi is a necessity for a Sikh to prove the faith the Sikh has within Guru Jee and to what extent that Sikh would go to for Guru Jee. If that Sikh was a Gursikh/Gurmukh he will know this to be a truth. Discipline is needed for a Sikh, hence discipline doesn’t reside eating an animal just as another animal would do due to its lack of knowledge and intelligence, but understanding Guru Jee’s Hukam through faith. To acquire Vaheguru jee’s jot within ourselves we will have to go through Guru Jee, just as the in-acknowledgeable beings had to do in Satyug, which was to go through a teacher sent by Vaheguru Jee about discipline and the wrong doing of eating an animal. than man dhhan arapee sabho sagal vaareeai eih ji(n)dh || I dedicate my body, mind, wealth and all to Him. I totally sacrifice my soul to Him. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh [%sig%]

Re: Last resort meat

kds · 29 Jan 2006

Also, Bhai Desa Singh Jeeo has said to eat meat is a sin and this rehit was accepted by Guru Gobind Singh Jee. bhai desa singhs rehatnama says that you can eat meat of goat http://www.allaboutsikhs.com/rehat/rehat_16.htm#4 The Preparation and Consumption of Food Never consume fish, meat, or alcohol. The flesh of a goat may be eaten provided the goat is killed with a single blow well away from a langar, but all other meat is forbidden. Always wash your hands before eating. Take food when you are hungry. Never eat alone. Share your food with other Singhs. Gather many Singhs and give them food. [25, 32, 65, 66, 70, 102, 107 (cf. 105)] also this rehatnama divides human on the lines of castes Marriage Marry a girl from your own caste. [28] Caste A Singh protects cows and Brahmans. Ensure that your cooking arrangements are kept unpolluted. Do not permit the following to participate in your langar: barbers, Jhivars who shave heads, weavers, potters, and others of low caste. Brahmans and those of good family who do not touch bhang or tobacco can all pre-pare food in a langar. Preaching should convince the four castes of the message concerning warfare. '° [16, 102?4 so it is not possible that this rehatnama is taken as authentic source

Re: Last resort meat

singh · 29 Jan 2006

ansa is obvious evry1 agrees its rong to eat meat the contoversy comes about wether its alrite if its life or death situation. wats the diference? hu cares wether ur gna die or not, u dont commit a sin to prolong ur life, it doesnt become alrite to do because it prolongs ur life, if u were to die at the moment then accept it as the will of god and dont commiet a sin to change it

Re: Last resort meat

uk-ute · 29 Jan 2006

some1 - "according 2 many, its better to die, then to prolong ur panths fight. If on the battle field, u face death out of hunger, victory by eating your horse... which would be better for the panth? bhung was used as a painkiller, quite like morphine for the injured after battle." some1, do you think its humanly possible for an army of hundreds ( guru jis fauj) to annialate an army of tens of thousends (muslims) forty singhs running on meat could not kill thousends of muslims, forty singhs running on naam could very easily destroy a whole army if guru wills it. one can never benefit by going against gurus hukam/ will, as god is the architect of destiny. if you please guru then the panth will blossom, satguru will not be pleased if you decide to disobey him, whatever your reason. he is the cause of all causes, we cannot cause anything, especially if we are going against his hukam. only one who has no faith in the power of satguru would say - " we have to eat meat to stay alive, so that we can do good for the panth" you cannot do anything without gurus blessings, you will not blessing by commiting kurehit. by commiting a false act (eating meat), how can you say you are fighting for the truth.

Re: Last resort meat

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 29 Jan 2006

VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh I've said what I believe Bhai Sahib 'kds' Jeeo and every one else, and if Bhai Desa Singh Jee really said that, then I have to say that I disagree with it. Eating a goat is the same as eating any other animal, as a goat isn't a different type of specie but a animal like the rest. A goat goes through and feels the same pain and carnage any other animal goes through. So has everyone forgotten the point of killing an animal. No, seems like the humans might as well start killing each other for meat as well. The pain and cries we would go through when being cutted up flesh by flesh is heard by the animal as well. The horrible torment is heard by them as well. Plus, it's filthy to eat meat, which means eating an animal. If anyone so wishes to eat meat then go ahead You Animal! and then go through the suffering you would have to go through in Narak for doing so. Sorry but this is how I feel. The world is most defiantly corrupt if the Sikhs argue over the acceptibility of eating meat. VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Last resort meat

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 29 Jan 2006

VahegurooJekaKhalsaVaheguroojekeFateh bhai Sahib 'uk-ute' Jeeo well said, that was great and very impressive and I hope every understands this concept of obeying Guru Jee's Hukam, fighting for the truth and finally making sacrifices for the truth. If the Sikhs can do this, then and only then will they blossom forth amongst this world of faithlessness where Kalyug roams as a King. The Sikhs are Kings if they keep their faith in Guru Jee and his rehit. THe Sikhs need more people like Bhai Sahib 'uk-ute' Jeeo, which means people that abide by the truth. Guru Jee would be pleased with this. VahegurooJekaKhalsaVaheguroojekeFateh

Re: Last resort meat

Harcharan Singh · 29 Jan 2006

Veer Shaktishali ji, You said: "hence discipline doesn’t reside eating an animal just as another animal would do due to its lack of knowledge and intelligence" This is a non-sensical comment. Animals don't each other because of their lack of intelligence, carnivours eat herbivours because that is the way Akaal Purkh has designed the eco-system in such a way that it is a biotic community, without which the predators the whole eco-system would collopse. God designed Lions, Tigers, Leopards, Jaguars, Sharks, Dolphins, Orcas, King Cobras, Reticulated Pythons, Anacondas, Wolves, Hyenas, Komodo Dragons and Eagles, to name but a few, for a purpose, to keep the eco-system in balance. Please do not mix and confuse spirituality and the supreme human form (both supreme in good and bad), with a wrong understanding of nature. Sikhi and nature are completely compatible, in nature animals take what they need and live by the simplest means, ideal humans should do the same, problem is they don't. We don't need to eat meat, so don't. If we need to, then that is a matter of individual opinion. But I can't see why people argue over this. We all have fruit and veg all year around, so the question of needing meat never occurs. The extra need and difference that seprates us from animals, is the need for Waheguru's charan. There is nothing wrong with animals eating flesh to survive, this is what they were made for, this is what the bacteria in their stomachs has evoved to digest, this is what they have canines and poisons for. Whether humans need to eat meat is a different subject. Personally I don't see why Eskimos and Aborigines should eat snow and sand, they need to eat what they need to eat, I personally don't think God has a problem with that, because they have historically only taken what they needed from nature and had zero impact on it. Unlike the modern civilisation which wiped millions of buffolo from North America to 1 - weaken the native Indians by taking away their main sustenance and 2 - for greed - hides and meat etc. Gurbani's line on meat is clear, take only what you need from the world, we today do not need meat, meat us a luxury, it does cause pain to animals when they are killed, so need for it. This is in line with nature. If God forbid the situation ever arises that we are starving and meat is the last resource, let people make their own minds up, act in the most common sensical way and live with their decision, it has nothing to do with anyone else. As a panth, focus on what we have in common, that is the understanding of simplicity, minimal pain and impact on and to the world. Even water has living bacteria in it, scientifically we all consume meat. The point is to have as little impact as possible. Langer is a great institution and provides many answers to this subject. We serve strictly vegetarian food in Guru ka langar, that is given. Why, so we don't exclude people who may not eat meat and because as Sikhs, we are simple and take what we need, there is fruit and veg available, so that is what we serve. If every Sikh listens to their Guru, then every Sikhs home should be a Gurdwara, Guru ka Gar open to all. That means that the rules of the Guru da langer must apply also,no meat. As for the thread, it's a personal choice if it ever came down to it. Nothing to debate. Some Sikhs did hunt and eat Boar in the mid to late 18th century when in hard times, but not all. As is now, it was then, a personal choice. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Last resort meat

uk-ute · 29 Jan 2006

harcharansingh"The extra need and difference that seprates us from animals, is the need for Waheguru's charan." we have higher intellect and conciounce, you go and take a lamb from his mother, and chop his head off, then tell me you didnt hear your conciounce saying it was wrong. conciounce can be blackened over time, like if you get any child and kill an animal in front of them they will be upset, but the same child when older wouldnt have a problem. animals do not know any better, they do not stick with one marrital partner, they do not feel bad about killing. lions find hyena cubs and kill them, but dont eat them, i have seen this many times on documentaries. they do it because of competetion with hyenas. we are very different from animals, we have the ability to reason. harcharansingh-"As a panth, focus on what we have in common, that is the understanding of simplicity, minimal pain and impact on and to the world. Even water has living bacteria in it, scientifically we all consume meat. The point is to have as little impact as possible." bacteria is not meat, saying bacteria is meat is like saying plants are meat. harcharansingh-"Personally I don't see why Eskimos and Aborigines should eat snow and sand, they need to eat what they need to eat, I personally don't think God has a problem with that" due to bad karm (deeds) they have been born into a situation where they are bound to commiting sins (eating meat) just like non sikhs in this country, who are born without knowledge of what satguru has taught (dont eat meat, cut hair, use intoxicant, etc) just because its not against ones beliefs to eat meat, cut hair, commit adultery, uses tobacco, doesnt make them any less of a sin, they are still all sins. meat is filthy, the kurehit is eating the meat, not killing the animal, eg- if an animal died of old age, its still a kurehit to eat it. meat is impure just like tobacco. spiritually you will die if you use meat or tobacco if you are spiritually dead, theres no poiont in life gurbani says many times, those who live without repeating naam may aswel be dead. harcharansingh-"Langer is a great institution and provides many answers to this subject. We serve strictly vegetarian food in Guru ka langar, that is given. Why, so we don't exclude people who may not eat meat and because as Sikhs, we are simple and take what we need, there is fruit and veg available, so that is what we serve. If every Sikh listens to their Guru, then every Sikhs home should be a Gurdwara, Guru ka Gar open to all. That means that the rules of the Guru da langer must apply also,no meat." we serve vegetarian food, because its a kurehit to eat meat, if we wanted to cater for everyone, then we why dont we prepare meat for those who eat meat, and vegetarian dishes for those who are vegetarian? just like we prepare different dals and sabjis, so you can choose what you want yes eating meat is a personal choice, which can result in either you remaing a gursikh, or becoming a kurehitee

Re: Last resort meat

. · 29 Jan 2006

If there is no meat in Langar purely so that everyone can eat it, why is there milk based dishes in Langar? Why are there onions and garlic in Langar? Is this not disrespectful to those people who do not eat those?

Re: Last resort meat

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 29 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKAKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Thanks Bhai Sahib 'uk-ute' Jeeo and well said. Bhai Sahib Harcharan Singh Jeeo, ask a lion cub to stop its way and make it understand the concept of emotion. Now ask a child to stop it's way and make it comprehend the concept of emotion. Who would understand pain? Or reason? However, you may still argue this case but animals can gain some intellegence if Vaheguru Jee so wishes. For example, Guru Gobind Singh Jee's elephant use to do Choul sahib seva, whereas another elephant in Guru Gobind Singh Jee's time was made drunk and madly ran towards Guru Jee's army carelessly killing but if it was an human who was forcefully drunk that person would know not to kill. Animals would do anything to satisfy their hunger for whatever the cost may be, whereas Humans know not to go to such an extent. karathooth pasoo kee maanas jaath || They belong to the human species, but they act like animals. VahegurooJeKAKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Last resort meat

Harcharan Singh · 29 Jan 2006

harcharansingh"The extra need and difference that seprates us from animals, is the need for Waheguru's charan." we have higher intellect and conciounce, you go and take a lamb from his mother, and chop his head off, then tell me you didnt hear your conciounce saying it was wrong. --------------------- That concience is what begs for waheguru's charan as I have pointed out conciounce can be blackened over time, like if you get any child and kill an animal in front of them they will be upset, but the same child when older wouldnt have a problem. animals do not know any better, they do not stick with one marrital partner, they do not feel bad about killing. --------------- A few animals do have only one partner for life i.e. cranes, dikdik (small antelope)... lions find hyena cubs and kill them, but dont eat them, i have seen this many times on documentaries. they do it because of competetion with hyenas. we are very different from animals, we have the ability to reason. ----------------- Whats the difference between this and what George Bush and a million other "Humans" before have done through war, killing others to get there own country, people, family aheaed, animal instinct. harcharansingh-"As a panth, focus on what we have in common, that is the understanding of simplicity, minimal pain and impact on and to the world. Even water has living bacteria in it, scientifically we all consume meat. The point is to have as little impact as possible." bacteria is not meat, saying bacteria is meat is like saying plants are meat. ------------- My apologies, I meant to say microscopic life found in water i.e. gastrotrichs, which are not plants and invisible to the human eye. harcharansingh-"Personally I don't see why Eskimos and Aborigines should eat snow and sand, they need to eat what they need to eat, I personally don't think God has a problem with that" due to bad karm (deeds) they have been born into a situation where they are bound to commiting sins (eating meat) just like non sikhs in this country, who are born without knowledge of what satguru has taught (dont eat meat, cut hair, use intoxicant, etc) ------------------ So you think that everyone who is not born a Sikh has bad karam. And you are the authority on stereo typing that a whole race of people must have performed bad deeds, even though they may be the happiest, kindest, most honest people on the planet, because of their necessary diet, they are of bad karam. Ok. just because its not against ones beliefs to eat meat, cut hair, commit adultery, uses tobacco, doesnt make them any less of a sin, they are still all sins. meat is filthy, the kurehit is eating the meat, not killing the animal, eg- if an animal died of old age, its still a kurehit to eat it. meat is impure just like tobacco. spiritually you will die if you use meat or tobacco if you are spiritually dead, theres no poiont in life --------------- Your disgust of meat makes you sound like a brahman. Comparing meat and tombaku is non-sensical, one kills you and is a drug, the other is food which some people in the world need to eat to stay alive. Although, it is a fact that most people eat it out of greed. gurbani says many times, those who live without repeating naam may aswel be dead. ------------ Yes it does. harcharansingh-"Langer is a great institution and provides many answers to this subject. We serve strictly vegetarian food in Guru ka langar, that is given. Why, so we don't exclude people who may not eat meat and because as Sikhs, we are simple and take what we need, there is fruit and veg available, so that is what we serve. If every Sikh listens to their Guru, then every Sikhs home should be a Gurdwara, Guru ka Gar open to all. That means that the rules of the Guru da langer must apply also,no meat." we serve vegetarian food, because its a kurehit to eat meat, if we wanted to cater for everyone, then we why dont we prepare meat for those who eat meat, and vegetarian dishes for those who are vegetarian? just like we prepare different dals and sabjis, so you can choose what you want --------------- This is a really silly arguement. Eating fruit and veg isn't against anyones religion, eating meat is - Buddist monks, Jains, Hindu's etc.... Having a langar that all can eat provides for everyone and doesn't leave anyone out, all people eat fruit and veg (please don't give me an atkins e.g.). yes eating meat is a personal choice, which can result in either you remaing a gursikh, or becoming a kurehitee -------------- You missed the whole point of the discussion, it was about last resort. It was about focusing on what everyone agrees on i.e. that meat is not necessary. It said that treat your house as a Gurdwara, and your langar as Guru da langar, hence no meat. That in it self resolves all problems. If it's a life and death situation, let people make up their own mind, which they will do anyway, it's silly to discuss that situation anyfurther. Sat Sri Akaal.

Re: Last resort meat

Harcharan Singh · 29 Jan 2006

Veer Shakti ji, You have contradicted yourself: "Animals would do anything to satisfy their hunger for whatever the cost may be, whereas Humans know not to go to such an extent. karathooth pasoo kee maanas jaath || They belong to the human species, but they act like animals." This clearly says that humans act like animals, it is only through his kirpa that we don't. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Last resort meat

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 29 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJekEFateh Bhai Sahib harcharan Singh jeeo most goraa, kaalae and asians are like animals but Guru jee has given the Sikh discipline and common sense to make them distinct from animals, he he, that sounds kind of funny. This is still true. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJekEFateh

Re: Last resort meat

uhh · 29 Jan 2006

I was thinking about Kulbir Singh's response and realized that Guru Sahib already gave us the perfect example of dying rather than committing a bujjar kurait. Bhai Taru Singh Jee and countless other shaheeds died because they refused to cut their hair--because it was a bujjar kurait. So is eating meat etc.

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 29 Jan 2006

Shakti that is a very rude comment. Guru ji gave Sikhs morals, but never called Bhai Mardana, of Guru Hargobind Sahib never called pendey Khan an animal Wow that is an extremely charged comment. Can't believe you even said it We are all Animals, like it or not

Re: Last resort meat

Kulbir Singh · 29 Jan 2006

Lionking jeeo, I see nothing wrong in the response of Shakti Shali Sha Soora jee. He has stated a fact, though not the most diplomatic comment, that anyone who is deviod of Naam is an animal. Gurbani goes on to state that ones who are without the Gurmantr are like dogs, pigs, donkeys, snakes, crows and like animals. So all those who have not come to my True Guru are "Kaalay chor". Kulbir Singh

Re: Last resort meat

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 29 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJekeFateh Bhai Sahib 'lionking' Jeeo manu Marff Kardou Kirpa Karka if I hurt anyone but the ones that agree with eating meat the statement relates to you. I did truly sound rude but I didn't mean it the way you've taken it. We're not animals, gurbani has stated humans to be different to animals. Also why does it say to obtain the human body is a jewel and amazing. A animal is a low specie and it can't really be compared to a human. I gave this comment because I'm fed up with the Sikhs that are agreeing with eating meat. Whoever ate meat is an animal but if the sin has been erased through Guru jee, hence Guru Hargobind Sahib or Naam then that person is a Human, as they then have a status to be called a disciplined Sikh. Make the sacrifice for the truth, for Sikhi and for Vaheguru Jee. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJekeFateh

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 29 Jan 2006

I'm honestly ignorant on this issue, but arn't we Sikhs animals either+ more specifically dogs - Hum Kokar terey Darbar. If I've gotten the wrong understanding of the abveo shabad, please forgive me and enlighten me. Also although i agree Sikhs have been given Naam, Sikhs still ahve pretty much same moral, values, norms as many toher - Punjabis, Gorey, kaley Piley. If I find a non-drinking, non-smoking, someone who dones't go around having sex with every second person on the street, vegetarian, wakes up Amritvele (although does not do paath, but works, does Kirt kamai, shares his earnings) Will you still call him an animal, even though he has similar moral values as Sikhs? Also Kulbir SIngh JI will you call BHai Buddhu Shah an animal, or Bhia Gani Khan the muslim saints who helped Guru ji dress up as "Uch da peer", who were given a hand-written Hukamnama by Guru Ji - were all of these animals two like everyone else? What is an animal???

Re: Last resort meat

khalistani · 29 Jan 2006

ok meat is NOT A BUJJAR KUREIGHT ask any one wat is HALAAAAL and rthen check EVERY purtaan source, it says HALAAL is kureight but meat is to be eaten onlY and only as a last resort so cytting ure hair is imposible, thas a kureight BUT chatka is NOT A kureight as a last resort is definatley ok to eat and for those whos ay naam will fill u up if u at tha avastha then great but wat if someone like me is in the jungle, and has low avastha wa u gonna do now? not everyoby can get nurishment off of naam it isnt as easyt as people on this board make it sound jus go a week without food and ull find out wa im sayin bhula chuka maf

Re: Last resort meat

Roopkaur · 29 Jan 2006

Khalistani, Puraatan rehitnaamey also mention that Singhs should not sleep with muslim women, so does that mean that if a so called Singh did a bujjer kurehit with a Hindu women, it will be acceptable? Also, you say chatka is alright, so what if the animal does not die with the first stroke, will you leave it lying there and move on to the next animal to try again, since you can no longer eat it? When people cut their hair to save their lives, can they too make the argument that Oh I am a low avastha person, and I cannot make myself stronger through naam, so its ok, I havent done a bujjer kurehit. Do bujjar kurehits only count if "high avastha" valey do them? If bani has already made the stand for Sikhs, that meat is not ok, than what need is there to argue?

Re: Last resort meat

Hmmm · 29 Jan 2006

Without even getting into the whole meat argument other than to respond to somones post above pointing out that Kuttha = halal meat... can you please explain how the word kutta translates to halal meat i.e. meat prepared in abrahamic fashion? Note how in ADV how Guroo Sahib specifically addresses meat prepared in this way and its certainly not simply as kuttah. It just my understanding is Kuttah means killed and I dont see how it translates to halal meat especially when Guroo Sahib addresses halal meat differently and specifically. Secondly totally agree that its against Rehat, however that doesn't mean it didnt happen... I suspect that back then they did what they needed to in order to survive, even if by doing so they ultimatly became dead on the inside. It is not for us to judge just know what Guroo Sahib says about those who stray and pray when the entire world is hunting for you, that Guroo Sahib will keep you strong.

Re: Last resort meat

WhatThe... · 29 Jan 2006

"jus go a week without food and ull find out wa im sayin" forget a week...try 2 days

Re: Last resort meat

amarjeet singh · 30 Jan 2006

meat is a kurehit

Re: Last resort meat

.. · 30 Jan 2006

meat ok as last resort when there aint nothing left but what r the chances of having nothing left???

Re: Last resort meat

uk-ute · 30 Jan 2006

"That concience is what begs for waheguru's charan as I have pointed out" no r they are 2 separate things "Whats the difference between this and what George Bush and a million other "Humans" before have done through war, killing others to get there own country, people, family aheaed, animal instinct." we are born with conciounce, animals are not

Re: Last resort meat

singhz lets unite · 30 Jan 2006

how come we eat plants. plants have life too!

Re: Last resort meat

Truth · 30 Jan 2006

>>how come we eat plants. plants have life too!<< Becasue Guruji hasn't forbidden us to eat plants, that's why. I think this debate has shown three distinct categories: 1. Meat is kurehit, period. Under no circumstances can Singhs eat meat. 2. Halal meat is the actual kurehit, but meat in general is not allowed. Guruji left room for chatka meat as a last resort for Singhs when they faced extreme hardships. 3.Halal meat is a kurehit, but Sikhs can eat any other kind of meat. I have personally stated my position before ( the second one). I think this debate is going nowhere, so lets call it a truce?

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 30 Jan 2006

******* >>how come we eat plants. plants have life too!<< Becasue Guruji hasn't forbidden us to eat plants, that's why. ******** Although Guru Ji didn't tell us to do blind faith, rather to use our Ukal...S tha logic wouldn't work. Guru ji himself says it's impossible to dinstinguish the two, which is very true as, you would you define a fungei Eats (not an autotrphs, does not produce it's own food) - heterotrph eats i's own food respirates (like animals - it does nto photosynthesize like plants do) doens't have legs (plant characteristic) 2 arguments for animal 1 for plant - so we cant eat "khumba di sabji?" I agree , second one seems liek the most rational one.

Re: Last resort meat

... · 30 Jan 2006

khalistani is correct.. in a life and death situation i highly doubt any of you would be willing to STARVE YOURSELF TO DEATH. People make it seem like this an easy thing, i know for a fact I would not be able to do this. Those of you who think they could do it, research what happens when you starve to death. You would simply not be able to do it to yourself. Realistically think about the situation, i am sure you have seen movies like 'shindlers list' and the pictures of those jews and what happened to them without food. Someone just post up one picture of someone who is at the verge of dying without food, and im sure everyone will realize they would not be able to do this to themself. However, those who are that level and can survive with naam, they can be excused from the above post.

Re: Last resort meat

Niranjan Singh · 30 Jan 2006

>>>There were many Babbers who cut thier hairs as matter of covert operations vijaydeep Singh, can you name these individuals and tell us what they did ?

Re: Last resort meat

khalistani · 30 Jan 2006

lionking uk jee i disagree wit u on tha greatly read guru nanak dev jes shabads they clearly make it clear tha all plants have life in them remeber, in chourasi lakh, we are not always reborn in something such as a human or dog, w.e a animal we can be reborn into a vast numbe rof things, even plants so plants do have life butttt we do need to eat something to survive and do bhagthee and plants do not have children, etc. and its much better for u in every way so plants is definetley much better way to go,and jus to mkae myself clear guru je has BANNED MEAT, HALAAL, CHATKA, EVERYTRHIN in NORMAL circumstances but theres a reaosn yhalaal is kureight there will never be ANY reanos to do halaal but if u have no food( i kno this will prob never happen but IF) this happens, u can do chatka and eat it theres is nuthin wrong with tha for survival bhula chuka maf

Re: Last resort meat

uhh · 30 Jan 2006

>>>> khalistani is correct.. in a life and death situation i highly doubt any of you would be willing to STARVE YOURSELF TO DEATH. People make it seem like this an easy thing, i know for a fact I would not be able to do this. Those of you who think they could do it, research what happens when you starve to death. You would simply not be able to do it to yourself. Realistically think about the situation, i am sure you have seen movies like 'shindlers list' and the pictures of those jews and what happened to them without food. Someone just post up one picture of someone who is at the verge of dying without food, and im sure everyone will realize they would not be able to do this to themself. <<<< WOW! Really? dont have the faith to die hungry? is it a lot to ask to allow urself to be scalped to death too? have u seen what happens when ur scalped to death? MAN UR BRAINS ARE OUTSIDE! whoa, yeah in that case its ok to cut ur hair too!

Re: Last resort meat

? · 31 Jan 2006

Firstly I believe Halaal was the only meat available at the time. The Mughal Leadership did not allow other types (this needs to be verifyed). The Bujjar Kurehats are the 4 actions which will wreck your Kamai the most. There is *no* difference between Halaal and Chatka etc. If Halaal will "spiritually destroy" you then so will Chatka. There is no difference between between Halaal and Chatka other than Halaal has less blood in it.

Re: Last resort meat

amarjeet singh · 31 Jan 2006

to all amritdharees, u cant say things like, its 2 hard to starve to death, u gave ur head to vahiguru, therefore you should die before commiting a bujjar kurehit

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 31 Jan 2006

************ guru je has BANNED MEAT, HALAAL, CHATKA, EVERYTRHIN in NORMAL circumstances but theres a reaosn yhalaal is kureight there will never be ANY reanos to do halaal but if u have no food( i kno this will prob never happen but IF) this happens, u can do chatka and eat it theres is nuthin wrong with tha for survival bhula chuka maf ************* This I agree with you veer ji, btu the below I disagree with you - ******** we do need to eat something to survive and do bhagthee and plants do not have children, etc.[b/] and its much better for u in every way ********* Two things, it's nto better for you in every other way, whether for the godo or bad. Although plants do nto ahve childrne in the traditional sense, i.e sexual reproduction, they do hvae it another way. For instance why do you think there's pollen flying around in the air during the summer=? Do you know what that is? It's plant sperm. When they fly aroudn and attach to another plant it will then do it's naturall process. Read about Mapple. Also, there are certain plants which have both sex organs in one plant - they reproduce in that way, no in the traditional human children thing. So it woudl be incorrect to say that. Thing is we've labeled everythin in Human terms - children, God is the lord - why if God is genderless then God cannot be HE, HIS, LORD - these are all human characteristics that we've used due to lack of the english language. We find this in English translations, but where do we find them in Gurbani or Prof Sahib Singh's interpretations (they do come there too, but a lot less than English)? Although I agre with your first statement - ****** Author: amarjeet singh Date: 01-31-06 07:41 to all amritdharees, u cant say things like, its 2 hard to starve to death, u gave ur head to vahiguru, therefore you should die before commiting a bujjar kurehit ******* Are you saying all those SInghs who ate meat for survival in order to continue fighting battle were"kurehitees" and in other words- not Guru-ke-Sikh any more? Were all of them bey-mukh to the Guru? What was the poitn of fighting then at all? THe point of fighting was for a principle - what's the point if you break another principle to keep one principle - what's the point? They might jsut as well cut their hair, and get rid of the problem that way - they chose the harder way - to live the life of the Guru's instructions - do you seriously think they would commit a kurehit while fighting for the Sikh cause? Agree with khalistani in this issue bhull chukk maaf

Re: Last resort meat

WhatThe... · 31 Jan 2006

When the Singhs were at war and had to live in the jungles , do u think they had all the time in the world to plough the fields, plant crops, water them, wait months for them to grow, harvest them, and then eat them? I doubt it. This is probably when the Nihung tradition of chatka came about. Also, there were no Shoppers Drug Mart, or Pharmasaves around where the Singhs could get a perscription for Tylenol #3s or Morphine filled, so they used what was available for pain relief....probably Canabis Bhang or whatever you wanna call it. Recreational use of these things just for taste or enjoyment is absolutely wrong and unacceptable however as a LAST RESORT, I think it's okay.

Re: Last resort meat

Roopkaur · 31 Jan 2006

Since when can Sikhs bend and break rules in times of hardship? Is bani has already answered this question (sabai rasaatel jai), than who are we to make exceptions. I agree that it is unimaginable how difficult it would be to starve yourself, but is not getting sawed in half, having your children cut up and put around your neck, having your scalp taken off, being boiled alive, being bricked alive, being wrapped in cotton and burned alive, are all these seen as easy? I cannot imagine how our mahaan shaheeds could give this much kurbaani, yet shy away from not eating anything and going against gurbani and the hukams of guru ji (see Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee's hukamnaamey) just to prolong their life. On one hand we have quotes from gurbani and Sri Guru Ji's hukamnamey, as well as references from rehitnaamey, and on the other hand we have a statement made by 'khalistani' based on a supposed historic happening with no support from gurbani or the principles of Sikhi.

Re: Last resort meat

khalistani · 31 Jan 2006

ya liopnking ure right they do "reproduce: but im talkin not in the diverty classifiaction way, the normal way a parent nurtures its youth, so the youth need THE PARENT TOO etc, stuff liek tha \and agree wit lionkinguk bhula chuka maf

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 01 Feb 2006

************* Author: Roopkaur Date: 01-31-06 19:34 Since when can Sikhs bend and break rules in times of hardship? Is bani has already answered this question (sabai rasaatel jai), than who are we to make exceptions. I agree that it is unimaginable how difficult it would be to starve yourself, but is not getting sawed in half, having your children cut up and put around your neck, having your scalp taken off, being boiled alive, being bricked alive, being wrapped in cotton and burned alive, are all these seen as easy? I cannot imagine how our mahaan shaheeds could give this much kurbaani, yet shy away from not eating anything and going against gurbani and the hukams of guru ji (see Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee's hukamnaamey) just to prolong their life. On one hand we have quotes from gurbani and Sri Guru Ji's hukamnamey, as well as references from rehitnaamey, and on the other hand we have a statement made by 'khalistani' based on a supposed historic happening with no support from gurbani or the principles of Sikhi. ************* So what you suggest is that the never ate meat. Ever? I never denied Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji's Hukamnama - just like Gurbani condemnd krodh,as it's not benificial for your spiritual jeevan - yet you can be the most krodhi person on th eplanet -yet be a Sikh. If you can be the most krodhi person on the planet, yet be a Sikh (we're all bhullanhar - arn't we? - or can you say tha anyone with 5 chor are not Sikhs?) Similarily I believe, that Guru Sahib is telling us to stay away from meat, yet the reason why no Rehitnamey (formal code of conduct of the Khalsa way of a Sikh) condemns meat, but condemns hallal is exactly that Guru Sahib has done Hukam to stay away from meat, just like Gurbani tells us to stay away from Krodh - but doesn't mean your not a Sikh anymore beause you get into Krodh. Sikhs too have human needs, such as eating, whether we like it or not. it's not wise to deny all historical evidence pointing at the Singhs eating meat as a last resort - for the purpose of your own beliefs. bhull chukk maaf

Re: Last resort meat

amarjeet singh · 01 Feb 2006

it comes down to gurmat vs manmat eating meat is manmat whatever the tym/situation it doesnt suddenely become acceptable bcos u mite die without it, if ur gonna either die or eat meat, then die. why would the rules change just because ur about to die? gurmat doesnt change. there are not a certain set of rules to follow at 1 tym in ur life and another set for a different tym in ur life. if there is nothing to eat accept it as waheguru's will, ye i know a lot easier said then done, but still, there is never an excuse to eat meat.

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 01 Feb 2006

ya liopnking ure right they do "reproduce: but im talkin not in the diverty classifiaction way, the normal way a parent nurtures its youth, so the youth need THE PARENT TOO etc, stuff liek tha \and agree wit lionkinguk bhula chuka maf ************* There are several animals, where parents do NOT nurture it's children.As a matter of fact it is rare that this is done in the animal kingdom, but is mainly done in mammals i think:S - so going by that loci it woudl be okay to eat un-supervised animals =P? Most animals do not need parents =)

Re: Last resort meat

Friend · 01 Feb 2006

Plants have life they reproduce Animals Have life the reproduce. Plants breath. Animals breath. Plants have electrical activity in them and can sense their environment. Animals have electrical activity in them and can sense their environment. Plants have a nervous system. Animals have a nervous system. Plants need food. Animals need food. Plants and meat eaters and vegetable eaters. Animals and meat eaters and vegetable eaters. Plants flourish when cared for and nourished. Animals flourish when cared for an nourished. Are any of them sentient like humans and can tell the difference between the 5 chor? No. Whether you are consuming an animal or a plant you do so with what your conscience tells you is what is right at that time. If your conscience tells you it is wrong then abstain. If conscience tells you Ok, then carry on. So long as you are not being swayed by the 5 chor. It is foolish to argue over meat. Your diet will not make you a better Sikh if you carry the 5 chor in your heart.

Re: Last resort meat

khalistani · 04 Feb 2006

there are great differences between animals and plants jus eat a diet of either nad ull find out i can personallly say a veggie diet is much better for my mind and health,which helps me way more to do bhagthee, than a meat body which i dunt kno y, jus doesnt make me feel good meat is NOT good for the body some can say it is due to protien, etc. but it is nooot milk has ENOUGH protien etc. but thas tru, if u dont do no paath, and still indulge in 5 chors, ure diet aint gonna have any effect on u but a veggie diet way better for bhagthee marag than a meat diet i can say tha from personal expiernce bhula chuka maf

Re: Last resort meat

Friend · 07 Feb 2006

I do not eat meat but I do not judge those people who do. I know plenty of healthy meat eaters and I know plenty of ill vegetarians. Your diet will not make you a better Gursikh. There is no difference between a plant and an animal when you take a life. If you are talking in absolutes then a life is a life. There is no Panj Choor associated with certain food. This is pure Maya to think so. If you wish to talk about humans, then do you know why we became humans from apes? It is beacuse we ate bone marow: http://cogweb.ucla.edu/ep/AustralopithecusGarhi.html Would great Waheguru have done this if he thought it was siniful to eat flesh. I have said this many times before. I am a vegetarian, but I do not wish to judge those who eat meat. It would be wrong of me, and it is not an issue us Sikh's should be concerned about. Stay away from this topic and let people be.

Re: Last resort meat

LionKing (LK) · 07 Feb 2006

*********** there are great differences between animals and plants jus eat a diet of either nad ull find out i can personallly say a veggie diet is much better for my mind and health,which helps me way more to do bhagthee, than a meat body which i dunt kno y, jus doesnt make me feel good meat is NOT good for the body some can say it is due to protien, etc. but it is nooot milk has ENOUGH protien etc. but thas tru, if u dont do no paath, and still indulge in 5 chors, ure diet aint gonna have any effect on u but a veggie diet way better for bhagthee marag than a meat diet i can say tha from personal expiernce bhula chuka maf ************* Firstly, I don't agree that veggei diet is necessarily better than a meat diet. Let's not get into the science of the body, because that's simply ridiculous and not a good anti-meat argument. You say it's better for you - have you ever tried meat diet - how can you comment on a diet you havn't tried? Yes meat is healthy - no doubt. Veggie diet can be sufficient - no doubt let's just leave it there, and respect it other's opinion, and not judge others by what they eat =)