Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

akj....?

akj....?

sikh · 21 Jan 2006

no offence to ANYONE but whats the big deal about everyone saying only ajk amrit is right. If you take amrit from another jatha , taksal, dodra, and the other ones. Its the same amrit am i right? It asically the same rehit. I also have one more little question why is it that in AKJ only bibis with a keski can do kirtan. We wear a chunni to cover our head is that not ebought im sorry if i offended anyone but i think this jatha is going way to far with this. stopping people from doing kirtan unless they wear a dastaar>? it makes some feel uncomfratobale and makes them change jathas, no offfence to anyone again. this is just what i have seen anad heard. PULL CHUK MAAf!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: akj....?

Kaljug Jeev · 22 Jan 2006

waheguroojikakhalsawaheguroojikifateh..! veeerji/phenji...i would like to ask u...one sigle lil question..wht would u think or do if u have guru jis darshan!...well the story is that..people or i personaly think...not AKJ but...the amrit that the punj singh prepare from the AKJ jatha...is the right one..because bhai rama singh ji (sorry if thats not the name) wrote or said that he got the darshan of guru gobind isngh ji maharaj...maharaj ji told bhai sahib to take amrit from the punj singh that tells him to keep keski as kakar!very clear..and veerji/phenji...ur thoughts are totaly wrong..AKJ is following the REHATNAMA which is written from ppl of guru gobind singh ji maharaj! and sorry to say...they are not going over the limit or over doing where bibia with keski should do kirtan..cause if the bibia who doesnt wear keski...u see most of them...dont cover thier head properly..and they dont follow the same rehat as the men!...what do u say? bhulchukmaaf..! waheguroojikakhalsawaheguroojikifateh!

Re: akj....?

Gurpreet Singh · 22 Jan 2006

Every Jatha follows a maryada. Some go the extra mile to show their pyar for Guru Sahib. If you don't agree with wearing a Keski then there's so many other sangat you can go to.No need to 'change' jatha. We are all one khalsa Panth but some of us like milk in our tea and some of us like creme.

Re: akj....?

R singh · 22 Jan 2006

firstly i dont think anyone says akj amrit is only right, amrit is amrit. And the rehits do differ between jathas. reason some people are favoured towards akj is that they try to keep strict rehat as guru ji wouldve liked us to. you mentioned a point about keski, well theres been many arguments over keski/kes being the fifth kakar. when it comes down to it, its pointless having kes as the kakar, because it already says you cannot cut hair in the bujjar kurehit and every other kakar is something new to add to your body.

Re: akj....?

Bruce Lee · 22 Jan 2006

AKJ is keeping the Khalsa panth alive!!! The amount of naam simran the singhs do!!

Re: akj....?

.. · 22 Jan 2006

I AGREE

Re: akj....?

singh · 22 Jan 2006

I DISAGREE Firslty , AKJ DO SAY THIER AMRIT IS THE BEST. Does this make it so...NO, but they do infact say so. They say that they are carrying on "tat gurmat" but what is the basis for this tat gurmat. ONE individual...Bhai Sahib Randeer Singh Ji. I do not say he is not a Gursikh, but what I do point to is that there was Amrit before him and there is Amrit after him that is NOT AKJ. The big deal...keski vs. kes. The rest of the panth does not accept Keski as a Kakkar (though many people feel it is manditory-necessary), but the AKJ are the only ones that do. Why is that? I suppose when guru sahib passed down the rehit of Amrit the rest of the panth was in the dark. Even the panthic rehit maryada states that the kes are the kakkar...not the keski. Unlike some other issues which were of controversy then and mentioned, kes was not. There is no alternative here... Kes is the kakkar...AJK amrit is not the only amrit.

Re: akj....?

Swinder Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh Really a great experience to remember, their way of naam simran. This is my personal experience. They call in Waheguru to be there in partakash roop when they do simran. I have attended so many simarn sadhnas by some other gursikhs, but here the experience is unique, no match at all, say marvellous. A I afraid of their rehat a little bit. Otherwise I have all appreciations for them.Their rehat is not for katche pilai(weak and pale). Gur Fateh ji

Re: akj....?

. · 23 Jan 2006

the amount of simran the singhs.....and singhnees do.. just thought id add that in somewhere.

Re: akj....?

moorakh · 23 Jan 2006

Bruce Lee's comment is absolutely stupid. Guru Maharaj is keeping the Khalsa panth alive, and singhs from lots of jathas do simran - in fact there are so many thousands of more people who aren't part of akj but they still do lots of abhyaas. it's true that with abhyaas and rehit guru sahib ji gives kirpa to khalsa, but it is not due to any single jatha.

Re: akj....?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 23 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh I also agree with Bhai Sahib 'Bruce Lee' Jeeo. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: akj....?

so · 23 Jan 2006

"They call in Waheguru to be there in partakash roop when they do simran. I have attended so many simarn sadhnas by some other gursikhs, but here the experience is unique, no match at all, say marvellous. " yeh of course its unique and yes of course there's no other simran like it but this doesnt make it the best in fact its so unique that its not even sikhi anymore and gurugobindsinghji said to bhainandlaalji to sit in gurumrahraj's darbar with respect not jumping around everywhere.

Re: akj....?

singh · 23 Jan 2006

R singh "amrit is amrit" yes either its amrit or its not, now many groups make 'amrit' then distribute it in bottles what a joke, i mean how can you call that amrit, other hand, we have 5 'singhs' who eat meat, and use intoxicants they also make 'amrit' but the thing is amrit is amrit, its either amrit. or its not. panj must be 5 khalsa singhs, who follow khalsa rehit if they are not khalsa, and dont follow khalsa rehit, they are not panj pyare (5 beloved ones) therefore they make sugary water, and not amrit.

Re: akj....?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 23 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJekEFAteh kal mai mukath naam thae paavath gur yeh bhaedh bathaavai || In this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, liberation comes from the Naam. The Guru has revealed this secret. 'this doesnt make it the best in fact its so unique that its not even sikhi' Bhai Sahib 'so' Jeeo even the Gurmantar - Vaheguru hasn't been mentioned in Gurbani, as it's meant to remain Gupt to Manmukhs but free to use by the ones that have taken Amrit. maram thumaaraa gur thae paaeiaa || I have obtained Your secret from the Guru. Furthermore, how else can one break open the Dasam Duar without Naam Dhirr, because in the past other Sants, which have recited the Gurmantar could have been blessed with Naam Dhirr just as the way Bhai Sahib Randhir SIngh Jee was. No matter what the Naam has to fuse within the breath to travel from inside of the body to the Dasam Duar. However, instead of that person who's taken Amrit but not from AKJ has to do through the long meditation of Gurmantar to be able to have the Naam flow within the breath whereas if the devotee took Amrit from AKJ they could begin the whole process immediatly. Moreover, the reason for why AKJ's Amrit, which is still Guru Gobind Singh Jee's is more strict and better then other Amrit, is due to the fact that they follow the strictness of every rehit even the forgotten, with full pyaar but only some follow every rehit after taking Amrit from Akj, as others just slack off. I don't even know why people like that take Amrit if they don't even comprehend the true meaning of Amrit - what a joke. All rehits, Kakaars, etc, forgotten were re-established by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee by Guru Gobind Singh Jee. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJekEFAteh

Re: akj....?

moorakh · 23 Jan 2006

Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Bhagat Puran Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Sant Baba Kartar Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Sant Baba Teja Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it.

Re: akj....?

moorakh · 23 Jan 2006

Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Sant Baba Nand Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Saint Scholar Niranjan Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Sant Baba Attar Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. [%sig%]

Re: akj....?

moorakh · 23 Jan 2006

Sant Baba Thakur Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Sant Baba Isher Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Sant Baba Sundar Singh Jee was a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly was the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh Jee is a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly is the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. Baba Nihaal Singh Jee is a true Khalsa and a Pure Khalsa, as he truly is the son of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. He re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it. [%sig%]

Re: akj....?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 23 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh I totally agree Bhai Sahib 'Moorakh' Jeeo, as all these Gursikhs that have re-established the strength within Sikhi and intenseness of it were amazing and inspiring in every way. They were all truly sons of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: akj....?

Prabhjoyt Singh · 23 Jan 2006

So "bruce lee" without the akj would the panth be dead? Are akj hiher thatn Guru ji and Akaal purakh? Think a bit before writing such comments

Re: akj....?

M S Nijjar · 23 Jan 2006

I agree with "Moorakh" Jee, ALL of them were TRUE GurSikhs! Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!!

Re: akj....?

D Kaur · 23 Jan 2006

Its not about what jatha you have taken amrit from. Its about the punj pyaaray and if the amritsanchar is being conducted properly. If an amritsanchar is not being preformed properly, then can we really call that an amritsanchar? Can we consider the following to be proper amritsanchars: -where amrit is given to the ablakee by only one punj pyaara and not all give -where the punj pyaaray do not follow guru ji’s hukum and rehit -where rules for men are different than rules for bibiaan (we are suppose to be equal – referring to wearing keski) -giving Singhs khanday dee pul and giving Bibiaay kirpan dee pul. -Most important: where guru ji is not present (Laridaar saroop) These are just some reasons as to why some amritsanchars are not considered to be proper amritsanchars. It has nothing to do with AKJ. [%sig%]

Re: akj....?

Swinder Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Author: so Date: 01-23-06 05:27 yeh of course its unique and yes of course there's no other simran like it but this doesnt make it the best in fact its so unique that its not even sikhi anymore and gurugobindsinghji said to bhainandlaalji to sit in gurumrahraj's darbar with respect not jumping around everywhere. """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" Mr. So jeo, I could not understand your advice of not jumping around everywhere.I donnt want to be roped in, in any sort of politics if going on here at this site. Pl.spare me. I have no inclination,favor or preference for any one/group.I donnt know here even who is to whom.My simple policy is I bow to the sikh(having faith in 5s) whosoeven he may be.I donnt like or even like to care this dirty politics of this and that group. I want and pray to my almighty guru to be the sikh of His definition, not the definition of others having preferences, favors,reservations,doubts,fears,temptations, inclinations etc. I am just new to this site, only two months or so.You tell me, I shall start saying the things in your way but be sure it should in favor of the whole sikh panth, not any individual or group. In the last I would like know the sakhi where Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji told Bhai Nand Lal ji to sit in Guru Maharaj's darbar with respect not jumping around everywhere. With regards and best wishes Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh.

Re: akj....?

...... · 24 Jan 2006

I wish little kids on this forum would stop making comments for established Panthic jathebandies. The vioce of the Jatha is Keertan and Gurbani. It says nothing which is against Gurmat.

Re: akj....?

Heera Singh · 24 Jan 2006

Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh!! okay... wow... where do I begin?... hmm.. okay... firstly.. whoever thinks 'AKJ Amrit' (God-forbid we call it AKJ amrit and not Guru Sahibs Amrit) is the only 'real' amrit... boy... you are WAY off... ... so.. apparently only those singhs that took Amrit at an AKJ program are considered to be Sikhs?... hmm... oh.. sorry... I guess I'm not a Sikh.. and neither is Sant Jarnail Singh, or Baba Thakur Singh... or Baba Isher Singh.. or many many other mahaan Gurmukhs... you people who think 'akj amrit' is the only one... u all make Sikhi look like a joke... honestly... ... wow... honestly... where do you get off saying that 'amrit from outside akj is not real amrit sanskar' (as sum1 said in another thread)... whoever feels that way CANNOT call themselves a Sikh... oh my LORD have MERCY on your souls!!!!! so.. u guyz are saying that my panj pyaray were wrong?.. and they weren't really panj pyaray 'cause they didn't take amrit from AKJ?... who the HELL made you guyz God?.. who gave YOU permission to decide who is a Sikh and who isn't?... y'all better be careful of what you say... disrespecting the panj pyaray, tha's like disrespecting Guru Gobind Singh jee himself... and whoever does so.. is goin STRAIGHT to hell.. don't matter how 'STRICT' your amrit is or how much naam u do... ... man i know AKJ people who would be disgusted by hearing that 'akj amrit is the only real amrit'... and of course you're all above Sri Akaal Takht rite?... ushaa.. theekh ah.. so i guess y'all should be makin all panthic decisions from now on.....keep it up guyz!! at this rate, u'll be more extrmist then the Taliban and other islam extremist groups in no time!!.. u know, the ones that believe that 'Islam is the only tru way... everybody else will go to hell'..... tha's basically the path u guyz are on now... sayin that 'akj amrit is the only real amirt, and all others are false'.. bahahahaha.. y'all make me lauff... and whats even FUNNIER is that the elders aren't even disputing this... which kinda makes it look like either: a) they're the ones feeding this nonsense to the youth or b) that they agree with them and are proud!!..hmmm.. maybe we can get u guyz some airtime on the Jihad television network... wow.... once again.. LORD HAVE MERCY ON YOUR SOULS!!! y'all need to realize that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randir Singh (who'm I personally consider an absolutely chardi-kalaa gurmukh... a Sant-Sipahi) and Bhai Rama Singh weren't the only Gursikhs on the face of this earth.. everybody has their own path to God... they were given their path... tha's not the ONLY path.. follow it if u must... but do NOT disrespect or insult those who do not follow the same path as you... you know what.. i'd like to hear from the AKJ elders... whats THEIR opinion on this?... lets get this all out in the open... is this the natural feeling of all AKJ sangat?.. or is this the feeling of a few LOST souls.. i personally don't feel its the general consenus among AKJ sangat... I am amritdhari, but didn't take amrit at an AKJ program... however I still get tabla and keertan seva at akj programz.. and as per AKJ maryada only amritdhari sikhs can do seva... HOWEVER.. i would still like to hear from some elders... please teach these youth some sense..!! whoever said 'akj amrit' is the only 'real' amrit.... well.. y'all better start BEGGING Guru Jee for forgiveness.... worry bout urselves, and start doin some REAL bhagtee..!! GOD BLESS..... VAHEGURU PLEASE HAVE MERCY!! VAHEGURU JEE KA KHALSAAAAAAAAAAAAA.... VAHEGURU JEEE KEE FATEHHHHH!!!

Re: akj....?

Gurpreet Singh · 24 Jan 2006

Vahegurooo...I couldn't have put it over any better Heera Singh

Re: akj....?

sumone · 24 Jan 2006

Totally agree with you Heera Singh... U guys need to WAKE UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BIG TIME!!!!!!!! Dont turn something as beautiful as the Khalsa into some kinda joke!!

Re: akj....?

amarjeet singh · 24 Jan 2006

chill out heera singh plaez what people are trying to say is there a certain way an amrit sanchaar is sposed to be conducted and at amrit sanchaars organised by akj the correct way of giving amrit is carried out. the correct rehit is given. naam drir is given. for those who take amrit where the correct rehit is not given or naam drir is not given, i wouldnt say there not amritdharis. i would say tht it is a lot harder to do naam without naam drir though. and i would say without rehit sikhi is impossible. 5th kakaar is keski. if one doesnt wear a keski, i dont think they could be classed as khalsa. akj follows guru gobind singhs jis rehit. hmmmm nd about panj payreh. u have to realise that jus bcos 5 singhs get together nd do ardaas doesnt make panj pyareh. if the singhs doin seva in the panj have no kamai or keep no rehit or give out rong rehit (u can eat meat), or give amrit in a bottle. this is not amrit and the 5 singhs are not the panj pyareh. in conclusion akj are bloody great :-)

Re: akj....?

Bruce Lee · 24 Jan 2006

Bhai Prabhjoty jee, in todays societies look at the takalis who are run by govt agents. The nanaksarias who are following sant baba. GNSJ who are destroying our heritage. Then look at AKJ who naam abyiase singhs keeping the pnath in chardi kala with guru sahibs kirpaa.

Re: akj....?

Roopkaur · 24 Jan 2006

The question is not about whethet the amrit is AKJ or not, but whether is is amrit at all. Like it was mentioned before, it is only amrit when prepared according to maryada. Someone mentioned that there are so many maryadas, which one should we follow? Well, guru ji has given his Sikhs bibek budhi, and an abhilakhee who is in search of tat gurmat will use it to find the right maryada. For example, let us use our bibek budhi on this scenario. We all know that the Guru jot resides in only the laridaar saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahhib Ji. And an amrit sanchaar is only an amrit sanchaar if it is in the presence of our present guru, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Therefore which amrit sanchaar will give the abhilaakhi more lahaa, one that is conducted in the presence of Guru Ji, or when the is conducted in the presence of a pad chhed bir? Take another scenario. Whether one believes keski isi a kakaar or not, it is obvious that the dastaar is mandatory for both males and females, otherwise Sikhs cannot lay claim to the statement that both are equal. Now would an abhilaakhi then want to take amrit from panj pyarey who fully endorse this mandatory rehit, whether they call it kakaar or not, or would an abhilaakhi want to take amrit from those that just want to give amrit to the most people, and will compromise on rehit to acheive this? In conclusion, the question is not about which jathabandee has the best amrit, it is which amrit is prepared according to maryada. And the basic maryada is not that different in panthic jathebandees. Differences such as how AKJ makes it mandatory for bibiaa to wear keski can be thought of logically, what makes more sense, that both males and females wear the same bana, or that the panth put their females in an inferior position, just like other religions, by making the dastaar mandatory for males, but optional for females?

Re: akj....?

a sikh · 24 Jan 2006

i agree tottaly with herra singh

Re: akj....?

A singh · 24 Jan 2006

amarjeet singh...the onli decent post thats made sense on this thread. good job mate. tanks

Re: akj....?

..... · 24 Jan 2006

"Bhai Prabhjoty jee, in todays societies look at the takalis who are run by govt agents. The nanaksarias who are following sant baba. GNSJ who are destroying our heritage. Then look at AKJ who naam abyiase singhs keeping the pnath in chardi kala with guru sahibs kirpaa" bhai Bruce Lee Ji, im sorry to burst your bubble but not Akj's are perfect neither are all Taksali's or Nanaksari's etc dont bash a samparda based on the actions of a few i know of MANT Taksali's that are hardcore abyiasees, but they dont need to go around telling everyone nor do they need to prove themselves to anyone (but Guru Ji), many are just gupt Stop bashing samparda's, not all Akj's are bad, not all Taksali's are bad

Re: akj....?

Dhiyalang Saroopae · 24 Jan 2006

RoopKaur Bhenji, wasn't your response just a lengthy version of ~ AKJ is the only Jatha that holds correct amrit sanchars ~ ?

Re: akj....?

Roopkaur · 24 Jan 2006

Dhiyalang Saroopae ji, No, although AKJ amrit, atleast traditionally, has been garanteed for an abhilakhee to find puraatan rehit, I totally believe it is possible for others to organise an amrit sanchaar, all they have to do is make an effort at tat gurmat maryada, i.e. laridaar saroop, dastaar for both genders etc.

Re: akj....?

singh · 25 Jan 2006

why are so many other jathas threatened by the fact that AKj does Amrit sanchaars properly? Why do they just not clean their own house up?

Re: akj....?

sanjha singh · 25 Jan 2006

Heera Singh - good post mate

Re: akj....?

A · 25 Jan 2006

we need ekta! [%sig%]

Re: akj....?

confused · 25 Jan 2006

heyy moorakh i hope you knwo Baba Gurbachan Singh and his whole family wore keskis wonder why

Re: akj....?

Prabhjoyt singh · 25 Jan 2006

Bruce lee Firstly the name is Prabhjoyt Singh And secondly is every member of your jatha perfect? And comments like that divide the panth and nothing else! due to people like you there is so much division in the panth and no Khalistan and do you call shouting, screaming and head-banging abhiyaas? Yes i know there are chardi kala singhs in akj but alot of youth who do these kind of headbanging things are just doing it for a show and if it is beyond control they should try to control it. Here is what bani says about this headbanging thing http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=1700 and secondly whats with "akj only amritvele" that is no different to the way the Brahmins treated Bhagat Namdev Ji and do you know what happend? here read for yourself http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=4151 But i do agree with some things you said such as the kar sewa wale destroying history and just becuse Harnek su is bad that dont make all of Nanaksar bad. And if there are GOI agents in Taksal such as mohkam su thatdont mean the Taksal is bad

Re: akj....?

Suprised · 26 Jan 2006

Prabhjoyt Singh, How many hours of Simran do you do at Amritvela? Do you even keep strict Amritvela? Keep telling yourself that all these people who are getting Maha-Lahaa from Naam and Bani are just showing off, if it makes you feel more secure about yourself. If you havent ever tasted Rass that made you want to shout out Vaheguru's name at the top of your voice, then to be honest I feel sorry for you. These types of people have amazing spiritual experiences, whilst you just complain on the internet. I can imagine you being the type of person who laughs at someone if they are crying out of Pyaar and Prem for Guru Sahib in a Keertan Darbar or Amritvela, and thinks "what a show off". And certainly don't try to be a Sikhitothemax scholar and quote Bani when you are unaware of what it means. Sorry if I've offended you but this is the truth. Let's try not to throw stones at other people's houses if ours is made of glass.

Re: akj....?

Harcharan Singh · 26 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Without offending anyone, could I ask if Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji used to act in the way describing present AKJ Sikhs (in the previous post)experiencing "ras" whilst doing naam simran? Interstingly, this is how Kukai got their name, they were also known to not be able to control their emotions/physical actionswhen perfoming naam simran back in Baba Ram Singh Namdhari's days. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: akj....?

Dhiyalang Saroopae · 26 Jan 2006

RoopKaur Bhenji, Isn't it true that what you may define as "Tat Gurmat Maryada" or "Puraatan Rehit" may not be the same as someone else's definition?

Re: akj....?

Tooting · 26 Jan 2006

why is ther so much politics with you amritdharis? just chill.

Re: akj....?

Suprised · 26 Jan 2006

This topic has already been discussed and Kulbir Singh has explained it very well. http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=57752&t=57605 Until we reach the very higher stages when Simran goes Ajapa Jap there is nothing wrong is loud Simran so we can concentrate more easily. My Benti is that those people who are harbouring negative thoughts in the Amritvela or Keertan program, concentrate on the Shabad or leave. Having negative thoughts in these types of sessions does not help to spiritually uplift the Sangat. If other people are tasting Prem Rass, and you are angered by this, you should reflect on your own Jeevan. All problems come down to a lack of Pyaar for Vaheguru and lack of Naam Abhiyaas. Lets not try to sterilize the Sikh faith further by criticizing people expressing their Prem, just because we are trying to take a cheap shot at AKJ. ra(n)g hasehi ra(n)g rovehi chup bhee kar jaahi || In the Lord's Love, they laugh, and in the Lord's Love, they weep, and also keep silent. paravaah naahee kisai kaeree baajh sachae naah || They do not care for anything else, except their True Husband Lord. dhar vaatt oupar kharach ma(n)gaa jabai dhaee th khaahi || Sitting, waiting at the Lord's Door, they beg for food, and when He gives to them, they eat.

Re: akj....?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 26 Jan 2006

VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Nicely said Bhai Sahib 'Suprised' jeeo. VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: akj....?

Roopkaur · 26 Jan 2006

Dhiyalang Saroopae ji, What I am saying is that if we actually did vichaar of the puraatan rehits and actually looked at historical proofs, as well as the seena baseena rehit passed down through gursikhs, instead of being so adamant in what so and so baba or sant has said, or instead of trying to modernise and assimilate, if the panth used their bibek budhi to discern between right and wrong, if we used gurbani and gurmat as our guides instead of our manmat,we would all have similar ideas of maryada.

Re: akj....?

Dhiyalang Saroopae · 27 Jan 2006

RoopKaur Bhenji, I understand what you are saying, but I also believe that "historical proofs, seena baseena rehit" are still open to interpretation. Afterall, even you said that we could have "similar" ideas on maryada, but I think even you can acknowledge that we would not have identical ideas on maryada. This means that differences in the Panth will have consisted in the past and will continue in the future. I suppose the key is for each jatha not to display a 'holier than thou' attitude and exercise some humility. Which, lately, has been severely lacking on some of the posts made on this forum. Lastly, the words of "sants or baba's" are taken to be of a higher level because everyone feels there is some power behind them. There is a certain gyaan behind them. Would you feel keski is a the 5th Kakaar if Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh said it wasn't? Would you be inclined to reject Raagmala if Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh said it was Gurbani? Of course not. You cannot blame DDT or other Jatha's for their views and simply pass it off as "they just listen to whatever Sant **** says", because in a way that's what you do as well. Which is a beautiful thing!

Re: akj....?

singh · 27 Jan 2006

dhayalang saroopei ji well said fateh!

Re: akj....?

simple singhani · 28 Jan 2006

WJKK WJKF ....waheguru waheguru waheguru ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Author: Tooting Date: 01-26-06 09:01 why is ther so much politics with you amritdharis? just chill. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Just shows whos giving amritdharees a bad name...forgive me if iam wrong.. we are meant to be humble gursikhs. A lot of non-amritdhareesalso think the amritdharees think they are thebest..and..show ego just because their amrithdaree.. i dont think we should give a bad impression guys. sorry for going off the topic.. felt it needed to be pointed out. WJKK WJKF!

Re: akj....?

Roopkaur · 28 Jan 2006

>Would you feel keski is a the 5th Kakaar if Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh said it wasn't? Would you be inclined to reject Raagmala if Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh said it was Gurbani? Of course not. You cannot blame DDT or other Jatha's for their views and simply pass it off as "they just listen to whatever Sant **** says", because in a way that's what you do as well. Which is a beautiful thing!< These statements were not made by Bhai Sahib individually, like many people like to believe, these are stands that the whole jatha with Bhai Sahib took, as sangat, which is how decisions are made in the jatha. Just because Bhai Sahib was more vocal about these beliefs through his writings etc. does not mean he came up with these ideas on his own. I do not believe in these stands because Bhai Sahib said so solely, but because of the proof that I have seen to support them. If someone was able to show me stronger proof proving otherwise, which I have not encountered so far, then I would change my mind.

Re: akj....?

great · 29 Jan 2006

i love how no elders have responded to heera singh's post thats greaaaaaat!

Re: akj....?

Dhiyalang Saroopae · 29 Jan 2006

RoopKaur Bhenji, Although, decisions could have been made as a jatha, there is no doubt in my mind that the words of Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh are held at a higher level then any other Gursikh in the Jatha. It is completely obvious to many outsiders that Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh is the role model for the whole Jatha. Pictures of Bhai Sahib are prominently displayed on all AKJ sites. So even though the decisions may have involved other Singhs, I highly doubt that any ideas posed by any other Singhs were given much clout compared to Bhai Sahib's ideas. Which is FINE, because no doubt, Bhai Sahib's avastha was at a level where his words SHOULD have been given more importance. Lastly, the proof you have seen was most likely shown to you once you've been told that Keski was the kakaar or Raagmala was not bani. I believe that you never took time to research before your conclusion was made, or perhaps you were already suggested a conclusion before any research was done. It's easy to find proof to support your belief, once you already have your mind made up. Also, although you say that you have received no proof that would change our mind; I have seen that any evidence that you see that goes against your beliefs is immediately challenged. If truth is what you're seeking then why challenge? Why not listen, research and then make a decision? These are things that will never happen. You will continue to believe what you believe and I respect that. But I guess the main thing that bothers ppl about AKJ is that alot of AKJ don't respect other's beliefs regarding Sikhi. I've heard many singh say "I like AKJ, but don't judge me on my beliefs if I don't judge you. Let me do my thing, you do yours, and we can get along." Regards.

Re: akj....?

sikh · 29 Jan 2006

ok i feel stupid for starting this topic because we are all one , i take it all bak

Re: akj....?

Roopkaur · 29 Jan 2006

Dhiyalang Saroopae ji, You have made many assumptions on your part. To answer you in brief, I have read the proof for raagmaalaa, or kes as kakaar, and do not find it has much substance, that is why I believe what I do. As for Bhai Sahib, it has already been mentioned that I did not make decisions on his own, fasley were made as sangat. If the majority were not agreeing with Bhai Sahib, then he did not argue with the sangats decision. As for your last question, my only response is that many people first attack and criticise the jatha, and when they face retaliation of some sort, they say that Jatha valey are egotistical and self-loving.

Re: akj....?

Dhiyalang Saroopae · 30 Jan 2006

RoopKaur Bhenji, My apologies for any assumptions I may have made. My conclusions were based on talking with AKJ youth and reading posts on this forum and others. Also, just like you don't find that evidence for Raagmala and Kes as a Kakaar doesn't have much substance, I'm sure other would find that proof against Raagmala and Keski as a Kakaar doesn't have much substance. I suppose the key is to agree to disagree, and not judge one another. I'm willing if you are?..

Re: akj....?

js · 30 Jan 2006

In Dasam Bani, "Kes" or another word that means the same thing comes in bani along with the other 4 kakkars implying these are the 5 kakkars, no where does the word "Keski" show up or anything that means that. So is this not enough ?? Now please do not say that dasam bani is not bani or that its not full written by guru gobind singh ji or that this specific writing of 'kes' is written by someone else and its been changed. Please do not insult dasam bani or guru gobind singh ji by saying that. Would love to see someone knowledgeable to answer to that as i am a moorakh and not well educated. bhul chuk maph!

Re: akj....?

singh · 31 Jan 2006

js, there are whle articles showing where keski is mentioned. Please do some reading before making such comments here.

Re: akj....?

js · 31 Jan 2006

Articles you say ?? at least please put me in the right direction, tell me where i can get these articles so i can do the research/reading myself. Do they have as high respect or higher than dasam bani ?! Please enlighten me, only trying to learn.

Re: akj....?

Singh · 31 Jan 2006

"js" Veer Ji please tell us which Puratan Saroops (or indeed even printed Saroops) we can find this Kes reference, and why it has only claimed to be Guru Gobind Singh's Bani in the last few years.

Re: akj....?

js · 31 Jan 2006

Veerji, its in Sri Dasam Granth. I dont think this important would be changed and i have seen it in some sanchiya i read in english. Im pretty sure if you read any version it would be in there. And why wouldnt it be dasam pita jis bani ?? Also if you listen to prof. raagi bhai balbir singh and his diwaans, most of his kirtan is done from dasam bani !!

Re: akj....?

... · 31 Jan 2006

The shabad js is talking about is "nishane sikhi". This is known as a fake composition and is found in the appendix of some Dasam Granth birs. Not all. All Sikh scholars agree that it was written in the late 1800s.

Re: akj....?

Roopkaur · 31 Jan 2006

'Js' For keski references, two references that have come from guru ji's times mention keski as a kakaar. One is the Bhat Vehis, which were written by the bards or poets of guru jis darbaar which mention kesgi as the the kakaar, not kes. The other is the eye witness account of Abdul Tarani, who was a spy of Aurangzeb and later got amrit schuck. These are contemprary accounts as opposed to the poem you refer to, written 100 years or so later.

Re: akj....?

NJ · 31 Jan 2006

holy moly. no wonder there is no ekta in the Sikh Panth. how many times are you all planning on discussing topics like these? you know what, you're making a JOKE of Sikhi. gosh, have some fear. live in fear those who think they are better cause they belong to some better group. groups where never layed out by any of our Guru's. all of you who have the time to disrespect Sikhi in anyway, go get a life. no one has any right to tell someone not to do kirtan. are you God? where in Guru Granth Sahib Ji does is say that non-amritdhari's can't do keertan. and where does is say that a certain amrit from a certain group is right, i don't care if a chardi kala Gursikh says so....tell me a Gurbani tuk that says akj amrit or blah blah amrit is the right one? there's no mention in Guru Granth Sahib ji about any group, so all of you are wasting your time. WAKE UP. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the only source. no akj, no blah blah, is going with you in the end. gosh. you guys have waaaaaaaaay to much time on your hands and now i'm wasting my time too. Jap Naam.

Re: akj....?

khalistani · 31 Jan 2006

read dasam granth to see if keski is kakaar or kesh bhula chuka maf

Re: akj....?

Singh · 01 Feb 2006

Infact it has only been passed off as "Guru Gobind Singh Jis" work recently. Dr Manasukhani in the late 1980s refers to this as "Bhai Nand Lals" work. It seems no one is sure where it came from or who wrote it. Dr Manasukhani is one of the main offenders for pro Kesh as Kakkar propaganda. He mentions Prahilad Rai Rehatnama references which don't even exist, reproduces the Kabul Hukamnama which has no credibility as an authentic document at all, and the aforemented Nishani Sikhi document. It is sad that people try to pass off spurious writings as those of Guru Sahib or famous Gursikhs to try and prove their point.

Re: akj....?

Singh · 01 Feb 2006

Roopkaur Bhain Ji, I havent heard of this Keski reference in Abdul Tarani's work before. Could you give us the quote and a little bit more information?

Re: akj....?

Admin · 01 Feb 2006

Topic locked. Admin