Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

ratoval shasters are graet!!!

ratoval shasters are graet!!!

MOW! · 21 Jan 2006

recently i took my sarbloh kirpan from ratoval (ratoval is a pind near ludhiana where some jatha singhs make shasters) to a professional gora knife maker/sharpener. previously i was a unsure about how practical or good alot of the shasters were from india or if sarbloh was practical for a blade, since when my sarbloh kirpan from mehta chownk was examined by another knife expert he said the metal was completely wrong for a blade and it would chip very easily and well quite unimpressed. to my suprise the gora said that this ratoval kirpan was very well designed and upon sharpening it (he could tell the quality of the metal used by putting it on a grinder) he said that the sarbloh blade was of a very good quality and was just right for that of a sword (he said it was a type of carbon steel but without a huge amount of carbon in it). therefore in conclusion if anyone is looking to get a good sarbloh kirpan which is actually practical, then they should visit ratoval pind next time they go to panjab. already mow wala and the j wala have brought back about 20-30 of these kirpans for jatha youth in uk and most are very happy with them.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

Harcharan Singh · 21 Jan 2006

Mow Ji, How can carbon steel be sarbloh? Carbon steel swords are exactly that - carbon (coals) added into melted steel. This is how the Japanese made the best swords in the world, with the added benefit of the number of times the steel was folded. Does this mean that the "jatha" Singhs are not making Sarbloh kirpans? Satnaam Harcharan Singh

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

I want a good kirpan · 21 Jan 2006

R these going to be available at the keertan darbar tonight at seven kings gurdwara, goodmayes? thank you

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

... · 21 Jan 2006

Harcharan Singh, All kirpans, all batas, all "sarbloh" is low-carbon steel. It is virtually pure ie. over 99%. 100% pure iron is a lab creation and was not used either in Guru Sahib's time or even on today's time. Even cast-iron isn't 100% pure. It's something like 97-98%.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

MOW! · 21 Jan 2006

dear mr harcharan singh i read your posts and they always seem so negative you sound really miserable! why dont you just smile and be happy :) we have to remember in guru jis times they didnt have a periodic table or an idea about elements, molecular masses, etc. so just because sarbloh translates as "all-steel" or "all-iron" this doesnt mean it has to be chemically pure iron (fe) by what science says. chemically pure iron is almost impossible to obtain, and if you had a shaster made of pure iron it would be really soft and useless for anything. sarbloh battas are all iron with carbon in it and there is very little variation of what battas are made out of. if they were made of wrought iron (this is closer to pure iron with lower carbon content) then they would be soft and malleable. plus wrought iron does not rust as easily and everyone knows that sarbloh is prone to rusting. and carbon steel as used in shasters actually has less carbon in it than cast iron does. i hope this has helped you learn about sarbloh :)

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

Boongwala · 21 Jan 2006

Yes thanks to Jwala and Mow I have a ratonval Kirpan in 2 sizes, 2 foot and 1 foot. Both are nicely made and are practical to wear.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

Jj · 21 Jan 2006

mow ji have u got ne spare?

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

Singh · 21 Jan 2006

I heard that the thing that distinguishes between a steel and an iron is the percentage of carbon content. Theres a certain number (maybe 2%, not sure), and anything below that is steel, and above is iron....i may be wrong, remember reading about something like that in school.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

unreal · 21 Jan 2006

Dear Harcharan Singh - Sarbloh is steel. What is steel? Steel is iron with carbon added to it. Iron is an inferior material for weapons as compared to steel - Singhs fought with steel swords. note: There are different types of steel. Re Japanese making the best swords - sigh, that is a myth. The most that can be said is they made the best swords in Japan. Their swords and their method of forging met their particular needs and wants in terms of time, environment, and function. The whole reason they folded the stock material during forging was because they had such crappy material to work with and needed to hammer out the impurities. Moreover, give a differentially hardened katana to someone not trained in its use and proper cutting form and ask them to cut through a tatami roll and you'll find the blade can bend and set more easily than a european through-tempered/spring-tempered blade. Their is no "best" sword - only whats best for you in the particular circumstances you find yourself in. Harcharan Singh wrote: > Mow Ji, > > How can carbon steel be sarbloh? Carbon steel swords are > exactly that - carbon (coals) added into melted steel. This is > how the Japanese made the best swords in the world, with the > added benefit of the number of times the steel was folded. > > Does this mean that the "jatha" Singhs are not making Sarbloh > kirpans? > > Satnaam > > Harcharan Singh [%sig%]

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

unreal · 21 Jan 2006

If all sarbloh is low-carbon steel then it truly is an inferior material for swords. That is why I think you're wrong. Sarbloh is steel and carbon content in steel can differ. Singhs who depended on their kirpans for their lives would not have fought with sub-par weapons - they would have used high-carbon steel swords with a proper heat-treatment and they would have avoided low-carbon steels which are horrible at keeping an edge - low-carbon steel is too soft. .. wrote: > Harcharan Singh, > > All kirpans, all batas, all "sarbloh" is low-carbon steel. It > is virtually pure ie. over 99%. 100% pure iron is a lab > creation and was not used either in Guru Sahib's time or even > on today's time. > > Even cast-iron isn't 100% pure. It's something like 97-98%.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

ekta · 21 Jan 2006

steel is brittle, carbon creates much stronger bonds, as well as a much lighter blade

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

unreal · 21 Jan 2006

First, someone might be a knifemaker but that doesn't mean they know anything about making swords - swords require a whole different set of skills and knowledge. While tempering and heat-treatment in knives may not be as vital, it is in forging a sword. Second, just because the material in a small kirpan is good for the kirpan, doesn't mean it is good for a 4 foot sword. Case in point: stainless steel can be very good in shorter length knives but is inferior in longer length swords. Third, while there is a need to balance the 'hardness' and 'softness' of a blade to ensure it has 'sharpness' and 'toughness', quality swords tend to be made from high-carbon steel not low-carbon steel. Fourth, the guy used a grinder? Was there something wrong with the edge of your kirpan? Generally, you only use a grinder to re-shape the edge and don't need it for sharpening. Other than that, I'm not familiar with ratoval kirpans and leave their shape and handling to your better judgment. MOW! wrote: > recently i took my sarbloh kirpan from ratoval (ratoval is a > pind near ludhiana where some jatha singhs make shasters) to a > professional gora knife maker/sharpener. previously i was a > unsure about how practical or good alot of the shasters were > from india or if sarbloh was practical for a blade, since when > my sarbloh kirpan from mehta chownk was examined by another > knife expert he said the metal was completely wrong for a blade > and it would chip very easily and well quite unimpressed. > > to my suprise the gora said that this ratoval kirpan was very > well designed and upon sharpening it (he could tell the quality > of the metal used by putting it on a grinder) he said that the > sarbloh blade was of a very good quality and was just right for > that of a sword (he said it was a type of carbon steel but > without a huge amount of carbon in it). > > therefore in conclusion if anyone is looking to get a good > sarbloh kirpan which is actually practical, then they should > visit ratoval pind next time they go to panjab. already mow > wala and the j wala have brought back about 20-30 of these > kirpans for jatha youth in uk and most are very happy with > them.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

Singh · 21 Jan 2006

I have the 1 footer ratowal kirpan. and I have to admit, it's a very impressive shastar. Very well made.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

MOW! · 21 Jan 2006

when the first person said low-carbon steel, he meant low carbon in the fact that even a "high carbon steel" actually has very little carbon it in compared to iron. i think we can all agree (apart from mr harcharan singh) that sarbloh is carbon steel rather than wrought iron. yes a grinder was needed, although ratoval shasters are graet they didnt put a particularly good blade on the kirpan (better than what you get from other shasters from india but not razor sharp), that is why i took it there for sharpening. so if you have a ratoval kirpan its a good idea to go and get someone to sharpen it properly mr "Jj" sengh since i know you are a chardi kala singh i will do my best to find you a kirpan :)

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

rsingh · 22 Jan 2006

MOW where is mine??? Ill pick it up next week !!!!!!! thanks ;)

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

Harcharan Singh · 22 Jan 2006

Thank you for your kind comments Mow Ji. With Waheguru's kirpa, I am generally in Chardi Kalaa. Please don't let yourself worry about my emotional balance. I was under the impression this forum was to discuss Sikhi, I would go to a "Joke" forum if I wanted to have a laugh. I was simply pointing out that the commonly understood translation of sarbloh (Iron) was not in line with your comment about the sword being a good quality carbon steel. Iron is a pure element. Every atom in a chunk of iron is an iron atom. Iron is not as strong as people think. Steel is better. To make steel, they melt down iron and mix in small amounts of other elements. There are different types of steel based on what they mix in and how much. Each type of steel has different advantages, such as stength, durability, chemical reactivity, and many other qualities. Typical elements that are added to iron to make steel include Carbon, Manganese, Silicon, Chromium, and Molybdenum. But most of the atoms of steel are still iron, because they only usually add in a small percent of other elements. I was not discussing nor stating my opinion on sarbloh in any other context. WROUGHT IRON: .00% to .04% (4 pts.) carbon, 3% silica. Characteristics: soft, malleable, welds easily, resists burning in the forge, resists rust, when bent tends to stay bent. STEEL: .04% (4 pts.) to 2.25% (225 pts.) carbon. Most modern steel runs from 20 point "mild steel" to 150 point "tool steel". Steel has a low silica content and usually various trace metals. In the period we are dealing with these trace metals were accidental. In the modern period they are intentional, creating various alloys for different purposes. Intentional or accidental, they will affect the performance of the steel, and ores containing different elements were used for different tools or weapons. Trial and error works even when you don't know why something works. Characteristics: harder, less malleable, difficult to weld, easy to burn in the forge, rusts, tends towards springiness, shatters when over-hardened, cracks when worked at wrong temperature - all in proportion to its carbon content. CAST IRON: Up to 8% impurities including 3.5% to 4.25% carbon, plus phosphorus, silica etc. Characteristics: hard, brittle, non-malleable, casts in liquid form, heat resistant, withstands compression, rusts, doesn't weld at all. Cast iron is produced (in useable quantities) by high heat blast furnaces. So here is the basic problem: wrought iron, available in classical and early medieval Europe, makes dandy door hinges but lousy swords. It won't hold an edge, it bends and deforms; it's actually worse than bronze. Cast iron, available in Asia because of the design of their smelting furnaces and the use of coal, won't work very well either. It is much too brittle. Only steel achieves the required balance of qualities, but there is no easy and sure way to smelt it in quantity. Different weapons require different quanities of carbon. From my understanding quality swords carbon conteny varies from 30 to 90 points of carbon to steel. My understanding is similar to "unreals" i.e. quality swords have high carbon content. Guru Kirpa. <<(()) ; - ) >>> Harcharan Singh

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

uksingh · 22 Jan 2006

sarbloh doesnt contain any carbon, the techniques used in the 1700s to extract iron from ore are different from those used now. there maybe traces of minerals, eg in the order of 0.005%. carbon chemically and physically changes iron, steel and carbon are two different things carbon is not iron, hence not sarbloh. i posted an extract from a company on the internet which makes both steel, and extracts pure iron using old methods, before.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

Charan Dhoori · 22 Jan 2006

MOW Bhai Sahib do you to pre-order the Kirpans or can you go the Rathowal and buy a Siri Sahib on the spot? In regards with steel and sarbloh... a POSSIBLE solution for the pro-steal and pro-sarbloh people could be having a sarbloh (iron) kirpan with steel plating? What you think?

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

..... · 22 Jan 2006

i asked a very professional sword maker who is a Sikh from the USA about making Sarbloh kirpans... his reply was even though a kirpan can be made of Sarbloh but it is not a practical weapon This gentleman was not prepared to make a Sarbloh kirpan simply because it would not be a good weapon but had no problem in making one of Damascus, but these can be very expensive

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

LionKing (LK) · 22 Jan 2006

i read your posts and they always seem so negative you sound really miserable! why dont you just smile and be happy :) ******* May'be cause we see them as negative. I.e Bhaji pumps comments about raag-kirtan, something some of us others arn't concerned about and naturally might see the posts as negative - I usually tend to see them knowledgable and informative.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

unreal · 22 Jan 2006

I'm not sure I agree with that. Some steels may be brittle, others are not - saying all steel is brittle is a generalization unless you're generally comparing steel to jello :) Moreover, as stated above, steel is iron with carbon added. Regarding weight, this is really a function of how much material is being used for a a sword and not really what type of steel is being used. ekta wrote: > steel is brittle, carbon creates much stronger bonds, as well > as a much lighter blade

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

unreal · 22 Jan 2006

Dear Harcharan Singh - A lot of information in your post, but as a matter of 'form', when copying/pasting text, it is best to include the reference or website from which the text was copied so readers can access the document itself. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe much of what you pasted below was word-for-word from an online article. There is nothing wrong with that but since we're all here to learn, it is best to post the referenced web site. Harcharan Singh wrote: > Thank you for your kind comments Mow Ji. > > With Waheguru's kirpa, I am generally in Chardi Kalaa. Please > don't let yourself worry about my emotional balance. > > I was under the impression this forum was to discuss Sikhi, I > would go to a "Joke" forum if I wanted to have a laugh. > > I was simply pointing out that the commonly understood > translation of sarbloh (Iron) was not in line with your comment > about the sword being a good quality carbon steel. > > Iron is a pure element. Every atom in a chunk of iron is an > iron atom. Iron is not as strong as people think. > > Steel is better. To make steel, they melt down iron and mix in > small amounts of other elements. There are different types of > steel based on what they mix in and how much. Each type of > steel has different advantages, such as stength, durability, > chemical reactivity, and many other qualities. Typical elements > that are added to iron to make steel include Carbon, Manganese, > Silicon, Chromium, and Molybdenum. But most of the atoms of > steel are still iron, because they only usually add in a small > percent of other elements. > > I was not discussing nor stating my opinion on sarbloh in any > other context. > > WROUGHT IRON: .00% to .04% (4 pts.) carbon, 3% silica. > > Characteristics: soft, malleable, welds easily, resists burning > in the forge, resists rust, when bent tends to stay bent. > > STEEL: .04% (4 pts.) to 2.25% (225 pts.) carbon. Most modern > steel runs from 20 point "mild steel" to 150 point "tool > steel". Steel has a low silica content and usually various > trace metals. In the period we are dealing with these trace > metals were accidental. In the modern period they are > intentional, creating various alloys for different purposes. > Intentional or accidental, they will affect the performance of > the steel, and ores containing different elements were used for > different tools or weapons. Trial and error works even when you > don't know why something works. > > Characteristics: harder, less malleable, difficult to weld, > easy to burn in the forge, rusts, tends towards springiness, > shatters when over-hardened, cracks when worked at wrong > temperature - all in proportion to its carbon content. > > CAST IRON: Up to 8% impurities including 3.5% to 4.25% carbon, > plus phosphorus, silica etc. > > Characteristics: hard, brittle, non-malleable, casts in liquid > form, heat resistant, withstands compression, rusts, doesn't > weld at all. Cast iron is produced (in useable quantities) by > high heat blast furnaces. > > So here is the basic problem: wrought iron, available in > classical and early medieval Europe, makes dandy door hinges > but lousy swords. It won't hold an edge, it bends and deforms; > it's actually worse than bronze. Cast iron, available in Asia > because of the design of their smelting furnaces and the use of > coal, won't work very well either. It is much too brittle. Only > steel achieves the required balance of qualities, but there is > no easy and sure way to smelt it in quantity. > > Different weapons require different quanities of carbon. From > my understanding quality swords carbon conteny varies from 30 > to 90 points of carbon to steel. > > My understanding is similar to "unreals" i.e. quality swords > have high carbon content. > > Guru Kirpa. > > <<(()) ; - ) >>> > > Harcharan Singh

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

unreal · 22 Jan 2006

Dear uksingh, I appreciate what you are saying but I believe whoever gave you the information was mistaken It doesn't matter what techniques were used to extract the iron in the 17th century, fact of the matter is Singhs used steel swords not iron swords. The ability to make high-carbon steel swords existed well before 1699 and it makes no sense that Sikhs would choose to use an inferior, outdated material for their weapons. Fact of it is, that Sikhs used steel kirpans not iron kirpans. Therefore, if we say that Guru Gobind Singh ji and his Sikhs wore sarbloh kirpans, that logically means Guru Gobind Singh ji and his Sikhs wore steel kirpans. While I can't speak for items like pots and pans, when it came to weapons, the Sikhs used carbon-steel. uksingh wrote: > sarbloh doesnt contain any carbon, the techniques used in the > 1700s to extract iron from ore are different from those used > now. > > there maybe traces of minerals, eg in the order of 0.005%. > > carbon chemically and physically changes iron, steel and carbon > are two different things > > carbon is not iron, hence not sarbloh. > > i posted an extract from a company on the internet which makes > both steel, and extracts pure iron using old methods, before.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

Jj · 23 Jan 2006

Tanks mow ji "mr "Jj" sengh since i know you are a chardi kala singh i will do my best to find you a kirpan :) " ps am not chardee kala am a pappi!!

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

H · 23 Jan 2006

GURFATEH MOW JI WHERE IN RATOVAL CAN YOU GET THESE KIRPAN'S. I AM GOING TO INDIA IN FEB AND IF I HAVE SOME FREE TIME I'M THINKING OF POPPING DOWN TO LUDHIANA AND CHECKING OUT THESE KIRPANS. IF ANY PARTICULAR JATHA/GURUDWARA, COULD YOU PLEASE INFORM ME OF WHICH SO I CAN TELL MY DRIVER WHERE TO GO WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

MOW! · 23 Jan 2006

you just need to tell your driver to go to ratoval pind. if he doesnt know then go to ludhiana and ask someone there. i think it was well within an hours drive from ludhiana. once you get there just ask anyone. ratoval have been making shasters at least since bhai randhir singhs time and at gurdwara bibeksar sahib rainsbai alot the sarblohi singhs had custom made ratoval shasters. a singh who does seva in the panj pyare at bibeksar sahib amrit sanchars also suggested to go to ratoval for your kirpans. if ratoval shasters arent sarbloh, i dont know where your going to get sarbloh shasters from!!

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

newbie · 24 Jan 2006

i am a bit confused about what a ratoval kirpan is? can someone put a picture on here?

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

amarjeet singh · 24 Jan 2006

get sarbloh kirpans by buying propa sarbloh nd give it 2 some1 2 make

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

singh · 24 Jan 2006

mow - "that sarbloh is carbon steel rather than wrought iron." mow ji, sarbloh is iron, not carbon steel. whether sarbloh is used for shaster is a different topic.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

unreal · 24 Jan 2006

Singh, Please answer this question: Did Guru Gobind Singh ji and the Sikhs of his time use sarbloh weapons? singh wrote: > mow - "that sarbloh is carbon steel rather than wrought iron." > > mow ji, sarbloh is iron, not carbon steel. > > whether sarbloh is used for shaster is a different topic.

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

singh · 24 Jan 2006

im not sure, i think they were sarbloh - iron, from the ones i have seen eg guru hargobind jis katar in the amritsar complex museum section

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

BABBAR · 24 Jan 2006

VAHEGUROOO JI KA KHALSA VAHEGUROOO JI KI FATEH Bhai sahib mow singh ( train waley ) :o) just got time to read " abit " of this topic and thought id say THANK U :o)

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

unreal · 24 Jan 2006

Dear singh, The reason I asked is that Guru Sahib's weapons are considered to be made of sarbloh and Guru Sahib's weapons are not made from iron but from carbon steel. Likewise the shastar you saw in the museum was made from carbon-steel not iron. I think that we are narrowing the meaning of sarbloh too much. In other words, it is possible, in the past, that the carbon-steel used in shastars was called sarbloh AS WELL AS the iron used in pots and pans. To Singhs of the time, sarbloh was sarbloh - iron was iron whether it had carbon or not. singh wrote: > im not sure, i think they were sarbloh - iron, from the ones i > have seen > > eg guru hargobind jis katar in the amritsar complex museum > section [%sig%]

Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!

meo · 05 Mar 2006

mow can u post a picture of your ratovaal kirpan [%sig%]